1. Introduction
C. kanran is one of the seven major species of Chinese orchids. It is mainly distributed in Fujian, Taiwan, Guangdong, Guangxi, and Yunnan, among other regions of China. Its flowering period ranges from October to January of the following year.
C.
kanran ‘Zhushalan’ is a precious traditional cultivar and a representative variety of
C. kanran in Yunnan Province. It has a long flowering period, high ornamental and economic value, and has been highly sought after by people since ancient times. Therefore, there is a need to develop tools and strategies to sustain and improve its production. Unfortunately, the production and market of Chinese orchids still face many challenges, such as long flowering cycles, unclear molecular regulation of flowering periods, limited flower types and colors, severe diseases, and environmental stresses [
1,
2]. Introducing new traits in orchids, such as new flower colors, through mutation breeding or hybrid breeding is difficult. However, transgenic technology can easily achieve targeted modification of orchid traits [
3,
4].
Transgenic technology is an important means of improving desirable plant traits through genetic engineering. Since the first genetically modified plants were obtained in 1983, research on plant genetic transformation has advanced rapidly [
5]. Transgenic technology transfers the desired target genes into plants and can programmatically inhibit or enhance gene expression. This technology has been used to enhance the ornamental value of horticultural plants by modifying their genomes [
6]. Compared with traditional breeding strategies, transgenic methods have greater potential for creating new phenotypes. Currently reported plant genetic transformation methods include Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, particle bombardment, and the pollen tube pathway. Among them, Agrobacterium-mediated transformation and particle bombardment are the most commonly used methods in orchid breeding [
7]. Agrobacterium-mediated transformation is characterized by high efficiency and low cost and is widely used for the stable genetic transformation of plant species [
8,
9]. This method was successfully used for the genetic transformation of Phalaenopsis orchids in 1997 [
10], and
Dendrobium sonia in 1998 [
11,
12]. Recent advances in molecular biotechnology have led to great achievements in the genetic transformation of other orchids, including
Dendrobium Sonia ‘Earsakul’ [
13],
Dendrobium ‘Chao Praya Smile’ [
14],
Erycina pusilla [
15],
Oncidium [
16],
Phalaenopsis [
17], and
C.
sinense [
18]. These advances have resulted in improvements in key horticultural plant traits, including flower color [
19], floral fragrance [
20,
21], flower development [
22,
23], and disease resistance [
24]. In addition, advances in genomics, bioinformatics, and sequencing technologies have led to the publication of the whole genome data of orchids, such as
Phalaenopsis aphrodite [
25],
C.
goeringii [
26], and
C.
ensifolium [
27], laying a solid foundation for transgenic breeding of orchids.
The selection of genetic transformation receptor materials and their regenerative ability are crucial for efficient transformation. The receptor material must have efficient and stable regeneration capabilities, high genetic stability, and a large number of stable explant sources [
1]. Callus tissue is commonly used as a receptor material for genetic transformation in orchids. However, it is generally believed that callus tissue from Orchidaceae plants is not a suitable transformation receptor because of the difficulty in maintaining single cells. In particular, callus tissue is prone to mutation and the formation of chimeras. Kuehte et al. argued that embryogenic callus is a more suitable transformation receptor material for orchids because it can be obtained directly from regenerated plants after transformation. This eliminates the need for embryonic development, which makes callus chimeras and new somatic embryos difficult to form. Additionally, non-transformed cells can be effectively removed during this process [
28]. However, inducing embryogenic callus in orchids requires adding special substances, and the induced callus tissue has limited growth ability, making subculture difficult. Protocorms, a unique growth state of a few plants in Orchidaceae, are easy to induce and have a very high instantaneous expression rate after co-cultivation. Inducing callus tissue allows regeneration into protocorm-like bodies (PLBs), which can then regenerate whole plants [
29]. Therefore, protocorms and PLBs are currently ideal transformation receptor materials for orchids, with high regeneration rates in transformation. PLBs have been successfully used as transformation receptors in
P. aphrodite,
D. nobile,
O. sphacelatum, and
D. officinale [
12,
30,
31]. In
Cymbidium, due to the special shape of its protocorms and PLBs, they are referred to as rhizomes. Apart from callus tissue and protocorms, other receptor materials for orchid genetic transformation have been reported, including suspended cells, pollen, and immature embryos [
10,
32,
33,
34]. In addition to the transformation receptor, several other factors affect the success and efficiency of orchid genetic transformation, such as the pre-culture time [
35], Agrobacterium strain [
12], concentration of the bacterial solution [
36,
37], infection mode and time [
10], and co-culture time [
38].
