Skip to Content
You are currently on the new version of our website. Access the old version .
BuildingsBuildings
  • Article
  • Open Access

9 January 2026

23 Pages

The Revitalization Path of Historical and Cultural Districts Based on the Concept of Urban Memory: A Case Study of Shangcheng, Huangling County

,
,
,
,
,
and
1
School of Architecture, Chang’an University, Xi’an 710061, China
2
Xi’an International Science and Technology Cooperation Base: International Joint Research Center for Green Urban Rural and Land Space Smart Construction Technology Innovation, Xi’an 710061, China
3
Construction of Virtual Teaching and Research Room for Land and Space Planning Major, Xi’an 710061, China
4
Shaanxi Provincial Federation of Social Sciences Circles, Xi’an 710061, China

Abstract

The prevailing challenges of fading characteristics and identity crises in historical and cultural districts of small and medium-sized cities have been identified. Traditional analytical methods have been found to be deficient in systematically capturing the unique forms and urban memory of these districts. The present study thus adopts the Shangcheng Historical and Cultural District of Huangling County as a case study, proposing a comprehensive analytical framework that integrates urban memory and multi-dimensional methods such as space syntax, grounded-theory-inspired coding, and urban image analysis. The district is subject to a systematic assessment of its spatial form, structural design, and the mechanisms by which urban memory is conveyed. The proposal sets out targeted renewal strategies for four aspects: paths, edges, nodes and landmarks, and districts. The research findings are as follows: (1) Paths with high integration and connection degrees simultaneously serve as both sacrificial axes and carriers of folk narratives. (2) Edges are composed of the city wall ruins, Loess Plateau landform, and street spaces. The fishbone-like street structure leads to significant differences in the connection degrees of main and secondary roads. (3) Nodes such as Guanyv Temple-Confucian Temple, the South Gate, and the North City Wall Ruins Square have high visual control, while the visual integration and visual control of the Qiaoshan Middle School and Gongsun Road historical nodes are relatively low, and their spatial accessibility is insufficient. (4) Based on the “memory–space” coupling relationship, the district is divided into the Academy Life Area, the Historical and Cultural Core Experience Area, and the Comprehensive Service Area, providing an effective path to alleviate the problem of functional homogenization. The present study proffers a novel perspective on the revitalization mechanisms of historical districts in small and medium-sized cities, encompassing both theoretical integration and practical strategy levels. It further contributes methodological inspirations and localized planning experiences for addressing the cultural disconnection and spatial inactivity problems of historical urban areas on a global scale.

1. Introduction

Historic and cultural districts, as the material carriers of urban memory, are the spatial crystallization of local cultural characteristics and collective identity. In the context of the ongoing influence of global urbanization, the effective protection and revitalization of these valuable historical assets, and their integration into contemporary urban development, has emerged as a pressing global concern [1,2]. This issue is especially pressing in small and medium-sized cities, where their historic and cultural districts are typically confronted with significant challenges, including the erasure of distinctive identities and the decline of a local sense of belonging. These challenges are particularly evident in the fragmentation of spatial structure, the deterioration of cultural memory, and the dilemma between protection and development [3].
Historic and cultural districts are not only the physical remnants of a city, but also the spatial carriers of collective memory, cultural identity, and social relationships. The research paradigm has evolved from the preservation of physical forms to the holistic inheritance of values. The related research can be divided into three themes. The first is updated value cognition, with related research aiming to elevate protection and renewal from “the preservation of objects” to “the continuation of meaning”. Specifically, the research emphasizes the value of social cohesion and local identity, and through empirical quantitative analysis, it has confirmed the positive correlation between heritage site visits, heritage consciousness, community belonging, and social network strength [4,5]. The public value theory was introduced and developed, defining the success criteria of district renewal as the collaborative creation and distribution of economic, social, cultural, and environmental public values [6,7]. Subjective dimensions such as memory, perception, and experience were main areas of focus, with indicators like “place and memory” being developed [8], and methods such as social media data and questionnaire surveys have been utilized to capture the emotional cognition and value evaluation of the public towards heritage [7,9]. These studies provide a theoretical basis for understanding districts as “living places” and “memory spaces”. The second theme is the process mechanism and governance model of renewal, with related research focusing on the question of “how to renew”, emphasizing the adaptability, participation, and systematic nature of the process. On one hand, research advocates participatory decision-making and collaborative governance, proposing a systematic participatory assessment framework [10] and exploring the key role of community governance in public space renewal [11]. On the other hand, in response to the fragmentation of governance, a multi-level, differentiated adaptive governance framework has been proposed, such as the “city-district-street” three-level linkage strategy [12], and a gradual “micro-renewal” path for “non-protected historical districts” [13]. Additionally, the concepts of circular economy [10] and urban resilience [14,15] have been introduced, viewing renewal as a process of resource circulation and value regeneration, and emphasizing that districts should possess the ability to adapt and transform in response to external shocks. The third theme is the technical methods and evaluation system of renewal, with related research focusing on “how to understand and evaluate” districts, aiming to develop refined and scientific analytical tools. Firstly, spatial syntax theory and multi-source data integration have become hotspots. Research widely employs spatial syntax analysis of street network structural characteristics [13] and integrates big data such as street view images, POI, and mobile phone signaling to quantitatively assess spatial vitality, functional mix, and environmental quality [12,16]. Secondly, a systematic evaluation system is continuously constructed, such as the form resilience assessment framework [15], the multi-dimensional layered analysis method based on historical urban landscape [17], and the coupling coordination degree model [18]. Finally, multi-criteria decision analysis methods were employed for scheme comparison, supporting scientific decision-making. These technical methods provided strong support for a profound understanding of the spatial form and functions of the neighborhood.
Although the protection and renewal of historical and cultural districts have achieved remarkable results, providing important references for the comprehensive analysis framework of historical districts in medium-sized cities based on the concept of urban memory proposed in this paper, the existing research still has the following deficiencies in integrating urban memory with spatial form analysis, adapting to the context of small and medium-sized cities, and generating urban memory-oriented renewal strategies: Firstly, there is a lack of a systematic translation platform for memory and space. Existing research either focuses on the quantitative morphological quantification of spatial syntax or on the description of memory based on grounded theory [19]. However, space and memory are merely regarded as separate descriptive dimensions, lacking a structured theoretical interface to systematically translate the urban memory into identifiable and operable spatial design elements. This results in the inability of the demand for preserving memory to substantially guide the specific optimization of spatial structure, causing a separation between the memory of historical districts and spatial design. Secondly, the exploration and integration of “local knowledge” of distinctive cultural districts with distinct regional characteristics in medium-sized cities is insufficient. Existing research cases are mostly concentrated in large cities or famous tourist destinations [20], and although their method models have certain reference value, they face challenges in terms of applicability for a large number of medium-sized cities’ historical districts that are facing material decline, low commercial vitality, aging population structure, and sparse daily pedestrian flow. These districts often exhibit the characteristic of sparse data, few commercial POIs, scarce dynamic human flow data such as mobile phone signals, and lagging street scene image updates, making quantitative analysis methods relying on such big data difficult to effectively capture and translate the unique local narratives and cultural practices hidden in these areas [13]. Thirdly, renewal strategies often fail to be integrated with spatial logic and urban memory. Although many studies have proposed renewal strategies involving spatial elements, they are often based on universal functional requirements or esthetic principles, failing to be associated with the “space–memory” of specific districts and also unable to shape the place spirit and unique experiences.
In order to address the research gap identified above, this study takes the historical and cultural area of Shangcheng in Huangling County, China, as an empirical case, aiming to explore the following core issues: (1) How can a spatial diagnostic framework that can systematically translate urban memories be constructed? (2) Considering the scarce dynamic data of historical districts in small and medium-sized cities, how can we analyze the insufficient spatial efficacy and historical inheritance predicament of historical districts? (3) How can we construct a set of “space–memory” coupled analysis-driven update and governance strategies? To address these issues, this study has constructed a “memory–space” coupled analysis framework with a structured translation interface based on urban imagery. The core innovation of this framework does not lie in the innovation of a single method but in providing a systematic diagnostic and strategy generation logic for cultural districts in small and medium-sized cities. Its main contributions are manifested in the following three aspects: At the theoretical level, it proposes urban imagery as the operational interface for memory–space translation. The key theoretical advancement of this study lies in establishing urban imagery as a translation platform connecting urban memories and quantitative spatial analysis, deconstructing, classifying, and precisely mapping abstract collective memory narratives onto specific spatial elements, thereby achieving the transformation from cultural narratives to spatial design language. At the methodological level, a set of mixed analysis paths for reference in small and medium-sized cities’ historical districts with scarce data has been designed. In response to the data predicament of small and medium-sized cities, this study attempts to propose a mixed-method chain of “analyzing historical documents–conducting field investigations–extracting imagery elements–verifying spatial syntax”, providing a reference analysis method for similar themed but data-limited districts. At the strategic level, a decision-making logic for coupling diagnosis-driven cultural space update strategies has been established. The strategy generation of this study follows the logic of “space syntax diagnosis–memory encoding diagnosis–identifying actual problems–proposing update strategies”, ensuring that the strategies have corresponding spatial syntax and memory encoding analysis as the basis, and proposing a collaborative governance mechanism to ensure the dual goals of space optimization and cultural continuation of the update strategies are achieved. This exploration is not only an expansion and integration of existing urban memory theories and spatial analysis techniques but also a supplement to research cases and methods regarding the revitalization of cultural heritage in small and medium-sized cities.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Study Area

