1. Introduction
The global increase in greenhouse gas emissions observed recently and the need to ensure energy security have prompted the search for environmentally friendly sources of renewable energy [
1]. Biomass is increasingly used as a source of sustainable fuel. The amount needed for it to supplement global annual electricity demand is expected to reach 360 million tons [
2]. Composting waste organic materials is one of the oldest and most environmentally friendly methods of their utilization [
3]. Both spent mushroom substrate and municipal waste are by-products of human economic activity and human existence. Composting organic waste is a safe way to dispose it, and as an organic fertilizer, it can be used to enrich the soil, which in turn can increase the value of energy crops [
4]. Organic fertilizers are a safer alternative to mineral ones in the soil environment. Their components are released slowly, and, in effect, nutrient balance in the soil is maintained for a longer time. Humic acids in organic waste compost stimulate soil microorganisms that have a positive effect on soil structure [
5].
The most common energy crops, subject to many studies, are osier willow (
Salix vinimalis), giant miscanthus (
Miscanthus x giganteus), and tuberous sunflower (
Helianthus tuberosus) [
6,
7]. Despite the fairly extensive literature on the above species, little attention has been paid to Chinese silver grass (
Miscanthus sienensis Andersson), a plant with many economic possibilities, which is also used as an energy crop (biofuels, thermal energy). Additionally, its cultivation increases organic carbon content in the soil, and it does not compete with plants cultivated for food production [
8]. Thus far, research has mainly focused on
Miscanthus x giganteus, a hybrid of
Miscanthus sacchariflorus and
Miscanthus sinensis. A perennial grass species,
Miscanthus x giganteus is cultivated in Europe due to its high yield (10–25 t/ha of dry matter), but it is not resistant to low temperatures and water shortages in the same way that
Miscanthus sinensis Andersson is.
Miscanthus sinensis is not as sensitive to low temperatures, heavy metal contamination, or stress factors as are other hybrid species [
9]. It combines such features as high yields, low demand for nutrients and water, phytoremediation potential, and an ability to adapt to adverse environmental conditions [
10]. For this reason,
Miscanthus sinensis Andersson is one of the most beneficial species of its genus [
11]. In order to maximize the amounts of
Miscanthus sinensis biomass used for energy purposes, it is necessary to focus on the assessment of factors determining its yield [
12].
3. Results
The values of Sielyaninov’s coefficient (K) indicated that the most favorable weather conditions for Chinese silver grass (
Miscanthus sinensis Andersson) were in the 2018 growing period (
Table 1) and less beneficial in 2019 and 2020. In 2018, the beginning of the growing period was quite dry and very dry, but June, July and October were optimal for plant growth and development.
The dry matter content of mushroom compost was 30%, with a much higher value of 68% for municipal waste compost (
Table 2). The pH value of mushroom compost was 6.41, close to neutral, while for municipal waste compost, it was neutral (7.10). According to Vitti et al. [
25], pH of good-quality compost should range from 6.0 to 7.8.
According to Madej et al. [
26], composted waste plant materials contain up to 450 g·kg
−1 of dry matter, with the N concentration ranging from 13 to 15 g·kg
−1DM, the P concentration ranging from 2.19 to 4.81 g·kg
−1DM, and the K concentration being 4.98 g·kg
−1DM. In the present experiment, a much higher content of macronutrients was noted. Mushroom compost and municipal waste compost contained 20.9 g·kg
−1 and 14.30 g·kg
−1 of N, 8.86 g·kg
−1 and 17.32 g·kg
−1 of P, and 11.21 g·kg
−1 and 25.4 g·kg
−1 of K, respectively. In particular, mushroom compost contained higher amounts of N (20.9 g·kg
−1) than did municipal waste compost, and in municipal waste compost, more P and K was noted. Despite these differences, the C:N ratio values were similar for both kinds of organic waste.
Compared to the values provided by the BN-89/9103-09 Polish Standard [
27], the content of heavy metals (
Table 3) was at a relatively low level and did not exceed permissible amounts. It was much lower in mushroom compost than in municipal waste compost. However, quality parameters of both organic materials were satisfactory, with neutral pH, relatively high nutrient content, and moderate heavy metal content. Mladenov [
28] reported similar results.