Currently, the genetic transformation of most Orchidaceae species is still at the preliminary exploration stage. Only a few species, such as P. aphrodite, D. nobile, and O. sphacelatum, have relatively well-established genetic transformation systems. Cymbidium plants are hindered by rhizome induction. However, the genetic transformation system of only one species, C. sinense, has been reported due to the advanced technology of inducing rhizomes through lateral buds. In short, many highly favored orchids, such as most Chinese orchids, including C. kanran, have not achieved key breakthroughs in genetic transformation research. Particularly, a comprehensive and systematic analysis of the factors affecting the transformation frequency in C. kanran has yet to be conducted. Due to the high heterogeneity among Chinese orchids, the transformation systems established for other Cymbidium species are not expected to produce similarly efficient results in C. kanran. Therefore, establishing an efficient genetic transformation system for C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’ is crucial. This will advance research on functional genes and facilitate the molecular-assisted breeding of important traits.
In this study, we used rhizomes as receptor materials and evaluated the effects of key factors such as pre-culture time, bacterial solution concentration, infection time and method, and co-culture time on the regeneration and transformation rate of C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’ rhizomes. Our goal was to develop an efficient genetic transformation and regeneration system for C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’. The results of this study lay the groundwork for validating functional genes underlying key agronomic traits in C. kanran and for further developing genomics-assisted breeding in Cymbidium.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Plant and Plasmid Materials
The
C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’ seeds were collected from Dali Languo Flower Industry Development Co., Ltd. (Dali, China). All collected seeds were derived from self-pollination and matured for ten months. After sterilization with 75% (
v/
v) ethanol for 30 s and 0.1% (
w/
v) HgCl2 for five minutes, the seeds were rinsed and then aseptically sown in the germination medium (
Table 1). After 180 days, healthy rhizomes with uniform growth (1–2 cm) were selected and transferred onto the propagation medium (
Table 1) to obtain a large number of rhizomes. The plasmids used in the experiment were pCAMBIA1301, which contains the T-DNA region with hygromycin phosphotransferase (HPT) and β-glucuronidase (GUS) genes, and pCAMBIA1300, which contains the T-DNA region with HPT and green fluorescent protein (GFP) genes (
Figure 1). All the above materials are stored at the Flower Research Institute of the Yunnan Academy of Agricultural Sciences. All experiments were conducted under aseptic conditions. All factors evaluated, including pre-culture time, Agrobacterium strain, concentration of the bacterial solution, infection mode and time, and co-culture time, were set based on previous studies [
12,
35,
36,
37,
38].
2.2. Culture Media
The culture medium was prepared using ½ MS medium, tryptone, activated carbon, agar, sucrose, 6-benzylaminopurine (6-BA), and naphthaleneacetic acid (1-naphthaleneacetic acid (NAA) at a pH level between 5.8 and 6.0. The composition of the culture media used in this study is presented in
Table 1.
2.3. Selection of the Agrobacterium Strain
To identify a suitable Agrobacterium strain, the pCAMBIA1301-GUS vector plasmid was introduced into Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains LBA4404, EHA105, and GV3101. Each strain was then added to YEB medium and cultured overnight until the OD600 reached 0.8–1.0. Each treatment consisted of 30 rhizomes infected for 60 min and was independently repeated three times.
2.4. Genetic Transformation and Regeneration Workflow
The genetic transformation and plant regeneration process followed a systematic sequence: pre-culture, infection, co-culture, selection, regeneration, and molecular confirmation. The detailed workflow is as follows:
Step 1: Pre-culture. Healthy rhizomes (approx. 1 cm) with good growth potential were selected and then subjected to dark cultivation for different periods (5, 10, 15 days) to obtain tender tissues receptive to infection and assess the effect of dark cultivation duration on the transformation frequency and regeneration rate of C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’. Each treatment consisted of 60 rhizomes infected for 60 min and was independently repeated three times.
Step 2: Infection. The pre-cultured rhizomes were slightly wounded and submerged in Agrobacterium suspension. Different concentrations, including OD600 of 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, and 1, were evaluated. To identify the optimal infection time and mode for maximizing the regeneration frequency, different shaking (200 r/min) times, including 20 (S20), 40 (S40), and 60 (S60) minutes, were first evaluated, and S40 was identified as the most optimal. Next, three combinations of S40 and vacuum for different times, including S40V10, S40V20, and S40V30, were evaluated. After five days of co-cultivation, GUS histochemical staining was performed to detect and quantify the transient expression rate of GUS. Each treatment consisted of 30 (transformation) or 60 (regeneration) rhizomes, independently repeated three times.
