From Waste to Cathode: A Comparative Evaluation of Sol–Gel and Co-Precipitation Routes for Closed-Loop Recycling of Lithium-Ion Battery Cathodes

The exponential growth of lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) in electric vehicles and energy storage systems has amplified the urgent need for sustainable recycling strategies. Conventional pyrometallurgical and hydrometallurgical methods for LIB recycling are energy-intensive, chemically demanding, and fail to preserve the structural integrity of cath-ode materials. Closed-loop recycling, in contrast, enables the recovery of layered oxides with minimal processing steps, reducing environmental footprint and supporting a circular economy. This study provides a systematic comparison of two regeneration approaches—sol–gel synthesis and hydroxide co-precipitation—for closed-loop recycling of layered NCM (LiNi_xCo_yMn_zO₂) cathode materials recovered from spent LIBs. Spent cells were mechani-cally processed and leached using malic acid to recover Ni, Co, Mn, which were subsequently used to synthesize NCM622 cathode powders. The regenerated materials were characterized using SEM/EDX, XRD, and electrochemical testing in CR2032 coin cells. Both methods successfully produced phase-pure layered oxides with the R-3m structure, with distinct differences in structural ordering and electrochemical behavior. The sol–gel-derived NCM622 displayed higher crystallinity and reduced cation mixing, evidenced by an I(003)/I(104) ratio of 1.896 compared to 1.720 for the co-precipitated sample, and delivered a high initial discharge capacity of 170 mAh/g at 0.1 C. However, it exhibited significant capacity fade, retaining only 60 mAh/g after 40 cycles. In contrast, the co-precipitation route produced hierarchical porous spherical agglomerates that offered superior cycling stability, maintaining ~150 mAh/g after 40 cycles with lower polarization (ΔE_p = 0.16 V). Both materials demonstrated electrochemical performance comparable to commercial NCM. Overall, hydroxide co-precipitation emerged as the most industrially viable method due to scalable processing, compositional robustness, and improved long-term stability of regenerated cathodes. This work highlights the critical influence of synthesis route selection in LIB closed-loop recycling and provides a technological framework for industrial recovery of high-value NCM cathode materials.