Skip to Content
You are currently on the new version of our website. Access the old version .
SustainabilitySustainability
  • Article
  • Open Access

2 January 2023

20 Pages

Comprehensive Evaluation of Freeway Driving Risks Based on Fuzzy Logic

,
and
1
Intelligent Transportation Systems Research Center, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan 430063, China
2
Guangxi Key Laboratory of ITS, Guilin University of Electronic Technology, Guilin 541004, China
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.

Abstract

The quantitative evaluation of driving risk is a crucial prerequisite for intelligent vehicle accident warning, and it is necessary to predict it comprehensively and accurately. Therefore, a simulated driving experiment was conducted with 16 experimental scenarios designed through an orthogonal design, and 44 subjects were recruited to explore the driving risks in different situations. A two-layer fuzzy integrated evaluation model was constructed, which considered the workload as an important element for balancing driving risk and driving behavior. Workload and road environment indicators were taken as the underlying input variables. The results show that the comprehensive evaluation model is well-suited to identify the risks of each scenario. The effectiveness of the proposed method is further confirmed by comparing the results with those of the technique for order preference by similarity to an ideal solution (TOPSIS) model. The proposed method could be used for real-time vehicle safety warning and provide a reference for accident prevention.

1. Introduction

Road traffic accidents have become one of the most threatening challenges faced by the global community. According to the WHO, by 2022, there will be 1.3 million road traffic fatalities annually, costing nations up to 3% of their GDP in lost economic output [1]. These increasing numbers have brought the issues of traffic safety to the considerable attention of the international community. The aim of resolution A/RES/74/299 passed by the UN General Assembly is to halve the number of individuals hurt or killed in traffic accidents globally by 2030. Scholars from various countries have discussed traffic issues from a variety of perspectives. This has given a good impetus to the continuous improvement of road traffic safety.
The traffic system is complex and composed of interconnected subsystems, including drivers, vehicles, and the driving environment. The driving risk will inevitably increase in this dynamic system as a result of fluctuations in elements within the subsystem that lead to an imbalance in the interaction. Only the effective operation of every component in the traffic system can guarantee the driver’s safety while driving.
The challenge today is to determine how to comprehensively and systematically evaluate the danger of driving from a holistic viewpoint as the process of vehicle intelligence advances. Driving risk evaluation is a crucial foundation for accident warning and is a key part of achieving automated driving. It is necessary to provide a thorough description of the driver, vehicle, and driving environment to construct a driving risk evaluation model. Although this has been extensively discussed by researchers, there is still no consensus on the best way to set up an assessment index system. Evaluation indices still rely on accident data. However, these data are insufficient to satisfy the requirements of traffic risk assessment. The application of risk evaluation is somewhat constrained since there are many indices, and the evaluation procedure is cumbersome. Many of the aforementioned issues have still not been effectively resolved in this field.
The purpose of this work is to develop a comprehensive method for assessing highway driving risk that can be used to promptly offer feedback on the state of driving safety. Using the driving workload as the breakthrough point, we designed and carried out simulated driving experiments. By taking into account the driving workload, driving performance, and driving environment, we ultimately realized the construction of the driving risk evaluation model. The proposed two-layer fuzzy integrated evaluation model enables a comprehensive measurement of driving state safety.
The remaining sections are organized as follows. The next section introduces the work related to the current study. Section 3 presents the details of the simulated driving experiment. Section 4 elaborates on the driving risk assessment approach suggested in this study. The results from the simulated driving experiment are presented in the fifth part. To ensure the model’s validity, a two-layer technique for order preference by similarity to an ideal solution (TOPSIS) model was created, and the evaluation results of the two techniques are compared. The research is concluded in the last section.

3. Driving Experiment and Dataset

To construct the driving risk evaluation model, we designed and conducted a simulated driving experiment. This experiment provided a reliable dataset for the next investigation.

3.1. Subjects

A total of 45 subjects were recruited for this experiment. During the data collection, experimental data were collected from 44 subjects due to equipment malfunctioning with 1 subject. The drivers ranged in age from 22 to 62 ( M = 31.07 ± 9.78 ), had a license that had been in good standing for 2 to 28 years ( M = 6.80 ± 6.37 ), and drove between 2 and 100 thousand kilometers each year ( M = 15.7 ± 19.0 ). There were 39 men and 5 women; among them, 14 were experienced drivers, and 40 were novice drivers. According to our survey, the participants were in good physical and mental health, and their vision was normal (including corrected vision).

3.2. Apparatus

The simulated driving experiment was launched using the driving simulation platform shown in Figure 1. The driving simulation platform is located in the Intelligent Transportation System Research Center of the Wuhan University of Technology. It is a single-channel projection simulator consisting of a modified real vehicle and the UC-win/Road software. The software provides a rich set of editable traffic scenarios, which can be used to create virtual driving scenarios easily and rapidly. We used this software to create simulated driving scenarios. For driving data transmission, we gathered experimental vehicle data over the controller area network (CAN) bus and then provided it to the aforementioned software as input for driving operation behavior. This was accomplished with the aid of our self-developed SDK plugin.
Figure 1. Driving simulator: (a) simulation platform; (b) simulated driving.
The NASA-TLX scale is a multidimensional evaluation tool that assesses participants’ workload in six key areas: mental demand, physical demand, temporal demand, performance, effort, and frustration. It is the most frequently used instrument for measuring psychological load and is widely employed in performance research. According to related research, the NASA-TLX scale offers higher sensitivity than the majority of comparable tools, has good reliability, and has the potential to more accurately represent workload [28].