In this study, we selected the Shangcheng Historical and Cultural District in Huangling County, Shaanxi Province, as a typical case (Figure 1). Huangling County is the location of the Mausoleum of the Yellow Emperor and has a unique cultural status. According to the seventh national population census in 2020, the permanent population of Huangling County was approximately 127,000, with an urbanization rate of 62.81% and a per capita regional GDP of CNY 142,000. It is a typical small city in the western region. Shangcheng has a deep historical connection with the duty of guarding and worshiping the Yellow Emperor’s Mausoleum and has formed a spatial and cultural pattern where the “mausoleum–town” coexist and thrive together. The total area of the district is 17.3 hectares, with 1199 residents, 468 households, and 294 courtyards. There are 19 historical buildings preserved. The district is located at the southern foot of Bridge Mountain and has a Loess Plateau landform, with the south being lower and the north being higher, with a height difference of approximately 60 m.
Figure 1. Location analysis chart.
However, similar to many historical districts of small cities, Shangcheng is facing a series of typical development challenges: (1) With the relocation of Bridge Mountain Middle School and the migration of residents to the new town, the population continues to decline, and the vitality of the district is receding. (2) The land structure is mainly composed of urban residential areas (46.4%), with a lack of cultural, public service, and green space facilities and an unbalanced layout. (3) The architectural styles on both sides of Xuanyu Street are mixed, street spaces are fragmented, and cultural memory carriers are gradually disappearing. These phenomena reflect the common problems encountered by historical districts of small cities in the rapid urbanization process. Therefore, taking Shangcheng as the research object not only helps to dissect its own protection and renewal path but also provides empirical reference for similar historical districts of small cities to address cultural rupture and spatial deactivation issues, which has significant practical significance and disciplinary value [21,22].

2.2. Research Method

This study innovatively integrates three methods, space syntax, grounded-theory-inspired coding, and urban image, to construct a sequential research framework of “Objective Spatial Structure Analysis–Subjective Memory Cognition Decoding–Spatial Memory Association Analysis and Problem Exploration–Comprehensive Strategy Generation” [23,24] (Figure 2). Firstly, spatial syntax is used for axial analysis and visibility analysis to quantify indicators such as connectivity, integration, and control of the street network and to analyze the spatial structure. Secondly, the memory text is encoded in three levels to systematically understand local memory. Then, using urban imagery as a structured integration platform, the quantitative results of spatial syntax are correlated and compared with memory coding to identify the problems faced by Shangcheng renewal. From the four dimensions of path, edge, node and landmark, and district, specific “mausoleum–town” symbiotic activation strategies are proposed to form a research loop from problem identification to solution generation.
Figure 2. Research framework diagram.

