1. Introduction
Recent clinical surveillance has indicated an increasing incidence of
Brucella anthropi (formerly
Ochrobactrum anthropi) infections, identifying it as an emerging opportunistic pathogen [
1,
2,
3,
4]. Although taxonomic reclassification aligning this organism with the highly virulent
B. melitensis raised concerns regarding its pathogenicity, comparative genomics has revealed that
B. anthropi lacks the signature intracellular virulence determinants found in classical
Brucella species [
5]. Unlike niche-restricted
Brucella lineages,
B. anthropi exhibits exceptional genomic plasticity and competence for mobile genetic elements [
6,
7], as exemplified by the multi-replicon structure of the reference strain ATCC 49188 [
8]. Consequently, the absence of classical virulence factors is likely counterbalanced by the rapid acquisition of multidrug resistance and secondary virulence modules, thereby accelerating the evolution of
B. anthropi into a critical pathogenic threat.
Clinically, this genomic versatility exacerbates the therapeutic challenges posed by the intrinsic resistance of the bacterium.
B. anthropi possesses intrinsic resistance to most β-lactams, resulting in limited therapeutic options that are easily compromised by the acquisition of secondary resistance traits [
9,
10]. Notably, in 2022, a report documented an IMP-producing
B. anthropi strain from a carbapenem-resistant infection [
11], indicating that this organism has transitioned from an environmental saprophyte to a reservoir of last-resort antibiotic resistance. Crucially, such clinical emergence likely represents only the endpoint of an evolutionary process, and the genetic assembly of these high-risk phenotypes likely occurs earlier in anthropogenic environments characterized by intense selection pressure.
Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTPs) serve as critical repositories for antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and pathogens, creating continuous selection pressure that drives microbial evolution [
12,
13]. Although current biosecurity protocols often focus on treated effluents, the subsequent application of reclaimed water for irrigation introduces a direct interface between these reservoirs and agricultural soils [
14]. In this complex matrix, the convergence of residual antibiotics, heavy metals, and high bacterial density facilitates horizontal gene transfer (HGT) [
15], transforming soil microflora into persistent reservoirs of multidrug resistance. Crucially, evidence suggests that pathogens, such as
B. anthropi, do not remain static in this environment and can be aerosolized from contaminated soil, particularly during irrigation and tillage operations [
16]. This bioaerosol pathway establishes a plausible transmission route to the respiratory tract of agricultural and sanitation workers, potentially facilitating colonization and subsequent dissemination into broader community settings [
17].
In the present study, a blaIMP-1-carrying B. anthropi strain (SBA01) was isolated from municipal wastewater-irrigated soil. This isolation occurred in 2019, predating the major clinical reports of this specific phenotype and suggesting an earlier environmental origin. By characterizing SBA01, the molecular mechanisms underlying its resistance, stability, and capacity for transspecies dissemination were investigated. Furthermore, a comprehensive risk index was used to quantify the pathogenicity and mobility of this lineage, providing a practical basis for controlling its environmental and occupational transmission.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Sample Collection, Isolation, and Identification
Sampling was conducted on 24 January 2019, at a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) in Jinan, Shandong Province, Eastern China (116°57′14.07″ E, 36°41′38.86″ N). The sampled green spaces have a documented history of continuous irrigation with effluent which represents the final discharge point into the receiving river ecosystem since approximately 2007, at a frequency of one to two times per week. Four composite superficial soil samples (depth 0–10 cm) were collected. For each of the four designated sampling plots (standardized to approximately 10 × 10 m), a five-point sampling strategy was strictly employed, wherein five distinct core subsamples (from the four corners and the center) were pooled to generate a single representative composite sample [
18]. At least 30 g of soil samples were collected in sterile plastic bottles, placed in a cooler box at 4 °C, and transported to the laboratory within 12 h for immediate processing. The soil samples were subjected to a pre-enrichment step in brain–heart infusion broth, which was performed overnight before application to the plates. The enriched solutions (100 µL) were plated on MacConkey agar (Oxoid, Basingstoke, UK) supplemented with 2 mg/L of meropenem (Meilun, Dalian, China) to isolate potential carbapenem-resistant isolates [
19]. Species identification was performed using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (Bruker, Billerica, MA, USA) [
20].
