3.1. Sulfate-Mediated Interaction of TA Governs Divergent Gelation Behaviors of κ-CRG and Agarose
Figure 1 contrasts gelation behavior of κ-CRG and agarose because the two polysaccharides share a related galactan backbone structure yet differ critically in charge density. κ-CRG contains sulfate substituents that introduce strong anionic charges within networks, whereas agarose lacks sulfate groups. Thus, agarose gelation can rely effectively on helix–helix association supported by nonpolar (hydrophobic) interactions and dense hydrogen-bonding (
Figure 1a). Although κ-CRG undergoes gelation through a similar helix-based association mechanism, electrostatic repulsion arising from its sulfate groups is expected to hinder close helix–helix packing and thereby reduce overall mechanical robustness relative to agarose. Consistent with the structural difference, the storage modulus (G′) of a 1% agarose gel is substantially higher (4560 ± 223 Pa) than that of a 1% κ-CRG gel (294 ± 10 Pa) (
Figure 1b), indicating that agarose forms a rigid percolated network under the same concentration. These baseline data establish κ-CRG as a mechanically weaker but highly tunable platform whose modulus is constrained by charge-driven repulsion.
To study how TA influences the gelation of the two polysaccharides, TA was introduced over a broad concentration range. For agarose, the incorporation of only trace amounts of TA (0.2–0.4 wt%) was sufficient to produce turbid gels, and a slightly higher TA content (0.6 wt%) completely inhibited gel formation, yielding precipitated aggregates instead (
Figure 1c, lower row). This behavior indicates that TA interacts strongly with the agarose galactan backbone, and that even a modest increase in TA concentration can disrupt the intrinsic helix–helix domain formation required for agarose gelation, thereby driving macroscopic phase separation and aggregation. In contrast, κ-CRG retained its characteristic transparent gel state even in the presence of 5 wt% TA—approximately ninefold higher than the TA level that abrogated agarose gelation (
Figure 1c, upper row). Further increasing TA up to 15 wt% did not measurably compromise gelation or optical clarity. The optical distinction between the two systems was further supported by UV–Vis measurements, which confirmed optical transparency in TA/κ-CRG (A
550 = −0.16) and pronounced turbidity in TA/agarose (A
550 = 1.66) (
Figure 1d). The slight negative value in absorption might be due to light scattering of solid gels. Because the principal structural distinction between agarose and κ-CRG is the presence of sulfate groups tethered to the backbone, the large difference in gelation/aggregation outcomes upon TA addition is most consistently explained by preferential TA binding with the sulfate functionalities in κ-CRG (
Figure 1e). Such sulfate-directed binding would effectively sequester TA away from extensive direct binding to the neutral galactan backbone, thereby suppressing the rapid turbidity increase and precipitation observed in the agarose/TA system. We further quantified the viscoelastic reinforcement of the TA/κ-CRG hydrogels by measuring the storage modulus (G′) using an oscillatory rheometer (
Figure 1f). All reported G′ values were obtained at a strain of 0.5%, which belongs to the linear viscoelastic region for all tested gel formulations (
Figure A1). Notably, G′ increased in a TA concentration-dependent manner (5–15%), indicating progressive network strengthening with increasing TA content. In particular, at 15 wt% TA, the κ-CRG gel exhibited a G′ value more than fivefold higher (1632 ± 31 Pa) than that of the negative control (κ-CRG only) (294 ± 12 Pa). This mechanical enhancement is consistent with the interpretation that TA preferentially associates with κ-CRG sulfate groups, thereby partially neutralizing the intrinsic electrostatic repulsion between anionic helices. Reduced inter-helix repulsion would facilitate closer helix–helix packing and/or enlargement of junction zones, effectively increasing the crosslinking density of the physically crosslinked network and manifesting macroscopically as a higher storage modulus.
To provide evidence explaining the proposed sulfate-associated interaction between κ-CRG and the hydroxyl group of TA, FTIR spectroscopy was performed using κ-CRG and κ-CRG:TA mixture corresponding to [κ-CRG]:[galloyl] = 1:14.7. Under this condition, the peak position at 841.3 cm
−1 was shifted to 843.2 cm
−1 (
Figure 1g). The range of wavenumber, 840–850 cm
−1, belongs to the well-known region assigned to the sulfate attached to D-galactose [
17]. These results support sulfate-associated intermolecular interactions between κ-CRG and the hydroxyl groups of TA.
