Abstract
The development of hydrogen fueling processes is an essential infrastructure component needed for the adoption of hydrogen-fueled vehicles as a transportation technology. This study provides techno-economic analysis (TEA) for two hydrogen fueling pathways (Case A, Case B), one of which (Case A) does not employ hydrogen liquefaction, while the other one (Case B) does. Both cases consider the same conditions as one another, of gaseous hydrogen inlet availability and gaseous hydrogen outlet dispensing. The TEA analysis carried out is based on data supported from the literature and process flowsheet UNISIM® software simulations. The obtained TEA results indicate that the levelized cost of hydrogen (LCOH) of the gaseous hydrogen Case A is USD 4.20/kg H2, which is lower than the LCOH of the liquefied hydrogen Case B, which is USD 10.14/kg H2. Given the energy equivalence of a gallon of gasoline to kg H2, and the higher efficiencies of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles over gasoline vehicles, the above conditions suggest that Case B fueling (with hydrogen liquefaction) involves high energy consumption and may delay the growth of hydrogen-fuel-based transportation technology, while Case A fueling (no hydrogen liquefaction) will likely become preferrable over both Case B hydrogen fueling and gasoline fueling, thus accelerating the growth of hydrogen-fuel-based transportation technology.
1. Introduction
Hydrogen is an important pathway in driving society’s transition to using low/no-carbon energy systems in power, transport, and industrial applications. The use of hydrogen as fuel for hydrogen-fuel-cell-powered vehicles has a significant number of potential energy and environmental sustainability benefits given the large number of energy resources that can be used for hydrogen production, the higher energy efficiency and spectacular air quality improvement that would be attained by replacing gasoline-powered vehicles with hydrogen-fuel-cell-powered vehicles, the significant electricity cost reductions and energy efficiency improvements attained by replacing electricity-powered vehicles with hydrogen-fuel-cell-powered vehicles due to the much faster fueling times of the latter ones, and the lower overall energy use efficiencies that would arise in using electricity produced from heat-generating energy resources such as natural gas to power electric vehicles. Hydrogen liquefaction and gaseous hydrogen compression to high pressures are often employed to deliver high volumetric densities primarily for storage purposes in several of the aforementioned applications. The California Energy Commission [1] reports around 50 active light-duty vehicle hydrogen refueling stations (HRSs) and 35 more being planned. The inventories of these stations range from as low as just 50 kg to 800 kg. However, the adoption of hydrogen as a fuel for automobiles is somewhat restricted due to the high price of hydrogen at its fueling stations. Numerous techno-economic studies have been conducted to identify an optimal pathway to deliver hydrogen at fueling stations. Ref. [2] presents a techno-economic assessment of on-site refueling stations for different hydrogen sources, such as green ammonia, biogas and water. A 2017 report [3], by Sandia National Laboratories presents a detailed analysis of five station designs for capacities up to 300 kg/day, concluding that the cost of dispensed hydrogen is lower for the case in which hydrogen is delivered as gas to the fueling stations. The reported costs range from USD 30.53/kg to USD 14.26/kg for conventional stations, which receive hydrogen via tube trailers, compared to USD 38.47/kg to USD 20.23/kg for fueling stations with an on-site steam methane reformer (SMR) [3]. Mayer et al. [4] evaluated the costs of HRSs using trucked-in gaseous and liquid hydrogen under various utilization rates and ambient conditions but did not consider the costs of production and liquefaction. Their analysis shows that liquid hydrogen stations can achieve lower costs of EUR 0.18/kg by the year 2050 compared to EUR 0.63–0.76/kg for gaseous stations, particularly for high utilization and large station sizes. Ling et al. [5] suggest that off-site delivery via pipeline is the most economical option when pipeline capacity is fully utilized. These calculations state that liquid hydrogen tanker delivery becomes cost-effective at longer transport distances (300–1000 km), while gaseous tube trailers are viable at shorter ranges (<300 km), resulting in the paper’s conclusion that on-site hydrogen production via electrolysis was found to be economically unfeasible, with a levelized cost exceeding CNY 35/kg, primarily due to high electricity and electrolyzer costs. These conclusions are supported by LCOH computations in which only operating expenditure (OPEX) is annualized while the capital expenditure (CAPEX) is treated as an up-front lump-sum investment. In our study, the novelty of our LCOH computations emerges through the inclusion of both operating expenditure (OPEX) and capital expenditure (CAPEX) that are annualized, as commonly used in techno-economic and infrastructure studies; the execution of extensive simulations of two associated process flowsheets corresponding to no use of hydrogen liquefaction (Case A) and the use of hydrogen liquefaction (Case B) and their fair and objective LCOH comparison; and the reference of hydrogen transportation costs but not their inclusion in the LCOH computations so as to reduce the uncertainty of the obtained LCOH values given the significant dependence of transportation costs on uncertain factors such as the distance of hydrogen production sites to hydrogen fueling sites.
