1. Introduction
The material properties at the p/i and i/n interfaces of hydrogenated amorphous silicon a-Si:H p-i-n solar cells influence the electric field distribution in the i-layer [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6]. The transport of photogenerated carriers (electrons and holes) in the i-layer is primarily driven by the drift effect of the i-layer’s built-in electric field; electrons drift from the i-layer to the n-layer, while holes drift from the i-layer to the p-layer. The i-layer material properties at the p/i and i/n interfaces strongly influence the built-in electric field distribution and the collection efficiency of carriers transported to the p and n layers. Inserting high-bandgap hydrogenated amorphous silicon carbide (a-SiC
x:H) or hydrogenated amorphous silicon oxide (a-SiO
x:H) films at the p/i interface blocks back diffusion of photogenerated electrons toward the p-layer via the conduction band offset (Δ
Ec), while the valence band offset (Δ
Ev) reduces the number of holes injected from the p-layer into the i-layer, which can effectively improve the open-circuit voltage (
Voc) of the cell [
7,
8]. However, high-bandgap materials have higher defect densities, which make carriers more prone to recombination. A high Δ
Ev also reduces the collection efficiency of photogenerated holes crossing from the i-layer to the p-layer [
9].
High-bandgap materials at the p/i interface can enhance the electric field at the p/i interface but weaken it in the subsequent bulk region of the i-layer, making photogenerated carriers produced by short-wavelength photons at the p/i interface easier to collect. In contrast, the collection efficiency of photogenerated carriers produced by medium- and long-wavelength photons inside the i-layer decreases [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15]. The effect of adding high-bandgap materials at the i/n interface on the built-in electric field of the i-layer is smaller than at the p/i interface. Generally, the impact on cell characteristics is lower than at the p/i interface.
Common a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H high-bandgap silicon-based alloy materials may exhibit different effects on the conduction and recombination of photogenerated carriers, due to distinct defect structures arising from the addition of carbon and oxygen atoms. The a-SiO
x:H film exhibits n-type behavior due to micro n-type doping by oxygen atoms, meaning that in addition to the effects of Δ
Ec and Δ
Ev and defect density, the a-SiO
x:H film also experiences a positive O
3+ space charge that alters the built-in electric field distribution [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6]. Adding an a-SiO
x:H high-bandgap film at the p/i interface significantly enhances the electric field at this interface due to its n-type property, while reducing the built-in electric field in the bulk region of the i-layer, causing a significant decrease in the fill factor of the cell [
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15]. In contrast, the a-SiC
x:H film, unlike the a-SiO
x:H film, does not possess n-type properties and does not interfere with the electric field via space charge formation.
The novelty of this study lies in the use of pulse-wave modulation (PWM) plasma technology to fabricate a-SiCx:H and a-SiOx:H films with nearly identical optical bandgaps (Eg), refractive indices, and extinction coefficients. By eliminating optical variations, we can explicitly isolate and compare the effects of the chemical bonding states—specifically, oxygen-induced n-type doping versus carbon incorporation—on the internal electric field distribution and solar cell performance.
2. Materials and Methods
a-Si:H, a-SiC
x:H, and a-SiO
x:H films, as well as p-i-n solar cells, were deposited on glass, single-crystalline silicon, and fluorine-doped tin oxide (FTO: SnO
2:F) glass substrates using PWM plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD) technology [
14,
15,
16,
17]. A 13.56 MHz radio-frequency (RF) power source controlled the on and off states of the RF power using a square-wave pulse. Plasma excitation occurred during the plasma
ton, and plasma termination occurred during the plasma
toff time. Gases within the vacuum chamber were excited or ionized into active radicals during
ton, and these active radicals were neutralized back to their original neutral gaseous state during
toff. By adjusting the RF power and the
ton/
toff time ratio, the generation and neutralization of active radicals can be precisely regulated to control the bonding composition and the optical and electrical properties of the deposited films [
14,
15,
16,
17]. The PWM method was specifically chosen because it allows decoupling of the electron temperature and gas dissociation efficiency, enabling precise optical matching of
Eg, refractive index (
n), and extinction coefficient (
k) required for this comparative study.
