2. Materials and Methods
The study of the algae in the waterbodies of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park was carried out on material collected, during the summer, on 6 July 2008. This was a one-time sampling collection. The samples collected came from 7 sites and 4 different waterbodies with a total of 21 samples (3 replicate samples per site).
Samples were taken in the littoral and pelagial in plankton, benthos, and epilithic from stones. Phytoplankton was collected with an Apstein net and stored in sterile bottles. The epilithic rock samples were cleaned with a soft toothbrush by lightly scrubbing in a circular motion, then rinsed with distilled water. The toothbrush was cleaned with distilled water after each sample. This rinse water was collected in a sterile Whirl-pak. Phytobenthos samples were collected with a large nylon liquid baster and placed in a sterile Whirl-pak. Algal and water samples were transported to the lab in an ice cooler at 0 °C until they could be taken to the lab for processing.
The temperature, conductivity, and pH of the water were measured at the time of sampling with a HANNA Waterproof Portable pH/Temperature meter and an Oakton Waterproof CON 150 Meter. There were 21 water samples analyzed in the lab with a Shimadzu ICPE-9000 multitype inductively coupled plasma (ICP) emission spectrometer for Hg, TP, and NO3.
Diatom slides were prepared with a peroxide technique [
21]. All slides of soft and diatom algae were identified with a Leica DM2500 light microscope under 400 to 1000x magnification.
International handbooks were used to identify algae [
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39]. To update the nomenclature, we used the Algaebase.org website [
40]. Therefore, all names are currently accepted taxonomically.
The determination of saprobic indices was carried out according to the Pantle–Buck method in Sládeček’s modification [
19].
Saprobity indices were obtained for each algal community as a function of the number of saprobic species and their relative abundances:
where
S is the index of saprobity for algal community (unitless),
s is the species-specific saprobity index, and
n is the cell density of each species.
The similarity calculations were performed using the BioDiversity Pro 2.0 program and network analyses in JASP were performed using the botnet package in R Statistica package of [
41]. The canonical correspondence analyses were done with the CANOCO Program 4.0 [
42]. The program GRAPHS [
43] was used for comparative floristic of revealed communities. The bioindicator analyses were done with the help of ecological preferences of identified algae and cyanobacteria species [
44,
45,
46].
Description of Study Sites
The Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park study site is located in the Knob Region (
Figure 1) of Kentucky, USA. The ALBNHP has two park locations (site A and site B). They are roughly 12 km apart (
Figure 2). Site A had only one sampling location (sample #1), which is the Sinking Spring (
Figure 3a). The Sinking Spring is groundwater recharged and flows between layers of the limestone bedrock. Site B had sampling locations 2 to 7 (
Figure 3b,
Table 1). Sample #2 was plankton towed from an artificial pond (
Figure 4b), whereas samples #3 to #7 were from ephemeral streams (
Figure 4a,
Figure 5a,b and
Figure 6a,b). At sample location #5, the stream was sinking into the bedrock (
Figure 6a) and at sample location #6, the stream was reemerging (
Figure 6b).
3. Results
The water chemistry and geographical position of seven studied sites are represented in
Table 2. The elevations of the studied waterbodies are very similar; they are located at 137–260 m a.s.l. The average water temperature during the sampling period varied between 14.2 °C from the cave wall and in the small pool of site #1 and 26 °C in the sinking stream of site #5. Water conductivity and total dissolved solids (TDS) have minimal values in the pond of site #3, whereas the maximal values are from sites #1 and #3. The pH of the water pH ranged with an amplitude of 7.4 (site #1) and 8.3 (site #4), with all sites being alkaline. Total phosphorus (TP) and nitrate values were minimal but the quantity available was enough for base growth. Only one heavy metal, Hg, was determined in this study. The Hg metal had a minimal value at site #7 (13 ppm), but maximal value at site #2 (40 ppm) where water conductivity and TDS had the lowest values.
There were 88 species of algae and cyanobacteria observed in the waterbodies from seven study sites of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park (
Table 3). Diatoms were strongly represented with 54 species, followed by cyanobacteria with 20 species, and green algae with 11 species. Charophyta and Rhodophyta divisions were represented by two and one species, respectively. The distribution of taxonomical content in each site is represented in
Table 3. This is the first algal diversity study from the ALBNHP. We analyzed the taxonomical group’s distribution and diversity, as well as species ecological preferences according to [
44,
45], which is listed in
Table 3. It can be seen that the species richness was highest on the cave wall and in the small pool of site #1 (36) and in the Knob Creek ephemeral stream of site #7 (35), whereas minimal species richness was revealed in the stream and pool of site #3 (13). Diatoms prevailed in all the studied communities but in site #7 it was accompanied by twenty cyanobacteria species.
