1. Introduction
Nowadays, recycling is a global priority. However, in most countries, several polluting solid wastes with recycling potential require specific research to develop the most suitable approaches for their valorization into new products and/or raw materials in an environmentally sustainable way [
1,
2,
3,
4]. Such approaches often present very challenging processes, but they yield relevant benefits, including the conservation of natural resources, improved solid waste management, and reduced environmental degradation. They also play a key role in generating economic value and raising awareness among people, companies, and governments about the urgent need for environmental sustainability on the planet. This scenario includes the sludge generated by municipal sewage treatment plants (STPs).
Large volumes of STP sludge are produced annually worldwide. When disposed of inappropriately, they cause significant damage to the environment and public health. Indeed, STP sludges in their raw form are highly harmful, as they consist of a complex and heterogeneous mixture of inorganic and organic compounds, which can contain large amounts of hazardous substances such as heavy metals and pathogens [
5,
6,
7]. As a result, STP sludges are generally classified as hazardous solid waste by environmental legislation [
7]. This scenario makes the eco-friendly disposal of STP sludge very complex and highly challenging from both economic and environmental perspectives. In Brazil, for example, STP sludge is generally subjected to a liming treatment process, transforming it into non-hazardous and non-inert solid waste (class IIA), which can be disposed of in sanitary landfills [
8]. However, this method is costly and comes with environmental and health restrictions, making it a limiting factor [
9]. Consequently, several approaches for sustainable valorization of the STP sludges have been investigated with promising results, including clay bricks [
8,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16], cement [
13,
17], concrete [
13,
18,
19], mortars [
20,
21], lightweight aggregate [
22,
23], soil substitute [
24], activated carbon [
25], and thermal processing [
26,
27].
Wall tiles are construction materials with high water absorption (>10%) and are widely used in both indoor and outdoor environments. They belong to group BIII of the ISO 13006 standard [
28]. The most commonly used technological route for manufacturing dry-pressed wall tiles (group BIII) includes preparing the white- or red-firing ceramic paste, followed by uniaxial pressing and fast single-firing. A highly relevant issue in wall tile manufacture concerns the formulations of the triaxial pastes (clay/carbonate material/filler) used, which are composed of non-renewable natural raw materials, such as kaolin and illite clays, carbonates, quartz, feldspars, and talc, among others, in varying amounts [
29,
30]. Wall tile formulations contain between 10% and 16% carbonate materials (calcite and dolomite), which are essential for obtaining technological properties, crystalline phases based on calcium aluminosilicate, and a porous microstructure after the firing process. However, the intensive use of non-renewable natural raw materials has become a major concern for the ceramic tile industry in many parts of the world, as it may lead to the total depletion of natural raw material deposits.
A sustainable approach that has been successfully applied to mitigate the depletion of natural raw material deposits used by the ceramic sector involves the partial or total replacement of non-renewable ceramic raw material with renewable solid waste. In this scenario, several types of solid waste were tested in the formulation of wall tile pastes with promising results, including blast furnace slag [
31], fine fire clay sanitaryware waste [
32], grits waste [
33], eggshell waste [
34], cement raw mix waste dust [
35], and marble waste [
36].
STP sludges contain appreciable amounts of oxides such as CaO, Al
2O
3, Fe
2O
3, and SiO
2 [
5,
8,
16]. Therefore, STP sludges are highly attractive for use in ceramic tile formulations. However, to date, few studies have been carried out aiming at the application of municipal sewage sludges in the manufacture of ceramic tile materials. Jordán et al. [
37] studied the effects of adding 0%–10% weight of sewage sludge as a partial replacement for clay in ceramic tile production. The results indicated that the incorporation of sewage sludge tends to increase water absorption and decrease mechanical strength. Zhou et al. [
38] produced split tiles fired at 1210 °C using untreated municipal sewage sludge as a replacement for kaolin. An optimal tile formulation was found, consisting of 60% weight crude municipal sewage sludge, 15.2% weight quartz, 20.6% weight feldspar, and 14.2% weight kaolin, with acetic acid as a modifier. The resulting split tiles had a bending strength of 25.5 MPa and a water absorption of 1.14%, meeting the property requirements for fine-grade split tiles according to ISO 13006 [
28]. Amin et al. [
39] investigated the possibility of using municipal sewage sludge for floor tile production. For this purpose, a commercial floor tile formulation was incorporated with up to 35% weight municipal sewage sludge, pressed at 30 MPa, and fired between 1050 °C and 1150 °C. They found that floor tiles could be produced with a maximum addition of 7% weight sewage sludge fired at 1150 °C (for water absorption < 10%), and 10% weight sewage sludge or 5% weight sewage sludge for floor tiles fired at 1150 °C and 1100 °C, respectively (for water absorption > 10%). Therefore, STP sludges have not yet been effectively examined in the formulation of triaxial wall tile pastes for the manufacture of red-firing wall tiles.