The process conditions included a fixed chamber pressure of 0.9 Torr and a substrate temperature of 210 °C. For the a-Si:H films, the SiH4/H2 flow ratio, ton/toff time, and RF power were 20/80 sccm, 20/5 ms, and 10 W, respectively. For the a-SiCx:H films, the SiH4/CH4/H2 flow rates, ton/toff time, and RF power were 20/2.5/80 sccm, 20/1 ms, and 30 W, respectively. For the a-SiOx:H films, the SiH4/CO2/H2 flow rates, ton/toff time, and RF power were 20/2.5/80 sccm, 20/5 ms, and 15 W, respectively.
Figure 1 shows schematic diagrams of the p-i-n solar cells: (a) the a-Si:H reference cell (b) with a-SiC
x:H or a-SiO
x:H placed at the p/i interface, and (c) a-SiC
x:H or a-SiO
x:H placed at the i/n interface. The i-layer of the a-Si:H p-i-n reference cell was a 500 nm thick a-Si:H film, serving as a baseline for comparing cell characteristics. To verify the influence of the wide-bandgap a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films, the film thickness was set to 100 nm, accounting for 1/5 of the 500 nm i-layer thickness. Specifically, 1/5 of the a-Si:H film at the p/i interface (where light enters the front of the i-layer from the p-layer) and at the i/n interface (where light penetrates to the rear of the i-layer) was replaced with a-SiC
x:H or a-SiO
x:H films. This resulted in two types of cells with embedded buffer layers (i
B): a p/i
B/i/n structure of p/i
B-a-SiC
x:H or a-SiO
x:H (100 nm)/a-Si:H (400 nm)/n, and a p/i/i
B/n structure of p/a-Si:H (400 nm)/i
B-a-SiC
x:H or a-SiO
x:H (100 nm)/n. The five cells were designated as follows: the reference cell (C_i-a-Si:H), cells with a-SiC
x:H added at the p/i interface (C_p/i
B-a-SiC
x:H) and a-SiO
x:H (C_p/i
B-a-SiO
x:H), and cells with a-SiC
x:H added at the i/n interface (C_i
B-a-SiC
x:H/n) and a-SiO
x:H (C_i
B-a-SiO
x:H/n).
The
n,
k, and
Eg of the a-Si:H, a-SiC
x:H, and a-SiO
x:H films were measured using a J. A. Woollam M-2000 ellipsometer (J. A. Woollam, Lincoln, NE, USA). Measurements were conducted over the wavelength range of 190–1700 nm at incident angles of 55°, 60°, 65°, and 70°. The polarization state (p- and s-planes) of light reflected from the film surface was measured to obtain amplitude and phase differences, and the thickness (d),
Eg,
n, and
k were then simulated using the Tauc–Lorentz model [
17,
18]. The Si-H, Si-C, and Si-O bonding in a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H was measured using a Thermo Scientific Nicolet iS5 Fourier-transform infrared spectrometer (FTIR) (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA). The current density–voltage (
J-V) characteristics of the solar cells were measured using an Agilent B2912A Source Measure Unit (SMU) (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) under AM 1.5 solar illumination provided by a SAN-EI ELECTRIC XES-40S1 solar simulator (SAN-EI Electric, Osaka, Japan).
3. Results and Discussion
The optical and structural properties of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films were primarily controlled by RF power and
ton/
toff.
Figure 2 shows the
Eg values of the a-SiO
x:H and a-SiC
x:H films. For the a-SiO
x:H films,
Eg gradually increased from 1.759 to 1.802 to 1.826 eV as the RF power increased from 8 to 15 to 20 W, with
ton/
toff = 20/5 (ms). For the a-SiC
x:H films, due to the lower dissociation efficiency of CH
4,
Eg increased only from 1.777 to 1.794 eV when the RF power was raised from 20 to 30 W under the condition of
ton/
toff = 20/5 (ms). To increase
Eg, the
ton/
toff ratio was increased to 20/1 (ms), yielding an
Eg of 1.806 eV. The difference in
Eg between the 1.802 eV a-SiO
x:H film and the 1.806 eV a-SiC
x:H film was less than 0.2%; thus, a-SiO
x:H and a-SiC
x:H films under these conditions were used as buffer layer materials.