Figure 7a demonstrates that in sites #3 to #7, the cyanobacteria species also played an important role in algal communities where they contained up to 10% to 15% of total species richness in the site’s community.
Porphyridium purpureum (Rhodophyta) algae was represented in sites #2, #3, and #7.
Bioindicator plots of algal species preferences for each site community are shown in
Figure 7,
Figure 8,
Figure 9,
Figure 10 and
Figure 11 and
Table 3 and
Table 4. Therefore, algae in the studied habitats of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park have mostly benthic and planktonic-benthic ecology with up to 8% to 15% of planktonic species, and 3% to 8% of epiphytes and soil inhabitants (
Figure 7b).
Temperature indicators were represented by four ecological groups (
Figure 8a). Temperate temperatures of water were preferred by most species, cool-water indicators in sites #1 and #2 represented up to 23% of species richness of these communities, and warm temperature regimes were preferred by 20% of species in site #7. Lotic and oxygen saturation indicators (
Figure 8b) could be characterized from sites #1 to #5. They were well oxygenated, but, in sites #6 and #7, species were found that could survive in waters enriched by sulfides, as a result of organic degrading destruction in low moving water. The aerophilic community species were observed in the stream and pool site #3 that demonstrates a high-oxygen enrichment environment.
Salinity indicators in the studied waterbodies of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park were mostly from indifferent groups accompanied by halophilic species in sites #1 to #4 and #6 and #7 (
Figure 9a). The mesohalobic species also were represented in communities of sites #1 to #3 and #7, but in low numbers. The high salinity indicators, such as halobiontes, were represented in sites #3 to #7 by 3% to 13%. Therefore, the water of the studied sites can be defined as low-to-middle enriched by chlorides.
The water pH indicator distribution shows a prevalence for indifferents and alkaliphiles in all sites excluding those of site #2 where acidophilic species are about 18%. Alkalibiontes were found in communities of sites #2, #4, and #5, which contained about 5% to 15% of the algae species richness (
Figure 9b). Therefore, the waterbodies of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park can be defined as low-alkaline.
The organic pollution indicators according to the Watanabe system demonstrate low-to-middle organic enrichments of the studied sites (
Figure 10a). Saproxenes and eurysaprobes represent about 83% to 100% of community but saprophiles, indicators of aquatic organic pollution represented up to 17% in sites #1, #6, and #7, which helps to define all studied waterbodies in the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park as low organically polluted. The same results can be seen in the indication of organic pollution with indices saprobity S (
Figure 10b). Indicator prevalence of class 1 to 3 (up to 90%) demonstrated low organically polluted waters in all of the studied sites.
Activity of photosynthetic processes can be revealed with algae nutrition type indicators.
Figure 11a shows a strong prevalence of autotrophic species (ats and ate), up to 80% to 100% in the studied site communities, excluding site #3 where the mixotrophes were 50%. Indicators of the trophic state demonstrated a presence of diverse groups of algae, from oligotrophic to hypereutrophic states (
Figure 11b). In these groups, the oligotrophic and mesotrophic groups (blue and green in
Figure 6b) were represented, up to 50% to 70% in different site communities that can be defined in the studied waterbodies of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park as mostly mesotrophic. The eutrophic indicators were enriched communities in sites #1 to #3 and #7 that can infer some eutrophication trends.
We used a comparative floristic program, GRAPHS, to compare the diversity of the algal communities on both, the division and species level.
Figure 12a demonstrates the dividing of division species richness into two different clusters based on a similarity level of 70%. The diatoms are represented in one cluster, whereas all other divisions are clustered into two clusters. A comparison of species richness on the sites is shown in the dendrogram of
Figure 12b. Two clusters are based on 50% similarity. The first includes communities from sites #1, #2, #4, and #7, which are enriched by diatoms in the range of 30 to 36 species (
Table 3 and
Table 4). The other three sites (#3, #5, and #6) have a two-time lower diversity (13–17 taxa) as compared with the other cluster.
