Skip to Content
You are currently on the new version of our website. Access the old version .
SustainabilitySustainability
  • Article
  • Open Access

15 January 2026

27 Pages

Investigating Sustainable Development Trajectories in China (2006–2021): A Coupling Coordination Analysis of the Social, Economic, and Ecological Nexus

,
,
,
and
School of Geomatics and Urban Spatial Informatics, Beijing University of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Beijing 100044, China
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.

Abstract

The successful attainment of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) necessitates robust monitoring frameworks capable of tracking progress toward tangible outcomes while capturing dynamic sustainability trajectories. However, existing SDG evaluation methods suffer from three critical limitations: (1) misalignment between global targets and national priorities, which undermines contextual relevance; (2) fragmented assessments that neglect holistic integration of social, economic, and ecological dimensions, thereby obscuring systemic interdependencies; and (3) insufficient longitudinal analysis, which restricts insights into temporal patterns of sustainable development and hinders adaptive policymaking. To address these gaps, we employed China’s 31 provinces as a case study and constructed an SDG indicator framework comprising 178 metrics—harmonizing global SDG benchmarks with China’s national development priorities. Using official statistics and open-source data spanning 2006–2021, we evaluate longitudinal SDG scores for all 17 goals (SDGs 1–17). Additionally, we developed a composite SDG index that considers the coupling coordination degree of the social–economic–ecological system and evaluated the index value under different economic region settings. Finally, we developed a two-threshold model to analyze the dynamic evolution of SDG conditions, incorporating temporal sustainability (long-term development resilience) and action urgency (short-term policy intervention needs) as dual evaluation dimensions. This model was applied to conduct a longitudinal analysis (2006–2021) across all 31 Chinese provinces, enabling a granular assessment of regional SDG trajectories while capturing both systemic trends and acute challenges over time. The results indicate that China’s social SDG performance improved substantially over the 2006–2021 period, achieving a cumulative increase of 126.53%, whereas progress in ecological SDGs was comparatively modest, with a cumulative growth of only 23.93%. Over the same period, the average composite SDG score across China’s 31 provinces increased markedly from 0.502 to 0.714, reflecting a strengthened systemic alignment between regional development trajectories and national sustainability objectives. Further analysis shows that all provinces attained a status of “temporal sustainability with low action urgency” throughout the study period, highlighting China’s overall progress in sustainable development. Nevertheless, pronounced regional disparities persist: eastern provinces developed earlier and have consistently maintained leading positions; central and northeastern regions exhibit broadly comparable development levels; and western regions, despite severe early-stage lagging, have demonstrated accelerated growth in later years. Our study holds substantial significance by integrating multi-dimensional indicators—spanning ecological, economic, and social dimensions—to deliver a holistic, longitudinal perspective on sustainable development.

1. Introduction

In 2015, the United Nations Sustainable Development Summit formally adopted Transforming our World: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (hereafter referred to as the 2030 Agenda), which sets out 17 sustainable development goals (SDGs) and 169 specific targets [1,2,3]. These goals encompass the three dimensions of society, economy, and ecology [4,5,6], providing a comprehensive blueprint for global sustainable development. However, substantial disparities exist across countries. To respond to the UN’s call and localize the 17 SDGs within the Chinese context, China formulated the China’s Agenda 21: White Paper on Population, Environment, and Development, and subsequently introduced policy documents such as the China’s National Plan on Implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development [7,8], offering concrete pathways toward achieving the SDGs in China. Nevertheless, given China’s vast territory and the pronounced developmental differences among its eastern, central, western, and northeastern regions, a robust monitoring framework is urgently needed. Such a framework should be capable of tracking progress toward tangible outcomes, capturing dynamic sustainability trajectories, and providing objective evaluations of regional development conditions, thereby guiding targeted improvements and informing region-specific strategies for advancing sustainable development.
Quantifying sustainable development is fundamental to assessing the status of a region, with the core task being the establishment of a robust and comprehensive indicator system. To this end, scholars have collected relevant indicator data using Earth observation [9], remote sensing data [10], and statistical yearbooks [11,12]. However, due to the singularity of data sources, many studies have only monitored and evaluated individual SDG targets. Only SDG 11.3.1 (land use efficiency) and SDG 11.6.2 (population-weighted urban PM2.5) were examined in one study [9], while another study [13] analyzed four goals: SDG 1 (no poverty), SDG 10 (reduced inequalities), SDG 8 (decent work and economic growth), and SDG 13 (climate action). From the perspective of assessing a region’s overall sustainable development, such approaches offer only a partial view and cannot adequately reflect the full complexity of development conditions. Furthermore, most global-level studies rely primarily on the SDG Index dataset [14,15], and the monitoring of many self-constructed SDG indicator systems remains fragmented in design and largely sector-oriented [16]. Moreover, global targets are not always aligned with national priorities, which weakens contextual relevance when applying a uniform set of indicators across different countries and regions. For instance, SDG 14 (life below water) has limited applicability for landlocked countries, whereas SDG 9 (industry, innovation and infrastructure) is of far greater urgency for rapidly developing economies such as China and India. Therefore, having a well-developed SDG indicator system that aligns with the national and regional context is crucial for accurately assessing local sustainable development.
Since the launch of the 2030 Agenda, numerous scholars have explored the interrelationships between different systems and the 17 SDGs. For instance, the 17 SDGs have been classified under the three pillars of sustainable well-being, and their interconnections have been analyzed in a study [4]. Another study [5] investigated the interactions between terrestrial ecosystems and the 17 SDGs across 31 Chinese provinces from 2000 to 2015. Such studies primarily analyzed the impact of individual systems on the SDGs, providing insights for developing system-specific strategies. The 17 SDGs and their sub-targets are themselves highly interconnected [17]. Accordingly, many studies have sought to identify the underlying drivers of changing interactions among indicators across regions [1,11,15,18,19,20]. For example, shifts in the trade-offs and synergies among 16 SDGs (excluding SDG 14) in China from 2000 to 2020 have been analyzed using 86 provincial-level indicators in a study [11]. The dynamic evolution of trade-offs and synergies across national, provincial, and regional scales during the same period has also been assessed in another study [20]. Given the complexity of interactions among indicators—and the fact that the 17 SDGs are grounded in the three dimensions of society, economy, and ecology—an objective evaluation of sustainable development at the regional level requires simultaneous consideration of all three dimensions. However, existing assessments of sustainable development at the provincial level in China remain fragmented to some extent. On the one hand, some studies have constructed evaluation frameworks solely by coupling environmental performance with human well-being [21], failing to fully reflect the integrity and internal interconnections of the society–economy–ecology system. On the other hand, many existing studies are spatially limited to specific regions [12,22,23,24], which constrains a systematic understanding of China’s overall development pattern. Marked disparities exist across China’s regions in terms of social, economic, and ecological conditions. For example, inland provinces face challenges in economic development and ecological protection that differ substantially from those encountered in coastal areas, while the climatic and ecological characteristics of tropical and subtropical provinces are not representative of the country as a whole. In contrast, this study covers all 31 provinces of China and constructs a comprehensive indicator system encompassing social, economic, and ecological dimensions, thereby enabling a systematic depiction of the spatiotemporal patterns of regional sustainable development at the national scale. This holistic perspective not only facilitates the identification of regional heterogeneity and common evolutionary trends but also provides a more solid scientific basis for formulating policy recommendations that are both nationally applicable and regionally targeted.
Early studies on the impacts of human society (socio-economic dimensions) on nature have shown that past couplings exert legacy effects on present conditions and future possibilities [25], highlighting the importance of time-series analyses of regional development. Although many studies compare sustainable development conditions at different time points within the same region to reflect developmental progress over a given period [26,27,28,29], this approach often obscures the underlying causes of major disruptions in development. To systematically assess sustainable development at the provincial level in China, this study builds upon the coupling coordination degree (CCD) model and incorporates the optimized framework proposed by Huan et al. [30], taking into account China’s development characteristics across the social, economic, and ecological dimensions. Compared with alternative approaches such as structural equation modeling or network analysis—which primarily focus on causal inference or interaction structures—the CCD model does not explicitly capture non-linear feedback mechanisms or detailed causal pathways. However, by jointly quantifying the coupling intensity and coordination level among socio-economic-ecological subsystems, it provides an effective and policy-relevant measure of overall development coordination. This makes the CCD framework particularly suitable for long-term, province-level, and cross-regional comparative assessments of sustainable development. Furthermore, the optimization introduced by Huan et al. [30] increases the relative contribution of the comprehensive development index T within the coordination degree D, thereby mitigating the so-called “low-coupling trap” inherent in the traditional CCD model—where a relatively high coupling degree C combined with a low overall development level T may lead to an overestimation of coordination. This enhancement improves the robustness and interpretability of the composite SDG index in capturing regional sustainability performance.
To evaluate China’s progress in sustainable development and to provide references for achieving the SDGs, this study addresses the following research questions:
  • How can a provincial-level SDG indicator system be constructed to provide an objective and comprehensive assessment of sustainable development across China?
  • How can a dynamic monitoring framework be established to evaluate the temporal evolution of socio-economic and ecological progress across China’s 31 provinces?
  • What are the spatial and regional disparities in SDG performance among China’s provinces, and how can targeted policy recommendations be proposed to support the localization and implementation of the SDGs?
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 introduces the study area and the data used. Section 3 presents the methodology employed in this study, including the calculation of SDG scores and the construction of a dynamic monitoring framework. Section 4 presents the assessment results of social, economic, and ecological SDGs at both national and provincial scales. Section 5 discusses regional disparities, provides policy recommendations based on our monitoring and evaluation framework, and addresses research uncertainties. Finally, Section 6 concludes the paper.