2.2. Genomic DNA Sequencing and Bioinformatics Analysis
Genomic DNA of the donor strain SBA01 was extracted and purified using the Gentra Puregene Yeast/Bact. Kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). To resolve complex plasmid architectures, a hybrid sequencing strategy was employed. Short-read sequencing was performed on the Illumina NovaSeq 6000 platform (San Diego, CA, USA) with 150 bp paired-end reads, while long-read sequencing was executed on the Oxford Nanopore Technologies MinION platform (Oxford, UK) [
20]. Hybrid de novo assembly was conducted using Unicycler v0.4.8 in ‘--bold’ mode to achieve complete circularization [
21]. Structural closure of the chromosome and plasmids was confirmed by identifying terminal overlapping sequences at unitig extremities.
Definitive taxonomic classification of SBA01 was confirmed by calculating the Average Nucleotide Identity (ANI) against the
B. anthropi reference genome (ATCC 49188T) using FastANI v1.34, applying a species-delineation threshold of >95%. Genome annotation was performed via the Bacterial and Viral Bioinformatics Resource Center (BV-BRC) server (Chicago, IL, USA). Resistome and virulome profiles were characterized using the BV-BRC Comprehensive Genome Analysis service, incorporating CARD v3.1.2 (identity ≥ 95%, coverage ≥ 95%) and VFDB v3.3.0 (E-value < 1 × 10
−10, identity > 80%) [
22]. To pre-evaluate the mobilization potential of the identified extrachromosomal elements, potential origins of transfer (oriT) and mobilization modules were profiled using OriTDB (
https://bioinfo-mml.sjtu.edu.cn/oriTDB2/oriTfinder.php; accessed on 1 February 2026) [
23], and plasmid incompatibility (Inc) typing was performed via PlasmidFinder v2.0.1. Integrated prophages were predicted using the PHASTER web server, retaining only ‘intact’ regions (score > 90) [
24]. The genetic-environment comparison chart was created using Easyfig v2.2.2 [
25].
For comparative phylogenomic analysis,
B. anthropi genomic sequences were retrieved from the BV-BRC database. Quality control was enforced using stringent inclusion criteria: CheckM completeness
95%, contamination
2%, contig L50
20, and N50
150,000 bp. This rigorous filtering yielded 72 high-quality genomes (accession IDs and metadata are detailed in
Table S7). A Neighbor-Joining (NJ) tree was constructed utilizing the BV-BRC Bacterial Genome Tree service. Specifically, whole-genome single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were extracted from aligned global conserved protein families (PATRIC GFams), with branch stability evaluated via 100 bootstrap replicates. Clade assignments were established based on terminal branching architecture, where a “mixed-source lineage” was strictly defined as a localized cluster characterized by the direct interspersion of environmental and anthropogenic terminal nodes. The final phylogeny was visualized and annotated using iTOL v6 [
26].
To elucidate the fundamental genetic basis of the intrinsic colistin resistance, a targeted comparative analysis was executed within the R v4.4.1 programming environment. Initially, a curated theoretical panel of candidate genes canonically associated with polymyxin tolerance and envelope regulation was established. Utilizing the annotated protein sequence files (.faa), an orthology-based intersection was performed to extract the shared (core) genetic repertoire among three strategically selected
B. anthropi genomes: the target multidrug-resistant strain SBA01, the wild-type reference strain ATCC 49188, and a formally characterized colistin-susceptible clinical isolate, T210003. Utilizing the shared orthologous protein sequences, systematic multiple sequence alignments were conducted to pinpoint amino acid substitutions and structural variations exclusively harbored by SBA01. Special analytical focus was directed toward identifying nonsynonymous mutations within two-component regulatory systems and multidrug efflux pump repressors (e.g., phoP, mexP, and nfxB) [
27].
2.3. Conjugation Experiments
To fundamentally validate the bioinformatically predicted mobilization machinery, broth mating assays were conducted in independent biological triplicates.
