1. Introduction
In the most energetically efficient inertial confinement fusion (ICF) scheme with a “shock ignition” (SI), the processes of the capsule implosion with deuterium–tritium (DT) fuel and its subsequent “ignition” are separated in time [
1,
2]. After a uniform, close-to-adiabatic, compression of the capsule for several tens of nanoseconds, a thermonuclear fusion begins in the hottest and densest central region of the compressed target. This region is additionally heated by converging to the central strong shock wave. The latter is generated by an even more powerful laser pulse spike with a duration of several hundreds of picoseconds. During this time, the compressed fuel does not have time to expand. The escape of neutrons and their absorption in a fusion reactor blanket provide useful energy to the power cycle of the inertial fusion energy (IFE) plant, whereas α-particles absorbed nearby in the dense DT fuel provide additional heating and thus support thermonuclear fusion in the rest of the fuel. The described scheme of the SI ICF can be implemented with laser pulses having a complex time shape with a short final spike, whose power exceeds the main driving pulse by one or two orders of magnitude.
After a recent demonstration of the ignition in indirect compression experiments at the NIF 3ω Nd glass facility [
3], the undoubted advantage of which is the homogeneity of target compression, the focus of ICF research is shifting to the implementation of advanced direct compression schemes, e.g., SI ICF with more efficient laser drivers. The laser driver for the IFE power station must meet a number of challenges. First of all, it must have the highest overall efficiency and a short radiation wavelength
λ for efficient absorption in plasma and higher ablation pressure, and it must allow temporal profiling of laser pulses for the SI ICF. Most of these requirements could be satisfied with e-beam-pumped KrF drivers [
4,
5].
Compared to solid-state lasers, a KrF laser possesses (i) a short lifetime of the excited B state of KrF molecule
τc ≈ 2 ns (taking into account a radiation decay time and quenching collisions); (ii) low gain saturation parameters—the saturation intensity
Is ≈ 2 MW/cm
2 for a quasi-stationary amplification of “long” nanosecond pulses with
τ ≥
τc, for which an instant intensity manages the gain saturation, as well as saturation energy density
εs ≈ 2 mJ/cm
2 for “short” sub-nanosecond and picosecond pulses with
τ ≤
τc. The three-orders-of-magnitude-lower
Is and
εs are well compensated by a larger gain volume of KrF lasers effectively pumped by e-beams. As a small
τc does not allow storage of the population inversion in the gain medium during the pumping time
τp >>
τc (usually of a few hundred nanoseconds), an angular multiplexing scheme is conventionally used to effectively extract the pump energy from amplifiers in a train of time-separated and angularly separated pulses obtained by splitting the initial laser beam into multiple beamlets (see, e.g., [
5]). But a direct amplification of the entire SI ICF pulse shape meets difficulties as a steep high-intensity final spike strongly saturates the gain medium compared with a pulse foot. A precise precompensation of the saturation is required before pulse amplification, which increases the spike-to-foot ratio of the initial pulse shape even more [
6]. An alternative approach is a simultaneous-in-time amplification of both long and short pulses in separate beamlets, in which the rest gain remains in a course of a quasi-continuous amplification of long pulses in addition to amplifying short pulses [
7,
8]. A combining of long and short pulses on a target after their demultiplexation makes it possible to produce a temporal shape required for the SI ICF.
The feasibility of the simultaneous amplification of high-energy long pulses (~50 J, 100 ns) on par with a train of sub-ps pulses with a sub-TW peak power has already been demonstrated [
9]. Short pulses were generated using a Ti: Sapphire front end, which was frequency-tripled into the KrF amplification band [
8]. Unfortunately, a local growth of energy density in the evolving filaments significantly reduced the amplifier gain while three-photon absorption in the CaF
2 windows (material of the choice) produced window degradation [
9]. Also, the filamentation of powerful UV pulses in atmospheric air strongly distorted the laser beam distribution [
10].
In the present study, we deal with a nonlinear UV pulse compression when focusing radiation into a nonlinear medium. It differs favorably from other methods of generating short pulses using a mode-locking technique, dye lasers, or frequency tripling of a Ti: Sapphire laser by means of its simplicity, availability in terms of the cost, and high contrast (the ratio of the peak power of the short pulse to the pre-pulse) determined by the threshold nature of nonlinear processes. A nonlinear temporal compression of discharge-pumped KrF laser pulses was investigated over decades in high-pressure SF
6 and CH
4 gases, which are promising nonlinear medium [
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21]. It was shown that an effective pulse compression with an appropriate increase in peak power can be obtained via a backward stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) [
12,
13,
14,
15,
17,
18,
21], backward stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) [
11,
16], and their combination in a four-wave mixing (FWM) scheme [
19,
20]. An advantage of the SBS is the small frequency shift in the Stokes components (Δ
λB~10
−3 nm) compared to the width of the KrF laser gain bandwidth (Δ
λ~2 nm), which allows one further amplification of the compressed pulses in KrF amplifiers. However, a large dephasing time
T2 determined by a lifetime of hypersonic phonons in the medium, namely, 100–600 ps in gases compressed up to 10 atm and 30–150 ps in various SBS-active liquids, generally sets lower limits for the achievable pulse duration. The length of the nonlinear interaction
Lnl for SBS generated from a spontaneously scattered light is typically selected to be
gB ×
I ×
Lnl ≥ 25 for one pass just to exceed the SBS threshold. Some advantages in pulse shortening below
T2 and the higher reflection give a so-called self-seeding SBS configuration implemented with a Nd: YAG laser in CCl
4 [
22] and C
8F
18 [
23], in which a part of the transmitted pump radiation was reflected back into the nonlinear interaction region by means of an additional mirror. Unfortunately, the choice of transparent liquids for the UV KrF laser wavelength is very limited; the best ones are the fluorocarbons C
6F
14 and C
8F
18 (
gB ≈ 0.5 × 10
−2 cm/MW). Among gases, SF
6 has the largest SBS gain (
gB ≈ 0.9 × 10
−2 cm/MW).
The advantage of the SRS compression is a shorter phase dephasing time: in CH
4 compressed up to 7.5 atm,
T2~25ps, this makes it possible to obtain shorter picosecond pulses in a backward reflection. The disadvantage of the SRS is a significant shift in the wavelength of the Stokes components out of the KrF gain bandwidth Δ
λR >> Δ
λ. To overcome this wavelength misalignment, the FWM of Stokes and anti-Stokes components was additionally used, wherein the original frequency of the KrF laser wavelength was restored in temporally compressed pulses, which could be further amplified in the chain of KrF amplifiers [
19,
20].
The present experiments were conceived to elucidate the competition between nonlinear SBS and SRS processes in compressed SF
6 and CH
4 gases in the case of backscattering and forward scattering. Such competition has commonly been observed in experiments with various types of lasers, including excimer lasers, while the results obtained often contradicted each other. In the present experiments, we used both narrowband and broadband pumping radiation with a final goal to select an effective scheme for the temporary compression of UV pulses generated using a discharge-pumped KrF laser with a 20 ns pulse length. The obtained sub-ns pulses will be further implemented for combining the SI ICF pulse shape at a multistage e-beam-pumped GARPUN KrF laser facility [
8].
2. A Layout of Experiments
A discharge-pumped KrF laser EMG 150 TMSC 150 (Lambda Physik, GmbH) was used in the experiments on the nonlinear scattering of λ = 248 nm radiation in high-pressure SF6 and CH4 gases. This is a two-chamber laser (oscillator and amplifier) with a common power supply operating in an injection-controlled scheme. When a narrowband seed radiation from the oscillator was injected into an unstable resonator cavity of the amplifier, the output radiation had an energy of up to 200 mJ in pulses of τ ≈ 20 ns FWHM, a beam divergence of ~0.3 mrad, and a narrow bandwidth of Δλ ≈ 1.2 × 10−3 nm (Δν ≈ 0.2 cm−1). Alternatively, with a blocked narrowband oscillator, the bandwidth of the output radiation was Δλ ≈ 0.25 nm (Δν ≈ 40 cm−1), while other laser parameters changed slightly. The experiments were performed with a repetition rate of 1 Hz, although the laser could operate with 80 Hz.
The backscattered radiation was monitored in the layout shown in
Figure 1. The laser energy, before being focused in a gas cell, was step-wise attenuated in the dynamic range 0.01–0.94 from the initial value
E using a nine-stage diffraction attenuator DVA-22-250 (Inst. of Automation and Electrometry SB RAS, Novosibirsk, Russia). The energy was measured using a PESO-SH-V2 calorimeter with a NOVA II display (Ophir Photonics, Jerusalem, Israel). To monitor the radiation time behavior, high-speed photodiodes (Thorlabs DET10A) were used. The pulse shapes of the incident radiation that passed through the cell with the nonlinear medium and that reflected back were recorded using photodiodes PD 1, PD 2, and PD 3, respectively, with a TDS 3054C 500 MHz oscilloscope (Tektronix Inc., Beaverton, OR, USA) with a time resolution of ~1 ns. Even shorter UV pulses obtained through nonlinear compression were measured using a streak camera PS-1/S1 (Institute of General Physics of the RAS, Moscow, Russia) with a picosecond time resolution. The images on the screen of the streak camera were registered with an Anima-PX reader (Optronics Gmbh, Kehl, Germany). The time-integrated spectra of the scattered radiation were recorded using an ASP-150 T (Avesta Project Ltd., Moscow, Russia) spectrometer with a spectral resolution of ~0.3 nm. To illuminate the entrance slit of the spectrometer uniformly, a scattering diffuser was set in front of it. The temporal dynamics of scattered spectral components was studied using an MDR-12 grating monochromator (LOMO, St. Petersburg, Russia) tuned to the required wavelength range with a registration of the selected radiation by the PD 4 photodiode.
