5.1. Maximum Payload Capacity and System Limitations
The levitation capability of the proposed demonstrator was evaluated through incremental payload testing. The baseline system, with a total mass of approximately 35 kg, achieved stable levitation prior to the addition of external loads.
External payloads were introduced in discrete increments of 10 kg (10, 20, 30, and 40 kg), followed by a final 7.5 kg increment near the operational limit, corresponding to a maximum external payload of 47.5 kg. Considering the baseline demonstrator mass of approximately 35 kg, the total system mass reached approximately 82.5 kg under the final loading condition prior to the loss of levitation. The payload additions were applied sequentially during the experiment, and the corresponding loading stages can be identified from the transient air-gap response shown in
Figure 11. As the applied mass increased, a progressive reduction in the levitation air gap was observed, indicating the increasing electromagnetic force demand required to balance the system weight. Despite this reduction in air gap, stable levitation was maintained throughout all intermediate loading stages.
The transient air-gap response during the loading sequence is presented in
Figure 11. A clear asymmetry between the sensor measurements is observed, where sensors 2 and 3 consistently report lower air-gap values compared to sensors 1 and 4. This behavior indicates a non-uniform load distribution caused by an offset in the center of gravity, resulting in an inclined levitation posture. As a result, disks 2 and 3 were subjected to a higher effective load compared to disks 1 and 4, leading to increased torque demand and earlier saturation of the corresponding drive units.
The critical operating limit was reached at approximately 50 s, upon the addition of the final 7.5 kg payload. At this point, the motors associated with disks 2 and 3 reached their effective torque and current limits, leading to actuator saturation and triggering the protection mechanisms of the motor drivers. Following this event, a rapid decrease in air-gap values was recorded for sensors 2 and 3, while sensors 1 and 4 exhibited a temporary increase due to load redistribution. Subsequently, the system lost levitation and descended onto the predefined mechanical spacers.
Although direct electrical current and voltage telemetry were not recorded during the experiments, the observed behavior is consistent with the expected increase in current demand due to elevated magnetic drag forces at reduced air gaps. Therefore, the electrical power characteristics of the system were evaluated primarily through theoretical power analysis and experimentally observed actuator saturation behavior under increasing payload conditions. This behavior demonstrates that the maximum payload capacity of the system is not limited by the fundamental electrodynamic levitation mechanism, but rather by the available actuation power and current limits of the onboard drive system. In this context, the observed stall condition represents a system-level operational boundary. This finding highlights a key distinction between externally powered laboratory setups and fully self-contained EDS systems, where power delivery and actuator constraints become the dominant factors governing system performance.
5.2. Levitation Stability and Air-Gap Deviation Characteristics
The measured steady-state response of the levitation system was analyzed at five predefined reference air-gap conditions, as listed in
Table 5. For each operating point, the system was allowed to reach equilibrium, and air-gap measurements were recorded over a fixed sampling window.
The measured air-gap values at each reference condition are compared against their corresponding targets in
Figure 12. The experimental results demonstrate a close agreement between the commanded and achieved air-gap values, indicating the consistency of the open-loop operating strategy.
The statistical characteristics of the steady-state air-gap measurements are summarized in
Table 6. For all reference conditions, the system exhibited low standard deviation values, indicating a stable levitation response with minimal fluctuation around the equilibrium position.
Across all operating conditions, the deviation of the air gap remained within a narrow band of approximately ±0.1 mm. This level of stability is significantly below the predefined acceptable limit of ±0.5 mm, indicating a robust steady-state response.
The observed deviations are primarily attributed to sensor noise, vibrations induced by the rotating disks, and minor structural compliance within the system. Accordingly, the measured air-gap fluctuations are interpreted as secondary mechanical and measurement-related effects rather than indicators of inherent electromagnetic instability.
5.3. Engineering Insights and System-Level Implications
The experimental results highlight the strong coupling between mechanical loading, electromagnetic force generation, and actuation system limitations in the proposed self-contained architecture. As the payload increases, the required levitation force rises, leading to a reduction in the achievable air gap at constant rotational speeds. This, in turn, increases the induced eddy currents and associated magnetic drag forces, directly translating into higher torque demand and current draw from the drive system.
A key finding of this study is that the operational boundary of the self-contained EDS demonstrator is governed primarily by actuator current and power limitations rather than by electromagnetic levitation capability. Although the levitation force can be increased by reducing the air gap, this approach rapidly increases magnetic drag and torque requirements, making it impractical due to actuator constraints.
