3.1. GPC and Polarization Analysis
The gel permeation chromatography (GPC) analysis of the synthetic multilayer 3D chiral polymers reveals significant insights into their molecular weight characteristics and structural implications (
Table 1). For polymer
5A, which incorporates naphthalene units, the weight-average molecular weight (Mw) is 115,453 g/mol, with a number-average molecular weight (Mn) of 33,934 g/mol and a polydispersity index (PDI) of 3.402 (
Supplementary Materials, Figure S4). The relatively high PDI indicates a broad molecular weight distribution, which is typical for polymers synthesized via step-growth polymerization. The theoretical layer count of 89 suggests a well-defined multilayer structure, which is crucial for its chiral properties. In polymer
5B, featuring naphthalene-dihydroacenaphthylene units, the Mw is 116,561 g/mol and the Mn is 33,209 g/mol, yielding a PDI of 3.510 (
Figure S4). The introduction of dihydroacenaphthylene likely enhances the polymer’s rigidity and contributes to its chiral architecture, as the fused aromatic system can promote π–π stacking interactions, potentially influencing the multilayer formation. The theoretical layer count of 76 indicates a slight reduction in layering compared to polymer
5A, which may correlate with steric effects introduced by the dihydroacenaphthylene moiety. Polymer
5C, containing methoxy-substituted naphthalene, exhibits an Mw of 116,894 g/mol and an Mn of 33,272 g/mol, with a PDI of 3.512 (
Figure S3). The methoxy group can enhance solubility and influence the polymer’s electronic properties, potentially facilitating better packing and layer formation. The similar PDI values across the three polymers suggest consistent synthetic conditions, while variations in Mw and layer counts reflect the influence of specific substructures on the overall polymer architecture.
Polymer 5A, which consists solely of naphthalene units, exhibits the highest number-average molecular weight (Mn), the largest theoretical layer count, and the lowest polydispersity index (PDI) among the three polymers. The elevated Mn of 5A (33,934 g/mol) can be attributed to the simplicity and uniformity of its naphthalene-based structure, which likely facilitates a more efficient and consistent polymerization process. This uniformity minimizes chain termination and branching, resulting in longer, more homogeneous polymer chains. The theoretical layer count of 89 for polymer 5A indicates a well-defined multilayer architecture, which is a direct consequence of the regularity in its naphthalene structure. The absence of bulky substituents allows for optimal stacking and alignment of the polymer chains, enhancing the formation of distinct layers. Additionally, the lower PDI of 3.402 suggests a narrower molecular weight distribution, indicative of a more controlled polymerization process. In contrast, polymers 5B and 5C, which incorporate bulky dihydroacenaphthylene and methoxy groups, respectively, experience steric hindrance and potential chain irregularities, leading to increased molecular weight distributions and lower theoretical layer counts. These factors collectively elucidate the superior characteristics of polymer 5A in terms of molecular weight, layer formation, and uniformity.
The synthesized polymers are primarily composed of naphthalene, bromine (Br), methoxy, and boric esters, reflecting a carefully designed elemental composition that enhances their chiral properties. This fundamental composition plays a crucial role in the polymers’ structural integrity and contributes to their unique optical characteristics. Following the analysis of their elemental makeup, we observed significant optical rotation in these polymers, indicative of their chiral nature and potential applications. The ability to finely tune the elemental composition allows for the optimization of their optical activities, which is essential for advancing their use in optoelectronic devices and other chiral applications.
The optical rotation values of the synthesized multilayer 3D chiral polymers demonstrate a clear correlation between structural composition and chiroptical properties. Polymer 5A, which consists solely of naphthalene, exhibits the highest optical rotation of +24. The notable optical activity of these polymers is primarily due to the inherent chirality and efficient π–π stacking of naphthalene units, which support a defined chiral arrangement for strong optical rotation. Polymer 5B, incorporating naphthalene-dihydroacenaphthylene, exhibits a reduced optical rotation of +11, as the bulky side group introduces steric hindrance and disrupts chiral uniformity, resulting in weaker π–π interactions. Polymer 5C, with a methoxy group, shows the lowest optical rotation of +3. The methoxy group adds flexibility and steric bulk, further compromising the planar structure and reducing chiral interactions, highlighting the importance of structural integrity in chiroptical properties.
