Skip to Content
You are currently on the new version of our website. Access the old version .
EnergiesEnergies
  • Article
  • Open Access

16 October 2019

30 Pages

A Risk Assessment Model of Coalbed Methane Development Based on the Matter-Element Extension Method

,
,
and
1
School of Management Engineering, Capital University of Economics and Business, Beijing 100070, China
2
Institute for Public Safety Research, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
*
Authors to whom correspondence should be addressed.
This article belongs to the Special Issue Life Cycle Assessment of Energy Systems

Abstract

Coalbed methane development represents a complex system engineering operation that involves complex technology, many links, long cycles, and various risks. If risks are not controlled in a timely and effective manner, project operators may easily cause different levels of casualties, resource waste and property loss. To evaluate the risk status of coalbed methane development projects, this paper constructs a coalbed methane development risk assessment index system that consists of six first grade indexes and 45 second grade indexes. The weight of each index is calculated based on the structure entropy weight method. Then, a theoretical model for risk assessments of coalbed methane development is established based on the matter-element extension method. Finally, the model is applied to analyze a coalbed methane development project in the southern Qinshui Basin of China. The results show that the overall risk level of the coalbed methane development project is Grade II, indicating that the overall risk of the project is small, but the local risk of the project needs to be rectified in time. The assessment results are consistent with the actual operation of the project, indicating that the established risk assessment model has good applicability and effectiveness.

1. Introduction

With the rapid development of the global economy and the continuous advancement of urbanization, national dependence on black fossil energy, such as coal and oil, has increased. However, this increased dependence has caused excessive emissions to the atmosphere of toxic and harmful substances, such as carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, carbon monoxide and soot. These problems have caused environmental pollution problems, such as greenhouse effects, acid rain and haze, which have seriously affected the quality of life and health of residents. The above situation has received the attention of many actors, including the Chinese government. To achieve a balance between economic development and environmental protection, China’s energy use structure is changing to a pattern of “high efficiency, low energy consumption, low pollution and low emissions” under the leadership of the government [1].
In this context, coalbed methane (CBM) has become a prominent resource. CBM is mainly composed of methane that is stored in coal seams, adsorbed on the surface of coal matrix particles, partially free in coal pores or dissolved in coal seam water hydrocarbon gas. It is an associated mineral resource of coal and unconventional natural gas, and it is also a clean and high-quality energy source. China is a large coal mining country that experiences frequent gas explosions [2]. Since 1949, 126 severe gas explosion accidents (defined as killing 30 or more people in one accident) have occurred, and 7502 people have died [3]. These accidents have not only caused serious casualties and property losses, but have also had a serious negative impact on society [4,5]. The development of CBM can not only improve environmental pollution [6], but also fundamentally reduce the methane content in the coal seam, which is beneficial to reducing the occurrence of coal mine gas explosions [7,8,9]. These advantages have driven CBM development as a component of the new energy industry and ushered it into a golden development period [1]. However, CBM development represents a complex system engineering operation that involves complex technology, many links, long cycles, and various risks. CBM development is highly susceptible to various risks, such as economic, legal, technological, and management risks, and risk control failure can result in casualties, resource waste and property losses. To avoid these risks and promote the steady development of the CBM industry, it is necessary to first understand and perceive the risks throughout the life cycle of CBM development via risk assessment research.
At present, achievements have been made in the research on CBM development risk assessment. Roadifer et al. [10] evaluated the future trends and risks of CBM development and identified the key factors affecting CBM reserves and productivity by combining experimental and mathematical-statistical methods. Senthi et al. [11] used Monte Carlo simulations and the hypercube model to evaluate the economic risks faced by the CBM industry. Chen et al. [12] also used the Monte Carlo simulation method to establish a risk transformation process model of the main uncertain factors in the CBM economy. Zhang et al. [13] determined the optimal index weights using the optimized combination entropy method and the triangular fuzzy number method and established a CBM development potential assessment model. Acquah-Andoh et al. [14] explored the best schemes for optimizing a company’s revenue share for CBM development contracts based on factor analysis, discounted cash flow and parameter sensitivity analysis and found that the best scheme can distribute the economic risks of CBM development between governments and contractors. Luo et al. [15] used the net present value method to evaluate the economics of CBM production in China and found that the CBM price, productivity and operating costs are the three main factors affecting the economic feasibility of CBM development. Mares et al. [16] found that the uncertainty of adsorption capacity and desorption capacity were two important factors affecting the commercial development of CBM development, and their study provides a reference for the economic risk assessment of CBM development. Mu et al. [17] believed that three aspects are of great significance for avoiding CBM development risks: Pre-evaluation of CBM development, geological and gas reservoir engineering research and engineering technological innovation. Kirchgessne et al. [18] believed that safety and environmental factors also affect the economic benefits of CBM recovery. Su et al. [19] improved the discounted cash flow method by performing a hierarchical differentiation evaluation, staged evaluation and dynamic evaluation. It is also believed that production has the greatest impact on the economics of CBM development.
In summary, although scholars have made some achievements in the research on CBM development risks, the following shortcomings are observed:
(1)
Most studies focus on economic risk factor analyses of the national CBM industry. At present, risk assessment research for CBM development projects has not provided a reference for investors, insurance companies and CBM development operators.
(2)
Although several researchers have studied the risk of CBM development projects, the research depth was insufficient because the studies only determined the weight of the CBM risk assessment indicators. These studies used the weights to identify the main risk factors of CBM development, but failed to quantitatively measure the overall risk levels of CBM development projects and calculate the membership degree of each bottom index.
(3)
In terms of the construction of the indicator system, the above studies lack a systematic and comprehensive indicator selection process and did not cover the life cycle of CBM development, including geological exploration, drilling, gathering, and market applications. Therefore, the research results have a certain one-sidedness.
To fill the above gaps and achieve a reasonable assessment of the risk status of coalbed methane development projects, this paper will construct a risk assessment model for coalbed methane development. First, this paper seeks to construct a complete risk assessment index system for CBM development, including the laws, regulations and policies, resource characteristics, engineering technology and organizational management, according to the risk characteristics involved in the life cycle of CBM development.
Second, to scientifically determine the weight of each index, the weight calculation method should be chosen reasonably. The AHP, Delphi method and expert experience are commonly used methods to determine the index weights in risk assessment, and the AHP is the most widely used method [20]. However, the disadvantage of AHP is that if the index system contains a large number of indexes, it will greatly increase the workload of experts, which affects the acquisition of the judgment matrix, and thus, affects the accuracy of the weight calculation. Compared with the AHP, the structure entropy weight method (SEWM) can reduce a large amount of the computational workload and obtain more accurate results in the case of a large number of indexes. The SEWM combined the methods of subjective and objective assignments, as well as qualitative and quantitative analysis [21]. The main steps of the SEWM include: (1) Collecting experts’ comments and forming the typical order; (2) analyzing the blind degree (uncertainty) of indexes; (3) normalized treatment of indexes; and (4) determining the index weight of each layer. Please refer to Section 2.2 for the specific calculation process.
Third, scientifically assess the risk of CBM development, and the assessment method should be rationally selected. The risk assessment method in this paper is based on the matter-element extension method (MEEM). Because MEEM is a method for multi-index comprehensive assessment and mainly based on the extrinsic matter-element model, extension set and correlation function theory [22], the method can judge the membership level of things according to different characteristics of the elements and less data and can avoid the randomness and subjectivity of the evaluation process to a certain extent. It is a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods. At present, this method has achieved good results in risk assessment in many fields, such as oil exploitation [23], tailings pond [24], and building fire [25]. The main steps of the MEEM include the following: (1) Determining the classical domains, joint domains, and matter elements; (2) calculating the correlation degrees; (3) assessing multi-level extension; and (4) classifying risk. Please refer to Section 2.3 for the specific calculation process. Finally, this paper will conduct a case study to verify the feasibility of the risk assessment model.
The main contents of this paper include the following parts: Section 1 introduces the research significance, research purposes, literature review and current deficiencies in the field of coalbed methane development risk research. Section 2 introduces the research steps of the article, constructs the risk assessment index system of coalbed methane development, introduces the calculation steps of the structural entropy weight method and uses this method to calculate the index weight, and then introduces the calculation process of the matter-element extension method. Section 3 conducts a case study to verify the validity of the evaluation model. Section 4 analyses and discusses the assessment results. Section 5 summarizes the conclusions of the article.

