1. Introduction
One of the most challenging questions in astrophysics is the mismatch between the measurements of the velocities of stars in galaxies, and the predictions for galaxy rotation curves from the standard general theory of relativity. This question led the astrophysicists arguing about the existence of dark matter. Other theorists instead have tried to modify General Relativity (GR) or the Newtonian laws. The most prevailing belief is that for explaining the galaxy rotation curves, the galaxy has to be soaked in a dark matter halo [
1,
2,
3]. Regardless of this question, a theoretical spherically symmetric solution for GR, called a wormhole, where two different universes can be causally connected through a “wormhole throat” and where a physical traveller can go in principle from one universe to the other and be observed doing this from an observer located in one of the universes, gives a concept of a non-trivial topological structure linking separate points in space-time [
4,
5,
6,
7]. This property of the space-time is different from black holes solutions, which may also connect two universes, but possess event horizons, so that the trajectory of the traveller cannot be followed by an external observer beyond the point where the observer crosses the horizon.
The existence of a multi universe, each of them with different vacuum energy density, has been widely discussed in both string theory and in inflationary cosmology. One possibility is that these universes were initially connected in the early stages of evolution but are now totally disconnected. Another possibility that appears more interesting is that some of these universes are now still connected through a wormhole and may be this connection leads to observable consequences. In this letter, we propose a modified theory of gravity, which for spherically symmetric solutions produces asymmetric wormholes. The asymmetry is a consequence of the fact that in our case the wormholes connect universes with different vacuum energy densities, and therefore are necessarily asymmetric. For large distances the solution produces gravitational potentials that can be suitable for the explanation of galaxy rotation curves. The parameters that defines the asymmetry of the wormhole hole determine linear gravitational potentials and therefore could provide an explanation for the rotation curves in galaxy halos. It is interesting to note that the possibility that the massive object detected at the centre of our galaxy is a wormhole rather than a black hole has been discussed together with some possible observational consequences related to the effect of this on the geodesics produced by this object [
8]. These effects are indeed even more acute in the case of the solutions discussed in this paper due to the generation of the linear potentials.
1.1. Two-Measures Theory
Many modified theories of gravity have been formulated for explaining phenomena beyond GR. One example is the two-measures theory [
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17] where in addition to the regular measure of integration in the action
, includes another measure of interaction which is also a density volume and a total derivative. In this case, one can use for constructing this measure 4 scalar fields
, where
. Then, we can define the density
, and then we can write an action that uses both of these densities:
As a consequence of the variation with respect to the scalar fields
, assuming that
and
are independent of the scalar fields
, we obtain that
where
. Since
, then for
, (
2) implies that
. This result can be expressed as a covariant conservation of a stress energy momentum of the form
, and using the 2nd order formalism where the covariant derivative of
is zero, we obtain that
implying
. This suggests the idea of generalising the two-measures theory by imposing the covariant conservation of a non-trivial kind of energy-momentum tensor, which we denote as
[
18]. Therefore, we consider an action of the form
where semicolon; denotes covariant derivative,
and
is the dynamical vector field. If we assume
to be independent of
and having
being defined as the Christoffel connection coefficients, then the variation with respect to
gives a covariant conservation:
. A full phenomenology for using these theories is described in [
19,
20].
1.2. Diffusive Energy Theory from Action Principle
Calogero [
21] proved that the diffusion equation in a curved space-time implies a non-conserved stress energy tensor
, which has some current source
:
where
is the diffusion coefficient of the fluid. This generalisation is Lorentz invariant and the current
is a time-like covariantly conserved vector field and its conservation tells us that the number of particles in this fluid is constant. This non-conservative stress energy tensor can emerge from variations in the action (
3), by replacing the dynamical time vector field for a gradient of a scalar field
:
The variation with respect to
gives a covariant conservation of a current
which it is the source of the stress energy-momentum tensor. Equation (
6) has a close correspondence to (
4). By taking variations with respect to
, we obtain 4 equations of motion which correspond to a covariant conservation of the energy-momentum tensor
. By changing the 4 vector to a gradient of a scalar
, we change the conservation of energy-momentum tensor to an asymptotic conservation of energy-momentum tensor (
6) which corresponds to a conservation of a current
. From a variation of the action with respect to the metric, we get a conserved stress energy tensor
:
By considering
being equal to
, the original measure
is modified to a Galileon measure
, and the action (
5) gets the following form
Here if we take variation with respect to the scalar
, the equation of motion gives
. This idea was also used in the context of string theory in [
22,
23].
2. The Action
Let us start with the following two-measure action
where; represents covariant derivative with respect to the Levi-Civita connection and
is a scalar field. The first two terms in the above action represents standard
k-essence theories whereas the last term has another contribution with a different Galilean measure.
Then the variation with respect to the scalar
gives
, which for a cosmological solution leads to an interactive unified DE/DM scenario [
18,
24,
25]. The second term on this action depends on
which is a function of a scalar field
and a kinetic term
that contains any
k-essence theory. If
, the scalar field
represents a canonical scalar field, whereas when
represents a phantom scalar field. The third term in the action (
9) also depends on an energy-momentum tensor
that couples to the vector field and it is assumed to be independent of it. In [
18], the authors studied the specific case where the function
is defined as follows
where
is an energy potential, which in general is different than the potential
. Note that the potentials are coupled with different measures. In [
18], the special case where
was studied.
Variations of the action (
9) with respect to the metric gives us the following field equations
where we have assumed that commas denote differentiation,
and the vector field is equal to the gradient of the scalar field
that appears in the Galileon measure, namely
From a variation with respect to the scalar
we obtain a non-conserved current, which is given by
If we vary the action (
9) with respect to the scalar field
and the vector field
, we respectively get
Here, is the d’Alambertian. In the next section, a spherically symmetric space-time of this model will be introduced in order to then analyse the special case of asymmetric wormholes.
4. Centre of Gravity Coordinates
The wormhole has two special radii. The first one is the neck, where
is a minimum, and from (
28) we obtain that the radial coordinate for this is
. The second one is the centre of gravity radius, or the equilibrium radius, where the Newtonian gravitational force vanishes. In general, when one considers an extended object, one defines a worldline on the basis of the centre of mass, as discussed by Pound [
28]. So here also, for analysing the behaviour with respect to this special location, we have to use the coordinates of the centre of gravity by considering a shift
The coordinates of the centre of mass are a type of collective coordinates used when one is dealing with extended objects, and therefore since a wormhole is an extended object, it is natural to use them. So if the wormhole interacts with another wormhole or with a point particle, the use of coordinates that vanish at the centre of gravity is preferable since the centre of gravity coordinate truly describes the collective motion of the extended object. Then, other coordinate choices will not be so physically correct.
Demanding that for small
,
does not contain linear terms in
and inserting (
35) into (
29), we obtain that the linear term of
is cancelled for the following choice of
,
Now, by expressing the small
limit in terms of the centre of gravity coordinates, we find
where we see that the linear terms are now cancelled. We can see that for positive values of
that the Newtonian potential produces attraction towards the centre of gravity point
for small
, so the radius
is indeed the radius towards where test particles are attracted to. This is therefore the centre of gravity radius. Notice that
, with whatever constant angles we choose, represent a geodesic motion. To ensure that the metric has the correct signature for small
, we require also that
In the case where
, we obtain that the 00 component of the metric becomes,
In the 00 component of the metric, the coefficient of the
term equals to
, where
M is the mass of the wormhole. Therefore one has that
and from Equation (
31) we can get the dependence of the mass in terms of
a and
The linear term of
for large
can be expressed in terms of
M, obtaining,
The coefficient that multiplies
for large
identified the values of the cosmological constant at the two sides of the wormhole. Because of:
The discontinuity of the cosmological constant between the two asymptotic sides of the wormhole is:
A combination of a Newtonian potential with linear
and inverse of
can provide an explanation for flat rotation curves without introducing dark matter. Moreover, in four different recent studies [
29,
30,
31,
32], the authors found that this combination fits well with 110 different spiral galaxies and also 25 dwarf galaxies. Furthermore, there is only one free parameter for each galaxy, viz., the mass to light ratio of each galaxy, and yet with no flexibility the fit capture the essence of the data. Hence, invoking the presence of dark matter may be nothing more than an attempt to describe global effects in purely local galactic terms. On the contrary, the standard NFW profile or other dark matter profiles have more parameters for each galaxy. In order fit the same 138 galaxies data studied in [
30] as fitting parameters, one needs two additional free parameters for each galactic halo. This gives us 276 free parameters to fit for a dark matter profile approach. Thus, these kinds of potentials are physically very well motivated and describe galaxy rotation curves in good agreement with observations. An interesting point arises here. The wormhole parameters
a,
and
b appear in the constants which are related to the flat rotation curves described in [
30,
33]. Thus, the asymmetric wormhole is acting as a trigger of a dark matter behaviour. Notice that the linear term in the Newtonian potential
is proportional to the mass of the wormhole
M. For positive values of
we obtain that the Newtonian potential produces an attractive force. Notice that using the coordinates of the centre of gravity
, the linear term and the
term are both proportional to the mass
M, as is the discontinuity in the cosmological constant across the wormhole. So the mass appears as the source of gravitational attraction, at both large and small distances. As well us being the source of the discontinuity of the cosmological constant across the wormhole.