Due to a small spectral shift, the radiation reflected by the SBS stays inside the laser bandwidth. Therefore, there was a potential danger of damage to the output meniscus coupler of the laser and its output window due to the radiation back reflected from the nonlinear medium when it was focused in an inverse converging wave of the unstable telescopic resonator. In this regard, a polarization decoupling of the incident radiation and that reflected back from the cell was foreseen with a help of a quarter-wave phase plate and a polarizer. However, in the experiments described below, an optical delay line of about 15 m length was used between the laser and the cell, thanks to which the reflected pulse returned after 100 ns, i.e., to the moment when the gain in the laser decayed after a termination of the pumping discharge.
The cell with the SF
6 had an inner diameter of 26 mm and a length of 250 cm; it was filled at a pressure of 10 atm. It was chosen based on previous experiments [
12,
13,
16,
17]. Plane-parallel windows made of fused silica glass KU-1 with a diameter of 40 mm and a thickness of 10 mm were used. The pump radiation was focused into the cell using lenses with focal lengths of
F = 0.8 or 2 m. The first lens was set close to the cell entrance, and the second one was 70 cm in front of the cell. The Fresnel reflection from the windows was excluded from the registration of backward radiation by means of a slight inclination of the cell axis relative to the axis of the incident radiation. The cell with CH
4 at a pressure of 50 atm had an inner diameter of 20 mm and a length of 70 cm. It was closed from both sides with thick, wedge-shaped windows of 30 mm diameter, which excluded the Fresnel reflection of the pump radiation being focused into the cell using a lens with
F = 0.5 m set at 15 cm in front of the cell.
The radiation distribution in the focal plane was measured using a Spiricon SP620U profiler (Ophir Photonics), while a K8 glass plate was used to convert the UV laser light into green fluorescence [
10]. The focal distribution had a Gaussian-like symmetric central part and broad, low-intensity wings, originating from a temporal evolution of laser light in the unstable resonator cavity of the laser [
24]. The distribution of pump radiation in the focal spot for all lenses used in the experiments remained similar and scaled proportionally to the focal length
F, while the peak intensity in the spot
I varied as
. For a given pulse duration
τ ≈ 20 ns, the peak intensity in the center of the focal spot could be expressed via other variables as
. Note that, for the highest pump energy
Emax ≈ 120 mJ and the shortest focal length
F = 0.5 m, the maximal peak intensity was 4.3 × 10
10 W/cm
2, which was still less than the breakdown thresholds for the gases under investigation.
4. Discussion
The above-described results demonstrate a strong competition between two nonlinear scattering processes, SBS and SRS. Firstly, it was observed in compressed gases with a ruby laser [
26,
27], and then it was reported for shorter laser wavelengths (see e.g., [
12,
28]). Both the SBS and SRS, each having different dependencies on gas pressure, could occur simultaneously even if one of them had higher gain coefficient in some region of parameters. Their interaction originates mainly from the change in the spatial distribution of optical fields altered (depleted) by an intense level of scattering. Backward SRS pulse compressors for KrF ICF were also discussed in [
16,
29,
30], wherein limitations from the other scattering processes were considered, e.g., SBS and forward SRS. The latter was shown to be asymmetric relative to the backward SRS and was able to proceed with a broadband pumping, similar to present experiments.
Among other things, there is a discrepancy between our results on backscattering in SF
6 and in the experiments [
17], wherein, in similar conditions, no backscattered SRS radiation was measured at all. On the other hand, in accordance with present experiments, Tomov et al. [
12] observed a short backward Raman scattering with a pulse duration in the range of 120–400 ps preceding the Brillouin backscattered signal. However, after the development of the SBS, the SRS was suppressed because of the higher gain for the Brillouin mode.
