Advances in Corneal Tissue Engineering: Comparative Performance of Bioengineered Grafts in Animal Models

Background and Objectives: Corneal opacity is the fifth global cause of blindness and moderate-to-severe visual impairment due to scar tissue formation. The purpose of this study is to provide an integrated overview of the current state of corneal engineering strategies focused on the comparison with healthy corneas. It aims to identify engineering strategies that would result in functional corneas, providing real alternatives to donor corneal transplants. Materials and Methods: systematic review was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) and according to the protocol with the ID: CRD420250654641 at the PROSPERO database. The focus question, prompted by considering the shortage of human corneal grafts, was: what is the performance of bioengineered corneal grafts in experimental animal models when compared with healthy eyes in the restoration of corneal anatomy and function? Results: Incorporating human corneal epithelial cells w/ or w/o human corneal stromal stem cells into a gelatin methacrylate and polyethylene glycol diacrylate matrix emerges as the leading option for epithelial layer regeneration. Human and bovine decellularized corneas, porcine corneal ECM in Gelatin methacrylate, dual layered collagen vitrigel and tissue-engineered human anterior hemi-corneas have shown promise for simultaneous regeneration of the corneal stromal and epithelial layers. Corneal stromal tissue regeneration could be positively impacted by transplantation with grafts derived from aligned self-lifting analogous tissue equivalents and collagen-based hydrogels. Finally, scaffolds of silk fibroin and human purified type I collagen represent promising approaches for corneal endothelial regeneration, though their effectiveness is contingent upon integration with endothelial cells. Conclusions: Collectively, these findings contribute to the growing body of evidence supporting the potential of tissue-engineered corneal substitutes as viable therapeutic options for corneal blindness and vision impairment. Assessing the optical and functional properties of the regenerated cornea should be a cornerstone in all studies aiming to evaluate their clinical effectiveness.