2. Materials

2.1. Study Area

This study covers 31 provincial-level administrative regions in China (excluding Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan), accounting for 99% of the country’s total land area, as illustrated in Figure 1. Based on factors such as geographical location and developmental status, these 31 provinces are further categorized into four major economic regions: northeastern region, eastern region, central region, and western region [31]. The detailed classification is presented in Table 1. As a large developing country, China has faced and experienced the detrimental environmental consequences of industrialization, as well as the disparities arising from swift economic growth and population expansion [27]. These issues presented considerable environmental challenges to the country [32]. In 2005, China officially incorporated the development goal of a “harmonious society” into its 11th Five-Year Plan, with the objective of nurturing a sense of belonging and unity among its citizens, ultimately fostering stability and prosperity, with the aspiration to achieve this by 2020 [33]. After that, China has been endeavoring to harmonize resources across various regions in fulfillment of its pledge to the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda [6]. In this context, China is well-suited to assess its sustainable development status, thereby providing valuable insights for future advancements.
Figure 1. Overview of the study area. Source: The provincial administrative boundary map of China was obtained from the Resource and Environmental Science Data Platform; the economic regionalization scheme was adopted from the National Bureau of Statistics of China.
Table 1. Economic zone division in China. Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China [31].

2.2. Data Used

To conduct a comprehensive and rigorous evaluation of SDG conditions at the provincial level, we compiled 312 relevant data records covering the period from 2006 to 2021. Table 2 provides an overview of the data used, including names, sources, and related details. We collected remotely sensed observations, i.e., nighttime light data, which was used to extract urban boundaries according to the method proposed by Xie and Weng [34]. In combination with the land use data, we evaluated key indicators, e.g., SDG 15.2.1 (forest coverage rate). Environmental monitoring datasets, e.g., carbon emissions and PM2.5 concentrations, were systematically used to assess relevant indicators including SDG 11.6 (reducing the adverse environmental impact of cities) and SDG 13.2 (Integrating Climate Change Measures into National Policies). In addition, road traffic network data were employed to evaluate SDG11.2 (Public Transport Accessibility), while administrative boundary data served as a foundational layer for spatial analysis. Most SDG indicators were derived from statistical sources, such as data from the National Bureau of Statistics. It should be noted that indicators related to SDG 14 (Life Below Water), such as coastal water quality, are difficult to quantify for inland provinces but remain essential for coastal provinces. Therefore, SDG 14 indicators were assessed only for China’s 11 coastal provinces.
Table 2. Relevant data used in this study and the sources of the data. Source: Song et al. [28].

3. Methods

3.1. Overview of the Methodology

To address the complexities of sustainable development in China, we designed a dynamic, evidence-based evaluation system that integrates environmental, economic, and social dimensions. Figure 2 illustrates the analytical process of SDG evaluation, including three steps.
Figure 2. The analytical process of the study. Source: The research workflow diagram was drawn by the authors, and the SDG icons were obtained from the United Nations.
Firstly, we introduced an innovative method for evaluating the integration of SDGs at the provincial level, underpinned by a comprehensive analysis of Chinese provinces spanning from 2006 to 2021 [28]. This method facilitates a more refined assessment by selecting indicators that are regionally relevant, setting distinct benchmarks, and evaluating SDG performance from a holistic perspective.
Secondly, we employed the entropy weight method to objectively assign weights to the 17 SDGs and then scientifically classified them into social, economic, and ecological dimensions, effectively reducing subjective bias. Building upon this, we introduced an innovative coupling coordination degree model to develop a comprehensive sustainable development index system for Chinese provinces, enabling precise quantification of coordinated development across social, economic, and ecological dimensions while establishing a multidimensional synergy evaluation mechanism that overcomes the “unbalanced development” issue in traditional assessments.
Finally, the sustainable development monitoring and evaluation framework developed was utilized to evaluate the sustainability of each province’s development over a designated timeframe, i.e., 2006–2021, and to ascertain whether there is an immediate necessity to revise development strategies moving forward.
Based upon the tripartite classification of the 17 sustainable development goals (SDGs) into social, economic, and ecological dimensions, integrated with the coupling coordination degree (CCD) model, we developed a composite SDG index for China. This index serves as an objective metric to reflect the sustainable development status of various provinces and provides a quantitative foundation for systematically evaluating the overall progress of SDG implementation at the provincial level. This multidimensional evaluation framework exhibits three key characteristics:
Objectively quantifying the sustainable development performance of Chinese provinces.
Establishing a systematic metric for assessing provincial-level SDG implementation.
Revealing synergistic development patterns among social, economic, and ecological subsystems through coupling coordination mechanisms.
This integrated framework provides scientific support for formulating regional sustainable development strategies and policy-making.

3.2. SDG Score Calculation

Drawing inspiration from the “Global Indicator Framework for the Sustainable Development Goals and Targets of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development” (GIF-SDG) [35] and the “China’s National Plan on Implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development” (CNPI-2030ASD) [36], we have formulated a provincial-level local indicator system for SDGs following our prior research [28]. The newly established indicator system comprises 178 indicators, providing robust theoretical underpinnings and methodological frameworks for subsequent goal calculation. This local indicator system is characterized by two key features:
Dual alignment: Adopt global SDG indicators (e.g., poverty, clean energy) while embedding China’s national priorities (e.g., ecological civilization, dual-carbon goals, common prosperity).
Data-driven approach: Prioritize indicators with available provincial data (e.g., statistical yearbooks, environmental monitoring reports, and spatial data).
During the goal computation stages, we innovatively merged the averaging method with independent weighting to construct a comprehensive assessment framework noted for its exceptional robustness and adaptability. Ultimately, we computed SDG scores for goals 1–17, spanning the years 2006 to 2021, across China’s 31 provinces (as detailed in Table S1).

3.3. Sustainable Development Evaluation

3.3.1. Category Classification

Building upon our established SDG indicator system, we adopted a three-dimensional classification framework (i.e., society, economy, and ecology) derived from Song et al. [5] to structure the evaluation of China’s provincial SDG performance (Table 3), with specific indicators detailed in Table S2. This methodological approach enabled a systematic assessment of regional development across three domains: social SDGs, economic SDGs, and ecological SDGs. Each evaluation dimension was operationalized through more than 30 specific indicators and over 50 data points, sourced from provincial statistical yearbooks, environmental monitoring datasets, and spatial data repositories. This rigorous data-driven methodology provides a robust empirical foundation for analyzing regional disparities and tracking sustainable development progress.
Table 3. Sustainable development goal category classification. Source: Song et al. [28].

3.3.2. Normalization of Single SDG Score

To enable cross-provincial comparison of sustainable development progress, SDG scores for all provinces (2006–2021) were standardized using a min-max normalization approach. This methodological adjustment ensures dimensional consistency and enhances comparability across regions while preserving the original positive relationship between indicator values and development performance. Given the uniformly positive orientation of all goals, the standardization formula was applied as follows:
x i j k ′ = x i j k − x i m i n x i m a x − x i m i n
where x i j k ′ is the normalized value of goal i in province j for year k, x i j k denotes the raw value of goal i in province j for year k, x i j m i n is the minimum value of goal i across all provinces and years, and x i m a x is the maximum value of goal i across all provinces and years.