3.2. Monovalent Galloyl Interactions Partially Reinforce κ-CRG Gels but Lack Cooperative Network Stabilization
To distinguish whether the κ-CRG reinforcement observed with TA arises primarily from (i) additive, local charge screening at sulfate groups, or (ii) a multivalency-amplified, cooperative mechanism enabled by the clustered gallol units within TA, pyrogallol—a monomeric gallol lacking the multivalency of TA—was selected as a model small molecule and introduced at concentration of 2–6 wt%, chosen to provide gallol-equivalent inputs comparable to those used for TA. Qualitatively, both pyrogallol/κ-CRG and pyrogallol/agarose formed self-supporting, optically transparent gels across all tested pyrogallol concentrations (
Figure 2a). Quantitatively, UV–Vis measurements showed A
550 = −0.13 for pyrogallol/κ-CRG and A
550 = 0.19 for pyrogallol/agarose (
Figure 2b). Importantly, this result contrasts with the agarose/TA system shown in
Figure 1c, where even trace amounts of TA induced turbidity and precipitation. The preservation of transparency and gel integrity in agarose upon pyrogallol addition suggests that monomeric gallol motifs, when presented without a multivalent scaffold, do not substantially disrupt helix formation or promote mesoscale complexation/phase separation in a neutral galactan matrix. In other words, the TA-driven turbidity and aggregation observed in agarose are consistent with multivalency-enabled bridging or condensation effects, rather than with a generic gallol–backbone interaction alone.
Consistent with selective strengthening of κ-CRG networks, oscillatory rheology revealed that pyrogallol increases the storage modulus (G’) of κ-CRG gels in a concentration-dependent manner, followed by an apparent saturation at higher pyrogallol loadings (
Figure 2c). Relative to the pyrogallol-free control (~300 Pa), G’ increased markedly at 2–4 wt% pyrogallol to 600–700 Pa (593.15 ± 28.32 for 2 wt% and 653.21 ± 29.55 for 4 wt%) and then remained near this level at 6 wt%, indicating that a finite population of reinforcing interaction sites becomes progressively occupied and approaches a plateau (596.89 ± 12.72 Pa). These results support the conclusion that gallol motif alone can reinforce κ-CRG, plausibly associating with sulfate-rich domains and partially mitigating inter-helix electrostatic repulsion, thereby facilitating closer helix–helix association. However, when benchmarked against TA at comparable gallol equivalents (
Figure 1f), pyrogallol yields substantially only a modest modulus enhancement, implying that charge screening by individual gallol units is not sufficient to recapitulate the full strengthening by TA. We attribute this gap to TA’s multivalency [
18].
3.3. Polyphenol Intervention Stage Controls Pathway-Dependent vs. Pathway-Independent Gelation
Gelation of κ-CRG proceeds through a stepwise process in which a high-temperature random-coil state undergoes a coil–helix transition upon cooling, followed by the development of inter-helical associations that form a three-dimensional network (
Figure 3a, top). Because κ-CRG reinforcement observed with polyphenols in
Figure 1 and
Figure 2 was attributed to sulfate-associated interactions, we next examined whether the intervention stage—i.e., whether the polyphenol encounters κ-CRG before or during helix development—alters the final network architecture and properties. Temperature-ramp rheology revealed a narrow plateau for 1 wt% κ-CRG between 66.6 and 71.7 °C, which we define as a proto-helical regime, whereas ≥90 °C corresponds to a fully random-coil regime (
Figure 3a). Accordingly, polyphenols (TA or pyrogallol) were introduced either at 90 °C or 70 °C while maintaining identical composition and processing otherwise (
Figure 3b).
To select polyphenol concentrations for the temperature-dependent experiments (90 °C vs. 70 °C), we first monitored G’ as a function of polyphenol content. Across concentrations, both TA and pyrogallol exhibited a characteristic reinforcement-turnover profile. G’ increased at low polyphenol loadings, reached a maximum (~6 wt% for pyrogallol and ~15 wt% for TA), and then decreased at higher concentrations (
Figure 3c). This trend is consistent with sulfate-mediated strengthening that eventually saturates, followed by structural perturbation of helix formation and/or junction-zone organization once excess polyphenol begins to frustrate helix–helix association. Based on these profiles, we selected 8 wt% for pyrogallol and 20 wt% for TA to clearly probe whether the final network depends on the stage of polyphenol intervention.
Strikingly, the intervention stage exerted a strong effect for pyrogallol but not for TA. When pyrogallol was introduced in the random-coil regime (90 °C), the resulting gel exhibited G′ = 432.5 ± 23.7 Pa after cooling to room temperature. In contrast, introduction of pyrogallol in the proto-helical regime (70 °C) produced substantially stiff gel G’ = 944.4 ± 44.9 Pa (
Figure 3d). This result supports the view that κ-CRG is a weak gel, in which elasticity is governed by a subset of long-lived, load-bearing junction zones rather than network-average connectivity [
19]. Importantly, the lower modulus upon pyrogallol addition at 90 °C (432.5 ± 23.7 Pa) can be rationalized by early-stage binding. Pyrogallol association with κ-CRG chains in the random-coil state likely perturbs subsequent coil → helix conversion and/or the organization of nascent helices into mechanically stable junction domains, thereby limiting the formation of load-bearing junction zones during cooling. By contrast, when pyrogallol is added after partial ordering has already emerged (70 °C), a fraction of proto-helical segments may be less accessible to disruptive binding [
20], allowing junction-zone development to proceed more effectively and yielding higher G′ (944.4 ± 44.9 Pa).
Thermal signature of gelation corroborates this stage-dependent effect. Neat κ-CRG gelled at ~67 °C (
Figure 3a), whereas pyrogallol addition depressed the gelation temperature to ~55 °C when introduced at 90 °C and further to ~49 °C when introduced at 70 °C (
Figure 3e). The larger decrease upon 70 °C intervention suggests that, once proto-helical domains have formed, pyrogallol preferentially associates with the remaining exposed/less ordered chain regions, effectively modifying backbone interactions that are critical for propagating helix formation; consequently, helix development becomes less favorable, and gelation shifts to lower temperature. In contrast, TA produced little change in storage modulus (G’) and gelation temperature converged to a transition near 55 °C, comparable to the pyrogallol system mixed at 90 °C (
Figure 3f,g). This stage-insensitive behavior is consistent with TA’s multivalency, which can promote chain-to-chain association through multipoint sulfate-associated interactions and thereby facilitate network organization even when introduced at different structural states [
21]. Considering all results,
Figure 3 demonstrates that monomeric pyrogallol imprints pathway dependence—with both stiffness and gelation temperature sensitive to the intervention stage—whereas multivalent TA behaves as a pathway-independent organizer, yielding similar thermal behavior while preserving robust network formation in κ-CRG gels.
3.4. Valency-Dependent Disintegration of Polyphenol/κ-CRG Gels in Aqueous Conditions
Next, we assessed the macroscopic stability of the κ-CRG gel network in aqueous environments by monitoring the morphological evolution of gel discs over time. Gels were prepared by mixing pyrogallol (6 wt%) or TA (15 wt%) with hot 1 wt% κ-CRG followed by cooling, molding into discs (15.5 mm diameter, ~5 mm height), and incubating at 37 °C in simulated gastric fluid (SGF, pH 1.2) or simulated intestinal fluid (SIF, pH 6.8) with shaking (100 rpm) (
Figure 4a). To quantitatively monitor the disintegration kinetics of the gel, the changes in gel diameter over time were additionally analyzed from top-view images using ImageJ (
Figure 4b–d, right panels).
We first established the baseline behavior of native κ-CRG gels without polyphenols. The rate of disintegration followed SGF > DW > SIF (
Figure 4b). In SGF (≈35 mM sodium), gel discs rapidly disintegrated within ~30–50 min, whereas in SIF the gels retained their structure over the same time scale and were even more stable than in DW. This qualitative trend was also supported by the diameter analysis. In SGF, the gel diameter decreased to 13.4 ± 0.2 mm at 30 min, and no measurable gel disc remained at 50 min due to complete disintegration, whereas the gels in SIF and DW retained diameters of 14.4 ± 0.2 mm and 13.3 ± 0.1 mm, respectively, at 50 min (
Figure 4b, right panel). This pH/ionic-strength dependence is consistent with reduced junction stability at low pH, where partial protonation of sulfate groups diminishes anionic coordination sites important for helix aggregation [
22], while the sodium-rich environment in SIF (100 mM sodium phosphate buffer) can partially stabilize helix-bundle junctions.