This work aims to investigate the potential for valorization of STP sludge from the southeastern region of Brazil as an alternative raw material in the production of red-firing wall tiles. In particular, this investigation proposes a sustainable approach for transforming STP sludge, which is widely available on a global scale, into a renewable raw material source for the ceramic tile industry, which can contribute positively to the basic sanitation sector, support the circular economy, and advance the sustainable development goals outlined in the UN 2030 Agenda.
2. Materials and Methods
This research is a preliminary experimental work developed on a laboratory scale that analyzed the valorization potential of STP sludge in the manufacture of new red-firing wall tiles. For this purpose, the following raw materials were used: common clay, calcitic limestone, quartz, and STP sludge. Common clay, calcitic limestone, and quartz were acquired from commercial companies. A sewage treatment company located in the southeastern region of Brazil supplied the STP sludge. After collecting, the raw STP sludge used in this work was subjected to an inertization treatment process to eliminate pathogens, following the same procedures described by Areias [
8]. Briefly, the inertization treatment consisted of drying of raw STP sludge at 65 °C for 48 h, followed by mixing and homogenizing the dried sludge with 15 wt.% of hydrated lime.
All raw materials were subjected to a beneficiation process that included drying at 110 °C for 24 h, followed by crushing in a porcelain ball mill (model 1A, Gardelin, São Paulo, Brazil) and sieving to a fraction < 200 mesh (<75 µm).
Table 1 presents the chemical composition of the raw materials, determined using an energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (model EDX 700, Shimadzu, Tokyo, Japan).
Table 2 summarizes the qualitative mineral composition of the raw materials obtained via X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis.
To study the effect of STP sludge incorporation, four ceramic pastes for red-firing wall tiles were developed by replacing conventional limestone with STP sludge, as described in
Table 3. The STP sludge-free red wall tile formulation (MIA1 Paste), composed of 70% weight clay, 15% weight limestone, and 15% weight quartz, was used as a reference [
33]. The red wall tile formulations described in
Table 3 underwent a dry granulation process, homogenization, and moisture control to 7% weight [
40].
The chemical composition of the wall tile formulations was obtained using an energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (model EDX 700, Shimadzu, Tokyo, Japan). Mineralogical analysis of the wall tile formulations was carried out by XRD in a conventional diffractometer (model XRD-7000, Shimadzu, Japan) with Cu-Kα radiation at a scanning speed of 1.5° (2θ)/min and 2θ = 10°–70°. Mineral phases were identified using JCPDS-ICDD cards described in
Table 4. Thermal analyses of the ceramic pastes were conducted by differential thermal analysis (DTA) and thermogravimetric analysis (TG) using a simultaneous thermal analyzer (model STA 409E, Netzsch, Selb, Germany) over a temperature range of 25 °C to 1100 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C/min. Dilatometric analysis was performed on a dilatometer (model DIL 402 C, Netzsch, Selb, Germany) in the temperature range of 25 °C to 1200 °C, also at a heating rate of 10 °C/min under an air atmosphere.
Rectangular red wall tile pieces measuring 115.0 mm × 25.4 mm × 7.0 mm were compacted by uniaxial pressing at 35 MPa, dried at 110 °C for 24 h, and finally fired in a laboratory kiln at temperatures of 1150 °C, 1160 °C, 1170 °C, and 1180 °C for 5 min. A heating rate of 30 °C/min was applied, and cooling was performed by thermal inertia, switching off the kiln. Five test pieces were prepared for each wall tile formulation.
In this work, the following physical and mechanical properties of the fired wall tile pieces were determined in accordance with the procedures described in the technical standards: linear shrinkage, apparent density, water absorption, apparent porosity, and flexural strength. Linear shrinkage values were obtained by measuring the length of the dried and fired wall tile pieces, following ASTM C326-09 [
41]. The apparent density, water absorption, and porosity were measured according to ISO 10545-3 [
42]. The flexural strength was determined by a three-point bending test, as specified in ISO 10545-4 [
43], using a universal mechanical testing machine (model 5582, Instron, Norwood, MA, USA).