3.3.3. Weights

To reduce subjective bias in the evaluation outcomes, we employed the entropy weighting method to determine objective weights for each SDG indicator. Based on information entropy theory, this method assigns weights according to the degree of dispersion of indicators across the sample, thereby reducing the disproportionate influence of low-information indicators and extreme values on the composite assessment. Previous studies have demonstrated that the entropy weighting method effectively minimizes subjective interference [12], and it was therefore applied to compute entropy-based weights for indicators within the three dimensions (i.e., society, economy, and ecology). The methodology proceeded as follows:
Entropy weight calculation: For each SDG, we computed its information entropy based on data variability across provinces and years. Goals with greater variability (i.e., higher entropy reduction) were assigned higher weights, reflecting their greater discriminatory power in assessing development performance.
Dimension Score Synthesis: Using the entropy-derived weights, we aggregated the normalized SDG scores (Section 3.3.2) to generate composite scores for social, economic, and ecological dimensions. This weighted summation ensured that indicators with stronger explanatory power contributed more significantly to the final dimensional assessments.
This objective weighting framework enhances the robustness of provincial evaluations by grounding indicator importance in empirical data patterns rather than subjective judgment.
p i j k = x i j k ′ ∑ i = 1 n x i j k ′
e i j = − ∑ i = 1 n p i j k × ln p i j k + β ln n
d i j = 1 − e i j
w i j = d i j ∑ j = 1 m d i j
where p i j is the weight of goal i in province j for year k, n is the record size for the corresponding goal, x i j k ′ is the normalized value of the goal, and e i j is the entropy value of goal i in province j. Since goal scores were normalized, a situation where the weight is 0 may occur in Equation (2). Therefore, a small value β = 10 − 9 was introduced when calculating the entropy value e i j . d i j is the information utility value of goal i in province j, and w i j is the entropy weight of goal i in province j for the corresponding dimension. m is the total number of goals related to that dimension. For example, as shown in Table 3, SDGs 6, 13, 14, and 15 were categorized under the ecological dimension (m = 4). However, due to data unavailability for SDG 14 (Life Below Water) in non-coastal provinces, only SDGs 6, 13, and 15 were retained for the entropy weight calculation (m = 3). This adjustment ensured that weights were derived solely from goals with complete provincial coverage. The resulting province-specific SDG weights are detailed in Table S3.
U i k = ∑ i = 1 , j = 1 n , m x i j k ′ × w i j
where U i k is the dimensional SDG score for province i in year k. By multiplying the normalized indicator scores x i j k ′ for all indicators related to the dimension in province i by the corresponding information entropy weight w i j for that goal, and then summing them. Since x i j k ′ is the normalized score, the score U i k will fall between 0 and 1, which allows for a good evaluation of the coupling coordination degree [37].

3.3.4. Composite SDG Index

The coupling degree quantifies the strength of interaction between two distinct dimensions, with positive synergies among these dimensions serving as a critical foundation for sustainable development [38]. After categorizing SDGs into social, economic, and ecological dimensions, employing the CCD model provides an effective framework for evaluating the harmonious integration of these dimensions—a key indicator of sustainable development progress:
C i k = 2 × U i m k × U i n k U i m k + U i n k
T i k = β m U i m k + β n U i n k
where C i k represents the coupling degree between two dimensions in province i for year k, and T i k is the comprehensive index of the CCD between the two dimensions in province i for year k. U i m k and U i n k correspond to dimensional scores, e.g., social and economic dimensions, of province i in year k for the m and n dimensions, respectively. β m and β n represent the weights of m and n dimensions in province i for year k. While the conventional coupling degree model is limited to pairwise interactions between two dimensions, a more comprehensive assessment of sustainable development requires analyzing the synergistic relationships among all three dimensions—society, economy, and ecology—simultaneously. To address this limitation, Cong [39] proposed an extended CCD model capable of capturing the dynamic interplay among multiple dimensions, thereby providing a holistic evaluation of sustainable development progress:
C i k = 3 × U i s k × U i n k × U i l k 3 U i s k + U i n k + U i l k
T i k = β s U i s k + β n U i n k + β l U i l k
Given that sustainable development in a region necessitates the equal importance of societal, economic, and ecological development, we have assigned equal weights, denoted as β s = β n = β l . Consequently, Equation (10) can be further transformed into Equation (11).
T i k = U i s k + U i n k + U i l k 3
Finally, the coupling coordination degree D i k can be obtained using the coupling degree C i k and the comprehensive index T i k .
D i k = C i k × T i k
After standardizing and normalizing the raw data, the calculated multidimensional scores U i k for each province and year will all fall within the range [0, 1]. At this stage, the coupled coordination degree D i k can be computed using Equation (12) [22].
It should be noted that the CCD model implicitly assumes a certain degree of independence among dimensions prior to coupling, which may simplify the complex interdependencies among social, economic, and ecological systems and can only provide an overall assessment of the interactions and influences among multiple systems [37,38], without fully capturing real-world dynamics. However, since the primary objective of this study is not to identify causal relationships among the social, economic, and ecological dimensions, but rather to assess their relative coordination status and co-evolutionary patterns across provinces and over time, the CCD model remains an appropriate tool for this research. Based upon the CCD evaluation results, we evaluated the overall SDG score for each province in every year [30]:
S D G S i k = D i k × T i k
where S D G S i k is the comprehensive SDG score for province i in year k. Additionally, sensitivity analysis was employed to evaluate the influence of each individual sustainable development goal on the outcomes of S D G S i k . To guarantee that the holistic assessment of the SDG progress for each province and year is not contingent upon a particular goal, we conducted a sensitivity analysis for each goal across all provinces and years. When the goals are mutually independent, the sensitivity index for each goal can be calculated using the following Formula [40]:
S A = C S D G S i k − S D G S i k S D G S i k C X i j k ′ − X i j k ′ X i j k ′
where SA is the sensitivity index, c x i j k ′ represents the goal score derived after adjusting the normalized score x i j k ′ of the original value by ±10%, S D G S i k is the overall SDG score calculated from the original goal score, and C S D G S i k is the overall SDG score recalculated using the adjusted goal score.

3.4. Dynamic Monitoring Framework of SDG Status

To construct a resilient and innovative framework for assessment and monitoring, we introduced a two-threshold model for the evolution of SDG conditions, namely temporal sustainability (Equation (15)) and action urgency (Equation (16)). When the SDG progress in a specific region is advancing positively, the region’s SDG condition is robust sustainability (V > 0); otherwise, it is poor sustainability (V < 0). Furthermore, by taking the average of overall SDG scores across different regions at the initial time point as the benchmark, we assessed the urgency of sustainable development in a particular region over a defined time span. Low urgency (U < 0) indicates that the region is currently performing well, whereas high urgency (U > 0) indicates that the region is performing poorly and requires immediate improvement [41]:
V i = S D G S i k 2 − S D G S i k 1 k 2 − k 1
U i = ∑ i = 1 i = 31 S D G S i k 1 31 − S D G S i k 2 k 2 − k 1
where V i represents the sustainability of SDG condition in province i during the period from the starting time k1 to the ending time k2. S D G S i k 2 and S D G S i k 1 are the comprehensive sustainable development scores of province i in the years k2 and k1, respectively. U i represents the urgency of sustainable development in province i.
The monitoring and evaluation framework for sustainable development, built upon these foundations, is depicted in Figure 3. This framework is employed to evaluate the developmental status of a region over a specified period. To ensure the rationality of classification and enhance the robustness of the model, a Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) was implemented. The disturbance term was defined as ±10% of the corresponding parameter, and the simulation was iterated 1000 times. After the iterations, the proportions of V > 0, V < 0, U > 0, and U < 0 were calculated to evaluate the stability and reliability of the classification results.
Figure 3. Two-threshold model for SDG conditions. Source: The four-quadrant framework was referenced from Peng et al. [41], and the schematic diagram was drawn by the authors.
Quadrant I: This quadrant depicts a scenario characterized by robust sustainability, yet there exists a pressing need for further enhancement. Within Quadrant I, a V value greater than 0 (V > 0) signifies that these regions have achieved commendable progress in sustainable development over the evaluation period. Conversely, a U value greater than 0 (U > 0) indicates that, despite this progress, the overall condition of these regions at the conclusion of the evaluation period remains below the average, confronting severe and urgent challenges that necessitate immediate attention and resolution.
Quadrant II: This quadrant illustrates a scenario marked by poor sustainability and an urgent demand for further improvement. Within this quadrant, a V value less than 0 (V < 0) signifies that these regions have encountered developmental imbalances during the evaluation period, exemplified by the overexploitation of natural resources to the point of depletion and an inability to regenerate. Concurrently, a U value greater than 0 (U > 0) indicates that the overall condition of these regions at the conclusion of the evaluation period falls below the average, confronting severe and pressing issues that require immediate attention and resolution. These regions exhibit sluggish progress in sustainable development and are grappling with significant resource, environmental, or social challenges. In the short term, profound reforms and interventions are imperative; otherwise, they risk descending into an even deeper crisis.
Quadrant III: This quadrant represents a scenario of poor sustainability coupled with a low sense of urgency for improvement. Within this quadrant, a V value less than 0 (V < 0) highlights that these regions have encountered developmental imbalances during the evaluation period. Conversely, a U value less than 0 (U < 0) indicates that, despite these challenges, the overall condition of these regions at the end of the evaluation period remains above average. The sustainable development process in these regions has been sluggish or even stagnant throughout the evaluation period, revealing underlying structural issues in their development. It may be attributed to a robust developmental foundation in the region, which temporarily obscures the developmental imbalances observed during this period. Although these structural problems have not yet precipitated a crisis, failure to address them promptly may lead to severe repercussions in the future.
Quadrant IV: This quadrant epitomizes a scenario of commendable sustainability with a relatively low urgency for further improvement. Here, a V value greater than 0 (V > 0) signifies that these regions have achieved significant strides in sustainable development throughout the evaluation period. Meanwhile, a U value less than 0 (U < 0) underscores that the overall condition of these regions at the conclusion of the evaluation period surpasses the average, indicating a robust and thriving state. These regions have showcased their potential for green development and stand as exemplary models for other regions seeking to enhance their sustainability performance.

