Next Article in Journal
Developing Gridded Climate Data Sets of Precipitation for Greece Based on Homogenized Time Series
Previous Article in Journal
A Climatology of Atmospheric Patterns Associated with Red River Valley Blizzards
Article Menu
Issue 5 (May) cover image

Export Article

Open AccessComment

Climatization—Negligent Attribution of Great Salt Lake Desiccation: A Comment on Meng (2019)

Geomorphology and Fluvial Research Group, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer Sheva 8410501, Israel
Department of Watershed Sciences & Ecology Center, Utah State University, Logan, UT 84322, USA
Rocky Mountain Research Station, US Forest Service, Ogden, UT 84401, USA
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Climate 2019, 7(5), 67;
Received: 29 March 2019 / Revised: 8 May 2019 / Accepted: 11 May 2019 / Published: 14 May 2019
PDF [2480 KB, uploaded 14 May 2019]


A recent article reviewed data on Great Salt Lake (Utah) and concluded falsely that climate changes, especially local warming and extreme precipitation events, are primarily responsible for lake elevation changes. Indeed climatically influenced variation of net inflows contribute to huge swings in the elevation of Great Salt Lake (GSL) and other endorheic lakes. Although droughts and wet cycles have caused lake elevation changes of over 4.5 m, they have not caused a significant long-term change in the GSL stage. This recent article also suggests that a 1.4 °C rise in air temperature and concomitant increase in the lake’s evaporative loss is an important reason for the lake’s decline. However, we calculate that a 1.4 °C rise may have caused only a 0.1 m decrease in lake level. However, since 1847, the lake has declined 3.6 m and the lake area has decreased by ≈50%, despite no significant change in precipitation (p = 0.52) and a slight increase, albeit insignificant, in river flows above irrigation diversions (p = 0.085). In contrast, persistent water extraction for agriculture and other uses beginning in 1847 now decrease water flows below diversions by 39%. Estimates of consumptive water use primarily for irrigated agriculture in the GSL watershed suggest that approximately 85% (2500 km2) of the reduced lake area can be attributed to human water consumption. The recent article’s failure to calculate a water budget for the lake that included extensive water withdrawals misled the author to focus instead on climate change as a causal factor for the decline. Stable stream flows in GSL’s headwaters, inadequate temperature increase to explain the extent of its observed desiccation, stable long-term precipitation, and the magnitude of increased water consumption from GSL together demonstrate conclusively that climatic factors are secondary to human alterations to GSL and its watershed. Climatization, in which primarily non-climatic processes are falsely attributed to climatic factors, is a threat to the credibility of hydrological science. Despite a recent suggestion to the contrary, pressure to support Earth’s rising human population—in the form of increasing consumption of water in water-limited regions, primarily to support irrigated agriculture—remains the leading driver of desiccation of inland waters within Earth’s water-limited regions. View Full-Text
Keywords: Aral Sea Syndrome; Anthropocene; agriculture; water balance; saline lake; global change Aral Sea Syndrome; Anthropocene; agriculture; water balance; saline lake; global change

Figure 1

This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited (CC BY 4.0).

Share & Cite This Article

MDPI and ACS Style

Wine, M.L.; Null, S.E.; DeRose, R.J.; Wurtsbaugh, W.A. Climatization—Negligent Attribution of Great Salt Lake Desiccation: A Comment on Meng (2019). Climate 2019, 7, 67.

Show more citation formats Show less citations formats

Note that from the first issue of 2016, MDPI journals use article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Related Articles

Article Metrics

Article Access Statistics



[Return to top]
Climate EISSN 2225-1154 Published by MDPI AG, Basel, Switzerland RSS E-Mail Table of Contents Alert
Back to Top