1. Introduction
Radionuclide contamination of aquatic ecosystems resulting from nuclear industry operations represents one of the most pressing environmental challenges. Notable examples of significant impacts on the biosphere include the discharge of radioactive waste into the Techa River and Lake Karachay at the Mayak Production Association (PA Mayak) and the Siberian Chemical Combine (SCC) [
1], releases into the North Sea from the Sellafield reprocessing plant, United Kingdom [
2], leakage from storage facilities at the Hanford Site, USA [
3], and incidents at other nuclear installations. A substantial contribution to the radioactive contamination of water bodies has been made by the atmospheric dispersion of radionuclide-bearing aerosols during accident events, most notably the Kyshtym disaster at PA Mayak in 1957 and the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant accident in 1986 as well as nuclear weapons testing. The principal radionuclides contaminating freshwater systems vary depending on the source of contamination and include isotopes of
90Sr,
137Cs,
60Co,
235–238U,
239Pu,
241Am, and others [
4,
5], whereas marine environments are predominantly affected by
90Sr,
137Cs,
144Ce,
91Y,
95Nb,
235–238U,
239Pu and
241Am [
6]. Furthermore, considering their long half-lives and complex speciation under different redox conditions, actinides present in the environment demand particular scrutiny.
It should be noted that the mobility and bioavailability of radionuclides within a water body are governed by a range of parameters, including its hydrological and wind-wave regime, bottom topography, depth, meteorological conditions, physicochemical characteristics (temperature regime, pH, Eh, salinity, etc.), as well as the taxonomic and functional diversity of the biota—most critically the microbial community and lower plants. Apart from phytoplankton and the microbial communities inhabiting bottom sediments, higher aquatic plants and benthic and benthonic organisms—including fish, mollusks, and other fauna—play a significant role in the accumulation of radionuclides in freshwater bodies [
7]. The radioecological hazard posed by radionuclides in aquatic environments is primarily determined by their physicochemical speciation: their chemical form and state in solution (dissolved, as organic or mineral complexes, or associated with colloidal or pseudo-colloidal particles). Under certain conditions, favorable geochemical environments may develop within a water body that promote radionuclide immobilization in bottom sediments. This process proceeds via adsorption onto suspended particulate matter followed by gravitational settling to the sediment layer. Biogenic processes, including photosynthesis (which governs the oxygen regime of the water body), biosorption, biomineralization, bioaccumulation, and radionuclide assimilation by phytoplankton substantially enhance the intensity of self-purification. Phytoplankton, comprising microalgae and cyanobacteria, plays a pivotal role in radionuclide sedimentation, particularly during periods of intense bloom development in the summer season [
8]. Active biomass growth generates a large sorption surface area [
9,
10], facilitating efficient radionuclide removal from the water column upon cell senescence and death. The accumulation of radionuclides by microalgae is further promoted by their capacity to produce phytochelatins—a family of macromolecules bearing diverse functional groups which enable cells to sequester trace elements required for growth or, under adverse conditions, to reduce cytoplasmic concentrations of toxic metals [
11]. However, during seasonal transitions (winter and early spring) and shifts in dissolved oxygen saturation within the water column, radionuclide desorption may occur in shallow water bodies with low biological productivity, resulting in elevated radionuclide concentrations in the aqueous phase [
12,
13,
14].
Thus, high biological productivity of water bodies leading to the formation of substantial organo-mineral bottom sediment layers constitutes an important factor ensuring both the intensity of self-purification and the reliable long-term immobilization of radionuclides within the active sediment layer [
15,
16]. One of the key mechanisms of radionuclide immobilization in bottom sediments is biomineralization, whereby the metabolic activity of anaerobic sulfur-cycling microorganisms promotes the formation of low-solubility precipitates such as pyrrhotite, troilite, and hydrotroilite [
17]. The anaerobic iron-cycling microbial community, in turn, facilitates the formation of oxidized low-solubility ferrous phases, including ferrihydrite and other iron oxyhydroxides, which possess high sorption capacity for a broad range of radionuclides [
18,
19,
20,
21].
