Towards Cognitive Moral Quasi-Realism
AbstractThere is a long-standing discussion concerning the nature of moral discourse. Multiple views range from realism—according to which moral discourse is closer to scientific discourse than to fictional discourse—to anti-realism—according to which moral discourse is rather closer to fictional discourse. In this paper, I want to motivate a novel anti-realist account. On this view, there are no moral properties or truths, neither mind-independent nor mind-dependent ones (i.e., anti-realism). However, moral cognition results from the use of higher order cognitive abilities with enough resources to grant moral discourse with all the features of a realist talk (i.e., cognitive quasi-realism). I defend this view based on empirical evidence on human moral development and by showing that the resulting account can meet the demands of robust moral realism. The paper concludes by placing the proposed view within the metaethical landscape by comparing it against other forms of anti-realism, most significantly against expressivism. View Full-Text
Share & Cite This Article
García-Ramírez, E. Towards Cognitive Moral Quasi-Realism. Philosophies 2018, 3, 5.
García-Ramírez E. Towards Cognitive Moral Quasi-Realism. Philosophies. 2018; 3(1):5.Chicago/Turabian Style
García-Ramírez, Eduardo. 2018. "Towards Cognitive Moral Quasi-Realism." Philosophies 3, no. 1: 5.