1. Introduction
Imaging spectroscopy in the visible and near-infrared spectral regions is considered an important technique for monitoring and understanding coastal ocean processes such as mapping phytoplankton distributions and seagrass leaf area indices, as well as monitoring algal blooms and coral health [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5]. Compared with traditional remote sensing imaging technology, hyperspectral imaging technology can obtain high-resolution images while also obtaining narrowband spectral information and can recognize the unique absorption and reflection characteristics caused by the physical properties of target materials through fine spectral segmentation features.
With continuous improvements in aerospace technology, low-cost commercial spectral imaging remote sensing satellites have experienced explosive growth and development. With the introduction of space concepts such as satellite-chain plans, satellite clusters, and constellation networking, more stringent requirements have been initiated for the cost, volume, weight, reliability, and instrument performance of spectral imaging space-based payloads. In addition, to reduce costs further, many commercial satellites have eliminated mechanical vibration, thermal vacuum, thermal equilibrium, and electromagnetic compatibility tests at the component level for spectral imaging instruments through whole-satellite testing verification. Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop a mature, reliable, and advanced spectral imaging system to develop low-cost, high-performance optical space-based payloads that can be easily promoted to the vast commercial satellite market.
At present, mature spectral imaging technology systems provide filter dispersion, interference, curved prism dispersion, and grating dispersion. Filter dispersion spectral imaging technology uses filters for spectral band-selective imaging, which has the drawback of being unable to simultaneously image multiple channels. It is mainly used for multispectral imaging [
6]. Interferometric spectral imaging technology uses an interferometer to obtain the interference fringe information of the detection target, which requires spectral restoration to obtain the original spectral data. It has high requirements for the stability and accuracy of the platform and post-image processing [
7]. Curved prism dispersion spectral imaging technology uses curved prisms as spectral elements, which are expensive, difficult to process, require high precision, have long processing cycles, and are difficult to assemble and adjust. However, this optical system has high transmittance, so it is mainly used for military reconnaissance applications [
8,
9]. Grating dispersion spectral imaging technology can use mature commercial grating products as spectral components, making it easy to develop low-cost and short-term hyperspectral imaging instruments. In summary, the prism dispersion has the problems of high optical processing difficulty and high cost. The various types of filter dispersion have the defect of time-division imaging. The Fourier transform-based interferometric imaging technology has the disadvantage of difficult spectral data restoration and high platform stability requirements. The grating dispersion can be utilized in optical system design using commercial grating products, significantly reducing development costs and shortening development cycles. It is the most suitable hyperspectral imaging technology system for commercial satellites [
10]. We propose an innovative Dyson hyperspectral imager based on concave grating dispersion [
11].
The Dyson spectral imaging system has the advantages of optical path multiplexing, compact structure, and lightweight design. In addition, it also has excellent full-spectrum aberration correction ability, with low distortion and easy implementation of a large relative aperture. In 1959, Dyson first proposed that a simple concentric arrangement of a plano-convex lens and concave mirror would be free of all Seidel aberrations at the design wavelength and center of a field imaged at 1:1 magnification [
12]. In the Dyson prototype, the detector image plane and the slit plane are located on the same side of the plano-convex lens, and both coincide. There are two main issues in the prototype of the Dyson structure for engineering implementation. First, the optical window packaging of the detector results in the photosensitive surface of the detector being unable to adhere tightly to the surface of the plano-convex lens. Second, the packaging of the detector structure and circuit board makes the external dimensions of the camera much larger than the size of the detector target surface. However, in the prototype of the Dyson structure, the distance between the target surface and the slit is only a few millimeters, which makes it impossible to achieve spatial arrangements of the camera component, slit component, and front telescope objective component.
To implement the Dyson prototype structure, Pantazis Mouroulis proposed a design approach using glued prisms and fiber optics [
13]. This design can alleviate the spatial distribution problem of telescope objective components and detector components, but the spatial allocation of mirrors, fiber optics, and detectors is still insufficient, and the system is complex. David W. Warren proposed the introduction of a meniscus lens, which allows the surfaces of objects and images to be appropriately pulled out of the surface of the plano-convex lens and adds a small reflector behind the slit surface [
14]. This solution significantly improves the spatial layout of the Dyson prototype structure, but because the object surface and image surface are still on the same side of the plano-convex lens, the installation and adjustment of the optomechanical structure are difficult in a tight engineering layout. Pantazis Mouroulis also proposed a similar design form, which uses mirrors to bend the slit and telescope objective light path at an angle to adjust the spatial position distribution of the detector and telescope objective [
15]. However, there is still the problem of an insufficient spatial layout of the mirrors and detectors. Pantazis Mouroulis [
16] and William R. Johnson [
17] subsequently proposed another design form, which involved designing Dyson prisms as irregular parts and processing reflective surfaces to bend the optical path, thereby separating the image plane from the object plane. However, the above two design forms introduce the problem of irregular prism processing. The proposed Dyson prism has an irregular convex surface at the incident end of the object surface. The internal reflection surface of the Dyson prism and the edge of the light exit surface in front of the image face both have corners, which cannot be machined and polished. Moreover, ensuring the flatness and smoothness of the surface near the corner is difficult, resulting in high processing costs and a low yield of Dyson prisms. In addition, the correction mirror group and concave grating behind the Dyson prism are not coaxial optical systems, making instrument installation and adjustment difficult.