To ensure the relative relationship between the
n and
k of the a-SiO
x:H and a-SiC
x:H films, the Tauc–Lorentz model [
18,
19] was used for analysis.
Figure 3 presents the full spectrum of (a)
n and (b)
k for a-Si:H, a-SiC
x:H, and a-SiO
x:H films from 190 to 1680 nm, along with (c) the difference in
n between a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films (Δ
n) divided by the
n value of the reference a-Si:H film (
na-Si:H), i.e., Δ
n/
na-Si:H, and (d) the difference in
k (Δ
k) divided by the
k value of the reference a-Si:H film (
ka-Si:H), i.e., Δ
k/
ka-Si:H. These variations are defined in Equations (1) and (2):
Figure 3a,b show that the
n and
k values of the wide-bandgap a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films were close to each other but lower than those of the a-Si:H film used in the reference cell.
Figure 3c presents the Δ
n/
na-Si:H of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films, with a very small variation error ranging from +1.4% to −0.98%. The refractive index (
n) values of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films were nearly identical.
Figure 3d shows the Δ
k/
ka-Si:H of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films, with a variation error ranging from +1.2% to −4.1%. Although slightly larger than Δ
n/
na-Si:H, the values remained very small, indicating that the
k values of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films were also close to each other. The selected a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films possessed similar properties in terms of
Eg,
n, and
k. Under these conditions, the effects on the p/i and i/n interfaces could be comparatively analyzed; in particular, the n-type doping effect of the a-SiO
x:H film compared to the a-SiC
x:H film could be examined under conditions of similar optical characteristics.
To confirm the differences in Si-H, Si-C, and Si-O bonding between the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films, we examined the FTIR spectra, shown in
Figure 4, of 200 nm thick a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films for (a) the wagging and bending bands and (b) the stretching band.
Table 1 summarizes the hydrogen contents
CH, the integrated area of Si-C bonds
ISi-C or Si-O bonds
ISi-O, the integrated area of C-H
2 bonds
IC-H2 or Si-O-Si bonds
ISi-O-Si, and the microstructural ratio (
RS) of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films.
Figure 4a shows that the a-SiC
x:H film had a larger absorbance amplitude than the a-SiO
x:H film in the Si-H wagging mode (550 to 740 nm). The integrated absorption strength, I, is calculated as follows:
where α is the absorption coefficient. The hydrogen concentration,
NH, is then determined using [
20,
21,
22]
where
AH is the proportionality constant (1.6 × 10
19 cm
−2) [
21,
22]. Finally, the hydrogen content of the film is defined as
where
NSi is the atomic density of silicon (5 × 10
22 cm
−3) [
21,
22].
The CH 21.18% of the a-SiCx:H film is slightly larger than 21.06% of the a-SiOx:H film. The difference between the two films in the main Si-H bond intensity was not significant.
The Si-C stretching mode and C-H
2 wagging mode of the a-SiC
x:H film are primarily located at the peak positions of 770 and 1000 cm
−1 [
23]. The integrated areas of
ISi-C and
IC-H2 are 19.7 and 9.33 cm
−1, respectively. The Si-O bending band and Si-O-Si stretching band are located at the peak positions of 780 and 1000 cm
−1 [
20,
21,
22,
24]. The integrated areas of
ISi-O and
ISi-O-Si are 49.7 and 330 cm
−1, respectively. These results indicate that the primary difference between the two films stems from the distinction in oxygen content.
Figure 4b shows the Si-H stretching mode of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films. The SiH and SiH
2 peaks of the a-SiC
x:H film are at 2004 and 2077 cm
−1, and the integrated areas are
ISiH 44.11 cm
−1 and
ISiH2 57.73 cm
−1. The SiH and SiH
2 peaks of the a-SiO
x:H film are at 2007 and 2080 cm
−1, and the integrated areas are
ISiH 34.69 cm
−1 and
ISiH2 52.06 cm
−1.