Conventionally, the shortest scattered laser pulses are obtained near the threshold of corresponding stimulated scattering process. After exceeding the threshold, the rapidly growing Stokes signal results in a depletion of the pump wave, so that the pump intensity drops below the threshold and the stimulated amplification is ended. With an increase in the pump peak intensity, the threshold for stimulated scattering is exceeded for a longer part of the pump pulse, which is why pulse width of the scattered signal should increase proportionally. In our experiments, this natural behavior held for the backward SBS and forward SRS, while, in the case of backward SRS in SF6, the Stokes pulse width was found to decrease with an increase in pump pulse intensity. Below, we provide a simple theoretical consideration that allows us to explain this anomalous dependency.
The conventional model of backward SRS is based on the following set of equations [
31,
32,
33]:
Here, and are the slow-varying amplitudes of the forward pump and the backward Stokes waves, and , having the wavenumbers , the frequencies , and the group velocities , respectively. The constants and describe linear attenuation at the pump and the Stokes waves, while is the relaxation rate of the specific normal vibrational coordinate , where is its slow-varying amplitude and is the resonant vibrational frequency, . The light–matter coupling coefficients are and , where are the refractive indices at the pump and the Stokes frequencies, and are, respectively, the number density of Raman-active molecules, their effective mass, and the derivative of the molecular polarizability with respect to the normal coordinate.
Introducing the new amplitude functions according to the following substitution
, one can rewrite (1) as follows:
where
and
are the new attenuation coefficients. In view of the fact that the attenuation coefficient
is rather small so that
during the entire interaction process, one can solve Equation (2) within the perturbation theory. To the lowest order of the perturbation theory [
34], we insert the exponents in the right-hand side of (2) being equal to unity and seek transient solutions of the following shape:
where the transient coordinate
, and
characterizes the pulse width
. One can easily find that both the soliton-like solutions (3) satisfy the second and the third part of Equation (2) under the following conditions:
The pump wave amplitude is then described as follows:
Substituting (5) in the first of Equation (2), we find the following:
Note that, when , we have the coefficient , the velocity of the transients exceeds the group velocity of the Stokes signal and all the amplitudes have the same phase. Vice versa, when , we have , the amplitudes differ from by in phase, and the transient velocity becomes less than the group velocity .
The above transient solutions describe the backward SRS process in which the Stokes characteristic pulse width decreases with an increase in pump intensity. Really, the initial intensity of the pump laser pulse
corresponds to the limiting value of (5) at
, i.e.,
Here, the characteristic threshold intensity
. According to (7), the pulse width of the Stokes pulse is large near the threshold intensity and gradually decreases with an increase in
, being of the order of
, i.e., of the order of the characteristic vibrational relaxation time of the Raman-active medium. This dependency qualitatively agrees with the experimental data in
Section 3.1.
5. Conclusions
A nonlinear pulse compression was obtained for a narrowband KrF laser radiation in compressed gases. When KrF laser pulses with a 20 ns temporal width were focused into a SF6 cell at 10 atm pressure both SBS and SRS optically phase-conjugated backward reflection was registered with an energy reflectivity of 10–14%. While the SBS pulse gradually shortened from 10 ns for a high pump energy of 100 mJ to 2–3 ns when approaching the SBS threshold of ~10 mJ, the SRS pulse exhibited an abnormal behavior. It had the shortest width of 30–60 ps for the maximal pumping of 120 mJ and broadened near the SRS threshold of ~30 mJ. The SRS pulse energy was about 2 mJ, which corresponded to the peak power of 5 × 107 W, and this was tenfold higher than the pump power (120 mJ and 20 ns). The theoretical model predicted a soliton-like SRS pulse compression to a temporal width of the order of the vibrational relaxation time.
In a CH4 gas cell at 50 atm pressure, both SBS and SRS optically phase conjugated backward reflection was observed for narrowband pumping with an energy reflectivity of 14%. There was no pulse compression of backward radiation, while, in the forward direction, SRS pulses shortened to 3–4 ns at reduced pumping. For broadband pumping (Δν ≈ 40 cm−1), a strong asymmetry was observed: a backward SRS and SBS reflection was completely absent, while, in the forward direction, the spectra were enriched by high-order Stokes SRS components as well as by the first anti-Stokes component.
Further experiments are underway to implement the best backward nonlinear reflection scheme for pulse compression and sequential amplification in a multistage GARPUN KrF laser installation [
8]. First, to increase the efficiency, we are going to use capillaries, which will increase the length of the nonlinear interaction over the Rayleigh length, while maintaining the high intensity of the focused laser beam [
35]. Secondly, the preliminary wrapping of the pump pulse by the Pockels cell will be implemented in a similar way to the experiments [
20].