Comparison of the Passive Behavior of NiTi and CoNiCrMo in Simulated Physiological Solutions

Biomedical alloys in general, except for the biodegradable type, exhibit passive behavior in neutral chloride solutions. Two commonly used biomedical alloys are nitinol (NiTi) and Co-35Ni-20Cr-10Mo (CoNiCrMo). In this work, the passive behavior of electropolished NiTi and CoNiCrMo in a simulated physiological solution (phosphate-buffered saline) was compared using data largely obtained from our previous studies involving potentiodynamic polarization and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The potentiodynamic results showed a marked difference in passive behavior between the alloys, with NiTi remaining completely passive up to the oxidation of water and CoNiCrMo, in contrast, undergoing solid-state oxidation and then transpassive dissolution. Both alloys exhibited Tafel-type behavior over the initial part of the passive range. A small but distinct difference in the apparent Tafel slopes was found between the two alloys and can be attributed to the difference in their predominant oxide; that is, TiO₂ versus Cr₂O₃. The EIS results also showed marked differences between the alloys in terms of the oxide thickness and resistivity. The thickness was greater for NiTi—consistent with surface analytical results—and differed in potential dependence between the two alloys in the passive region. The oxide resistivity, conversely, was substantially lower for NiTi and showed a similar potential dependence for the two alloys.