A report by NREL [6] shows a cost comparison for a liquid-delivered HRS versus an on-site HRS for varying station capacities and utilization rates in the year 2030. In some cases, the cost of the liquid-delivered HRS is lower than the on-site gas-delivered HRS. It must be noted that in that report, the costs of liquefaction (USD 3.40/kg) and hydrogen production via SMR (USD 1.50/kg) are considered for plant capacities of 100 tpd, while the HRS capacities range from 2 tpd to 18 tpd. Our study introduces a novel techno-economic analysis that considers the overall hydrogen fueling process fed by gaseous hydrogen delivered at conditions and costs typically associated with SMR-generated hydrogen, and delivering gaseous hydrogen at conditions typically delivered to high-pressure gaseous-hydrogen-powered vehicles. This approach also avoids uncertainties associated with transportation costs for delivering hydrogen to the hydrogen fueling process, and enables an accurate estimation of early-stage hydrogen infrastructure deployment for transportation applications.
Hydrogen liquefaction is highly energy intensive, with specific energy consumption (SEC) values typically ranging from 10 to 15 kWh/kg LH2 for existing liquefaction plants [7]. This is significantly above the thermodynamic minimum of approximately 2.33 kWh/kg, identified in our Supplementary Information document for a hydrogen feed entering the liquefier at 300 K and 20 bar. The Specific Liquefaction Cost (SLC) is affected by both capital-intensive refrigeration cycles and operational efficiencies. Process-level technoeconomic analysis requires detailed thermodynamic modeling and simulation tools capable of capturing the behavior of these complex processes. In practical liquefaction plants, ortho-to-para conversion (OPC) is an important transformation, related to exothermic heat release and boil-off losses during liquefaction, that is carried out using heat exchangers filled with catalysts. Such specialized types of equipment are typically unavailable in commercial simulation software, and thus only a few modeling studies typically describe this transformation using thermodynamically consistent simulation elements. Therefore, it is desirable that simulations adopt alternative OPC modeling techniques capable of closely replicating real plant behavior. In our study, we captured OPC within a heat exchanger by representing the process as a two heat exchanger and two reactor sequence, which to our knowledge is a modeling strategy carried out for the first time in UNISIM®, version R510, and similar to a modelling strategy used in Aspen HYSYS®, version 15 [8]. This representation enables a more accurate quantification of the exothermic OPC heat effects and their influence on cooling capacity and downstream liquefaction stages. OPC has also been considered in other liquefier simulation and cost studies, focusing on the SEC and SLC of the respective liquefiers [9,10,11], implemented in UNISIM® and supported by spreadsheet computations carried out in additional software.
The H2 liquefaction simulation workflow, as adopted in this study, is based on a process flowsheet modeled after the Linde H2 liquefaction plant in Leuna, Germany, incorporating realistic flow conditions, equipment configurations, and thermal integration strategies. Through this approach, we perform a rigorous evaluation of SEC and SLC within an industrially relevant design. This combination of plant-referenced modeling and catalytic conversion inside UNISIM® represents a valuable contribution to the current literature on hydrogen liquefaction system design.
2. Methodology
This study investigates and compares two distinct hydrogen fueling strategies that are provided with hydrogen produced via an SMR process at 5 tons per day, 20 bar and 300 K. Fueling of light-duty hydrogen-powered cars is considered. These cars typically have a 700 bar fuel tank holding 5 kg of hydrogen fuel in a gaseous state [12]. The simulations are performed in UNISIM® to accurately model the thermodynamics, mass and energy balance calculations. The simulation results are used to size key equipment, which then forms the basis for estimating CAPEX and OPEX in the techno-economic analysis.
2.1. Case Definitions
This work focuses on the two hydrogen fueling configurations (Case A, Case B) shown in Figure 1, one of which (Case A) does not employ H2 liquefaction while the other one (Case B) does. Both cases consider the same inlet and outlet conditions as one another, with an SMR generated gaseous hydrogen inlet and a highly compressed gaseous hydrogen outlet dispensed to hydrogen-powered vehicles.
Figure 1.
Block flow diagrams of Case A and Case B refueling processes.
2.1.1. Case A: H2 Refueling with SMR-Generated H2 and 700 Bar H2 Gas Dispensing
In the gaseous configuration, hydrogen produced via an SMR process is provided at 5 tons per day, 20 bar and 300 K. It is then first compressed to 250 bar, directed to a storage facility designed to hold one day’s production, subsequently compressed to 900 bar, and stored in a cascade system that provides about one hour of storage capacity. Prior to vehicle fill-up, the hydrogen is then pre-cooled to −40 °C in a refrigeration unit, so that the safety and efficiency fill-up requirements of the SAE J2601 protocol [13,14] are met.
2.1.2. Case B: H2 Refueling with SMR-Generated H2, H2 Liquefaction, and 700 Bar H2 Gas Dispensing
In the liquid configuration, hydrogen is also produced via an SMR process operating at 5 tons per day, with a hydrogen product at 20 bar and 300 K. It is then sent to a liquefaction unit, where it is converted to liquid hydrogen at 20 K and 1.3 bar, with ortho-hydrogen and para-hydrogen mole fractions equal to 0.01 and 0.99, respectively. The liquefied hydrogen is stored in a cryogenic liquid storage tank designed to hold one day’s production, then pressurized to 900 bar using a cryogenic pump, and subsequently evaporated and superheated to −40 °C, briefly stored in a high-pressure cascade storage system to smooth out transient fluctuations during dispensing, and dispensed without a need for pre-cooling because of the aforementioned superheating to −40 °C.