2. Methodology

This study follows four steps: (1) The key risk factors involved in the life cycle of CBM development were identified through literature analysis, field investigation, legal norm inquiry and expert consultations. Thus, the risk assessment index system of CBM development was determined; (2) The SEWM was used to determine the weight of each index; (3) Based on the MEEM, a theoretical model of risk assessment was constructed. The risk classification rules were determined; (4) A case study was implemented. The main research steps involved in this paper are shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Steps of the present study. CBM, coalbed methane.
The four steps are described as follows:
Step 1: Build a targeted risk assessment index system for CBM development. First, the status quo of risk assessment and the key influencing risk factors of CBM development were achieved through on-site investigation, reading relevant literature and visiting the insurance company and a third-party risk assessment institution. On this basis, a preliminary risk assessment index system was established. Some experts from consulting organizations, management departments, and research institutions engaged in CBM development were invited to evaluate the preliminary index system. According to the experts’ suggestions, this system mainly focused on the risks involved in geological resource exploration, drilling and drainage, gathering and transportation and market operations. Six main aspects, namely, laws and policies, resource characteristics, engineering technology, economic operation, organization and management, and safety and emergency protection, were covered. Finally, the first-level indexes were refined to the second-level indexes; thus, the risk assessment index system used in the CBM development was established.
Step 2: After the index system was determined, an index weight was assigned to all indexes in each layer. However, using the traditional analytic hierarchy process (AHP) method to assign the index weights would greatly increase the experts’ workload. Therefore, this paper introduced a new method, the SEWM, to assign the index weights. This method combines the methods of subjective and objective assignments via qualitative and quantitative analyses. The detailed principles and application method of the SEWM will be explained in Section 2.2.1.
Step 3: For quantitative risk assessment, this paper established a theoretical model of risk assessment based on the MEEM. The model covers four parts: (1) Determining classical domains, sections, and matter elements; (2) calculating correlation degrees; (3) assessing multi-level extension; and (4) classifying risk. The detailed calculation steps will be described in Section 2.3.
Step 4: Case study. A CBM development project in the southern part of the Qinshui Basin in China was chosen for the case study to verify the feasibility of the assessment system.

2.1. Construction of the CBM Development Risk Assessment Index System

2.1.1. Principle

To reflect the risks of CBM development accurately and objectively, the scientific basis, guidance, operability, systematic process, comparability and comprehensiveness were considered to establish the index system in this paper.

2.1.2. Construction of Index System

Life cycle theory has been widely used in many fields, such as economics [26], environmental research [27], and management research [28]. The basic meaning of the life cycle can be understood as the whole process from “cradle to grave”. For a product, the life cycle is the process of returning to nature from nature, which includes not only raw material collection and processing, but also the product storage, transportation and sales. According to the above definition, this paper divides the life cycle of CBM development into three main stages: Resource exploration, resource exploitation, and gathering and market operation. The risk characteristics of these three stages were analyzed, and the risk factors were summarized into the following six categories: (1) Risks of laws, regulations and policies; (2) risks of resource characteristics; (3) risks of engineering and technology; (4) risks of economic operations; (5) risks of organization and management; and (6) risks of safety and emergency protection.
Second, these six types of risks are used as first grade indexes, which are then refined to second grade indexes through an on-site investigation and a literature review [10,11,12,13,15,16,17,18,19,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37] and related laws and regulations. The laws and regulations include the “Mineral Resources Law of the People’s Republic of China” [38], “Coalbed Methane Industry Policy” [39], “Safety Production Law of the People’s Republic of China” [40], and “Hazardous Chemicals Safety Management Regulations” [41]. Third, the index system was revised through expert consultation. Finally, the assessment index system of CBM development risk was determined (Figure 2), and it consisted of six first grade indexes and 45 s grade indexes. For a detailed index analysis, please refer to Appendix A.
Figure 2. CBM development risk assessment index system.

2.2. Determination of Index Weights

To accurately calculate the weight of each index, a reasonable weight calculation method should be selected. The AHP, Delphi method and expert experience are commonly used methods to determine the index weights in risk assessment, and the AHP is the most widely used method [20]. Because many indexes are included in the proposed index system, the use of the AHP to determine the index weight would entail a large workload, which would not be conducive to acquiring the judgement matrix. Therefore, this paper introduced the SEWM to determine the index weight of the CBM development risk assessment system. The SEWM combines subjective and objective assignment methods, as well as qualitative and quantitative analyses. This method can reduce the calculation workload and achieve higher accuracy, especially for the many indexes in the CBM development risk assessment system.