Since the primary focus of researchers has been directed toward the behavior of radionuclides in water bodies subject to anthropogenic influence, including those contaminated as a result of accidents or releases from industrial facilities [
22,
23,
24,
25,
26], as well as natural or artificial reservoirs serving as repositories for radioactive waste [
27,
28] the majority of such studies have been conducted on phytoplankton communities and bottom sediments altered by technogenic factors. Investigations of radionuclide behavior in marine ecosystems [
29,
30,
31] and large river systems are subject to considerable limitations owing to the substantial contribution of hydrogeological factors, such as currents and significant water depth, among others. For this reason, studies of small enclosed water bodies of shallow depth that have not been subjected to technogenic impact are of particular importance in radioecological research concerned with the distribution of radionuclides between the aqueous phase and bottom sediments. Work with such systems may yield more detailed information on the role of physicochemical, geochemical, and biogeochemical factors governing radionuclide behavior, and may subsequently serve as a basis for modeling these processes in larger water bodies. A representative example of a dystrophic lake that allows for the assessment of the role of eutrophication in radionuclide behavior is Lake Dryazlo, located in the Nelidovsky District of Tver Oblast, Russia. Currently, no industrial or agricultural activities are conducted in the area surrounding the lake; therefore, it can be regarded as a typical lake for the European part of Russia with minimal anthropogenic impact.
The aim of the present study is to model the accumulation of Sr, U, Pu, and Am by phytoplankton and the bottom sediments derived therefrom, under stimulation with various sources of biophilic elements, using Lake Dryazlo (Tver Oblast) as a model system—a dystrophic water body characterized by comparatively low biological productivity.
4. Discussion
Lake Dryazlo can be characterized as a low-productivity water body with low concentrations of biophilic elements. The dissolved organic matter content during the spring and autumn periods did not exceed 13 mg/L. Nitrogen and phosphorus concentrations were extremely low. The lake is located in an area with minimal anthropogenic impact, which was further confirmed by the absence of detectable technogenic radionuclides in the water and bottom sediments. Accordingly, this lake represents a suitable model object for investigating the behavior of technogenic radionuclides under natural conditions.
During the period of active bloom in summer, when water temperature exceeds 20 °C, biomass accumulation occurs, with dominance of unicellular (fam.
Chlorophyceae,
Chlamydomonas,
Chlorochytrium) and filamentous (fam.
Aphanochaete,
Sirogonium) green algae, diatoms (fam.
Bacillariophyta,
Epithemia), and cyanobacteria (gen.
Aphanizomenon,
Cyanobium), which are typical of freshwater bodies [
41,
42,
43,
44]. This leads to a transient accumulation of organic matter and a decrease in dissolved oxygen concentration to 5.2 mg/L, with dissolved organic matter reaching 22.6 mg/L at peak phytoplankton development. Based on these data, a laboratory experiment was designed to model dystrophic conditions, in which no additional biophilic elements were added to the water samples, and eutrophic conditions, in which nitrogen and phosphorus sources (ammophos) and a sulfur source (sodium sulfate) were introduced.
Assessment of radionuclide concentration reduction in the aqueous phase demonstrated a substantially higher efficiency of radionuclide transfer to bottom sediments compared to experiments conducted in the absence of illumination. The maximum degree of aqueous phase purification from radionuclides was observed under eutrophic conditions, exceeding 98% for actinides and reaching up to 76% for
90Sr. This can be attributed to the interaction of actinides and
90Sr with phytoplankton biomass and subsequent deposition into bottom sediments following cell sedimentation upon cell death, to the effect of stimulating additives, particularly ammophos, and to changes in physicochemical conditions, such as a decrease in dissolved oxygen content. The latter process may promote the development of reducing conditions, facilitating the reduction of U and Pu to sparingly soluble forms [
45]. Following phytoplankton activation, the dominant representatives were the unicellular green alga
Chlamydomonas, the diatom
Epithemia, the filamentous charophyte green alga
Sirogonium, and the cyanobacterium
Cyanobium. It is well established that radionuclide interactions with cells of these organisms may occur via surface sorption as well as intracellular accumulation. The mechanisms of U accumulation by phytoplankton are described in detail in [
46], according to which the U accumulation coefficient for various phytoplankton species ranges from 30–60 to 600–1600. U is sorbed onto the cells themselves and onto their metabolic products, accumulates in the periplasm, and may be reduced by bacterial cells. In [
10], using the cyanobacterium
Arthrospira platensis as a model organism, high uptake and sorption capacity toward
239Pu,
90Sr, and
241Am were demonstrated following the addition of polyphosphates, attributable to biosorption and bioaccumulation processes.
Chlamydomonas sp. isolated from extreme uranium mine tailings exhibited a U uptake capacity of approximately 4.30 mg U g
−1 dry biomass via two possible mechanisms: the dominant pathway was biosorption onto cell walls (ca. 90%), with 10% attributable to bioaccumulation [
47]. Investigation of the role of cell wall components of the freshwater alga
Chara fragilis in U sequestration revealed that coprecipitation of uranyl species with CaCO
3 constitutes the primary binding mechanism, while direct exchange of Ca
2+ with UO
22+ plays a minor role [
48]. Metabolic processes such as photosynthesis, most likely through pH regulation, play a key role in U uptake by algae. In the green alga
Ankistrodesmus sp., U is rapidly captured on the cell surface via complexation with carboxylate, amino, and amide groups, which serve as nucleation sites for the precipitation of insoluble rose-like compreignacite (K
2[(UO
2)
6O
4(OH)
6]·8H
2O). Vogel et al. demonstrated that U removal efficiency by living
Chlorella vulgaris is affected by pH and cell activity [
49]. Diatomaceous algae are among the most promising microorganisms for
90Sr removal from contaminated water bodies owing to their unique silica-based cell walls (frustules) with abundant silanol groups (Si–OH) that serve as binding sites for divalent cations such as Sr
2+ [
50]. Taking into account phytoplankton biomass productivity, over a single growing season, sorption and subsequent transfer to bottom sediments per gram of biomass may be expected to account for 1.89 × 10
4 Bq of
90Sr, 5.41 × 10
4 Bq of
233U, 6.64 × 10
4 Bq of
239Pu, and 4.04 × 10
4 Bq of
241Am. However, the self-purification of the lake water column through phytoplankton development represents only one aspect of the process; the strength of radionuclide binding within bottom sediments is equally important.
Furthermore, the high radionuclide removal efficiency observed under simulated eutrophic conditions may be attributed to the effect of introduced phosphate on the formation of sparingly soluble compounds with
90Sr, U,
241Am, and
239Pu [
51,
52,
53,
54,
55]. The contribution of mineral additives is confirmed by the experiment with sterile water (system 6) supplemented with ammophos and sodium sulfate, in which
90Sr removal efficiency reached 37%, while that of U,
241Am, and
239Pu reached 66%, 54%, and 82%, respectively. Thus, based on the results of a laboratory experiment with the addition of ammophos to sterile water, it has been demonstrated that the mechanism of actinide and strontium mineralization in phosphate phases, described in the studies cited above, may play an important role in freshwater bodies upon the addition of a phosphorus source.
Thermodynamic modeling results indicated that under the studied conditions, both chemical and biogenic mineralization of actinides can be expected to occur. Phosphate addition is predicted to promote the formation of the following actinide phases: AmPO
4(am), autunite, PuO
2(am), PuPO
4(s), as well as Sr
3(PO
4)
2(s) (
Table A7, see
Appendix A). Furthermore, the release of carbon dioxide during the respiration of phytoplankton and microbial communities of bottom sediments may contribute to the formation of sparingly soluble strontium carbonates (strontianite), as well as the inclusion of strontium into minerals of the aragonite group. These processes were described in [
56].
U represents the most redox-sensitive element during eutrophication. As a result of a biogenic reduction in the redox potential of the system due to oxygen consumption, U phases, such as uraninite and mixed U(IV) oxides, exhibited a shift in saturation index (SI) toward the formation of less soluble species under both high- and low-trophic conditions [
57]. Accordingly, under low-trophic conditions without stimulation, the formation of actinide and
90Sr phosphate phases are not predicted. The role of bottom sediment microorganisms in the formation of authigenic mineral phases that facilitate actinide immobilization (sorption and mineralization) is discussed below.
It should be noted that bottom sediments collected from different areas of the lake are heterogeneous in composition: zones with high sand content (sample B1) coexist with zones dominated by clay fractions (sample B2) and zones characterized by organic matter accumulation (sample B3) with localized anaerobic microenvironments and associated sulfide-ferrous mineral phases. Assessment of radionuclide distribution coefficients (K
d) for bottom sediments (
Table 3) revealed substantial differences among samples. Minimum K
d values for all radionuclides were recorded for the loamy sand sample (B1). For the clay-dominated sample, K
d values increased by a factor of 5–7, while the sulfide-organic sediment sample yielded maximum K
d values for U and
239Pu (1300 and 9200 cm
3/g, respectively). Furthermore, assessment of U and
239Pu distribution coefficients for sample B2 following microbial activation showed values comparable to those obtained for sample B3, while the K
d for
241Am exceeded those recorded for sample B3 by nearly a factor of 2. The increase in K
d with increasing clay content can be attributed to
90Sr sorption by a reversible, non-specific cation exchange mechanism on planar surfaces, whereby
90Sr adsorbs as a fully hydrated outer-sphere complex [
58,
59], and to the formation of various surface complexes for actinides. The retention of actinides on clays (montmorillonite) is governed by a multi-site sorption behavior, which includes cation exchange on planar sites and surface complexation (inner-sphere complexation) on edge sites [
60,
61]. Clay minerals such as montmorillonite, illite, and kaolinite exhibit a high affinity for uranyl ions through a combination of distinct physicochemical mechanisms involving specific, variable-charge sites located on the edges of the clay platelets, such as aluminol (≡Al–OH) and silanol (≡Si–OH) groups, to which uranyl binds through the formation of inner-sphere surface complexes [
62].
The increase in K
d for U and
239Pu in sample B3 can be attributed to the reducing properties of sulfide ions [
63] and ferrous minerals under oxidizing conditions, which form iron oxide coatings [
64] that actively immobilize actinides, including
241Am [
65,
66]. The occurrence of redox processes in sample B3 is further supported by the absence of significant differences in
90Sr immobilization between samples B2 and B3, which have comparable clay mineral contents.
Sequential desorption data corroborate the conclusions regarding
90Sr behavior across the three sediment types. The increased contribution of ion-exchangeable fractions in samples B2 and B3 relative to sample B1 correlates with their higher clay content. The acid-soluble fraction may be associated with the formation of calcium and strontium carbonate mineral phases [
67]. For U, the contribution of exchangeable forms increases in sample B2, while in sample B3 the acid-soluble and residual fractions become more prominent. The increase in the acid-soluble fraction can be linked to the role of carbonate minerals, primarily calcite, which is capable of participating in U immobilization, as well as to the contribution of iron-bearing mineral phases. The increase in the residual fraction in sample B3 to 30% may be attributed to the possible microbial reduction of U to sparingly soluble forms. For
239Pu, a similar trend is observed across samples B1–B2–B3, differing from U in that iron-bearing fractions play a dominant role in its immobilization in samples B2 and B3. The contribution of exchangeable forms, e.g., on clay minerals, did not exceed 10–15%. For sample B3, approximately 40% of
239Pu occurs in strongly bound forms, likely associated with its reduction and immobilization within iron-bearing mineral phases [
68,
69,
70]. For
241Am, a similar trend is observed from sample B1 to B3, with a decrease in labile fractions and an increase in exchangeable, acid-soluble, and residual fractions. The residual fractions can be attributed to the presence of iron-bearing minerals, particularly in sample B3, as well as to surface precipitation of Am(OH)
3 on clay mineral surfaces, for example through the formation of polynuclear hydroxide species at high surface loadings, or incorporation into or association with natural organic matter in aggregated forms [
61,
71].
The most pronounced changes were observed for sample B2 following microbial activation. The increases in Kd for U by a factor of 3.7, for
239Pu by a factor of 13, and for
241Am by a factor of 2 can be explained by both chemical and biogeochemical factors. Chemical factors include the formation of phosphate complexes described above, as well as intracellular phosphate accumulation. In our previous studies using the cyanobacterium
Arthrospira as a model organism, it was demonstrated that accumulation of intracellular polyphosphates can significantly enhance the immobilization of actinides and
90Sr [
10]. The increase in
90Sr accumulation may be related to the expansion of carbonate phases formed through microbial carbon oxidation.