Furthermore, the experiments revealed a strong sensitivity to mass distribution within the platform. Even minor offsets in the center of gravity resulted in uneven load sharing among the levitation units, leading to asymmetric air-gap behavior and localized overloading of specific motors, as smaller air gaps locally increase magnetic drag and current demand. This highlights the importance of precise mass balancing in multi-actuator EDS systems. While such asymmetries can be compensated by differential speed control of individual disks using the existing distance sensors and independent motor drives, all experiments in this study were conducted under equal-speed conditions, and therefore these effects were directly observed in the measured air-gap distribution.
In terms of operational limits, the duration of continuous levitation was primarily constrained by the available onboard energy capacity. The high current demand associated with elevated magnetic drag leads to significant power consumption, directly limiting the achievable operation time, while thermal effects remain secondary within the tested conditions. Although the system was originally designed based on a minimum operational requirement of 60 s, the selected battery configuration was intentionally oversized in order to avoid operation near the discharge limits of the batteries. Under full-power conditions, the onboard battery system is capable of supplying the demonstrator for approximately 145 s. Furthermore, the experimental tests conducted in this study were performed below the maximum continuous power level of the system; therefore, no operational time limitation was encountered during the experiments.
From a design perspective, electromagnetic optimization should not focus solely on maximizing levitation force. Increasing lift by reducing the air gap is straightforward; however, this simultaneously increases magnetic drag and torque demand. Therefore, minimizing drag force is equally critical, as it directly determines both the feasibility of achieving levitation and the sustainability of operation.
The practical implementation of Halbach arrays requires careful consideration of mechanical integration and material selection. Although theoretical configurations may suggest closely packed magnet arrangements, the strong interaction forces between magnets make assembly challenging. Adequate spacing, robust structural support, and appropriate disk material selection are essential to ensure safe operation. In addition, while non-conductive materials reduce parasitic eddy current losses, they must also allow for precise balancing, as imbalance-induced vibrations can lead to mechanical damage at high rotational speeds.
Another critical aspect is the transient torque requirement during startup. The torque required to accelerate the disk from rest in the presence of a conductive plate is significantly higher than the torque required during steady-state operation. As a result, systems that can sustain levitation at a given speed may still fail to reach that speed under load. This necessitates either controlled engagement strategies or careful motor sizing based on worst-case torque conditions.
Increasing actuator capability is also subject to a coupled design trade-off. Higher motor power requires larger motors, drivers, and energy storage systems, all of which increase system mass. This added mass increases the required levitation force and associated drag, reinforcing the need for a co-design approach between electromagnetic and actuation subsystems.
Mechanical stiffness plays a critical role in maintaining stable levitation. Structural deformation directly affects the air gap, and even small deflections can lead to significant performance degradation in systems operating at millimeter-scale tolerances. Ensuring high structural rigidity is therefore essential for consistent and repeatable operation; otherwise, similar experimental results cannot be reliably reproduced.
Thermal effects, particularly within the conductive plate, may become significant in prolonged operation scenarios due to eddy current losses. Although thermal behavior was not experimentally investigated in the present study, heat generation within the conductive plate could potentially lead to thermal expansion and air-gap deviations in long-duration applications, indicating the possible need for future thermal management considerations.
From a dynamic standpoint, the rotational inertia of the disks can introduce additional challenges during transient operation. The use of counter-rotating disks is recommended to reduce net angular momentum and improve system stability.
Finally, the presence of high currents and electromagnetic interference necessitates careful design of the sensing and communication infrastructure. Proper isolation and filtering of sensor signals are essential to ensure reliable measurement and control performance in such environments. In addition, the resolution of the position measurement sensors should be selected at least one order of magnitude (≈10×) higher than the target air-gap resolution; in this study, a sensor resolution of was used for an air-gap deviation range on the order of .
Discrepancies between simulation and experimental results were also observed. Finite element predictions of levitation force did not fully match experimental measurements, likely due to edge effects, skin effects, and modeling limitations. Consequently, a conservative safety factor on the order of 2 is recommended when designing electromagnetic systems and selecting actuators.
Moreover, the motor controllers were configured to limit current below their theoretical maximum ratings for safety reasons. As a result, the experimentally validated payload capacity represents a conservative operational limit rather than the absolute physical capability of the system.
Overall, these findings demonstrate that the performance of self-contained EDS systems is governed by tightly coupled electromagnetic, mechanical, and actuation constraints, requiring a holistic design approach that considers force generation, drag minimization, actuator capability, structural integrity, and energy consumption.