2.1. Particle Size and Surface Structure Analysis of ZnO
Figure 1 shows TEM images of nano-ZnO samples calcined at different temperatures. These images clearly illustrate how calcination temperature affects the morphology and size of ZnO particles.
Figure 1a Roasted at 260 °C: The ZnO particles in this sample have an average size of 14.3 nm. The particles are evenly distributed, with a regular shape and smooth surface. At this temperature, ZnO shows low grain aggregation and significant particle spacing, indicating low crystallinity and the presence of numerous surface defects and active sites.
Figure 1b Roasted at 360 °C: The average particle size of ZnO increased to 21.2 nm, with slight particle aggregation. The increased temperature promotes further lattice growth of ZnO particles, reducing crystal defects and surface active sites.
Figure 1c Roasted at 460 °C: After calcination, the ZnO particle size increased to 24.1 nm, with more pronounced aggregation and irregular particle morphology. Higher calcination temperatures improve the crystallinity of ZnO, promoting grain growth and significantly reducing surface active sites.
Figure 1d Roasted at 550 °C: At 550 °C, the ZnO particle size increased to 35.3 nm, with noticeable agglomeration and increased irregularity. At this stage, the grain size of ZnO increases, and the number of oxygen vacancies decreases, reducing catalytic performance. The TEM images in
Figure 1 clearly show that higher calcination temperatures increase the ZnO particle size and promote grain growth, thereby reducing surface active sites. This phenomenon affects the desulfurization performance of ZnO, as larger ZnO particles exhibit lower desulfurization efficiency.
In addition to changes in particle size, the effect of calcination temperature on the specific surface area and pore structure of nano-ZnO was also evaluated using nitrogen adsorption-desorption measurements at 77 K. As shown in
Table 1, the specific surface area of nano-ZnO decreased significantly with increasing calcination temperature. Specifically, the BET surface area declined from 46.86 m
2/g at 260 °C to 6.86 m
2/g at 550 °C. This substantial decrease is primarily attributed to particle growth and aggregation induced by higher calcination temperatures, which reduces the overall surface area and active sites available for H
2S adsorption. A lower specific surface area may consequently lead to reduced desulfurization performance, highlighting the importance of optimizing calcination conditions to maintain high surface activity.
The surface area measurements were conducted using a Quantachrome NOVA gas adsorption analyzer, with nitrogen as the adsorbate and BET method applied for data analysis. Prior to measurement, the samples were degassed at 200 °C for over 2 h to remove moisture and contaminants.
Figure 2 shows the XRD diffraction patterns of nano ZnO prepared at different calcination temperatures, including the patterns before and after the desulfurization reaction. The XRD patterns provide information about the structural changes of ZnO during the desulfurization process.
Figure 2a (Before Reaction, 260 °C calcination): The XRD pattern of the sample calcined at 260 °C shows a strong diffraction peak, indicating that the ZnO crystal structure is well-formed with no apparent impurities or other compounds.
Figure 2b (After Reaction, O: 1.23%): After the reaction, the diffraction peaks of ZnO shift slightly, and a diffraction peak for ZnS appears. The presence of oxygen promotes the formation of oxygen vacancies on the ZnO surface, facilitating the reaction between ZnO and H
2S, leading to the formation of ZnS. This change indicates that a structural transformation occurred in ZnO during the desulfurization process.
Figure 2c (After Reaction, O: 0%): Under oxygen-free conditions, the XRD pattern of ZnO shows significant changes. The diffraction peak for ZnS increases noticeably, while the ZnO diffraction peak decreases. This suggests that under oxygen-free conditions, more ZnS forms on the surface of ZnO, and the increase in oxygen vacancies promotes the formation of ZnS. The XRD analysis in
Figure 2 reveals the crystallographic changes in ZnO during the desulfurization process, particularly the reaction between ZnO and sulfur to form ZnS under different conditions. This suggests that oxygen vacancies play a catalytic role in the desulfurization process.
2.2. Desulfurization Performance Analysis
Figure 3 shows the XPS spectrum of Zn
2P for nano-ZnO calcined at 260 °C, both before and after the desulfurization reaction. XPS analysis provides detailed information on the chemical state of the ZnO surface.
Figure 3(a) Before the reaction: The Zn
2P spectrum shows the presence of Zn, with the Zn
2p3/2 peak at 1021.75 eV, indicating that the ZnO surface is primarily composed of Zn, with no significant reaction.