2.2.1. Spatial Syntactic Analysis

In the domain of spatial syntax, three distinct analysis methods are recognized. Axial analysis is employed when the space is distributed linearly [25]; convex space analysis is used when the space is distributed in a nodal pattern. Visibility analysis is implemented when there is obvious occlusion in the space. However, several core analytical indicators are similar, including connectivity, integration, depth, control, and intelligibility [26]. In this study, the primary analytical methods employed were axis analysis and visibility analysis [27].
Connectivity, defined as the number of spaces where a specific space intersects within a system, serves as a fundamental indicator for quantifying accessibility in urban form analysis. The formula is as follows:
∁ i = k i ,
Integration signifies the extent of aggregation or dispersion between a specific element and other elements within a spatial system [28], thereby underscoring the centrality of space within the broader system. The degree of integration within a given space directly correlates with its accessibility, centrality, and the ease with which people flow can be gathered. The formula is as follows:
I N T i = n log 2 n − 2 / 3 − 1 + 1 n − 1 M D i ,
In the system, i represents a specific street (i = 1, 2, …, n); k is the total number of streets close to street i.
Control represents the degree to which a certain space is controlled by an intersection and is numerically equal to the sum of the reciprocals of the connection values of the adjacent spaces. The formula is as follows:
C t r l = ∑ j = 1 k 1 ∁ i ,
The street adjacent to i is denoted by j (j = 1, 2, …, k); Ci is the connection value.
The concept of “depth” in this context refers to the minimum number of connections necessary to establish a path between two distinct spaces from a given space [29]. The arithmetic mean of the average depth values of each node is equivalent to the global depth value. A reduced depth value signifies enhanced accessibility to the node. The formula is as follows:
M D i = 1 n − 1 × T D i ,
T D i = ∑ j = 1 n d i j ,
M D i = ∑ j = 1 n d i j n − 1 ,
The minimum number of steps between street I and street J is denoted as dij, while n represents the total number of streets.
Intelligibility is defined as the number of axes directly connected to a specific axis, thereby determining the importance of that axis within the overall system. This concept involves a direct correlation between the connection degree of the axis and its global integration degree. A higher degree of relevance indicates a higher degree of understandability, suggesting that the overall spatial structure can be inferred from the local spatial structure. The formula is as follows:
R i 2 = ∑ C i − C ¯ I N T i − I N T g ¯ 2 ∑ C i − C ¯ ∑ I N T i − I N T g ¯ 2 ,
The spatial basic model used in this research is essentially a two-dimensional plane model. Although we obtained the terrain height difference and building height data through on-site survey, this three-dimensional information was not incorporated into the computational model in the spatial syntactic axis analysis and field of view analysis. This constitutes the simplification of the spatial expression in this study.

2.2.2. Grounded-Theory-Inspired Coding

In order to systematically sort out and extract the urban memories carried by the neighborhoods, this study employs a three-level coding method inspired by grounded theory to analyze the textual data [30]. Open coding involves analyzing the collected historical documents and interview texts to extract initial concepts. Main axis coding involves clustering the initial concepts according to the five elements of urban imagery to form higher-level concepts, such as “paths memory”, “edges memory”, “nodes memory”, etc. Selective coding involves further systematizing and integrating data on the basis of main axis coding to refine the core classification of all concepts. The coding method focusing on the evolution process and development context, such as the evolution of urban spatial layout and sacrificial routes, is classified as diachronic memory. The coding method focusing on the structure and state at a certain moment, such as architectural nodes and functional positioning, is classified as synchronic memory. Thus, a coding system for urban memory is constructed [31].
To ensure the objectivity of the coding, another researcher was invited to independently code 20% of the randomly selected texts. Inter-coder reliability was calculated using the method established by Holsti, and the results are presented as follows:
R = n K n − 1 k + 1
Among them, R represents the discriminant reliability of interaction, n represents the number of researchers, and K represents the average inter-rater consistency among the researchers. Generally speaking, when R > 0.8, it indicates acceptable reliability; when R > 0.9, it indicates very high reliability. After calculation, R = 0.895. The results show that there is little difference in the coding results among different researchers, indicating that the developed coding results are valid.

2.2.3. Urban Image Integration Analysis

The urban imagery theory provides a structured framework for integrating objective spatial data and historical cultural memories in this research. Using five elements as the basic analytical units, it systematically organizes spatial syntax and the findings of coding [32,33,34,35]. Firstly, the study area is decomposed into five types of urban imagery elements. Secondly, the morphological characteristics of these elements are quantified using spatial syntax. Through the coding results, the core urban memory types attached to these elements are identified. On this basis, the quantitative spatial characteristics of the elements are comprehensively analyzed along with their corresponding memory connotations, revealing the specific predicaments faced by each element. Finally, based on the diagnostic results, updated strategies are proposed to ensure that the proposed planning strategies are not only based on objective spatial efficacy assessment but also rooted in deep cultural memories, thus achieving a collaborative design of spatial optimization and memory continuation (Figure 3).
Figure 3. Theoretical framework of the coupling of urban image, spatial syntax, and grounded-theory-inspired coding.

2.3. Data

This study employs multi-source data to support multi-dimensional analysis, ensuring the comprehensiveness and reliability of the research findings. All data can be roughly classified into three categories.
The first is spatial form data. This includes Open Street Map and high-resolution satellite images, which are used to construct the spatial foundation model of the study area; it also includes building outlines, heights, and street section data obtained through on-site mapping and drone aerial photography, which are the basis for spatial syntax analysis.
The second is urban memory data. This includes historical materials from the literature, such as local chronicles, relevant academic research, etc., which directly record the historical evolution, major events, important figures, and functional changes of Shangcheng. In addition to semi-structured interview records and questionnaire survey data from local residents, merchants, and visitors, a combination of purposive sampling and snowball sampling is used. First, we connected with the street office and community committee, selecting original residents and merchants of different ages and lengths of residence, and conducted 22 semi-structured interviews. The interview outline focuses on personal/family and spatial-related historical memories, daily life trajectories, perceptions of changes, and emotional identification. Based on the interviews, a structured questionnaire was designed, covering the cognition and evaluation of the urban image, used to supplement and quantitatively verify the common cognitive patterns emerging from the interviews. All the interview recordings were transcribed into text, and together with historical document excerpts and questionnaires, they were imported into the NVivo20 software for systematic three-level coding. The first step was open coding, where all the texts were analyzed sentence by sentence to extract all the narratives related to the space and places of the city, historical events, social activities, and personal feelings (such as the city being a “left temple–right shrine” complex of mausoleum–urban-scape). Macro-regional narratives that describe a scale far greater than the block itself lack specific spatial references and have obvious digressions, and those that cannot be verified or have no direct connection to the block’s space were excluded to ensure that the subsequent coding and analysis process could closely focus on the correlation between space and memory. Then, axial coding analysis was conducted, with the classification principle being the specific spatial elements directly related to the narrative content. For example, descriptions of activities on the street, traffic flow lines, or changes in street morphology were classified under “path memory”. Finally, selective coding was carried out, integrating the coding results focusing on the evolution process into “temporal memory” (such as “evolution of the sacrificial procession”), and integrating the coding results focusing on the specific state at a certain moment into “simultaneous memory” (such as “function of architectural nodes”) (Table 1).
Table 1. The classification framework and case study of urban memory in Shangcheng.
The third category is social and economic data. This mainly includes macro-level data such as population and economy from statistical yearbooks, which are used to understand the macro background and current predicaments of the neighborhood development, and to support the diagnosis of problems and the practical relevance of strategies.