Escherichia coli J53 (azide-resistant) and
Klebsiella pneumoniae K19 (exhibiting a high amikacin MIC) served as recipient strains. Robust controls were established: individual donor/recipient cultures were used to confirm the efficacy of the selective media, and a parallel mating mixture treated with DNase I (100 U/mL) was incorporated to definitively rule out natural transformation. Donor and recipient cultures were grown to the logarithmic phase (OD600 ≈ 0.6), mixed at a 1:1 volume ratio, and co-incubated overnight (16 h) at 37 °C without agitation. Following serial dilution, transconjugants were recovered on selective agar supplemented with 2 mg/L imipenem and respective counter-selection antibiotics (sodium azide for J53; amikacin for K19). Conjugation frequencies were subsequently calculated as the number of transconjugant colony-forming units (CFUs) per donor CFU [
19].
To elucidate the co-transfer dynamics of the identified extrachromosomal elements, genomic DNA of TBK1 was sequenced on the Illumina NovaSeq 6000 platform. Short-read assembly was performed using Unicycler v0.4.8 in short-read-only mode. The structural integrity of the co-transferred bipartite system was validated by aligning the TBK1 raw reads against the high-quality, circularized reference templates of pSBA01-IMP and pSBA01-con established from the donor strain. This mapping-based verification utilized a stringency threshold of >99.9% sequence identity and 100% breadth of coverage, effectively filtering background recipient chromosomal DNA. Furthermore, the relative plasmid copy number (PCN) in the transconjugant was estimated by normalizing the mean mapping depth of the plasmid-specific contigs against the average chromosomal coverage of the K. pneumoniae recipient.
2.4. Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
The minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of eight antibiotics—meropenem, ertapenem, colistin, ceftazidime/avibactam, tigecycline, cefotaxime, ciprofloxacin, and amikacin (Meilun, Dalian, China)—were determined for the isolates. Routine susceptibility testing was performed using the agar dilution method as recommended by the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI). However, tigecycline and colistin were evaluated using the broth microdilution method. Specifically for colistin, to prevent drug absorption artifacts, assays were strictly conducted following ISO 20776-1 guidelines utilizing unsupplemented cation-adjusted Mueller–Hinton broth (CAMHB) and untreated polystyrene microtiter plates without the addition of polysorbate 80 [
28].
The MIC results were primarily interpreted according to CLSI (2020) breakpoints. Due to the absence of species-specific clinical breakpoints for B. anthropi, the MICs for tigecycline and colistin were interpreted utilizing the European Committee on Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing (EUCAST, version 10.0) breakpoints, with colistin specifically referring to the non-species-related pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PK/PD) resistance threshold (>2 μg/mL). Quality control was successfully validated using Escherichia coli ATCC 25922, with all MICs falling within acceptable standard ranges.
2.5. Multidimensional Quantitative Health Risk Index Framework
To comprehensively evaluate the potential health hazards posed by SBA01, a weighted vector-based risk index model was developed that integrated the phenotypic (PRI), genotypic (GRI), and spreading (SRI) risk dimensions.
The
PRI quantifies clinical treatment challenges. To ensure comparability, the index was standardized against 12 core antibiotic classes prioritized by the WHO (available at
https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241515528, accessed on 1 February 2026), including carbapenems, polymyxins, and third-generation cephalosporins. Scores were weighted by clinical hierarchy (
):
for “last-resort” agents (carbapenems and colistin),
for high-priority broad-spectrum agents, and
for other standard therapeutic classes. Intrinsic resistance profiles were excluded to avoid score inflation.
PRI is defined as:
where
represents the binary resistance status (1 for non-susceptible and 0 for susceptible). The denominator, mathematically expressed as the sum of all assigned constant weights (
), establishes the theoretical maximum score, reflecting a hypothetical pan-resistant profile across all 12 evaluated antibiotic classes.
The
GRI represents the cumulative hazard of genetic determinants, integrating both ARGs and virulence factors.