4. Results

4.1. Assessment of Social–Economic–Ecological SDGs

4.1.1. Results of National Scale

Table S3 presents the entropy weights assigned to the 17 SDGs across China’s 31 provincial-level regions (excluding Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan) for the period 2006–2021. Figure 4 summarizes the national-level evolution of China’s social, economic, and ecological SDG scores from 2006 to 2021, calculated as the arithmetic mean across the 31 provinces. The corresponding three-dimensional (social, economic, and ecological) scores for the 31 provinces are further illustrated in Figure 5. Overall, all three dimensions exhibit a clear long-term upward trajectory, indicating sustained progress in national sustainable development. Driven by sustained, large-scale, and targeted national policies in poverty alleviation and environmental protection [42], both the social and ecological dimensions exhibited stable upward trajectories throughout the period. Notably, the social dimension saw a remarkable cumulative increase of 126.53%, while the ecological dimension grew at a slower pace, with a cumulative rise of 23.93%. Although the economic dimension follows an overall upward trajectory, it experienced a temporary decline in 2009 due to the lagged impacts of the 2008 global financial crisis, before rebounding sharply in 2010 and maintaining sustained growth thereafter.
Figure 4. China’s social, economic, and ecological SDG scores from 2006 to 2021. Source: The three-dimensional SDG scores for China’s 31 provinces were calculated using the entropy-weighting method based on the 17 SDG scores reported in Table S1, and national-level three-dimensional scores were obtained using the mean value method.
Figure 5. SDG scores of 31 provinces in China from 2006–2021: (a) social SDG score, (b) economic SDG score, and (c) ecological SDG score. Source: Calculated using the 17 SDG scores of 31 provinces in Table S1 with the entropy-weighting method.
Time-series linear regression results (Table 4) further confirm the robustness of these trends. All three dimensions exhibit statistically significant positive coefficients (p < 0.05), indicating persistent improvement over the study period. Among them, social SDG scores show an exceptionally strong linear trend (R2 = 0.991), while economic and ecological dimensions also demonstrate good model fits (R2 = 0.844 and 0.862), albeit with slightly higher variability.
Table 4. Key parameters of timeline linear regression analysis of social, economic, and ecological SDG scores. Source: Based on the three-dimensional SDG scores of China in Figure 4, obtained through linear regression analysis.

4.1.2. Results of Provincial Scale

Figure 5a–c present the SDG scores of China’s 31 provinces in the social, economic, and ecological dimensions for the years 2006, 2011, 2016, and 2021, calculated using the entropy weighting method. Table S4 reports the complete scores derived from both the entropy and equal-weight methods, and the correlation analysis indicates a high degree of consistency between the results obtained using the two weighting schemes. From 2006 to 2016, all provinces exhibited improvements across the three dimensions, although the magnitude of growth and spatial distribution varied substantially. In the social dimension, Gansu Province recorded the most pronounced increase, with a cumulative growth rate of 392.35%. This substantial improvement may be associated with sustained investments in poverty alleviation, infrastructure modernization, and long-term policy support directed toward inland and western regions. Except for eastern provinces, all other regions achieved social SDG growth rates exceeding 100%. Notably, the nine provinces with relatively slower social progress were primarily concentrated in eastern China, including the three municipalities directly under the central government—Beijing, Tianjin, and Shanghai. These regions exhibited comparatively high initial development levels, with social SDG scores already reaching 0.593 in Beijing and Shanghai and 0.503 in Tianjin in 2006, which partly constrained their relative growth rates over the study period. In terms of the economic dimension, the continuous implementation of China’s Western Development Strategy (since 2000), which emphasizes infrastructure investment (e.g., railways and energy networks) and tax incentives, has substantially promoted economic development in western regions. As a result, Ningxia recorded the largest increase in economic SDG scores (173.35%), followed by Xinjiang (104.93%). Moreover, Ningxia’s abundant coal, wind, and solar resources, together with Xinjiang’s advantages in oil, gas, and agricultural production, further facilitated industrial expansion and export growth, supported by major state-led projects such as the China–Europe Railway Express. It should be noted that conclusions regarding the impacts of national policies on regional economic development are primarily based on qualitative analysis and literature review, and thus represent interpretive inferences rather than statistically validated causal relationships. Meanwhile, Beijing and most coastal provinces maintained high performance in both social and economic dimensions, indicating relatively strong coupling and coordination between economic development and the ecological environment in these regions [23].
Regarding the ecological dimension, Qinghai Province demonstrated the most remarkable improvement, with its ecological SDG score increasing by 82.14%. Several western provinces, including Inner Mongolia, Guizhou, and Gansu, as well as Beijing, also achieved growth rates exceeding 50%. These improvements are closely aligned with the implementation of a series of national environmental policies. The Ecological Conservation Redline Policy introduced in 2011 designated approximately 25% of China’s land area as protected zones (e.g., the Sanjiangyuan region in Qinghai), aiming to safeguard biodiversity and critical water resources. This policy is directly related to SDG 6.6.1 (changes in the extent of water-related ecosystems), SDG 14.5.1 (coverage of protected marine areas), and SDG 15.5.1 (progress in reducing biodiversity loss). In addition, large-scale afforestation and ecological restoration programs, such as the Grain for Green Program, have contributed to the recovery of degraded landscapes and are directly associated with SDG 15 (Life on Land). Furthermore, stringent air quality management measures implemented in Beijing—including pre-Olympic environmental actions and the Beijing–Tianjin–Hebei Air Pollution Prevention and Control Action Plan launched in 2013—resulted in a reduction of more than 60% in PM2.5 concentrations, which is directly reflected in SDG 11.6.2 (annual mean levels of fine particulate matter in cities). In contrast, Heilongjiang, Tianjin, and Zhejiang experienced declines in their ecological SDG scores during the study period, despite having relatively high initial values (all exceeding 0.50 in 2006). Notably, Ningxia recorded the lowest ecological score among all provinces in 2021, at only 0.31, highlighting the urgent need for targeted ecological restoration and policy interventions in this region.

4.2. Comprehensive Assessment of the Achievement of the SDGs

4.2.1. Spatiotemporal Pattern of the Composite SDG Index

To assess the influence of individual SDG scores on the composite index, with particular attention to the differences associated with SDG 14 between coastal and inland provinces, Table S4 additionally reports the three-dimensional SDG scores for coastal provinces calculated using the entropy-weighting method while excluding SDG 14. The results indicate that the inclusion of SDG 14 exerts a certain influence on the ecological SDG scores of coastal provinces; however, after integrating the social and economic dimensions, the composite SDG index values and relative rankings of China’s 31 provinces remain unchanged. Furthermore, systematic sensitivity analyses were conducted by introducing ±10% perturbations to each SDG score and computing the corresponding sensitivity coefficients. Consistent with the results reported in Table S4, most SDGs exhibit low sensitivity (SA < 0.1), with only a few showing relatively higher sensitivity, and maximum coefficients of 0.1847 (+10%) and 0.1885 (−10%), as detailed in Tables S5 and S6. These findings confirm that individual SDG scores have a relatively limited impact on the composite index, highlighting its robustness and reliability in measuring regional sustainable development performance. Given the ecological significance of SDG 14 for coastal regions, this indicator was retained for coastal provinces in the subsequent analyses.
The comprehensive SDG index was calculated using the results derived from the CCD model. This index integrates the synergistic interactions among the social, economic, and ecological dimensions, offering a comprehensive metric to evaluate the progress of sustainable development at the provincial level. Figure S1 displays the temporal evolution of the three-dimensional coupling coordination degree across all 31 provinces in China. Meanwhile, Figure 6 illustrates the temporal trends in the comprehensive SDG indices for Chinese provinces from 2006 to 2021, presented as boxplots at five-year intervals (2006, 2011, 2016, and 2021). As shown, the distribution of composite SDG indices across Chinese provinces demonstrated a steady upward trajectory and convergence toward higher values from 2006 to 2021. In 2006, the majority of provincial scores clustered within the range of 0.456–0.558, reflecting moderate sustainable development performance. By 2021, this range narrowed and shifted upward to 0.681–0.744, indicating both improved aggregate outcomes and reduced regional disparities. Over the same period, the average provincial score rose markedly from 0.502 to 0.714, underscoring systemic progress in aligning regional development with national sustainability goals. Notably, most provinces demonstrated significant improvements in their sustainable development status over time, with particularly pronounced progress observed in northwestern regions such as Qinghai, Gansu, and Ningxia. By 2021, all provinces had achieved scores exceeding 0.6, with Beijing leading the nation at 0.807.
Figure 6. Spatial distribution of the composite SDG index for (a) 2006, (b) 2011, (c) 2016, and (d) 2021. Source: Compiled from the three-dimensional SDG scores of 31 Chinese provinces calculated via the composite SDG index; the provincial base map was obtained from the Resource and Environmental Science Data Platform.