3. Results

3.1. Paths: The Core Axis Has a Single Function and Its Cultural Potential Remains to Be Activated

By integrating the axis analysis of spatial syntax with the historical evolution of urban spatial patterns [36], the path structure and function of Shangcheng are evaluated. The results show that the degree of axis integration in the area was generally low (Figure 4), and the connection degree of the axes exhibited a high degree of dispersion (Figure 5). Among them, the two indicators of Xuanyuan Street (N) and Gongcong Road (L) were relatively high, indicating that they are the main walking corridors in the study area, facilitating frequent daily social activities among local residents. From the perspective of urban spatial evolution, Xuanyuan Street was once the core of the “sacrificial axis,” as evidenced by folk narratives such as the “Wu Sheng Protecting the Mausoleum” parade (Figure 6). The concentration of traditional residences in the area suggests a positive adaptive relationship between historical heritage and residents’ lives. However, the functional business forms surrounding the current path are single, and this coupling advantage of space and memory has not been transformed into corresponding vitality.
Figure 4. Analysis of axis integration.
Figure 5. Analysis of axis connectivity.
Figure 6. The evolution diagram of the sacrificial tour route.

3.2. Edges: A Diverse Interface Shaped by Both Visual and Historical Memory

The edge is the key to the formation of a block’s image, which can give people a distinct sense of entering or leaving. It can be divided into visual edges, natural edges, artificial edges, and functional cultural edges. The edge of Shangcheng consists of three elements: “Cheng, Tai, and Xiang”. “Cheng” refers to the ancient city wall, “Tai” refers to the Loess Plateau landform, and “Xiang” refers to the street space. The visibility analysis can be combined with the historical street layout and the memory of the surrounding environment for unified analysis. Visibility analysis measures edge perception through visual integration (VI), the visual clustering coefficient (VCC), and visual connectivity (VC). VI reflects the accessibility and concentration of the visual space, while VCC reflects the strength of the visual limitation effect of the spatial edge. VC can reflect the permeability of space. Analysis related to urban memory can identify special edges that have not been manifested spatially. From the VI and VCC perspectives, the values of the two indicators on Xuanyuan Road are the highest, indicating that they are important edges where people’s lines of sight converge. The northern city wall Ruins Park also has a relatively high VCC. Located at the foot of Qiaoshan, it offers good visibility and a strong sense of edge. The index values of secondary roads such as Donghou Road and Dongwa Road are relatively low. The main reason is that the streets are narrower than those of Xuanyuan Street, and a large number of end alleys have disrupted the continuity of the edges. From the VC perspective, the VC of Xuanyuan Street, Donghou Road, and Gongsun Road is significantly higher than that of other edge roads, indicating that they have good spatial permeability and are prone to attracting traffic flow. They are important roads for enhancing the sense of edge (Figure 7). From the perspective of the layout of historical streets and the memory of the surrounding environment, the traditional fishbone structure has led to a large number of dead-end roads (Figure 8), and the connection degree between the main roads in the area varies greatly. Meanwhile, historical relics such as the city wall Ruins and retaining walls around, as important memory carriers, jointly form the unique and diverse edges of Shangcheng.
Figure 7. Visibility analysis: (a) visual integration; (b) visual clustering coefficient; (c) visual connectivity.
Figure 8. The current situation of land use, population, and buildings in Shangcheng District.

3.3. Nodes and Landmarks: The Imbalance Between Spatial Control and Cultural Visibility

Nodes and landmarks serve as anchor points for the vitality and memory of historical districts. This study, by identifying important public spaces and historical buildings and combining them with visibility analysis, reveals the differences in spatial efficiency among various nodes and landmarks. Nodes are usually important public spaces within a region. According to the summary of historical architectural memory, the important nodes within Shangcheng include the North Wall Square (Node 1), Qiaoshan School (Node 2), Gongsun Road Historical Node (Node 3), Guandi Temple–Confucian Temple Node (Node 4), and South Gate Node (Node 5) (Figure 9). According to visibility analysis, nodes one, four, and five are all located around Xuanyuan Road. They are important spaces where streets meet, as well as key nodes where traffic flow and sightlines converge. They have a relatively high degree of control. Among them, the intersection of Gongsun Road and Xuanyuan Street has the highest degree of control. Near the intersection, there are landmark buildings such as Guandi Temple and Confucian Temple, which have good recognizability. It is an important spatial transition point. To build such an open space, a reasonable spatial layout is needed to guide the focus of the line of sight and enhance the memory point of the block. The integration and control levels of nodes two and three are relatively low. However, there are many historical buildings such as traditional residences and academy ruins within the nodes. Due to the fact that some newly added or expanded buildings have disrupted the rationality of the original spatial layout, these two nodes lack accessibility and are unable to effectively exert their cultural influence.
Figure 9. Visibility analysis of nodes and landmarks.
Landmarks are usually the distinctive buildings and structures within a region. The important landmarks of Shangcheng are determined through the analysis of historical architectural memory and are shown in Table 2. As shown in Figure 9, the visual integration and connection degree of the Confucian Temple are higher than those of the Guandi Temple, indicating that it is more easily perceived. When the crowd is at the intersection of Xuanyuan Street and Gongsun Road, the Confucian Temple has higher visibility compared to the Guandi Temple and can be directly observed by pedestrians, giving it a strong landmark quality. In addition, landmarks 2 to 9 are all important historical buildings of residential nature, far from the main roads, and are difficult to be observed in the line of sight, which seriously weakens the recognizability of such markers. Nodes and landmarks are merely basic spatial carriers. It is necessary to create a shared and vibrant space with folk cultural characteristics through distinctive activity experiences, thereby enhancing the value and connotation of nodes and landmarks.
Table 2. Summary of historical building landmarks.

