In-Line Target Production for Laser IFE

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Your manuscript needs to be revised before it can be accepted.

Comments for author File: Comments.pdf

Author Response

Dear Sir!

We have revised the manuscript #applsci-691813 according your comments, namely:

Abstract: it was improved; the abbreviation of "FST" is supported with the full meaning Whole text: minor spell checking were made; the iterations from the text were took off Introduction was improved according your comments The newly obtained results are presented more clearly in order to avoid the dual or multiple publications References are improved according you comments

Sincerely yours,

Elena Koresheva

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Reviewer 2 Report

Review Report: "In-line target production for laser IFE", by  
Irina Aleksandrova , et al.

 

      The manuscript proposes a new method of a spherical inertial fusion target fabrication and its injection into a reactor. The manuscript is rather well organized, and presents the new results in this research field of Inertial Confinement Fusion. Before its publication, Authors are recommended to clarify the followings points:

 

1) The new results in the target fabrication and in the target injection have been published in Refs. [2]-[12] by the Authors previously. The differences must be clearly explained in the paper between the present work and the previous works in Refs. [2]-[12], in order to avoid the dual or multiple publications.

 

2) The following closely relating works must be cited in the paper. For example, the following references must be cited in the paper: [1]. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fusengdes.2006.07.071,  [2]. https://doi.org/10.1109/TPS.2018.2876471.

 

3) The English presentation style should be polished up throughout the paper. For example, in Abstract the abbreviation of "FST" first appears without showing the full meaning.

 

Author Response

Dear Sir

We have revised the manuscript #applsci-691813 according your comments, namely:

Abstract: it was improved, the abbreviation of "FST" is supported with the full meaning Whole text: minor spell cheking were made; the iterations from the text were took off Introduction was improved The newly obtained results are presented more clearly in order to avoid the dual or multiple publications References are improved.

Sincerely yours,

Elena Koresheva

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf