2.1. Haloargentates
There are 29 compounds of dinculear haloargentates, predominantly with 0D structures, with a minority displaying either 1D or 0D characteristics. Only one example (RUNSID) contains an inorganic network of 2D layered structure, but the compound contains both dinuclear [
and pentanuclear [
iodoargentate clusters. Some characteristic structures of dinuclear haloargentates are presented in
Figure 1, while the detailed information on the CSD entries are presented in
Table 1 and
Table 2.
The structure of CEQJAM contains 1D chains of edge-sharing [
tetrahedra templated by [Cu(Br)(phen
complex cations. On the other hand, the structure of EFATIP contains a 3D inorganic substructure, where [Zn(en
cations template a [
iodoargentate framework of vertex-sharing [
tetrahedra. On the contrary, the structure of IHINES contains a one-dimensional iodoargentate inorganic subnetwork stabilized with Ag
Ag metallophilic interactions (Ag-Ag distances in the range of 2.9–3.1 Å). In this case, the inorganic subnetwork is templated by N-heterocyclic carbene silver complex cations with coordination number 2, forming
-
stacked dimers. The effect of the shape of the templating metal–organic cation can be effectively contrasted with the structure of VUDKUB, where the one-dimensional iodoargentate subnetwork [
is made from edge-sharing tetrahedra, but weak argentophilic interactions can be distinguished (Ag-Ag distances 3.3 Å). In this case, the templating cations are formed from potentially tetradenate bis N-heterocyclic carbene silver complex of the general formula [
. There are only six examples of trinuclear haloargentates (with one-dimensional inorganic subnetwork), among which only one is a zero-dimensional assembly. The structure of PUNKIU consists of [Zn(bipy
cations templating the 1D iodoargentate chain of the formula [
. As shown in
Figure 2, the inorganic subnetwork propagates perpendicularly to the
plane.
In the iodoargentate, a short AgAg contact can be distinguished, 3.2 Å, indicating an argentophilic interaction. The structure of PUZJUR also contains a trinuclear iodoargentate, of the formula [; however, it is a discrete assembly with -I connected triangles. In this case, the assembly is templated by the [Fe(phen cation and no argentophilic interactions are detected. There are only two examples of haloargentates with a nuclearity of four. The structure of YASYEZ contains a 1D inorganic subnetwork of chloroargentate [ templated with a large heteroleptic ruthenium complex. In this case, argentophilic interactions can be distinguished with AgAg distances in the range of 2.99–3.10 Å. The second tetranuclear structure, YIJHIJ, is discrete and templated with a di-silver tetra-NHC ligand where a strong argentophilic interaction with a distance of 2.84 Å can be detected. In the iodoargenate, strong argentophilic interactions are also present, with distances below 3.0 Å, in the range of 2.84–2.89 Å. The [ iodoargentate possesses a rather irregular shape with each Ag center exhibiting a distorted tetrahedral coordination geometry.
There are only six examples of trinuclear haloargentates (with one-dimensional inorganic subnetwork), among which only one is a zero-dimensional assembly. The structure of PUNKIU consists of [Zn(bipy
cations templating the 1D iodoargentate chain of the formula [
. As shown in
Figure 2, the inorganic subnetwork propagates perpendicularly to the
plane.
The members of the pentanuclear haloargentates templated with metal–organic cations include 13 examples of 0D and 1D dimensionalities of inorganic subnetworks. The structure of DUQMIO contains chains [ propagating perpendicular to the plane and possess a cross-section of a ten-armed star. Such a unique assembly is templated with a tetrahedral zinc solvento complex with bis 4,4-bipyridine ligands, which are arranged along the c direction by - stacking interactions. One of the nitrogen heteroatoms remains uncoordinated. On the other hand, a structure of DUQLIN contains 1D iodoargentate chains of a composition [, propagated along the b direction of the unit cell. The structure is templated by bis-bipy manganese(II) solvento complex (DMSO). Argentophilic interactions are present in the structure, with Ag-Ag distances in the range of 3.1–3.3 Å. The octahedral manganese(II) complex molecules are arranged into dimers by T-shape - stacking interactions.
