An INRBO-SSA-LSTM Hybrid Framework for Short-Term Power Load Forecasting in Smart Microgrids
Abstract
1. Introduction
1.1. Motivation and Literature Review
1.2. Main Contributions and Paper Organization
- (1)
- Proposal of an Improved Optimization Algorithm (INRBO):
- (2)
- Development of an Adaptive Signal Denoising Strategy:
- (3)
- Construction of a Double-Layer Optimized Forecasting Framework:
- (4)
- Comprehensive Empirical Validation and Ablation Study:
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Denoising of Data by Singular Spectrum Analysis (SSA)
- (1)
- Embedding:
- (2)
- Singular Value Decomposition (SVD).
- (3)
- Grouping:
- (4)
- Diagonal Averaging:
2.2. Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) Network
- (1)
- Forget Gate:
- (2)
- Input Gate and Candidate Cell State:
- (3)
- Update of cell state.
- (4)
- Output Gate and Hidden State:
2.3. The Proposed Improved NRBO (INRBO) Algorithm
2.3.1. Cosine Adaptive t-Distribution Perturbation Strategy
2.3.2. Boundary-Aware Non-Uniform Guidance Strategy
2.3.3. Fitness-Aware Hybrid Perturbation Strategy
2.4. The Proposed Double-Layer Optimized INRBO-SSA-LSTM Forecasting Architecture
2.4.1. SSA Parameter Optimization
2.4.2. The Proposed INRBO-SSA-LSTM Forecasting Framework
- (1)
- Phase I: Feature Selection and Data Preprocessing
- (2)
- Phase II: First-Layer Optimization (Adaptive SSA Denoising)
- (3)
- Phase III: Second-Layer Optimization (Adaptive LSTM Forecasting)
- (4)
- Phase IV: Final Forecasting and Evaluation
3. Benchmark Testing of the Optimization Algorithm
3.1. Analysis of the Effectiveness of Different Strategies
3.2. CEC2017 Benchmark Tests with Different Dimensions
3.3. Tests on the CEC2022 Benchmark Suite
3.4. Wilcoxon Rank-Sum and Friedman Tests
4. Results and Discussion
4.1. Data Description and Feature Correlation Analysis
4.2. Evaluation Metrics
4.3. Signal Denoising and Hyperparameter Optimization Analysis
4.4. Ablation Study and Forecasting Performance
4.4.1. Progressive Ablation Study of Prediction, Decomposition, and Optimization Modules
4.4.2. Comparative Experiments Across Different Months
4.5. Discussion on the Robustness and Extremum Capturing Ability of Models
5. Conclusions
5.1. Conclusion
- (1)
- Good algorithmic performance: According to all kinds of evaluations in the CEC2022 benchmark suite, it can be seen that the proposed INRBO is better than the traditional NRBO and many advanced swarm-based methods (such as WOA, HHO) in terms of search accuracy, convergence speed and stability. Based on the results of the Wilcoxon rank-sum test and Friedman mean ranking, both are , and thus the combined multi-strategy architecture can solve the problem of local optima in high-dimensional spaces.
- (2)
- Practicability of Dimension Reduction: In order to reduce the number of features in the actual meteorological-load data, Pearson correlation coefficient (PCC) evaluation has been used to reduce the eight features to four essential climate factors (Temperature, Pressure, Water Vapor Pressure and Apparent Temperature). Pre-processing is done to reduce the curse of dimensionality and over-fitting of the model.
- (3)
- Accurate Adaptive Signal Filtering: Use the good optimization ability of INRBO to solve the problem of manual setting of parameters in Singular Spectrum Analysis (SSA). Determined a reasonable size for the window and the number of principal components () dynamically in INRBO-SSA to achieve a relatively high signal-to-noise ratio of 15.87 dB and filter out high-frequency random fluctuations in the basic load pattern effectively.
- (4)
- Good predictive accuracy and flexibility of stability: All the time in the prediction period, the two-tier structure has been able to find globally optimal hyperparameters for the LSTM model. Ablation analysis shows that our method is better than all the benchmark alternatives in all aspects, with a very small prediction error (MAE = 8.8992, RMSE = 10.9764, MAPE = 3.7866%) and a good value of 0.9741. It should be pointed out that in the event of a sudden peak-and-trough load fluctuation, the system has good dynamic stability and peak-capture ability, so it is a very reliable reference for microgrid power scheduling.
5.2. Limitations and Future Work
Author Contributions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Conflicts of Interest
References
- Zhu, G.; Zhang, S.; Deng, Z.; Wang, J.; Li, Y.; Dong, J.; Bauer, P. Extended hybrid modulation for multistage constant-current wireless EV charging. IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 2025, 40, 10095–10110. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Liu, B.; Wu, J.; Chai, L. Distributed Privacy-Preserving Algorithm for Economic Dispatch and Demand Response of Smart Grid with Homomorphic Encryption. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 2025, 16, 173–182. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Akhtar, S.; Shahzad, S.; Zaheer, A.; Ullah, H.S.; Kılıç, H.; Goňo, R.; Jasinski, M.L.; Leonowicz, Z. Short-Term Load Forecasting Models: A Review of Challenges, Progress, and the Road Ahead. Energies 2023, 16, 4060. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Anusha, T.G.; Vinod, A.; Binas, M.S.; Kumar, S.; Bindu, C.J. A Comprehensive Review of the Short-Term Load Forecasting Techniques Using Different Models. In Proceedings of the 2025 2nd International Conference on Trends in Engineering Systems and Technologies (ICTEST), Kochi, India, 3–5 April 2025; pp. 1–6. [Google Scholar]
