Plasma as Proxy for Tissue Metabolism When Extending Lifespan in Mice

Objective: Despite most often used in research and medicine, it is unclear how well blood metabolite levels can reflect metabolic changes in tissues. Methods: We used untargeted metabolomic data from plasma, liver, gastrocnemius muscle, kidney, inguinal fat, and gonadal fat tissues from mice treated with lifespan-extending interventions: caloric restriction, rapamycin, canagliflozin, 17-α estradiol, and acarbose. Results: For each tissue, about 37% of the identified metabolites were also found in plasma and used for comparative analyses. We found that plasma metabolites do not primarily reflect the metabolome of a single tissue type. Caloric restriction caused the highest proportion of significantly altered metabolites detected in both organs and blood. Unsaturated triacylglycerols, diacylglycerols, amino acid-derivatives, and sphingomyelins had the most concordant overlaps between four tissues and plasma, followed by carbohydrates with three tissue/plasma intersections. Concordant plasma/tissue changes were found more pronounced in male mice than in female mice. Surprisingly, many compounds that responded similarly to lifespan-extending treatments in tissues and in plasma originated from dietary compounds, specifically, ergothioneine, DHA-containing fats, and diacylglycerides. Ergothioneine, previously associated with healthy aging in humans, showed concordant treatment responses in blood and all tissues except gonadal fat. DHA-containing fats showed consistent regulation between blood and inguinal and gonadal adipose tissue. The kidneys showed coherent trends with blood metabolite levels for LPC 15:0, LPC 17:0, and pinitol. Under treatments with strong life-extending effects, 1,5-anhydro-glucitol blood levels were co-regulated with both liver and kidney levels. Conclusions: Overall, plasma can only serve as limited proxy for tissue metabolism. Yet, several potential blood biomarkers were discovered as concordant in plasma and tissues in lifespan-extending interventions.