2.1. Variables Affecting Adsorption Capacity of Fe3+
Four kinds of commercially activated carbons derived from coal, coconut shell, nutshell and wood, were used to screen their adsorption capacities for Fe
3+. As shown in
Figure 1A, the significant difference was observed in the adsorption capacity of Fe
3+ under different elution processes. Compared with the deionized water, activated carbons eluted by acidic solutions showed an obvious increase in the adsorption capacity of Fe
3+ in all cases. Among the acidic solutions, the elution efficiency from highest to lowest was nitric acid, sulfuric acid, and hydrochloric acid. This trend was attributed to oxidizing abilities of elution solutions. Acidic solutions enhanced the removal of impurities from the activated carbon surface, increasing the available sites for Fe
3+ adsorption. Nitric acid, being a strong oxidizing agent, was the most effective, likely due to its ability to create more surface functional groups that favored Fe
3+ binding [
17]. After the treatment of low-oxidizing detergent solutions (deionized water and hydrochloric acid), there was no significant difference observed among the four kinds of commercially activated carbons. The minimal effect of deionized water and hydrochloric acid suggested that these solutions did not significantly modify the surface properties of the activated carbons. However, when high-oxidizing detergent solutions (nitric and sulfuric acid) were used, the Fe
3+ adsorption capacity of coal-derived activated carbon (CAC) increased by approximately 27% compared to the other three types. This significant improvement highlighted the role of the oxidizing agent in enhancing the adsorption capacity of activated carbon. The specific structure and surface chemistry of CAC may have interacted more favorably with oxidizing agents, resulting in more efficient adsorption sites for Fe
3+. Therefore, CAC was confirmed as the best candidate of activated carbons and nitric acid was used for the elution process.
Next, the concentration of nitric acid was investigated systematically, as shown in
Figure 2B. It was observed that for nitric acid concentrations below 30%, the contents of carboxyl, hydroxyl, and lactone groups on the CAC surface increased with the nitric acid concentration. Correspondingly, the adsorption capacity of Fe
3+ also increased. This trend can be attributed to the enhanced surface oxidation, which introduced more functional groups that serve as active sites for Fe
3+ adsorption. However, for nitric acid concentrations above 30%, a decrease in adsorption capacity was observed, even though the maximum contents of carboxyl, hydroxyl, and lactone groups had not yet been reached. There were only slight increases in the contents of these functional groups at higher nitric acid concentrations. While the presence of carboxyl, hydroxyl, and lactone groups can potentially increase the number of active adsorption sites, leading to improved adsorption capacity, excessively high nitric acid concentrations led to detrimental effects on the CAC structure. Under extreme oxidizing conditions, such as those provided by high concentrations of nitric acid, the structure of CAC can be significantly compromised. The aggressive oxidative environment can cause pore collapse, reducing the surface area and pore volume, which are critical for effective adsorption. This structural degradation negates the benefits of the increased functional groups, resulting in a net decrease in adsorption capacity for Fe
3+.
Special attention was paid on the ultrasonic treatment during the elution process. As shown in
Figure 1C, the contents of functional groups and adsorption capacity of Fe
3+ of CAC barely changed after the ultrasonic treatment in the deionized water. Although the ultrasonic treatment was slightly harmful to the increase in the contents of functional groups, a slight improvement was observed in the adsorption capacity of Fe
3+. It might be because the ultrasonic treatment was beneficial for clearing pore channels. This phenomenon indicated that the content of functional groups might be beneficial for the adsorption of Fe
3+, but they were not necessarily consistent, and the latter was decided by various factors. When 30% nitric acid was employed as the elution solution during the ultrasonic treatment, although the ultrasonic treatment was slightly harmful to the increase in contents of functional groups, a sharp change was observed in the adsorption capacity of Fe
3+ with the ultrasound time. The maximum value of the adsorption capacity of Fe
3+ reached 37.5 mg/g, which was 1.6 and 2.2 times higher than treatments of only nitric acid or ultrasound. Moreover, an additional experiment was carried out in which 30% nitric acid and ultrasound were respectively used to treat CAC. However, the adsorption capacity of Fe
3+ only reached 30.7 mg/g, which was 1.2 times lower than our combination method. It might be explained that the ultrasonic treatment could clear the pore channel of CAC which should be beneficial for the interaction between nitric acid and the internal surface of CAC [
18]. Meanwhile, the ultrasonic treatment might be harmful to the structure stability of the micropore or partial mesoporous of CAC particularly in the very long processing time.
The SEM analysis was used to study the effect of pretreatment on the structure and morphology of CAC. As shown in
Figure 2A, the surface of the initial CAC was not smooth and flat, where the edge of the pore channel was clear, and its size ranged from 3–10 μm. After acid eluting, the outer surface of CAC was seriously destroyed, as shown in
Figure 2B. Many internal channels were exposed leading to lower diffusional resistance for Fe
3+. In fact, the ultrasonic treatment would also destroy the outer surface of CAC, as shown in
Figure 2C. The size of the channel entrance was increased by over 20 μm. However, a lot of fragments were observed in this sample and some of them even blocked the channel entrance, which might be not a good phenomenon.
Figure 3D shows the morphology of CAC with the pretreatment of acid eluting under the ultrasonic treatment. Although the outer surface of CAC was corroded, the pore channel became very smooth and flat, and the size of the channel entrance was increased by over 20 μm. Meanwhile, no fragment was observed on the channel entrance. More importantly, a lot of small pores were observed. During the pretreatment, they might be generated or were originally internal channels, but now, the outer surface was slightly corroded, causing them to be exposed. Although nitric acid was also used in
Figure 2B, its distribution might be uneven, leading to more interaction with the outer surface. This phenomenon lead to a lot of channels being destroyed. In
Figure 2D, nitric acid might diffuse into the pore channels well under the assistance of the ultrasonic treatment. Therefore, outer and internal channels could be modified simultaneously leading to the stronger adsorption ability for Fe
3+.
2.2. Preparation of Fe2O3/CAC
The iron ion was adsorbed on the surface of pretreated CAC by impregnation and precipitation methods, which was further converted into Fe2O3 under calcination. Variables affecting catalytic performance were systematically investigated including Fe2O3 loading, precipitants and calcination processes.
The effect of the concentration of Fe(NO
3)
3 on the catalyst is shown in
Figure 3A. It was observed that for the concentration of Fe(NO
3)
3 below 0.6 mol/L, the catalyst Fe
2O
3/CAC increased with the amount of Fe
2O
3, while for volumes above this value, a decrease in the activity was observed indicating that maximum activity was not necessarily consistent with the content of Fe
2O
3. Although Fe
2O
3 was the active site, it did not mean all Fe
2O
3 attached to the surface of CAC could participate in the reaction. Although Fe
2O
3 served as the active site, not all Fe
2O
3 attached to the surface of CAC participated in the reaction. At high loadings, Fe
2O
3 likely agglomerated randomly (similar to multi-layer adsorption or even aggregation), leading to mass transfer limitations for the substrate molecules trying to reach the active sites. This aggregation could block the diffusional channels of the CAC, reducing the overall effectiveness of the catalyst.
Precipitation was a crucial process during the preparation of Fe
2O
3/CAC. It not only directly determined the most amount of the iron attachment, but also affected the formation of Fe
2O
3 on the carrier surface. Five kinds of precipitants were evaluated, as shown in
Figure 3B. Generally, precipitants with weak bases showed better performance in facilitating the attachment of iron on the carrier surface. When a strong base like NaOH was used, the precipitation formed rapidly, observable even to a naked eye. This phenomenon was actually caused by the aggregation of Fe(OH)
3 rather than its effective attachment to the carriers. Consequently, very low catalytic performance was detected in the NaOH sample. Although NaHCO
3 was the weakest base used in this work, the maximum catalytic performance was found in the Na
2CO
3 sample. This might be because if the base of the precipitant was too weak, it would affect the amount of iron precipitated. The findings suggest that the choice of precipitant played a significant role in the preparation of the Fe
2O
3/CAC catalyst. The weak bases appeared to provide more controlled and effective precipitation process, leading to better dispersion of Fe
2O
3 on the carrier surface. In contrast, strong bases caused rapid precipitation and aggregation, which negatively impacted the catalytic performance. The impurities introduced by urea or ammonia solutions could interfere with the catalytic reaction, possibly by blocking active sites or altering the surface properties of the catalyst.