Figure 3(b) After the reaction (O: 1.23%): After the reaction under aerobic conditions, the Zn
2P peak shifted slightly, indicating the reduction of Zn and its transformation into ZnS. Oxygen participation promotes the formation of oxygen vacancies on the ZnO surface, which facilitates the formation of ZnS.
Figure 3(c) After the reaction (O: 0%): In the absence of oxygen, the Zn
2P peak shifted significantly, indicating that Zn was transformed into ZnS, along with the formation of other oxides. The XPS results in
Figure 3 show that oxygen vacancies and reaction conditions significantly affect the chemical state and desulfurization performance of the ZnO surface. Changes in oxygen concentration and reaction atmosphere can alter the valence state of Zn on the ZnO surface, thereby affecting desulfurization efficiency.
Table 2 presents the XPS data for Zn and O elements on the nano-ZnO surface at different calcination temperatures. The data show that the calcination temperature significantly affects the surface oxygen vacancies and the chemical state of ZnO. Roasting at 260 °C: The Zn binding energy is high, and the Zn-O binding energy is strong, indicating fewer oxygen vacancies on the surface and a more stable ZnO surface. Roasting at 550 °C: The binding energies of Zn and Zn-O decreased, indicating an increase in oxygen vacancies on the ZnO surface, which enhances the role of oxygen vacancies in promoting desulfurization. The results in
Table 2 further confirm the effect of calcination temperature on the chemical state of the ZnO surface. Higher temperatures lead to more oxygen vacancies, which, in turn, affect the desulfurization performance of ZnO.
Figure 4 shows the S2P XPS spectrum of nano-ZnO after desulfurization, indicating the formation of sulfides on the ZnO surface. Analysis of the S2P peak reveals the chemical states of sulfur species generated during the ZnO desulfurization reaction [
6,
7]. Zinc polysulfide is unstable and easily oxidized
Figure 4(b) After the reaction (O: 1.23%): After the reaction in oxygen, the S2P peak shifted, indicating the formation of ZnS on the ZnO surface.
Figure 4(c) After the reaction (O: 0%): Under anaerobic conditions, the S2P peak shifted significantly, indicating the formation of polysulfides. The XPS analysis in
Figure 4 reveals the types and quantities of sulfides on the ZnO surface, with oxygen concentration playing a crucial role in sulfide formation [
8,
9,
10].
Figure 5 shows the H
2-TPR (hydrogen temperature-programmed reduction) diagram of nano-ZnO at different calcination temperatures. The figure illustrates the effect of calcination temperature on the reduction performance of ZnO.
Figure 5(a) Roasted at 260 °C: The reduction peak of ZnO is low, indicating weak reduction at this temperature.
Figure 5(b) Roasted at 360 °C: The ZnO reduction peak shifts to a higher temperature, indicating enhanced reduction.
Figure 5(c) Roasted at 550 °C: The ZnO reduction peak shifts significantly to higher temperatures, indicating that high-temperature roasting enhances ZnO’s reducibility.
Figure 5 H
2-TPR analysis shows that calcination temperature significantly affects the reduction performance of ZnO. High-temperature roasting enhances the reduction performance of ZnO, thereby promoting its desulfurization efficiency.
Figure 6 shows the desulfurization activity of nano-ZnO, further confirming the effect of calcination temperature on ZnO’s desulfurization performance.
Figure 6(a) ZnO with a particle size of 14.3 nm: This sample demonstrates the highest desulfurization efficiency and the shortest reaction time.
Figure 6(b) ZnO with a particle size of 35.3 nm: This sample shows the lowest desulfurization efficiency and the longest reaction time. The results in
Figure 6 further demonstrate that ZnO with smaller particle sizes has higher desulfurization activity, due to its larger specific surface area and more oxygen vacancies.
