1. Introduction
Optimal growth, development, and health in goslings depend on a nutritionally balanced diet, with calcium and crude protein being fundamental nutrients that regulate skeletal development, metabolism, and overall physiological function. Protein serves as the primary building block for tissue formation, enzymatic activity, and metabolic regulation, ensuring proper growth and physiological homeostasis [
1]. Calcium, one of the most abundant minerals in the body, plays a critical role in bone mineralization, neuromuscular function, and cellular signaling pathways [
2]. However, imbalances in dietary calcium and protein—whether deficiency or excess—can impair nutrient metabolism, disrupt physiological processes, and lead to metabolic disorders that negatively affect growth performance [
3,
4].
Although poultry nutrition research has extensively studied nutrient requirements for broilers and layers, relatively fewer studies focus on goslings, despite their unique nutrient metabolism and growth characteristics. The National Research Council (NRC, 1994) recommends a dietary calcium range of 0.6–1.0% for growing waterfowl, while more recent studies suggest that goslings may require slightly higher levels (~0.9%) due to increased growth rates and bone mineralization demands [
5]. Similarly, the optimal crude protein concentration for goslings is reported to range between 16% and 20%, supporting muscle development, enzymatic activity, and overall metabolic efficiency. The NRC (1994) [
5] recommends a protein intake of 16–18% for growing goslings, but some recent studies indicate that higher dietary protein levels (≥22%) may not further enhance growth and could increase nitrogen excretion, potentially leading to metabolic inefficiencies and environmental concerns [
6]. These findings highlight the importance of balancing protein intake to maximize growth while minimizing waste nitrogen output.
The interaction between dietary calcium and protein levels influences nutrient absorption, utilization, and overall metabolic efficiency [
7]. Excess dietary calcium can interfere with protein digestion and amino acid absorption by forming insoluble complexes with phosphorus and proteins, reducing their bioavailability in the intestine. Conversely, inadequate protein intake may impair calcium metabolism by affecting calcium-binding proteins, intestinal absorption, and renal excretion rates. Additionally, an improper calcium-to-phosphorus ratio can impair bone mineralization, alter enzymatic activities, and affect feed conversion efficiency, emphasizing the need for a well-balanced diet. Understanding these nutrient interactions is critical for optimizing dietary formulations, improving nutrient retention, and mitigating metabolic complications in goslings.
Goslings are particularly vulnerable to nutritional metabolic diseases resulting from inappropriate calcium and protein levels [
8]. Excess protein intake can contribute to avian gout due to increased uric acid production and renal overload, while excessive dietary calcium can lead to hypercalcemia, which disrupts phosphorus metabolism and contributes to soft tissue mineralization and nephrocalcinosis. Calcium deficiency or an imbalanced calcium-to-phosphorus ratio may result in rickets and skeletal deformities, leading to poor bone development and increased susceptibility to fractures. Given the rapid growth phase during the brooding period, goslings have heightened nutritional requirements, making dietary optimization essential for maximizing production efficiency and preventing diet-induced metabolic disorders [
9]. Despite their importance, precise dietary recommendations for calcium and protein levels in goslings remain limited, particularly under modern production systems.
The present study aims to investigate the effects of dietary calcium and protein levels on the growth performance, intestinal development, and nutrient utilization of Jiangnan white goslings during the brooding period. Furthermore, it aims to establish a scientific foundation for reducing the prevalence of nutritional metabolic diseases and enhancing production efficiency.
4. Discussion
The findings demonstrate that dietary Ca and CP levels significantly influence the growth performance of goslings. Excessive dietary Ca (2.88%) substantially reduced BW, ADG, and ADFI, while markedly increasing the FCR. These observations align with previous studies. Abdulla et al. [
12] demonstrated that dietary calcium levels significantly impact growth performance and tibial calcium and phosphorus content in chicks. Similarly, Shafey and McDonald [
13] reported that high-calcium diets impair growth performance and feed conversion efficiency, emphasizing that increased protein levels cannot fully mitigate the growth-suppressing effects of excessive calcium. Zhu et al. [
14] further corroborated these findings, noting that elevated calcium levels and imbalanced calcium-to-phosphorus ratios significantly reduce BW, ADFI, and ADG in 21-day-old Pekin ducks. The present study reinforces these conclusions, suggesting that excessive dietary calcium disrupts nutrient absorption and induces metabolic imbalances, ultimately impairing growth performance. In contrast, moderate dietary Ca levels (0.96%) supported optimal BW, ADG, and ADFI, underscoring the importance of maintaining appropriate calcium levels to enhance skeletal development and metabolic efficiency. Notably, goslings fed 0.96% Ca exhibited superior growth metrics compared to those receiving 0.32% Ca, indicating that insufficient calcium may constrain skeletal mineralization, even when FCR remains favorable.
Crude protein levels also influenced growth performance, with goslings fed 14.5% CP achieving the highest BW, ADG, and ADFI. Studies on Chinese indigenous goose breeds suggest that dietary protein levels between 17% and 20% yield optimal growth performance [
15]. This aligns with findings by Ashour et al. [
16], who demonstrated that incremental increases in dietary protein within a suitable range (e.g., 13% → 14.5% → 16%) improve BW and feed conversion efficiency in geese. Similarly, Abou-Kassem et al. [
17] identified 18% as the optimal protein level for geese aged 1–7 weeks, facilitating superior growth performance. Importantly, no significant differences were observed between 16% and 18% CP, suggesting a threshold beyond which additional protein does not yield further benefits. These findings highlight the importance of formulating diets with adequate protein levels to optimize growth performance while avoiding excessive protein, which may impose metabolic burdens without additional benefits [
18]. Although CP levels did not significantly affect FCR, the observed interaction between Ca and CP levels underscores the need for balanced nutrient formulations. Specifically, moderate Ca (0.96%) combined with lower CP levels (14.5%) synergistically promoted better growth outcomes and excessive Ca reduced growth efficiency, particularly in combination with high CP, likely due to impaired nutrient absorption and metabolic burden, aligning with the physiological demands of goslings during early development.
The calcium-to-phosphorus ratio (Ca: P) was deliberately adjusted in a gradient manner in this study, allowing us to assess its impact alongside absolute calcium levels. The observed reduction in feed intake in the high-calcium group (2.88%) raised the question of whether growth suppression was primarily due to decreased nutrient intake rather than a direct metabolic effect of calcium. However, our analysis shows that despite lower ADFI, absolute calcium intake remained higher than in the other groups, and significant growth suppression was observed even when adjusted for differences in feed intake. This suggests that the negative effects of high dietary calcium were not simply due to lower protein and energy intake but were a result of altered nutrient metabolism, phosphorus absorption inhibition, and disruptions in protein utilization [
19]. Previous studies have suggested that high dietary calcium levels can reduce feed palatability, alter gut motility, and influence hormonal regulation of appetite, which may explain the reduction in feed intake observed in this study.
Feed represents the largest production cost in commercial poultry farming, accounting for approximately 60–70% of total expenses [
20]. The cost of calcium and protein sources varies, and unnecessary over-supplementation can increase feed costs without improving productivity. Excess dietary calcium (2.88%) increases feed costs without enhancing performance, making it economically inefficient. Protein sources, particularly soybean meal and fish meal, are among the most expensive ingredients in poultry diets. Increasing protein to 22.5% did not significantly improve weight gain but increased nitrogen excretion, leading to higher feed costs and potential environmental pollution.
UA is the final product of protein metabolism in poultry and serves as an indicator of protein metabolic status and overall nutritional balance [
21]. The level of CP in the diet significantly influences UA concentrations [
22]. Similarly, Cr, the final metabolite of muscle-derived N-[imino(phosphino)methyl]-N-methylglycine, is excreted via glomerular filtration, making its concentration a reliable marker of renal filtration capacity [
23]. UN, as the primary product of nitrogen metabolism, reflects amino acid balance in the feed and protein metabolic efficiency [
24]. Excessive dietary calcium (2.88%) was associated with elevated serum UA, Cr, and UN levels, indicative of metabolic stress and compromised renal function. In contrast, moderate calcium levels (0.96%) supported optimal serum profiles, enhancing nutrient absorption and metabolic efficiency. Higher dietary CP (22.5%) elevated serum Cr and UN levels, reflecting increased renal nitrogen excretion driven by heightened protein catabolism. Conversely, a CP level of 18.5% balanced protein adequacy while minimizing metabolic stress. These findings align with Rasool et al. [
25], who observed a negative correlation between UN concentration and growth performance, including daily weight gain and muscle development in chickens. Similarly, Xi et al. [
26] demonstrated that increasing dietary protein levels raises serum UA, Cr, and UN concentrations, supporting the current study’s results. Together, these observations suggest that excessive dietary protein imposes metabolic burdens, increasing nitrogenous waste excretion and potentially reducing growth efficiency. The concurrent decline in feed intake and rise in UA, Cr, and UN levels suggest that goslings may have adapted by reducing their voluntary feed consumption to mitigate metabolic overload and renal stress. Notably, the interaction between high calcium and high protein intake appears to amplify the metabolic burden, leading to higher nitrogen excretion and potential renal inefficiency. This aligns with previous findings in poultry, where excess calcium can impair amino acid digestibility and protein metabolism, further exacerbating metabolic stress [
27]. The reduction in feed intake observed under these conditions may be a compensatory response to limit additional metabolic strain, reinforcing the idea that nutrient imbalances, rather than feed palatability, were the primary drivers of intake suppression.
Serum Ca levels were highest in goslings fed 2.88% Ca, while phosphorus (P) levels peaked in the 0.32% Ca group, emphasizing the intricate interplay between Ca and P absorption. Moderate CP levels (14.5% and 18.5%) were associated with higher serum P concentrations, suggesting enhanced mineral utilization at these protein levels. Notably, significant interactions between dietary Ca and CP levels underscore the importance of balanced nutrient formulations, as excessive levels of either nutrient disrupt serum profiles, whereas moderate levels optimize metabolic outcomes. Carreras-Sureda et al. [
28] highlighted the critical role of Ca
2⁺ in maintaining endoplasmic reticulum (ER) homeostasis, which is essential for proper protein folding and overall protein metabolism. Disruptions in ER homeostasis caused by imbalanced Ca
2⁺ levels can impair protein metabolism and cellular functionality. Furthermore, Anthony et al. [
29] utilized advanced methodologies to explore calmodulin-protein interactions, providing deeper insights into how calcium regulates protein metabolism through such molecular mechanisms. These findings align with the present study’s observations, demonstrating significant interactions between dietary calcium and protein levels and their collective impact on metabolic and physiological outcomes in goslings.
Moderate dietary calcium (Ca) levels (0.96%) consistently supported superior villus height (VH) and crypt depth (CD) across intestinal segments, indicating that balanced calcium levels enhance mucosal development and intestinal functionality. This finding is consistent with the study by Paone et al. [
30], which demonstrated that optimal dietary calcium levels promote intestinal health and structural integrity. In contrast, excessive Ca (2.88%) impaired intestinal morphology, likely due to disruptions in mineral balance and interference with phosphorus absorption. High calcium levels can also alter the gut’s ionic environment, negatively affecting cell proliferation and differentiation in the intestinal epithelium, ultimately reducing nutrient absorption efficiency. The observed reduction in VH and CD with high Ca levels aligns with findings that excessive calcium inhibits the absorption of other critical nutrients, such as phosphorus and zinc, thereby compromising intestinal structure and functionality [
31,
32]. Conversely, lower Ca levels (0.32%) may initially promote epithelial development in younger goslings due to reduced competition for nutrient absorption. However, prolonged deficiencies may hinder sustained growth and nutrient uptake, emphasizing the importance of maintaining an optimal balance in dietary calcium levels.
Crude protein levels significantly influenced intestinal morphology, particularly VH. Higher CP levels (18.5–22.5%) enhanced VH and CD in most intestinal segments, reflecting the essential role of dietary protein in supporting epithelial cell turnover and intestinal growth. Adequate protein intake supplies the essential amino acids required for mucosal regeneration and the synthesis of digestive enzymes, both of which are vital for maintaining an intact intestinal barrier and ensuring efficient nutrient absorption and digestion [
33,
34]. However, the lack of additional morphological improvements with CP levels exceeding 22.5% suggests that excessive protein intake may impose unnecessary metabolic burdens, such as increased nitrogen excretion, without providing further benefits to gut structure [
35]. This finding highlights the importance of tailoring dietary protein levels to the specific physiological needs of goslings, optimizing intestinal development while minimizing metabolic inefficiencies. These results align with existing studies indicating that excessive protein consumption can strain metabolic processes without enhancing productive or structural outcomes [
36].
The significant interaction effects between Ca and crude protein (CP) on intestinal morphology highlight the intricate interplay between these nutrients. The significant Ca × CP interactions observed for VH and CD indicate that maintaining a moderate Ca level (0.96%) alongside balanced CP intake (14.5–18.5%) supports optimal intestinal structure and function. Balanced dietary formulations are crucial to preventing the competitive absorption or metabolic stress that can result from imbalanced nutrient levels. Calcium functions as a cofactor in various enzymatic processes, including those associated with protein metabolism, and thus has a direct impact on intestinal health through nutrient interactions [
37]. The segment-specific responses observed in this study underscore the gastrointestinal tract’s adaptability to dietary variations; this is consistent with the study of Poole et al. [
38]. For example, while lower Ca levels may initially promote epithelial development in the jejunum and ileum, moderate Ca (0.96%) supports sustained gut health and functionality over the long term. These findings reflect the dynamic nature of the gastrointestinal system in adapting to dietary inputs and maintaining growth and metabolic homeostasis. Balanced nutrient levels ensure optimal intestinal structure and functionality, emphasizing the need for precise dietary management to maximize productivity and animal health.
In this experiment, α-AMS activity in 30-day-old goslings was significantly higher than that in 14-day-old goslings, which aligns with the findings of Noy et al. [
39], who reported a 100-fold increase in AMS activity in the duodenum of 21-day-old chicks compared to 4-day-old chicks. This underscores the age-dependent maturation of digestive enzyme systems in poultry. Interestingly, a similar age-related shift was observed in TPS activity under different dietary protein levels. At 14 days, the highest TPS activity occurred in the 22.5% CP group, whereas at 30 days, the highest TPS activity was recorded in the 14.5% CP group. This discrepancy may reflect the dynamic regulation of protease secretion during development. Early in life, higher dietary protein may transiently stimulate trypsin production to meet the high demand for amino acids. However, prolonged exposure to excessive protein could trigger negative feedback regulation mechanisms, downregulating protease synthesis and activity in the later stage of growth [
40,
41]. The results also emphasize that moderate dietary calcium levels (0.96%) optimize enzymatic activities in the duodenum, particularly for lipid digestion, as indicated by higher LPS activity. However, excessive Ca (2.88%), despite increasing α-AMS activity, may disrupt overall nutrient digestion efficiency, likely due to its influence on the gut’s ionic environment and enzyme activation processes. Research shows that varying dietary calcium levels can alter intestinal flora composition and abundance, disrupt homeostasis, and impair nutrient absorption by affecting the secretion of digestive enzymes [
42].
Furthermore, CP levels significantly influenced enzyme activities, with lower CP (14.5%) supporting balanced enzymatic function. Protein levels beyond metabolic demands may lead to inefficiencies in nutrient digestion, as enzymes adapt to higher dietary loads [
43]. The jejunum, a critical site for nutrient absorption, demonstrated improved TPS activity at moderate Ca levels, highlighting the importance of balancing dietary nutrients for enzymatic efficiency. The elevated lipase activity observed with higher CP levels (22.5%) suggests an adaptive response to increased dietary fat and protein, enhancing lipid digestion capacity. However, reliance on excessive protein to drive enzymatic activity may impose metabolic burdens on the digestive system, reducing overall efficiency and potentially affecting long-term health [
44]. These findings emphasize the need for precise dietary formulations to optimize enzymatic activities and maintain intestinal homeostasis.
