Simple Summary
A recent review examined the causes of the decline in the size of the monarch butterfly population that overwinters in Mexico. The evidence indicates that herbicide use in agricultural fields has reduced the number of milkweeds in the summer breeding range, thus reducing the size of the population that migrates to Mexico. This conclusion has been challenged by Davis, who claims that the summer population has not declined and that decreasing migratory success is to blame. He faults the review for not considering studies that purport to show that the summer population has remained stable. He argues that conservation efforts to add milkweed to the landscape are unnecessary. Here, we examine the four studies he cites. Three of these are based on yearly surveys of adult monarchs or larvae. We cite several studies that show that yearly surveys conducted during the period when milkweeds were being eradicated from agricultural fields underestimated the size of the summer population and thus could not detect the population decline. Another study that found no genetic evidence of a population decline is open to interpretation. None of the four studies cited negates the preponderance of the evidence of milkweed decline leading to monarch decline.
Abstract
Davis critiqued a recent review, “Eastern North American Monarch Butterfly Conservation Needs and Opportunities: What the Science Tells Us”. He argued that Eastern North American monarch numbers in the summer have not declined, despite dramatic declines in the area covered by this population in Mexico during the winter. These declines in winter numbers, he said, can be explained by increasing mortality during the fall migration and subsequent density-dependent increases the following spring. A strong impetus for these arguments appears to be Davis’s concern that recommendations by “certain circles” of the monarch research community could steer conservation funding toward a species that does not need our help. Here, we address these concerns, and note that there is no evidence that conservation funding focused on providing breeding habitat for monarchs detracts from conservation for other species in need of help, or from efforts to support migrating monarchs.