- Jafari, M.; Kavousi-fard, A.; Chen, T.; Karimi, M. A Review on Digital Twin Technology in Smart Grid, Transportation System and Smart City: Challenges and Future. IEEE Access 2023, 11, 17471–17484. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Iyaniwura, A.A.; Mayaki, C.S. Artificial Intelligence-enabled smart grid systems for real-time load forecasting, fault detection, renewable energy integration and optimization. Glob. J. Eng. Technol. Adv. 2025, 10, 191–208. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Dabe, N.P.; Kukarni, K.S.; Kadlag, S.S.; Dandotia, A.; Gupta, M.K.; Tiwari, A. Hybrid Generative AI for Smart Grid Load Forecasting with Renewable Energy Integration. In Proceedings of the 2025 World Conference on Cutting-Edge Science and Technology (WCCEST), Indore, India, 24–26 September 2025; pp. 1–6. [Google Scholar]
- Ahmed, M.M.; Mirsaeidi, S.; Koondhar, M.A.; Karami, N.; Tag-Eldin, E.M.; Ghamry, N.A.; El-Sehiemy, R.A.; Alaas, Z.M.; Mahariq, I.; Sharaf, A.M. Mitigating Uncertainty Problems of Renewable Energy Resources Through Efficient Integration of Hybrid Solar PV/Wind Systems into Power Networks. IEEE Access 2024, 12, 30311–30328. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Patel, V.R.; Makwana, V.H. Short-Term Solar and Wind Power Forecasting Using Machine Learning Algorithms for Microgrid Operation. Energies 2025, 19, 550. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, Y.; Zheng, R.; Liu, M.; Zhu, J.; Zhao, X.; Zhang, M. Short-Term Load Forecasting Model Based on Time Series Clustering and Transformer in Smart Grid. Electronics 2025, 14, 230. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Karima, N.N.; Syafruddin, W.A.; Mahfud, M.; Subiyanto, L.; Setiadi, H. Enhancing Short-Term Load Forecasting Using Hyperparameter-Optimized Deep Learning Approaches. Energies 2025, 19, 705. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Asiri, M.M.; Aldehim, G.; Alotaibi, F.A.; Alnfiai, M.M.; Assiri, M.; Mahmud, A. Short-Term Load Forecasting in Smart Grids Using Hybrid Deep Learning. IEEE Access 2024, 12, 23504–23513. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Ertürk, M.; Emeç, M.; Turhan, M. Hybrid Deep Learning and Transformer-Based Framework for Multivariate Electricity Consumption Forecasting. Appl. Sci. 2026, 16, 2760. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Sakib, M.; Mustajab, S. CEEMDAN-TCN-AutoLSTM: A Triple-Force Ensemble Using Cross-Stitch Networks for Short-Term Load Forecasting. Arab. J. Sci. Eng. 2025, 50, 19939–19970. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Zhang, A.; Zhang, S.; Li, G. Research on CNN-LSTM Power Load Forecasting Model Based on Attention Mechanism. In Proceedings of the 2025 International Conference of Clean Energy and Electrical Engineering (ICCEEE), Changchun, China, 18–21 July 2025; pp. 1–5. [Google Scholar]
- Pentsos, V.; Tragoudas, S.; Wibbenmeyer, J.; Khdeer, N. A Hybrid LSTM-Transformer Model for Power Load Forecasting. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 2025, 16, 2624–2634. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Kong, W.; Dong, Z.Y.; Jia, Y.; Hill, D.J.; Xu, Y.; Zhang, Y. Short-Term Residential Load Forecasting Based on LSTM Recurrent Neural Network. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 2019, 10, 841–851. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rafi, S.H.; Nahid-Al-Masood, N.A. Highly Efficient Short Term Load Forecasting Scheme Using Long Short Term Memory Network. In Proceedings of the 2020 8th International Electrical Engineering Congress (iEECON), Chiang Mai, Thailand, 4–6 March 2020; pp. 1–4. [Google Scholar]
- Yin, S.; Chen, Z.; Liu, W.; Su, Z. Ultra Short-Term Charging Load Forecasting Based on Improved Data Decomposition and Hybrid Neural Network. IEEE Access 2025, 13, 58778–58789. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Aswanuwath, L.; Pannakkong, W.; Buddhakulsomsiri, J.; Karnjana, J.; Huynh, V. A Hybrid Model of VMD-EMD-FFT, Similar Days Selection Method, Stepwise Regression, and Artificial Neural Network for Daily Electricity Peak Load Forecasting. Energies 2023, 16, 1860. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Pham, M.; Nguyen, M.; Wu, Y. A Novel Short-Term Load Forecasting Method by Combining the Deep Learning with Singular Spectrum Analysis. IEEE Access 2021, 9, 73736–73746. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Stratigakos, A.C.; Bachoumis, A.; Vita, V.; Zafiropoulos, E.P. Short-Term Net Load Forecasting with Singular Spectrum Analysis and LSTM Neural Networks. Energies 2021, 14, 4107. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Neeraj, N.; Mathew, J.; Behera, R.K. Power load forecasting based on long short term memory-singular spectrum analysis. Energy Syst. 2021, 13, 789–811. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Kaur, S.; Bala, A.; Parashar, A. A hybrid PSO-LSTM-based electricity prediction and optimization technique for home appliances. Sci. Technol. Energy Transit. 2026, 81, 132. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Hou, B.; Zhou, Y.; Liu, R.; Zhang, H. PSO-LSTM-Based Ultra-Short-Term Load Forecasting Study for Solar Heating System. Energies 2025, 18, 6254. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Ning, Y.; Wang, J.; Wang, Z.; Zhu, Y.; Zhang, J. Electricity Load Forecasting Method Based on Improved PSO-LSTM Modeling. In Proceedings of the 2025 International Conference on Power Electronics and Electric Drives (PEED), Dali, China, 7–9 March 2025; pp. 56–60. [Google Scholar]