3.3. Experiment Design

This experiment controls four factors of the driving environment, including horizontal curve radius, longitudinal slope gradient, traffic flow, and sign information. We designed the scenarios according to the L16(45) orthogonal table shown in Table 1 and expected to obtain 16 experimental scenarios [29]. The simulated driving software UC-win/Road was used to conduct the scenario construction and simulation experiments. The simulated driving experiment road is a highway with a design speed of 100 km/h and a lane width of 3.75 m, in line with the specifications of the Highway Engineering Technical Standard (JTG B01-2014) (in China). It is situated in the plain microhill region and has four lanes going in both directions. The subjects’ workloads were measured using the NASA-TLX scale and driving performance data were collected using UC-win/Road simulation software.
Table 1. Orthogonal test factors.

3.4. Procedure

The staff asked the subjects some questions about their background and current health state before the experiment started, after which they explained the use of the driving simulator and the NASA-TLX scale [30]. They next arranged for the subjects to perform adaptive training to ensure that they were competent and could make accurate evaluations. Afterward, the staff confirmed that the subjects had no adverse reactions during the exercise.
To exclude interference, all individuals in the room turned off their communication devices before the formal experiment began. Unrelated people were asked to leave the laboratory. Subjects were asked to maintain their driving habits as in a real car as much as they could. The staff notified the subject of the trip’s destination before inviting them to the experiment section. They then asked the subject to determine the direction of the destination after successfully recognizing the traffic signs. After completing the driving task of one experimental scenario, the subject drove the vehicle into the transition section, completed the NASA-TLX scale with the assistance of the staff, and then drove into the next section. The experiment was limited to 90 min, thus avoiding fatigued driving.
The driver could only drive once in the scenario after the experiment formally started. The team arranged the cases in a random sequence to prevent learning effects. If a traffic accident occurred during driving, the subject was forced to take a 20-min break before continuing; if two driving accidents occurred, the experiment was terminated, and this subject was excluded from the experiment.

3.5. Data Processing

The input parameters of the evaluation model are divided into three categories, namely, driving environment, driving performance, and driving workload. Among them, the driving environment parameters were preset in the simulator during the scenario-building stage. Driving performance data were provided by the driving simulator. During the experiment, the driving simulator captured and preserved real-time driving performance data at a frequency of 10 Hz. These data could be exported after the experiment was completed. Driving workload data were provided by the NASA-TLX scale completed by the subjects. After obtaining the raw experimental data, we processed them to obtain data matrices.

3.5.1. Driving Performance

We filtered and extracted all driving performance data from the output data of the driving simulator and stored them in a table. We then segmented these time-series data by scenario and removed the data for nonexperimental road segments.
In this paper, we applied the DBSCAN algorithm to determine outliers and preprocess the driving performance data. DBSCAN (density-based spatial clustering of applications with noise) is a clustering method based on the density of sample points that determines the core points by taking into account the connectivity of a sample with other sample points in its neighborhood. To be considered core points, each sample point’s neighborhood must have M i n P t s (minimal sample points) of samples within a specified E p s (minimum radius) [31]. E p s and M i n P t s are artificially set. We chose the Mahalanobis distance as the distance measure between two points because it has two advantages [32]. One is that it excludes the interference of correlation between variables. Second, it eliminates the influence of the dimensions. Therefore, it enables us to effectively treat the driving performance variables.
We applied the 4-dist chart to determine the two key parameters of the DBSCAN algorithm: E p s and M i n P t s . The 4-dist, as well as the K-dist, chart is a method in [31] to determine these two parameters of the cluster in the database. The results of the experiment indicate that the 4-dist and the K-dist charts are not significantly different. Therefore, we set M i n P t s to 4 and determined the E p s by interaction using the 4-dist chart.
The 4-dist chart in Figure 2 shows the optimal E p s for driving performance to be [0.3, 2]. We set E p s = 0.3 and performed DBSCAN iterations in steps of 0.1. The calculation results are shown in Figure 3.
Figure 2. 4-dist chart of driving performance.
Figure 3. Silhouette coefficient.
The silhouette coefficient is an evaluation method of clustering validity. The closer its value is to 1, the better the clustering effect [33]. As seen from Figure 3, the upward trend of the silhouette coefficient is no longer obvious for E p s > 1.4 . Thus, we set the parameters of DBSCAN E p s = 1.4 and M i n P t s = 4 . After completing the parameter settings, we applied the DBSCAN algorithm to filter out the outliers. Then, we calculated the mean values of each driving performance parameter separately by scenario number. By calculation, we obtained the driving performance matrix X p .