Upon polyphenol incorporation, a clear valency-dependent divergence in stability emerged, with pyrogallol-containing gels being consistently more stable than TA-containing ones in both SGF and SIF (
Figure 4c,d). In both media, pyrogallol/κ-CRG discs underwent only gradual reductions in diameter over the observation window (0–30 min), preserving macroscopic integrity throughout. The gel diameter decreased from 15.5 to 12.9 ± 0.3 mm in SGF (
Figure 4c, right panel, red) and from 15.5 to 13.9 ± 0.1 mm in SIF over 30 min (
Figure 4c right panel, green). In contrast, TA/κ-CRG discs exhibited rapid shrinkage immediately upon exposure to aqueous media, with pronounced size reduction. In SGF, the diameter of TA/κ-CRG gels decreased from 15.5 to 14.7 ± 0.3 mm at 10 min, to 6.4 ± 0.2 mm at 20 min, and no measurable gel disc remained at 30 min (
Figure 4d, right panel, red). Similarly, the diameter of TA/κ-CRG gels was decreased from 15.5 to 10.3 ± 0.1 mm at 20 min and 3.3 ± 0.3 mm at 30 min (
Figure 4d, right panel, green). The observed faster breakdown of TA/κ-CRG gels can be rationalized by the distinct network architectures inferred from
Figure 1,
Figure 2 and
Figure 3. Importantly, the increased initial G′ of TA/κ-CRG does not necessarily indicate greater resistance to aqueous disintegration. Pyrogallol primarily engages sulfate groups through localized, effectively monodentate interactions that partially reduce electrostatic repulsion yet preserve a substantial fraction of the native κ-CRG helix–helix junctions, allowing the network to retain global connectivity under hydrated conditions. In contrast, TA, owing to its multidentate architecture, promotes multipoint chain-to-chain bridging and dynamic bond exchange during gel formation [
21], thereby markedly increasing gel stiffness while shifting network connectivity toward TA-mediated supramolecular junctions [
23]. As a result, in aqueous environments, particularly in acidic SGF where native κ-CRG junctions are already destabilized, local dissociation or rearrangement of these TA-mediated junctions can directly disrupt percolation across the network and lead to rapid disintegration [
24].
3.5. Multivalent TA-Mediated Surface Adhesion of κ-CRG Gels
The results presented in
Figure 1,
Figure 2,
Figure 3 and
Figure 4 demonstrate that polyphenol/κ-CRG interactions can reorganize the gel network from local molecular binding to the supramolecular architecture of the entire system. In particular, TA forms multipoint interactions between κ-CRG chains through its multivalent galloyl groups, generating supramolecular junctions that simultaneously modulate the mechanical properties of the gel and its disintegration behavior in aqueous environments. Such interactions are not necessarily limited to the internal network structure but may also operate at the gel–surface interface. Indeed, polyphenols are known to form strong non-covalent interactions with various polymeric and biological surfaces, particularly through polyphenol–protein and polyphenol–polysaccharide interactions [
25,
26].
To test this hypothesis, the surface adhesion behavior of native κ-CRG gel, pyrogallol/κ-CRG gel, and TA/κ-CRG gel was compared. The gel discs were first placed on a rough sandpaper surface (P100), and their adhesion behavior was observed after the substrate was inverted so that the gels faced downward along the direction of gravity (
Figure 5a). Both the native κ-CRG gel and the pyrogallol/κ-CRG gel detached immediately upon inversion. In contrast, the TA/κ-CRG gel remained firmly attached to the surface even when the substrate was completely inverted. The adhesion persisted even under repeated mechanical perturbations applied by tapping the substrate. These results indicate that the TA-containing gel forms stable interfacial interactions with rough solid surfaces. A similar trend was observed on human skin (
Figure 5b). When gel discs of identical composition were attached to the skin between the wrist and forearm, the native κ-CRG gel and pyrogallol/κ-CRG gel detached immediately. In contrast, the TA/κ-CRG gel remained adhered to the skin surface and maintained its attachment even after repeated arm movements. This observation demonstrates that the TA/κ-CRG gel exhibits strong adhesion not only on rigid substrates but also on compliant biological surfaces such as skin.