3.2. Characteristics of UV-Vis and Photoluminescence
The UV-Vis absorption spectra of multilayer 3D chiral polymers, particularly those with naphthalene derivatives, reveal valuable information about their electronic properties and aggregation behavior. Polymers 5A and 5B show strong absorbance from 270 to 370 nm, indicating π–π* transitions related to the naphthalene chromophore. Polymer 5A displays a distinct feature between 300 and 325 nm, suggesting aggregation. The tailing in both polymers indicates significant intermolecular interactions, while polymer 5C, with a methoxy group, shows an additional peak from 375 to 450 nm due to enhanced intramolecular charge transfer.
The ultraviolet (UV) spectral analysis of multilayer 3D chiral polymers shows distinct electronic transitions linked to their molecular structure. Polymer 5C, containing dimethoxynaphthalene, displays a clear π–π* transition, indicating strong electronic interactions, enhanced conjugation, and electron delocalization from methoxy substituents that stabilize excited states.
Polymers
5A and
5B, both of which are based on naphthalene and its derivatives, display relatively similar UV spectra, indicating analogous electronic environments (
Figure 4). The lack of significant differentiation between these two polymers implies that the structural modifications introduced in polymer
5B, through the incorporation of dihydroacenaphthylene, do not substantially alter the electronic transitions compared to the naphthalene framework of polymer
5A. This observation underscores the role of specific functional groups in modulating the optical properties of multilayer chiral polymers.
The excitation wavelengths of the multilayer 3D chiral polymers exhibit distinct variations that reflect their unique molecular compositions and structural characteristics. Polymer 5A, which is naphthalene-based, demonstrates an excitation wavelength of 330 nm, indicative of its relatively higher energy electronic transitions. In contrast, both polymer 5B, incorporating naphthalene and dihydroacenaphthylene, and polymer 5C, composed of naphthalene and dimethoxynaphthalene, exhibit excitation wavelengths of 426 nm. This shift to a longer wavelength suggests a lower energy transition, likely due to the influence of the additional substituent groups in polymers 5B and 5C, which can alter the electronic distribution and conjugation length. The similarity in the excitation wavelengths of polymers 5B and 5C highlights the role of structural modifications in tuning the electronic properties of multilayer chiral polymers.
In polymer
5A, the presence of two prominent peaks at approximately 440 nm and 540 nm is noteworthy, with the latter exhibiting significantly greater intensity, suggesting a specific electronic transition (
Figure 5A). The peak at 540 nm is indicative of a more efficient radiative transition, potentially involving an intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) state or an excited state stabilized by the polymer’s conformation. The pronounced intensity of this peak reflects a favorable environment for emission, attributed to reduced non-radiative decay pathways in the excited state. The peak at 440 nm is likely associated with Raman scattering rather than a direct electronic transition related to the naphthalene core. This distinction is crucial, as it raises questions about the interpretation of the nature of the other bands in the luminescence spectra of the investigated polymers.
For polymer
5B, which incorporates both naphthalene and acenaphthene, the photoluminescence (PL) spectrum reveals peaks at 461 nm and 492 nm, with the peak at 461 nm being more intense (
Figure 5A). The observed shift in peak position compared to polymer
5A is attributed to the introduction of acenaphthene, which modifies the electronic environment and introduces new pathways for exciton relaxation. The differences in peak intensities suggest that the acenaphthene moiety enhances non-radiative decay processes or competes with the radiative transition-associated naphthalene unit, resulting in a relative suppression of emission at longer wavelengths.
Polymer 5C, featuring a methoxy substituent, displays peaks at 441 nm and 464 nm, with the peak at 441 nm being slightly more intense. The methoxy group, as an electron-donating substituent, significantly influences the electronic properties of the polymer. The proximity of these two peaks indicates a closer energy level alignment, which facilitates rapid exciton migration between states. The relatively balanced intensities of the peaks suggest that the electronic transitions in this polymer are more evenly matched, potentially due to the stabilization of excited states through intramolecular interactions.