The role of phosphate phases was demonstrated by microanalysis of the precipitate. In all experiments, the formation of calcium-bearing phases was detected (points 1, 3, 4, 7, 10) upon calcite precipitation driven by microbial respiration and CO
2 release. At points 1 and 7, U, Ca, and O were detected; the co-localization of these elements may indicate partial substitution of Ca
2+ by uranyl ions in the calcite crystal lattice or uranyl adsorption onto the mineral surface. In experiments with
90Sr addition, co-accumulation of Sr, Ca, and O was recorded (points 3, 4, 10), consistent with the precipitation of strontianite (SrCO
3) or isomorphous substitution of Ca
2+ by Sr
2+ in the calcite crystal lattice, yielding a solid solution. In experiments involving the addition of phosphorus and sulfur sources (
Figure 10C,D), co-accumulation of P and Ca was detected in addition to calcites (points 6, 9), indicating the formation of calcium phosphate phases. The presence of U and
90Sr at these points suggests their co-precipitation with calcium phosphate through incorporation into the crystal lattice, as well as the possible formation of discrete mineral phases such as autunite (hydrated calcium uranyl phosphate) or calcium-strontium phosphate.
Sequential desorption data for sample B2-2 * indicate an increased contribution of the exchangeable and residual fractions for
90Sr, likely associated with the formation of strontium phosphate phases or the incorporation of
90Sr into iron-bearing phases, for example through inclusion in the structure of biogenic siderite (FeCO
3) formed during microbial reduction of Fe(III) hydroxides, as well as possible association of
90Sr with sulfide minerals (pyrite). For U and other actinides, the most significant changes in desorption mechanisms were observed, manifested as an increase in the acid-soluble and residual fractions. The increase in the residual fraction can be attributed to microbial reduction of U to sparingly soluble forms, which has been described in considerable detail in the literature [
72,
73,
74,
75].
The increase in the acid-soluble fraction can be explained primarily by the formation of biogenic iron-bearing mineral phases, arising from the dissolution of pre-existing iron minerals and their redeposition in new forms, in particular sulfide-ferrous phases produced by sulfate-reducing bacteria. Scanning electron microscopy analysis at point 8 revealed co-accumulation of Fe and S, which, given the development of reducing conditions through microbial activity and the low oxygen content at this point, is indicative of iron sulfide formation in the precipitate. This phase may play a significant role in U immobilization, as iron sulfide particles are capable of reducing U(VI) to U(IV), leading to the formation of uraninite. In addition, the formation of freshly precipitated iron hydroxide phases promotes actinide sorption [
76].
The transformation of potential iron-bearing phases under conditions of varying trophic status is presented in
Table A7 Saturation index values for calcite indicate that its precipitation is more likely under high-trophic than under low-trophic conditions. The formation of Fe(III) hydroxides in bottom sediments is thermodynamically unfavorable; however, other iron mineral phases—goethite, hematite, and magnetite—are predicted to form under all conditions considered. Under high-trophic conditions, the formation of sulfide-ferrous mineral phases (troilite, pyrrhotite) is thermodynamically more favorable.
Analysis of the microbial community of bottom sediments following microbial activation of sample B2 revealed an increased contribution of iron-reducing microorganisms, including representatives of the genera
Pseudomonas,
Comamonas, and
Geobacter, as well as bacteria involved in reductive and oxidative processes of the sulfur cycle, including representatives of the genera
Desulfatiglans,
Thiobacillus,
Desulfobulbus,
Sulfurifustis, Sulfuritalea,
Sulfurisoma, and
Desulfovibrio [
77,
78,
79,
80].
Considering the lake system as a whole, the microbial communities of the three geochemically distinct sediment samples exhibited broadly similar taxonomic compositions (
Figure 11), dominated by aerobic and anaerobic organotrophic bacteria capable of participating in iron–manganese cycles (
Gaiella,
Pseudomonas,
Hyphomicrobium,
Leptolinea,
Methylocystis,
Rhodobacter), sulfur cycles (
Desulfobacca,
Desulfobulbus), and carbon cycles (
Anaerolinea,
Bacillus,
Clostridium). It is worth noting that the microorganisms found in the bottom sediment samples are quite typical of freshwater lakes [
81,
82,
83,
84].
