Micromechanical Analysis in Applications of Active Mono-Slip and Continuum Dislocations in the MDCM
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Please see the attached file for the reviewer's comments.
Comments for author File: 
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Dear Sir/Madam
I reviewed the manuscript based on your excellent comment. Please, find the attached file.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Title: micro-Mechanical analysis in the applications of active mono-slip and continuum dislocations in the MDCM
This paper proposes mono-slip dependent continuum dislocation method for analysis of matrix dominated composite structures. The paper is properly structured with a details description of the formulation step by step. For the publication of this paper in this journal, I recommend minor revision based on the following comments:
- Author needs to check and revise typos overall the manuscript.
For example:
Line313 eq.,(25) -> eq.(25),
Line 322 eq, (27) -> eq.(27),
Line 344 :’ ~task of : -‘ (if this is not ‘-‘sign, need to be deleted)
Line 571: of Strain -> of strain
Please use the same expressions for ( Fig. 7, figure-7, fig.9, fig-9 ).
- There are many symbols used in the paper; if it is possible, I recommend adding summaries of its explanation for the readers.
- Line 397 : ⅹ, * are used. If the are different operators, please add a clear explanation, otherwise use only one.
- Figure captions are too simple. Please add more explanation for the readers.
- For Fig. 6 and 7, I recommend adding analysis results with a different method, such as FEM, for clear validation.
- For Fig. 8 and 9, If some of the data come from the references, please clearly express it in the legend. Also, please check the strain in Fig.9.
Author Response
Dear Sir/Madam
I reviewed the manuscript based on your remarkable comment. Please, find find the attached file.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
