Design and Preparation of Anti-Reflection Nanoarray Structure on the Surface of Space Solar Cell Glass Cover
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The authors present a work that involved systematic research and precise control of nanometer anti-reflection structure parameters in preparation for anti-reflection structure.
Author Response
Thank you very much for your affirmation of this study.
Reviewer 2 Report
The content of the paper titled: “Design and preparation of anti-reflection nano array structure on the surface of space solar cell glass cover” has successfully designed and prepared an anti-reflective nano-array structure on the surface of space solar cell glass. The results obtained are very interesting but cannot be published. The author should edit according to the following recommendations:
- The author needs to add all acronyms, source formulas in all parts of the manuscript content, rearrange the manuscript content according to a 4-part structure, introduction, research methods, results and discuss and conclude.
- The author needs to add details of the process and steps performed by experimental methods and simulation methods.
- It is necessary to supplement the obtained results of previous works and present new results on the content in the introduction and conclusion to highlight the content. Besides, the author can change the title of the article content to suit the content.
- The author needs to answer the question?
+ Why did the author choose SiO2 thin film as photovoltaic cell glass?
+ Why is the thickness of SiO2 thin film related to the ability to absorb and reflect light images. So the question arises, with which thickness will be suitable for the set conditions such as time, depth and duty cycle through process parameters.
- Currently, in the world to make materials capable of transmitting light, researchers use many methods with many different materials, among them, the choice of SiO2 material is still the most important because this is best solution with low cost. To highlight the applicability of SiO2 materials and the microstructural properties of the materials, the author can refer to the following article "A New Study on the Structure, and Phase Transition Temperature of Bulk Silicate Materials by Simulation" Method of Molecular Dynamics”
- All of the above requirements should be fully explained by the author and added to the manuscript content to increase the attractiveness and highlight the outstanding issues.
- Suggest the author revise the entire English grammar and style to suit the requirements of scientific research.
- Congratulations to the author on their success with this work.
Minor editing of English language required
Author Response
Dear reviewer:
We submitted this manuscript to Coatings, numbered coatings-2415499. We would like to thank you for your constructive and insightful comments and suggestions, which were helpful to the improvement of our manuscript. And we have revised and modified this manuscript very carefully according to your comments. In the revised version, the revised words and sentences by authors were marked with red color.
Thank you for your great help!
Yours sincerely,
Juncheng Liu
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
The present manuscript could be improved.The main recommendations are as follows:
1. Abstract has to be restructured.The main points to be considered are:
-original aspects to be stressed;
-the existing drawbacks to be discussed;
-the prospects of this research to be clearly mentioned
2. Intoduction has to be much improved
-main objective of the present research has to be clearly specified
-the structure of the article has to be well defined
3. A chapter has to be dedicated to the Theoretical Model
4. The experimental approach has to be discussed in another chapter
5. Industrial implementation of the research results of the authors has to be discussed
6. Comparison of the article results with other results in the field published by different authors
Moderate editing of English required
Author Response
Dear reviewer:
We submitted this manuscript to Coatings, numbered coatings-2415499. We would like to thank you for your constructive and insightful comments and suggestions, which were helpful to the improvement of our manuscript. And we have revised and modified this manuscript very carefully according to your comments. In the revised version, the revised words and sentences by authors were marked with red color.
Thank you for your great help!
Yours sincerely,
Juncheng Liu
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Before agreeing to submit online, it is recommended that the author check the entire English grammar and style to meet the requirements of the journal without having to send it back to the reviewer. Congratulations on the success of the authors.
Minor editing of English language required
Reviewer 3 Report
The manuscript was improved based on the reviewers recommendations.
I consider that the present version of the manuscript could be accepted for publication in Coatings.
Moderate editing of English is required.