After Na
2CO
3 was confirmed as the most suitable precipitant, the amount required was investigated systematically (
Figure 3C). It was observed that the concentration of Na
2CO
3 at 0.5 mol/L and the catalytic performance both reached the maximum value. The concentration of Na
2CO
3 played a crucial role in determining the efficiency of the Fe
2O
3/CAC catalyst. At optimal concentrations, Na
2CO
3 facilitated the uniform precipitation of iron, ensuring that Fe
2O
3 was well-distributed across the carrier surface. This uniform distribution is critical for maximizing the available active sites and enhancing the catalytic performance. However, at lower concentrations of Na
2CO
3, insufficient precipitation resulted in poor iron loading. This deficiency meant fewer active sites were available for catalysis, leading to suboptimal catalytic performance. On the other hand, at higher Na
2CO
3 concentrations, the rapid and excessive precipitation likely caused iron ions to cluster together rather than disperse evenly. These clusters would create areas of high local concentration, which hindered the access of substrate molecules to the active sites due to mass transfer limitations.
Calcination was a crucial process for converting Fe(OH)
3 into Fe
2O
3, ensuring the latter was firmly attached to the carrier surface. TG/DTG analysis was used to study the calcination process and confirm the optimal calcination conditions, as shown in
Figure 3D. At temperatures between 300 and 500 °C, the decomposition of Fe(OH)
3 to Fe
2O
3 was efficient, which was essential for creating a stable and active catalyst. The maximum mass loss rate was observed at 350 °C. When the heating temperature exceeded 500 °C, only slight mass loss was still observed.
Therefore, Fe
2O
3/CAC was prepared under different calcination temperatures from 300 to 500 °C to evaluate their catalytic activities during the production of sebacic acid. As shown in
Figure 3E, the calcination temperature barely affected the iron loading but significantly influenced the catalytic activity of the final catalyst. When the temperature was too low and couldn’t reach the decomposition temperature of the precursor, the formation of the active component Fe
2O
3 on the carrier surface was reduced. Conversely, if the heating was too high, the decomposition occurred too rapidly, leading to the agglomeration of Fe
2O
3. This agglomeration affected its dispersion on the carrier surface, thereby reducing the catalytic activity. This finding highlighted the importance of optimizing the calcination temperature to ensure efficient conversion of Fe(OH)
3 to Fe
2O
3 while maintaining good dispersion on the carrier surface. The optimal temperature facilitated the formation of well-dispersed Fe
2O
3 particles, which are crucial for high catalytic activity. On the other hand, both insufficient and excessive temperatures compromised the catalyst’s performance by either incomplete decomposition or particle agglomeration, respectively. Further analysis of the calcination time was conducted to study its impact on the catalytic performance, as shown in
Figure 3F. It was observed that for calcination time up to 3 h, both iron loading and catalytic performance reached their maximum values. However, for a period exceeding this duration, a slight decrease in iron loading and a sharp decrease in catalytic performance were detected. This might be explained by the possibility that the matrix was slightly destroyed or Fe
2O
3 was converted into other forms under prolonged calcination times.
