3.1. Variation in Tassel Weight, Phytochemicals and Antioxidant Activity
The variations observed among tassel development stages and corn varieties were significant (
p ≤ 0.01) for all parameters (
Table 2). In general, variation in varieties contributed to the largest portion of total variationsin most traits (51.9–95.0%), except in tassel fresh weight in which tassel development had the largest portion (41.3%). The interactions between the development stage (S) and variety (V) were highly significant (
p ≤ 0.01) for
TAC,
TCC, TAY, TCY, and antioxidant activity determined by the TEAC assay. However, the S × V interactions contributed to very small portions of the total variation in these traits.
The results indicate that the effect of variety was the main source of variation in the phytochemicals and antioxidant capacity. The results in this study support those of previous investigations. The main effect of season and the season by genotype interaction contributed to small portions of the total variation in phytochemicals and the antioxidant capacity. The evaluation of corn genotypes for these characteristics over a few seasons was sufficient to identify the superior genotypes [
27].
However, the variation in varietal glume and anther colors, ranging from light green to purple (
Figure 1), was the most important factor in determining the genetic variability of these phytochemical traits. Pigmentation in plant tissue, especially floral pigments, is a source of many phytochemicals, e.g., chlorophyll, carotenoids, flavonoids, and anthocyanins [
28]. The information is important for corn breeders to develop special corn varieties and produce phytochemicals so that food product processors and manufacturers can use this byproduct to develop value-added products.
3.2. Effect of Development Stages on Tassel Weight and Phenolic Compounds
The VT tassel and the 1st day of pollen shed stages had the highest tassel fresh weights of 28.2 and 29.4 g, respectively, whereas the 1st day of pollen shed had the highest tassel dry weight of 9.4 g (
Figure 3). These results are similar to those of a previous study. Hybrid corn varieties had increased tassel dry weights from tassel emergence to the first pollen shed. The tassel weight was highest before pollen shed and, then, it gradually reduced until pollen shed was completed [
29]. The tassel weight continued to decrease after pollen shed. The reduction in tassel weight would be possibly due to the loss of pollen grains. However, the quantity of pollen production in corn tassels was depended on the tassel structure in different corn varieties, such as the number of tassel branches, the tassel length, the length of anthers, the number of spikelets, and thetassel area index. The number of tassel branches and number of spikelets are important traits of tassel architecture as these traits were correlated with pollen production [
30].
Corn varieties had significantly different (
p ≤ 0.01) tassel fresh weights. Hibrix3 had the highest tassel fresh weight (31.2 g) followed by Sugar75 and KGW1 (29.2 and 28.8 g, respectively) (
Table 3). These varieties also had high tassel dry weights. The tassel fresh weight and tassel dry weight across development stages showed similar patterns. However, modern field corn hybrids had smaller tassels than older corn hybrids, and smaller tassels reduce light interception and improve grain production efficiency at a high plant density [
31].
Differences among development stages were observed for TPC, ranging from 11.1 to 13.0 mg GAE/g DW sample. The 1st day of pollen shed had the highest TPC of 13.0 mg GAE/g DW sample, followed by the VT tassel and 50% pollen shed stages. Based on the yield per unit of area, the TPY ranged from 4.18 to 6.13 kg GAE/ha, showing a similar trend to the TPC (
Figure 4a,b). The P4546 field corn had the highest TPC of 15.8 mg GAE/g DW sample followed by Hibrix3 sweet corn, and S6248 and PAC339 field corn (13.4, 12.9, and 12.8 mg GAE/g DW sample, respectively) (
Table 3). Hibrix3 had the highest TPY of 6.78 kg GAE/ha because this sweet corn has big tassels and a high tassel weight.
Modern field corn breeding has focused on the improvement of adaptability to climate change, drought tolerance, disease resistance, and insect resistance. These characteristics may affect phenolic accumulation in field corn because phenolic acids play a key role as defense compounds in response to environmental stresses such as water stress, low temperature, high solar radiation, pathogenic infection, and nutrient deficiency [
32].