3.4. Districts: Partitioning Based on Memory Coding and Evaluation of Intelligibility

Based on the analysis of district memory, Shangcheng mainly serves three functions: residential living, tourism services, and historical experience. Therefore, this article divides the area into three thematic districts: the Academy Life Area, the Historical and Cultural Core Experience Area, and the Comprehensive Service Area. Among them, the Comprehensive Service Area is located at the entrance of the region, mainly for tourism reception. It is equipped with a square and a tourist reception center and has the largest flow of people in the entire block. The Historical and Cultural Core Experience Area is centered around the Confucian Temple and the Guandi Temple. Outside the core are residential areas, with traditional residences scattered here and there. It is the main tourist area within the region. The Academy Life Area is the main residential area of the block, including a few homestays. The relationship between the entire block and the district was explored through understandability analysis. Among them, the Academy Life Area has the best understandability. The reason is that there are fewer alleys at the end of this area and road accessibility is relatively good. The intelligibility of the Historical and Cultural Core Experience Area is closest to that of the entire area, indicating that this area’s road orientation, architectural texture, etc., have a high degree of similarity with the those of the entire area (Table 3).
Table 3. Intelligibility analysis.

4. Discussion

4.1. Update Strategy

Based on the comprehensive diagnosis of the spatial form and urban memory of Shangcheng, this study, starting from the five elements of urban imagery, proposes the following renewal strategies (Figure 10).
Figure 10. Update strategy: (a) reconstruct the “mausoleum-town” pilgrimage route and activate diverse edges; (b) improve nodes and landmarks; (c) determine district-guided functions.

4.1.1. Reconstruct the “Mausoleum–Town” Pilgrimage Route and Activate the Narrative Axis

As the main axis of the district, Xuanyuan Street has the highest integration and connection degree. Historically, it was the main axis for sacrificial activities, but currently, due to the lack of its inclusion in the tourism route, it has a single function and insufficient vitality. The strategy proposes integrating it into the “Sacrificial Ring Line” by adding tourism services, cultural displays, and commercial facilities along the line to make up for the shortcomings of the existing tourist route and drive the overall renewal [37,38]. At the same time, to address the problem of multiple dead-end roads and the low connection degree of secondary roads caused by the fishbone-shaped road network, the strategy suggests “key dead-end road connection + local ring line optimization” to enhance the overall integration degree of the road network and convenience in residents’ lives [39] (Figure 10a).

4.1.2. Activate Diverse Edges and Construct “Participatory Cultural Interfaces”

The edges are the intersection of natural and cultural memories. It is suggested to restore the city wall and retaining walls and incorporate leisure walkways, viewing platforms, and cultural exhibition halls to strengthen their function as experiential edges. If the vitality of the road edge is insufficient, it can be transformed from a closed interface into an open and interactive commercial and public space by rectifying the facade, utilizing courtyard spaces and modifying the street functions, to enhance the permeability and vitality of the interface [40] (Figure 10a).

4.1.3. Enhance the Spatial Effectiveness and Cultural Visibility of Nodes and Landmarks

There are many historical nodes and landmarks in Shangcheng, with long-lasting cultural heritage, which are important guiding factors for urban design. Facing the problem of the lack of accessibility of the nodes in the area and the low recognizability of some historical building landmarks, it is proposed to implant comprehensive functions such as Confucian academies and intangible cultural heritage workshops in highly controlled nodes to exert their spatial agglomeration effect; for low-visibility historical buildings, by rectifying the surrounding environment, optimizing the visual corridor, and improving their recognizability and accessibility, they can become the focus of cultural consumption and experience [41,42] (Figure 10b).

4.1.4. District-Guided Functions and Shape-Themed Experience Scenarios

The development positioning of Shangcheng is a living folk scene with memories and the inheritance of the history and development context of Huangling. Considering the problem of the disappearance of memory carriers and the homogenization of the area’s functions, it is necessary to shape differentiated and theme-rich experience areas for different districts to strengthen the overall image [43]. The academy life area is mainly used for residence, where the city wall ruins are protected and Qiaoshan Middle School is renovated, implanting cultural exhibitions and characteristic guesthouses to continue the academy culture; the core historical experience area is centered around the Confucian Temple and Guandi Temple, where historical building clusters are integrated into a cultural exhibition cluster, combining the terrace terrain setting with experience paths, to enhance the solemn and elegant atmosphere in which the tomb is guarded; and the comprehensive service area relies on the tourist center and square to create a gathering place for creative workshops, and tourism distribution and industrial incubation functions are undertaken [44] (Figure 10c).

4.1.5. Establish a Comprehensive Collaborative Governance Mechanism

The proposed update strategy in this study may encounter multiple challenges during its implementation, such as balancing protection and update, ensuring community sustainable development, and facilitating cross-departmental collaboration. To ensure the effective implementation and continuous operation of the strategy, the following governance implementation mechanisms need to be established (Figure 11).
Figure 11. The comprehensive collaborative governance mechanism.
Firstly, a “government guidance–community leadership–professional support–market participation” governance platform should be established with multi-party collaboration. By setting up organizations such as neighborhood update committees and community cooperatives, we can clarify the roles and collaboration processes of each party in the planning, design, implementation, and operation stages and ensure the full participation of key stakeholders such as local residents, merchants, and planners throughout the process. Secondly, full-cycle participation tools and institutional guarantees should be designed for implementation. Community workshops, joint design, subsidies for old house renovations, and review of business types can promote the transparency and local acceptance of the update process. Special attention should be paid to establishing a “community risk and benefit sharing mechanism”, such as through property rights incentives, operating dividends, and prioritizing local employment, to prevent gentrification during the update process and ensure that the development benefits truly benefit the local community. Finally, a sustainable long-term operation and cross-departmental collaboration system should be build. The establishment of a collaborative working platform involving departments such as cross-cultural, tourism, and housing and construction should be promoted, and policy and financial resources should be integrated. At the operational level, the “public asset trusteeship + social enterprise operation + community profit feedback” model should be explored through dynamic rent regulation, public income reinvestment, and other tools to ensure the long-term balance and resilient development of the neighborhood in terms of culture, economy, and society.