The number of hexanuclear haloargentate examples is 16. Among them, 0D, 1D, and 2D inorganic subnetworks can be found. The structure of JEPJEX, shown in
Figure 3, contains [
layers propagating along the
plane.
The structure is templated by bis-NHC silver complex, and its coordination number is 2. The structure of PUCVAN is also 2D, in terms of the iodoargentate connectivity of [. In this case, however, there can be distinguished metallophilic interactions with distances in the range of 3.1–3.2 Å. The iodoargentate layers propagate along the plane and are templated by the vanadium(II) solvento complex, which is remarkable, because in the synthesis of this compound, a starting material was . The structure of ZEXMUO is also an example of 2D layered haloargentate with a formula [. In this case, the templation occurs with the presence of [Fe(bipy and cations. The layers propagate along the plane. The argentophilic interactions are also detectable, with a AgAg distance of 3.04 Å. On the contrary, the ZICVUF structure has a 1D inorganic subnetwork. The [ iodoargentate propagates along the plane, templated by [Nd(DMF(dpdo)Nd(DMF with dpdo as -4,4’-bipyridine N,N’-dioxide. The argentophilic interactions can be detected in these chains, with distances in the range of 3.1–3.3 Å.
There are only two haloargentates with a nuclearity of eight in the CSD. The structure of BIZRIN contains a discrete self-assembled iodoargentate of the formula [
, templated by the
-carbonato-tris(bis(2-aminoethyl)amine)-tri-lead multinuclear complex. In this structure, eight [
tetrahedra are connected by sharing edges to give a cluster with
symmetry. Interestingly, no metallophilic interactions are detected in this structure. The structure of COZHIK, shown in
Figure 4, contains a 1D iodoargentate of the formula [
, templated with two barium(II) bis-tetraglyme complexes. Argentophilic interactions can be distinguished with a distance of 3.09 Å. The chains of iodoargentate propagate along the
b direction.
There are only two haloargentates with a nuclearity of nine. The structure of AMOZOU contains an iodoargentate of the formula [, which is 1D and is templated by the [La(DMF solvento complex. Argentophilic interactions can be identified with a distance of 3.14 Å. The chains propagate along the c direction. On the other hand, the structure of LINROS contains an inorganic subnetwork of 2D layered connectivity, despite the same formula of iodoargentate [. In this case, the structure is templated by [Al(DMSO, and argentophilic interactions can be distinguished with distances in the range of 2.99–3.11 Å.
There are only three haloargentates with a nuclearity of 10; two are 1D and one is 2D. The structure of CENHUC01 contains an iodoargentate of the formula [ templated by a [Co(bipy complex cation and the charge is balanced by one hydroxy anion. The crystal data, however, are not of sufficient quality, and level B alerts were reported in the checkcif. The 1D chains propagate along the a direction and no argentophilic interactions were detected. The structure of HUZCEL also contains a decanuclear iodoargentate with 1D connectivity. The iodoargentate of the formula [ is templated by a [Ni(bipy)(THF cation, and 1D chains are propagated along the a direction. The argentophilic interaction can be distinguished with distances in the range of 3.15–3.34 Å. In the structure of PUZKEC, the iodoargentate network is layered, templated with two [Mn(phen cations. The iodoargentate of the formula [ propagates along the plane, and argentophilic interactions are detected, with distances in the range of 3.05–3.35 Å.
There are no examples of haloargentate with nuclearities of 11 and 12 in the database. On the other hand, there are four examples of haloargentates with a nuclearity of 13, all of which possess a 3D inorganic subnetwork. The structure of QUSNOJ, shown in
Figure 5, contains a
symmetric iodoargentate of the formula [
in which argentophilic interactions can be detected, with distances in the range of 2.92–3.23 Å.
The templation occurs in the presence of two symmetric [Co(phen complex cations in the space group . The structures of CEQHIS, CEQHOY, and CEQHUE contain the same motif of bromoargentate of the formula [, which represents a 3D inorganic subnetwork. The structures are templated with [TM(phen complex cations, where TM = , , and . Argentophilic interactions can be distinguished with distances in the range of 2.87–3.24 Å. The three above-mentioned compounds crystallize in the space group.
There are only two haloargentates with a nuclearity of 14 and both are discrete 0D assemblies. The structure of ATAPOC contains an iodoargentate of the formula [, templated with four [Co(DMF solvento complexes. Argentophilic interactions can be distinguished, with distances in the range: 3.07–3.23 Å. On the other hand, the structure of COZGIJ possesses the same formula of the iodoargentate but a different templating cation, consisting of two dinuclear [(DMSO with two -DMSO bridging molecules. Also, the argentophilic interactions can be distinguished with distances in the range of 3.16–3.35 Å.
No haloargentates with a nuclearity of 15 can be found in the database, which are templated with metal–organic cations. However, there are two iodoargentates with a nuclearity of 16. These are halometallates of the formula [ and 1D connectivity. The structure of AMOZUA is templated with two [Pr(DMF complex cations, while the structure of AMUBAO is its samarium(III) analog. Argentophilic interactions can be also detected in both structures, with distances in the range of 3.05–3.27 Å. The iodoargentate chains propagate along the a direction, and the structures crystallize in the space group.
There is a gap in haloargentates with nuclearities between 16 and 22. The last two instances of haloargenatates comprise 0D examples of [ templated with [Ln(DMSO, where = , (the structures of MEMNOK and MEMNUQ). The argentophilic interactions can be distinguished within the linear-type iodoargentate with distances in the range of 2.8–3.2 Å.
2.2. Mixed-Metal Haloargentates
There are 25 examples of mixed-metal haloargentates in the database, presented in
Table 3. Only three of them are trinuclear. The structure of JAYVEO, shown in
Figure 6, contains 1D inorganic subnetwork of the lead–silver argentometallate of the formula [
.
The halometallate is templated by a [Fe(phen complex cation, and a short contact between silver and lead(II) occurs, with a distance of 3.55 Å. Additionally, argentophilic interactions can be detected, with a distance of 3.24 Å. The chain propagates along the a direction. The structure of JAYVIS is a analog of the structure JAYVEO. On the other hand, the structure of JAYVOY is an example of a lead-substituted iodoargentate of the formula [ and templated by [Ni(phen. The short contact PbAg can be detected with a distance of 3.57 Å.
Additionally, argentophilic interactions can be distinguished, with distances in the range of 3.22–3.28 Å. The chains propagate along the direction of a.
There are 11 examples of tetranuclear mixed-metal haloargentates. The structure of COZJEI contains a halometallate of the formula [, templated with a bis(tetra-glyme) barium complex cation. Its structure is discrete and no metallophilic interactions can be detected. The structure of HEVZOB also contains a 0D halometallate, of the formula [, which is templated by a [Zn(phen metal–organic cation. In the structure of this mixed-metal iodoargentate, argentophilic interactions can be distinguished with a distance of 3.08 Å. The shortest bismuth–silver distance in the structure is 3.63 Å. The structures of KEGDEJ, KOBCIP, KOBCOV, and KOBCUB are isostructural and contain a lead-substituted iodoargentate of the formula [. The iodoargentate has 1D connectivity and is templated by a [Ln(DMSO complex cation, where Ln = , , , and . The chains propagate along the a direction, and the shortest distance AgPb is 3.61 Å; no argentophilic interactions can be distinguished. The structures of LANCOW and LANCUC are isostructural and contain the same mixed-metal iodoargentate of the formula [ templated with a [Fe(bipy complex cation. In the structure of the halometallate, both AgBi and AgAg short contacts can be detected with distances of 3.54 and 3.03 Å, respectively. The structures LANDAJ and LANDEN are isostructural, containing the same bismuth-substituted bromoargentate of the formula [, which is a discrete assembly, templated with a [Fe(bipy complex cation. Similar to KEGDEJ and isostructural compounds, the structure of NEHKEV is a 1D sublattice, with the halometallate of the formula [ together with [ templated by a [Fe(phen complex cation. In the structure of this lead-substituted iodoargentate, no argentophilic interactions can be distinguished, and the shortest AgPb contact is 3.63 Å. The chains propagate along the a direction. There is only one mixed-metal haloargentate with a nuclearity of 5, templated by metal–organic cations. The halometallate formula is [, in the structure of LOWYEE. The connectivity of the inorganic subnetwork in this case is two-dimensional, and the templating cation is [Ni(dien)(MeCN (where dien is diethylenetriamine). The waved layer propagates along the plane, and in the halometallate, no argentophilic interactions can be found.
There are only two examples of mixed-metal haloargentates, templated with metal–organic cations, with a nuclearity of six. Both structures YEJQUD and YEJRAK are 0D bismuth-substituted haloargentates of formulas [ and [, respectively. Both structures are templated with [Co(bipy complex cations. In the structure of YEJQUD, there are distinguishable argentophilic interactions in the distance range of 3.01–3.35 Å, along with a short AgBi contact at a distance of 3.43 Å. In the structure of YEJRAK, argentophilic interactions are also present, with distances in the range of 2.99–3.33 Å, together with a short AgBi contact at a distance of 3.53 Å.
There are six examples of mixed-metal haloargentate hybrids with a nuclearity of seven in the database. All six compounds contain a halometallate motif of the formula [, where X = or . The motif has 3D connectivity and is templated with two [TM(bipy complex cations, where , , , and . For example, in the structure of UBIWIO, argentophilic interactions can be found in the [, with distances of 3.07 Å. The 3D connectivity is maintained thanks to K-Br weak bonds, with distances of 3.63 Å.
The structure of COZJAE contains a copper(I)-substituted iodoargentate with a nuclearity of eight, the only example in the database. The halometallate has a formula [ and is characterized by overall 1D connectivity. The structure is templated with two bis(tetraglyme) barium(II) complex cations, and argentophilic interactions can be detected with distances in the range of 3.02–3.28 Å. The AgCu short contact can be distinguished, with a short distance of 2.99 Å. The chains propagate along the b direction. The structure of MUBSAF contains the only mixed-metal haloargentate with a nuclearity of nine. The formula of the halometallate is [ and is templated by a [Y(DMF complex cation. In the structure of the halometallate, a short AgPb contact of 3.39 Å indicates metallophilic interactions. The halometallate forms a 1D zigzag constructed from a [ tetrahedron and [ unit, similar to a fragment commonly observed in the [ chain. The compound exhibits thermochromic behavior.
2.3. Halocuprates
There are 51 halocuprate structures with a nuclearity of two, as shown in
Table 4 and
Table 5. These are usually 0D structures or 1D structures. The majority of copper compounds gathered in the tables contain monovalent copper; however, divalent copper compounds can also be found. The first example of a structure with divalent copper chlorocuprate is ACAROM, shown in
Figure 7.
The [ anion is built from two edge-sharing [ tetrahedra. The short CuCu distance within the cluster is 3.30 Å. The example of structure COZGUV contains [ anions, formed by edge sharing of two triangles [. The shortest distance CuCu is 2.64 Å, in the dimer, templated with a bis(tetraglyme)barium(II) complex cation. The [ anion can be also polymeric, as in the structure of VAHWAD, where 1D chains are formed by edge-sharing tetrahedra in [. The cuprophilic interaction is weaker than in the [ anion, with a distance of 3.04 Å. The chains propagate along the a direction. The structure of YADTUS contains an iodocuprate of the formula [, forming chains by tetrahedra [ sharing edges and vertexes. The cuprophilic interaction can be distinguished with a distance of 2.76 Å, and the chains propagate along the a direction. There are only six examples of halocuprates with a nuclearity of three in the database; all of them are 1D structures containing monovalent or divalent copper ions. The structure of BOHYCU is built from [ chlorocuprate templated by a bis-hydrazide copper complex cation. The compound crystallize in the space group, and the chains are propagated along the a direction. The chain is directly bound to the complex cation by a weak Cu-Cl bond with a distance of 2.76 Å. Additionally, cuprophillic interactions can be distinguished with distances in the range of 2.76–2.89 Å. The structure of CUMWEM contains an iodocuprate of the formula [, templated with a 24-crown-8 potassium complex cation. The chains propagate along the a direction, and cuprophilic interactions can be detected with distances in the range of 2.67–2.80 Å. The structure of JIZBUP contains a chlorocuprate(II) of the formula [ templated with a diacetonitrile-(15-crown-5)-copper(II) complex cation. The shortest distance between copper(II) centers is 3.09 Å. The chains propagate along the (1) plane.