2.2.1. Principle of the SEWM

The basic idea of the SEWM is to analyze the indexes of the assessment system and the interrelationship between them and then to classify the indexes into independent hierarchical grades. The execution steps are as follows.
(1) Collection of experts’ comments
Several experts were invited to complete the questionnaire form (Table 1) in accordance with the procedure and requirements of the Delphi method [42]. The experts ranked the importance of each index independently according to their own knowledge and experience. The indexes were ranked from high to low according to their importance; for example, mark ‘‘1” represented ‘‘most important”, mark ‘‘2” represented ‘‘more important”, mark ‘‘3” represented ‘‘important”, and so on. Some indexes could be recognized as equally important, and the final rank of the indexes could be discussed by the experts.
Table 1. Collection of experts’ comments.
(2) Blind degree (uncertainty) analysis
The potential deviation and uncertainty of the experts’ comments on the index ranks might arise, due to noisy data. To eliminate noisy data and reduce uncertainty, the qualitative judgement conclusion from the experts should be statistically analyzed and addressed. To reduce the uncertainty of the experts’ ranking, the entropy value was calculated by the entropy theory. The execution steps are shown below [21,43].
Supposing that k experts were invited to take the questionnaire survey, then k questionnaire forms would be returned, and every form would be recognized as an index set and marked as R={r1, r2,…rk}; where ri refers to the expert ranking array denoted by {ai1, ai2,…ain}(i=1, 2,…k) and ai1, ai2,…ain can be any natural number from {1, 2,…n}. As previously mentioned, ‘‘1” represents the highest level of importance. The index sort matrix obtained from the k table is shown as matrix A.
A = [ a 11 a 12 a 13 ⋯ a 1 n a 21 a 22 a 23 ⋯ a 2 n ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ ⋯ a k 1 a k 2 a k 3 ⋯ a kn ]
where aij represents the ith expert’s evaluation of the jth index.
The qualitative ranking result could be transformed into quantitative results by a membership function, which can be defined as follows:
χ ( I ) = − λ p n ( I ) lnp n ( I ) ,
where p n ( I ) = m − I m − 1 , λ = 1 ln ( m − 1 ) , which can be input into Equation (2):
χ ( I ) = − 1 ln ( m − 1 ) ( m − I m − 1 ) ln ( m − I m − 1 ) .
Dividing both sides by (m-I)/(m-1), assume that 1-χ(I)/(m-I)/(m-1)=μ(I). Then,
μ ( I ) = ln ( m − I ) ln ( m − 1 ) ,
where I is defined as the qualitative ranking number of a certain index evaluated by an expert. For example, a set of qualitative ranking numbers 5, 2, 3, 4, 1 for the five indexes r1, r2, r3, r4, r5 was evaluated by one expert. Thus, index r5 was the most important, because I = 1. M is the transformation parameter and defined as m = j + 2, and j is the number of indexes.
The qualitative ranking number I is input into Equation (4) to obtain the quantitative transformation value of bij. Bij = μ(aij) is the membership degree of the qualitative ranking number I, and the matrix B = (bij)k*n is defined as the membership degree matrix. A new parameter, average understanding degree bj, was introduced to present the consistency degree of the evaluation of index rj by k experts; its calculation is as follows:
b j = b 1 j + b 2 j + ⋯ + b kj k .
Blind understanding degree σj is defined as the uncertainty of the evaluation of index rj by k experts,
σ j = | { [ max ( b 1 j , b 2 j , ⋯ b kj ) − b j ] + [ b j − min ( b 1 j , b 2 j , ⋯ b kj ) ] } / 2 | .
The global understanding degree Xj is defined as the degree of the evaluation of every index rj by all k experts invited,
X j = b j ( 1 − σ j ) .
(3) Normalized treatment
To obtain the weight of index rj, Equation (7) needs further normalized treatment,
ω j = χ j / ∑ j = 1 k χ j .
Obviously, ωj > 0 and ∑ j = 1 k ω j =1. The ω=(ω1, ω2,…ωj) was expressed as the weight vector of the index set R=(r1, r2,…rj).

2.2.2. Calculation of the Index Weight

In this study, a total of 12 experts who have worked in the CBM development industry for a long time, including three experts in CBM resource exploration, three experts in CBM mining technology, two experts in coal economy, two experts in energy policy, and two managers of CBM development enterprises. To more comprehensively formulate risk assessment criteria from multiple perspectives, the experts were randomly divided into four groups, each with three persons. In this way, the diverse understandings of various research fields could be fully explored, and different knowledge and experience could be used to perform a qualitative evaluation of each assessment index.
The weight determination of the indexes in the first grade was taken as an example:
(1)
The rank results from the four groups of experts were collected in Table 2:
Table 2. Expert ranking results.
(2)
The obtained rank matrix A:
A = [ 4 1 2 3 6 5 3 1 1 2 5 4 3 1 2 3 5 4 4 2 1 3 6 5 ]
(3)
The calculated membership matrix B was based on Equation (4) and rank matrix A, and m was set as 8.
B = [ 0.712 1.000 0.921 0.827 0.356 0.565 0.827 1.000 1.000 0.921 0.565 0.712 0.827 1.000 0.921 0.827 0.565 0.712 0.712 0.921 1.000 0.827 0.356 0.565 ]
(4)
The average degree of understanding of a particular dimension from all experts:
b j = b 1 j + b 2 j + b 3 j + b 4 j 4 = ( 0.770 , 0.980 , 0.960 , 0.851 , 0.460 , 0.638 ) .
(5)
Based on the previous results and Equations (5) and (6), the blind understanding degree σj for the indexes from all experts could be obtained. Then, the evaluation vector X could be calculated according to the blind understanding degree σj and Equation (7). Finally, the weight of each index could be achieved by the normalized treatment method. The calculated result of each parameter is shown in Table 3. Similarly, the weight distribution of the second grade indexes can be obtained by refining. The index distribution is shown in Table 4. The detailed calculation processes are shown in Appendix B (Table A2, Table A3, Table A4, Table A5, Table A6 and Table A7.).
Table 3. Weight distribution of the first grade index.
Table 4. Index weights and actual scores.

2.3. Assessment Model Construction

The goal of the MEEM is to use the degree of association of the extension set to determine the assessment level of the matter element feature. The MEEM is a method for comprehensive multi-index assessments, and it is mainly based on the extrinsic matter-element model, extension set and correlation function theory [22]. This method can judge the subordinate level of items according to their different characteristics with low data requirements and can avoid the randomness and subjectivity of the evaluation process to a certain extent. The MEEM combines qualitative and quantitative analyses and has achieved good results in risk assessment in many fields, such as oil exploitation [23], tailings pond [24], and building fire [25]. Based on the above advantages, this method is applied to research CBM development risk assessments.
The MEEM includes the following steps [44,45]: (1) According to the development of things and relevant reference materials, the characteristics of things are analyzed, the things are divided into several grades according to certain rules, the numerical range of each level is clarified, and a multi-index MEEM is established; (2) Using the correlation function to calculate the degree of association between the things to be evaluated and each assessment level; (3) Things have the highest degree of relevance to one of the levels, indicating that they are most consistent with that level. Next, the calculation process of the CBM development risk assessment model will be described in detail.

2.3.1. Determination of the Classical Domain, Joint Domain and Matter-Element Evaluation

The matter element uses the ordered triplet M = {C, R, V} as the basic element to describe things, where C is the name of the thing, R is the name of the feature, and V is the value taken by C for R [25].
(1) Determining the classical domain Mj
Let Mj be the classic domain of matter-element M:
M j = ( U j , R , V j ) = ( U j r 1 ( a j 1 , b j 1 ) r 2 ( a j 2 , b j 2 ) ⋮ ⋮ r i ( a j i , b j i ) ) ,
where Uj is the j risk level in the risk level domain U, Vj is the range of assessment index set R about the risk level Uj, and aji and bji are the lower and upper limits of the index ri at the jth risk level, respectively.
(2) Determining the joint domain Mc
Let Mc be the joint domain of matter-element M:
M c = ( U , R , V c ) = ( U r 1 ( a c 1 , b c 1 ) r 2 ( a c 2 , b c 2 ) ⋮ ⋮ r i ( a c i , b c i ) ) ,
where Vc is the range of evaluation index set R about the risk level domain U, and aci and bci are the lower and upper limits of the index ri at all risk levels, respectively.
(3) Determining the matter-element evaluation Mi
Let Mi be the matter-element evaluation of matter-element M:
M i = ( S i , R i , V i ) = ( S j r i 1 v i 1 r i 2 v i 2 ⋮ ⋮ r i p v i p ) ,
where Si is the ith first grade index to be evaluated, Ri={ ri1, ri2, …, rip} is the second grade assessment index set for Si, rip is the pth second grade assessment index of the ith first grade index, and Vi is the value of the second grade index Ri for Si.

2.3.2. Calculating the Correlation Degree

By introducing the concept of distance in classical mathematics, the correlation function of the second grade index rik of the CBM development risk assessment on the risk level Uj is established. Therefore, the correlation degree Kj(rik) of the kth second grade index in the ith first grade index with respect to the risk level Uj is determined.
K j ( r i k ) = { ρ ( v i k , V j ) ρ ( v i k , V c ) − ρ ( v i k , V j ) ρ ( v i k , V c ) − ρ ( v i k , V j ) ≠ 0 − ρ ( v i k , V j ) − 1 ρ ( v i k , V c ) − ρ ( v i k , V j ) = 0 ,
where ρ ( v i k , V j ) = | v i k − a j i + b j i 2 | − 1 2 ( b i j − a j i ) , ρ ( v i k , V c ) = | v i k − a c i + b c i 2 | − 1 2 ( b c j − a c i ) , aci and bci are the lower and upper limits of the index ri at all risk levels, respectively, and vik is the expert score for the second grade index rik.

2.3.3. Multi-Level Extension Assessment

(1) Primary assessment
Calculate the correlation matrix K(ri) of the first indexes for each risk level:
K ( r i ) = ( ω i 1 , ω i 2 , ⋯ , ω i p ) [ k 1 ( r i 1 ) k 2 ( r i 1 ) ⋯ k m ( r i 1 ) k 1 ( r i 2 ) k 2 ( r i 2 ) ⋯ k m ( r i 2 ) ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ k 1 ( r i p ) k 2 ( r i p ) ⋯ k m ( r i p ) ] = ( k j ( r i ) ) ,
where ωi = (ωik) is the weight vector of the second grade indexes, and the calculation method is shown in Formulas (1)~(8); and K(rik) = (kj(rik)) is the correlation degree matrix of the second grade indexes for each risk level.
(2) Secondary assessment
Determine the correlation degree matrix K(S) of the CBM development safety for each risk level.
K ( S ) = ( ω 1 , ω 2 , ⋯ , ω j ) [ k 1 ( r 1 ) k 2 ( r 1 ) ⋯ k m ( r 1 ) k 1 ( r 2 ) k 2 ( r 2 ) ⋯ k m ( r 2 ) ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ k 1 ( r p ) k 2 ( r p ) ⋯ k m ( r p ) ] = ( k j ( S ) ) ,
where ω = (ωj) is the weight vector of the first grade indexes, and the calculation method is shown in formulas (1)~(8); a®K(r) = (k(ri)) is the correlation degree matrix of the first grade indexes for each risk level.
(3) Determining the risk level
According to the principle of maximum membership degree, the risk level corresponding to the maximum correlation degree in the correlation degree matrix K(S) of the CBM development for each risk level is the risk level of the assessment object. That is, when m a x k j ( S ) = k j ( S ) , with j = (1,2,3…n), the risk level of the assessment object is at level j.

2.3.4. Risk Classification

To scientifically measure the risk of CBM development and ensure the systematic nature and accuracy of the assessment results, this paper divides the risk level of CBM development into five grades according to the actual CBM development situation and the risk classification rules in the literature [25,46], as shown in Table 5. Notably, when the established risk assessment model has been tested by a large number of empirical tests, the risk classification criteria can be corrected by data feedback to make the criteria more sensitive.
Table 5. Risk levels.

3. Case Study

The southern part of the Qinshui Basin is one of the earliest areas for CBM exploration and development in China, and it has also attracted the most investment and research in CBM exploration and development in China [47]. The CBM storage conditions in this area are stable and have good development potential [48,49]. As a key breakthrough area for CBM exploration and development, many experts have carried out exploration and research work here, leading to the accumulation of a wealth of test and production data [50]. The experts have a deeper understanding of the characteristics of reservoir CBM accumulation, reservoir geological conditions and gas layer distribution. Therefore, this paper takes a CBM development project in this area as the research object and invited 5 experts, including 1 CBM exploration expert, 2 CBM mining technical experts, 1 energy policy expert and 1 project manager, to participate. Based on the engineering practice data of the project, the experts anonymously scored the actual operation status of each second grade index. The total score for each index is 100. In this paper, the actual scores of the second grade indexes of the CBM development project are obtained by calculating the average value, as shown in Table 4.

3.1. Determination of the Classical Domain, Joint Domain and Matter-Element Evaluation

Take the first grade index laws, regulations and policies (r1) as an example to establish the matter-element M and determine its classical domain Mj, joint domain Mc and matter-element evaluation Mi. Similarly, classical domains, joint domains and matter-element evaluations of other first grade indexes can be obtained.
(1) Determining the classical domain Mj
The classical domains for each risk level are determined by Formula (9):
M I = ( U I r 11 ( 85 , 100 ) r 12 ( 85 , 100 ) r 13 ( 85 , 100 ) r 14 ( 85 , 100 ) r 15 ( 85 , 100 ) r 16 ( 85 , 100 ) ) M II = ( U II r 11 ( 70 , 85 ) r 12 ( 70 , 85 ) r 13 ( 70 , 85 ) r 14 ( 70 , 85 ) r 15 ( 70 , 85 ) r 16 ( 70 , 85 ) ) ,
M III = ( U III r 11 ( 50 , 70 ) r 12 ( 50 , 70 ) r 13 ( 50 , 70 ) r 14 ( 50 , 70 ) r 15 ( 50 , 70 ) r 16 ( 50 , 70 ) ) M IV = ( U IV r 11 ( 25 , 50 ) r 12 ( 25 , 50 ) r 13 ( 25 , 50 ) r 14 ( 25 , 50 ) r 15 ( 25 , 50 ) r 16 ( 25 , 50 ) ) ,
M V = ( U V r 11 ( 0 , 25 ) r 12 ( 0 , 25 ) r 13 ( 0 , 25 ) r 14 ( 0 , 25 ) r 15 ( 0 , 25 ) r 16 ( 0 , 25 ) ) ,
(2) Determining the joint domain Mc
The joint domain Mc is determined by Formula (10):
M c = ( U r 11 ( 0 , 100 ) r 12 ( 0 , 100 ) r 13 ( 0 , 100 ) r 14 ( 0 , 100 ) r 15 ( 0 , 100 ) r 16 ( 0 , 100 ) ) .
 (3) Determining the matter-element evaluation Mi
The matter-element evaluation M1 of indexes r1i is determined by Formula (11):
M 1 = ( S 1 r 11 v 11 r 12 v 12 ⋮ ⋮ r 1 p v 1 p ) = ( R 1 r 11 91 r 12 88 r 13 48 r 14 83 r 15 86 r 16 84 ) .

3.2. Calculating the Correlation Degree

Taking the correlation degree of the second grade index r11 of the first grade index r1 as an example, the calculation steps of the correlation degrees of the second grade indexes are obtained by Formula (12).
ρ(v11,V1)=|91 − (85 + 100)/2| − (100 − 85)/2 = − 6; ρ(v11,V2) = |91 − (70 + 85)/2| − (85 − 70)/2 = 6;
ρ(v11,V3) = |91 − (50 + 70)/2| − (70 − 50)/2 = 21; ρ(v11,V4)=|91 − (25 + 50)/2| − (50 − 25)/2 = 41;
ρ(v11,V5) = |91 − (25 + 0)/2| − (25 − 0)/2 = 66; ρ(v11,Vc) = |91 − (0 + 100)/2| − (100 − 0)/2 = − 9;
k1(r11) = ρ(v11,V1)/[ ρ(v11,Vc)− ρ(v11,V1)] = −6/(−9 + 6) = 2;
k2(r11) = ρ(v11,V2)/[ ρ(v11,Vc) − ρ(v11,V2)] = 6/(−9−6) = −0.4;
k3(r11) = ρ(v11,V3)/[ ρ(v11,Vc) − ρ(v11,V3)] = 21/(−9−21) = −0.7;
k4(r11) = ρ(v11,V4)/[ ρ(v11,Vc) − ρ(v11,V4)] = 41/(−9−41) = −0.82;
k4(r11) = ρ(v11,V5)/[ ρ(v11,Vc) − ρ(v11,V5)] = 66/(−9−66) = −0.88;
Similarly, the correlation degrees of the second grade indexes under other first grade indexes can be calculated. The calculation results are shown in Table 6. The calculation process is shown in Appendix C.
Table 6. The relevance of second grade indexes.

3.3. Multi-Level Extension Assessment

(1) Primary assessment
Taking the first grade index r1 as an example, the correlation degree matrix K(r1) is determined according to the weight calculation result in Table 4 and Formula (13).
K ( r 1 ) = ( ω 11 , ω 12 , ω 13 , ω 14 , ω 15 , ω 16 ) ( k j ( r 1 ) ) = ( 0.226 , 0.235 , 0.113 , 0.188 , 0.118 , 0.120 ) [ 0.200 − 0.400 − 0.700 − 0.820 − 0.880 0.333 − 0.200 0.600 − 0.760 − 0.840 − 0.435 − 0.314 − 0.040 − 0.043 − 0.324 − 0.105 0.133 − 0.433 − 0.660 − 0.773 0.077 − 0.067 − 0.533 − 0.720 − 0.813 − 0.059 0.067 − 0.467 − 0.680 − 0.787 ] = ( 0.463 , − 0.148 , − 0.504 , − 0.650 , − 0.769 )
In the same way, the correlation degree matrixes of other first grade indexes are calculated. The detailed calculation processes are shown in Appendix B.
K(r2)=(−0.006, 0.105, −0.411, −0.647, −0.765); K(r3)=(−0.075, 0.205, −0.276, −0.566, −0.711); K(r4)=(−0.204, 0.200, −0.260, −0.540, −0.694); K(r5)=(−0.188, 0.163, −0.286, −0.572, −0.714); K(r6)=(−0.295, 0.114, −0.103, −0.414, −0.610).
(2) Secondary assessment
According to formula (14), the comprehensive correlation degree matrix of the research object for each risk level is determined.
K ( S ) = ( ω 1 , ω 2 , ω 3 , ω 4 , ω 5 , ω 6 ) K i ( r i ) = ( 0.165 , 0.214 , 0.209 , 0.184 , 0.094 , 0.134 ) [ 0.463 − 0.148 − 0.504 − 0.650 − 0.769 − 0.006 0.105 − 0.411 − 0.647 − 0.765 − 0.075 0.205 − 0.276 − 0.566 − 0.711 − 0.204 0.200 − 0.260 − 0.540 − 0.694 − 0.188 0.163 − 0.286 − 0.572 − 0.714 − 0.295 0.114 − 0.103 − 0.414 − 0.610 ] = ( − 0.035 , 0.108 , − 0.317 , − 0.573 , − 0.716 )
(3) Determining the risk level
According to the principle of maximum membership degree, the risk level corresponding to the maximum correlation degree in correlation degree matrix K(S) of CBM development for each risk level is the risk level of the assessment object. Because m a x k j ( S ) =0.108=K2(S), the risk level of the CBM development project is Grade II.

4. Results and Discussion

(1).
The correlation degree of comprehensive risk of the research object is 0.108, and the overall risk level of the CBM development project is judged to be Grade II according to the principle of maximum membership degree. This finding shows that the overall risk of the project is small and within an acceptable range, but the local risk of the project needs to be rectified in a timely manner.
(2).
According to the calculation results of the correlation degree of the second grade indexes in Table 6, it is possible to determine the links with higher risks in the second grade indexes. The following is an analysis of the indexes with risk levels greater than Grade II.
(1)
According to the investigation, the operators of the project did not obtain the right to cooperate with foreign countries, which indicates that the project cannot be assisted by foreign companies in terms of technology and management. Therefore, the project is at a higher risk in foreign cooperation franchises.
(2)
The transportation technology of this project is relatively backwards, and mainly relies on tank trucks for CBM transportation, and there is no long-distance pipeline network for the system. Therefore, the transportation technology risk of this project is high. It is recommended that the project operator regularly check the reliability of the tank truck equipment and conduct safety training for the tank truck driver.
(3)
Because the project operators are affiliated with private enterprises, and the enterprises have been established only for a short period, a well-known corporate image or reputation in the CBM industry have not been established. For these reasons, the project’s external market resource risk is high.
(4)
The project is not doing well in safety training and education. According to the survey, not all employees have participated in safety training, which will cause high risks to the daily operation of the project. CBM leakage and explosion accidents caused by human error are not uncommon; therefore, project operators should pay more attention to this aspect.
(5)
The number of daily emergency drills of the project is not up to standard. During the investigation of the emergency drill record, it was found that the project conducted only one accident emergency drill every year, which did not meet the standards of China’ China’s Safe Production Law stipulates that emergency drills be performed at least once every six months for firms involved in the production, filling, storage, supply and sales of flammable and explosive chemicals and the emergency plan is to be continuously improved in light of the actual situation. Therefore, to reduce the project risk, the project operators should add at least one more accident emergency drill every year.
(6)
The project’s emergency supplies were not adequately prepared and did not include gas masks and explosion-proof emergency lights. The main component of CBM is methane, which is a flammable, explosive, toxic and corrosive gas. If a CBM leak accident occurs during the production process, rescue personnel are required to have a gas mask; otherwise, death, due to suffocation, is likely. Moreover, project operators should be equipped with a sufficient number of explosion-proof emergency lights. Other lighting equipment may cause methane explosion accidents, due to static electricity during use.
(7)
The risks of other second grade indexes are very small, and their risk levels reached the first or second level. First, the risks of laws, regulations and policies faced by the project are minimal. The current new energy policies and financial subsidy policies are conducive to the development of the CBM industry. Second, there is no conflict between mining rights and air rights in the block where the project is located. In addition, the major licensing and approval procedures for the project are also complete. Third, the coal reservoirs in the block where the project is located have good porosity, high permeability, high gas content and gas saturation, which are conducive to the development of CBM. Finally, the economic operational risks of the project are also small. The project’s return on investment and CBM production are at a high level.
(8)
In summary, the overall risk of the project is small and within an acceptable range, indicating that the project has development value. The assessment results are in good agreement with the actual operation of the project, indicating that the established risk assessment model is feasible and effective.