Step 3: Co-culture. After removing excess bacterial solution with sterile filter paper, the rhizomes were transferred to co-culture medium containing acetosyringone (AS) and incubated in the dark for one, three, or five days at 25 °C. Different concentrations of AS, including 0, 100, 200, and 300 μmol·L−1, were evaluated, with the treatment of 0 μmol·L−1 representing the control. AS, a phenolic compound naturally released by wounded plant cells, induces the virulence (vir) genes of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. This induction is crucial for the transfer of T-DNA from the bacterium into the plant cell genome. After five days of co-cultivation, the transient expression rate of GUS was detected via histochemical staining. Each treatment consisted of 30 (transformation) or 60 (regeneration) rhizomes, independently repeated three times.
Step 4: Selection and Regeneration. Following co-culture, the rhizomes were washed with sterile water containing 500 mg/L cefotaxime and transferred to regeneration screening medium (containing 15 mg/L meropenem and 50 mg/L hygromycin). The medium was refreshed every 7 days. These cultures were maintained at 25 °C under a 14 h light/10 h dark photoperiod for 30 days to induce shoot regeneration. The mortality rate was determined after 14 days. Different concentrations of hygromycin (Hgy), including 0, 20, 30, 40, 50, and 60 mg·L−1, were evaluated, with 0 mg·L−1 of Hgy representing the control. Each treatment consisted of 30 (transformation) or 60 (regeneration) rhizomes, independently repeated three times.
Step 5: Confirmation. Transgenic candidates were initially screened by GFP fluorescence observation. Subsequently, stable integration of the target gene was confirmed in regenerated plants via PCR and qRT-PCR analysis. Three biological and technical replicates were applied for both PCR and qRT-PCR.
To clearly distinguish between the different developmental stages of the transformation process, the following four parameters were calculated using the formulas below [
39]:
2.5. Transgenic Plant Identification
2.5.1. Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) Fluorescence Microscopy Detection
After sterilization, the rhizomes were observed using GFP fluorescence. The fluorescence signal was detected, and the pictures were taken with a Leica MZ16. The number of fluorescing rhizomes in each group was counted, and the fluorescence rate was determined using the above formula.
2.5.2. Molecular Biology Testing
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and quantitative reverse transcription PCR (qRT-PCR) are widely used to confirm transgenic lines [
39,
40]. In this study, transgenic plants were detected using PCR and qRT-PCR with the following primers:
GFP gene (411 bp): F: GCCATTTCGCCTTTTCAG and R: GTAGCGCGTGAGACTG.
Internal reference gene (ACTIN): F: ATGGCCGACGGTGAAGAAAT and R: GCAAAACCAGCCTTGACC.
2.6. Data Processing and Statistical Analysis
Data were statistically analyzed using SPSS 24.0 and Excel 2019. Data are presented as the mean ± SD of all replicates. Statistical differences among treatments were determined via One-Way ANOVA (analysis of variance) with a post hoc Tukey test. Significant differences were set at p < 0.05.
4. Discussion
C. kanran is one of the seven major Chinese orchids and boasts a long history. Due to its high ornamental value and rich cultural significance, its economic value has been expanding. However, the molecular regulation of many C. kanran traits, such as leaf color and stress resistance, remains unclear. Furthermore, it is difficult to improve these traits through traditional breeding methods. Therefore, establishing an efficient genetic transformation and regeneration system is crucial to enable functional genomics studies and molecular-assisted breeding of important C. kanran traits. In this study, we comprehensively examined the effects of dark culture time, bacterial concentration, infection method, infection time, and co-culture time on the transformation and regeneration rates of C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’ rhizomes. Based on these results, we developed an efficient genetic transformation and regeneration system for C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’.
The size of explants is crucial for stable transformation. In the case of
C.
kanran, the rhizomes are similar to immature embryos, capable of stable proliferation, making them excellent explant materials. If orchid embryos or rhizomes that are too large are used, chimeras may form [
28]. In this study, 1–2 cm healthy rhizomes were suitable for
C.
kanran genetic transformation and regeneration. However, the achieved transformation efficiency (11.67%) is still relatively low. Thus, further studies using different explants as receptor materials are required to improve the transformation efficiency.
The duration of dark culture significantly impacts both the transformation efficiency and the regenerative capacity of rhizomes. The optimal duration of dark culture varies significantly among different orchid species. For example,
D. officinale can be successfully transformed without undergoing a pre-culture stage [
41], whereas
C.
sinense requires at least one month of dark culture before transformation [
36]. In this study, the rhizomes of
C.
kanran ‘Zhushalan’ developed tender shoot tips after a period of dark culture. If the dark culture duration is too short, Agrobacterium infection becomes difficult, resulting in ineffective transformation or a low transformation rate. Conversely, an excessively long dark culture duration can hinder the complete elimination of Agrobacterium from the rhizomes, ultimately affecting their regeneration. Our findings indicate that a 10-day dark culture period allows for efficient regeneration and achieves a high transformation rate in
C.
kanran rhizomes under identical conditions. Moreover, they suggest that moderate dark culture times should be applied for Cymbidium species.