3.3. Analysis of Aggregation Phenomenon
Aggregation refers to the process where individual molecules come together to form larger assemblies. In the context of fluorescent materials, this phenomenon can lead to unique optical properties. Specifically, certain fluorescent molecules exhibit increased light emission when aggregated, a behavior that contrasts with conventional fluorescent compounds, which often experience quenching in similar conditions. Aggregated structures are gaining significance in various applications, including bioimaging, sensor technologies, and organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). Additionally, the aggregation of molecules can enhance molecular polarization, which in turn improves the non-linear optical properties of materials used in photonic devices.
The fluorescence properties of synthetic multilayer 3D chiral polymers, especially those containing naphthalene-based polymer
5A, display interesting behaviors under different water fractions. Notably, a strong aggregation effect is observed at water fractions between 60% and 90%, as indicated by a significant enhancement of the emission peak at 440 nm (
Figure 6A).
In contrast, the fluorescence peak of polymer
5A observed at approximately 550 nm demonstrates an aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) phenomenon (
Figure 6A). This quenching behavior, however, does not follow a straightforward stepwise progression. Instead, it appears to mirror the behavior of the first peak in the water fraction range of 0% to 50%. This observation suggests that the polymer’s fluorescence characteristics are highly sensitive to the aggregation state of the chromophores, which is influenced by the solvent environment.
The Stern–Volmer plot serves as a valuable tool for elucidating the relationship between the degree of aggregation and fluorescence quenching (
Figure 6B). The plot effectively reflects the total tendency of aggregation and quenching phenomena, providing insights into the dynamic interactions between the polymer chains and the solvent molecules. As the water fraction increases, the polymer chains likely undergo conformational changes that promote aggregation, leading to a decrease in the effective fluorescence quantum yield. The non-linear behavior observed in the Stern–Volmer plot indicates complex interactions that may involve both static and dynamic quenching mechanisms.
The chromatic shifts observed during the fluorescence measurements further highlight the sensitivity of the polymer’s optical properties to changes in the solvent composition. The coordinates of the emission spectra at varying water fractions—(0.34773, 0.53838), (0.30809, 0.43142), (0.268, 0.27539), (0.25193, 0.23285), and (0.19791, 0.06768) corresponding to water fractions of 0%, 10%, 40%, 70%, and 90%, respectively—demonstrate a clear trend of color transfer. This chromatic transition may be attributed to the alterations in the electronic environment surrounding the chromophores as they aggregate in response to increasing water content.
The initial water fraction (0%) corresponds to a relatively hydrophobic environment, which likely facilitates the solubilization of the naphthalene units, thereby enhancing their emission properties. As water is gradually introduced, the increasing polarity of the solvent could disrupt the π–π stacking interactions between the naphthalene moieties. This disruption is associated with a noticeable red shift in the emission spectra, which reflects the alterations in the electronic environment of the chromophores.
The analysis of the chromaticity coordinates reveals a systematic decrease in both the x and y values, suggesting a transition from vibrant emission to more subdued fluorescence as aggregation occurs and quenching mechanisms become prominent. Particularly at higher water fractions (70% and 90%), the significant drop in chromaticity coordinates indicates that the polymer predominantly adopts an aggregated state. In this context, the effective conjugation length of the chromophores is reduced due to enhanced intermolecular interactions, leading to a substantial decrease in fluorescence intensity and a notable shift in the emission profile.
It is critical to emphasize that the initial observations of sharp peaks could be influenced by Raman scattering. As such, the evaluation of the AIE effect should focus on distinct luminescence bands. Our subsequent analysis of the luminescence in the blue-green region of the spectrum corroborates the notion that a true AIE effect is not manifested, as the intensity decreases sharply with increasing water content.
The interplay between aggregation-induced emission (AIE) and aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) in the naphthalene-containing polymer 5A underscores the importance of molecular design in tuning the optical properties of chiral polymers. The observed fluorescence behavior is not merely a result of aggregation; it also reflects the intricate molecular interactions and conformational changes that occur in response to solvent polarity.