4.2. Research Innovation

In view of the analysis mentioned above, the contribution of this paper to the existing literature lies in the following three aspects.
The “space–memory” coupling analysis framework constructed in this study has achieved deep integration of urban memory theory and spatial form analysis. Existing studies often regard memory as an abstract cultural value or a dependent variable in social surveys, failing to systematically reveal how it specifically shapes spatial forms. However, this study transforms the abstract memory content into operational spatial design language. For instance, the edge elements “Cheng-Tai-Xiang” revealed through memory analysis and visual field analysis are transformed into a progressive design strategy of “restoring the city wall–activating the retaining wall–connecting the walkway”.
This study realizes the spatial translation of the “cultural genes” of historical districts in medium-sized cities by exploring the unique local knowledge of “the guarding culture of Emperor Huang’s Mausoleum”. Existing studies mostly focus on large cities or tourist hotspots, which have rich data and standardized methods but limited applicability to medium-sized cities with sparse data and unique local narratives. This study combines historical documents and field investigations to identify the “mausoleum–town” symbiotic urban memory of Shangcheng and systematically correlates it with the results of spatial syntax analysis. If only relying on big data (such as POI and mobile phone signals), it is difficult to capture such local spatial logic.
The update strategy proposed in this study is derived from a systematic interpretation of the results of the “space–memory” coupling analysis. For example, the priority activation of the Guandi Temple–Confucian Temple node in the node update strategy is based on its dual advantages of high visual control and strong memory carrying capacity, while the functional implantation of the Qiaoshan Middle School node is based on the contradiction diagnosis of low accessibility but high historical value. Without the analysis method of this study, it is likely that the strategy will only rely on experience to prioritize the renovation of “nodes that seem important” while ignoring their actual spatial efficacy and memory carrying capacity, resulting in an update effect disconnected from local identity.

4.3. Related Research Comparisons

Other scholars have also achieved similar research results. Lyu et al. (2023) [45] and Fu et al. (2025) [25], respectively, proposed effective vitality enhancement strategies in terms of integrating functions along high-integration axes and strengthening the influence of the main axis. Their spatial-oriented analytical approach is of significant inspiration. In comparison, this study not only focuses on spatial efficiency but also emphasizes identifying cultural genes and morphological structures through “memory–spatial” coupling diagnosis, making the update strategies have dual goals of spatial optimization and memory continuation. Moreover, compared with Gohari (2019) [27], who integrated spatial syntax and urban imagery methods, this study further introduced grounded-theory-inspired coding, systematically extracted urban memory, and used urban imagery as the translation platform for “space–memory”, making the strategy formulation more culturally targeted and systematic, thus achieving further expansion in method integration. This study used a two-dimensional axis model for analysis, mainly based on two considerations: Firstly, the study aimed to analyze the structural essence of the built road network of the block and its relationship with urban memory rather than simulating the dynamic impact of terrain on the formation of the road network. The two-dimensional model can effectively capture the characteristics of street and alley structures. Secondly, terrain elements were not ignored in this study but were integrated into the analysis of relevant elements of urban imagery through qualitative analysis, providing an important background basis for explaining the quantitative results of spatial syntax. This processing method is consistent with current research using spatial syntax to analyze historical blocks and is reasonable and feasible in terms of methodology.

5. Conclusions

This study employed a tripartite coupling analysis framework to systematically analyze the spatial form characteristics and urban memory structure of the historical district in Shangcheng and comprehensively evaluated its spatial conditions and renewal potential. By integrating the urban imagery theory as the integration interface and combining spatial syntax with grounded-theory-inspired coding, targeted revitalization strategies were proposed from four dimensions: paths, edges, nodes and landmarks, and districts. The research revealed that high-integration paths such as Xuanyuan Street not only serve transportation functions but also act as the “sacrificial axis” and carrier of folk narrative, being of great significance in both spatial and memory dimensions. However, their cultural potential has not been fully activated yet. The edges of Shangcheng are composed of the ruins of the city wall, Loess Plateau landform, and street spaces, and some areas suffer from the lack of continuity and vitality due to dead-end roads and mixed styles. Some historical buildings have weak cultural influence due to poor visibility and low accessibility. Based on the analysis of the correlation between memory and space, Shangcheng can be divided into the Academy Life Area, the Historical and Cultural Core Experience Area, and the Comprehensive Service Area. The zoning strategy can help alleviate functional homogeneity and strengthen the overall image. This research has made valuable contributions to the renewal and protection of historical districts and has also expanded the application of the research method of spatial syntax combination in urban heritage studies. The proposed renewal strategies can provide reference design guidance and decision-making basis for the protection and renewal of similar small cities’ historical districts.
This study couples spatial syntax with urban memory to provide a new perspective for the revitalization of historical and cultural districts. However, it still has the following shortcomings: (a) It relies on interviews and historical documents for data, with a limited sample size. In the future, social media texts can be combined to obtain multi-source data. (b) Although multiple methods have been attempted for integration, the logical connections among these methods still mainly rely on qualitative correlations and explanations. For instance, the corresponding relationship between the memory encoding category and the spatial syntax indicators lacks a systematic quantitative inference mechanism. The formation of research conclusions is, to some extent, dependent on qualitative interpretation and logical synthesis. Meanwhile, the two-dimensional spatial syntax analysis adopted in the study can effectively reveal the topological structure of the road network, but it does not fully integrate three-dimensional elements such as terrain elevation and building volume. There are certain limitations in the spatial perception depiction of boundaries and landmarks in the view analysis. (c) The proposed strategies have not been implemented yet, and their actual efficacy needs to be further verified through subsequent tracking evaluations and comparative studies. Future research can further explore the application of artificial intelligence-related technologies and cross-case comparisons and strategy validations. Artificial intelligence can be used to assist in multi-dimensional and time-series data collection and analysis. Through multiple channels such as smart sensors, satellite remote sensing, and social media, large-scale and dynamic data such as population movement trajectories and spatial usage frequencies can be obtained. AI technology can deeply explore human behavior patterns under different temporal and spatial conditions, thereby more accurately revealing the complex relationships between spatial configuration and usage behavior, providing more comprehensive and timely decision support for spatial optimization; in addition, the integration application of 3D Space Syntax or Walkability Analysis with Slope can be explored to more accurately model the impact of terrain height differences on pedestrian movement, line of sight, and spatial experience, thereby providing more accurate evaluations in the analysis of similar mountainous historical districts. The “space–memory” coupling analysis method constructed in this study can be applied to other types of historical and cultural districts for comparative research to test its universality and adaptability. At the same time, the built environment after implementation can be tracked and evaluated over the long term to verify the effectiveness of the strategies and continuously optimize them.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, X.K.; methodology, S.D., X.K. and K.Y.; formal analysis, K.Y., M.L. and J.W.; data curation, J.W., J.C. and X.K.; writing—original draft preparation S.D.; writing—review and editing, S.D., K.Y., J.C., P.L. and M.L.; visualization, S.D. and J.W.; supervision, K.Y. and P.L.; funding acquisition, K.Y. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This study is funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (52278047), Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (300102414501), Key Research Projects of Shaanxi Provincial Government Research Office in 2024 (2024HZ1186), and 2024 Shaanxi Provincial Communist Youth League and Youth Work Research Project (2024HZ1236).