The creation of liquid hydrogen (Case B) incorporates many inefficient steps compared to avoidance of liquefaction (Case A). Nevertheless, some Case B steps are more efficient than Case A steps, thus necessitating a detailed TEA to be carried out. As shown in Case B, the liquefaction of hydrogen requires significant use of cryogenic, compression and turbine processes, which, as shown in Case A, are not used at all in the gaseous hydrogen configuration. On the other hand, as also discussed in Krishna et al. [15], reaching the –40 °C, 900 bar gaseous hydrogen state for dispensing is accomplished without any pre-cooling if liquid hydrogen is available (Case B), while precooling is required if liquid hydrogen is not available (Case A).
3. Process Description
3.1. Case A
The detailed configuration for Case A is simulated on a steady-state basis in UNISIM®, as shown in Figure 2 (with blue and red arrows indicating material and energy flows respectively in all UNISIM® flowsheets). Given the flowsheet’s temperature ranges, normal hydrogen molar composition (75% ortho, 25% para) and the Peng–Robinson fluid package are used for the UNISIM® simulations. The feed from the SMR is first compressed to 250 bar using a two-stage compressor (K-100 and K-101) with an intercooling temperature of 300 K. The hydrogen at 250 bar is then stored in tube trailers serving as bulk low-pressure storage (V-100), sized to accommodate one day’s hydrogen demand. The vessels V-101, V-102, and V-103 represent the low-pressure (LP), medium-pressure (MP) and high-pressure (HP) storage vessels of the cascade system, whose pressure levels, shown in Table 1, are within ranges consistent with the literature [16]. Compressors K-102, K-103 and K-104, with equal compression ratios, are used to compress to the respective LP, MP and HP levels of storage pressure. A storage temperature of 300 K is achieved for the three levels using the inter-coolers E-102, E-103 and E-104. The heat exchangers E-105, E-106, E-107 are used to cool down to the final dispensing temperature of −40 °C.
Figure 2.
Case A UNISIM® simulation: H2 refueling with SMR-generated H2 and 700 bar H2 gas dispensing.
Table 1.
Inputs for simulation of Case A.
Considering hydrogen-fueled vehicles have low hydrogen pressure in their storage tank, the hydrogen dispensed to them initially flows from the LP cascade level until the vehicle tank’s pressure reaches the LP cascade level. The system then automatically transitions to the MP cascade level, and finally to the HP cascade level, fully fueling the vehicle. The hydrogen mass flow splits at the TEE-100 and TEE-101 T-sections are identified as 54.20% and 45.80% (Refer Supplementary Materials), respectively, for the LP and MP cascade storage levels.
Table 1 summarizes some of the most important inputs for the simulation.
3.2. Case B
The configuration for Case B, shown in Figure 3, employs a modular approach to illustrate the hydrogen fueling pathway designed to liquefy and dispense hydrogen with integrated unit operations, beginning with the SMR-derived hydrogen inlet and terminating with 700 bar gaseous hydrogen being dispensed to the vehicle. The liquefaction subsystem is encapsulated as a module, whose detailed flowsheet is described in detail in the “Hydrogen Liquefaction” section.
Figure 3.
Case B UNISIM® simulation: H2 refueling with SMR-generated H2, H2 liquefaction, and 700 bar H2 gas dispensing.
SMR-derived hydrogen is directed as a gaseous stream into the liquefier module, where it undergoes multistage cooling and ortho-to-para conversion to produce liquid hydrogen (LH2) at cryogenic conditions (~20 K and 1.3 bar). The liquefaction block also receives liquid nitrogen as a refrigerant stream, along with cooling water and electrical energy, representing utility consumption for refrigeration and compression. Gaseous nitrogen and cooling water are the utility outlets of the liquefaction process.
The liquid hydrogen (LH2) product from the liquefier is collected in a cryogenic storage tank (V-100) that provides bulk storage at low pressure. From there, LH2 is pumped to a high pressure of 850 bar using a cryogenic pump (P-100). The pressurized stream then enters an evaporator unit (E-100), where it is vaporized into 900 bar, −40 °C, high-pressure gaseous hydrogen (GH2) via near-ambient temperature-based heat exchange.
The high-pressure GH2 is then routed to V-101, a high-pressure cascade storage vessel that serves as a short-term buffer (typically providing 1 h capacity). Finally, the high-pressure GH2 is dispensed to the vehicle through a dispenser system. This integrated design enables gaseous hydrogen high-pressure fueling without the need for intermediate compression or pre-cooling equipment as in Case A.
Module: Hydrogen Liquefaction
Honeywell’s UNISIM® is used to model the entire liquefaction system. The employed flowsheet design emulates Linde’s hydrogen liquefaction plant in Leuna, Germany, as shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4.