In our subsequent study, we further explore the impact of aggregation on the optical properties of naphthalene-containing multilayered 3D chiral polymers. Our results reveal that different polymer structures exhibit varying degrees of aggregation-related emission behaviors. Specifically, polymer
5B, which contains naphthalene-dihydroacenaphthylene units, demonstrates a significant response in luminescence as the water fraction varied from 0% to 70%. Notably, there is a marked increase in luminescence upon aggregation; however, we also observe a decrease in fluorescence intensity at a water fraction of 40% (
Figure 7). This nuanced observation suggests that the interactions within the polymer structure can be influenced by the solvent environment, leading to complex changes in the emission characteristics as aggregation occurs.
The pronounced aggregation response of polymer 5B, characterized by enhanced luminescence as the water fraction increases, indicates that its multilayered architecture supports effective π–π stacking and spatial confinement. This facilitates significant luminescence enhancement upon aggregation, signaling a favorable interaction among the naphthalene units. However, the decrease in fluorescence intensity observed at a water fraction of 40% suggests a critical threshold: as hydrophilicity increases, it disrupts optimal molecular packing, resulting in diminished emission efficiency.
In contrast, polymer 5C, which features naphthalene-methoxy units, exhibits a subtler aggregation effect. The presence of the methoxy substituent introduces steric hindrance that limits effective π–π interactions and, consequently, the degree of luminescence enhancement when aggregates form. The methoxy group influences the polymer’s conformational adaptability and packing efficiency, leading to a less pronounced aggregation effect compared to polymer 5B.
While it is important to delineate between the mechanisms of luminescence and Raman scattering, our analyses explicitly focus on the luminescence properties observed in the blue-green region of the spectrum. The sharp decrease in intensity with increasing water content for both polymers underscores the complexities within the aggregation phenomena and suggests that an AIE effect could not be present in this system. While polymer 5B shows initial enhancement in luminosity upon aggregation, the observed reduction at 40% water fraction warrants careful consideration regarding the specific conditions under which AIE could be expected.
Our findings highlight the intricate interplay between molecular design, steric effects, and solvent environment in determining the aggregation behavior and optical properties of multilayered 3D chiral polymers. These insights provide a fundamental basis for advancing the development of materials with tailored emission characteristics for applications in optoelectronics and sensing.
Aggregation-induced polarization is a distinctive optical phenomenon observed in certain luminescent materials, characterized by enhanced emission intensity upon aggregation. Unlike conventional fluorescence, which often diminishes with increasing concentration due to self-quenching, AIP materials exhibit a marked increase in luminescence, attributed to the suppression of non-radiative decay pathways and the stabilization of excited states. This intriguing behavior is rooted in the intricate interactions among chromophores, such as π–π stacking. The unique properties of AIP have significant implications for the development of advanced optical devices, sensors, and biomedical applications, offering opportunities for improved sensitivity and specificity in various fields.
In the investigation of aggregation-induced polarization within multilayer 3D polymer
5A, a notable increase in optical rotation was observed, escalating from +24 to +66 as the water fraction was incrementally raised from 0% to 25% (
Figure 8). This pronounced enhancement in optical activity can be attributed to the aggregation of chromophores within the polymer matrix, which facilitates stronger intermolecular interactions and promotes the stabilization of excited states, thereby amplifying the polarization effect. The increase in water fraction likely induces a favorable microenvironment that enhances the aggregation process, leading to the observed optical rotation enhancement. However, a critical instability in the optical rotation was noted at a water fraction of 30%, suggesting a threshold beyond which the system undergoes significant structural or conformational changes. At this concentration, the polymer chains may experience increased solvation and mobility, disrupting the optimal aggregation state necessary for sustained AIP. The introduction of excess water could lead to competitive interactions, such as solvation effects or phase separation, which may detrimentally affect the chromophore alignment and aggregation. This phenomenon underscores the delicate balance between solvent interactions and aggregation dynamics, highlighting the need for precise control over environmental conditions to optimize AIP in polymeric systems.