3.5.2. Driving Workload

For the driving workload, we stored the measured NASA-TLX scale data in a table and calculated the weights w i based on the results of its second part (matching part). Then, we multiplied the scores Score i of the six driving workload dimensions in the first part of the scale with their corresponding weights and calculated the weighted total score to obtain the driving workload s .
s = ∑ 1 6 Score i × w i 100

4. Methodology

This section provides a detailed explanation of the steps involved in building the driving risk evaluation model. The modeling scheme is roughly divided into the following steps. First, we set up index sets and evaluation sets. Then, we constructed the membership functions and determined the index weights. Finally, we developed the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model. Figure 4 depicts the general structure of the comprehensive evaluation scheme of driving risk.
Figure 4. Driving risk evaluation block scheme.

4.1. Index Sets

Driving environment indices reflect the characteristics of the highway environment and the effects of static and dynamic factors on traffic safety. Road alignment can directly affect driving performance. On road sections with smaller horizontal curve radii, drivers need to carefully adjust the vehicle’s attitude to ensure that the vehicle passes through the curve safely [34]. When driving on longitudinally sloped sections, drivers need to ensure vehicle dynamics by constantly adjusting the accelerator and brake pedals [35]. The longitudinal slope increases the difficulty of vehicle control and the risk of collision. Drivers spend significantly less time maneuvering on curved and longitudinal slope sections, which increases the probability of accidents. One reasonable explanation is that more attention and mental resources are needed to obtain road information and make decisions [30,36].
The majority of researchers believe that as traffic volume increases, the crash rate also increases [37]. Fitzpatrick investigated the connection between driving performance and traffic flow using drivers’ cognitive time [38]. Compared to free driving, the severity of lateral conflict during lane changes rises with traffic flow, which undoubtedly increases the collision risk [39]. There is a threshold on the information of individual traffic signs. As the information on traffic signs grows, the driver’s cognitive time increases significantly, which shrinks the driver’s decision and maneuvering time [40,41]. Lyu et al. conducted a comprehensive analysis of the amount of traffic sign information to achieve information quantification and grading [24]. Based on information analysis for a large number of traffic signs, they classified the amount of traffic sign information into 4 levels. In this paper, we applied the above method to quantitatively classify the information on traffic signs and implement quantitative loading of driving workload for drivers in different scenarios.
Driving performance indices reflect the vehicle’s operation status and its dynamic performance [42]. According to studies, the vehicle speed is positively correlated with the traffic accident rate within a certain speed interval [43]. Therefore, the risk of traffic accidents increases as the operating speed increases. Longitudinal acceleration characterizes the fluctuation of the speed and can reflect the stability and safety of the vehicle in the longitudinal direction of the road [44]. Its variation is positively correlated with the traffic accident rate and can reflect the risk of driving to some extent. The lateral offset is the deviation of the longitudinal centerline of the vehicle from the centerline of its lane, which can reflect the lane keeping of the vehicle. Studies have shown that visual distractions during driving could lead to an increase in the lateral offset, thus causing driving risks [45]. Lateral acceleration is the acceleration perpendicular to the direction of travel when the vehicle is moving. It reflects the driver’s manipulation of the steering wheel and is often used to evaluate driving stability and comfort. Curve section driving is the root cause of lateral acceleration. As lateral acceleration increases, the risk of skid increases, which increases the possibility of accidents to some extent [34].
In addition, driving behavior is also affected by the workload experienced by the driver. According to the definition of mental workload, it is influenced by the driving task, driving environment, and driving experience and can reflect the driver’s attention resources during the driving task [46]. The driving workload and accident rate follow a U-shaped curve, indicating that there is no linear relationship between them. Accident rates under low or high driving workload conditions are higher than those under reasonable intervals [47].
In this paper, we considered the influence of the driving environment, driving performance, and driving workload on driving risk and selected nine indices from the above three aspects to build the index system. The related variables are shown in Table 2.
Table 2. Variable descriptions.

4.2. Evaluation Sets

The evaluation sets and membership functions of each index must be determined to construct a comprehensive evaluation model. The evaluation sets and membership functions of r , i , Q , S , v are determined according to the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People’s Republic of China and the Technical Standard of Highway Engineering (JTG B01-2014). Since indices such as a z , l , a x , s lack the classification criteria of the evaluation level, this paper applied the k-means clustering algorithm to construct their evaluation system.
The purpose of clustering is to group all samples into a finite number of clusters and extract intervals of different evaluation levels of each index to construct a fuzzy evaluation matrix. The k-means algorithm is one of the most widely used clustering algorithms and is efficient and easy to implement. Here, we determined the sample point distances using the Euclidean method to calculate the sum of squared distances between each cluster’s center point μ i and points inside it. The algorithm performs the iterative calculation on the data, stops the operations when a given accuracy is reached, and outputs the clustering results to minimize the total sum of J squares for each cluster.
Since the data we obtained were not labeled, we chose internal indices to evaluate the clustering effect as a way to select K when the indices are optimal. Here, we chose the silhouette coefficient for evaluation and verified this optimal value by referring to the gap statistic algorithm [33]. The gap statistic algorithm finds K that makes G a p K reach the maximum by calculating the sum of squares’ distances inside the cluster [48]. Under this condition, the difference between the random sample loss and the actual sample loss reaches the maximum.
Figure 5 shows the silhouette coefficients and G a p K of each index for different K . As seen from the figure, the optimal K values corresponding to a z , l , a x , s are 2 , 2 , 3 , 2 . Considering that there is not much of a difference between K = 2 and K = 3 , setting K = 3 is more favorable for the construction of the membership functions; hence, their K values were taken to be 3. Thus, the K values of each index were determined as 3 , 2 , 3 , 3 . The clustering results are shown in Figure 6.
Figure 5. Clustering index values for each evaluation index at different K values: (a) a z ; (b) l ; (c) a x ; (d) s .
Figure 6. Clustering results: (a) a z ; (b) l ; (c) a x ; (d) s .

4.3. Membership Functions

Based on the above results, the evaluation set and membership functions for each index were constructed. Considering the differences in attributes among indices, we used a combination of the triangular membership function and trapezoidal membership function to construct the membership functions of the comprehensive evaluation model. They are similar to Figure 7.
Figure 7. Example of membership functions.
This approach can reflect the differences between different indices while ensuring high sensitivity of the input and output variables [42]. Here, we applied the results of the K-means clustering analysis described above to define the clusters of indices that were categorized using the corresponding evaluation levels. We defined the upper and lower limits of each cluster as the segmented nodes of the corresponding membership function, thus achieving differential construction. The completed membership functions were constructed as shown in Table 3. The nodes of each evaluation interval are represented by the parameters in Table 3, and Table 4 displays their corresponding values.
Table 3. Index membership functions.
Table 4. Critical values of indices.

4.4. Weight System

Considering the differences in the importance of the foundation and superstructure indices, we calculated the index weights from the bottom to the top.
Previous studies have analyzed the correlation between driving workload, driving performance, and driving environment [49]. The gray relational characterizes the degree of correlation between indices and can reflect how important the participating indices are in comparison to the reference indices. From this, we can derive the weights of driving environment subordinate indices. Driving workload indices and driving performance indices can reflect the influence of driving environment factors on drivers’ driving behavior. This study chose the vehicle speed and driving workload to determine the weights for the driving environment index W e .
For other indices, the entropy weight method (EWM) was used to calculate the weights. EWM is an objective weighting method that determines the weight by calculating the difference in the information entropy of indices. In essence, it assigns weights to indices by considering their discrete degree, which can more accurately reflect the extent to which indices such as the driving environment, driving performance, and driving workload affect the risk of highway driving. According to Shannon’s information entropy theory, we calculated the index weights by Equations (2)–(4) [50]. Unlike the concept of information entropy proposed by Shannon, the value of a was taken here as the value of the number of evaluation objects involved in the weight calculation, instead of the default value of 2. This ensures a reasonable distribution of weights. This paper proposed a solution to the issue that zero values may appear after index normalization: whenever a particular index appears to be zero, all index values of the object involved in the weight calculation are increased by 1 × 10 − 5 . This ensures the data integrity to the maximum extent without affecting the weight distribution of indices.
ρ i j = x i j ′ ∑ i = 1 k x i j ′
I j = − ∑ i = 1 k ρ i j log a ( ρ i j )
w j = 1 − I j ∑ j = 1 m 1 − I j
where x i j ′ is the normalized data, ρ i j is the proportion of x i j ′ in index q j , I j is the information entropy of the index, and w j is the weight of index q j . We obtained the index weight vector W p using the aforementioned calculation. Based on the weight determination method in the previous section, we calculated the index weights separately. Table 5 displays the derived driving performance index weights W p and driving environment index weights W e .
Table 5. Index weights of the foundation.
After completing the foundation evaluation, we obtained the risk values of the foundation evaluation for each subject. By integrating the foundation evaluation results into vector form, we obtained the driving performance risk vector S p and the driving environment risk vector S e . Next, using Equation (5), we integrated S p , S e , and the driving workload vector s to obtain the superstructure’s weighting matrix X . To obtain the index weights W for the superstructure evaluation, we normalized the weighting matrix X and computed the index weights by the previously discussed EWM (Equations (2)–(4)). The calculation results are shown in Table 6. Thus, we completed the construction of the model weight system.
X = S p , S e , s = R i s k p 1 R i s k e 1 s 1 R i s k p 2 R i s k e 2 s 2 ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ R i s k p k R i s k e k s k k × 3 = x 11 x 12 x 13 x 21 x 22 x 23 ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ x k 1 x k 2 x k 3 k × 3
Table 6. Index weights of the superstructure.

