3.1. Calibration of Surface Energy in the JKR Repose Model
During the storage process of pellet feed, issues such as caking and segregation may occur. Understanding the surface energy characteristics of the pellets can help in taking measures to prevent these problems, thereby improving the flowability of the feed. Therefore, the calibration of surface energy using the JKR model for pellet feed is an important step in ensuring feed quality and feeding trough performance. This study conducted surface energy calibration for pellet feed with three different pellet sizes. The repose angles of the three types of pellet feed were measured using the Matlab image processing method for repose angle measurement (as shown in
Figure 5).
Taking pellet feed C as an example, the surface energy parameter was repeatedly adjusted between 0 and 0.5 J/m
2 in the discrete element software. When the absolute error between the simulated repose angle and the physical repose angle was less than 5%, the surface energy corresponding to the simulated repose angle was determined to be the surface energy of the pellet feed. The method for measuring the repose angle presented in this paper was used to determine both the physical experiment repose angle and the simulated experiment repose angle (see
Figure 6), where y
1 and y
2 represent the straight lines of the slope in the physical experiment and the simulation experiment, respectively, while φ
1 and φ
2 denote the actual repose angle and the simulated repose angle, respectively. The formula for the absolute error between the two is defined as follows:
. Based on this calibration at φ
2, the surface energy corresponding to pellet feed C is 0.22 J/m
2. Similarly, the surface energies corresponding to pellet feeds A and B are obtained as 0.15 J/m
2 and 0.22 J/m
2, respectively.
The PDI (Pellet Durability Index) test results show that all three pellet feeds exhibited excellent mechanical strength (PDI > 97%). Their fine content was consistently below 3%, indicating high structural stability and minimal differences in powder content, thus suggesting a limited impact on flow characteristics. This finding is consistent with the uniformity of flow characteristics observed for the three pellets during surface energy calibration, further supporting the rationality of using unified contact parameters in the discrete element model.
3.4. Comprehensive Optimization Analysis
Based on the simulation results, the optimal combination of structural parameters is a slope angle of 63°, with corresponding baffle opening heights for the dispensing of pellet feeds A, B, and C set at 28 mm, 28 mm, and 30 mm, respectively. The vector force chain diagram of the material feed process at the outlet of the stock bin is shown in
Figure 8. The blue, green, and red colors in the figure represent a gradual increase in force chain intensity. When pellet feed is fed from the inclined surface of the stock bin, the reduction in the cross-section of the feed outlet causes collisions between the pellets, as well as between the pellets and the structure, thereby consuming the kinetic energy of the pellet flow. Ideally, the pellet flow should be uniformly distributed. In the initial stage of pellet feed entering the feed outlet (t = 3.54 s), the force chains are mainly formed by the collisions between pellets or between pellets and the structure, exhibiting a darker color that facilitates the formation of arched stable force chains. However, due to the intricate interactions between pellets, the force chains rapidly break at the outlet. By the mid-stage (t = 10.54 s), the force chains gradually fracture during the accumulation and transmission processes, leading to a sparse distribution. However, coarse pellet feed, due to its strong contact forces, tends to form robust force chains [
32]. In the final stage (t = 17.54 s), as the feed inside the stock bin is gradually emptied, the contact between pellets decreases, resulting in an increase in weak force chains, which leads to a more uniform stress distribution at the pellet outlet. The force chains within the stock bin continuously generate and break during pellet flow, while the optimum angle of 63° is insufficient to support arch formation, resulting in stable and dense flow of pellet feed. Eventually, when no new pellets are introduced into the stock bin, the internal pellets will gradually be emptied.
Figure 9 shows the velocity distribution vector diagram of the pellets at the outlet of the stock bin. The velocity distribution vector diagram visually illustrates the flow characteristics of pellets within the stock bin, where red, green, and blue represent decreasing flow rates, respectively. In the early stage at the outlet (t = 3.54 s), the C pellet feed fails to achieve concentrated flow, resulting in a decrease in its velocity. In contrast, the other two types of granules exhibit a collapsing flow pattern, which causes an instantaneous increase in their velocity at the outlet. As we enter the mid-stage (t = 10.54 s), the flow of pellets from the stock bin becomes relatively stable. The A pellet feed is less influenced by gravity, resulting in a reduced flow rate at the outlet. In the final stage (t = 17.54 s), as the quantity of pellet feed within the stock bin decreases, a more uniform descent of the pellets can be clearly observed.
3.6. Overall Discussion
This paper compares previous studies from four aspects: experimental materials, the design of the feeding trough device, experimental factors, and a comparison with existing systems.
For the design of the stock bin, we should take into account the properties of the test materials, as well as the structural form of the stock bin, to ensure that there is no clogging inside and to avoid the occurrence of arching and material accumulation. The properties of the test materials can be categorized into four types: chemical properties, physical properties, mechanical properties, and pellet size and shape. In the design of bulk material conveying equipment, greater emphasis is typically placed on the physical properties, mechanical properties, and pellet size and shape. For instance, Li [
37] explored the chalking rates of three types of pelletized feed (for egg ducks, sows, and bream), focusing on the effects of their physical properties (e.g., Poisson’s ratio, collision recovery coefficient) on the chalking rate. In contrast, this study focuses on the flowability of the same type of sheep pelletized feeds and aims to investigate how the flowability of feeds with different pellet sizes affects the structural parameters of the feeding trough device. Consequently, only the density and shear modulus were varied in the selection of model parameters, as shown in
Table 1.