Table 3 shows the color changes of ZnO after the desulfurization reaction at various calcination temperatures. The color change is closely related to the types of sulfides formed on the ZnO surface. Roasting at 260 °C: After desulfurization, the product is reddish-brown, indicating the formation of polysulfides. Roasting at 550 °C: The product after desulfurization is white ZnS, indicating the formation of ZnS. The results in
Table 3 further confirm the effect of calcination temperature on the desulfurization reaction products. At lower temperatures, the products formed by ZnO are more complex and may include polysulfides, whereas at higher temperatures, ZnO primarily produces ZnS. This further confirms that calcination temperature and particle size significantly influence the desulfurization performance of nano-ZnO. An increase in calcination temperature promotes ZnO grain growth, reduces oxygen vacancies, and subsequently lowers desulfurization performance. ZnO with smaller particle sizes provides more active sites due to its larger specific surface area and higher number of oxygen vacancies, leading to higher desulfurization efficiency [
11,
12].
Figure 7 shows the color changes in products after the desulfurization reaction of nano-ZnO with different particle sizes. As shown in
Figure 1, as the particle size of nano-ZnO increases, the color of the desulfurization products lightens, and products formed by ZnO with different particle sizes exhibit varying colors [
13].
Figure 7a ZnO with a particle size of 14.3 nm: The desulfurization product is reddish-brown, indicating a high sulfur content and a darker product color.
Figure 7b After exposure of the 14.3 nm product: Over time, the reddish-brown product gradually turns light yellow, indicating that the sulfur species are unstable and oxidize in air to form stable polysulfides.
Figure 7c ZnO with a particle size of 21.2 nm: The desulfurization product is orange-red, indicating a lighter color and lower polysulfide content.
Figure 7d ZnO with a particle size of 24.1 nm: The desulfurization product is orange-yellow, indicating that as the particle size increases, the color lightens and the polysulfide content decreases.
Figure 7e ZnO with a particle size of 35.3 nm: The desulfurization product is light ochre, indicating further reduction in polysulfide content, with ZnS as the main product.
Figure 7f ZnS (white): As the desulfurization product of pure ZnO, ZnS is white, confirming that ZnO primarily produces ZnS under standard conditions, with the product being stable elemental sulfur. The results in
Figure 7 show that the smaller the particle size of nano-ZnO, the darker the color of the desulfurization products, resembling polysulfides. As ZnO particle size increases, the color of the desulfurization products lightens and approaches stable ZnS, indicating a decrease in polysulfide formation during the reaction. ZnO desulfurization products with different particle sizes exhibit varying colors, closely related to their surface structure and oxygen vacancy count. More oxygen vacancies and surface active sites lead to more complex sulfur species, resulting in darker product colors.
To further verify the composition of nano-ZnO desulfurization products with different particle sizes, the researchers reacted the products with a small amount of dilute HCl solution. After adding HCl to the desulfurization products of ZnO with different particle sizes, the products gradually dissolved, producing an H2S odor and causing the solution to turn turbid, indicating the presence of ZnS and elemental sulfur. As particle size increases, the solubility of the products decreases, indicating that larger particles contain less elemental sulfur and more ZnS. This phenomenon shows that the particle size of nano-ZnO directly affects the types and quantities of sulfides produced. ZnO with smaller particle sizes produces more polysulfides due to more surface active sites, while larger particles primarily generate ZnS.
Figure 8 shows the MS-H
2S-TPSR spectrum of nano-ZnO during the desulfurization reaction, enabling the analysis of sulfur species generation and transformation.
Figure 8 shows that at 200 °C, the SO desorption peak begins to appear, indicating that at lower temperatures, the ZnO surface releases oxygen-containing sulfides. These sulfur species are likely intermediates in an oxidized state, such as sulfate or polysulfides.
Figure 8 shows a small shoulder peak around 260 °C, indicating increased SO release from the ZnO surface, further confirming sulfide oxidation during low-temperature desulfurization.
Figure 8 shows that at 580 °C and 711 °C, the SO desorption peak becomes more prominent, with two overlapping peaks, indicating that the sulfur species generated in the reaction may exist in different chemical states (e.g., ZnS and sulfur coordinated with Zn). These peaks indicate that the ZnO desulfurization reaction not only produces ZnS but also generates polysulfides or other oxidized sulfur species.
Figure 8 analysis of the MS-H
2S-TPSR spectrum reveals that at least three different chemical states of sulfur species are generated by HS adsorption on the ZnO surface. These intermediates react with oxygen vacancies on the ZnO surface to form polysulfides or elemental sulfur. At higher temperatures, these sulfur species gradually transform into stable ZnS and SO
2.