The SEM analysis was used to study the structure and morphology of Fe
2O
3/CAC, as shown in
Figure 4. The pore channels were further enlarged, which might have been caused by the calcination process. The Fe
2O
3 particles were clearly observed, and most of them were evenly distributed inside the pores, maximizing the amount of effective active sites. The enlargement of the pore channels likely facilitated greater accessibility and dispersion of Fe
2O
3 particles within CAC. This enhanced distribution is crucial for catalytic efficiency as it increases the surface area available for reactions. The calcination process might have played a dual role by not only enlarging the pores but also helping to anchor the Fe
2O
3 particles firmly onto the CAC surface. Compared with the initial carrier, the elemental analysis of the catalyst also indicated that Fe
2O
3 was successfully immobilized on the surface of CAC, as shown in
Figure 4B–G. The elemental mapping confirmed the uniform distribution of iron across the CAC surface, suggesting a successful synthesis process. This immobilization is essential for maintaining the stability and reusability of the catalyst, as it prevents the leaching of the active metal during catalytic cycles. These results provided strong evidence that the calcination process not only enhances the physical characteristics of the CAC but also effectively incorporates Fe
2O
3 particles, thereby creating a highly efficient catalyst.
2.3. Properties of Fe2O3/CAC
Although Fe
2O
3 was tightly attached on the carrier surface through the calcination, the slight leakage couldn’t be avoided during the reaction. Thus, the residual amount of iron in the product should be also detected to ensure the product’s safety. As shown in
Figure 5A, the yield of sebacic acid reached the maximum value when the mass content of the catalyst was at 4%. After that, there was a slight change in the yield but would lead to a serious accumulation of iron in the product. The yield of sebacic acid reached 83.4%, which was increased 1.4 times than the traditional method (60.2%, as described in the
Section 3.6 “Production of sebacic acid” using untreated Fe
3O
4). Moreover, the residual amount of iron was three times lower (by only about 80 μg/g), when Fe
2O
3/CAC was used, than that of the control experiment of Fe
2O
3 without immobilization (~240 μg/g). It might be explained that iron was evenly dispersed and tightly attached on the internal and out surface of the carrier, maximizing the effective catalytic sites and minimizing the possibility of leakage. Next, the reaction was carried out under different rations between the thinning agent and substrate castor oil (
Figure 5B). The optimal ratio was 5. If it was above this value, although the residual amount of iron was also diluted, the concentrations of catalyst and substrate were also diluted, leading to the yield decrease.
The production of sebacic acid was evaluated at various temperatures, ranging from 250 to 300 °C, and the results were shown in
Figure 5C. The optimum operational temperature was determined to be 270 °C. Increasing the temperature benefited the reaction by providing more energy to the reacting molecules. Essentially, higher temperatures led to faster molecular motion, resulting in more frequent and energetic collisions between reacting molecules, which in turn increased the rate of reaction. However, it was also observed that at temperatures higher than the optimum, there was a downside. The more energetic collisions, while beneficial for reaction rates, also increased the likelihood of iron leakage from the catalyst. This iron leakage was detected as a higher iron content in the product. The elevated temperatures likely caused the Fe
2O
3 particles to become less stable and more prone to detachment from the carbon-activated carrier (CAC), leading to contamination of the sebacic acid product with iron.
The reaction time was also evaluated, as shown in
Figure 5D. The optimal operational time was determined to be 3 h, as extending the reaction time beyond this point did not result in any increase in the yield of sebacic acid. This reaction was conducted under high temperature and strong alkali conditions; thus, a longer reaction time would lead to iron leakage and potentially destroy the catalyst structure. The slight decrease in the yield of sebacic acid observed at 5 h might be attributed to unknown side reactions that could occur under prolonged exposure to these harsh conditions. Such side reactions could consume reactants or intermediates, thereby reducing the overall efficiency of sebacic acid production. This underscores the importance of carefully optimizing the reaction time to maximize yield while preserving catalyst integrity.
In industrial applications, recycling the catalyst is essential to reduce production costs. Consequently, the operational stability of the Fe
2O
3/CAC catalyst was examined, as shown in
Figure 5E. The catalyst was collected after each batch, washed, and then added to fresh reactants. After five batches, a slight decrease in yield was observed, indicating an excellent operational stability of the catalyst. The slight decrease in yield over multiple batches could be attributed to iron leakage under the extreme reaction conditions. Despite this, the catalyst demonstrated a remarkable ability to retain its activity over repeated cycles, highlighting its potential for sustainable industrial application. This durability reduces the frequency of catalyst replacement, thereby lowering operational costs and enhancing the overall efficiency of the process.