4.5. Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation Model

Let there be m different risk factors in total, which are represented by q 1 ,   q 2 ,   ⋯ , q m ; then, there are m indices of the comprehensive evaluation model corresponding to these influencing factors, and let the index set be Q = q 1 ,   q 2 ,   ⋯ ,   q m . The levels corresponding to the indices vary among them. Let the index q i have n levels; then, the index has n evaluation levels. The evaluation levels are v 1 ,   v 2 ,   ⋯ ,   v n , and the evaluation set is V = v 1 ,   v 2 ,   ⋯ ,   v n .
Let u j be the membership function of index q i in level v j ; then, u j = μ v j , U = u 1 ,   u 2 ,   ⋯ ,   u n . From this, we calculated the risk evaluation matrix R m × n based on the membership function, where r i j = u j q i .
After obtaining the evaluation matrix R and the index weight vector W , we performed a comprehensive evaluation layer by layer from the bottom to the top and calculated the driving performance risk vector R i s k p and the driving environment risk vector R i s k e . As shown in Equation (6), the comprehensive evaluation operation Δ − ∇ used the ( ⨁ ε , ⨂ ε ) operator. This strategy retains the evaluation information of individual indices while taking into account the overall effect [51].
e j = R ∘ W = r 1 j ∇ w 1 Δ r 2 j ∇ w 2 Δ ⋯ Δ r m j ∇ w m
where e j is the degree to which the indices are affiliated in level j . In this paper, f was defined as the quantitative matrix corresponding to the evaluation levels of indices. From this, we calculated the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation values R i s k p and R i s k e according to Equations (7)–(10).
e j ′ = e j ∑ j = 1 n e j
E ′ = e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , ⋯ , e n ′
f = 100 · 1 , n − 1 n , n − 2 n , ⋯ , 1 n
R i s k = E ′ · f T
We substituted s i into the corresponding membership functions and applied Equation (11) to obtain the superstructure evaluation matrix R . According to Equations (6)–(10), we integrated R , W , and f to obtain the comprehensive evaluation value of driving risk R i s k . Finally, we obtained the evaluation model of driving risk.
R = E p E e E s = e 11 e 12 ⋯ e 1 n e 21 e 22 ⋯ e 2 n e 31 e 32 ⋯ e 3 n 3 × n

5. Results

In the following, we present the evaluation results of the model. We constructed a two-layer TOPSIS model for comparison and calculated the evaluation results using the same input dataset. Finally, we compared the evaluation results of these two methods to verify the validity of the model.

5.1. Evaluation Results

Figure 8 is divided into two parts, showing the assessment values of driving performance R i s k p and driving workload s for each subject. The 44 subjects’ comprehensive risk of driving performance in 16 scenarios comprise the top section, while their driving workload scores s are depicted in the bottom part. R i s k p was determined by comprehensive assessment v , a z , l , a x . Heatmaps are used to display the evaluation results. Each square in the graph corresponds to a subject (horizontal coordinate) and a scenario (vertical coordinate). The color of the squares is used to indicate the driving performance risk (top) and driving workload (bottom) in a given scenario. In other words, the color depth of the blocks serves as an indicator of the risk values. The legend indicates that the color of the relevant square changes depending on the risk value: the greater the risk value is, the darker the color; the lower the risk value is, the closer the color is to white. It is clear that the model is capable of easily identifying scenarios with high driving performance risk and high driving workload. As seen from the figure, despite the high subjective driving load of drivers in some scenarios (e.g., segments 6 and 9), there was no deterioration in driving performance.
Figure 8. Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation values of driving performance and driving workload.
Figure 9 shows the evaluation results of each subject, that is, the value of driving risk, R i s k , which is obtained from the comprehensive evaluation of three variables R i s k e , R i s k p , s . It shows the comprehensive driving risk of the 44 subjects in 16 different scenarios in the form of a heatmap. As with the foundation evaluation, the comprehensive driving risk values are marked in the form of color depth, and the correspondence rules are the same. The figure illustrates that the model is able to clearly detect high-risk driving scenarios. As observed from the figure, the driving risk in these complicated scenarios (e.g., segments 8 and 9) is obviously higher than that of other sections. Compared with the assessment based on behavior or workload alone, the comprehensive assessment results of risk show a similar trend for each participant.
Figure 9. Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation values of driving risk.

5.2. Model Validation

To verify the effectiveness of the proposed method in this paper, we constructed a TOPSIS model for comparison. The TOPSIS model can be used to evaluate each solution by calculating the distance between the evaluation object and the ideal solution. This method can make full use of the original data with little information loss and works well to resolve the multi-index decision problem. Similar to the method proposed in this work, the TOPSIS model we built is divided into two evaluation structures. The calculation process is as follows.
First, we normalized and standardized the data of each index and then integrated them to construct the evaluation matrix Z k × m . Equation (12) illustrates the process of standardization.
z i j = x i j ∑ i = 1 k x i j 2
We determined the positive ideal solution Z + and the negative ideal solution Z − of the matrix Z . Z + is the vector consisting of the optimal values of each column of Z , and Z − is the vector consisting of its worst values. Since we normalized the data, the optimal value is the maximum value of each column, and the worst value is its minimum value. The representation of Z + and Z − is shown in Equations (13)–(14).
Z + = z 1 + , z 2 + , ⋯ , z m +
Z − = z 1 − , z 2 − , ⋯ , z m −
where z m + = m a x z 1 m ,   z 2 m ,   ⋯ ,   z k m , z m − = m i n z 1 m ,   z 2 m ,   ⋯ ,   z k m . Accordingly, we calculated the evaluation object’s distance d i + from the positive ideal solution Z + and its distance d i − from the negative ideal solution Z − . The calculation process is shown in Equations (15)–(16). Finally, we evaluated the solution by calculating the similarity C of each evaluation object to the ideal solution by Equation (17).
d i + = ∑ j = 1 m w j z j + − z i j 2
d i − = ∑ j = 1 m w j z i j − z j − 2
C i = d i − d i + + d i −
The TOPSIS model evaluation integrates three aspects: driving environment, driving performance, and driving workload. This makes it possible to assess the comprehensive driving risk. The driving environment index and driving performance index are the results of the foundation evaluation in TOPSIS. We calculated the similarity C of the comprehensive driving risk of each subject in different scenarios. A higher value of C indicates a higher risk. Figure 10 shows the analysis results of the comprehensive driving risk. By comparison, we can see that the assessment results of these two methods are basically the same. However, this conclusion remains to be tested.
Figure 10. TOPSIS evaluation values of driving risk.
We used the two-sample K-S test to test the evaluation results. The test findings indicate that there was no statistically significant difference between the two samples (Z = 1.119, p = 0.163). The null hypothesis is accepted with p > 0.05. In other words, the distributions of the assessment results for the two methods are the same. Pearson correlation analysis was used to test the evaluation results of these methods, and the test results show a significant positive correlation between them (r = 0.824, p < 0.01). This further verifies the effectiveness of the method proposed in this work.