Data Availability Statement

Data are available from the corresponding authors and can be shared upon reasonable request.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank the editors and reviewers for their constructive comments on this research. Thanks also to the members of the research team and everyone who helped us during the survey.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Abbreviation

The following abbreviation is used in this manuscript:
UNESCOUnited Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization

References

  1. Huang, Z.; Huang, L. Research Progress and Prospects of “Urban Memory” Renewal Planning Paths—Based on International Comparative Perspective. SSR 2024, 6, 98–106. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  2. UNESCO. SDG 11.4 Implementation Guidelines; UNESCO: Paris, France, 2023. [Google Scholar]
  3. Geng, L.; Xue, M.; Li, J.; Ma, J. Historic District Conservation: A Critical Review of Global Trends, Development in the 21st Century, and Challenges Through CiteSpace Analysis. Buildings 2025, 15, 1232. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. Li, H.; Ikebe, K.; Kinoshita, T.; Chen, J.; Su, D.; Xie, J. How heritage promotes social cohesion: An urban survey from Nara city, Japan. Cities 2024, 149, 104985. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Du, J.; Wang, Y. The influence of perceived landscape value on tourists’ behavioral intentions in historical and cultural blocks. PLoS ONE 2025, 20, e0312491. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Zhang, R.; Martí Casanovas, M.; González, M.B.; Zhang, Z.; Li, H. The Guidance of Public Value in China’s Historic Environment: Research on Regeneration Strategies Using Taiyuan’s Bell Tower Street as an Example. Land 2024, 13, 1189. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  7. Tang, Z.; Zhao, Y. Perception and Evaluation of Cultural Heritage Value in Historic Urban Public Parks Based on Social Media Data: A Case Study of Shanghai. Buildings 2025, 15, 3864. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  8. De Leão Dornelles, L.; Gandolfi, F.; Mercader-Moyano, P.; Mosquera-Adell, E. Place and memory indicator: Methodology for the formulation of a qualitative indicator, named place and memory, with the intent of contributing to previous works of intervention and restoration of heritage spaces and buildings, in the aspect of sustainability. Sustain. Cities Soc. 2020, 54, 101985. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  9. Tenzer, M.; Schofield, J. Using Topic Modelling to Reassess Heritage Values from a People-centred Perspective: Applications from the North of England. Camb. Archaeol. J. 2023, 34, 147–168. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  10. Gravagnuolo, A.; Angrisano, M.; Bosone, M.; Buglione, F.; De Toro, P.; Fusco Girard, L. Participatory evaluation of cultural heritage adaptive reuse interventions in the circular economy perspective: A case study of historic buildings in Salerno (Italy). J. Urban Manag. 2024, 13, 107–139. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  11. Ding, F.; Ren, Y.; Goudos, S.; Zhao, Y. Analysis of Public Space in Historic Districts Based on Community Governance and Neural Networks. IEEE Access 2023, 11, 81021–81032. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  12. Zhang, Q.; Cheng, T.; Xu, P.; Jiang, X. Balancing Heritage Conservation and Urban Vitality Through a Multi-Tiered Governance Strategy: A Case Study of Nanjing’s Yihe Road Historic District, China. Land 2025, 14, 1894. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Wang, Y.; Wang, Y. Research on preservation and renewal strategies for historic districts under space syntax. ITM Web Conf. 2025, 77, 01058. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  14. Zheng, Y. Exploring historical cultural neighborhood conservation and revitalization based on the theory of urban resilience: A case study of Congshanfang in Zhongshan City. E3S Web Conf. 2024, 553, 04005. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  15. Xu, K.; He, Y.; Chen, Y.; Zhou, M. Morphological resilience evaluation research on the conservation and renewal of historic districts: A case study on Xijie Historic District, Quanzhou. Front. Archit. Res. 2025; in press. [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  16. Lyu, Y.; Abd Malek, M.I.; Binti Ja’afar, N.H.; Liu, C.; Liu, Z.; Han, Z. Multi-data driven and space syntax approach to urban heritage revitalization: Insights from Zhongshan Rd. Historic District, China. Ain Shams Eng. J. 2025, 16, 103473. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Wang, Y.; Jin, C.; Xu, D.; Wang, T.; Wang, B. Analysis of Multi-Dimensional Layers in Historic Districts Based on Theory of the Historic Urban Landscape: Taking Shenyang Fangcheng as an Example. Land 2024, 13, 1736. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  18. Li, L.; Wu, Y.; Zhang, J. Bridging Heritage Conservation and Urban Sustainability: A Multidimensional Coupling Framework for Walkability, Greening, and Cultural Heritage in the Historic City of Shenyang. Sustainability 2025, 17, 5284. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Xiang, L.; Feng, C.; Liu, Y.; Wang, Y. Space and culture acculturation: Exploring urban regeneration in historic conservation areas, Yangmeizhu Street in Beijing, China. Front. Archit. Res. 2025, 14, 1274–1290. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Lan, W.; Li, J.; Wang, J.; Wang, Y.; Lei, Z. Cultural Diversity Conservation in Historic Districts via Spatial-Gene Perspectives: The Small Wild Goose Pagoda District, Xi’an. Sustainability 2025, 17, 2189. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Han, J. Research on the Evolution and Optimization of Urban Spatial Morphology in Huangling County. Master’s Thesis, Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology, Xi’an, China, 2024. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Wang, J. Research on Urban Spatial Morphology of Huangling County. Master’s Thesis, Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology, Xi’an, China, 2020. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  23. Stevens, Q.; Thai, H.M.H. Mapping the character of urban districts: The morphology, land use and visual character of Chinatowns. Cities 2024, 148, 104853. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Wang, F.; Leung, X.Y.; Jiang, L. Cultural heritage-scape and tourists’ psychological well-being: A mixed-method study. J. Hosp. Tour. Insights 2025, 1–20. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Fu, J.-M.; Tang, Y.-F.; Zeng, Y.-K.; Feng, L.-Y.; Wu, Z.-G. Sustainable Historic Districts: Vitality Analysis and Optimization Based on Space Syntax. Buildings 2025, 15, 657. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  26. Filomena, G.; Verstegen, J.A.; Manley, E. A computational approach to ‘The Image of the City’. Cities 2019, 89, 14–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Gohari, H. Structural analysis of the elements of Lynch’s image of the city based on space syntax. Proc. Inst. Civ. Eng. Urban Des. Plan. 2019, 172, 141–158. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  28. Turner, A. From axial to road-centre lines: A new representation for Space Syntax and a new model of route choice for transport network analysis. Environ. Plan. B Plan. Des. 2007, 34, 539–555. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Yun, Y.W.; Kim, Y.O. The effect of depth and distance in spatial cognition. In Proceedings of the 6th International Space Syntax Symposium, Istanbul, Turkey, 12–15 June 2007; pp. 1–14. [Google Scholar]
  30. Mohajan, D.; Mohajan, H.K. Exploration of Coding in Qualitative Data Analysis: Grounded Theory Perspective. Res. Adv. Educ. 2022, 1, 50–60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  31. Kurbanova, L.; Gunya, A.; Abdulaeva, E. The urban environment of Grozny as a space for constructing and reproducing the collective memory of modern Chechen society. Sociol. Nauka I Soc. Prakt. 2025, 13, 74–94. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  32. Zhang, G.; Li, S. Research on the Symbolic Construction and Translation of Internet Celebrity Urban Memory in the Video Era. Philos. Ideol. Res. 2024, 4, 35–43. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  33. Statucki, P.M. Constructing memory in urban space: Case of the Bałuty district in Łódź. Acta Univ. Lodz. Folia Sociol. 2023, 86, 23–42. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  34. Li, X.; Lin, R.; Park, S. Spatial syntax-based analysis of the spatial layout and road planning in Yanji City. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Smart Transportation and City Engineering (STCE 2024), Chongqing, China, 6–8 December 2024; Feng, Z., Mikusova, M., Eds.; SPIE: Cergy, France, 2025; p. 86. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  35. Lynch, K. The Image of the City; MIT Press: Cambridge, MA, USA, 1960. [Google Scholar]
  36. Yang, L.; Jin, Q.; Fu, F. Research on Urban Street Network Structure Based on Spatial Syntax and POI Data. Sustainability 2024, 16, 1757. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  37. Ai, J.; Kim, M. Spatial Remodeling of Industrial Heritage from the Perspective of Urban Renewal: A Case Study of Coal Mine Site in Jiaozuo City. Land 2024, 13, 1901. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  38. Xu, X.; Xue, D.; Huang, G. The Effects of Residents’ Sense of Place on Their Willingness to Support Urban Renewal: A Case Study of Century-Old East Street Renewal Project in Shaoguan, China. Sustainability 2022, 14, 1385. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  39. Rizvić, S.; Sadžak, A.; Buza, E.; Chalmers, A. Virtual Reconstruction and Digitalization of Cultural Heritage Sites in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Rev. Natl. Cent. Digit. 2008, 12, 82–90. [Google Scholar]
  40. Zhang, X.; Edelenbos, J.; Gianoli, A. Urban conservation in multi-level governance: Comparing the interaction patterns in conserving different types of cultural heritage in the mainland of China. Urban Gov. 2024, 4, 25–36. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  41. Jiang, Y. Research on Historical Block Conservation and Historical Building Regeneration Design Strategies Based on Urban Renewal: A Case Study of Wuhan Tiandi Historical Block. Commun. Humanit. Res. 2024, 44, 7–18. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  42. Luo, N.; Guo, X.; Ni, Y.; Lyu, X.; Li, X.; Xu, Y. Digital Humans and Authentic Experience at Heritage Sites: A Cognitive-Emotional Path Study. Acad. Manag. Proc. 2025, 2025, 20042. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  43. Ma, Y.; Wang, S.; Wang, Z.; Chen, G. Contemporary Demands of Scenes in Urban Historic Conservation Areas: A Case Study of Subjective Evaluations from Foshan, China. Buildings 2024, 14, 2837. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  44. AlShaalan, M.K.; Durugbo, C.M. City branding as innovation for tourism development: Systematic review of literature from 2011 to 2023. Manag. Rev. Q. 2024, 75, 2173–2205. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  45. Lyu, Y.; Abd Malek, M.I.; Ja`afar, N.H.; Sima, Y.; Han, Z.; Liu, Z. Unveiling the potential of space syntax approach for revitalizing historic urban areas: A case study of Yushan Historic District, China. Front. Archit. Res. 2023, 12, 1144–1156. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.