Mechanical properties are crucial for determining the angle of inclination of the side walls of the stock bin. Specifically, the smaller the natural angle of repose, the better the flowability. Most current studies on the angle of repose conducted by scholars primarily focus on powders and spherical pellets [
13], and most utilize traditional methods for measuring the angle of repose. In contrast, this study proposes a Matlab-based image processing method for determining the angle of repose and effectively calibrating the surface energy within the JKR contact model. Although the JKR model is sensitive to humidity in adhesive pellet systems, our study focused on dry pellet feed (moisture content 7.3%) under controlled laboratory conditions. Prior works [
24,
25] have demonstrated that humidity effects become negligible when material moisture is below 10%, as surface water films are insufficient to alter inter-pellet adhesion. The surface energy calibration obtained via repose angle measurements (
Section 3.1) inherently accounts for ambient interactions, ensuring model validity. Future field applications may require humidity compensation, which could be addressed by integrating environmental sensors into the PLC system.
In this study, the Discrete Element Method (DEM) was employed to simulate the kinematic characteristics of pellet feed, providing a theoretical basis for the design of feeding trough devices. Currently, feeding trough devices, such as screw conveyors [
23] and trough wheels [
38], primarily use rotational mechanisms to transport feed. Ma et al. [
23] conducted a simulation and experimental study using the DEM to investigate the flow characteristics of paddy during the discharge process of harvester grain tanks. The results revealed that the mass flow rate of the screw conveyor was constant, with zero acceleration. Furthermore, due to the asymmetry of the grain tank, different walls experienced varying pressures. The four vertical walls were subjected to less pressure compared to the inclined walls at the bottom of the tank, facilitating the formation of funnel flow within the tank. These findings underscore the importance of focusing on the slope of the inclined surface and the height of the baffle opening when optimizing the structure of the feed trough.
The types and requirements of feeds can vary significantly in agricultural production, necessitating enhancements in their versatility to accommodate different types of feed. In this study, three common pellet size feeds used in the market for feeding sheep were selected for in-depth analysis. When optimizing the slope of the stock bin and the height of the baffle opening, the average feeding rate was utilized as an indicator to assess the flow performance of the three types of pellet feed, enabling targeted design and optimization of the stock bin parameters.
The average feed rate directly impacts feed application. An excessively fast or slow rate could result in feed wastage or insufficiency, thereby affecting the nutrient intake of the animals. Emphasizing the feed rate can enhance the adaptability of feed trough devices to various feeds and improve the effectiveness of their monitoring and control systems. With advancements in sensor technology, researchers are increasingly focused on addressing the issue of precision feeding within the livestock industry [
39]. The automatic feeding system developed by Noor et al. [
39] utilized a PLC microcontroller and a pulse width modulation technique to control the speed actuator for timed and rationed feeding. However, in contrast to Noor’s study, this research imposes higher demands on the control of position and speed during the lifting and lowering of the baffle. To achieve this, a closed-loop control system has been implemented, allowing for dynamic adjustments to the output through a real-time feedback mechanism for high precision control. It is important to note that, when calculating the actual feeding time, the up and down stroke reaction time of the servo motor must be excluded.
The experimental validation component of this study addresses two main aspects. First, it verifies the feasibility of the simulation model in optimizing the structural parameters of the feeding trough device through bench tests. Second, it assesses the feeding accuracy achievable by the control system under the optimal combination of structural parameters. Three different types of feed were utilized to nourish three types of sheep in the tests, aiming to observe the control system’s ability to monitor various pellet feeds and its performance in discharging under different sheep conditions. Despite the device demonstrating a high degree of discharge accuracy during the validation process, it is important to consider the feed intake of the sheep in relation to the type of feed, as well as the individual body condition of the sheep. Furthermore, this study also needs to focus on a non-cross-contamination recovery mechanism for feeds to ensure effective separation between different feeds within the same feeding trough unit in order to reduce resource wastage and improve feeding efficiency.
The improved feed trough by Ayantunde et al. [
6] relies on gravity discharge and requires manual adjustment of the baffle height. In contrast, this study achieves fully automatic and precise control through a PLC-HMI system. While traditional designs are typically optimized for a single pellet size feed, this paper utilizes DEM simulation and parameter optimization to develop a feed system adaptable to three different pellet sizes. The problem of clogging is effectively solved by dynamically adjusting the baffle height (28–30 mm), and its sensitivity to changes in pellet size is superior to that of a screw conveyor. Regarding automated feeding systems, the automatic rabbit feeding system developed by Noor et al. [
39] was controlled by a PIC microcontroller, resulting in a dosing error of 1.2%. In this study, however, the error was reduced to 0.3% through the use of servo motors with closed-loop control technology, thereby significantly improving control accuracy. Furthermore, drawing inspiration from the virtual model by Pomar et al. [
3], this system integrates RFID ear tag technology and an HMI. This integration allows for the direct correlation of feeding data with individual sheep, enabling personalized and precise feeding. In terms of equipment maintenance, existing rotary feeders with grooved wheel structures [
38] necessitate the regular replacement of worn parts. Conversely, the baffle design in this study reduces maintenance frequency by minimizing the number of moving parts. In summary, compared to existing feeding systems, this study presents clear advantages in terms of control accuracy and multi-pellet size adaptability, offering a more cost-effective solution for precision feeding in small- and medium-sized farms.