Because of its low hygroscopic moisture in the analytical state, biomass was found suitable to be used for energy purposes (
Table 4). If moisture of a material increases, its caloric value decreases. According to the literature, the average calorific value of dry hay is 18 MJ·kg
−1, but when moisture content increases to 70%, it decreases to 4 MJ·kg
−1 [
29]. As regards biomass conversion into biogas, plants with lower moisture content (dried grass or straw) are of higher energy values [
30]. In the present experiment, the average moisture content of
Miscanthus sinensis was 4.67%, with much higher values than those in the analytical state observed by Kowalczyk-Juśko [
31] for some other energy crops (
Helianthus tuberosus–9.7%,
Spartina pectinata–13.5%,
Miscanthus sacchariflorus–7.2%). The moisture content of
Miscanthus x giganteus in the dry state is 9.21% [
32]. The most favorable moisture content for the process of combustion is 6–8% [
33]. Its value depends on the leaf-to-stem ratio of fresh biomass, as leaves contain more water than do stems [
34]. Organic fertilizers applied to Chinese silver grass did not affect the moisture level of hygroscopic biomass, but it varied over the years of research. The most favorable value of 3.08% was noted in the second year.
The highest percentage of hygroscopic moisture (4.82%) was noted on the plot where the highest dose of mushroom compost was applied. The lowest value (4.54%) was found for plants treated with 75% municipal waste compost and 25% mushroom compost applied together. However, differences in the hygroscopic moisture of Miscanthus sinensis biomass between fertilized plots were not statistically significant. On the other hand, hygroscopic moisture content varied significantly over the years of research.
An important element in the assessment of an energy crop is its ash content. According to the literature, when ash content increases by 1%, the heat of combustion decreases by 0.2 kJ·kg
−1 [
35]. Dradrach et al. [
36] reported that ash content in
Miscanthus sinensis was 4.74%. In the present experiment, its average three-year value was 4.45% (
Table 5). In dry-state samples, the highest amount (5.91%) was recorded in the first year, while the lowest in the second, at 3.07%. The differences in ash content between years of research were statistically significant. Unlike the year of research, treatment combinations did not significantly affect ash content in
Miscanthus sinensis biomass. Compared to other species,
Miscanthus sinensis ash content is not high. For
Miscanthus sacchariflorus, it is 4.3%, with 7% in rapeseed, and, for comparison, in bituminous coal, it is 22% [
18,
37,
38]. In the present experiment, no interaction concerning ash content between years and treatments was observed.
In the experiment conducted by Eiland et al. (2021), the ash content of Chinese silver grass biomass was 79% higher in the first year than in the second [
39]. Kalembasa reported that ash content in the biomass of
Miscanthus sinensis was 5.2% [
40], and in another study, high ash content was found to have a negative effect on biomass calorific value [
41]. Gołąb-Bogacz et al. (2021) reported that nitrogen fertilizers increased the ash content of
Miscanthus biomass [
41]. In
Miscanthus sinensis intended for energy purposes, ash content should be as low as possible. In a good quality plant material, it should range from 2 to 4% [
42]. In the present experiment, the highest critical value with more than 7% of ash in dry matter was recorded in the first year in plants treated with urban waste compost.
The heat of combustion of
Miscanthus sinensis biomass in the dry state significantly varied over the years research (
Table 6). According to Dradrach et al. [
36], for
Miscanthus sinensis biomass, it was 17,472 kJ·kg
−1DM. In the present experiment, the average value across treatment combinations and years of research was higher, at 18,918 kJ·kg
−1DM. The highest heat of combustion was noted in 2020 (19,485 kJ·kg
−1) and the lowest in the second year (2019), at 18,169 kJ·kg
−1. It was expected that organic fertilizers, compared to control, would significantly increase the heat of combustion. The recorded values were similar to those of
Miscanthus x. giganteus, whose calorific value was reported to be 18.79 kJ kg
−1DM [
43].
The differences between years of research were statistically significant. Mushroom and municipal waste composts significantly increased the Miscanthus sinensis heat of combustion. The highest value (19,201 kJ·kg−1) was on the plots treated with mushroom compost on its own and with municipal waste compost also on its own (19,129 kJ·kg−1). As a three-year average, the lowest heat of combustion amounting to 18,516 kJ·kg−1 was noted in the dry-state sample from the control plot.
