Targeted Myocardial Restoration with Injectable Hydrogels—In Search of The Holy Grail in Regenerating Damaged Heart Tissue
, Michał Kuzemczak 2,3,†, Engracia Loh 1, Wellington Wu 1 and Theo Kofidis 1,4,*Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The review paper " Targeted Myocardial restoration with Injectable Hydrogels - In Search of the Holy Grail in Regenerating Damaged Heart Tissue" is a well written paper, that is really fun to read. I did not find any flaws and this review should definitvely published although I personally am not convinced that the hydrogels make the impossible possible, but they may be one cobblestone to myocardial regeneration of the infarcted myocardial tissue.
Minor: ther eis one typing error in line 216 on page 7: spell "because" instead of "beacause"
Author Response
Dear Reviewer
Thank you for your comment. We appreciate the positive response.
We have corrected the spelling error in page 7.
Reviewer 2 Report
The manuscript titled, "Targeted Myocardial Restoration with Injectable Hydrogels - In Search of The Holy Grail in Regenerating Damaged Heart Tissue" includes a review on studies about hydrogel based myocardial recovery trial. Authors searched the relevant articles about myocardiac regeneration through interventional approach and summarized the scientific meanings.
The manuscript is qualified for translating scientific achievements to the readers and recommended to be published as it is with minor revision on typos.
Minor points;
line 136: compund=> compound
line 274: protocls=> protocols
List of abbreviations:
- CACs, hUMSC, AGHM, bFGF ... appears more than twice
- recommend to be rearranged in alphabetical order
Author Response
Dear Reviewer
We appreciate your kind comments. Apologies for the typos. We have corrected the error in revised version. Additionally, the list of abbreviation are reorganized as advised.
