Next Article in Journal
Optimization of the Auxiliary-Beam System in Railway Bridge Vibration Mitigation Using FEM Simulation and Genetic Algorithms
Previous Article in Journal
Preventing Shoulder-Surfing Attacks using Digraph Substitution Rules and Pass-Image Output Feedback
 
 
Font Type:
Arial Georgia Verdana
Font Size:
Aa Aa Aa
Line Spacing:
Column Width:
Background:
Article

Noether-Type First Integrals Associated with Autonomous Second-Order Lagrangians

Department of Applied Mathematics, University Politehnica of Bucharest, 060042 Bucharest, Romania
Symmetry 2019, 11(9), 1088; https://doi.org/10.3390/sym11091088
Submission received: 27 July 2019 / Revised: 26 August 2019 / Accepted: 29 August 2019 / Published: 31 August 2019

Abstract

:
In this paper, the analysis is centered on Noether-type first integrals in Lagrange-Hamilton dynamics based on autonomous second-order Lagrangians. More precisely, by using the classical Noether’s theorem and a non-standard Legendrian duality, the single-time and multi-time versions of Noether’s result are investigated for autonomous second-order Lagrangians. A correspondence is established between the invariances under flows and the first integrals for autonomous second-order Lagrangians. In this way, our results extend, unify and improve several existing theorems in the current literature.

1. Introduction

Over time, the multi-time version associated with Lagrange-Hamilton-Jacobi dynamics has been extensively studied by many researchers (see, for instance, Rochet [1], Motta and Rampazzo [2], Cardin and Viterbo [3], Udrişte and Matei [4], Treanţă [5,6,7,8,9,10]). The concept of multi-time has a long story and we make a dishonesty by mentioning only a part of the research works that contain it: Dirac et al. [11], Tomonaga [12], Friedman [13], Saunders [14], Udrişte and Matei [4], Prepeliţă [15], Mititelu and Treanţă [16], Treanţă [5,6,7,8,9,10].
In this paper, inspired and motivated by the ongoing research in this field, we consider multi-time evolutions and the notion multi-time is regarded as multiple parameter of evolution. For the multi-time case, the multi-index notation introduced by Saunders [14] is used. Throughout the paper, we develop our points of view, by developing new concepts and methods for a theory that involves single-time and multi-time second-order Lagrangians. More exactly, by using a non-standard Legendrian duality, the main aim of this work is to study the single-time and multi-time versions of Noether’s result for autonomous second-order Lagrangians. We prove that there exists a correspondence between the invariances under flows and the first integrals for autonomous second-order Lagrangians. This actually reflects Noether type theorems between symmetries and conservation laws for dynamical systems. This work can be an important source for many research problems and it should be of interest to engineers and applied mathematicians. For other different but connected ideas to this subject, the reader is directed to Ma [17,18].
The present paper is structured as follows. Section 2 contains some auxiliary results including the classical Noether’s theorem. Section 3 introduces the main results of this paper. More exactly, Noether-type first integrals are investigated for autonomous second-order Lagrangians. Finally, Section 4 concludes the paper.