6. Conclusions

This work proposes a fuzzy mathematics-based method for assessing the risk of highway driving. It achieves risk evaluation in the process of driving and is able to evaluate the effect of each influencing factor on driving risk. Its main contribution is the realization of comprehensive measurement and assessment of highway driving risk.
The model integrates data from three aspects: driving environment, driving performance, and driving workload. The evaluation system is constructed by clustering, and the weight system is constructed by the entropy weight method and gray relational analysis. The model is divided into two layers. Driving environment data and driving performance data were collected and provided by the driving simulator and driving workload data were obtained based on the NASA-TLX scale. As a comparison, we also constructed a two-layer TOPSIS model and tested the evaluation results. The test showed a significant positive correlation between the results. Thus, the validity of the model was verified. The findings demonstrate that the proposed method can accurately measure driving risk.
The method provided in this study has certain advantages. It characterizes the risk of the human factors in terms of the driving workload, which provides a more comprehensive consideration of driving risk. In addition, it does not require additional equipment in the data measurement process and the required data can be provided by vehicle sensors and scales. This facilitates the application of the model in real driving conditions. Road traffic safety is influenced by various factors, which may be correlated with each other. Optimization of the index system of the model, traffic safety facilities, and improvement measures for traffic safety management will be the focus of future research.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, L.X. and J.Z.; methodology, L.X. and J.Z.; software, R.C. and J.Z.; validation, R.C. and J.Z.; formal analysis, L.X. and J.Z.; investigation, L.X.; resources, L.X.; data curation, L.X.; writing, L.X. and J.Z.; visualization, J.Z.; supervision, R.C. and L.X.; project administration, L.X.; funding acquisition, L.X. and R.C. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

The authors acknowledge the support from the National Nature Science Foundation of China (52262046), the Nature Science Foundation of Guangxi Province (Nos. 2019GXNSFBA245050, 2022GXNSFBA035640).

Institutional Review Board Statement

The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, and approved by the Ethics Committee at the Intelligent Transportation Systems Research Center, Wuhan University of Technology.