5. Conclusions

With the development of the CBM industry in various countries around the world, a mature and complete risk assessment system is needed to accurately determine the overall risk level and local risk weakness of CBM development projects. This paper provides a reference for government policy formulation, investor project feasibility analyses, insurance company insurance premium rate determination, and project operator risk perception improvement ability. This study fills the gap in the literature concerning the above requirements. The main contributions of this paper are as follows:
(1)
Taking a CBM development project as the research object and considering the risk characteristics of exploration, mining, gathering and market application involved in the project life cycle, a CBM development risk assessment index system consisting of six first grade indexes and 45 second grade indexes is constructed.
(2)
Based on the SEWM, the weights of the risk assessment indexes are calculated. Then, the MEEM is used to construct the theoretical model of CBM development risk assessment.
(3)
A case study of a CBM development project in the southern Qinshui Basin of China was carried out using the established CBM development risk assessment model. The results show that the overall risk level of the CBM development project is Grade II, indicating that the overall risk of the project is small and within an acceptable range, although the local risk of the project needs to be rectified in a timely fashion. The assessment results are in good agreement with the actual operation of the project, indicating that the established risk assessment model has good applicability and effectiveness.
(4)
The study makes three contributions. First, the research results can help relevant government departments formulate policies to reduce the risks faced by the CBM industry. Second, this work can provide a reference for investors to evaluate the feasibility of CBM development projects and for insurance companies to determine the insurance rate of CBM development projects. Finally, the research results are also conducive to improving the risk awareness and risk perception of CBM project operators. Therefore, the accuracy of managers’ risk aversion decisions can be improved, and the waste of resources and property loss caused by the failure of risk management and control in the daily production process of the project can be reduced.

Author Contributions

Data curation, W.W.; Formal analysis, W.W., S.L. and Y.Z.; Methodology, W.W. and Y.Z.; Supervision, S.L.; Writing—original draft, W.W.; Writing—review and editing, Y.Z. and S.M.

Funding

This research was funded by [National Natural Science Foundation of China], grant number [51474151], and [PICC disaster research fund], grant number [D14-01].

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Abbreviations

CBMCoalbed methane
SEWMStructure entropy weight method
MEEMMatter-element extension method

Appendix A

Table A1. Index analysis.

Appendix B

Table A2. Weight distribution of the second grade indexes of r 1.
The calculated membership matrix B1 is based on Formula (4), and m is set as 8.
B 1 = [ 1.000 0.921 0.356 0.827 0.565 0.712 0.921 1.000 0.565 0.712 0.827 0.356 0.921 1.000 0.565 0.827 0.712 0.712 0.921 1.000 0.712 0.827 0.356 0.565 ]
Table A3. Weight distribution of the second grade indexes of r 2.
The calculated membership matrix B2 is based on Formula (4), and m is set as 10.
B 2 = [ 0.946 1.000 0.886 0.815 0.732 0.500 0.500 0.631 0.886 1.000 0.946 0.732 0.815 0.500 0.315 0.631 0.886 0.946 1.000 0.631 0.815 0.315 0.500 0.732 1.000 0.946 0.886 0.815 0.631 0.500 0.315 0.732 ]
Table A4. Weight distribution of the second grade indexes of r 3.
The calculated membership matrix B3 is based on the Formula (4), and m is set as 10.
B 3 = [ 1.000 0.946 0.815 0.732 0.886 0.500 0.631 0.815 1.000 0.886 0.946 0.631 0.815 0.315 0.500 0.732 0.946 1.000 0.886 0.815 0.500 0.631 0.732 0.886 1.000 0.946 0.732 0.815 0.886 0.500 0.631 0.886 ]
Table A5. Weight distribution of the second grade indexes of r 4.
The calculated membership matrix B4 is based on Formula (4), and m is set as 11.
B 4 = [ 0.477 0.954 0.845 0.903 0.602 0.778 0.699 0.301 1.000 0.699 1.000 0.954 0.903 0.477 0.602 0.845 0.778 1.000 0.778 1.000 0.903 0.954 0.845 0.699 0.602 0.477 0.954 0.602 0.903 0.845 0.954 0.699 0.778 0.477 0.301 1.000 ]
Table A6. Weight distribution of the second grade indexes of r 5.
The calculated membership matrix B5 is based on Formula (4), and m is set as 7.
B 5 = [ 1.000 0.774 0.613 0.387 0.898 1.000 0.898 0.774 0.613 0.898 0.898 0.613 1.000 0.387 0.774 1.000 0.613 0.898 0.387 0.774 ]
Table A7. Weight distribution of the second grade indexes of r 5.
The calculated membership matrix B6 is based on Formula (4), and m is set as 11.
B 6 = [ 1.000 0.954 0.845 0.477 0.903 0.778 0.699 0.602 0.602 0.954 0.953 0.845 0.477 1.000 0.778 0.778 0.602 0.699 1.000 0.845 0.954 0.301 0.903 0.602 0.477 0.699 0.778 1.000 0.903 0.945 0.477 1.000 0.602 0.699 0.778 0.845 ]

