Cryptic Genetic Diversity in Deer: The Evolution of the White-Tailed Deer (Cervidae, Artiodactyla) in the Neotropics

The systematics of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) has been controversial. Some mammalogists consider the white-tailed deer to be a single species, whereas others consider it to consist of multiple species. To help resolve the controversy, we sequenced mitochondrial cytochrome B (mtCyt-b) in samples collected from 83 Neotropical white-tailed deer. Furthermore, we analyzed mitogenomes of samples collected from 19 white-tailed deer. There were five main results, as follows: (1) Phylogenetic analyses with the mtCyt-b dataset showed the existence of eight groups of O. virginianus, three in North and Central America and five in South America. It was hypothesized from different analyses that a Central American O. virginianus population generated the white-tailed deer populations in South America. (2) The haplotype temporal diversification within O. virginianus occurred during the Pleistocene. With the mitogenome dataset, it was dated to have occurred approximately 2.2 mya, using both Bayesian inference and haplotype networks. (3) All of these O. virginianus groups showed elevated levels of mitochondrial genetic diversity for the mtCyt-b dataset, with the exception of the Ecuadorian population (4) Some groups of O. virginianus yielded significant evidence of female population expansions with the mtCyt-b dataset. (5) Although the genetic heterogeneity among these O. virginianus groups was significant, the genetic distances were relatively small. Provisionally, the karyotypic differences between North American and Colombian specimens were very small; therefore, until further karyotypic studies demonstrate otherwise, we consider the existence of a single species of O. virginianus. Because mtDNA genomes have only one quarter of the effective number of autosomal nuclear genes, this generates relatively rapid coalescence times, which can inflate estimates of divergence among populations. Therefore, it is very important to soon sequence the nuclear genes for the different geographic assemblages of O. virginianus found.