Process flowsheet of Linde’s hydrogen liquefaction plant in Leuna, Germany [7].
The process involves 100% pure hydrogen gas at 20 bar and 300 K entering the liquefaction plant and being pre-cooled to 80 K using liquid nitrogen through the heat exchangers (LNG-100 and LNG-101). The pre-cooled hydrogen further undergoes cryogenic cooling from 80 K to 23 K via the heat exchangers (LNG-101 to LNG-107) before it is fed to the Joule–Thompson valve for expansion. In actual practice, the ortho-to-para conversion occurs by incorporating catalysts in the above heat exchangers. In this study, ortho-to-para conversion reactors are incorporated in the flowsheet, similar to other literature studies [8]. Finally, the hydrogen gas exiting the heat exchanger LNG-107 is expanded using a Joule–Thompson valve (VLV-100) to deliver a liquid–vapor hydrogen mixture at a pressure of 1.3 bar, temperature of −252.10 °C, and ortho-hydrogen and para-hydrogen mole fractions equal to 0.01 and 0.99, respectively. A separator vessel (V-100) is then used to carry out the liquid–vapor hydrogen separation after expansion. The gaseous hydrogen resulting from the Joule–Thomson expansion is recycled back through an ejector (Ejector-100), where it mixes with the high-pressure hydrogen feed gas.
The refrigeration cycle, which carries out the aforementioned cryogenic cooling of hydrogen from 80 K to 23 K via the heat exchangers (LNG-101 to LNG-107), uses normal hydrogen as the working fluid. The refrigeration cycle starts with hydrogen flowing through a series of compressors (K-100 and K-101) and intercoolers (E-100 and E-101) to pressurize it up to 25 bar and cool it down to 300 K. The resulting 25 bar hydrogen is then cooled to below 80 K using liquid nitrogen. A part of the resulting 80 K hydrogen is then split (TEE-100) into two portions. The first portion is expanded through the turbines (K-102, K-103 and K-104), which operate between 25 bar and 3 bar pressure, and is then fed to the heat exchangers and recycled back to the compressor (K-101). The second portion is expanded through the Joule–Thompson valve (VLV-101) to 1 bar to achieve a temperature below 23 K, and is then passed through heat exchangers as a cooling utility and recycled back to the compressor (K-100). The simulation flowsheet is shown in Figure 5.
Figure 5.
UNISIM® flowsheet of hydrogen liquefier.
Some key parameters used in the process simulation of the liquefier in Case B are listed in Table 2.
Table 2.
Process simulation parameters for the liquefaction flowsheet.
The ortho-to-para reaction conversion is determined on the basis of equilibrium hydrogen data, and is thus calculated at the exit temperature of the heat exchanger, as shown in Table 3., using data published by the Brookhaven National Laboratory [18], as shown in Table 4. The reaction temperature is the exit temperature of the respective heat exchanger, as in practice the reaction occurs within the heat exchangers.
Table 3.
Conversion of ortho-hydrogen across the reactors.
Table 4.
Ortho-H2–para-H2 equilibrium composition [18].
4. Techno-Economic Analysis
4.1. Hydrogen Production
For both the Case A and Case B scenarios, the SMR-derived hydrogen inlet is identical. Thus, the cost of acquiring the raw material hydrogen is identical. Almost 95% of the USA’s hydrogen production is from natural gas via the SMR process, and 4% is produced by the gasification of coal [19]. The cost of producing hydrogen via SMR ranges from USD 2 to USD 3/kg H2 [15]. An average price of USD 2.50/kg H2 is assumed in our study for all scenarios. The inlet conditions of the hydrogen fueling processes in this study are assumed to be at a pressure of 20 bar and a temperature of 300 K, which are the typical outlet conditions of an SMR plant [20].
4.2. Liquefaction Plant
The cost steps given by [21] are used to perform financial analysis of a hydrogen liquefaction plant. Guthrie’s method is used to evaluate the cost of the liquefaction plant and hence the levelized cost of hydrogen (LCOH) in units of . As per the methodology, the cost of each piece of equipment is determined, and these costs are added to obtain the total cost of the process. The equipment purchase cost Ep (USD) is calculated using the equation below:
The nature of the normalized capacity parameters and the values of the cost dimensionless constants for the liquefaction plant equipment components are presented in Table 5.
Table 5.
Values of cost dimensionless constants and the nature of normalized capacity parameters of major hydrogen liquefaction equipment [21].
Based on the purchase cost, the cost of bare module CBM (USD) is calculated as:
The bare module cost factor (FBM) is a function of the pressure factor (FP) and material factor (FM) and is defined as follows. The corresponding constants are listed in Table 6.
Table 6.
Values of constants and factors related to the bare module factor [21].
The cost constants for various pieces of equipment in the above calculations were based on information from equipment manufacturers in 2001. Thus, the present cost of equipment is determined using the average chemical engineering plant cost index (CEPCI) of the target year. The most recent CEPCI value, found online, was reported to be 798.8 as of June 2024 and 394.3 in the year 2001 [22]. For heat exchangers, the ortho-to-para catalyst cost is assumed to be 15% of the heat exchanger cost [17].