Porvaz [
44] reported that the calorific value of
Miscanthus sinensis ranged from 17 to 19 MJ/kg. In the present research, similar values were noted. The overall average calorific value of
Miscanthus sinensis biomass (
Table 7) was 17,679 kJ·kg
−1. Treatment with composts significantly affected the calorific value of
Miscanthus sinensis. Statistically significant differences were noted between control plants and those growing on plots treated with composts. As a three-year average, dry-state samples of control plants were of the lowest calorific value, at 17,284 kJ·kg
−1. Plants with the highest calorific value (17,964 kJ·ha
−1) were from the plot treated with mushroom compost on its own (MSC100%). Significant differences in calorific value were also noted between the years of the experiment, with the lowest in the first and second, with values of 17,884 kJ·ha
−1 and 16,903 kJ·ha
−1, respectively.
The chemical composition of plant biomass has a direct impact on its calorific value and on its processing to produce energy. The main components determining the value are multimolecular biopolymers such as cellulose (35–48%), hemicellulose (22–30%), and lignin (15–27%), used in a complex process to produce bioenergy [
45]. Their content ensures that it is possible to obtain energy or liquid and gaseous fuels from biomass [
46]. The hypothesis put forward in the experiment assumed that varied combinations of organic fertilizers, each introducing 170 kg N ha
−1 to the soil, would affect the chemical composition of
Miscanthus sinensis. The content of lignin is particularly important because lignin-derived methoxyphenols are the main component of smoke in the initial stage of combustion [
47]. According to Chupakhin et al., for the best calorific value,
Miscanthus sinensis should contain 41–45% cellulose, 20.6–33% hemicellulose, and 19.0–23.4% lignin [
12].
Roszkowski [
48] argues that high lignin yield has an impact on biomass calorific value. In the present experiment, treatment affected lignin content and, at the same time, biomass calorific value. The three-year average of the
Miscanthus sinensis lignin concentration was 7.93% (
Table 8). As regards treatment groups, the biomass of
Miscanthus sinensis produced the most lignin in response to the combination of municipal waste compost with mushroom compost in proportions of 25:75 and 75:25. In the first year, the highest (7.60%) was noted on the plot treated with a mixture of municipal waste compost (75%) and mushroom compost (25%). In the second and third year, the highest lignin concentration, with 8.67% and 8.39%, respectively, was in response to municipal waste compost (25%) applied together with mushroom compost (75%), i.e., in inverse proportion. As an average of treatment combinations, the highest percentage of lignin was noted in the second year of the experiment (8.48%) and the lowest in the first (7.35%).
The content of lignin noted in the experiment was very low. Chupakhin et al. reported that
Miscanthus sinensis is a species with a low lignin content of 8% as its average value [
12]. Low lignin content is a desirable feature in bioethanol production, but it depends on many factors [
11]. Liu et al. highlighted the multidimensional genetic background of
Miscanthus sinensis and the unexplained molecular processes determining its parameter values and its resistance to abiotic stress factors [
10].
Neither treatment nor years of research significantly affected
Miscanthus sinensis cellulose content (
Table 9). There was no interaction between them either. As an overall average, the cellulose percentage in the biomass was 45.88% DM, which was within the range of 40–55% and can be regarded as high content in lignocellulosic biomass. In the study by Chupakhin et al., cellulose content, with an average value of 40.6%, and biomass yield increased each year of research [
12]. This was not consistent with the results obtained in the present experiment.
Neither treatment combinations of mushroom and municipal waste composts nor year of research significantly affected hemicellulose content in
Miscanthus sinensis biomass (
Table 10). As an average effect of treatment groups and years of cultivation, the hemicellulose concentration was 32.01%. Sun and Cheng [
49] noted that the share of cellulose in lignocellulosic biomass was 40–55%, with 24–40% being hemicellulose. Thus, the content determined in the experiment was within the above ranges. Chupakhin et al., found that the average content of hemicellulose was 30.2%, and they also noted that some
Miscanthus species contained high levels of cellulose and hemicellulose and low levels of lignin and ash [
12].