3. Results and Discussion
The X-ray diffractograms of the red wall tile pastes are shown in
Figure 1. It can be seen in
Figure 1A that the mineralogical phases found in the STP sludge-free reference wall tile paste (MIA1 Paste) included kaolinite, muscovite, quartz, gibbsite, goethite, calcite, and dolomite. This mineralogical composition reflects the raw materials used in its paste (
Table 2 and
Table 3). In the paste containing 10% mass STP sludge (MIA3 Paste), the same mineral phases were identified along with the presence of gypsum, as observed in
Figure 1B. Therefore, replacing limestone with STP sludge modifies the mineralogical composition of the red wall tile pastes.
Table 5 presents the chemical analyses and loss on ignition (LoI) of the red wall tile pastes studied. It was found that the incorporation of STP sludge as a replacement for limestone tends to cause small but relevant changes in the chemical composition of the ceramic pastes. The iron oxide content (Fe
2O
3) in ceramic pastes directly influences the reddish coloration of the produced wall tiles. The effect of incorporating the STP sludge was to provide greater amounts of SiO
2, Al
2O
3, Fe
2O
3, K
2O, and Na
2O and a decrease in the amounts of CaO and MgO. Additionally, there was also an increase in the LoI value. This result was consistent with the XRD analysis (
Figure 1). Thus, the substitution of limestone with STP sludge is expected to influence the behavior of the technological properties of red wall tiles.
Figure 2 shows the wall tile formulations plotted on the SiO
2-Al
2O
3-CaO phase diagram [
44]. For this purpose, only the three main oxides (SiO
2, Al
2O
3, and CaO) described in
Table 4 were considered, as they are essential for the formation of the calcium aluminosilicate phases. The MIA1 Paste (STP sludge-free) was positioned at the boundary between two compatibility triangles: quartz–mullite–anorthite and quartz–mullite–wollastonite. It was found that the substitution of limestone with STP sludge moved the MIA2, MIA3, and MIA4 Pastes into the quartz–mullite–anorthite compatibility triangle. This demonstrated good chemical similarity between the wall tile formulations studied. This result is of technological relevance because it indicates the possibility of valorization of STP sludge as a partial or total substitute for natural limestone in wall tile pastes.
Figure 3 shows the thermal behavior of the MIA1 Paste (STP sludge-free) and the MIA3 Paste (with 10 wt.% STP sludge). Both pastes presented thermal behavior very similar to and typical of ceramic pastes used in wall tile manufacture [
45]. The thermal behavior illustrated by the DTA-TG curves in
Figure 3 can be described as follows: (a) small endothermic events at ~120 °C with a mass loss of 1.082% (MIA1 Paste) and at ~130 °C with a mass loss of 1.750% (MIA3 Paste) due to the release of physically adsorbed water [
33,
45]; (b) endothermic events at 283.1 °C with a mass loss of 1.761% (MIA1 Paste) and at 283.0 °C with a mass loss of 2.806% (MIA3 Paste) are related to the dehydration of hydroxides (gibbsite and goethite) [
40]; (c) endothermic events at 521.9 °C with mass loss of 4.781% (MIA1 Paste) and at 520.5 °C with mass loss of 5.210% (MIA3 Paste) related to the dehydroxylation of kaolinite to form amorphous metakaolinite [
33,
40,
45]; (d) endothermic events at 780.6 °C with a mass loss of 6.293% (MIA1 Paste) and at 745.0 °C with a mass loss of 2.850% (MIA3 Paste) attributed to the decomposition of carbonates (calcite and dolomite) [
46,
47,
48]; and (e) exothermal events at 948.8 °C (MIA1 Paste) and 950.0 °C (MIA3 Paste) mainly related to the formation of the mullite and calcium aluminosilicate phases [
45]. The endothermic event associated with the decomposition of gypsum (CaSO
4, calcium sulfate—anhydrous) [
49] present in the MIA3 Paste was likely overlapped by the endothermic events of carbonate decomposition (
Figure 3B). The total mass losses obtained from the TG curves were 13.917% (MIA1 Paste) and 12.616% (MIA3 Paste). Therefore, these thermal behaviors are in line with the chemical and mineralogical compositions of the wall tile pastes.
Figure 4 displays the dilatometric curves for the MIA1 Paste (STP sludge-free) and MIA3 Paste (with 10 wt.% STP sludge). The ceramic pastes presented small differences in dilatometric behavior, reflecting their chemical and mineralogical compositions and thermal analysis. However, the incorporation of STP sludge tends to cause greater total firing shrinkage of the red wall tile pieces. It should be noted that both pastes showed slight expansion up to approximately 500 °C, likely due to the thermal expansion of the minerals present in the starting raw materials. Between 500 °C and 580 °C, a small shrinkage was observed due to dehydroxylation of kaolinite. The wall tile pastes showed the beginning of shrinkage at approximately 880 °C (MIA1 Paste) and 890 °C (MIA3 Paste). It was also noted that, from 1055 °C (MIA1 Paste) and 1050 °C (MAI3 Paste), the shrinkage became more pronounced, indicating that sintering was in progress. Finally, it was observed that the temperature of the maximum sintering rate was 1197.5 °C (MIA1 Paste) and 1198.2 °C (MIA3 Paste), respectively.