The statistical analyses were completed to provide clarify of the differences between the floras of all the sites and their relationships with environmental variables. Therefore, the canonical correspondence plot in
Figure 10a shows that the environmental variables (
Table 2) were divided into three different groups with respect to their influence on algal communities at the division level. Cluster 1 combines sites #1 and #2 that are influenced by Hg and prefer lower water temperatures and pH. Cluster 2 included floras from sites #4 to #7 which were influenced by water temperature and pH. Site #3 (cluster 3) did not show any preferences to environmental factors. We compared the biplot CCA in
Figure 13a and triplot with the most abundant species in
Figure 13b. This caused the community diversity from the sites to be divided into four clusters in relation to environmental factors. Therefore, algae in sites #4, #5, #7 preferred high pH (cluster 1) from which
Cymbella cymbiformis was a marker taxon. Cluster two included communities at sites #3 and #6, which preferred high water temperature with marker species of
Achnanthidium deflexum and
A.
minutissimum. Cluster 3 represented species from site #1, which preferred nutrients enrichment. Only site #2 community with
Amphora inariensis and
Cavinula weinzierlii formed cluster 4 with low dependence with Hg concentration when TDS was also low.
We compared the species content in the sites’ flora with the help of a correlation coefficient calculation. The matrix in
Table 5 demonstrates that algal communities in the studied sites of #1 and #2, #2 and #4, #2 and #7, and #4, #5, #6, #7 were most similar. The JASP correlation plot with the aid of R statistics was used to combine species diversity to the two most correlated communities with respect to enrichments by diatoms and green algae (sites #1 and #2) and diatoms and cyanobacteria (sites #6 and #7) (
Figure 14a) on the level of similarity 90%. When the similarity filter is about 50% (
Figure 14b), there are four different clusters. The most similar were algae from sites #6 and #7, then, sites #4 and #5, then, sites #1 and #2, and only site #3 represented the most different community.
The calculation of the percent of unique species in the BioDiversity Pro program (
Table 6) showed that site #1 community included up to 61% of unique taxa, most of which were diatoms, then followed by sites #2 (46%), #3 (33%), and #4 (32%). The communities of sites #6 and #7 were represented by the most common taxa with the lowest uniqueness. It was assumed that diatom diversity plays a major role in the formation of the algal community’s process in the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park.
Index saprobity S was calculated on the bases of species-specific index s from
Table 3 and saprobity indicators content on the studied site communities.
Table 7 shows that index saprobity had a low range of values and represented class 2 water quality on all sites excluding site #3. The classification of water quality parameters [
47] on the bases of nitric nitrogen concentration (
Table 2) and the index saprobity S (
Table 4) reflect Class 2–3 of water quality and available organic enrichments at sites #1, #2 and #6, #7. We conducted the calculation for the water ecosystem state index (WESI) [
44,
48] to define the environmental impact on the algal communities from the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park studied sites. Therefore,
Table 7 demonstrates that there is little impact on site #3, which was the only site with a WESI value of more than one, whereas all other site communities were affected and had a WESI index below one.
4. Discussion
Since there has not been previous algal floras studies from the ALBNHP waterbodies, in the first investigative stage, we found 88 taxa of algae and cyanobacteia in seven studied sites from this historical park’s waterbodies. This study describes algal community geographical differences. It is not surprising that diatoms predominated, as in some other investigated places in Kentucky, where their species richness has reached from 25 [
8] to 279 [
13] taxa.
Algae indicators are used in the National Aquatic Resource Surveys [
49,
50] as part of the rivers and stream water quality assessment program on the bases of density and abundance values for both soft-bodied algae (non-diatom) and diatoms [
20]. The diatom bioassessment index (DBI) is a multimetric index, developed in Kentucky based on a calculation of Bacillariophyta algae only (diatom richness, Shannon index, PTI, siltation index,
Fragilaria richness, and
Cymbella richness) and cannot help in the assessment of contaminated waters [
20,
51]. However, in many cases, data from diatoms only are not enough for assessing aquatic habitat conditions because they can have a mostly non-diatom algal community, however, algae species’ autecology is likely correlated with nutrient concentrations. Therefore, bioindicator methods, which included a full species list of community in assessment, can help in the multiparametric indication of aquatic habitats.