RS was estimated from Equation (6) and is 0.57 and 0.60 for the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films, respectively [
22]. The microstructures of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films are similar.
The FTIR data show that the CH and RS of the a-SiCx:H and a-SiOx:H films are similar, but the large difference stems from the oxygen content.
Figure 5 presents the
J-V characteristic curves for the reference cell and the four test cells containing a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H buffer layers in the 1/5 position of the p/i and i/n interfaces. The curves cover (a) 0 to
Voc, (b) −0.5 to 0 V reverse bias, and (c)
Voc to 1.0 V forward bias ranges. The data for the short-circuit current density (
Jsc),
Voc, maximum output current density (
Jm), maximum output voltage (
Vm), maximum output power (
Pmax), fill factor (
FF), and efficiency (
η) of the five cells are listed in
Table 2.
Figure 5a and
Table 2 show that the reference cell C_i-a-Si:H had the highest
Jsc of 13.38 mA/cm
2; the lowest
Voc of 0.8369 V; the highest
Jm,
Vm, and
FF of 11.31 mA/cm
2, 0.6800 V, and 68.69%, respectively; and the highest
η of 7.692%. In the four test cells,
Jsc was consistently lower than that of the reference cell C_i-a-Si:H, and
Voc was consistently higher. The
FF values for cells with buffer layers at the p/i interface (57.82% and 43.99%) were significantly lower than those for cells with buffer layers at the i/n interface (64.84% and 67.38%, respectively).
Figure 5b shows the variation in current density (
J) from −0.5 to 0 V. In this range, the
J of the four test cells remained lower than that of the reference cell. Notably, the C_p/i
B-a-SiO
x:H sample with a-SiO
x:H at the p/i interface showed a current that gradually increased from the second lowest (−13.00 mA/cm
2) to the second highest (−13.56 mA/cm
2) as the voltage changed from 0 to −0.5 V. At the same time, the magnitude relationship of the
J values for the other three cells remained basically unchanged. This result indicates that when a-SiO
x:H is placed at the p/i interface,
J increases rapidly with increasing reverse bias; that is, photogenerated carriers in the i-layer can continuously increase the current because the reverse bias enhances the electric field intensity in the i-layer.
Figure 5c shows the variation in
J from
Voc to 1.0 V forward bias. Within this range, the increase in the four test cells was smaller than that in the reference cell. For example, at 0.915 V, the buffer layers at the p/i interface exhibited stronger suppression of forward current than those at the i/n interface. Specifically, the C_p/i
B-a-SiC
x:H cell showed the lowest current density, which correlates with its highest
Voc of 0.8998 V. This demonstrates that the impact of the a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H films at the p/i interface on blocking hole injection from the p-layer into the i-layer was higher than their impact on blocking electron injection from the n-layer into the i-layer.
Placing a-SiCx:H and a-SiOx:H buffer layers at the p/i interface improved the Voc; the a-SiCx:H film increased it to 0.8998 V, which is higher than the 0.8482 V of the a-SiOx:H film. This implies that the ΔEv in the a-SiCx:H film was higher than that in the a-SiOx:H film. Because this energy barrier is more difficult to cross, there was greater blocking of holes injected from the p-layer into the i-layer or of photogenerated holes flowing from the i-layer to the p-layer, resulting in a larger Voc with the addition of the a-SiCx:H film. The cell with the a-SiOx:H p/iB buffer layer had the lowest FF of 43.99%, while the cell with the iB/n buffer layer had the second-highest FF (67.38%). This is distinct from the cell with the a-SiCx:H p/i buffer layer, which had a slightly higher FF (57.82%), while the cell with the i/n buffer layer had a lower FF (64.84%). It is worth noting that while oxygen incorporation in a-SiOx:H induces an n-type doping effect, creating a positive space charge (O3+), carbon incorporation in a-SiCx:H primarily widens the bandgap and increases structural disorder without acting as a donor. This structural distinction allows a-SiCx:H to provide a high ΔEv at the p/i interface without collapsing the bulk electric field, unlike the n-type a-SiOx:H.