4.2.2. Monitoring and Evaluation of Progress Towards SDG

Periodic assessments are crucial for sustainable development, as they facilitate the timely identification of emerging challenges and provide a basis for targeted adjustments and policy reforms. In line with the recommendation by Lu et al. [43] to conduct evaluations every 3–5 years, the period from 2006 to 2021 was divided into three intervals for systematic analysis: 2006–2011, 2011–2016, and 2016–2021. The dynamic sustainability monitoring results for each stage are shown in Figure 7a–d, with provinces color-coded by economic region based on the classification scheme provided in Table 1. To verify the accuracy of the classification, we performed a Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) by introducing a ±10% perturbation to the indicator results and running 1000 random iterations. The classification outcomes from these 1000 iterations were recorded in Tables S7–S10 (corresponding to Figure 7a–d) for validation purposes. The results clearly reveal distinct clustering patterns among provinces within the same region: western provinces generally exhibit higher levels of urgency, while eastern provinces show lower urgency.
Figure 7. Sustainability and urgency of achieving sustainable development over a period of time: (a) 2006–2011, (b) 2011–2016, (c) 2016–2021, and (d) overall assessment during the period of 2006–2021. Source: Derived from the composite SDG index of 31 provinces using the double-threshold model classification method.
Figure 7a presents the dynamic monitoring results of provincial sustainable development from 2006 to 2011. Guizhou emerged as the most critical case, performing poorly in both social and economic dimensions. By 2011, it was the only province whose social dimension score remained below 0.3 (Figure 5), placing it firmly in the urgent intervention category (U > 0). This classification is further supported by the simulation results in Table S7, where Guizhou was assigned to the urgent group in most scenarios. Ningxia, Xinjiang, Qinghai, and Gansu were nominally categorized as low-urgency regions (U approximately equal to 0), however, their scores clustered near the intervention threshold. Nearly half of the simulation runs reclassified these provinces as urgent, indicating structural vulnerability. Among them, Ningxia consistently recorded the lowest ecological scores nationwide from 2006 to 2021, highlighting persistent ecological constraints. In 2011, Xinjiang was the only province with an economic dimension score below 0.35, while Qinghai and Gansu ranked lowest in the social dimension, reflecting pronounced deficits in social development during this phase.
Figure 7b indicates that the period from 2011 to 2016 was characterized by relatively limited progress in China’s provincial sustainable development. Provincial SDG scores clustered within narrow ranges (from 0.561–0.653 to 0.607–0.677), and the national average increased by only 0.033, substantially lower than the growth observed during 2006–2011 (Figure 6). Monte Carlo simulation results (Table S8) reveal considerable uncertainty in provincial development status, as classification outcomes were broadly distributed across the four quadrants. Eight provinces, including Ningxia and Xinjiang, were characterized by positive development levels accompanied by relatively high improvement urgency (V > 0, U > 0), most of which are located in western China. Liaoning exhibited unsustainable development with relatively low urgency (V < 0, U < 0), while Tibet was the only province combining negative growth with high improvement urgency (V < 0, U > 0). Examination of Tibet’s three-dimensional SDG scores (Figure 5) shows stagnation in social development, declining economic performance, and pronounced ecological degradation during this period. These patterns are likely associated with the region’s fragile high-altitude ecosystem and land-use adjustments following the Fifth Central Tibet Work Forum in 2010, which induced a temporary decline in grassland [44] and forest coverage and reduced ecological carrying capacity. At the regional scale, development performance differed markedly across China’s four economic zones, with western provinces generally closer to critical thresholds, central and northeastern regions remaining near transition states, and eastern provinces maintaining comparatively stable development trajectories.
During the period from 2016 to 2021 (Figure 7c), most provinces were classified as achieving sustainable development with relatively low improvement urgency (U < 0, V > 0). Gansu and Ningxia remained exceptions, continuing to fall within the urgent improvement category (U > 0). By 2021, these two provinces exhibited the lowest ecological dimension scores nationwide, with Ningxia showing a particularly pronounced gap relative to other regions, indicating persistent ecological constraints. Although Qinghai and Xinjiang demonstrated comparatively better overall performance, Monte Carlo simulation results suggest that both provinces retained a nearly 50% probability of being classified as requiring urgent improvement (U > 0) (Table S9). Qinghai, despite modest economic gains since 2016, ranked lowest nationally in 2021, pointing to ongoing structural limitations in economic development. Xinjiang, by contrast, experienced a slight decline in ecological performance relative to 2016 (Figure 5), suggesting emerging ecological pressures during this period.
Figure 7d provides an integrated 16-year assessment, indicating that all 31 Chinese provinces were classified as achieving sustainable development with relatively low improvement urgency. As shown in Table S10, the probability of falling into this category reached 100% for most provinces, with only Shanghai (0.2%) and Tianjin (2.1%) exhibiting a marginal likelihood of unsustainable development (V < 0). These results are broadly consistent with the findings of Biggeri et al. [27] regarding China’s sustainability performance during 2015–2019. It should be noted that low improvement urgency does not necessarily correspond to a high absolute level of sustainable development; rather, it reflects relatively stable development trajectories under existing policy frameworks. This interpretation is consistent with previous studies indicating that China has not yet reached the global frontier of sustainable development [45], despite a long-term increase in its SDG composite score reported by the Sustainable Development Solutions Network (SDSN) [46]. At the provincial level, regions such as Ningxia and Gansu, although still exhibiting relatively low absolute SDG index values in 2021 (both below 0.5; Figure 5), showed measurable improvements over time, as reflected by their negative urgency values (−0.007 and −0.008, respectively) and upward shifts in historical rankings. Similar patterns were observed in Qinghai (−0.009) and Xinjiang (−0.010), indicating gradual progress alongside persistent regional disparities. In contrast, the lowest sustainability improvement scores were recorded in Tianjin (0.007), Heilongjiang (0.008), and Shanghai (0.008), consistent with the Monte Carlo simulation results. While Shanghai and Tianjin maintained relatively stable development due to their high initial baselines, Heilongjiang experienced a notable relative decline, dropping from 11th nationally in 2006 to 27th in 2021, with a net increase of only 0.127 points. This trajectory highlights the need for targeted policy adjustment in regions facing structural development constraints. Overall, these findings underscore both the cumulative progress achieved and the enduring interregional disparities in China’s sustainable development.