Plant phenolics are the most widely distributed natural secondary metabolites in plant phyla. Flavonoids are very large sub-groups of the phenolic compounds and play an important role in functional pollen development. The synthetic pathway of plant phenolics is controlled by development and environmental signals [
33]. Oxidative stress and production of relative oxygen species are induced by stresses and these factors affect the proteins, DNA, and lipids of plant cells. Lipid peroxidation has a harmful and damaging effect on cell membranes. Simultaneously, lipid peroxidation also plays a role as a signaling molecule through theproline-linked pentose phosphate pathway for biosynthesis of secondary metabolites, and the resulting secondary metabolites are important for the protection of cell membranes from oxidative stress [
34].
3.3. Anthocyanins in Corn Tassels
The
TAC in corn tassels increased consistently from the VT tassel stage to the later stages of flower development. The 75% of pollen shed stage had the highest
TAC of 343.1 μg CGE/g DW sample, followed by the 50% of pollen shed and 1st day of pollen shed stages, whereas the 1st day ofpollen shed and 50% of pollen shed stages had the highest TAY values of 155.0 and 142.
6g CGE/ha, respectively (
Figure 4c,d). On average, across the development stages and varieties, TAC values ranged from 11.1 to 1864.6 μg CGE/g DW sample. KGW1 had the highest
TAC of 1864.6 μg CGE/g DW sample at 75% of pollen shed followed by the 50% of pollen shed, 1st day of pollen shed, and VT tassel stages (1716.6, 1647.2, and 1099.3 μg CGE/g DW sample, respectively). TAY was closely related to the tassel dry weight, and KGW1 of purple waxy corn was a superior variety for TAY as it maintained the highest TAY at the 50% of pollen shed and 1st day of pollen shed stages (898.7 and 873.4 g CGE/ha, respectively) (
Table 4).
The aims of this research project were to find suitable times for corn tassel harvest and suitable corn types and varieties for the production of corn pollen with a high anthocyanin content in the tassels that are appropriate for use as a raw material for functional food products. The hypothesis underlying the research project was that theanthocyanin level in corn tassels is related to the purple color of the glumes and anthers in different corn types and varieties and at development stage of corn tassel development. In our earlier work, in other corn parts,
TAC increased from the milky stage to the maturity stage in waxy corn kernels and was highest in purplish black-colored genotypes [
35]. A similar increase in anthocyanins in purple corn silk was also observed from the silking stage to the milky stage, but it decreased slightly at the maturity stage [
1]. Moreover, the anthocyanin concentration in purple corn was affected by several factors such as the genotype, growing location, extraction solvent, and determination method. These factors should be considered for the production of anthocyanin from corn tassels for industrial use.
3.4. Carotenoids in Corn Tassels
The
TCC among development stages ranged from 39.9 to 54.1 μg/g DW sample. The 50% of pollen shed and 75% of pollen shed stages had the highest
TCC values of 51.7 and 54.1 μg/g DW sample, respectively, whereas the stage of 50% of pollen shed stage had the highest TCY of 22.9 g/ha, followed by the 75% of pollen shed, 1st day of pollen shed, and VT tassel stages (20.3, 19.7, and 17.0 g/ha, respectively) (
Figure 4e,f). These results suggest that pollen shedding affects the tassel weight and leads to a decreased carotenoid yield in the late stages of tassel development.
Variations in
TCC and
TAC followed a similar pattern across the stages of tassel development and corn varieties.
TCC ranged from 26.1 to 88.4 μg/g DW sample. KGW1 had the highest
TCC of 88.4 and 85.7 μg/g DW sample at 50% of pollen shed and 75% of pollen shed, respectively. TCY ranged from 8.2 to 46.3 g/ha across the stages of tassel development and corn varieties, and KGW1 had the highest TCY value of 46.3 g/ha at 50% of pollen shed, followed by the 1st day of pollen shed (35.8 g/ha) and 75% of pollen shed (33.6 g/ha) stages (
Table 5).
In general, pollen, petals, and fruits have high levels of carotenoids. Pollen is an important source of carotenoids in several crops, such as calendula, marigold, and chamomile [
36]. According to Bogdanov [
37], beta carotene is the main carotenoid compound in pollen, with contents ranging from 10 to 200 μg/g sample (17%) recorded. The total carotenoid contents in corn tassels in this study were higher than those reported previously in the kernels of yellow-orange corn from Nigeria [
38], Italy [
19], and central Malawi [
39]. The results indicated that corn tassel could be used as a new source of carotenoids for functional food supplements. The collection of corn flower pollen is more convenient and productive than the collection of bee pollen.
3.5. Antioxidant Capacity in Corn Tassels
The results from the DPPH
• and TEAC methods provided similar information about antioxidant activity. The pollen harvested at 75% of pollen shed had the lowest antioxidant capacity. Antioxidant capacity values determined by the DPPH
• method ranged from 75.4 to 81.8% (
Figure 5a). P4546 also had the highest level of DPPH
• radical scavenging activity (92.4%) followed by PAC339 (87.3%), S6248 (82.0%), and KGW1 (78.3%), respectively (
Figure 6).
The antioxidant capacity was closely related to TPC especially for field corn, as illustrated by the results for P4546. The results in this study were in agreement with those in a previous report of the cobs, husks, and silks of corn. TPC was also closely related to the antioxidant capacity, as determined by the DPPH
• method and ABTS
•+ method (
r = 0.709 and
r = 0.871, respectively) [
3]. The range of values measured by the DPPH
• radical scavenging assay in this study was comparable to those from a previous report using different extraction solvents including ethanol (83.0–85.2%), methanol (69.9–83.7%), and acetone (69.8–80.4%) [
11]. Moreover, the antioxidant capacity values in corn tassel determined by the DPPH
• method, which ranged from 54.9 to 78.3%, were similar in purple waxy and super sweet corn silk, but they were higher than those in white waxy corn silk [
1].
The antioxidant capacity determined by the TEAC method ranged from 54.1 to 61.2 μmol TE/g DW (
Figure 5b). P4546 had the highest TEAC values at the 1st day of pollen shed and 50% and 75% of pollen shed stages (79.1, 79.3, and 76.2 μmol TE/g DW sample, respectively), KGW1 also had the highest TEAC values at the 1st day of pollen shed and 50% of pollen shed stages (81.3 and 74.9 μmol TE/g DW sample), and PAC339 had the highest values at 50% of pollen shed (77.2 μmol TE/g DW sample) (
Table 6). However, the antioxidant levels obtained from this research were lower than those obtained in purple corn kernel [
35] and fresh corn pollen by TEAC assay in previous studies [
9].
The results indicated that the greatest antioxidant activity in the tassels exists in pollen. According to Aličić, et al. [
40], the major components of pollen are carbohydrates, crude fibers, proteins, and lipids, and the minor components include minerals, trace elements, vitamins, carotenoids, phenolic compounds, flavonoids, sterols, terpenes, and amino acids. Although a number of these components have antioxidant activity, phenolics contribute the most to antioxidant activity in pollen [
9]. Thus, the late tassel developmental stage with the lowest level of pollen grains had the lowest pollen fresh weigth and pollen dry weight, resulting in a reduction in the antioxidant activity.
In general, natural bioactive compounds play important roles in improving the health of various populations. Fruits and vegetables are well-known souces of these compounds. However, some agricultural byproducts that are normally considered as waste have high contents of phytochemicals that are potentially useful for industrial applications. Corn tassel with pollen is a byproduct from the corn production field, and it might be a new source for agro-industry utilizations.
In comparison with vegetables and fruits that have higher contents of phytochemicals than corn byproducts, corn byproducts should be more practical due to their lower cost. However, the byproducts from field corn production are more practical for use as a raw material than the byproducts from hybrid seed production, as the amount of the byproduct is sufficient for the commercial scale, and it is important to verify the appropriate time for harvest. In this study, the most appropriate times for tassel harvest were shown to be from the 1st day to 50% of pollen shed. Although corn tassel has a lower bioactive content than some plants, such as some fruits and vegetables, corn tassel is still interesting because corn is produced on a large scale and a large amount of corn tassel is available.
Harvesting 50% of tassel and leaving the rest of the tassel in the field does not affect seed setting in corn grain production. Thus, tassel from the grain production field has potential for use as a raw material for the production of several value-added products. Corn tassel can generate additional income to corn growers and can also help reduce production costs. As corn waste is reduced, corn production should be more effective and sustainable. However, further research should focus on the environmental effects, harvest methods, and the effects of post-harvest on bioactive properties.