For ARGs, baseline weights (
) were initially mapped to the sequence-level risk ranking framework (ARGrank) defined by Zhang et al. [
29]: Rank I (highest risk) = 10; Rank II (high risk) = 5; Rank III (mid risk) = 3; Rank IV (low risk) = 1. However, to account for algorithmic limitations (e.g., environmental masking) in the reference database and ensure conservative risk profiling, a systematic four-tier curatorial criterion was applied: (1) Intrinsic Resistance Exclusion (
): Chromosomally encoded determinants reflecting the species-specific biological baseline were excluded to negate genomic background noise. (2) Sequence-level Discrepancy Resolution: Determinants with multi-rank annotations across different reference alleles (e.g.,
floR annotated as both Rank I and IV) were strictly categorized by their highest documented rank to ensure a conservative estimation. (3) Manual Escalation for Last-Resort Targets: High-risk plasmid-borne ARGs explicitly compromising WHO ‘Reserve’ category antibiotics (e.g., the carbapenemase), even if unlisted in the initial training set, were phenomenologically escalated to Rank I (
). (4) Homolog-based Inference for Unmapped Targets: For acquired determinants targeting standard antibiotics lacking direct allele matches, weights were inferred based on the predominating rank of their closest functional homologs (typically Rank IV,
). The detailed classifications and assigned weights for all identified ARGs are summarized in
Table S5. For virulence factors, the following hierarchical criteria were established: Tier 1 (
) for master conserved envelope regulators and structural determinants crucial for extreme environmental resilience and potential host-adaptability (including the
bvrR/S system and
ricA), and Tier 2 (
) for general biosynthetic or metabolic components (including
lpx and
manA). The complete inventory and tier assignments of VFs are provided in
Table S6.
To ensure dimensional consistency,
was normalized to
on a scale of
using a reference maximum value (
, representative of highly virulent clinical pathogens), this threshold reflects the theoretical upper bound of genetic hazards identified in highly virulent clinical pathogens (e.g., co-occurrence of multiple high-risk ARGs and essential virulence regulators):
The
SRI evaluates the potential for horizontal gene transfer (HGT), prioritizing functional biological evidence. The index is defined as the maximum value between experimental observations and bioinformatic predictions. An experimental score (
) of 1.0 is systematically assigned upon phenotypic confirmation of successful HGT in mating assays.
A maximum experimental score () of 1.0 is assigned only upon phenotypic confirmation of successful HGT via mating assays. The bioinformatic score () characterizes the genomic context of the target ARG. Given the absence of standardized replicon-typing profiles for this genus in public databases, plasmid identification relied on the structural resolution of complete, circular extrachromosomal contigs via hybrid assembly. Subsequent mobility classification was determined through functional annotation utilizing OriTDB. was assigned based on the following hierarchy: 0.8 for ARGs localized on self-transmissible plasmids (encoding both a complete T4SS and a relaxase); 0.5 for mobilizable plasmids (harboring relaxases or oriT sequences but lacking a functional T4SS); and 0.3 for ARGs associated with IS elements, transposons, or integrons without broader conjugal machinery. In multi-plasmid systems, if multiple plasmids or genetic scaffolds within a single strain carry ARGs, the final SRI corresponds to the maximum score among all individually assessed elements.
The Integrated Risk Magnitude (
), ranging from 0 to
, was derived as the Euclidean modulus of the risk vectors to reflect the convergence of phenotypic (
), genotypic (
), and spreading (
) hazards:
Based on the geometric distribution of this three-dimensional vector space, the health risk was stratified into four non-linear tiers: Low (); Moderate (); High (); and Critical (). These unequal intervals are predicated on the biological significance of multidimensional risk accumulation. Specifically, the “Critical” threshold of 1.4 reflects the simultaneous maximization of at least two risk categories (e.g., ), representing the dangerous co-occurrence of pan-drug resistance alongside high-frequency mobility or severe pathogenicity. This stratification ensures that the most hazardous “convergent” phenotypes are prioritized for immediate clinical or environmental biocontainment.