5. Discussion

5.1. The Composite SDG Index Under Different Economic Region Settings

Understanding regional differences is crucial for the equitable allocation of resources, ensuring that regions with greater needs receive adequate support to achieve SDGs. In addition, analyzing the SDG index across regions allows for benchmarking, enabling regions to compare their performance against peers. This fosters healthy competition and encourages regions to learn from best practices. Taking these factors into account, we carried out a comparative statistical analysis of the composite SDG index under different economic zone settings (Figure 8). The Natural Breaks method was utilized to classify provincial sustainable development levels, i.e., the composite SDG index value, into three distinct categories: unsustainable development (low index score), medium sustainable development (medium index score), and high sustainable development (high index score).
Figure 8. The composite SDG index under different economic zone settings: (a) proportions of provinces with unsustainable development (low index value), medium sustainable development (medium index value), and high sustainable development (high index value) and (b) average composite SDG scores under different economic region settings during the period of 2006–2021. Source: Calculated as the average of 31 Chinese provinces classified according to the four major economic regions; the economic region classification method was obtained from the National Bureau of Statistics of China. Note: The dotted line indicates a threshold value of 0.6, which is regarded as an acceptable level of the composite SDG score in this study.
Figure 8a shows that notable disparities in sustainable development levels were evident among various economic regions. Eastern regions consistently exhibited the highest degree of sustainable development, with all provinces (100%) achieving a high level of sustainability in 2021. This was followed by the central regions, where 83.33% of the provinces demonstrated high sustainable development. Eastern regions often have a more diversified and advanced industrial structure, with a higher proportion of high-tech and service industries that are typically more sustainable. Additionally, the central government has implemented a series of policies aimed at promoting sustainable development in the central region. These policies include incentives for green industries, support for renewable energy projects, and environmental protection measures, which have effectively spurred sustainable practices in the region. In contrast, the western and northeastern regions exhibited a comparatively lower degree of sustainable development, with merely one-third of their provinces attaining a high level of sustainability. Many western regions are characterized by vast areas of arid and semi-arid land, fragile ecosystems, and limited water resources. For example, in some parts of northwestern China, the scarcity of water makes it difficult to support large-scale agricultural and industrial activities in an environmentally sustainable way. The harsh natural conditions also pose challenges for infrastructure construction and maintenance, which are essential for economic development and sustainable practices. Northeastern regions were once the heart of China’s heavy industry, with a strong focus on sectors such as steel, coal, and machinery manufacturing. However, these traditional industries have faced significant challenges in recent decades due to overcapacity, technological obsolescence, and environmental pollution. The process of industrial transformation and upgrading in the northeast has been slow, and many old industrial bases still rely on outdated production methods, resulting in high energy consumption and pollution emissions.
Figure 8b For instance, the disparity in composite SDG index values between the eastern and western regions was markedly greater in 2006, with a difference of 0.17, compared to a much smaller difference of 0.09 in 2020. The Chinese government has implemented a series of balanced development strategies over the years, such as the Western Development Strategy. These strategies aim to promote coordinated development among different regions by providing financial support, policy incentives, and infrastructure construction in less-developed areas. For example, under the Western Development Strategy, significant investments have been made in transportation, energy, and communication infrastructure in the western regions, which has improved their economic development conditions and narrowed the gap with the eastern regions in terms of sustainable development capabilities. It is of particular note that in 2006, the northeast regions kicked off with a higher development level, as evidenced by an index value of 0.53, in contrast to the central regions, which had an index value of 0.50 at the same time. Nevertheless, over the following years, the northeastern regions demonstrated sluggish growth momentum. By around 2017, the central regions had managed to overtake them, with the northeast regions recording an index value of 0.65 while the central regions reached 0.66. This striking shift can most probably be attributed to several factors. Firstly, northeastern regions have long been heavily reliant on resource-based industries, which are often subject to market fluctuations and resource depletion. Secondly, their industrial structure is overly monolithic, lacking the diversity and flexibility needed to adapt to changing economic circumstances. Lastly, the severe population exodus from the northeast regions has led to a shortage of labor and talent, further hampering their economic development and sustainable growth.

5.2. Policy Recommendations

As a significant developing nation, China boasts a diverse topography, an expansive territory, and a massive population. During our 16-year study of China’s sustainable development journey, we discovered that all 31 of its provinces have achieved steady progress along the path of sustainable development. As depicted in Figure 7d, a comprehensive evaluation of China’s overall situation over the past 16 years reveals that all 31 provinces fall within the scope of sustainable advancement in achieving SDGs, with a low level of urgency for improvement. This finding underscores the suitability of China’s overall development trajectory, as no major regional imbalances are evident. Nevertheless, at the implementation level, significant inter-provincial disparities continue to exist, indicating ample room for optimization.
We developed a sophisticated two-threshold model to assess the dual dimensions of SDG conditions, specifically focusing on sustainability and urgency (Section 3.4). The sustainability dimension measures the extent to which a province is progressing towards achieving long-term SDG targets in an environmentally friendly, socially inclusive, and economically viable manner. Further, the urgency dimension evaluates the immediate need for a province to take corrective actions to address potential SDG shortfalls or to accelerate its progress to meet the set goals within the stipulated time frame. Based upon the comprehensive evaluation results derived from this two-threshold model, we conduct an in-depth clustering analysis of Chinese provinces. This clustering analysis leverages cutting-edge statistical and machine-learning methodologies to cluster provinces that share similar SDG condition profiles. Through this process, we are able to discern clear and unique patterns along with defining characteristics within various groups of provinces. These insights are of paramount importance as they serve as the cornerstone for devising highly targeted and truly effective sustainable development strategies. Given that the K-median clustering method demonstrates greater robustness compared to the traditional K-means approach [47], we opted to employ K-median clustering on our results. Subsequently, we summarized the defining characteristics of the various categories identified. The results of this analysis are depicted in Figure 9. As illustrated, the provinces were classified into three distinct categories based on their temporal characteristics: Category I (characterized by high urgency and high sustainability), Category II (featuring medium urgency and medium sustainability), and Category III (marked by low urgency and low sustainability). For detailed information on which category each province falls into, refer to Table S11. We have provided suggestions for sustainable development based on the different temporal characteristics (i.e., temporal sustainability and action urgency) of various provinces.
Figure 9. Clustering results of provincial sustainable development conditions based upon the K-median algorithm from 2006 to 2021; Category I means regions with high urgence and high sustainability, Category II means regions with medium urgence and medium sustainability, and Category III means regions with low urgence and low sustainability. Source: Obtained by performing K-median clustering on the results of Figure 7d; the base map of Chinese provincial administrative regions was obtained from the Resource and Environmental Science Data Platform.
Category I provinces are predominantly situated in northwestern regions and Guizhou. While these regions have demonstrated significant improvements in sustainable development levels, they continue to exhibit high action urgency due to historical developmental constraints. These include unfavorable geographical conditions (e.g., extensive desert areas in Xinjiang), locational disadvantages (remote inland positioning with underdeveloped transportation networks), and low population density, all of which have hindered early-stage development. These regions necessitate urgent, targeted policy interventions to foster integrated social, economic, and ecological development. Key strategies should include:
Talent retention and attraction mechanisms, such as competitive incentives and career development opportunities, to counteract brain drain;
Accelerated infrastructure modernization, prioritizing transportation networks (e.g., railways, highways) to improve regional connectivity;
Scaled-up ecological restoration initiatives, focusing on sand fixation technologies and sustainable land management practices to combat desertification.
Category II provinces, characterized by moderate sustainability and urgency, typically boast abundant natural resources—exemplified by Tibet and Sichuan’s substantial hydropower and energy reserves. These regions possess a solid foundation for sustainable development, with comparatively lower transformation pressure. To capitalize on their geographical and resource advantages, they should adopt a focused strategy by:
Prioritizing high-potential sectors (e.g., clean energy, eco-tourism) to achieve rapid breakthroughs;
Leveraging policy incentives to attract green investments and technological innovation;
Establishing demonstration projects in resource-efficient development models for regional replication.
Category III provinces encompass China’s three municipalities, alongside coastal provinces leveraging strong marine industry and foreign trade advantages [48]. These regions, characterized by early-stage development, advanced urbanization, and mature industrial systems, now face constrained growth potential, resulting in relatively subdued sustainable development performance despite low transformation urgency. To address this, they should adopt a quality-oriented strategy by:
Consolidating institutional and infrastructural foundations to safeguard development gains;
Optimizing resource allocation through digitalization and green technology integration;
Pioneering high-value-added sectors (e.g., blue economy, advanced services) to drive sustainable upgrading.

5.3. Limitations and Future Perspectives

This study builds upon our previous research and focuses on China’s 31 provinces. However, as noted in Section 2.2 regarding SDG14 (Life Below Water), data for non-coastal regions are unavailable. Consequently, this indicator was not assessed for non-coastal areas and was omitted from the calculations, which may introduce some error when comparing overall development levels across regions. Moreover, significant data gaps exist within our SDG indicator set, particularly for earlier years. Future research will aim to address these challenges, including developing methods to fill missing indicators, examining interactions between marine and inland regions to assign reasonable SDG14 scores for inland areas, further expanding our SDG indicator set (currently limited to 2021), and implementing downscaling approaches for sustainable development assessments. From a methodological perspective, our previous work [28] has systematically established and validated a provincial-level SDG indicator system for China. The present study primarily focuses on applying this established indicator set for empirical analysis and validation, and therefore does not pursue a systematic comparison across alternative paradigms of sustainable development measurement, nor does it extensively discuss competing operationalization strategies. Future research could build upon the existing indicator framework by comparing this approach with other SDG measurement frameworks, thereby clarifying the applicability and limitations of different operationalization strategies in provincial-level sustainability assessments and further contributing to theoretical discussions on sustainable development measurement.