2.3. Desulfurization Mechanism Analysis
Many studies suggest that the desulfurization products of commercial ZnO are ZnS, independent of temperature. Under aerobic conditions, ZnS undergoes the following regeneration reaction between 700 °C and 800 °C:
The SO
2 desorption peaks at 580 °C and 711 °C on the SO
2 mass chromatographic curve are inferred to correspond to sulfur coordinated with Zn in the surface phase and sulfur in ZnS in the bulk phase, respectively. These species are oxidized by active oxygen separated from lattice oxygen or oxygen from water at higher temperatures [
14].
ZnS with spinel and non-spinel structures can be transformed into ZnO at 480 °C and 600 °C, respectively, with SO
2 desorbed [
15]. This indicates that the SO
2 desorption peak in the 200 °C to 282 °C range is due to sulfur that is more easily oxidized than the sulfur in ZnS. Room-temperature desulfurization of nano-ZnO with different particle sizes produces products of varying colors, with instability resembling that of polysulfides. XPS analysis shows that the desulfurization products contain sulfur species similar to those in polysulfides [
13]. This paper presents MS-H
2S-TPD (TPSR) analysis, which shows that sulfur species desorbing SO
2 at 200 °C are considered to have polysulfide bonds. The observed reddish-brown coloration, the low-temperature SO
2 desorption peaks, and the broadening of the S2p XPS peaks suggest the likely presence of zinc polysulfide (ZnS
x), which is known to be thermodynamically unstable and prone to oxidation, forming elemental sulfur.
The Gibbs free energy of reaction (2) is −300.37 kJ/mol, which is lower than that of reaction (1), at −14.84 kJ/mol. This suggests that reaction (2) is more likely to occur. Consequently, the temperature range of the SO2 desorption peak for sulfur species in zinc polysulfide is lower than that in ZnS.
Zn
2+, Zn
+, and other zinc species are present in nano-ZnO. When oxygen vacancies are present, they capture electrons, forming “
![Catalysts 15 00547 i001]()
”. To maintain electrical neutrality in the crystal, adjacent Zn2
+ ions are reduced to Zn
+, while oxygen vacancies lower the binding energy of lattice oxygen. This promotes the reduction of metals from higher to lower oxidation states [
16] and aids the oxidation desulfurization reaction. A surface reaction between sulfur species and ZnO lattice oxygen is unlikely. However, sulfur species can occupy or adsorb oxygen vacancies [
17]. The room temperature desulfurization mechanism of nano-ZnO was analyzed based on the characteristics of its desulfurization products under anaerobic conditions. These include the large specific surface area of nano-materials and the abundance of oxygen vacancies.
Oxygen vacancies, which are bound to electrons, preferentially adsorb surface oxygen on nano-ZnO, forming highly reactive oxidation species such as O
22− and O
2− [
18]. These highly reactive particles collide with H
2S adsorbed on nano-ZnO or sulfur coordinated to zinc atoms, initiating a rapid redox reaction that oxidizes sulfur from a valence of −2 to oxidation states of −1, 0, or fractional values. These neutral sulfur species adsorb onto the ZnO surface and oxygen vacancies, where they are unstable. The generated sulfur exhibits catalytic activity, oxidizing H
2S to elemental sulfur [
19]. Unstable active intermediates react with H
2S or sulfur coordinated to adjacent zinc atoms, forming compounds that contain S-S bonds. As the size of nano-ZnO particles increases and the specific surface area and oxygen vacancies decrease, the formation of S-S bonds decreases, while the replacement of lattice oxygen by sulfur increases. This indicates that oxygen vacancies and surface area are key internal factors influencing the desulfurization performance of the desulfurizer.
Alkali metal sulfides (or ammonium sulfides) react with elemental sulfur at room temperature, producing polysulfides [
20].
It can be concluded that particles with high oxidation activity, such as O
22− and O
2−, oxidize H
2S to elemental sulfur, which then reacts with sulfur coordinated to zinc atoms, forming zinc polysulfide. The reaction is as follows:
Under oxygen-free conditions, a large amount of reddish-brown desulfurization products are produced during the ZnO desulfurization reaction at 14.3 nm, consistent with the proposed reaction mechanism. Additionally, during the vulcanization reaction, some bonds break while others form. The reddish-brown desulfurization products are likely zinc oxysulfides (ZnSxOy) or ZnSxOyH, which contain polysulfide bonds.