4. Discussion
Identification of
blaIMP-1-carrying
B. anthropi in municipal wastewater-irrigated soil underscores evolving role of nonfermenting Gram-negative bacteria as underestimated reservoirs involved in environmental dissemination of carbapenem resistance. Although
B. anthropi is typically regarded as a commensal soil organism or opportunistic pathogen of low virulence [
7,
9], these genomic findings reveal its potential to act as a resilient genetic vehicle for high-risk ARGs at the wastewater–soil interface. Specifically, the isolation of strain SBA01 demonstrated that environmental habitats under anthropogenic pressure have become assembly sites for multidrug-resistant genetic scaffolds. These genetic linkages, previously considered hallmarks of high-risk clinical Enterobacteriaceae, are now consolidated within resilient soil populations, effectively bridging gap between environmental resistomes and opportunistic human pathogens [
30,
31].
A pivotal finding in this study was genomic stability of
blaIMP-1 within the 21 kb plasmid, maintained by type II TA system [
32]. Bacterial persistence in soil environments requires metabolic efficiency, and maintenance of ARG-carrying plasmids typically imposes fitness cost [
33]. However, identification of plasmid addiction system in SBA01 explains maintenance of multidrug-resistant phenotype even in absence of direct antibiotic selection pressure. This mechanism effectively locks resistance determinants within population, prevents plasmid curing, and facilitates vertical transmission. Consequently,
B. anthropi populations in wastewater-affected soils may function as long-term genetic hubs for carbapenemases capable of surviving fluctuating environmental conditions that might otherwise eliminate less adapted plasmid hosts [
34,
35].
Beyond persistence, transmission of resistance from SBA01 to
Escherichia coli and
Klebsiella pneumoniae demonstrates its intrinsic capacity for HGT under prescribed conditions. Although small 21 kb plasmid harboring
blaIMP-1 lacks complete conjugative transfer region, the sequencing results indicate that co-resident unclassified 50 kb plasmid functions as helper element, providing necessary mating pair formation machinery [
36]. This mobilization strategy represents distinct dissemination paradigm compared with pandemic spread of bla
KPC and bla
NDM, which is predominantly driven by large, self-transmissible broad-host-range plasmids belonging to IncF, IncX3, or IncC incompatibility groups [
37]. Unlike the autonomous expansion typically observed with large Inc-type plasmids, the helper-dependent mobilization of
blaIMP-1 in SBA01 suggests a more cryptic mode of resistance persistence. Under this framework, small non-conjugative plasmids leverage pre-existing, broad-host-range conjugative networks of environmental helper elements to traverse phylogenetic barriers. While in vitro assays empirically demonstrate the feasibility of such interspecies exchange, extrapolating definitive directionality within natural ecosystems requires a cautious interpretative lens. The discovery of near-identical mobile genetic elements (MGEs) across disparate taxa—including clinical
Klebsiella and
Pseudomonas—may signify evolutionary convergence or independent acquisitions from a shared environmental reservoir, rather than strict unidirectional dissemination originating from
B. anthropi. Consequently, in the high-density microbial matrices of wastewater-irrigated soils, SBA01 is characterized as a resilient participant within a broader genetic network. In this environment, sub-inhibitory antimicrobial pressures and high cell densities likely facilitate the stochastic and bidirectional shuffling of resistance determinants between environmental opportunists and clinical lineages [
5,
37].
Beyond horizontal element exchange, the
mcr-independent colistin resistance observed in SBA01 highlights complex chromosomal adaptations. The identified mutations in regulatory loci, such as
phoP and
mexP/nfxB, are established drivers of lipid A structural modifications and compensatory efflux pump overexpression in related Gram-negative species [
38]. Furthermore, the functional acquisition of elevated colistin MICs in transconjugants—despite the absence of direct
mcr determinants on the plasmids—indicates an intricate plasmid-host regulatory crosstalk. It is postulated that extrachromosomal elements form a non-canonical trans-activation network. Specifically, exogenous expression of the plasmid-encoded
MltD enzyme and continuous
qacEΔ1 transporter activity likely perturb localized peptidoglycan homeostasis and alter transmembrane electrochemical gradients. These structural interventions may act as physical stimuli, triggering severe envelope stress responses (ESRs) in recipient cells. Upon activation, ESR pathways can bypass standard regulatory checkpoints, upregulating latent intrinsic resistance mechanisms. Additionally, the co-transferred
AraC-family transcriptional regulator may interact with chromosomal promoters to activate endogenous efflux or envelope-remodeling operons. Although this combinatorial model integrates mechanical envelope stress with regulatory crosstalk, definitive validation requires targeted transcriptomic and mutagenesis investigations.