Appendix C

(1) The correlation degree matrix of the first grade index r2 is calculated as follows:
K ( r 2 ) = ( ω 21 , ω 22 , ω 23 , ω 24 , ω 25 , ω 26 , ω 27 , ω 28 ) ( k j ( r 2 ) ) = ( 0.160 , 0.173 , 0.160 , 0.124 , 0.124 , 0.075 , 0.067 , 0.118 ) [ − 0.222 0.400 − 0.300 − 0.580 − 0.720 − 0.143 0.200 − 0.400 − 0.640 − 0.760 0.571 − 0.267 − 0.633 − 0.780 − 0.853 − 0.273 − 0.333 − 0.200 − 0.520 − 0.680 0.077 − 0.067 − 0.533 − 0.720 − 0.813 − 0.297 0.182 − 0.133 − 0.480 − 0.653 − 0.174 0.267 − 0.367 − 0.620 − 0.747 0.182 − 0.133 − 0.567 − 0.740 − 0.826 ] = ( − 0.006 , 0.105 , − 0.411 , − 0.647 , − 0.765 )
(2) The correlation degree matrix of the first grade index r3 is calculated as follows:
K ( r 3 ) = ( ω 31 , ω 32 , ω 33 , ω 34 , ω 35 , ω 36 , ω 37 , ω 38 ) ( k j ( r 3 ) ) = ( 0.170 , 0.158 , 0.134 , 0.121 , 0.111 , 0.073 , 0.098 , 0.136 ) [ − 0.770 − 0.067 − 0.533 − 0.720 − 0.813 − 0.297 0.182 − 0.133 − 0.480 − 0.653 − 0.258 0.438 − 0.233 − 0.540 − 0.693 − 0.143 0.200 − 0.400 − 0.640 − 0.760 − 0.174 0.267 − 0.367 − 0.620 − 0.747 − 0.347 − 0.059 0.067 − 0.360 − 0.573 − 0.241 0.467 − 0.267 − 0.560 − 0.707 − 0.286 0.250 − 0.167 − 0.500 − 0.667 ] = ( − 0.075 , 0.205 , − 0.276 , − 0.566 , − 0.711 ) ;
(3) Correlation degree matrix of the first grade index r4 is calculated as follows:
K ( r 4 ) = ( ω 41 , ω 42 , ω 43 , ω 44 , ω 45 , ω 46 , ω 47 , ω 48 , ω 49 ) ( k j ( r 4 ) ) = ( 0.087 , 0.147 , 0.134 , 0.145 , 0.086 , 0.104 , 0.086 , 0.057 , 0.155 ) [ − 0.105 0.133 − 0.433 − 0.660 − 0.773 − 0.241 0.467 − 0.267 − 0.560 − 0.707 − 0.273 0.333 − 0.200 − 0.520 − 0.680 − 0.317 0.077 − 0.067 − 0.440 − 0.627 − 0.059 0.067 − 0.467 − 0.820 − 0.747 0.077 − 0.067 − 0.533 − 0.720 − 0.813 − 0.397 − 0.214 0.158 − 0.120 − 0.413 − 0.143 0.200 − 0.400 − 0.640 − 0.760 − 0.241 0.467 − 0.267 − 0.460 − 0.707 ] = ( − 0.204 , 0.200 , − 0.260 , − 0.540 , − 0.694 ) ;
(4) Correlation degree matrix of the first grade index r5 is calculated as follows:
K ( r 5 ) = ( ω 51 , ω 52 , ω 53 , ω 54 , ω 55 ) ( k j ( r 5 ) ) = ( 0.270 , 0.181 , 0.250 , 0.115 , 0.229 ) [ 0.000 0.000 − 0.500 − 0.700 − 0.800 − 0.222 0.400 − 0.300 − 0.580 − 0.720 − 0.308 0.125 − 0.100 − 0.460 − 0.640 − 0.142 0.200 − 0.400 − 0.640 − 0.760 − 0.297 0.182 − 0.133 − 0.480 − 0.653 ] = ( − 0.188 , 0.163 , − 0.286 , − 0.572 , − 0.714 ) ;
(5) Correlation degree matrix of the first grade index r6 is calculated as follows:
K ( r 6 ) = ( ω 61 , ω 62 , ω 63 , ω 64 , ω 65 , ω 66 , ω 67 , ω 68 , ω 69 ) ( k j ( r 6 ) ) = ( 0.151 , 0.133 , 0.133 , 0.062 , 0.141 , 0.098 , 0.088 , 0.095 , 0.100 ) [ − 0.286 0.250 − 0.167 − 0.500 − 0.667 − 0.241 0.467 − 0.267 − 0.560 − 0.707 − 0.397 − 0.241 0.158 − 0.120 − 0.413 − 0.317 0.077 − 0.067 − 0.440 − 0.627 − 0.143 − 0.200 0.400 − 0.640 − 0.760 − 0.297 0.182 − 0.133 − 0.480 − 0.653 − 0.403 − 0.258 0.095 − 0.080 − 0.387 − 0.373 − 0.159 0.233 − 0.260 − 0.507 − 0.273 0.333 − 0.200 − 0.520 − 0.680 ] = ( − 0.295 , 0.114 , − 0.103 , − 0.414 , − 0.610 )