On the basis of the above shortcomings and deficiencies, an advanced Dyson hyperspectral imaging technique is proposed, in which all surfaces of the Dyson prism are convex flat surfaces without small convex platforms, eliminating all edge corners of the transmission and reflection surfaces. The incident surface and exit surface of the prism are perpendicular, and the reflective surface maintains a standard angle of 45° with the incident and exit surfaces. It is easy to process and has a simple coating process. The system is a coaxial optical system that is easy to fabricate and test and can be mass-produced at a low cost. On the basis of the above technology, we completed the development of a series of products in
Section 5, which we applied to aerospace, aviation, and ground use.
The organization of the paper is as follows:
Section 2 describes the optical design and analysis of the advanced Dyson spectrometer. The fabrication and alignment of the instrument are introduced in
Section 3. In
Section 4, the performance assessment of the imaging spectrometer is described in detail.
Section 5 provides the promotion and application of serialized products via this technique. Finally, the discussion and conclusions of the study are presented in
Section 6 and
Section 7, respectively.
2. Optical Design and Analysis of the Spectrometer
2.1. Imaging Characteristics Analysis of the Dyson Imaging Structure (DIS)
The DIS consists of a plano-convex thick lens and a concave mirror. The radii of the convex surface of the plano-convex lens and the concave surface of the concave mirror are
r and
R, respectively. These two surfaces share a common center
C, as shown in
Figure 1a. The concave reflector serves as the system aperture and is located on the focal plane of the plano-convex thick lens.
The radius of a concave mirror,
R, can be calculated as
If the object point is located at the common center of the DIS, the light will pass through the center of the sphere without deviation, and the system’s spherical aberration will be zero. If the object point is not located at the center of the sphere, but the system satisfies the sine condition, the coma is zero. Compared with the aperture (i.e., concave mirror), the distortion of the DIS is zero because of the rotational symmetry of the front and rear optical paths. Under the near-axial condition of the DIS, the Petzval sum can be expressed as
By substituting Equation (1) into Equation (2), the Petzval sum of the DIS can be obtained:
The field curvature of the DIS under near-axial conditions is zero. Since any object point in the DIS is imaged on a straight line passing through the object point and point C, the sagittal field curvature on the image plane is zero. Moreover, the Petzval curvature of the DIS is also zero, which implies that the meridian field curvature is also zero. Therefore, the DIS does not exhibit astigmatism.
However, there are high-order aberrations in the nonparaxial optical path of the DIS. The Petzval curvature of the DIS is not zero, and the sagittal field curvature on the image plane is zero. Therefore, the main aberration of the DIS is the meridian field curve. The DIS does not produce an axial aberration, coma or sagittal field curve, and the distortion is related only to the absorption of different light waves by the medium in the object space and image space. However, the DIS has a meridian field curve, and the meridian field curve can be corrected via optimization [
18].
There is a deviation angle between the incident light and the outgoing light in the nonparaxial optical path of the DIS, as shown in
Figure 1b. The deviation distance between the actual position of the light emitted from the rear surface of the thick lens and the ideal position,
dx, can be expressed as
where P is the object point, P′ is the image point, L is the distance from the common spherical center C to the incident light and the outgoing light, and n is the refractive index of the lens.
The distance between the ideal image plane and the real image plane, s, can be expressed as
The above formula shows that the influence of the field of view on the image plane offset is much greater than that of the aperture angle. Therefore, the DIS can achieve high-quality imaging under a large aperture angle.
2.2. Aberration Characteristic Analysis of the Dyson Spectrometer
The Dyson spectrometer is a concentric optical structure, with the grating surface serving as the system aperture. The analysis of its aberration characteristics is based on the wavefront aberration model of the concentric optical system and introduces the influence of dispersion gratings, as shown in
Figure 2. The coordinate system is established in the Dyson spectrometer with the common center C of the surface as the coordinate origin. XCY is the object plane and the image plane, with the
z-axis perpendicular to the XCY plane and along the optical axis direction. O (x1, y1) is the object point, and I (x2, y2) is the image point of O. R is the curvature radius of the grating. Pg is the center of the grating and is located on the
z-axis. The direction of the grating lines is parallel to the
x-axis. Qg (X, Y) is any point on the surface of the grating. Ig is the vertical distance from Qg to the optical axis.