To quantitatively evaluate this adhesion behavior, lap shear tests were performed using sandpaper (P100) as the adherend substrate (
Figure 5c). The shear strengths of native κ-CRG, pyrogallol/κ-CRG, and TA/κ-CRG gels were 3.4 ± 0.7, 2.2 ± 0.3, and 28.1 ± 5.0 kPa, respectively. Consistent with the qualitative adhesion results, TA/κ-CRG exhibited markedly higher adhesion strength than either native κ-CRG (~3.4 kPa) or pyrogallol/κ-CRG (~2.2 kPa). Inspection of the sandpaper surfaces after lap shear tests further revealed distinct failure modes (
Figure A2). Native κ-CRG and pyrogallol/κ-CRG primarily exhibited adhesive failure at the gel–sandpaper interface, whereas TA/κ-CRG showed cohesive failure within the gel layer due to the aforementioned strong adhesion.
The origin of this adhesion can be attributed to the multivalent nature of TA. Even after forming the gel network with κ-CRG chains, a fraction of galloyl groups may remain exposed at the network surface. These exposed galloyl groups can interact with opposing surfaces through multipoint non-covalent interactions, thereby promoting stable interfacial adhesion. Such multivalent interfacial interactions allow the gel to maintain stable adhesion even under mechanical perturbations [
27]. The large increase in lap shear adhesion strength observed for TA/κ-CRG is consistent with this interpretation and further supports that TA-mediated multivalent interactions operate not only within the bulk gel network but also at the gel–substrate interface. This behavior is consistent with the dynamic supramolecular network characteristics of TA-mediated junctions discussed in
Figure 3 and
Figure 4.
The observed interfacial adhesion also suggests potential applications of TA/κ-CRG gels. When fabricated as thin sheets, the gels can form conformal coatings that adhere closely to skin surfaces. Through polyphenol-based interactions, the gels may effectively interact with biological macromolecules such as keratin in the stratum corneum. On this basis, the gels could potentially be utilized as exfoliating sheets that adhere to the skin surface (
Figure 5d). In particular, the well-known protein affinity of TA [
28] suggests that interactions with keratin may facilitate the removal of dead skin cells during sheet detachment. From a translational perspective, the TA content in skin-contacting κ-CRG gels should be selected by balancing interfacial adhesion and functional performance against possible irritation risk and cytocompatibility limitations, because tissue responses to TA can depend strongly on dose, formulation composition, and exposure conditions [
29]. Although TA has been widely explored in skin-interfacing hydrogels owing to its polyphenol-mediated adhesion and additional antioxidant, antibacterial, and anti-inflammatory functions, these beneficial properties do not eliminate the need for careful dose optimization in topical formulations [
15,
28,
30]. Prior dermatological literature has reported contact reactivity to topical tannic acid, with patch-test positivity observed at concentrations as low as 0.25% (aq.) in susceptible cases [
30]. At the same time, the biological response to TA is likely formulation-dependent, and TA embedded within a polymeric network may behave differently from free TA applied directly to skin. Therefore, further studies will be required to define an appropriate TA dose window that preserves adhesion while minimizing barrier perturbation and irritation, ideally through standardized cytocompatibility assays, reconstructed epidermis or barrier-function testing, and human patch testing before biomedical or cosmetic translation.
In perspective of the context of existing κ-CRG reinforcement strategies, the present results show that polyphenol-mediated modulation of κ-CRG gels differs in character from conventional strategies used to control carrageenan gel networks. Existing approaches often rely on ion-mediated stabilization, such as K
+- or Ca
2+-assisted helix aggregation and junction-zone stabilization [
31,
32], or on polymer-based reinforcement through blending with additional polymers such as PVA, double-network design, or formation of an additional polymer-supported matrix [
9,
10,
11]. By contrast, the present gelation strategies utilize small molecule polyphenols (pyrogallol = 126.1 Da and TA = 1701.2 Da) as new additives to form sulfate–polyphenol–sulfate bridges keeping the inherent helical domains intact [
16]. Thus, the binding mode differences between K
+ and TA are allowed synergistic mechanical benefits in case of simultaneous addition of K
+ and TA. Upon the addition of potassium ion, the storage modulus of the κ-CRG gel was increased from 393.8 ± 81.6 to 1503.2 ± 156.1 Pa, which is similar to that of the TA/κ-CRG gel (1387.2 ± 12.7 Pa). Notably, additions of both TA (5%) + K
+ (30 mM) exhibited further increase (2366.1 ± 189.4 Pa) (
Figure A3). This result indicates that TA-mediated modulation should be viewed not simply as another reinforcement additive, but as a distinct route for controlling the structure–property relationships of κ-CRG hydrogels.