References

  1. Zhou, C.; Huang, G.; Chen, J. A multi-objective energy and environmental systems planning model: management of uncertainties and risks for Shanxi province, China. Energies 2018, 11, 2723. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  2. Cheng, L.; Ge, Z.; Chen, J.; Ding, H.; Zou, L.; Li, K. A Sequential approach for integrated coal and gas mining of closely-spaced outburst coal seams: Results from a case study including mine safety improvements and greenhouse gas reductions. Energies 2018, 11, 3023. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  3. Wang, J.F.; Li, W.J. China’s Coal Mine Accidents and Comments of Safety Specialists; China Coal Industry Publishing House: Beijing, China, 2002; pp. 1–8. [Google Scholar]
  4. Zhang, J.J.; Xu, K.L.; You, G.; Wang, B.B.; Zhao, L. Causation analysis of risk coupling of gas explosion accident in Chinese underground coal mines. Risk Anal. 2019, 4, 1–13. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  5. Zhang, J.J.; David, C.; Xu, K.L.; You, G. Focusing on the patterns and characteristics of extraordinarily severe gas explosion accidents in Chinese coal mines. Process Saf. Environ. Prot. 2018, 117, 390–398. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Knez, D.; Wiśniowski, R.; Owusu, W.A. Turning filling material into proppant for coalbed methane in Poland—Crush test results. Energies 2019, 12, 1820. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  7. Li, G.F.; Li, G.H.; Liu, G. Analysis on the ground extraction effect of coal-bed methane at typical area in Jincheng, China. J. China Coal Soc. 2014, 39, 1932–1937. [Google Scholar]
  8. Karacan, C.O.; Ruiz, F.A.; Cote, M.; Phipps, S. Coal mine methane: A review of capture and utilization practices with benefits to mining safety and to greenhouse gas reduction. Int. J. Coal Geol. 2011, 86, 121–156. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  9. Liao, Y.Y.; Luo, D.K.; Li, W.D. Development strategy analysis of China’s CBM. Acta Pet. Sin. 2012, 33, 1098–1102. [Google Scholar]
  10. Roadifer, R.D. Coalbed methane parametric study: What’s really important to production and when? In Proceedings of the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Denver, CO, USA, 5–8 October 2003. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  11. Senthil, B. Economic Feasibility of Coalbed Methane Projects Using Monte-Carlo and Hypercube Simulation. Ph.D. Thesis, Mississippi State University, Starkville, MS, USA, 1994. [Google Scholar]
  12. Chen, Y.H.; Yang, Y.G.; Luo, J.H. Uncertainty Analysis of Coalbed Methane Economic Assessment with Montecarlo Method. Procedia Environ. Sci. 2012, 12, 640–645. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Zhang, Y.C.; Yang, Y.G.; Luo, J.H. Study on risk assessment of CBM development based on optimized combination weighting. J. Saf. Sci. Technol. 2016, 12, 91–97. [Google Scholar]
  14. Acquah-Andoh, E.; Putra, H.A.; Ifelebuegu, A.O.; Owusu, A. Coalbed methane development in Indonesia: Design and economic analysis of upstream petroleum fiscal policy. Energy Policy 2019, 131, 155–167. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  15. Luo, D.K.; Dai, Y.J. Economic evaluation of coalbed methane production in China. Energy Policy 2009, 37, 3883–3889. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  16. Mares, T.E.; Moore, T.A.; Moore, C.R. Uncertainty of gas saturation estimates in a subbituminous coal seam. Int. J. Coal Geol. 2009, 77, 320–327. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Mu, F.Y.; Wang, H.Y.; Wu, J.T.; Sun, B. Practice of and suggestions on CBM development in China. Nat. Gas Ind. 2018, 38, 61–66. [Google Scholar]
  18. Kirchgessne, D.A.; Masemore, S.S.; Piccot, S.D. Engineering and economic evaluation of gas recovery and utilization technologies at selected US mines. Environ. Sci. Policy 2002, 5, 397–409. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Su, J.; Zhang, J.; Zhu, W. Improved methodology of economic evaluation of coalbed methane based on discounted cash flow analysis. J. China Univ. Min. Technol. 2018, 47, 176–183. [Google Scholar]
  20. Lau, C.K.; Lai, K.K.; Lee, Y.P.; Du, J.Z. Fire risk assessment with scoring system, using the support vector machine approach. Fire Saf. J. 2015, 78, 188–195. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Cheng, Q.Y. Structure entropy weight method to confirm the weight of evaluating index. Syst. Eng. Theory Pract. 2010, 30, 1225–1228. [Google Scholar]
  22. Cai, W. Introduction of Extenics. Syst. Eng. Theory Pract. 1998, 1, 76–84. [Google Scholar]
  23. Jin, Y.Q.; Hu, M.; Wu, Q.; Fang, C.X. Quantitative risk assessment model for high pressure oil and gas well control based on the matter-element extension. J. Saf. Environ. 2014, 14, 147–150. [Google Scholar]
  24. Wang, J.M.; Jia, M.T.; Wang, J.; Chen, J.H.; Long, K.M. Risk evaluation of break-dam in tailings reservoir based on matter-element extension model. J. Saf. Sci. Technol. 2014, 4, 96–102. [Google Scholar]
  25. Xie, Z.X.; Li, Y.Y.; Wu, X.R.; Wang, F.; Wang, W. Evaluation of the archive fire risk based on the matter-element and multi-level extension model. J. Saf. Environ. 2019, 19, 27–34. [Google Scholar]
  26. Iribarren, D.; Martíngamboa, M.; O’Mahony, T.; Dufour, J. Screening of socio-economic indicators for sustainability assessment: A combined life cycle assessment and data envelopment analysis approach. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2016, 21, 202–214. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Elhami, B.; Raini, M.G.N.; Soheili-Fard, F. Energy and environmental indices through life cycle assessment of raisin production: A case study (Kohgiluyeh and Boyer-Ahmad Province, Iran). Renew. Energy 2019, 141, 507–515. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  28. Alvarez-Rodriguez, C.; Martin-Gamboa, M.; Iribarren, D. Sustainability-oriented management of retail stores through the combination of life cycle assessment and dynamic data envelopment analysis. Sci. Total Environ. 2019, 68, 49–60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Zhang, Y.S.; Niu, C.H. Research on risk factors and strategies of China’s CBM industry development under the background of energy revolution. Sci. Manag. Res. 2019, 37, 68–73. [Google Scholar]
  30. Ge, X.; Liu, D.; Cai, Y.; Wang, Y. Gas content evaluation of coalbed methane reservoir in the Fukang area of Southern Junggar Basin, northwest China by multiple geophysical logging methods. Energies 2018, 11, 1867. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  31. Lei, C.L.; Liu, X. Assessment of economic benefit for coalbed methane development project from geological hazard risk. Coal Geol. Explor. 2016, 44, 75–79. [Google Scholar]
  32. Zhai, G.M.; He, W.Y. Occurrence features and exploration orientation of coalbed methane gas in China. Nat. Gas Ind. 2010, 30, 1–3. [Google Scholar]
  33. Jie, M.X.; Ge, X.D.; Peng, C.Y.; Xiong, X.Y.; Xia, F. Advances in the CBM exploration and development techniques and their developing trend in China. Nat. Gas Ind. 2011, 31, 63–65. [Google Scholar]
  34. Lyu, Y.M.; Tang, D.Z.; Li, Z.P.; Shao, X.J.; Xu, H. Fitting and predicting models for coalbed methane wells dynamic productivity. J. China Coal Soc. 2011, 36, 1481–1485. [Google Scholar]
  35. Xia, L.Y.; Luo, D.K.; Dai, Y.J. Risk evaluation methods of CBM development projects. Nat. Gas Ind. 2012, 32, 117–120. [Google Scholar]
  36. Henriqson, E.; Schuler, B.; Van Winsen, R.; Dekker, S.W.A. The constitution and effects of safety culture as an object in the discourse of accident prevention: A Foucauldian approach. Saf. Sci. 2014, 70, 465–476. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  37. Zhao, B.F.; Zhang, C.; Jia, B.S.; Zhai, C.X.; Ren, H.Z.; Guo, J.W. DMIP-MCDM based method of evaluating safety input for coal enterprises. China Saf. Sci. J. 2017, 27, 127–131. [Google Scholar]
  38. People’s Republic of China Mineral Resources Law; PRC Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress: Beijing, China, 1986.
  39. Coalbed Methane Industry Policy; PRC National Energy Board: Beijing, China, 2013.
  40. Safety Production Law of the People’s Republic of China; PRC Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress: Beijing, China, 2002.
  41. Hazardous Chemicals Safety Management Regulations; PRC State Council: Beijing, China, 2002.
  42. Dalkey, N.C. The Delphi method: An experimental study of group opinion. Futures 1969, 1, 408–426. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  43. Liu, F.; Zhao, S.Z.; Weng, M.C.; Liu, Y.Q. Fire risk assessment for large-scale commercial buildings based on structure entropy weight method. Saf. Sci. 2017, 94, 26–40. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  44. Cai, W. Extension theory and its application. Chin. Sci. Bull. 1999, 7, 673–682. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  45. Cai, W.; Yang, C.Y. Basic theory and methodology on Extenics. Chin. Sci. Bull. 2013, 58, 1190–1199. [Google Scholar]
  46. Guan, X.J. Evaluation method on risk grade of tunnel collapse based on extension connection cloud model. J. Saf. Sci. Technol. 2018, 14, 186–192. [Google Scholar]
  47. Wang, Y.; Liu, D.; Cai, Y.; Li, X. Variation of petrophysical properties and adsorption capacity in different rank coals: An experimental study of coals from the Junggar, Ordos and Qinshui Basins in China. Energies 2019, 12, 986. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  48. Qin, Y.; Liang, J.S.; Shen, J.; Liu, Y.H.; Wang, C.W. Gas logging shows and gas reservoir types in tight sandstones and shales from Southern Qinshui Basin. J. China Coal Soc. 2014, 39, 1559–1565. [Google Scholar]
  49. Zhang, Z.; Qin, Y.; Fu, X.H. The favorable developing geological conditions for CBM multi-layer drainage in southern Qinshui basin. J. China Univ. Min. Technol. 2014, 43, 1019–1024. [Google Scholar]
  50. Li, Q.; He, J.J.; Cao, J. Physical characteristics of coalbed methane reservoir in Heshun Area of Qinshui Basin. Oil Geophys. Prospect. 2013, 48, 734–739. [Google Scholar]

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.