According to Hamilton’s wavefront aberration theory, the sum of the optical path difference (OPD) in concentric optical systems can be expressed by the following formula:
The OPD introduced by concave grating can be expressed as [
18]
where N (X, Y) represents the difference in the number of grating lines at points Pg and Qg. M is the diffraction order, and λ is the selected wavelength.
Therefore, the wavefront aberration at image point I of the Dyson spectrometer is the sum of the OPD of the concentric optical system and the OPD introduced by the grating:
The above equation reflects the difference between the actual wavefront and the ideal wavefront of light with a wavelength of λ emitted from point O, passing through a point Qg on the grating, and reaching the image plane. Because the concentric spectral imaging system is a dual telecentric system, both the object space and the image space are plane waves. The pupil wavefront aberration generated by the light passing from the object space to the grating is represented as , and the pupil wavefront aberration generated by the light passing through the grating to the image space is represented as .
Assuming that the light emitted from the center Pg of the grating toward point O passes through a series of concentric spheres and media as a plane wave perpendicular to the optical axis to reach point O, according to the Hamilton function and the axial symmetry of the concentric system, the wavefront aberration generated by the light reaching point O is a function of the distance between point O and center C:
Assuming that the light emitted from the off-axis point Qg on the grating to point O passes through a series of concentric spheres and media as a nearly plane wave to reach point O, and that the angle between the reference wave of the object plane and the object space is θ, then
The numerical aperture of the system in the object space is
. Moreover, the angle between the reference wave in the object space and CO is assumed to be
θ1. The distance between the reference wave from point Qg to point O and center point C of the system when it intersects is d
1sin
θ. According to the characteristics of concentric optical systems, the wavefront aberration at point O becomes
.
The following relationships exist in concentric optical systems:
Rewriting Equations (13) and (14) yields
By the same principle, the wavefront aberration generated from point Qg and point Pg to point I can be calculated as follows:
where θ2 is the angle between the wave emitted from point Qg and the CI when it passes through a series of optical surfaces and media between Qg and I and reaches the image space.
In summary, in the Dyson spectrometer, the wavefront aberration generated by the light wave emitted from point O to its corresponding image point I is as follows:
where W0 is the inherent wave aberration of a concentric optical system, which contains only aberration terms above the second power and can be ignored.
From the triangle relationship and the grating equation, the following conclusions can be drawn:
By substituting Equation (16) into Equation (15), we can obtain
The relationship is the wave aberration result of the Dyson spectrometer. As seen from the above equation, the variation in the wavefront aberration in the Dyson spectrometer is related to the line density of the spherical grating, diffraction order, and diffraction wavelength. When the grating has equidistant parallel grooves, no additional wavefront aberration is introduced. The addition of a Rowland grating to the Dyson spectrometer still results in concentricity, giving it a significant advantage in terms of aberration control. However, because the diffraction grating diffracts light of different wavelengths at different positions, the system loses the symmetry of the diffraction direction, which will cause certain astigmatisms at different wavelength positions. This astigmatism can be optimized by changing the radius of the convex surface of the flat convex thick lens and adjusting the distance between the thick lens and the grating appropriately. Owing to the presence of the refracted lens, the system produces color differences. Two materials can be glued together, or a crescent lens can be added to correct the color difference.
2.3. Initial Parameter Calculation of the Dyson Spectrometer
To effectively control the astigmatism of the Dyson spectrometer, a design method for dual-wavelength astigmatic imaging at the longest and shortest wavelengths in the working wavelength range was proposed [
19].
An imaging schematic diagram of the principal ray diffraction path at any wavelength in the sagittal and meridional planes is shown in
Figure 3. If the system can achieve ideal imaging, the sagittal image point should coincide with the meridional image point, and the astigmatism should be zero, that is, δ = 0.
From the direct relationship between the angles in the figure, the following can be seen:
According to the triangular sine theorem and Snell’s law,
By substituting Equation (19) into the grating equation, we can obtain
When the stigmatic condition δ = 0 is satisfied,
:
By inverting and squaring the numerator and denominator of the above formula, it can be rewritten as
According to the Taylor expansion of the grating equation, we can obtain
By substituting Equation (23) into Equation (22), we can obtain
Take two wavelengths λa and λb as the stigmatic wavelengths, input them into the above equation and subtract them to obtain the stigmatic parameters at the two wavelengths. When the diffraction order m = 1, the dual-wavelength stigmatic equation can be formulated as
where na and nb are the refractive indices of wavelengths λa and λb, respectively. The above formula can be used to calculate the grating constant when two wavelengths are stigmatic. Furthermore, the grating constant can be calculated on the basis of the spectral broadening at the image plane via Equation (26).