The concentration of Agrobacterium and the duration of infection significantly impact rhizome regeneration and transformation rates. If the concentration of the bacterial solution is too low or the infection duration is too short, Agrobacterium cannot fully adhere to the receptor tissue and fails to achieve effective transformation [
42,
43]. Conversely, a high bacterial solution concentration or long infection duration can damage the receptor material, further affecting its regeneration [
42,
43]. We compared the transformation rates of
C.
kanran ‘Zhushalan’ rhizomes under different bacterial solution concentrations and infection times and found no significant differences in transformation rates. However, there were significant differences in regeneration frequency. An Agrobacterium infection solution concentration of around OD
600 = 0.6 with an infection time of 20 to 40 min was suitable to maximize the transformation rate and regeneration frequency of ‘Zhushalan’ rhizomes. This confirms that, when the Agrobacterium solution concentration is low and the infection duration is appropriate, there is no overflow of Agrobacterium on the surface of rhizomes, allowing them to grow normally.
The receptor tissues of Cymbidium species, such as the rhizomes (PLBs), have dense structures that provide substantial physical resistance to natural
Agrobacterium infection [
44]. The exogenous addition of AS effectively induces the expression of virulence (vir) genes on the Agrobacterium Ti plasmid, thereby enhancing infectivity [
36,
45,
46]. This process helps overcome host cell wall barriers and promotes the efficient transfer and integration of T-DNA. In this study, we found that 100 μmol·L
−1 is the optimal AS concentration for achieving higher transformation efficiency in
C.
kanran ‘Zhushalan’. However, this concentration might be more appropriate and specific for the identified Agrobacterium strain EHA105. Therefore, additional investigations are needed before applying this concentration to other Agrobacterium strains or Cymbidium species.
Co-culture time is also an important factor in genetic transformation. Different orchids have different requirements for co-culture time. For example, extending the co-culture time is beneficial for improving the transformation rate in
D.
nobile [
47]. In contrast, in
P. aphrodite, extending the co-culture time does not increase the transformation efficiency. Instead, it leads to the death of the explants [
10]. In this study, co-culture time had no significant impact on the transformation rate of
C.
kanran ‘Zhushalan’. However, when the co-culture time exceeded three days, it became difficult to inhibit Agrobacterium on the surface of the rhizome, resulting in browning and death. Collectively, our findings show that rigorous control of these influencing factors is crucial to efficiently transform
C.
kanran ‘Zhushalan’. These factors, among others, including AS concentration, co-culture time, incubation period, antibiotics, dark incubation, humidity, inoculation sites and frequency,
Agrobacterium strains, and plant genotypes and status, have been revealed to be the most essential in the process of Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation of horticultural plants [
48].
PCR analysis is an effective method for transgenic detection and is widely used to screen positive transgenic plants. Herein, the band of the target fragment was successfully amplified, confirming the reliability of the transformation system. It is also noteworthy that the concentration of the bacterial solution, infection time and method, and co-culture time had no significant impact on the transformation rate of the
C. kanran rhizomes. Furthermore, we achieved a transformation efficiency of 11.67% for
C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’, which is higher than that of
Phalaenopsis orchid (1.2–5.2%) [
17]. However, the achieved transformation efficiency is lower than that in
D. lasianthera (35–70%) [
12], Dendrobium orchids (19.87–27.3%) [
30,
49], and in Chrysanthemum (
Chrysanthemum ×
morifolium Ramat.) (51.50%) [
50]. The recorded differences in the transformation rate may be attributable to differences in vectors, transformation methods, or explants. The Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation system for
C. kanran established in this study provides a useful tool for functional genomics research and molecular breeding in
Cymbidium. Further improvement in the established system through evaluating other explants, vectors, and transformation methods, among others, is needed to elevate the transformation rate.
Collectively, this study establishes an efficient Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation system for the traditional and highly valued orchid C. kanran ‘Zhushalan’. Such a system is an important resource that will enable molecular breeding approaches for key traits that are difficult to achieve through traditional breeding, especially in perennial ornamental plants, where long generation times, limited heritability, and complex crossing can slow trait improvement. With this reliable genetic transformation system, ‘Zhushalan’ can now serve as a chassis for targeted gene function validation and genetic improvement of other Cymbidium species. Breeders and researchers can now directly modify target genes associated with desirable traits and biotic and abiotic stress tolerance. Furthermore, this efficient system may guide the development of a reliable transformation protocol for other orchid plants that are still difficult to transform.