The total capital expenditure (CAPEX) is assumed to be 18% of the cost of major equipment, including the cost of installation and equipment such as pipes, valves, etc.
The operating expense (OPEX) for the plant includes the cost of utilities (electricity, cooling water, liquid nitrogen), hydrogen feed cost, and labor and maintenance costs.
The key cost assumptions to determine the operating expense are listed in Table 7.
Table 7.
Key cost assumptions for the operating expense.
The detailed hydrogen fueling process descriptions provided in this work enable the creation of models that can help predict possible fueling process failures, thus reducing the cost ratio of unplanned maintenance to planned maintenance and keeping the overall maintenance cost within 2% of the CAPEX, as indicated in Table 7.
To assess performance of the plant, the levelized annual cost (LAC) and the LCOH are calculated as follows:
where , with being the mass of hydrogen acquired and dispensed per year, being the mass of hydrogen acquired and dispensed per day, and being the hydrogen fueling process availability in hours per year (refer to Supplementary Materials).
The frequency with which compounding occurs is denoted by , since compounding occurs on an annual basis . The plant lifetime is assumed to be 20 years, and the annual interest rate (refer to Supplementary Materials).
The specific energy consumption (SEC) of the hydrogen liquefaction cycle, as per Figure 5, is defined as the net electrical energy consumed per unit mass of liquefied hydrogen.
The liquefaction process employs three turbines and two compressors. From an energy consumption viewpoint, the power generated by the turbine is denoted as , while the power consumed by the compressor is denoted as .Then, the SEC is equal to:
While computing the electricity costs, an electrical efficiency of 95% is considered to account for losses across the mechanically rotating components. During the steady-state operation considered in this study, motorized equipment is typically at full load operating conditions, for which the 95% high-efficiency level is used based on industrial experience and a literature reference [9]. Equipment operating under partial-load conditions may experience lower efficiencies, although this is not our focus, as we consider steady-state operation.
4.3. Refueling Process Equipment
Cost estimates of refueling components are calculated using the NETL-provided [26] equipment cost scaling equation listed below:
Thus, the scaled parameters (SPs) are quantified using the reference costs (RCs) and reference parameters (RPs) available for the refueling components. The reference costs, parameters and scaling factors are taken from (1) the HDSAM tool developed by Argonne National Laboratory [27]; (2) the Nexant report published in collaboration with Air Liquide, Chevron Technology Venture, Gas Technology Institute, NREL, Tiax and ANL [28]; and (3) techno-economic studies carried out by Krishna Reddi and team [15,29]. The associated costs and parameters are listed in Table 8.
Table 8.
Reference costs and parameters for cost estimation.
Elgowainy et al. [31] derived equations to calculate the energy intensity (in units of kWh/kg-H2) of the pre-cooling unit and cost functions to estimate the unit cost for an air-cooled refrigerator and aluminum thermal block. These equations, listed below, are used to estimate the electricity costs and capital costs associated with refrigeration.
The cost of the aluminum thermal block is calculated using the equation below:
The required mass of the aluminum block is calculated as:
To determine the number of dispensers required for dispensing hydrogen, we make the following assumptions:
- Hydrogen dispensed per light duty vehicle : 5.
- The maximum allowable hydrogen flow rate is 60 g/s to balance speed and safety [14]. This corresponds to a minimum fueling time per vehicle approximately equal to about 2 min. An additional vehicle lingering time of 3 min is considered.
- Fueling time per vehicle, : 5 min.
- Surge in demand, : 0.50.
- Availability of dispenser, : 0.60.
The CAPEX for the fueling process is calculated as the sum of costs for all fueling-related equipment, multiplied by a factor of 1.23, which accounts for the indirect (installation, piping, engineering supervision, etc.) costs associated with each piece of equipment [28]. On the other hand, OPEX comprises the costs of hydrogen feed, electricity, cooling water, labor, operation and maintenance, insurance, property taxes, licenses, permits and overhead. The quantification of these OPEX costs is carried out using the OPEX component descriptions and the annualized percentages of associated capital investments associated with each OPEX component, shown in Table 9. An electrical/mechanical efficiency of 95% is considered for pumps and compressors to account for motor and drive losses [9]. A temperature rise of 10 K is permitted for cooling water used as a cold utility.
Table 9.
Operation and maintenance cost breakdown for fueling process components.
5. Results and Discussion
The sizing of equipment and economic calculations are executed based on the outputs of our simulation model for both cases. The stream tables can be referenced from the Supplementary information provided.
5.1. Equipment Sizing and Utility Requirements
The results of the major equipment and energy requirements obtained from the simulations are listed in Table 10.
Table 10.
Equipment size and utility requirements of fueling process components.
The values of the calculated capacity parameter (A) and the CAPEX breakdown in terms of values of the calculated cost of equipment in the liquefaction plant are shown in Table 11. The calculation steps are as described in the “Liquefaction Plant” section. In a similar fashion, a breakdown of the values of operating expenses is listed in Table 12.
Table 11.
CAPEX breakdown for the liquefaction plant.
Table 12.
OPEX breakdown for the liquefaction plant.
The calculated SEC of the simulated flowsheet is 9.72 kWh/kg LH2, and the SLC is USD 7.09/kg LH2. The reported SEC for the Linde Luena liquefier is 11.9 kWh/kg [7]. Cardella and team [9] reported an SEC of 9.9 kWh/kg LH2 for the classical hydrogen Claude cycle using liquid nitrogen for pre-cooling using the process conditions of the Linde Leuna plant.
5.2. Economic Comparison of Case A vs. Case B
Figure 6 and Figure 7 show the breakdown of the uninstalled CAPEX. The major cost differences for just the fueling-related equipment in CAPEX for both cases arise mainly from the compressor costs and the bulk storage of the gaseous hydrogen. The cost of storing liquid hydrogen seems economical due to the higher density of liquid hydrogen, resulting in smaller storage requirements compared to its gaseous state. However, Case B has a higher CAPEX because of the hydrogen liquefier plant.
Figure 6.
CAPEX breakdown for Case A.
Figure 7.
CAPEX breakdown for Case B.
Figure 8 and Figure 9 represent the operating expenses for both cases. The cost of the SMR-derived gaseous H2 feed is USD 3.42 million per year for both cases. Case B has an additional liquefaction cost of USD 9.70 million per year. Thus, the liquefaction cost is the major differentiating factor in the total OPEX: Case A, USD 4.5 million per year vs. Case B, USD 13.4 million per year.
Figure 8.
OPEX breakdown for Case A.
Figure 9.
OPEX breakdown for Case B.
Figure 10 illustrates the comparison of the LCOH for the two scenarios evaluated in this study. In Case A, the LCOH amounts to USD 4.20 , which includes USD 2.50 for hydrogen production and USD 1.70 associated with the fueling process, such as compression, storage and dispensing. Case B, which includes liquefaction, shows a higher total cost of USD 10.14 . Although the production cost remains the same, at USD 2.50 , the fueling process cost increases to USD 7.64 due to the additional capital and operating costs associated with the H2 liquefaction step in the process.
Figure 10.
Comparison of LCOH: Case A vs. Case B.
In two recent snapshots (in 2025 and 2026), shown in Figure 11 and Figure 12, of hydrogen prices at a fueling station in Los Angeles, it is shown that the price in 2025 was and in 2026 it declined to . The price differences between our study’s hydrogen cost estimates and these actual hydrogen retail prices at existing HRSs can be attributed to factors such as low station utilization rates, smaller station capacities and additional logistics-related issues. Current retail prices may remain high to potentially enable the investment of significant hydrogen-fueling-associated profits in the expansion of hydrogen-related infrastructure development efforts. Based on the aforementioned cost estimates identified in this work, it is clear that there is opportunity for H2 fuel price reduction while maintaining excellent HRS profitability.
Figure 11.
A 2025 snapshot of the H2 fueling price at a fueling station in Los Angeles.
Figure 12.
A 2026 snapshot of the H2 fueling price at a fueling station in Los Angeles.
6. Conclusions
The study encompasses simulations and techno-economic evaluations for two distinct hydrogen refueling pathways, as discussed earlier. The liquefaction simulation achieved an SEC of 9.72 kWh/kg LH2, which aligns with the Linde Leuna plant’s SEC, as reported in the literature.
The obtained results highlight the economic disparities between the two hydrogen fueling configurations examined in this study. Case A has a lower CAPEX and significantly lower OPEX than Case B. The highest cost contributors to the Case A CAPEX are the bulk gaseous storage, the four employed gas compressors, associated inter-coolers, and the final dispensing pre-cooling unit. The highest cost contributors to the Case B CAPEX are the liquefying process (including compressors, turbines and heat exchangers), the cryogenic pump and the cryogenic liquid storage tank. The highest cost contributors to the Case A OPEX are the SMR feed cost and the compressor-related electricity cost. The highest cost contributors to the Case B OPEX are the SMR feed cost and the liquefaction process operating cost (which includes compressor-related electricity and cryogenic utility costs). The presented OPEX analysis clearly indicates that hydrogen liquefaction is the major cost driving factor, contributing USD 7.09/kg to the overall cost of hydrogen dispensed to vehicles for Case B. Given the significant level of uncertainty regarding the location of hydrogen production and dispensing processes, hydrogen transportation costs are not included in this techno-economic analysis. Case A presents hydrogen costs that are relatively competitive with gasoline prices, thus making hydrogen-fueled vehicles an attractive transportation alternative. Hence, investing further in hydrogen liquefaction could be economically imprudent for the economic efficiency and growth of hydrogen use as fuel.