- Mirjalili, S.; Lewis, A. The whale optimization algorithm. Adv. Eng. Softw. 2016, 95, 51–67. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Tian, D.; Shi, Z. MPSO: Modified particle swarm optimization and its applications. Swarm Evol. Comput. 2018, 41, 49–68. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bozorgi, S.M.; Yazdani, S. IWOA: An improved whale optimization algorithm for optimization problems. J. Comput. Des. Eng. 2019, 6, 243–259. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Heidari, A.A.; Mirjalili, S.; Faris, H.; Aljarah, I.; Mafarja, M.; Chen, H. Harris hawks optimization: Algorithm and applications. Future Gener. Comput. Syst. 2019, 97, 849–872. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Xue, J.; Shen, B. A novel swarm intelligence optimization approach: Sparrow search algorithm. Syst. Sci. Control Eng. 2020, 8, 22–34. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Abualigah, L.; Diabat, A.; Mirjalili, S.; Elaziz, M.A.; Gandomi, A.H. The arithmetic optimization algorithm. Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 2021, 376, 113609. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Sowmya, R.; Manoharan, P.; Jangir, P. Newton-Raphson-based optimizer: A new population-based metaheuristic algorithm for continuous optimization problems. Eng. Appl. Artif. Intell. 2024, 128, 107532. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Xu, T.; He, J.; Li, Y.; Li, X.; Tang, J. A VMD–Bayesian-Optimized XGBoost–BiLSTM Hybrid Model for Short-Term Load Forecasting. Electronics 2026, 15, 2507. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]















| Function | INRBO | NRBO | NRBO1 | NRBO2 | NRBO3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean F1 | 3.68 × 103 | 4.39 × 108 | 3.45 × 108 | 4.55 × 106 | 3.20 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F1 | 3.64 × 103 | 3.88 × 108 | 2.28 × 108 | 4.56 × 106 | 3.54 × 103 |
| Average F3 | 3.00 × 102 | 1.95 × 103 | 1.55 × 103 | 3.37 × 102 | 3.00 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F3 | 5.11 × 10−4 | 1.54 × 103 | 1.34 × 103 | 3.12 × 101 | 1.08 × 10−6 |
| Average F4 | 4.03 × 102 | 4.55 × 102 | 4.46 × 102 | 4.14 × 102 | 4.00 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F4 | 1.25 × 100 | 3.94 × 101 | 2.35 × 101 | 2.29 × 101 | 2.38 × 10−1 |
| Average F5 | 5.16 × 102 | 5.47 × 102 | 5.46 × 102 | 5.15 × 102 | 5.28 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F5 | 6.90 × 100 | 1.58 × 101 | 1.27 × 101 | 5.23 × 100 | 1.00 × 101 |
| Average F6 | 6.01 × 102 | 6.24 × 102 | 6.25 × 102 | 6.03 × 102 | 6.02 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F6 | 1.06 × 100 | 8.58 × 100 | 9.32 × 100 | 1.15 × 100 | 2.18 × 100 |
| Average F7 | 7.31 × 102 | 7.72 × 102 | 7.67 × 102 | 7.35 × 102 | 7.33 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F7 | 8.87 × 100 | 2.19 × 101 | 1.59 × 101 | 9.60 × 100 | 1.04 × 101 |
| Average F8 | 8.18 × 102 | 8.37 × 102 | 8.33 × 102 | 8.18 × 102 | 8.23 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F8 | 6.49 × 100 | 9.00 × 100 | 6.05 × 100 | 7.90 × 100 | 8.00 × 100 |
| Average F9 | 9.02 × 102 | 1.04 × 103 | 1.08 × 103 | 9.27 × 102 | 9.08 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F9 | 4.05 × 100 | 1.04 × 102 | 1.54 × 102 | 3.81 × 101 | 1.45 × 101 |
| Average F10 | 1.91 × 103 | 2.27 × 103 | 2.05 × 103 | 1.73 × 103 | 1.80 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F10 | 1.57 × 102 | 3.51 × 102 | 2.69 × 102 | 2.17 × 102 | 2.71 × 102 |
| Average F11 | 1.13 × 103 | 1.20 × 103 | 1.22 × 103 | 1.13 × 103 | 1.14 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F11 | 3.40 × 101 | 7.88 × 101 | 8.14 × 101 | 4.52 × 101 | 1.89 × 101 |
| Average F12 | 3.72 × 104 | 3.61 × 106 | 2.08 × 106 | 4.28 × 104 | 1.34 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F12 | 1.96 × 104 | 6.45 × 106 | 1.84 × 106 | 5.30 × 104 | 1.24 × 104 |
| Function | INRBO | NRBO | SSOA | HHO | WOA | AOA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean F1 | 3.97 × 103 | 3.95 × 108 | 1.12 × 1010 | 5.49 × 105 | 8.22 × 106 | 7.67 × 109 |
| Standard Deviation F1 | 3.42 × 103 | 2.40 × 108 | 3.19 × 109 | 3.51 × 105 | 8.97 × 106 | 3.46 × 109 |
| Average F3 | 3.00 × 102 | 1.64 × 103 | 1.48 × 104 | 3.06 × 102 | 4.77 × 103 | 1.04 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F3 | 7.02 × 10−4 | 1.16 × 103 | 3.08 × 103 | 5.29 × 100 | 4.85 × 103 | 3.20 × 103 |
