Lesion-Symptom Mapping of Acute Speech Deficits After Left vs. Right Hemisphere Stroke: A Retrospective Analysis of NIHSS Best Language Scores and Clinical Neuroimaging

Background: Recent research suggests that damage to right hemisphere regions homotopic to the left hemisphere language network affects language abilities to a greater extent than previously thought. However, few studies have investigated acute disruption of language after lesion to the right hemisphere. Here, we examined lesion correlates of acute speech deficits following left and right hemisphere ischemic stroke to clarify the neural architecture underlying early language dysfunction. Methods: We retrospectively analyzed 410 patients (225 left, 185 right hemisphere lesions) from the Stroke Outcome Optimization Project dataset. Presence and severity of speech deficits was measured using the National Institute of Health Stroke Scale Best Language subscore within 48 h of onset. Manual lesion masks were derived from clinical MRI scans and normalized to MNI space. Lesion-symptom mapping was conducted using voxelwise and region-of-interest analyses with permutation correction (5000 iterations; p < 0.05), controlling for total lesion volume. Results: Speech deficits were observed in 53.7% of the cohort (58.2% left, 48.1% right hemisphere lesions). In the full sample, the presence of speech deficits was associated with bilateral subcortical and perisylvian damage, including the external and internal capsules, insula, putamen, and superior fronto-occipital fasciculus. Severity of speech deficits localized predominantly to left hemisphere structures, with peak associations in the external capsule (Z = 6.39), posterior insula (Z = 5.64), and inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus (Z = 5.43). In the right hemisphere cohort, the presence and severity of speech deficits were linked to homologous regions, including the posterior insula (Z = 3.70) and external capsule (Z = 3.63), although with smaller effect sizes relative to the left hemisphere cohort. Right hemisphere lesions resulted in milder deficits despite larger lesion volumes compared with left hemisphere lesions. Conclusions: Acute speech impairment following right hemisphere stroke is associated with damage to a homotopic network encompassing perisylvian cortical and subcortical regions analogous to the dominant left hemisphere language network. These findings demonstrate that damage to the right hemisphere consistently results in acute speech deficits, challenging the traditional left-centric view of post-stroke speech impairment. These results have important implications for models of bilateral language representation and the neuroplastic mechanisms supporting language recovery.