2. Auxiliary Results

In the classical (single-time) Lagrange-Hamilton dynamics it is well-known that if L = L x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) is an autonomous Lagrangian, then the associated Hamiltonian H = H x ( t ) , p ( t ) is a first integral both for Euler-Lagrange and Hamilton equations (see, for instance, Udrişte and Matei [4], Treanţă [5,6,7,8,9,10]).
The next result formulates the classical Noether’s theorem (for autonomous first-order Lagrangians).
Theorem 1.
[Noether] Let T ( t , x ) be the flow generated by the C 1 -class vector field X ( x ) = X i ( x ) , i = 1 , n ¯ . If the Lagrangian L x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) is invariant under this flow, where x : [ t 0 , t 1 ] R R n and x ˙ ( t ) : = d d t x ( t ) , then the function
I ( x , x ˙ ) = L x ˙ i ( x , x ˙ ) X i ( x )
is a first integral associated with the movement generated by the Lagrangian L .
Proof. 
Denote x s ( t ) : = T s , x ( t ) . The invariance of L means
0 = d L d s x s ( t ) , x ˙ s ( t ) | s = 0
= L x ˙ i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) X i x j x ( t ) x ˙ j ( t ) + L x i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) X i x ( t ) .
Consequently, using derivation formulas and Euler-Lagrange equations, we get
d I d t ( x , x ˙ ) = d d t L x ˙ i ( x , x ˙ ) X i ( x ) + L x ˙ i ( x , x ˙ ) X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
= d d t L x ˙ i ( x , x ˙ ) L x i ( x , x ˙ ) X i ( x ) = 0
and the proof is complete. □
Further, in order to formulate the multi-time version for Noether-type first integrals (associated with autonomous first-order Lagrangians), in accordance with Treanţă [5,6,7,8,9,10] and following Udrişte and Matei [4], consider Ω t 0 , t 1 R m a hyper-parallelepiped determined by diagonally opposite points t 0 , t 1 from R m . If we define the partial order product on R m , then Ω t 0 , t 1 is equivalent with the closed interval [ t 0 , t 1 ] . Also, consider the C 2 -class Lagrangian L x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) , t , where
t = ( t 1 , , t m ) = ( t γ ) Ω t 0 , t 1 , x = ( x 1 , , x n ) = ( x i ) : Ω t 0 , t 1 R n
x γ ( t ) : = x t γ ( t ) , γ { 1 , 2 , , m } , i { 1 , 2 , , n } .
In the case of several variables of evolution (that is, the multi-time version), the Hamiltonian H x , p , t = p i α x α i x , p , t L x , p , t (see summation over the repeated indices and p i α ( t ) : = L x α i x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) , t , α { 1 , 2 , , m } , t Ω t 0 , t 1 ) does not conserve, that is D α H 0 , where D α is the total derivative operator, even in autonomous case.
In the following, let L x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) be an autonomous C 2 -class Lagrangian. Introducing the multi-time anti-trace Euler-Lagrange PDEs (for more details, see Udrişte and Matei [4])
L x i δ β γ D β L x γ i = 0 , i = 1 , n ¯
and using Legendrian duality, we derive the multi-time anti-trace Hamilton PDEs (see δ β α as Kronecker’s symbol)
x i t β ( t ) = H p i β x ( t ) , p ( t ) , p i α t β ( t ) = δ β α H x i x ( t ) , p ( t ) .
A direct computation gives us D γ H = 0 . Consequently, H is a first integral both for multi-time anti-trace Euler-Lagrange PDEs and multi-time anti-trace Hamilton PDEs.
On the other hand, if we introduce energy-impulse tensor T of components
T β α x , p , t = p i α x β i x , p , t L x , p , t δ β α
and Hamilton tensor
H β α x , p = p i α x β i x , p 1 m L x , p δ β α ,
we get the following results:
(1)
D i v ( T ) : = D α T β α = 0 (conservation law);
(2)
the trace of Hamilton tensor is the Hamiltonian H x , p = p i α x α i x , p L x , p .
Next, consider the Hamiltonian tensor field H β α defined by
H β α x , p = p i α x β i x , p L β α x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) ,
where x and p are the canonical variables. Here, L β α x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) represents an extension of the Lagrangian L x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) , satisfying:
(a)
the trace of tensor field L β α is the Lagrangian L ;
(b)
the Lagrangian 1-forms L β α x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) d t β are completely integrable;
(c)
the functions L β α x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) determine the multi-time anti-trace Euler-Lagrange PDEs
L β α x i δ λ γ D λ L β α x γ i = 0 , i = 1 , n ¯ .
Further, we assume p i α ( t ) δ β γ = L β α x γ i x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) and that these n m 3 equations define the following m functions x γ = x γ ( x , p ) . If L β α = L δ β α , then H β α is exactly the classical energy-impulse tensor.
The following result formulates the generalized Hamilton PDEs governed by first-order Lagrangians.
Theorem 2.
(Generalized Hamilton PDEs, [4]) If x ( · ) is solution in ( 1 ) and p = p i α ( · ) is defined as above, then the pair x ( · ) , p ( · ) is solution of the following generalized Hamilton PDEs:
x i t β ( t ) δ γ α = H β α p i γ x ( t ) , p ( t ) , t
p i α t β ( t ) = H β α x i x ( t ) , p ( t ) , t .
Moreover, if the Lagrangian tensor field L β α is autonomous, then the divergence of the transposed Hamilton tensor field H β α is zero, that is β = 1 m D β H β α = 0 .
The next theorem formulates the multi-time version for Noether-type first integrals associated with autonomous first-order Lagrangians.
Theorem 3.
([4]) Let T ( t , x ) be the m-flow generated by the C 1 -class vector fields X α ( x ) = X α i ( x ) , α = 1 , m ¯ , i = 1 , n ¯ . If the Lagrangian L x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) is invariant under this flow, then the function
I ( x , x γ ) = L x β i ( x , x γ ) X β i ( x )
is a first integral of the movement generated by the Lagrangian L via multi-time anti-trace Euler-Lagrange PDEs.
Proof. 
The invariance of L means
0 = L x i ( x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) ) X α i x ( t ) + L x β i ( x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) ) X β i x j x ( t ) x α j ( t ) .
By direct computation and taking into account the multi-time anti-trace Euler-Lagrange PDEs, we get
D α I ( x , x γ ) = D α L x β i ( x , x γ ) X β i ( x ) + L x β i ( x , x γ ) X β i x j x x α j
= D α L x β i ( x , x γ ) L x i ( x , x γ ) δ α β X β i ( x ) = 0
and the proof is now complete. □

3. Main Results

This section, taking into account the aforementioned auxiliary results, introduces the main results of this paper. More exactly, the single-time and multi-time versions of Noether’s result are investigated for autonomous second-order Lagrangians.
Theorem 4.
Let T ( t , x ) be the flow generated by the C 2 -class vector field X ( x ) = X i ( x ) , i = 1 , n ¯ . If the autonomous second-order Lagrangian L x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) is invariant under this flow, then the function
I ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) = L x ˙ i ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) X i ( x ) + L x ¨ i ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
d d t L x ¨ i ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) X i ( x )
is a first integral of the movement generated by the Lagrangian L .
Proof. 
The invariance of L means
0 = L x i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) X i x ( t ) + L x ˙ i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) X i x j x ( t ) x ˙ j ( t )
+ L x ¨ i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) d x ¨ i d t ( t ) .
By using the associated Euler-Lagrange ODEs formulated as follows
L x i d d t L x ˙ i + d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i = 0 , i { 1 , 2 , , n } ,
it results
d I d t = d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) + L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x )
= d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) + L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x )
= d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) + L x ˙ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j + d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
+ L x ¨ i d x ¨ i d t d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x )
= d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) L x i X i ( x ) L x ¨ i d x ¨ i d t + d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
+ L x ¨ i d x ¨ i d t d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x )
= L x i X i ( x ) + d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) + d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x )
+ d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x )
= L x i + d d t L x ˙ i d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) + d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x )
+ d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x )
= L x i + d d t L x ˙ i d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) + d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x )
d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x ) = L x i + d d t L x ˙ i d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) = 0 .
In consequence, the function I ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) is a first integral of the movement generated by the autonomous second-order Lagrangian Lagrangian L . The proof is complete. □
The following two corollaries establish some more restrictive results.
Corollary 1.
Let T ( t , x ) be the flow generated by the C 2 -class vector field X ( x ) = X i ( x ) , i = 1 , n ¯ . If the autonomous second-order Lagrangian L x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) is invariant under this flow and d d t L x ¨ i ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) X i ( x ) is constant, then the function
I x , x ˙ , x ¨ = L x ˙ i ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) X i ( x ) + L x ¨ i ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
is a first integral of the movement generated by the Lagrangian L .
Proof. 
The invariance of L means
0 = L x i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) X i x ( t ) + L x ˙ i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) X i x j x ( t ) x ˙ j ( t )
+ L x ¨ i x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) d x ¨ i d t ( t ) .
Consequently, we get
d I d t = d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) + L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
= d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) + L x ˙ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j + d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j + L x ¨ i d x ¨ i d t
= d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) L x i X i ( x ) L x ¨ i d x ¨ i d t + d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j + L x ¨ i d x ¨ i d t
= L x i X i ( x ) + d d t L x ˙ i X i ( x ) d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) + d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x )
+ d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
= L x i + d d t L x ˙ i d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) + d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) + d d t L x ¨ i X i x j ( x ) x ˙ j
= L x i + d d t L x ˙ i d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i X i ( x ) + d d t d d t ( L x ¨ i ) X i ( x ) = 0 .
Thus, the function I ( x , x ˙ , x ¨ ) is a first integral and the proof is complete. □
Corollary 2.
For any autonomous regular second-order Lagrangian L · : = L x ( t ) , x ˙ ( t ) , x ¨ ( t ) , the Hamiltonian
H x i ( t ) , L x ˙ i ( · ) , L x ¨ i ( · ) : = x ˙ i ( t ) L x ˙ i ( · ) + x ¨ i ( t ) L x ¨ i ( · ) L ( · )
is conserved along to any extremal curve, c ( t ) : = x i ( t ) , i { 1 , 2 , , n } , solution of the Euler-Lagrange equations
L x i d d t L x ˙ i + d 2 d t 2 L x ¨ i = 0 , i { 1 , 2 , , n } ,
if x ˙ i ( t ) d d t L x ¨ i ( · ) = c t .
Remark 1.
As with the first-order Lagrangians, in the case of multiple variables of evolution (that is, the multi-time version), the Hamiltonian
H x , p , q , t = x γ i x , p , q , t L x γ i x , x γ i ( x , p , q , t ) , x α β i ( x , p , q , t ) , t
+ 1 n ( α , β ) x α β i x , p , q , t L x α β i x , x γ i ( x , p , q , t ) , x α β i ( x , p , q , t ) , t
L x , x γ i ( x , p , q , t ) , x α β i ( x , p , q , t ) , t ,
(multi-time second order non-standard Legendrian duality) or, shortly,
H = x γ i p i γ + x α β i q i α β L ,
(see summation over the repeated indices) with
p i γ ( t ) : = L x γ i t , x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) , x α β ( t ) , t Ω t 0 , t 1 ,
q i α β ( t ) : = 1 n ( α , β ) L x α β i t , x ( t ) , x γ ( t ) , x α β ( t ) , t Ω t 0 , t 1 ,
does not conserve, even in autonomous case (for more details, see Treanţă [8]).

4. Conclusions

In this paper, motivated and inspired by the ongoing research in this area, single-time and multi-time versions for Noether-type first integrals in Lagrange-Hamilton dynamics associated with autonomous second-order Lagrangians have been investigated. More exactly, by using a non-standard Legendrian duality, the results derived in this paper have extended and improved several existing theorems in the current literature.

Funding

The APC was funded by University Politehnica of Bucharest, “PubArt” program.

Conflicts of Interest

The author declares no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Rochet, J.C. The taxation principle and multitime Hamilton-Jacobi equations. J. Math. Econ. 1985, 14, 113–128. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  2. Motta, M.; Rampazzo, F. Nonsmooth multi-time Hamilton-Jacobi systems. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 2006, 55, 1573–1614. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  3. Cardin, F.; Viterbo, C. Commuting Hamiltonians and Hamilton-Jacobi multi-time equations. Duke Math. J. 2008, 144, 235–284. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  4. Udrişte, C.; Matei, L. Teorii Lagrange-Hamilton (Lagrange-Hamilton Theories); Monographs and Textbooks 8; Geometry Balkan Press: Bucharest, Romania, 2008. [Google Scholar]
  5. Treanţă, S. On multi-time Hamilton-Jacobi theory via second order Lagrangians. U.P.B. Sci. Bull. Ser. A 2014, 76, 129–140. [Google Scholar]
  6. Treanţă, S. PDEs of Hamilton-Pfaff type via multi-time optimization problems. U.P.B. Sci. Bull. Ser. A 2014, 76, 163–169. [Google Scholar]
  7. Treanţă, S.; Udrişte, C. Optimal control problems with higher order ODEs constraints. Balk. J. Geom. Appl. 2013, 18, 71–86. [Google Scholar]
  8. Treanţă, S. Higher-order Hamilton dynamics and Hamilton-Jacobi divergence PDE. Comput. Math. Appl. 2018, 75, 547–560. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  9. Treanţă, S.; Udrişte, C. Single-time and multi-time Hamilton-Jacobi theory based on higher order Lagrangians. In Mathematical and Statistical Applications in Life Sciences and Engineering; Adhikari, A., Adhikari, M., Chaubey, Y., Eds.; Springer: Singapore, 2017; pp. 71–95. [Google Scholar]
  10. Treanţă, S. Constrained variational problems governed by second-order Lagrangians. Appl. Anal. 2019. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  11. Dirac, P.A.M.; Fock, V.A.; Podolski, B. On quantum electrodynamics. Sel. Pap. Quant. Electrodyn. 1932, 2, 468–479. [Google Scholar]
  12. