Review Reports

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

The authors report a case of Akatsuki's disease combined with a skin tumor. This is a case report from an interesting perspective. Please consider the following point.

Figure 1: For the histopathological image, please add a photograph of the normal epidermis within the overall image. A weakly magnified image would be good to add.

Author Response

The authors report a case of Akatsuki's disease combined with a skin tumor. This is a case report from an interesting perspective. Please consider the following point.

Figure 1: For the histopathological image, please add a photograph of the normal epidermis within the overall image. A weakly magnified image would be good to add.

 

Thank you very much for reviewing our manuscript. We are pleased to hear your favorable comments. According to the suggestion, a weakly magnified histological image is now included in the revised manuscript. Thank you for the suggestion.

Reviewer 2 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

Thank you for the chance to review this interesting paper concering the occurance of Akatsuki  disease on a cutaneous basal cell carcinoma.

The Authors reported something that is already known in the routine practice, the development of crusts and keratin scales on the skin of people with poor hygenic conditions. The presentation on a basal cell carcinoma in curious.

Comments on the Quality of English Language

The English language should be improved.

For example, page 1 line 32 "After 2 months later" should be "After 2 months" or "Two months later".

Author Response

Thank you for the chance to review this interesting paper concering the occurance of Akatsuki  disease on a cutaneous basal cell carcinoma.

The Authors reported something that is already known in the routine practice, the development of crusts and keratin scales on the skin of people with poor hygenic conditions. The presentation on a basal cell carcinoma in curious.

The English language should be improved.

For example, page 1 line 32 "After 2 months later" should be "After 2 months" or "Two months later".

 

Thank you very much for reviewing our manuscript. We are pleased to hear the favorable comments.

According to the suggestion, English is now edited by editing service. The certificate is submited as a supplementary file.Thank you for the suggestion

Reviewer 3 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

Many dermatologists do not remove crusts adequately before biopsy, especially on the scalp of older men. A few more sentences with information about how to remove crusts before biopsy would be educational.

Comments on the Quality of English Language

only needs light editing

Author Response

Many dermatologists do not remove crusts adequately before biopsy, especially on the scalp of older men. A few more sentences with information about how to remove crusts before biopsy would be educational.

Comments on the Quality of English Language

only needs light editing

 

Thank you very much for reviewing our manuscript. We are pleased to hear your favorable comments. According to the suggestion, English is now edited by editing service. The certificate is submitted as a supplementary file. Thank you for the suggesiton.