The convergence of these multifaceted resistance networks and active mobilization dynamics fundamentally drives the high computed risk index (R = 1.63) assigned to SBA01. To contextualize this mathematical modeling, the result was benchmarked against reference strains. The distinct divergence between the susceptible wild-type (
B. anthropi ATCC 49188T, R = 0.48), the clinically isolated multidrug-resistant strain lacking high-tier virulence (T210003, R = 0.64), and SBA01 (R = 1.63) illustrates how the index captures the genomic risk escalation mediated by the convergence of mobile resistomes and resilience factors. Consequently, within this evaluation framework, SBA01 emerges as a high-priority genomic candidate for monitoring rather than a baseline environmental isolate. Crucially, its elevated risk profile is not defined by classical acute intracellular pathogenesis, but rather by its genomic potential to act as a resilient, mobile vehicle for high-priority carbapenemases. Surveillance paradigms could therefore benefit from expanding beyond traditional fecal indicators to monitor such opportunistic environmental hosts, which possess both the genetic markers for persistence at the soil–water interface and the conjugative machinery with the potential to transfer multidrug resistance across microbiomes [
39].
Integrating these findings within a One Health framework, the isolation of SBA01 from municipal wastewater-irrigated soil signifies a potential entry point for resistance determinants to interface with the community. Equipped with intrinsic soil adaptability and structural genomic stability, this lineage possesses the genetic architecture necessary to persist in agricultural matrices, independent of continuous wastewater seeding or direct selective pressure. Given the extensive irrigation history (2006–2019) at the sampling site, such agricultural soils function as long-term environmental niches. However, while the
Brucellaceae family exhibits robust environmental resilience, the soil–aerosol–human transmission axis [
40] requires careful contextualization. The current screening yielded a localized, singular clonal occurrence of SBA01 rather than a widespread ecological distribution. Without direct quantitative bioaerosol data, extrapolating the mechanical agitation of these soils into occupational respiratory colonization events remains strictly theoretical. Therefore, rather than projecting an immediate epidemiological threat, the identification of SBA01 exposes critical gaps in prevailing environmental monitoring strategies [
41]. Traditional regulatory frameworks are generally insufficient to detect cryptic resistance reservoirs sequestered within non-traditional environmental hosts. Broadening future surveillance to incorporate genomic-based biomonitoring at the wastewater–soil interface is essential to objectively assess whether these localized resistomes dissipate intrinsically or possess the capacity to evolve into broader public health threats.
Several empirical constraints characterize the current findings. The singular recovery of the blaIMP-1 carrying lineage (SBA01) from limited composite soil samples (n = 4) represents a highly localized event. This restricted sampling scale logically precludes extrapolations regarding its widespread environmental prevalence or long-term ecological dominance across broader agricultural matrices. Furthermore, while the genomic architecture indicates robust adaptability to soil environments, the proposed soil–aerosol–human transmission axis acts primarily as a theoretical risk framework. In the absence of targeted bioaerosol quantification, the actual occupational respiratory hazard and aerosolization potential of SBA01 remain to be empirically established. Methodologically, the primary isolation protocol relied on MacConkey agar supplemented with 2 mg/L meropenem. While effective for capturing high-risk clinical phenotypes, this stringent selective pressure intrinsically biases recovery toward robust Gram-negative isolates expressing high-level carbapenem resistance. Consequently, this approach introduces a systematic risk of omitting fastidious environmental hosts or atypical lineages that harbor sub-clinical, low-level carbapenemases (e.g., OXA-48-like variants), potentially underestimating the true breadth of the cryptic resistome within the soil matrix. Despite these constraints, this high-resolution genomic case study serves as a vital molecular baseline, highlighting the necessity of expanding current biomonitoring paradigms beyond conventional fecal indicators to capture cryptic multidrug-resistant vectors at the wastewater–soil interface.