There are 19 examples of structures containing halocuprate clusters with a nuclearity of four. The majority of them are 0D but there are also 1D systems (three examples only). The structure of ATUQIP contains an iodocuprate of the formula [, templated by two bis(12-crown-4) potassium complex cations. The iodocuprate forms chains along the (011) plane. In the chains, cuprophilic interactions can be distinguished with CuCu distances in the range of 2.51–2.64 Å. On the other hand, the structure of COZHAL contains the same iodocuprate motif [, but instead of a polymeric chain, a discrete assembly is formed. The structure is templated with a bis(triglyme)-bis(acetone)-barium(II) complex cation, and cuprophilic interactions can be detected with distances in the range of 2.72–2.86 Å. In the structure of LESVIR, another type of discrete halocuprate can be identified, with the formula [. In this chlorocuprate, cuprophilic interactions can be distinguished with distances 2.66 and 2.87 Å. The halometallate is templated by a large [ bishydrazone complex. On the other hand, the structure of YAFWEK contains an iodocuprate with an odd number of iodine atoms, of the formula [. In this iodocuprate, cuprophilic interactions can be detected, with distances in the range of 2.49–2.78 Å. The assembly is templated by three voluminous molecules of the complex cation [ derived from a phenoxy-oxazolyl-pyridine-type ligand, with a short Cu-Cu distance of 2.57 Å.
There are only 12 examples of pentanuclear halocuprate clusters in the database; the majority of them are characterized by 1D inorganic subnetwork connectivity, while the rest are discrete assemblies. The structure of EKIGIO contains a halometallate of the formula [
, which forms chains templated by a triaqua-(18-crown-6) calcium(II) complex cation. The compound crystallizes in the
space group and the chains propagate along the
b direction of the unit cell. The copper atoms in the halometallate are disordered, so it is difficult to decide upon the Cu-Cu distances in the cuprophilic interactions. On the other hand, the structure of NAZNUZ, shown in
Figure 8, contains a halocuprate of the same formula, [
, but this time, it is a discrete assembly.
In the halometallate, cuprophlic interactions can be detected with distances in the range of 2.50–2.56 Å. The structure is templated by a large trinuclear complex of the formula [, where L denotes a salen-type ligand with bridging phenolic oxygen atoms. The structure of WUZBIE contains a halometallate of the formula [ which forms 1D chains. In the structure of this bromocuprate, cuprophilic interactions can be detected, with distances of 2.76 and 2.81 Å. The structure is templated with the [Co(bipy complex cation, and the chains propagate along the (00) plane.
There is only one example of hexanuclear halocuprate in the database. The structure of DEFLOT contains a discrete iodocuprate cluster of the formula [. The structure is templated with a [ complex cation, where L is diphosphine dioxide chelating ligand. Cuprophilic interactions can be distinguished in the halometallate with distances of 2.58 Å. The compounds exhibit dual emission ascribed by the authors to the presence of octahedral ions and iodocuprate clusters. High quantum yields of luminescence are reported for these compounds.
There are five examples of heptanuclear halocuprate clusters templated with metal–organic cations in the database. Interestingly, there is no 0D cluster, but there are 1D, 2D, and 3D inorganic sublattice connectivities. The structure of LODVEG contains a halometallate of the formula [, composed of entirely copper(II) and templated with [Cu(TIM), where TIM represents 2,3,9,10-tetramethyl-1,3,8,10-tetraenecyclo-1,4,8,11-tetrazatetradecane. The shortest CuCu distances within the halometallate are in the range of 3.33–3.94 Å. The layers propagate along the plane. The problem is with the location of two water molecules, because it is not included in CSD data. It seems that one chloride is replaced to form a [(O) cluster. The structure of NIGNOG is built from the inorganic subnetwork of 3D connectivity. Here, the chlorocuprate of the formula [ is templated by a [Cu(en complex cation. The compound crystallizes in the space group, and cuprophilic interactions can be detected with distances in the range of 2.68–2.83 Å. The structure of WUZCAX contains a heptanuclear iodocuprate of the formula [ which forms inorganic chains templated by [Mn(bipy complex cations. The chains propagate along the a direction, and cuprophilic interactions can be distinguished with distances in the range of 2.80–2.84 Å. On the other hand, the structure of YEWVUS contains an iodocuprate of the formula [, forming chains and templated by [Y(DMF(O complex cations. The chains are propagated along the b direction, and cuprophilic interactions can be distinguished with distances in the range of 2.83–2.86 Å.