The Venn diagram constructed at the genus level reveals considerable overlap between samples B2 and B3, whereas only a single genus of nitrogen-fixing bacteria,
Rhizobium, is unique to the pair B1 and B3 (
Table A4). Microorganisms shared across all communities demonstrate the potential to carry out complete carbon, sulfur, and nitrogen cycling. Despite the high overall similarity between samples B2 and B3, sample B2 exhibits greater diversity, as well as the presence of unique genera of iron- and sulfur-oxidizing bacteria (
Acidibacter,
Ferritrophicum,
Sulfuricella). The community of sample B3 is characterized by the unique presence of bacteria capable of participating in photosynthesis and degrading complex organic matter (
Gemmatimonas). The bottom sediment community is the most distinct and includes representatives of genera involved in methane production (
Methanobacterium), obligate anaerobes (
Chlorobium,
Syntrophomonas), as well as alkaliphilic bacteria (
Oceanobacillus,
Virgibacillus). A number of microorganisms (
Figure 12) may participate in photosynthesis and biological nitrogen fixation. Representatives of the genus
Rhodobacter are capable of anoxygenic photosynthesis and molecular nitrogen fixation [
85]. It is noteworthy that denitrifying bacteria belonging to the genera
Hyphomicrobium and
Pseudomonas predominate across the samples [
86]. Several microorganisms detected in the bottom sediments, including representatives of the genera
Pseudomonas [
87] and
Geobacter [
88], are known for their capacity to participate in the enzymatic reduction of U.
Despite the considerable taxonomic overlap among samples, more pronounced differences in microbial diversity were detected, associated with differences in mineral composition (
Table A5). High diversity index values for the microbial communities of the natural lake biome reflect the abundance of OTUs comprising these communities, as well as the absence of clearly dominant taxa in the samples. The bottom sediment community B1, collected from the sand-dominated zone, exhibited the greatest divergence in terms of OTU richness, Chao-1, and Shannon index values. The reduced OTU count and Chao-1 index—which reflects the potential richness of rare and low-abundance species—may indicate a higher degree of community specialization driven by the specific characteristics of this habitat. In contrast, sample B2, characterized by a high clay content, displayed the highest overall diversity as assessed by the Simpson, Shannon, and Chao-1 indices. It is also noteworthy that the Shannon index values for communities B2 and B3 were closely similar, reflecting comparable community structure and evenness. Based on the high Shannon index values, both communities can be characterized as diverse and resilient. The Chao-1 index for community B3 was lower than that for B2, which may indicate a comparatively reduced adaptive potential of this community.
Biogenic mineral formation promoting strong radionuclide binding in bottom sediments likely proceeds at different intensities depending on local physicochemical and geochemical conditions. In summer, high phytoplankton productivity leads to organic matter accumulation in sediments, which may enhance actinide and
90Sr mineralization and reduce weakly bound forms. This is expected to be most effective in organic-rich, clay-containing sediments with ferrous sulfide phases, as exemplified by the zone of sample B3. Laboratory experiments confirm that biophilic elements significantly increase phytoplankton productivity and stimulate anaerobic sulfur- and iron-cycling microorganisms in bottom sediments. Thus, adding sulfur, phosphorus, and nitrogen to radionuclide-contaminated lakes may be a promising remediation strategy. These findings agree with previous studies of the Upa River (Chernobyl accident), where nitrogen and phosphorus stimulated
Planktothrix-dominated phytoplankton, removing Cs, Sr, U, and Pu from water [
89]. Enhanced radionuclide immobilization was achieved via sulfide-ferrous precipitates (pyrite, wurtzite, hydrotroilite) formed by sulfate- and iron-reducing bacteria, including
Desulfobacterota,
Desulfotomaculum,
Desulfosporomusa,
Desulfosporosinus,
Thermodesulfobium,
Thiomonas,
Thiobacillus,
Sulfuritallea, and
Pseudomonas.