From the 17 other studies from Kentucky, the vast majority of the algal species are equally divided between diatoms and green algae with both representing 37.7% of the community. Cyanobacteria is represented at 15.4%, Dinoflagellates and Euglenoids are both at 3%, Chrysophytes at 1%, and red algae and Xanthrophytes less than 1% [
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
52,
53]. In this case, we attribute the diversity of algae that we studied in the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park to a separate type of flora with diatoms in the first place, which is not typical for the flat landscape of Kentucky in a warmer climate.
In comparison to our investigation with other algal floras in Kentucky it can be seen (
Figure 15) that the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park algal flora is very different from others previously studied.
When we glance at the lake flora in Eurasia, it can be seen that diatoms prevailed according to the specific saturation of taxonomic divisions [
45,
54,
55]. Therefore, the prevalence of diatom species in the algal floras of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park can be assessed as peculiarities of this protected area, which can be related to the high heterogeneity of the occupied habitats and the long vegetation period with rather high temperature water, similar to the majority of Eurasian floras [
48,
56].
Nevertheless, the algal floras in USA have a long history of investigation and bioindicator methods have never been implemented before for the assessment of water quality in contrast to numerous studies in the Old World [
46]. Results of our analysis of the ecological preferences of algae and cyanobacteria in the diverse habitat of the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park allows us to characterize the water bodies studied as temperate temperature, well oxygenated in sites #1 to #5, but enriched by sulfides in sites #6 and #7. The waters are low-alkaline, with low-to-middle salinity, low-to-middle organically polluted, class 1 to 3 water quality, mostly mesotrophic, inhabited by strongly autotrophic species, which formed biomass in plankton, and on submerged substrates. The results are similar to the same assessment of waters in protected areas in Eurasia [
48,
56].
This comparative floristic study revealed differences between communities with diatom preference that formed clusters in each type of calculation. The algal communities were divided into groups related to species richness and enriched by diatoms. The CCA analysis of species-environment relationships divided the studied sites, with respect to high pH and high temperature water species’ preferences, from which the markers were identified. The marker species in these studied communities are different from those identified in Eurasian waterbodies [
44,
45,
48] and can be used in the monitoring of the ALBNHP aquatic habitats. Nevertheless, the study sites are under natural protection and influence. We found that site #1 was organically polluted more than the other six sites. This waterbody is located at a different park location, which the public has easy access to. This site is also groundwater fed which likely comes from outside the park. In order to assess the intensity of anthropogenic impact on the studied aquatic communities, we calculated the index saprobity S and found that water quality can be classified as good natural waters of class 1–3. But when these results were compared to the nitric-nitrogen saturation in each site using the WESI index calculation, we found that site #3 was the only site that was least impacted, whereas all other site communities were affected, presumably as a result of a small anthropogenic pressure with an influx of nutrients, but not toxicants. This is similar to the estimates in the basin of the agriculturally loaded Songhua River, China [
57].
5. Conclusions
Algae and cyanobacteria from seven sites were studied for the first time in the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park. There were 88 species identified from which diatoms were dominant. The taxa are divided into four different taxonomic divisions, including a few rare species of red and charophyte algae, but this algal study is centered on the diatom community composition from which one can infer acidification and water temperature as a result of statistical assessments.
Nevertheless, an indication of eutrophication and algae productivity with chlorophyll has been documented in USA [
58]. The bioindicator methods of water quality assessment with the use of algae and cyanobacteria species’ autoecology were first used in the USA on aquatic habitats during this study. The bioindicator results demonstrated the algal preferences of benthic and planktonic-benthic life styles in temperate temperature middle-oxygenated waters, low-to-middle enriched by chlorides, mostly well oxygenated, but sometimes saturated by sulfides, low-alkaline, low-to-middle organic enriched, class 1 to 3 water quality, and mostly mesotrophic. The majority of observed algal and cyanobacteria diversity of the park was represented by autotrophic species. This reflects the community high self-purification capacity, which is very important for the protection regime control but could not be revealed with chemical analysis only.
Both the bioindicator and statistical methods demonstrated the importance of biological monitoring of waterbodies in the Abraham Lincoln Birthplace National Historical Park in the face of identified anthropogenic pollution in the initial stage on site A.
Therefore, we conclude that the diversity of diatom algae not only plays a major role in the formation of the algal communities and their uniqueness in the studied protected area but diatom algae can also be a good indicator of environmental assessments and change.