There is only one example of halocuprate with a nuclearity of eight in the database. The structure of WUZBEA contains an iodocuprate of the formula [, forming chains and templated with [Cu(bipy and 1,1’-dimethyl-2,2’-bipyridinium dications together. The chains propagate along the c direction, and cuprophilic interactions can be distinguished with distances in the range of 2.72–2.76 Å. There are only three examples of halocuprates with a nuclearity of nine in the database. The structure of PARTOT contains an iodometallate of the formula [, which contains seven monovalent copper atoms and two divalent copper atoms. This mixed valence system is templated with a [Tb(DMF(O complex cation. The layers propagate along the plane of the unit cell, and the cuprophilic interactions can be detected with distances in the range of 2.81–2.85 Å. The structure of YEWWAZ is also two-dimensional with the same halocuprate cluster and ytterbium(III) analog of the templating complex cation. On the other hand, the structure of UHOWUK has a one-dimensional inorganic sublattice, composed of a halometallate with the formula [, which is claimed to be wrongly determined. The structure is templated by a [(phen complex cation. The layers propagate along the plane. There seem to be present cuprophilic interactions, but their identification is complicated by the disorder within the halometallate. The structure of IWEZEP also contains a disordered decanuclear halometallate, with a discrete assembly of the formula [, templated by two [Ni(phen complex cations. On the other hand, the structure of SODMUU contains a decanuclear halocuprate of the formula [, which contains one divalent copper center. The structure is templated with [Co(phen complex cations, and disorder in the occupations of copper centers can be seen and influences the distinguishability of the cuprophilic interactions.
2.4. Photocatalytic Degradation of Dyes
Non-perovskite hybrid halides are promising candidates for the photocatalytic degradation of dyes such as crystal violet, rhodamine blue, and methylene blue.
Table 6 presents key kinetic data, including rate constants and half-lives, from previously published studies. For crystal violet, half-lives range from 5.29 to 433.22 min, depending on the halometallate salt used. The shortest times were observed with mixed-metal silver–lead haloargentates templated with [TM(2,2’-bipy
, while the longest were found for iodoargentates templated with [Ln(DMA
cations. Similarly, for rhodamine blue, half-lives range from 2.06 to 630.13 min. The shortest were reported for bromoargentates templated with [TM(2,2’-bipy
, while the longest occurred with iodoargentates templated with [Ln(DMA
. The longest half-lives for both crystal violet and rhodamine blue come from the same study, while the shortest times for the two dyes are from different studies.
For a complete comparison, experimental conditions must be specified, including the light source, its power, and the initial concentration of the dye. We believe the initial dye concentrations were similar, but light power likely varied across studies. Additionally, the reaction vessel’s geometry could affect light penetration, impacting reaction efficiency. Other factors like mixing rate, photocatalyst grain size, and the quantity of the photocatalyst also likely influence dye degradation efficiency.
In addition to dye degradation experiments, studies on dye adsorption and release have also been conducted. In these experiments, the dye is first adsorbed from a solution onto the hybrid halide. The material is then separated from the solution and immersed in a sodium ion-containing solution, leading to the release of the dye as sodium ions exchange with ions at the hybrid halide interface. This process can be monitored using visible-range absorption spectroscopy [
45].
It appears that the interface between the solution and the non-perovskite hybrid halide is negatively charged. Some templating ions from the solid may dissolve, leaving behind a negatively charged inorganic subnetwork. As a result of Coulombic attraction, cations are drawn to the surface, where photocatalytic processes take place. Interestingly, anionic dyes did not adsorb onto the same hybrid halides as cationic dyes in these experiments.