| Average F4 | 4.03 × 102 | 4.55 × 102 | 1.30 × 103 | 4.21 × 102 | 4.37 × 102 | 8.77 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F4 | 1.12 × 100 | 4.04 × 101 | 4.97 × 102 | 2.88 × 101 | 4.14 × 101 | 3.82 × 102 |
| Average F5 | 5.16 × 102 | 5.48 × 102 | 6.09 × 102 | 5.54 × 102 | 5.60 × 102 | 5.61 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F5 | 8.75 × 100 | 1.65 × 101 | 1.97 × 101 | 1.35 × 101 | 2.36 × 101 | 2.27 × 101 |
| Average F6 | 6.02 × 102 | 6.25 × 102 | 6.62 × 102 | 6.42 × 102 | 6.39 × 102 | 6.42 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F6 | 1.86 × 100 | 9.30 × 100 | 1.08 × 101 | 1.14 × 101 | 1.33 × 101 | 8.32 × 100 |
| Average F7 | 7.37 × 102 | 7.67 × 102 | 8.31 × 102 | 7.83 × 102 | 7.77 × 102 | 7.98 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F7 | 1.08 × 101 | 1.81 × 101 | 1.49 × 101 | 1.77 × 101 | 2.47 × 101 | 1.23 × 101 |
| Average F8 | 8.18 × 102 | 8.33 × 102 | 8.74 × 102 | 8.32 × 102 | 8.39 × 102 | 8.33 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F8 | 6.23 × 100 | 5.54 × 100 | 1.24 × 101 | 7.75 × 100 | 1.58 × 101 | 5.51 × 100 |
| Average F9 | 9.04 × 102 | 1.07 × 103 | 1.93 × 103 | 1.48 × 103 | 1.51 × 103 | 1.41 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F9 | 7.27 × 100 | 1.31 × 102 | 3.15 × 102 | 2.51 × 102 | 3.85 × 102 | 1.74 × 102 |
| Average F10 | 1.84 × 103 | 2.18 × 103 | 3.31 × 103 | 2.03 × 103 | 2.08 × 103 | 2.13 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F10 | 2.38 × 102 | 2.93 × 102 | 2.59 × 102 | 2.56 × 102 | 3.37 × 102 | 2.92 × 102 |
| Average F11 | 1.13 × 103 | 1.19 × 103 | 6.15 × 103 | 1.16 × 103 | 1.23 × 103 | 2.57 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F11 | 1.45 × 101 | 6.49 × 101 | 2.90 × 103 | 5.44 × 101 | 7.80 × 101 | 2.32 × 103 |
| Average F12 | 3.92 × 104 | 2.61 × 106 | 4.88 × 108 | 2.19 × 106 | 3.61 × 106 | 3.83 × 107 |
| Standard Deviation F12 | 1.58 × 104 | 3.20 × 106 | 2.39 × 108 | 2.56 × 106 | 5.10 × 106 | 6.96 × 107 |
| Average F13 | 2.79 × 103 | 5.46 × 103 | 2.79 × 107 | 1.36 × 104 | 2.26 × 104 | 1.23 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F13 | 5.65 × 103 | 5.46 × 103 | 3.58 × 107 | 9.72 × 103 | 1.79 × 104 | 8.86 × 103 |
| Average F14 | 1.44 × 103 | 1.52 × 103 | 1.19 × 104 | 1.73 × 103 | 2.58 × 103 | 6.98 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F14 | 9.28 × 100 | 4.20 × 101 | 1.72 × 104 | 6.18 × 102 | 1.53 × 103 | 6.78 × 103 |
| Average F15 | 1.54 × 103 | 1.79 × 103 | 2.12 × 104 | 6.33 × 103 | 9.25 × 103 | 1.66 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F15 | 1.81 × 101 | 2.26 × 102 | 4.08 × 103 | 2.25 × 103 | 5.78 × 103 | 5.53 × 103 |
| Average F16 | 1.66 × 103 | 1.81 × 103 | 2.33 × 103 | 1.92 × 103 | 1.86 × 103 | 2.08 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F16 | 7.27 × 101 | 1.26 × 102 | 1.45 × 102 | 1.53 × 102 | 1.18 × 102 | 1.59 × 102 |
| Average F17 | 1.75 × 103 | 1.79 × 103 | 1.91 × 103 | 1.80 × 103 | 1.82 × 103 | 1.89 × 103 |
| StandardDeviationF17 | 3.11 × 101 | 3.66 × 101 | 6.58 × 101 | 5.85 × 101 | 6.62 × 101 | 9.10 × 101 |
| Average F18 | 6.76 × 103 | 7.99 × 103 | 1.86 × 108 | 1.80 × 104 | 1.89 × 104 | 1.83 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F18 | 5.96 × 103 | 6.54 × 103 | 1.82 × 108 | 1.20 × 104 | 1.16 × 104 | 9.50 × 103 |
| Average F19 | 1.92 × 103 | 5.06 × 103 | 7.70 × 105 | 1.23 × 104 | 1.46 × 105 | 5.07 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F19 | 1.54 × 101 | 5.84 × 103 | 5.90 × 105 | 9.57 × 103 | 3.76 × 105 | 3.25 × 104 |
| Average F20 | 2.07 × 103 | 2.16 × 103 | 2.33 × 103 | 2.17 × 103 | 2.19 × 103 | 2.15 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F20 | 5.92 × 101 | 6.80 × 101 | 5.45 × 101 | 5.71 × 101 | 8.33 × 101 | 6.38 × 101 |
| Average F21 | 2.20 × 103 | 2.32 × 103 | 2.41 × 103 | 2.32 × 103 | 2.33 × 103 | 2.33 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F21 | 1.04 × 100 | 4.62 × 101 | 2.06 × 101 | 6.34 × 101 | 5.42 × 101 | 3.01 × 101 |
| Average F22 | 2.30 × 103 | 2.34 × 103 | 3.20 × 103 | 2.38 × 103 | 2.58 × 103 | 3.05 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F22 | 1.79 × 101 | 1.91 × 101 | 3.02 × 102 | 2.55 × 102 | 5.47 × 102 | 3.31 × 102 |
| Average F23 | 2.62 × 103 | 2.65 × 103 | 2.82 × 103 | 2.68 × 103 | 2.65 × 103 | 2.72 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F23 | 8.72 × 100 | 1.53 × 101 | 4.70 × 101 | 3.55 × 101 | 2.27 × 101 | 3.58 × 101 |
| Average F24 | 2.75 × 103 | 2.77 × 103 | 2.94 × 103 | 2.81 × 103 | 2.77 × 103 | 2.84 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F24 | 1.14 × 101 | 5.60 × 101 | 6.69 × 101 | 9.45 × 101 | 6.99 × 101 | 8.43 × 101 |
| Average F25 | 2.93 × 103 | 2.96 × 103 | 3.35 × 103 | 2.92 × 103 | 2.94 × 103 | 3.21 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F25 | 2.45 × 101 | 3.54 × 101 | 1.18 × 102 | 6.21 × 101 | 6.19 × 101 | 1.23 × 102 |
| Average F26 | 2.99 × 103 | 3.32 × 103 | 4.34 × 103 | 3.53 × 103 | 3.44 × 103 | 3.95 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F26 | 2.08 × 102 | 4.23 × 102 | 3.14 × 102 | 5.50 × 102 | 5.00 × 102 | 3.85 × 102 |