The significant decrease in
FF caused by the a-SiO
x:H film had a low correlation with Δ
Ev. Instead, this decrease was due to the micro n-type doping of oxygen atoms in the a-SiO
x:H film, which caused misalignment and a reduction in the built-in electric field in the subsequent i-layer, leading to a significant reduction in overall
FF and
η when the a-SiO
x:H film was added to the p/i buffer layer [
5,
6,
10,
12]. This is also reflected in the fact that when the a-SiO
x:H film was moved to the i/n interface, the n-type doping enhanced the built-in electric field of the entire i-layer, resulting in the a-SiO
x:H film at the i/n interface achieving the second-highest
FF (67.38%), only slightly lower than that of the a-Si:H reference cell [
14,
15].
The effects of high-bandgap a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H thin films at the p/i and i/n interfaces were further validated using a second set of films with higher
Eg: a-SiC
x:H (
Eg: 1.820 eV) and a-SiO
x:H (
Eg: 1.826 eV). These films were deposited with a CH
4 flow rate of 5.6 sccm, RF power of 20 W, and
ton/
toff of 20/5, and a CO
2 flow rate of 2.5 sccm, RF power of 20 W, and
ton/
toff of 20/5, respectively.
Figure 6 compares the
J-V parameters (
Jsc,
Voc,
FF, and
η) of the original set (a-SiC
x:H,
Eg: 1.806 eV; a-SiO
x:H,
Eg: 1.802 eV) with those of the second set.
Table 3 lists the
Jsc,
Voc,
FF, and
η results for the second set.
Figure 6a,c show that across the four test cells,
Jsc was consistently lower than that of the reference cell (C_i-a-Si:H), while
Voc was, in general, higher. Placing a-SiC
x:H and a-SiO
x:H buffer layers at the p/i interface improved
Voc. The a-SiC
x:H film increased this to 0.8998 V (original) and 0.8874 V (second set), which is higher than the 0.8482 V (original) and 0.8468 V (second set) obtained with the a-SiOx:H film. As shown in
Figure 6b,d, both sets of samples showed that placing a-SiO
x:H at the p/i interface yields the lowest
FF (original: 43.99% and second set: 39.73%) and
η (original: 4.850% and second set: 4.210%) compared to a-SiC
x:H’s
FF (original: 57.82% and second set: 45.10%) and
η (original: 6.796% and second set: 5.021%). Conversely, when a-SiO
x:H is placed at the i/n interface, the
FF (original: 67.38% and second set: 65.50%) and
η (original: 7.430% and second set: 6.732%) significantly improved, surpassing those of a-SiC
x:H’s
FF (original: 64.84% and second set: 56.13%) and
η (original: 7.270% and second set: 5.939%). These results confirm that the oxygen-doping effect of a-SiO
x:H thin films decreases the internal electric field in the rear i-region when placed at the p/i interface, leading to lower
FF and
η compared to the a-SiC
x:H film. In contrast, at the i/n interface, this effect enhances the electric field in the front i-region, resulting in higher
FF and
η compared to the a-SiC
x:H film.
The higher Eg of the a-SiCx:H (Eg: 1.820 eV) and a-SiOx:H (Eg: 1.826 eV) films resulted in reduced film quality. Consequently, all parameters (Jsc, Voc, FF, and η) decreased due to high recombination rates as carriers passed through the high-density defects within the a-SiCx:H or a-SiOx:H films.
The experimental results above indicate that a-SiCx:H at the p/i interface significantly increases the Voc value due to a higher ΔEv effect. a-SiCx:H and a-SiOx:H films at the p/i interface have a greater attenuation effect on the fill factor. The electric field is too concentrated between the p-layer and these two buffer layers, weakening it in the subsequent i-layer and causing a significant drop in FF; this effect is more pronounced for the a-SiOx:H film due to its slight n-type doping. This is a substantial distinction in the application of a-SiOx:H and a-SiCx:H films. Regardless of placement at the p/i or i/n interface, the open-circuit voltage is higher, and the short-circuit current is lower than that of the reference cell, with band mismatches ΔEv and ΔEc contributing. Part of the Jsc decrease at the i/n interface is also due to reduced generation of photogenerated carriers from medium- or long-wavelength photons.