6. Conclusions

The present study proposes an SDG indicator framework by integrating global SDG metrics with China’s national development priorities, leveraging a comprehensive dataset comprising official statistics and open-source data to ensure methodological rigor and policy relevance. By evaluating SDGs 1–17 across 31 Chinese provinces from 2006 to 2021, the framework provides a longitudinal analysis of national sustainability trajectories, revealing disparities in progress and informing targeted policy interventions. To enhance analytical depth, the 17 SDGs were categorized into societal, economic, and ecological dimensions, and a composite SDG index was calculated using the CCD model and entropy weight method, with sensitivity analyses conducted to validate robustness. Additionally, dynamic provincial-scale monitoring of SDG status was performed via a two-threshold model, assessing both temporal sustainability and action urgency. The key findings are summarized below.
Social SDG scores saw a remarkable cumulative increase of 126.53%, while the ecological SDG scores grew at a slower pace, with a cumulative rise of 23.93%. Meanwhile, the economic SDG scores also followed an overall upward trajectory, despite experiencing a temporary decline in 2009 attributed to the global financial crisis of 2008, which suppressed foreign investment and exports.
In 2006, composite SDG scores in the majority of provinces clustered within the range of 0.456–0.558, reflecting relatively low sustainable development performance. By 2021, this range narrowed and shifted upward to 0.681–0.744, indicating both improved aggregate outcomes and reduced regional disparities. Over the same period, the average provincial score rose markedly from 0.502 to 0.714, underscoring systemic progress in aligning regional development with national sustainability goals.
A 16-year longitudinal assessment (2006–2021) reveals that all 31 Chinese provinces achieved “sustainable development with low improvement urgency”, though regional disparities persist. The highest urgency values—indicating slower progress—were recorded in Ningxia (−0.007), Gansu (−0.008), Qinghai (−0.009), and Xinjiang (−0.010). Despite their low-urgency classification, these provinces, which ranked among the bottom five nationally in SDG composite scores in 2006, remained below 0.5 by 2021, underscoring a sustained need for targeted policy interventions. Conversely, the lowest sustainability improvement scores were observed in Tianjin (0.007), Heilongjiang (0.008), and Shanghai (0.008), suggesting relatively stable but less dynamic progress in these regions.
Overall, this study provides a nationwide assessment of sustainable development across China’s 31 provinces, revealing pronounced regional heterogeneity across social, economic, and ecological dimensions. By decomposing the 17 SDGs into these three dimensions and examining their long-term coordinated evolution, the analysis captures structural asymmetries and temporal lags among sustainability pillars. The proposed two-threshold framework further distinguishes sustainability levels from improvement urgency, addressing a key limitation of conventional composite indices that focus primarily on development status. Integrating multidimensional indicators within a longitudinal framework, this study offers a holistic and replicable tool for provincial-scale sustainability monitoring. Jointly assessing sustainability status and improvement urgency enables policymakers to identify both lagging regions and provinces exhibiting structural stagnation despite relatively high development levels, thereby supporting more differentiated and stage-specific policy interventions aligned with regional contexts. Although this study focuses on China, the proposed framework is not country-specific in its methodological design. Grounded in the universal structure of the SDGs and a system-based coordination logic, it can be adapted to other large and heterogeneous countries through localized SDG indicator selection, scale adjustment, and threshold calibration. In national contexts characterized by substantial regional disparities and uneven development trajectories, the framework facilitates the simultaneous identification of lagging regions and areas experiencing structural stagnation despite relatively high development levels. As such, the approach provides a transferable analytical paradigm for assessing sustainable development dynamics at both national and subnational scales in other large, diverse countries. Nevertheless, the findings should be interpreted in light of limitations related to data availability, indicator completeness, and spatial scale, particularly for SDGs with strong geographic constraints such as SDG 14. While these uncertainties do not affect the overall trends identified, they may influence cross-regional comparability and fine-scale interpretation. Future research should focus on improving indicator coverage, strengthening marine–inland linkages, extending the temporal scope beyond 2021, and advancing downscaling approaches to enable more refined sustainability assessments.

Supplementary Materials

The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https://www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/su18020899/s1, Figure S1: Social-economic-ecological coupling coordination degree (SEE-CCD) of China’s 31 Provinces (2006–2021). Table S1: SDG scores of China’s 31 provinces from 2006 to 2021. Table S2: Provincial SDG indicators and their source documents in China. Table S3: SDG weighting via entropy approach. Table S4: Social, economic, and ecological SDG scores for 31 Chinese provinces (2006–2021) under different weighting schemes, including entropy-weighted results excluding SDG 14 for coastal provinces. Table S5: Sensitivity coefficient of SDGs after an increase in 10%. Table S6: Sensitivity coefficient of SDGs after a reduction of 10%. Table S7: Robustness assessment of sustainable development conditions across 31 Chinese provinces from 2006 to 2011 based on the two-threshold model. Table S8: Robustness assessment of sustainable development conditions across 31 Chinese provinces from 2011 to 2016 based on the two-threshold model. Table S9: Robustness assessment of sustainable development conditions across 31 Chinese provinces from 2016 to 2021 based on the two-threshold model. Table S10: Robustness assessment of sustainable development conditions across 31 Chinese provinces from 2006 to 2021 based on the two-threshold model. Table S11: Clustering results classification. Reference [28] is cited in Supplementary Materials.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, S.C. and M.D.; methodology, S.W. and S.C.; resources, S.W. and S.C.; investigation, S.W., Y.L. and Y.Q.; formal analysis, S.W., Y.L. and Y.Q.; data curation, S.W., Y.L. and Y.Q.; writing—original draft preparation, S.W.; writing—review and editing, S.W., S.C., M.D., Y.L. and Y.Q.; validation, Y.L. and Y.Q.; supervision, S.C. and M.D. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research was funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC, grant number 42301394) and supported by the Young Faculty Development Program (“Qingjiao Plan”) of Beijing University of Civil Engineering and Architecture (grant number X25025).

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

The original contributions presented in this study are included in the article/Supplementary Materials. Further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declared that they have no conflicts of interest to this work.