While hydrogen transportation costs for delivering hydrogen to the hydrogen fueling process are not negligible in determining the LCOH, we have chosen to exclude them from the scope of our study in order to present an impartial comparison between the gaseous (Case A) and liquid (Case B) fueling process scenarios. Transportation depends on several parameters—such as distance, mode of transportation (tube trailer, liquid tanker, or pipeline), capacity utilization and infrastructure availability—that are highly scenario dependent and would introduce large uncertainties into a comparative framework. The pipeline mode cost is significantly lower than the cost of both other modes at significant capacity utilization rates. As discussed by Ling Wu et al. [5] and listed in Table 13, the dependence of the annualized cost of hydrogen transportation on distance, which is just one of the aforementioned parameters, varies significantly for the other two modes. As can be seen in Table 13, the tube trailer mode cost is lower than the liquid tanker mode cost at 50 km, and higher at 1000 km. At the current currency equivalence of CNY 1 to about USD 0.14 [32], the tube trailer mode costs are USD 0.5474/kg at 50 km and USD 3.5448/kg at 1000 km, while the liquid tanker mode costs are USD 1.1942/kg at 50 km and USD 1.4742/kg at 1000 km. The aforementioned cost ranges suggest that the transportation of gaseous hydrogen vs. that of liquid hydrogen has a lower cost at small distances and higher cost at high distances, and that both transportation modes always involve less than half the hydrogen liquefaction operating cost of USD 7.09/kg. The above conditions justify the scope of our TEA Case A, B studies, which do not incorporate transportation costs, since they would not affect the conclusions that the hydrogen liquefaction approach (Case B) would be economically imprudent for the economic efficiency and growth of hydrogen fuel transportation, and that the gaseous hydrogen approach (Case A) would be economically competitive with gasoline-fueled transportation, thus making hydrogen-fueled vehicles an attractive transportation alternative.
Table 13.
Annualized cost of hydrogen transportation at different distances [5,12].
Supplementary Materials
The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https://www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/hydrogen7020082/s1, Figure S1: Blackbox for hydrogen liquefaction; Figure S2: Cascade dispensing flow diagram; Table S1: Complete cost breakdown of Case A; Table S2: Complete cost breakdown of Case B; Table S3: Process simulation stream data for Case A; Table S4: Process simulation stream data for Case B; Table S5: Process simulation stream data for hydrogen liquefaction; Table S6: Density of hydrogen at cascade storage pressure levels.
Author Contributions
S.S.B.: Investigation, Software, Calculations, Writing—Original Draft; I.V.M.: Investigation, Software, Writing—Review and Editing; V.I.M.: Conceptualization, Validation, Writing—Original Draft, Review and Editing, Supervision. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Data Availability Statement
The data used to carry out the presented technoeconomic analysis are provided in the manuscript and in the Supplementary Material. The original contributions presented in this study are included in the Supplementary Materials. Further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.
Conflicts of Interest
Ioannis Manousiouthakis is simply the founder of Hydrogen Engineering Research Company, LLC. All the authors declare no conflicts of interest.
References
- California Energy Commission. Hydrogen Refueling Stations in California. 2025. Available online: https://www.energy.ca.gov/zevstats (accessed on 30 April 2025).
- Perna, A.; Minutillo, M.; Micco, S.D.; Jannelli, E. Design and Costs Analysis of Hydrogen Refuelling Stations Based on Different Hydrogen Sources and Plant Configurations. Energies 2022, 15, 541. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Hecht, E.S.; Pratt, J. Comparison of Conventional vs. Modular Hydrogen Refueling Stations, and On-Site Production vs. Delivery; Sandia National Laboratories: Albuquerque, NM, USA, 2017.
- Mayer, T.; Semmel, M.; Guerrero Morales, M.A.; Schmidt, K.M.; Bauer, A.; Wind, J. Techno-economic evaluation of hydrogen refueling stations with liquid or gaseous stored hydrogen. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2019, 44, 25809–25833. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Wu, L.; Zhu, Z.; Feng, Y.; Wenyi, T. Economic analysis of hydrogen refueling station considering different operation modes. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2024, 52, 1577–1591. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Bracci, J.; Koleva, M.; Chung, M. Levelized Cost of Dispensed Hydrogen for Heavy-Duty Vehicles; National Renewable Energy Laboratory: Golden, CO, USA, 2024.
- Al Ghafri, S.Z.; Munro, S.; Cardella, U.; Funke, T.; Notardonato, W.; Trusler, J.P.M.; Leachman, J.; Span, R.; Kamiya, S.; Pearce, G.; et al. Hydrogen liquefaction: A review of the fundamental physics, engineering practice and future opportunities. Energy Environ. Sci. 2022, 15, 2690–2731. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Son, H.; Yu, T.; Hwang, J.; Lim, Y. Simulation methodology for hydrogen liquefaction. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2022, 47, 25662–25678. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cardella, U.; Decker, L.; Sundberg, J.; Klein, H. Process optimization for large-scale hydrogen liquefaction. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2017, 42, 12339–12354. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cardella, U.F. Large-scale hydrogen liquefaction under the aspect of economic viability. 2018. Available online: https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bvb:91-diss-20181130-1442078-1-3 (accessed on 1 March 2025).