Through the above derivation, the optical imaging characteristics of the Dyson structure and the aberration characteristics of the Dyson spectrometer were systematically analyzed, and it was found that the Seidel aberration of the Dyson structure was zero and that the grating with equal density did not introduce additional aberrations. Furthermore, the formula derivation of the initial structural parameters of the Dyson spectrometer was completed. Under the condition of considering astigmatism, we then utilized ZEMAX 2019 to determine the distribution of the power to suppress spherical aberrations and chromatic aberrations to further optimize the Dyson spectrometer on the basis of the above analysis.
2.4. Optical Design Results of the Advanced Dyson Spectrometer (ADS)
The optical design was analyzed to confirm its imaging performance and is presented in
Figure 4. The ADS can be divided into a telescope subassembly and spectral subassembly. The telescope subassembly is a transmissive coaxial lens that uses three materials: CAF2, H-LAK2A, and TF3. The slit uses optical etching and chrome plating technology. An optical filter is designed in front of the slit to prevent excess objects from falling on the slit and to cut off the spectral range in the serialized products (in
Section 5).
The spectral subassembly consists of 5 optical elements, including a modified Dyson prism, three correction lenses and a concave grating. The modified Dyson prism differs from all Dyson prisms proposed in previous studies. The incident surface and exit surface of the modified Dyson prism are perpendicular, whereas the reflective surface maintains a standard angle of 45° with both the incident and exit surfaces, greatly reducing the difficulty of fabrication and alignment. The material of the modified Dyson prism is silica, and the refractive index n is 1.456. The optimized parameters of the ADS are shown in
Table 1.
Figure 5 shows the simulation and analysis of the full-field MTF of an ADS with different wavelengths. The simulations revealed that the minimum MTF of the ADS was 0.82 at 36.5 lp/mm. The spot diagram in
Figure 6 shows the spatial resolution of the imaging system, with significant differences found for different FOVs of the ADS under different wavelengths. The average root-mean-square (RMS) diameter was ~8.5 μm, which was much smaller than the pixel size. To ensure that the optical imaging system has good imaging quality, the spectral distortion of the ADS is analyzed, and the results are shown in
Figure 7. The maximum spectral smile distortion and keystone distortion were less than 0.20 pixels in the effective FOV. These results demonstrate that the proposed ADS would exhibit excellent imaging performance.
5. Promotion and Application of Serialized Products
Based on the ADS proposed in this article, different spatial resolutions can be achieved by changing the design of a telescope subassembly, and the transmission bandwidth of the filter in front of the slit can be changed to achieve spectral band selection in the range of 400–1000 nm. The spectral resolution of the instrument can be changed by changing the number of merged pixels in the spectral dimension of the detector. By implementing the above adjustments, it is easy to achieve customized designs of spectral imaging instruments to meet the needs of different application scenarios.
To further validate the ADS technology, we developed a space-based imaging spectrometer, a ground-based imaging spectrometer, and an airborne imaging spectrometer (
Figure 19). All three imaging spectrometers have completed alignment, performance testing, and data application, achieving excellent imaging performance. The detailed design of these three instruments will be described in subsequent articles. A detailed comparison of the technical specifications of the four spectral instruments proposed in this article is shown in
Table 3.
Through the development of the abovementioned instruments, it has been verified that ADS technology can achieve excellent spectral imaging performance, can offer lightweight and compact designs, and is easy to mount on various aviation and aerospace platforms. In addition, the core dispersion element of the system uses commercial grating products from Jobin Yvon, which have the advantages of low cost and are easy to mass-produce.
6. Discussion
The ADS utilized the Dyson spectrometer with optical path multiplexing based on concave grating dispersion elements. We provided a detailed discussion on the proposed ADS from several aspects, including optical principles, optical design, structural design, adaptability analysis of on-board environment, integration and alignment, and performance testing. The ADS achieved spectral detection with a maximum width of 400–1000 nm, a minimum spectral resolution of 2.86 nm and a F-number of 2.2. The minimum spectral distortion could reach 0.1 pixels, with excellent spectral performance and an accuracy of 2.04% compared to standard radiometer measurements. Our core innovation lies in improving the design configuration of the Dyson prism, which significantly enhances system performance and reduces development difficulty. The ADS we designed completed on-board application and verification, and had good imaging quality.
The well-known and typical spectral imaging instruments mainly included the Portable Hyper-spectral Image for Low-Light Spectroscopy (PHILLS) [
20], Portable Remote Imaging Spectrometer (PRISM) [
15] and Advanced airborne hyperspectral imaging system (AAHIS) [
21]. A comparison between the published works and our ADS has been presented in
Table 4. The core advantage of the ADS lies in its high spectral resolution while maintaining consistent performance indicators. It was developed using commercial gratings and had low development costs.