Notice that the linear potential that appears in (
41) is in fact proportional to
and the mass of the gravitating objects. Since
is connected with the Hubble constant
, we see that there is a connection between the linear potential governing the dark matter sector and the Hubble constant governing the acceleration of the universe. This seems to be related to Milgrom’s idea (MOND) [
34], who advocates a relation between the minimal acceleration
and the Hubble constant
.
This solution and also this interpretation would be also valid for any other k-essence theory. Then, one can say that if ones assumes an asymmetric wormhole geometry, the potential could describe dark matter and dark energy in a unified form.
Let us finish this section by noticing that according to [
29], it was shown that by having linear and inverse potential terms, one can derive from first principles, the Tully-Fisher relation.
5. The Behaviour for the Scalar Potentials
In this section, we will assume a canonical scalar field (
). In order to find solutions for our specific diffusive two measures theory, one needs to impose an additional ansatz since we have more variables than remaining equations. As an example and completeness, let us assume that the scalar field behaves as
Here,
is a constant. Then, by replacing this form into (
22), one can easily find that the potential takes the following form
where
is an integration constant. Now, the scalar field
can be directly solved by using (
18); however, it depends implicitly on
. In order to find
one needs to solve the remaining Equation (
19). This equation is an ordinary first order equation which in principle has a solution but analytically, it can be easily solved. One can then solve that equation numerically to see the behaviour of the potential
. As one can see form
Figure 2, the potential
behaves with well defined asymptotic properties. We present this to show the existence of solutions. A variety of other solutions, starting from an ansatz different than (
44) could be explore also. As it can be seen from Equation (
9), the potential
is coupled with the standard volume measure
and acts like a vacuum energy potential (as can be seen in Equation (
12)). In contrast,
is coupled with the modified volume measure
and gives an equation on how the function
evolves in space-time. In our model,
was easily found analytically but
only was found numerically. Note that these potentials act like matter supporting the wormhole and they are not related to the metric which gives the gravitational potential of the wormhole.
6. Conclusions
In this paper we have explored wormholes solutions in a particular DE/DM unified model described in [
18,
25]. In this case and for asymmetric wormholes, we have found that the asymmetry between the two universes connected through a wormhole induces a linear term in the gravitational potential, and have calculated the coefficient of these linear term in the coordinates of the centre of gravity of the wormhole. These coordinates are expected to be the most suitable ones if we are interested in the collective motion of the wormhole as is the coordinates of the centre of gravity in non-relativistic mechanics. As discussed in [
33], these linear gravitational potentials can be used to explain the behaviour of galactic rotation curves. The idea that the massive object at the centre of our galaxy is a wormhole rather than a black hole has been discussed together with some possible observational consequences related to the effect of this on the geodesics produced by this object, if it is indeed a wormhole [
8]. These effects are indeed even more accurate in the case of the solutions discussed in this paper due to the generation of the linear potentials, which as have argued, could represent effects of dark matter. Let us stress here that even though we focused our study in wormhole geometries, the coefficients of the space-time (
28) and (
29) can also describe black hole solutions with a linear potential. This can be directly seen from
Figure 1 since if Equation (
34) is not valid, the geometry will be a black hole. This happens since
crosses zero showing the horizon at this point. Hence, effectively, the geometry can describe either a wormhole or a black hole in the centre of a galaxy.