In the ileum, TPS activity was optimized by moderate Ca levels (0.96%) and higher CP levels (22.5%), underscoring their critical roles in protein digestion and nitrogen utilization. The sensitivity of the distal intestine to dietary imbalances highlights the necessity for precise nutrient formulations to prevent inefficiencies in nutrient absorption. The sustained enzymatic response observed at moderate nutrient levels suggests that optimal Ca and CP ratios enhance the gut’s adaptability to dietary challenges, thereby supporting long-term digestive health. The interaction effects between Ca and CP across intestinal segments indicate that these nutrients act synergistically rather than independently to regulate enzymatic activity. Calcium, as a vital cofactor in numerous enzymatic reactions, influences digestive functionality through its roles in enzyme activation and the maintenance of mucosal integrity [
45]. Concurrently, protein supplies essential substrates for enzymatic adaptation, modulating the expression and activity of digestive enzymes [
46]. However, excessive dietary Ca can disrupt this synergy by altering the gut’s ionic environment, which is critical for enzyme activity, thereby reducing protein digestibility. Similarly, excessive protein intake may impose an enzymatic burden, leading to inefficiencies in digestion and metabolic stress [
47]. These findings reinforce the importance of balanced dietary formulations to optimize enzymatic activity and maintain gastrointestinal homeostasis.
Bregendahl et al. [
48] demonstrated that broilers fed low-protein diets exhibited significantly lower growth performance and nitrogen excretion compared to those fed high-protein diets. Moreover, they observed a direct correlation between nitrogen intake and excretion, emphasizing the environmental impact of higher dietary protein levels. However, contrary evidence suggests that moderately reducing CP levels, without compromising animal growth, can effectively decrease fecal nitrogen emissions while enhancing nutrient utilization efficiency. Importantly, such reductions can be achieved without detrimental effects on growth performance. Kim et al. [
49] further supported this by showing that the addition of protease to low-protein diets improved growth performance and CP utilization in piglets and finishing pigs, highlighting enzymatic supplementation as a strategy to mitigate the limitations of reduced protein intake.
Additionally, Kerstetter et al. [
50] noted that low-protein diets could inhibit intestinal calcium absorption, subsequently affecting calcium utilization. This finding underscores the interplay between protein and mineral metabolism, emphasizing the need for dietary adjustments to ensure balanced nutrient absorption and utilization. These findings collectively highlight the necessity of precision in formulating low-protein diets to balance environmental sustainability, physiological requirements, and growth performance.
This study further revealed that calcium utilization increased with dietary Ca levels, with the highest efficiency observed in the 2.88% Ca group. This may reflect a compensatory physiological response to excess dietary calcium, as the gut enhances absorption to counterbalance potential deficiencies caused by high excretion rates. However, such enhanced efficiency does not necessarily translate to improved growth due to the metabolic costs associated with excess calcium, which can disrupt overall nutrient absorption dynamics. Similarly, goslings fed 14.5% CP exhibited higher calcium utilization than those on 22.5% CP, suggesting that excessive protein levels may interfere with calcium metabolism by altering the gut’s ionic environment or increasing metabolic competition.
Phosphorus utilization was maximized in goslings fed a 0.96% Ca diet, underscoring the critical importance of maintaining an optimal calcium-to-phosphorus ratio. Excessive calcium levels (2.88%) likely impaired phosphorus absorption through the formation of insoluble calcium-phosphorus complexes in the gut. Although dietary CP levels did not directly influence phosphorus utilization, the significant interaction between Ca and CP suggests that balanced nutrient formulations are essential to avoid competitive inhibition of nutrient absorption.
Finally, protein utilization was significantly influenced by dietary CP levels, with the highest efficiency observed at 14.5% CP. This reflects the ability of goslings to metabolize and retain protein effectively when dietary levels align with physiological needs. In contrast, higher protein levels (22.5%) appeared to lead to metabolic inefficiency, as the excess nitrogen was excreted, increasing energy expenditure and renal burden. Although dietary calcium levels had no direct impact on protein utilization, significant interaction effects between Ca and CP levels highlighted the interconnectedness of nutrient metabolism, underscoring the need for balanced dietary formulations to optimize metabolic efficiency and overall performance.