3.4. Analysis of Particle Size
The dynamic light scattering (DLS) measurements of the multilayer 3D chiral polymers synthesized from 2,2′-(2,7-Naphthalenediyl)bis[4,4,5,5-tetramethyl-1,3,2-dioxaborolane]
2 and 1,8-dibronaphthalene derivatives
1,
3, and
4 reveal intriguing insights into the influence of molecular architecture and substructure on particle size distribution. The observed particle size of 222 nm for the benzene and naphthalene-containing multilayer 3D chiral polymer indicates a relatively compact structure, likely attributed to the efficient packing and π–π stacking interactions inherent to these aromatic components. The presence of naphthalene, with its larger conjugated system compared to benzene, facilitates stronger intermolecular interactions, contributing to the stabilization of smaller aggregates. In contrast, polymers containing benzene, naphthalene, and hydroacene exhibit a significant increase in particle size, with the highest intensity percentage being around 1000 nm (
Figure 9). This increase can be attributed to the additional structural complexity introduced by hydroacene, which promotes the formation of larger aggregates due to enhanced hydrophobic interactions and the potential for extended π-conjugation. The bulky hydroacene moieties may disrupt the compact packing observed in simpler structures, leading to the formation of larger, less densely packed aggregates.
Furthermore, the polymer incorporating benzene, naphthalene, and methoxy groups shows an even larger particle size of approximately 1500 nm. The methoxy substituent, being an electron-donating group, can alter the electronic properties and solubility of the polymer, potentially leading to increased steric hindrance and reduced intermolecular interactions. This effect can promote the formation of larger aggregates as a result of weaker cohesive forces within the polymer matrix.
In the analysis of the scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images of the multilayer 3D chiral polymer, distinct small particles were observed within each layer, exhibiting a propensity to aggregate (
Figure 10). This phenomenon corroborates the hypothesized multilayer structure of the polymer. The presence of these discrete particles suggests a hierarchical organization, where individual layers are not only formed but also interact through aggregation, potentially enhancing the overall structural integrity and functionality of the material. The layered arrangement may facilitate specific interactions among the particles, contributing to the chiral properties of the polymer. Furthermore, the observed morphology provides insights into the processing conditions and the self-assembly mechanisms at play during the formation of the multilayer architecture. This layered aggregation is critical for understanding the material’s properties and behaviors, paving the way for future applications in areas such as photonics and catalysis, where chiral structures can play a pivotal role.
3.5. Circular Dichrosim
Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is a pivotal technique used for investigating chiral polymers through the measurement of their differential absorption of left- and right-handed circularly polarized light. The resulting CD spectra unveil crucial insights into the conformational characteristics and secondary structures of the polymers, including aspects such as helicity and aggregation behavior. By analyzing CD signals, researchers can evaluate enantiomeric purity and monitor conformational changes in response to various stimuli, thus enhancing the understanding of the intricate relationship between molecular structure and optical activity in chiral materials.
In this study, we analyzed the optical activity of chiral polymer 5A in tetrahydrofuran (THF) using CD spectroscopy. A sample solution was prepared at an optimal concentration of 0.5 mg/mL to ensure sufficient signal intensity while minimizing solvent interference. The sample was housed in a quartz cuvette, allowing for the transmission of light across the relevant wavelengths. A monochromatic light source directed circularly polarized light through the sample, and the CD spectrometer measured the differential absorption of left- and right-handed circularly polarized light at each wavelength.
The CD spectrum of polymer
5A revealed a prominent optical absorption feature between 210 and 260 nm, which is characteristic of π−π* transitions typically observed in aromatic compounds. Notably, pronounced negative Cotton effects were identified within the wavelength ranges of 206–207 nm, 213–215 nm, 222–225 nm, and 247–252 nm. In contrast, positive Cotton effects were observed in the ranges of 215–218 nm, 228–230 nm, 235–237 nm, and 242–244 nm. These distinctive Cotton effects, illustrated in
Figure 11, are indicative of the presence of chirality and provide insights into the molecular conformation and interactions of polymer
5A.
It is acknowledged that the strong absorption of THF could complicate the analysis of CD signals in the 205–250 nm range. To mitigate this, we carefully selected our measurement conditions and ensured that the concentrations employed did not overwhelm the CD signal with solvent absorption effects. The CD spectrum is thus interpreted within the context of the known refractive and absorption properties of THF, reinforcing the conclusion that the observed Cotton effects are genuine indicators of chirality in polymer 5A.
These findings not only support the existence of optical activity in this polymer but also contribute to a deeper understanding of its molecular structure and interactions. The distinct Cotton effects observed in the CD spectra of polymer 5A affirm its chiroptical properties, thereby providing a reliable basis for future studies on the enantiomeric differentiation of chiral materials.