Figure 5,
Figure 6,
Figure 7 and
Figure 8 display the results of the physical properties of the red wall tile pieces as a function of the amount of STP sludge and the firing temperature, whose values are summarized in
Table 6.
The linear shrinkage results of the produced red wall tile pieces are shown in
Figure 5. Linear shrinkage values ranged from 1.40 to 4.27%, depending on the firing temperature and the amount of STP sludge added. It was found that both the firing temperature and STP sludge contributed to the increase in linear shrinkage. The increase in firing temperature enhances the sintering degree of the red wall tile pieces, particularly above 1160 °C. On the other hand, the incorporation of STP sludge as a substitute for limestone tends to increase the linear shrinkage value due to its chemical composition (
Table 1). In fact, as shown in
Table 5, the incorporation of STP sludge increases the amount of fluxing oxides (K
2O, Na
2O, and Fe
2O
3), which influences sintering behavior. Therefore, the linear shrinkage behavior aligns with the dilatometric curves (
Figure 4).
Figure 6 shows the apparent density of the red wall tile pieces. It can be observed that the apparent density of the pieces fired at temperatures between 1150 and 1170 °C presented only a small variation within the dispersion limits (1.74–1.80 g/cm
3). At 1180 °C, however, higher apparent density values were achieved (1.79–1.83 g/cm
3). This apparent density behavior can be attributed to several simultaneous and competing complex effects occurring during the firing process, including mass loss, mineral decomposition, crystallization of new phases, and sintering, which is typical of wall tile pastes [
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
45].
Figure 7 displays the water absorption behavior of the red wall tile pieces. The following water absorption values were found: MIA1 Paste (18.93%–19.38%), MIA2 Paste (17.33%–19.70%), MIA3 Paste (17.92%–19.66%), and MIA4 Paste (16.52%–19.04%). The high water absorption values are mainly associated with the decomposition of carbonates and dehydroxylation of kaolinite, as observed in the TG curves in
Figure 3, which generate open pores in the fired structure of the red wall tiles. The apparent porosity observed in
Figure 8 had a behavior very similar to that of water absorption.
Figure 7 also indicates that the red wall tile pieces incorporating STP sludge tend to exhibit lower water absorption values, particularly at higher temperatures. This fact can be explained by the composition of the STP sludge, which provides melting oxides to the ceramic pastes. These oxides influence the sintering behavior of the red wall tile pieces, as seen in the dilatometric curves (
Figure 4) and the linear shrinkage (
Figure 5).
Figure 9 presents the flexural strength behavior of the fired red wall tile pieces. For better visualization, the flexural strength data are summarized in
Table 7. Flexural strength values were established in the range of 11.37 to 19.59 MPa, depending on the firing temperature and the amount of STP sludge added. More specifically, it was noted that the flexural strength tended to increase with increasing firing temperature. On the other hand, it was found that at all firing temperatures, the effect of STP sludge incorporation on the flexural strength caused only a small variation within the dispersion limits. In addition, it is suggested that the possibility of formation of the anorthite phase, with greater mechanical strength [
50], as described in the phase diagram in
Figure 2, may also contribute to increasing the flexural strength of the red wall tiles produced. These findings are well correlated with water absorption (
Figure 7) and apparent porosity (
Figure 8).
In this work, the potential for valorization and practical application of STP sludge in the manufacture of red wall tiles was evaluated based on water absorption values (i.e., the open porosity level of the fired red wall tiles), which correspond to the key physical property for classifying the quality of ceramic tile materials. For wall tiles, the ISO 13006 standard [
28] specifies a water absorption value (WA) > 10%, corresponding to classification within the BIII group. According to the water absorption values described in
Figure 7, all red wall tile pieces produced fall within the BIII group of the ISO 13006 standard, regardless of firing temperature and the amount of STP sludge incorporated. On the other hand, the ISO 13006 standard [
28] also recommends a flexural strength value > 15 MPa for wall tiles with a thickness < 7.5 mm. In this context, based on the flexural strength values described in
Figure 9, pieces fired at 1170 °C and 1180 °C are the most favorable for red wall tile manufacture. This result is very relevant, as it indicates that STP sludge can be valorized as a partial or total substitute for conventional limestone in ceramic pastes, enabling the production of red wall tiles with good technical quality.