| Average F27 | 3.09 × 103 | 3.12 × 103 | 3.37 × 103 | 3.17 × 103 | 3.15 × 103 | 3.24 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F27 | 2.23 × 100 | 3.49 × 101 | 1.07 × 102 | 5.68 × 101 | 4.15 × 101 | 6.48 × 101 |
| Average F28 | 3.23 × 103 | 3.38 × 103 | 3.86 × 103 | 3.33 × 103 | 3.46 × 103 | 3.73 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F28 | 1.50 × 102 | 9.81 × 101 | 9.07 × 101 | 1.40 × 102 | 1.65 × 102 | 1.38 × 102 |
| Mean F29 | 3.17 × 103 | 3.25 × 103 | 3.65 × 103 | 3.35 × 103 | 3.36 × 103 | 3.37 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F29 | 2.58 × 101 | 6.02 × 101 | 1.52 × 102 | 9.71 × 101 | 8.74 × 101 | 1.26 × 102 |
| Average F30 | 6.92 × 103 | 4.55 × 105 | 6.02 × 107 | 1.61 × 106 | 1.09 × 106 | 1.93 × 107 |
| Standard Deviation F30 | 4.05 × 103 | 4.60 × 105 | 2.91 × 107 | 2.35 × 106 | 1.38 × 106 | 1.81 × 107 |
| Friedman mean | 1.034483 | 2.551724 | 6 | 3.068966 | 3.793103 | 4.551724 |
| Final Rank | 1 | 2 | 6 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| Function | INRBO | NRBO | SSOA | HHO | WOA | AOA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean F1 | 2.39 × 105 | 1.76 × 1010 | 5.56 × 1010 | 3.01 × 107 | 1.66 × 109 | 4.86 × 1010 |
| Standard Deviation F1 | 1.66 × 105 | 4.53 × 109 | 5.47 × 109 | 1.09 × 107 | 6.92 × 108 | 9.97 × 109 |
| Average F3 | 2.01 × 104 | 4.73 × 104 | 9.09 × 104 | 3.91 × 104 | 2.60 × 105 | 8.13 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F3 | 4.90 × 103 | 9.14 × 103 | 2.89 × 103 | 6.12 × 103 | 6.14 × 104 | 1.01 × 104 |
| Average F4 | 5.10 × 102 | 1.84 × 103 | 1.71 × 104 | 5.55 × 102 | 7.66 × 102 | 1.46 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F4 | 2.98 × 101 | 7.27 × 102 | 2.98 × 103 | 2.92 × 101 | 1.13 × 102 | 5.12 × 103 |
| Average F5 | 6.32 × 102 | 8.44 × 102 | 9.56 × 102 | 7.55 × 102 | 8.47 × 102 | 8.81 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F5 | 2.71 × 101 | 4.46 × 101 | 2.11 × 101 | 2.75 × 101 | 6.72 × 101 | 2.95 × 101 |
| Average F6 | 6.25 × 102 | 6.72 × 102 | 7.00 × 102 | 6.67 × 102 | 6.79 × 102 | 6.77 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F6 | 5.90 × 100 | 8.76 × 100 | 7.66 × 100 | 6.73 × 100 | 1.36 × 101 | 7.90 × 100 |
| Average F7 | 8.92 × 102 | 1.21 × 103 | 1.45 × 103 | 1.29 × 103 | 1.28 × 103 | 1.40 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F7 | 3.65 × 101 | 6.33 × 101 | 4.23 × 101 | 7.03 × 101 | 7.02 × 101 | 5.08 × 101 |
| Average F8 | 9.17 × 102 | 1.08 × 103 | 1.17 × 103 | 9.88 × 102 | 1.07 × 103 | 1.12 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F8 | 2.63 × 101 | 3.03 × 101 | 2.15 × 101 | 1.91 × 101 | 6.12 × 101 | 2.87 × 101 |
| Average F9 | 2.64 × 103 | 7.22 × 103 | 1.33 × 104 | 8.08 × 103 | 1.06 × 104 | 7.11 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F9 | 7.43 × 102 | 1.52 × 103 | 2.06 × 103 | 8.65 × 102 | 3.49 × 103 | 1.10 × 103 |
| Average F10 | 5.28 × 103 | 7.85 × 103 | 9.46 × 103 | 5.69 × 103 | 7.26 × 103 | 7.51 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F10 | 5.69 × 102 | 5.63 × 102 | 3.17 × 102 | 5.85 × 102 | 7.10 × 102 | 4.10 × 102 |
| Average F11 | 1.31 × 103 | 2.48 × 103 | 1.00 × 104 | 1.30 × 103 | 6.18 × 103 | 9.42 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F11 | 6.65 × 101 | 7.55 × 102 | 2.36 × 103 | 4.24 × 101 | 2.28 × 103 | 3.63 × 103 |
| Average F12 | 6.43 × 106 | 1.47 × 109 | 1.46 × 1010 | 3.01 × 107 | 2.42 × 108 | 1.35 × 1010 |
| Standard Deviation F12 | 3.76 × 106 | 7.97 × 108 | 3.54 × 109 | 2.24 × 107 | 1.46 × 108 | 2.95 × 109 |
| Average F13 | 8.37 × 104 | 2.46 × 108 | 1.49 × 1010 | 7.28 × 105 | 2.65 × 106 | 1.11 × 1010 |
| Standard Deviation F13 | 4.50 × 104 | 1.69 × 108 | 4.46 × 109 | 8.65 × 105 | 3.83 × 106 | 5.26 × 109 |
| Average F14 | 8.32 × 103 | 1.10 × 105 | 9.65 × 106 | 8.33 × 105 | 2.07 × 106 | 1.91 × 106 |
| Standard Deviation F14 | 9.21 × 103 | 1.97 × 105 | 7.97 × 106 | 7.33 × 105 | 2.86 × 106 | 1.49 × 106 |
| Average F15 | 2.71 × 104 | 1.98 × 106 | 5.20 × 108 | 8.95 × 104 | 1.58 × 106 | 1.83 × 107 |
| Standard Deviation F15 | 1.76 × 104 | 4.79 × 106 | 1.92 × 108 | 5.02 × 104 | 1.77 × 106 | 5.32 × 107 |
| Average F16 | 2.69 × 103 | 3.85 × 103 | 7.00 × 103 | 3.51 × 103 | 4.15 × 103 | 4.92 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F16 | 3.82 × 102 | 4.14 × 102 | 1.07 × 103 | 5.32 × 102 | 4.80 × 102 | 1.12 × 103 |
| Average F17 | 2.22 × 103 | 2.57 × 103 | 5.82 × 103 | 2.64 × 103 | 2.75 × 103 | 3.66 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F17 | 2.20 × 102 | 2.81 × 102 | 2.64 × 103 | 2.91 × 102 | 2.71 × 102 | 1.09 × 103 |
| Average F18 | 2.61 × 105 | 2.61 × 106 | 9.39 × 107 | 2.07 × 106 | 1.14 × 107 | 1.98 × 107 |
| Standard Deviation F18 | 2.27 × 105 | 3.04 × 106 | 5.93 × 107 | 2.60 × 106 | 1.22 × 107 | 2.56 × 107 |
| Average F19 | 2.11 × 104 | 1.28 × 107 | 1.09 × 109 | 9.08 × 105 | 1.22 × 107 | 5.40 × 107 |
| Standard Deviation F19 | 2.15 × 104 | 1.58 × 107 | 5.42 × 108 | 5.38 × 105 | 1.14 × 107 | 1.77 × 108 |
| Average F20 | 2.64 × 103 | 2.81 × 103 | 3.31 × 103 | 2.81 × 103 | 2.80 × 103 | 2.82 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F20 | 1.52 × 102 | 1.93 × 102 | 1.81 × 102 | 1.99 × 102 | 1.90 × 102 | 2.21 × 102 |
| Average F21 | 2.39 × 103 | 2.60 × 103 | 2.79 × 103 | 2.58 × 103 | 2.63 × 103 | 2.66 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F21 | 2.20 × 101 | 3.05 × 101 | 4.58 × 101 | 5.66 × 101 | 6.45 × 101 | 5.16 × 101 |
| Average F22 | 7.09 × 103 | 4.84 × 103 | 1.02 × 104 | 6.81 × 103 | 7.49 × 103 | 9.02 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F22 | 1.13 × 103 | 1.64 × 103 | 7.07 × 102 | 2.03 × 103 | 1.78 × 103 | 8.23 × 102 |
| Average F23 | 2.77 × 103 | 3.06 × 103 | 3.97 × 103 | 3.26 × 103 | 3.11 × 103 | 3.58 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F23 | 2.85 × 101 | 5.54 × 101 | 2.28 × 102 | 1.50 × 102 | 9.23 × 101 | 1.34 × 102 |
| Average F24 | 2.91 × 103 | 3.21 × 103 | 4.18 × 103 | 3.53 × 103 | 3.24 × 103 | 3.92 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F24 | 3.28 × 101 | 5.38 × 101 | 1.79 × 102 | 1.80 × 102 | 8.22 × 101 | 2.17 × 102 |
| Average F25 | 2.92 × 103 | 3.32 × 103 | 5.67 × 103 | 2.94 × 103 | 3.10 × 103 | 5.55 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F25 | 2.31 × 101 | 2.13 × 102 | 5.02 × 102 | 1.95 × 101 | 5.71 × 101 | 7.84 × 102 |
| Average F26 | 5.02 × 103 | 7.21 × 103 | 1.15 × 104 | 7.33 × 103 | 8.07 × 103 | 1.06 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F26 | 3.40 × 102 | 1.22 × 103 | 7.93 × 102 | 1.59 × 103 | 9.08 × 102 | 1.04 × 103 |
| Average F27 | 3.25 × 103 | 3.42 × 103 | 5.15 × 103 | 3.49 × 103 | 3.47 × 103 | 4.59 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F27 | 2.08 × 101 | 1.01 × 102 | 4.91 × 102 | 1.93 × 102 | 1.33 × 102 | 3.98 × 102 |
| Average F28 | 4.39 × 103 | 4.09 × 103 | 7.29 × 103 | 3.34 × 103 | 3.59 × 103 | 6.96 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F28 | 1.44 × 103 | 3.64 × 102 | 5.44 × 102 | 4.61 × 101 | 1.19 × 102 | 7.72 × 102 |
| Average F29 | 4.28 × 103 | 5.03 × 103 | 8.74 × 103 | 4.67 × 103 | 5.20 × 103 | 7.21 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F29 | 1.97 × 102 | 3.51 × 102 | 1.35 × 103 | 4.61 × 102 | 5.63 × 102 | 1.87 × 103 |
| Average F30 | 3.83 × 105 | 6.10 × 107 | 2.19 × 109 | 4.46 × 106 | 4.09 × 107 | 1.90 × 109 |
| Standard Deviation F30 | 2.59 × 105 | 4.47 × 107 | 9.67 × 108 | 2.69 × 106 | 3.33 × 107 | 1.42 × 109 |
| Friedman mean | 1.206897 | 3.103448 | 5.965517 | 2.413793 | 3.551724 | 4.758621 |
| Final Rank | 1.00 | 3 | 6 | 2.00 | 4.00 | 5 |
| Function | INRBO | NRBO | SSOA | HHO | WOA | AOA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean F1 | 4.02 × 107 | 4.96 × 1010 | 1.12 × 1011 | 2.54 × 108 | 7.95 × 109 | 1.10 × 1011 |
| Standard Deviation F1 | 1.69 × 107 | 6.89 × 109 | 6.13 × 109 | 6.37 × 107 | 2.79 × 109 | 1.21 × 1010 |
| Average F3 | 1.04 × 105 | 1.43 × 105 | 5.06 × 106 | 1.34 × 105 | 2.42 × 105 | 1.77 × 105 |
| Standard Deviation F3 | 2.23 × 104 | 2.08 × 104 | 1.42 × 107 | 2.27 × 104 | 7.42 × 104 | 2.26 × 104 |
| Average F4 | 6.80 × 102 | 9.03 × 103 | 3.61 × 104 | 8.67 × 102 | 2.64 × 103 | 3.46 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F4 | 4.95 × 101 | 2.77 × 103 | 4.33 × 103 | 1.79 × 102 | 8.94 × 102 | 7.31 × 103 |
| Average F5 | 7.82 × 102 | 1.11 × 103 | 1.23 × 103 | 9.13 × 102 | 1.07 × 103 | 1.17 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F5 | 4.76 × 101 | 4.48 × 101 | 3.32 × 101 | 2.60 × 101 | 6.67 × 101 | 3.14 × 101 |
| Average F6 | 6.44 × 102 | 6.88 × 102 | 7.11 × 102 | 6.78 × 102 | 6.91 × 102 | 6.95 × 102 |
| Standard Deviation F6 | 6.75 × 100 | 9.17 × 100 | 6.15 × 100 | 5.35 × 100 | 1.16 × 101 | 7.02 × 100 |
| Average F7 | 1.20 × 103 | 1.81 × 103 | 2.05 × 103 | 1.85 × 103 | 1.83 × 103 | 1.96 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F7 | 6.83 × 101 | 1.32 × 102 | 5.86 × 101 | 9.62 × 101 | 1.06 × 102 | 5.43 × 101 |
| Average F8 | 1.08 × 103 | 1.43 × 103 | 1.56 × 103 | 1.22 × 103 | 1.35 × 103 | 1.48 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F8 | 3.95 × 101 | 5.47 × 101 | 2.53 × 101 | 3.43 × 101 | 7.29 × 101 | 4.25 × 101 |
| Average F9 | 9.28 × 103 | 2.77 × 104 | 4.35 × 104 | 3.01 × 104 | 3.57 × 104 | 3.08 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F9 | 2.51 × 103 | 4.78 × 103 | 3.24 × 103 | 3.78 × 103 | 9.45 × 103 | 4.04 × 103 |
| Average F10 | 9.89 × 103 | 1.41 × 104 | 1.64 × 104 | 9.53 × 103 | 1.26 × 104 | 1.39 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F10 | 1.01 × 103 | 7.18 × 102 | 5.90 × 102 | 1.33 × 103 | 1.09 × 103 | 9.29 × 102 |
| Average F11 | 1.63 × 103 | 1.01 × 104 | 2.55 × 104 | 1.80 × 103 | 5.42 × 103 | 2.26 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F11 | 1.31 × 102 | 2.25 × 103 | 2.47 × 103 | 1.76 × 102 | 1.68 × 103 | 3.44 × 103 |
| Average F12 | 5.37 × 107 | 1.47 × 1010 | 8.10 × 1010 | 1.99 × 108 | 1.90 × 109 | 7.76 × 1010 |
| Standard Deviation F12 | 3.06 × 107 | 5.36 × 109 | 1.03 × 1010 | 1.44 × 108 | 8.74 × 108 | 1.64 × 1010 |
| Average F13 | 1.09 × 105 | 3.64 × 109 | 4.85 × 1010 | 4.94 × 106 | 1.65 × 108 | 3.76 × 1010 |
| Standard Deviation F13 | 7.12 × 104 | 2.01 × 109 | 1.17 × 1010 | 1.67 × 106 | 1.27 × 108 | 1.03 × 1010 |
| Average F14 | 1.32 × 105 | 2.57 × 106 | 2.10 × 108 | 3.04 × 106 | 5.42 × 106 | 7.83 × 107 |
| Standard Deviation F14 | 8.57 × 104 | 2.30 × 106 | 8.74 × 107 | 2.64 × 106 | 5.04 × 106 | 6.67 × 107 |
| Average F15 | 7.33 × 104 | 3.05 × 108 | 7.94 × 109 | 8.76 × 105 | 1.24 × 107 | 6.80 × 109 |
| Standard Deviation F15 | 5.84 × 104 | 1.74 × 108 | 2.55 × 109 | 3.81 × 105 | 1.79 × 107 | 4.13 × 109 |
| Average F16 | 3.57 × 103 | 5.83 × 103 | 1.04 × 104 | 4.53 × 103 | 5.89 × 103 | 8.36 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F16 | 4.79 × 102 | 6.96 × 102 | 1.32 × 103 | 6.33 × 102 | 9.26 × 102 | 1.58 × 103 |
| Average F17 | 3.35 × 103 | 4.67 × 103 | 1.31 × 104 | 3.76 × 103 | 4.16 × 103 | 1.24 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F17 | 3.30 × 102 | 4.80 × 102 | 5.51 × 103 | 4.38 × 102 | 5.22 × 102 | 4.58 × 103 |
| Average F18 | 8.95 × 105 | 1.67 × 107 | 2.64 × 108 | 5.58 × 106 | 4.63 × 107 | 1.39 × 108 |
| Standard Deviation F18 | 6.72 × 105 | 9.34 × 106 | 1.09 × 108 | 4.07 × 106 | 4.10 × 107 | 1.10 × 108 |
| Average F19 | 1.67 × 105 | 1.46 × 108 | 5.05 × 109 | 1.52 × 106 | 7.45 × 106 | 4.07 × 109 |
| Standard Deviation F19 | 1.93 × 105 | 9.07 × 107 | 1.22 × 109 | 1.23 × 106 | 6.44 × 106 | 1.75 × 109 |
| Average F20 | 3.36 × 103 | 3.80 × 103 | 4.64 × 103 | 3.50 × 103 | 3.85 × 103 | 3.74 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F20 | 4.26 × 102 | 2.88 × 102 | 1.90 × 102 | 3.42 × 102 | 3.81 × 102 | 2.24 × 102 |
| Average F21 | 2.55 × 103 | 2.96 × 103 | 3.30 × 103 | 2.91 × 103 | 3.01 × 103 | 3.08 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F21 | 4.33 × 101 | 8.20 × 101 | 8.38 × 101 | 9.89 × 101 | 1.07 × 102 | 9.07 × 101 |
| Average F22 | 1.18 × 104 | 1.57 × 104 | 1.83 × 104 | 1.22 × 104 | 1.40 × 104 | 1.61 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F22 | 1.18 × 103 | 1.17 × 103 | 4.92 × 102 | 8.16 × 102 | 1.12 × 103 | 4.78 × 102 |
| Average F23 | 3.04 × 103 | 3.59 × 103 | 5.04 × 103 | 3.96 × 103 | 3.80 × 103 | 4.52 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F23 | 6.61 × 101 | 9.10 × 101 | 2.80 × 102 | 1.87 × 102 | 1.89 × 102 | 2.02 × 102 |
| Average F24 | 3.12 × 103 | 3.72 × 103 | 5.52 × 103 | 4.34 × 103 | 3.86 × 103 | 4.96 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F24 | 5.76 × 101 | 1.13 × 102 | 2.98 × 102 | 2.42 × 102 | 1.59 × 102 | 3.76 × 102 |
| Average F25 | 3.17 × 103 | 6.95 × 103 | 1.58 × 104 | 3.27 × 103 | 4.10 × 103 | 1.58 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F25 | 5.67 × 101 | 1.11 × 103 | 8.31 × 102 | 6.56 × 101 | 2.32 × 102 | 1.59 × 103 |
| Mean F26 | 6.92 × 103 | 1.24 × 104 | 1.77 × 104 | 1.12 × 104 | 1.39 × 104 | 1.70 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F26 | 5.84 × 102 | 1.77 × 103 | 6.27 × 102 | 1.50 × 103 | 1.81 × 103 | 1.28 × 103 |
| Average F27 | 3.64 × 103 | 4.33 × 103 | 8.53 × 103 | 4.76 × 103 | 4.85 × 103 | 6.76 × 103 |
| Standard Deviation F27 | 8.52 × 101 | 3.86 × 102 | 8.22 × 102 | 5.68 × 102 | 5.44 × 102 | 5.90 × 102 |
| Average F28 | 7.44 × 103 | 7.24 × 103 | 1.37 × 104 | 3.82 × 103 | 5.15 × 103 | 1.23 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F28 | 2.32 × 103 | 6.67 × 102 | 1.13 × 103 | 1.25 × 102 | 4.36 × 102 | 1.43 × 103 |
| Average F29 | 5.62 × 103 | 7.99 × 103 | 1.64 × 105 | 6.66 × 103 | 8.82 × 103 | 6.37 × 104 |
| Standard Deviation F29 | 6.17 × 102 | 1.15 × 103 | 2.53 × 105 | 9.27 × 102 | 1.22 × 103 | 9.38 × 104 |
| Average F30 | 1.92 × 107 | 4.96 × 108 | 8.69 × 109 | 7.24 × 107 | 2.64 × 108 | 6.26 × 109 |
| Standard Deviation F30 | 5.83 × 106 | 1.93 × 108 | 2.75 × 109 | 2.92 × 107 | 1.10 × 108 | 3.47 × 109 |
| Friedman Mean Rank | 1.137931 | 3.344828 | 5.965517 | 2.241379 | 3.448276 | 4.862069 |
| Final Standings | 1.00 | 3 | 6 | 2.00 | 4.00 | 5 |
| Function | Metric | INRBO | NRBO | SSOA | HHO | WOA | AOA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | Mean | 300.0003 | 1300.6107 | 14,853.4986 | 313.9965 | 19,157.1786 | 9524.7233 |
| Std | 0.0004 | 1010.2348 | 5059.2511 | 17.1461 | 10,463.3968 | 4743.1445 | |
| F2 | Mean | 406.0718 | 445.5376 | 1914.3864 | 432.2151 | 440.4238 | 1311.8376 |
| Std | 2.6481 | 33.4958 | 839.3589 | 43.3382 | 50.2839 | 556.4257 | |
| F3 | Mean | 601.0722 | 627.3387 | 661.8728 | 635.8405 | 633.0072 | 640.4635 |
| Std | 1.0715 | 9.4082 | 7.9214 | 11.2947 | 11.6183 | 9.7146 | |
| F4 | Mean | 816.6533 | 832.3989 | 863.7452 | 825.0539 | 839.4115 | 828.9885 |
| Std | 7.8263 | 11.2754 | 10.0967 | 9.0855 | 16.4232 | 8.4257 | |
| F5 | Mean | 907.6952 | 1058.2495 | 1716.2517 | 1368.1470 | 1381.2034 | 1330.1367 |
| Std | 19.6917 | 122.7478 | 207.6563 | 178.2543 | 238.5497 | 165.6407 | |
| F6 | Mean | 3489.9944 | 4553.3395 | 2.67 × 108 | 5248.3239 | 3953.4724 | 154,398.4928 |
| Std | 1829.2603 | 2024.5967 | 3.15 × 108 | 2826.2056 | 1793.5886 | 823,816.6251 | |
| F7 | Mean | 2023.4353 | 2059.0767 | 2140.0668 | 2071.7825 | 2077.3921 | 2095.7093 |
| Std | 3.7396 | 22.0271 | 22.9690 | 38.5344 | 33.5342 | 23.0277 | |
| F8 | Mean | 2221.4578 | 2254.5032 | 2413.7417 | 2231.1344 | 2232.0582 | 2300.6136 |
| Std | 4.9132 | 49.1313 | 131.4398 | 9.1789 | 5.7809 | 104.8234 | |
| F9 | Mean | 2529.2847 | 2581.4051 | 2809.8528 | 2580.1931 | 2578.0987 | 2723.8787 |
| Std | 0.0004 | 55.4082 | 51.9550 | 39.1384 | 46.3551 | 50.9445 | |
| F10 | Mean | 2500.5730 | 2578.7062 | 2839.9847 | 2600.7115 | 2704.6407 | 2672.2746 |