- Cardella, U.; Decker, L.; Klein, H. Economically viable large-scale hydrogen liquefaction. In Proceedings of the IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, Kerala, India, 5–8 June 2016. [Google Scholar]
- Reddi, K.; Mintz, M.; Elgowainy, A.; Sutherland, E. Building a hydrogen infrastructure in the United States. In Compendium of Hydrogen Energy, Vols. Volume 4: Hydrogen Use, Safety and the Hydrogen Economy; Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy: Cambridge, UK, 2016; pp. 293–319. [Google Scholar]
- SOCIETY OF AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERS (SAE). Fueling Protocols for Light Duty Gaseous Hydrogen (J2601_201407); SAE International: Warrendale, PA, USA, 2014. [Google Scholar]
- SOCIETY OF AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERS (SAE). Fueling Protocols for Light Duty Gaseous Hydrogen Surface Vehicles (J2601_202005); SAE International: Warrendale, PA, USA, 2020. [Google Scholar]
- Reddi, K.; Elgowainy, A.; Rustagi, N.; Gupta, E. Impact of hydrogen refueling configurations and market parameters on the refueling cost of hydrogen. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2017, 42, 21855–21865. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Rothuizen, E.; Rokni, M. Optimization of the overall energy consumption in cascade fueling stations for hydrogen vehicles. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2014, 39, 582–592. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Son, H.; Austbø, B.; Gundersen, T.; Hwang, J.; Lim, Y. Economic Analysis of a Hydrogen Liquefaction Process Based on Techno-Economic and Energy Optimization. Comput. Aided Chem. Eng. 2022, 49, 1069–1074. [Google Scholar]
- Jensen, J.E.; Tuttle, W.A.; Stewart, R.B.; Brechna, H.; Prodell, A.G. Brookhaven National Laboratory Selected Cryogenic Data Notebook; Sections 1–9; 1980; Volume 1. Available online: https://ntrl.ntis.gov/NTRL/dashboard/searchResults/titleDetail/DE87002799.xhtml (accessed on 11 June 2025).
- Ryan, L. Hydrogen Production: Overview and Issues for Congress; Congressional Research Service: Washington, DC, USA, 2024.
- Connelly, E.; Penev, M.; Elgowainy, A.; Hunter, C. DOE Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Program Record. 9 September 2019. Available online: https://www.hydrogen.energy.gov/docs/hydrogenprogramlibraries/pdfs/19001_hydrogen_liquefaction_costs.pdf?sfvrsn=378c2204_1 (accessed on 11 June 2025).
- Sleiti, A.K.; Al-Ammari, W.A. Design and Analysis of Liquid Hydrogen Technologies Liquefaction, Storage, and Distribution; Elsevier: Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2024. [Google Scholar]
- Maxwell, C. Financial Analysis Cost Indices, Towering Skills. 3 March 2025. Available online: https://toweringskills.com/financial-analysis/cost-indices/ (accessed on 14 April 2025).
- Rutherford; Titan, Liquid Nitrogen Price in the USA, Rutherford & Titan. Available online: https://www.rutherfordtitan.com/liquid-nitrogen-generators/liquid-nitrogen-price-usa/ (accessed on 16 May 2025).
- Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. Schedule C—Commercial, Industrial, and Governmental Customers and Temporary Construction. Available online: https://www.ladwp.com/account/customer-service/water-rates/schedule-c-commercial-industrial-governmental (accessed on 18 April 2025).
- U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). U.S. Federal Statistical System. Available online: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.php?t=epmt_5_6_a (accessed on 15 April 2025).
- Turner, M.; Samaei, A.T.; National Energy Technology Laboratory. Quality Guidelines for Energy System Studies; Capital Cost Scaling Methodology; Revision3 Reports and Prior; NETL-PUB-22537; U.S. Department of Energy: Washington, DC, USA, 2019.
- Elgowainy, A.; Reddi, K. Hydrogen Delivery Scenario Analysis Model (HDSAM) V5.0; Argonne National Laboratory: Argonne, IL, USA, 2024.
- Nexant. Hydrogen Delivery Infrastructure Options Analysis. DOE Award Number: DE-FG36-05GO15032; U.S. Department of Energy: Washington, DC, USA, 2008.
- Ku, A.Y.; Reddi, K.; Elgowainy, A.; McRobie, J.; Li, J. Liquid pump-enabled hydrogen refueling system for medium and heavy duty fuel cell vehicles: Station design and technoeconomic assessment. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2022, 47, 25486–25498. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Houchins, C.; James, B.; Acevedo, Y. Hydrogen Storage Cost Analysis 2021 Annual Merit Review and Peer Evaluation Meeting Project ID: ST100 Award No. DE-EE0007601; DOE Hydrogen Program, 2021, Annual Merit Review and Peer Evaluation Meeting; Strategic Analysis Inc.: Arlington, VA, USA, 2021. [Google Scholar]
- Elgowainy, A.; Reddi, K.; Lee, D.-Y.; Rustagi, N. Techno-economic and thermodynamic analysis of pre-cooling systems at gaseous hydrogen refueling stations. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2017, 42, 29067–29079. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- CNY to USD Chart. Available online: https://www.xe.com/en-us/currencyconverter/convert/?Amount=1&From=CNY&To=USD (accessed on 11 June 2025).
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.