References

  1. Fuso Nerini, F.; Tomei, J.; To, L.S.; Bisaga, I.; Parikh, P.; Black, M.; Borrion, A.; Spataru, C.; Castán Broto, V.; Anandarajah, G.; et al. Mapping synergies and trade-offs between energy and the Sustainable Development Goals. Nat. Energy 2017, 3, 10–15. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  2. United Nations. Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development; United Nations: New York, NY, USA, 2015; Available online: https://undocs.org/en/A/RES/70/1 (accessed on 28 November 2025).
  3. Stafford-Smith, M.; Griggs, D.; Gaffney, O.; Ullah, F.; Reyers, B.; Kanie, N.; Stigson, B.; Shrivastava, P.; Leach, M.; O’Connell, D. Integration: The key to implementing the Sustainable Development Goals. Sustain. Sci. 2017, 12, 911–919. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. Costanza, R.; Daly, L.; Fioramonti, L.; Giovannini, E.; Kubiszewski, I.; Mortensen, L.F.; Pickett, K.E.; Ragnarsdottir, K.V.; De Vogli, R.; Wilkinson, R. Modelling and measuring sustainable wellbeing in connection with the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Ecol. Econ. 2016, 130, 350–355. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Song, W.; Cao, S.; Du, M.; He, Z. Aligning territorial spatial planning with sustainable development goals: A comprehensive analysis of production, living, and ecological spaces in China. Ecol. Indic. 2024, 160, 111816. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Xie, H.; Wen, J.; Choi, Y. How the SDGs are implemented in China—A comparative study based on the perspective of policy instruments. J. Clean. Prod. 2021, 291, 125937. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  7. Chen, J.; Ren, H.; Geng, W.; Peng, S.; Ye, F. Quantitative measurement and monitoring Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) with geospatial information. Geomat. World 2018, 25, 1–7. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  8. Lv, Y.; Wang, Y.; Yuan, J.; He, J. Some thoughts on promoting the implementation of sustainable development goals in China. China Popul. Resour. Environ. 2018, 28, 1–9. [Google Scholar]
  9. Liu, X.; Lu, L.; Guo, H.; Melchiorri, M.; Hafner, S.; Ban, Y.; Pesaresi, M.; Li, Q.; Baqa, M.F. Assessing urban sustainability in the Belt and Road region: A city-level analysis of SDG 11 indicators using earth observations. Int. J. Digit. Earth 2025, 18, 2522395. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  10. Bian, J.; Zhao, J.; Li, A. Remote sensing monitoring of mountain sustainable development goals (SDG15.4): A systematic review. Int. J. Digit. Earth 2025, 18, 2448216. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  11. Cao, M.; Chen, M.; Zhang, J.; Pradhan, P.; Guo, H.; Fu, B.; Li, Y.; Bai, Y.; Chang, L.; Chen, Y.; et al. Spatio-temporal changes in the causal interactions among Sustainable Development Goals in China. Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 2023, 10, 450. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  12. Shi, T.; Yang, S.; Zhang, W.; Zhou, Q. Coupling coordination degree measurement and spatiotemporal heterogeneity between economic development and ecological environment—Empirical evidence from tropical and subtropical regions of China. J. Clean. Prod. 2020, 244, 118739. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Zeb, A.; Ullah, O.; Zeb, A. Bridging equity and sustainability: A heterogeneous analysis of poverty, inequality, and green growth’s impact on environmental sustainability in BRI economies. J. Environ. Manag. 2025, 390, 126364. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  14. Çelik, S.; Öztürk, Ö.F.; Akkucuk, U.; Şaşmaz, M.Ü. Global sustainability performance and regional disparities: A machine learning approach based on the 2025 SDG Index. Sustainability 2025, 17, 7411. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  15. Kroll, C.; Warchold, A.; Pradhan, P. Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): Are we successful in turning trade-offs into synergies? Palgrave Commun. 2019, 5, 140. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  16. Selomane, O.; Reyers, B.; Biggs, R.; Hamann, M. Harnessing insights from social-ecological systems research for monitoring sustainable development. Sustainability 2019, 11, 1190. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Allen, C.; Metternicht, G.; Wiedmann, T. Initial progress in implementing the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): A review of evidence from countries. Sustain. Sci. 2018, 13, 1453–1467. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  18. Fader, M.; Cranmer, C.; Lawford, R.; Engel-Cox, J. Toward an understanding of synergies and trade-offs between water, energy, and food SDG targets. Front. Environ. Sci. 2018, 6, 112. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Pradhan, P.; Costa, L.; Rybski, D.; Lucht, W.; Kropp, J.P. A systematic study of Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) interactions. Earth’s Future 2017, 5, 1169–1179. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Xing, Q.; Wu, C.; Chen, F.; Liu, J.; Pradhan, P.; Bryan, B.A.; Schaubroeck, T.; Carrasco, L.R.; Gonsamo, A.; Li, Y.; et al. Intranational synergies and trade-offs reveal common and differentiated priorities of sustainable development goals in China. Nat. Commun. 2024, 15, 2251. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  21. Han, D.; Yu, D.; Qiu, J. Assessing coupling interactions in a safe and just operating space for regional sustainability. Nat. Commun. 2023, 14, 1369. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  22. Liu, Y.; Yang, P. Coupling coordination degree of regional forest ecological-nature-economy-society complex system: A case study in Changsha. Sci. Silvae Sin. 2023, 59, 139–146. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  23. Zhang, Y.; Fang, Z.; Xie, Z. Coordinated development of marine economy and ecological environment in coastal areas of China: Development level, coupling coordination measurement, and obstacle analysis. Sustainability 2023, 15, 9122. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Li, T.; Dong, Y.; Wei, X.; Zhou, H.; Li, Z. The rapid prosperity of China’s Pearl River Delta from the perspective of social–ecological coupling: Implications for sustainable management. Sci. Rep. 2024, 14, 19914. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Liu, J.; Dietz, T.; Carpenter, S.R.; Alberti, M.; Folke, C.; Moran, E.; Pell, A.N.; Deadman, P.; Kratz, T.; Lubchenco, J.; et al. Complexity of coupled human and natural systems. Science 2007, 317, 1513–1516. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  26. Allen, C.; Biddulph, A.; Wiedmann, T.; Pedercini, M.; Malekpour, S. Modelling six sustainable development transformations in Australia and their accelerators, impediments, enablers, and interlinkages. Nat. Commun. 2024, 15, 594. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  27. Biggeri, M.; Bortolotti, L.; Ferrannini, A.; Saccone, D. China’s subnational policies and the performance of provinces towards meeting the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals. Reg. Stud. Reg. Sci. 2023, 10, 439–460. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  28. Song, W.; Cao, S.; Du, M.; Lu, L.; Guo, H.; Wang, S.; Liu, Y.; Li, X. Provincial localization framework for SDGs in China: Enhancing support for sustainable governance. Appl. Geogr. 2025, 175, 103505. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Tang, H.; Hou, K.; Wu, S.; Liu, J.; Ma, L.; Li, X. Interpretation of the coupling mechanism of ecological security and urbanization based on a Computation-Verification-Coupling framework: Quantitative analysis of sustainable development. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. 2023, 263, 115294. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  30. Huan, Y.; Liang, T.; Li, H.; Zhang, C. A systematic method for assessing progress of achieving sustainable development goals: A case study of 15 countries. Sci. Total Environ. 2021, 752, 141875. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  31. National Bureau of Statistics of China. The Division Method of the Eastern, Western, Central, and Northeastern Regions. 2011. Available online: https://www.stats.gov.cn/zt_18555/zthd/sjtjr/dejtjkfr/tjkp/202302/t20230216_1909741.htm (accessed on 28 November 2025).
  32. Kagzi, M.; Dagar, V.; Doytch, N.; Krishnan, D.; Raj, M. Curbing environmental degradation to balance sustainable development: Evidence from China. Environ. Sustain. Indic. 2024, 24, 100465. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  33. Biggeri, M.; Bortolotti, L. Towards a ‘harmonious society’? Multidimensional development and the convergence of Chinese provinces. Reg. Stud. 2020, 54, 1655–1667. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  34. Xie, Y.; Weng, Q. Spatiotemporally enhancing time-series DMSP/OLS nighttime light imagery for assessing large-scale urban dynamics. ISPRS J. Photogramm. Remote Sens. 2017, 128, 1–15. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  35. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, U.N. Global Indicator Framework for the Sustainable Development Goals and Targets of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development; Department of Economic and Social Affairs, U.N.: New York, NY, USA, 2023; Available online: https://unstats.un.org/sdgs/indicators/indicators-list/ (accessed on 28 November 2025).
  36. The State Council of the People’s Republic of China. China’s National Plan on Implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development; The State Council of the People’s Republic of China: Beijing, China, 2016.
  37. Wang, S.; Kong, W.; Ren, L.; Zhi, D.; Dai, B. Research on misuses and modification of coupling coordination degree model in China. J. Nat. Resour. 2021, 36, 793–810. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  38. Fang, C.; Liu, H.; Li, G. International progress and evaluation on interactive coupling effects between urbanization and the eco-environment. J. Geogr. Sci. 2016, 26, 1081–1116. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  39. Cong, X. Expression and mathematical property of coupling model, and its misuse in geographical science. Econ. Geogr. 2019, 39, 18–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  40. Liu, J.; Ashton, P.S. FORMOSAIC: An individual-based spatially explicit model for simulating forest dynamics in landscape mosaics. Ecol. Model. 1998, 106, 177–200. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  41. Peng, Y.; Lai, Y.; Li, X.; Zhang, X. An alternative model for measuring the sustainability of urban regeneration: The way forward. J. Clean. Prod. 2015, 109, 76–83. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  42. Ge, Y.; Hu, S.; Song, Y.; Zheng, H.; Liu, Y.; Ye, X.; Ma, T.; Liu, M.; Zhou, C. Sustainable poverty reduction models for the coordinated development of the social economy and environment in China. Sci. Bull. 2023, 68, 2236–2246. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  43. Lu, Y.; Nakicenovic, N.; Visbeck, M.; Stevance, A.-S. Policy: Five priorities for the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Nature 2015, 520, 432–433. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  44. Du, Q.; Li, L. Assessing ecosystem service value dynamics and compensation gaps in key ecological zones of Xizang: Towards sustainable plateau development. Front. Environ. Sci. 2025, 13, 1648758. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  45. D’Adamo, I.; Della Sciucca, M.; Gastaldi, M.; Lupi, B. Indicator Assessment of Sustainable Development Goals: A Global Perspective. Sustainability 2025, 17, 8259. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  46. Sustainable Development Solutions Network (SDSN). Sustainable Development Report 2025: Financing Sustainable Development to 2030 and Mid-Century; Sustainable Development Solutions Network (SDSN): New York, NY, USA, 2025; Available online: https://dashboards.sdgindex.org/ (accessed on 25 December 2025).
  47. Li, J.; Song, S.; Zhang, Y.; Zhou, Z. Robust K-Median and K-Means clustering algorithms for incomplete data. Math. Probl. Eng. 2016, 2016, 4321928. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  48. Zhong, Y.; Li, J.; Luan, S.; Wang, Y. How Does Foreign Direct Investment Impact Sustainable Development? Empirical Evidence from China’s Coastal Areas. Sustainability 2024, 16, 4991. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.