| Std | 0.1567 | 68.3800 | 376.2897 | 92.7741 | 364.6072 | 140.5760 | |
| F11 | Mean | 2780.4744 | 2851.3746 | 3797.1471 | 2771.0581 | 2937.1144 | 3080.3682 |
| Std | 222.1153 | 141.8395 | 439.4374 | 127.0578 | 118.9649 | 234.5626 | |
| F12 | Mean | 2863.4330 | 2869.0100 | 3121.5973 | 2931.8036 | 2905.7553 | 3040.7334 |
| Function | INRBO | NRBO | SSOA | HHO | WOA | AOA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | - | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + |
| F2 | - | 9.92 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 1.68 × 10−3 + | 1.04 × 10−4 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + |
| F3 | - | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + |
| F4 | - | 4.11 × 10−7 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 4.22 × 10−4 + | 2.60 × 10−8 + | 1.29 × 10−6 + |
| F5 | - | 1.21 × 10−10 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.34 × 10−11 + |
| F6 | - | 1.99 × 10−2 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.67 × 10−3 + | 9.93 × 10−2 | 7.01 × 10−2 |
| F7 | - | 4.98 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 1.09 × 10−10 + | 4.50 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + |
| F8 | - | 8.15 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 1.07 × 10−9 + | 1.69 × 10−9 + | 3.69 × 10−11 + |
| F9 | - | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + |
| F10 | - | 9.92 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 9.06 × 10−8 + | 2.02 × 10−8 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + |
| F11 | - | 7.48 × 10−2 | 2.37 × 10−10 + | 5.37 × 10−2 | 5.27 × 10−5 + | 6.77 × 10−5 + |
| F12 | - | 3.26 × 10−7 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + | 1.33 × 10−10 + | 3.34 × 10−11 + | 3.02 × 10−11 + |
| Average Rank | 1.08 | 2.92 | 5.92 | 2.83 | 3.75 | 4.50 |
| Method | M | K | Fitness | MSE | RMSE | MAE | SNR | R2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SSA | 30 | 5 | - | 128.890 | 11.3530 | 8.8365 | 14.12 | 0.9612 |
| NRBO-SSA | 27 | 6 | 6.426213 | 104.130 | 10.2045 | 7.8302 | 15.04 | 0.9687 |
| INRBO-SSA | 36 | 8 | 6.413245 | 85.995 | 9.2734 | 7.0891 | 15.87 | 0.9741 |
| Model | MAE | RMSE | MAPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| LSTM | 19.4959 | 23.1557 | 8.63% |
| GRU | 27.7485 | 32.9407 | 12.54% |
| TCN | 20.9476 | 25.1366 | 9.47% |
| CNN | 28.5331 | 34.2072 | 12.99% |
| Transformer | 35.407 | 42.0107 | 15.95% |
| Model | MAE | RMSE | MAPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| SSA-LSTM | 11.1109 | 13.6583 | 4.76% |
| EMD-LSTM | 13.0152 | 16.372 | 5.56% |
| VMD-LSTM | 12.6055 | 15.2834 | 5.36% |
| CEEMDAN-LSTM | 16.2324 | 19.5441 | 7.01% |
| Model | MAE | RMSE | MAPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| INRBO-SSA-LSTM | 8.7393 | 10.8314 | 3.72% |
| INRBO-SSA-NRBO-LSTM | 9.5257 | 11.7973 | 4.07% |
| INRBO-SSA-SSOA-LSTM | 9.611 | 11.8493 | 4.11% |
| INRBO-SSA-HHO-LSTM | 9.7191 | 12.0037 | 4.16% |
| INRBO-SSA-WOA-LSTM | 9.6948 | 11.9504 | 4.15% |
| INRBO-SSA-AOA-LSTM | 9.4999 | 11.7293 | 4.07% |
| Model | MAE | RMSE | MAPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| INRBO-SSA-LSTM | 5.9071 | 7.5398 | 2.47% |
| INRBO-SSA-NRBO-LSTM | 9.7505 | 12.452 | 3.98% |
| INRBO-SSA-SSOA-LSTM | 9.6703 | 12.3292 | 3.95% |
| INRBO-SSA-HHO-LSTM | 9.2345 | 11.7638 | 3.78% |
| INRBO-SSA-WOA-LSTM | 9.8999 | 12.5907 | 4.04% |
| INRBO-SSA-AOA-LSTM | 9.6937 | 12.3309 | 3.96% |
| Model | MAE | RMSE | MAPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| INRBO-SSA-LSTM | 5.5114 | 7.3276 | 2.48% |
| INRBO-SSA-NRBO-LSTM | 8.4872 | 10.7171 | 3.82% |
| INRBO-SSA-SSOA-LSTM | 8.5241 | 10.7537 | 3.83% |
| INRBO-SSA-HHO-LSTM | 9.9321 | 12.4598 | 4.49% |
| INRBO-SSA-WOA-LSTM | 8.2632 | 10.4343 | 3.72% |
| INRBO-SSA-AOA-LSTM | 8.1635 | 10.3055 | 3.67% |
| Model | MAE | RMSE | MAPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| INRBO-SSA-LSTM | 5.6948 | 7.4021 | 2.18% |
| INRBO-SSA-NRBO-LSTM | 7.0432 | 9.072 | 2.68% |
| INRBO-SSA-SSOA-LSTM | 7.0696 | 9.0535 | 2.69% |
| INRBO-SSA-HHO-LSTM | 7.0121 | 9.0902 | 2.67% |
| INRBO-SSA-WOA-LSTM | 6.984 | 9.0186 | 2.66% |
| INRBO-SSA-AOA-LSTM | 6.7597 | 8.6913 | 2.58% |
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.
Share and Cite
Luo, J.; Chen, F.; Kong, L.; Liu, H. An INRBO-SSA-LSTM Hybrid Framework for Short-Term Power Load Forecasting in Smart Microgrids. Electronics 2026, 15, 3044. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics15143044
Luo J, Chen F, Kong L, Liu H. An INRBO-SSA-LSTM Hybrid Framework for Short-Term Power Load Forecasting in Smart Microgrids. Electronics. 2026; 15(14):3044. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics15143044
Chicago/Turabian StyleLuo, Jinming, Fujia Chen, Lingshang Kong, and Huijie Liu. 2026. "An INRBO-SSA-LSTM Hybrid Framework for Short-Term Power Load Forecasting in Smart Microgrids" Electronics 15, no. 14: 3044. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics15143044
APA StyleLuo, J., Chen, F., Kong, L., & Liu, H. (2026). An INRBO-SSA-LSTM Hybrid Framework for Short-Term Power Load Forecasting in Smart Microgrids. Electronics, 15(14), 3044. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics15143044