Data Availability Statement

The data used in the study are available from the corresponding author upon request.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. WHO. Road Traffic Injuries. Available online: https://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/road-traffic-injuries (accessed on 20 August 2022).
  2. Lange, J.L.; Gersten, J.C. Driving Risk Assessment of Older Drivers with Reduced Visual-acuity. In Proceedings of the 34th Annual Conference of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, Scottsdale, AZ, USA, 1–3 October 1990; pp. 477–490. [Google Scholar]
  3. Gunduz, G.; Yaman, C.; Peker, A.U.; Acarman, T. Prediction of Risk Generated by Different Driving Patterns and Their Conflict Redistribution. IEEE Trans. Intell. Veh. 2017, 3, 71–80. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  4. Wang, J.; Wu, J.; Li, Y. The Driving Safety Field Based on Driver–Vehicle–Road Interactions. IEEE Trans. Intell. Transp. Syst. 2015, 16, 2203–2214. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Fahmy, H.M.; Abd El Ghany, M.A.; Baumann, G. Vehicle Risk Assessment and Control for Lane-Keeping and Collision Avoidance at Low-Speed and High-Speed Scenarios. IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol. 2018, 67, 4806–4818. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Yan, Y.; Dai, Y.; Li, X.; Tang, J.; Guo, Z. Driving Risk Assessment Using Driving Behavior Data Under Continuous Tunnel Environment. Traffic Inj. Prev. 2019, 20, 807–812. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  7. Zhang, C.; Wang, B.; Yang, S.X.; Zhang, M.; Gong, Q.L.; Zhang, H. The Driving Risk Analysis and Evaluation in Rightward Zone of Expressway Reconstruction and Extension Engineering. J. Adv. Transp. 2020, 2020, 8943463. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  8. Sun, S.; Bi, J.; Guillen, M.; Perez-Marin, A.M. Driving Risk Assessment Using Near-Miss Events Based on Panel Poisson Regression and Panel Negative Binomial Regression. Entropy 2021, 23, 829. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  9. Katrakazas, C.; Quddus, M.; Chen, W.H. A New Integrated Collision Risk Assessment Methodology for Autonomous Vehicles. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2019, 127, 61–79. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  10. Yu, M.Y.; Vasudevan, R.; Johnson-Roberson, M. Occlusion-Aware Risk Assessment for Autonomous Driving in Urban Environments. IEEE Robot. Autom. Lett. 2019, 4, 2235–2241. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  11. Mullakkal-Babu, F.A.; Wang, M.; He, X.L.; van Arem, B.; Happee, R. Probabilistic Field Approach for Motorway Driving Risk Assessment. Transp. Res. Part C Emerg. Technol. 2020, 118, 102716. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  12. Feth, P.; Akram, M.N.; Schuster, R.; Wasenmueller, O. Dynamic Risk Assessment for Vehicles of Higher Automation Levels by Deep Learning. In Proceedings of the 37th International Conference on Computer Safety, Reliability, and Security (SAFECOMP), Vasteras, Sweden, 18–21 September 2018; pp. 535–547. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Wang, Y.B.; Xu, W.; Zhang, W.P.; Zhao, J.L. SafeDrive: A New Model for Driving Risk Analysis Based on Crash Avoidance. IEEE Trans. Intell. Transp. Syst. 2022, 23, 2116–2129. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  14. Hu, H.Y.; Wang, Q.; Cheng, M.; Gao, Z.H. Cost-sensitive Semi-supervised Deep Learning to Assess Driving Risk by Application of Naturalistic Vehicle Trajectories. Expert Syst. Appl. 2021, 178, 115041. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  15. Daniel, J.; Lauffenburger, J.-P.; Bernet, S.; Basset, M. Driving Risk Assessment with Belief Functions. In Proceedings of the IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium, Gold Coast, Australia, 23–26 June 2013; pp. 690–695. [Google Scholar]
  16. Jin, L.S.; Xian, H.C.; Jiang, Y.Y.; Niu, Q.N.; Xu, M.J.; Yang, D.M. Research on Evaluation Model for Secondary Task Driving Safety Based on Driver Eye Movements. Adv. Mech. Eng. 2014, 6, 624561. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Jin, L.; Xian, H.; Niu, Q.; Bie, J. Research on Safety Evaluation Model for In-vehicle Secondary Task Driving. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2015, 81, 243–250. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  18. Jin, L.S.; Li, K.Y.; Jiang, Y.Y.; Xian, H.C.; Gao, L.L. Classifying Secondary Task Driving Safety Using Method of F-ANP. Adv. Mech. Eng. 2015, 7, 895798. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Noh, Y.; Kim, S.; Jang, Y.J.; Yoon, Y. Modeling Individual Differences in Driver Workload Inference Using Physiological Data. Int. J. Automot. Technol. 2021, 22, 201–212. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Zeitlin, L.R. Estimates of Driver Mental Workload: A Long-term Field Trial of Two Subsidiary Tasks. Hum. Factors 1995, 37, 611–621. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Liu, H.; Xu, J.L.; Zhang, X.D.; Gao, C.; Sun, R.S. Evaluation Method of the Driving Workload in the Horizontal Curve Section Based on the Human Model of Information Processing. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022, 19, 7063. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  22. Shao, X.J.; Chen, F.; Ma, X.X.; Pan, X.D. The impact of lighting and longitudinal slope on driver behaviour in underwater tunnels: A simulator study. Tunn. Undergr. Space Technol. 2022, 122, 104367. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  23. Lyu, N.; Cao, Y.; Wu, C.; Xu, J.; Xie, L. The effect of gender, occupation and experience on behavior while driving on a freeway deceleration lane based on field operational test data. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2018, 121, 82–93. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Lyu, N.; Xie, L.; Wu, C.; Fu, Q.; Deng, C. Driver’s Cognitive Workload and Driving Performance under Traffic Sign Information Exposure in Complex Environments: A Case Study of the Highways in China. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2017, 14, 203. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Li, X.; Yan, X.; Wong, S.C. Effects of fog, driver experience and gender on driving behavior on S-curved road segments. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2015, 77, 91–104. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  26. Fitch, G.M.; Grove, K.; Hanowski, R.J.; Perez, M.A. Compensatory Behavior of Drivers When Conversing on a Cell Phone Investigation with Naturalistic Driving Data. Transp. Res. Rec. 2014, 2434, 1–8. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Davis, J.J.; Conlon, E.G. Identifying compensatory driving behavior among older adults using the situational avoidance questionnaire. J. Saf. Res. 2017, 63, 47–55. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  28. Moroney, W.F.; Biers, D.W.; Eggemeier, F.T. Some Measurement and Methodological Considerations in the Application of Subjective Workload Measurement Techniques. Int. J. Aviat. Psychol. 1995, 5, 87–106. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Xie, L.; Wu, C.; Lyu, N.; Duan, Z. Studying the effects of freeway alignment, traffic flow, and sign information on subjective driving workload and performance. Adv. Mech. Eng. 2019, 11, 1687814019853690. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  30. Hart, S.G.; Staveland, L.E. Development of NASA-TLX (Task Load Index): Results of Empirical and Theoretical Research. In Human Mental Workload; Hancock, P.A., Meshkati, N., Eds.; Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.: North-Holland, The Netherlands, 1988; Volume 52, pp. 139–183. [Google Scholar]
  31. Ester, M.; Kriegel, H.-P.; Sander, J.; Xu, X. A Density-based Algorithm for Discovering Clusters in Large Spatial Databases with Noise. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining, Portland, Oregon, 2–4 August 1996; pp. 226–231. [Google Scholar]
  32. Mahalanobis, P.C.; Bose, R.C.; Roy, S.N. Normalization of statistical variates and the use of rectangular co-ordinates in the theory of sampling distributions. Sankhay 1937, 3, 1–40. [Google Scholar]
  33. Rousseeuw, P.J. Silhouettes: A Graphical Aid to the Interpretation and Validation of Cluster Analysis. J. Comput. Appl. Math. 1987, 20, 53–65. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  34. Reymond, G.; Kemeny, A.; Droulez, J.; Berthoz, A. Role of Lateral Acceleration in Curve Driving: Driver Model and Experiments on a Real Vehicle and a Driving Simulator. Hum. Factors 2001, 43, 483–495. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  35. Furtado, G. Vehicle Stability on Combined Horizontal and Vertical Alignments. Ph.D. Thesis, Carleton University, Ottawa, ON, Canada, 2002. [Google Scholar]
  36. Hummer, J.E.; Rasdorf, W.; Findley, D.J.; Zegeer, C.V.; Sundstrom, C.A. Curve Collisions: Road and Collision Characteristics and Countermeasures. J. Transp. Saf. Secur. 2010, 2, 203–220. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  37. Roshandel, S.; Zheng, Z.; Washington, S. Impact of Real-time Traffic Characteristics on Freeway Crash Occurrence: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2015, 79, 198–211. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  38. Fitzpatrick, K.; Chrysler, S.T.; Park, E.S.; Iragavarapu, V.; Nelson, A.A. Driver Performance at High Speeds Using a Simulator. Transp. Res. Rec. 2012, 2321, 88–97. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  39. Golob, T.F.; Recker, W.W. A Method for Relating Type of Crash to Traffic Flow Characteristics on Urban Freeways. Transp. Res. Part A Policy Pract. 2004, 38, 53–80. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  40. Sharples, S.; Shalloe, S.; Burnett, G.; Crundall, D. Journey Decision Making: The Influence on Drivers of Dynamic Information Presented on Variable Message Signs. Cogn. Technol. Work. 2016, 18, 303–317. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  41. Han, L.; Du, Z.; Wang, S.; Chen, Y. Analysis of Traffic Signs Information Volume Affecting Driver’s Visual Characteristics and Driving Safety. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022, 19, 10349. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  42. Aksjonov, A.; Nedoma, P.; Vodovozov, V.; Petlenkov, E.; Herrmann, M. Detection and Evaluation of Driver Distraction Using Machine Learning and Fuzzy Logic. IEEE Trans. Intell. Transp. Syst. 2019, 20, 2048–2059. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  43. Aarts, L.; van Schagen, I. Driving Speed and the Risk of Road Crashes: A Review. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2006, 38, 215–224. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  44. Ivanchev, J.; Eckhoff, D.; Knoll, A. System-Level Optimization of Longitudinal Acceleration of Autonomous Vehicles in Mixed Traffic. In Proceedings of the IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Conference (IEEE-ITSC), Auckland, New Zealand, 27–30 October 2019; pp. 1968–1974. [Google Scholar]
  45. Engström, J.; Johansson, E.; Östlund, J. Effects of Visual and Cognitive Load in Real and Simulated Motorway Driving. Transp. Res. Part F Traffic Psychol. Behav. 2005, 8, 97–120. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  46. Galy, E.; Paxion, J.; Berthelon, C. Measuring Mental Workload with the NASA-TLX Needs to Examine Each Dimension Rather Than Relying on the Global Score: An Example with Driving. Ergonomics 2018, 61, 517–527. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  47. Piranveyseh, P.; Kazemi, R.; Soltanzadeh, A.; Smith, A. A Field Study of Mental Workload: Conventional Bus Drivers Versus Bus Rapid Transit Drivers. Ergonomics 2022, 65, 804–814. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  48. Tibshirani, R.; Walther, G.; Hastie, T. Estimating the Number of Clusters in a Data Set Via the Gap Statistic. J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. B-Stat. Methodol. 2001, 63, 411–423. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  49. Xie, L.; Wu, C.Z.; Duan, M.; Lyu, N.C. Analysis of Freeway Safety Influencing Factors on Driving Workload and Performance Based on the Gray Correlation Method. J. Adv. Transp. 2021, 2021, 6566207. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  50. Shannon, C.E. A Mathematical Theory of Communication. Bell Syst. Tech. J. 1948, 27, 379–423. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  51. Yang, L. Study on Fuzzy Mathematics and Its Applications. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Advances in Mechanical Engineering and Industrial Informatics (AMEII), Hangzhou, China, 9–10 April 2016; pp. 124–127. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.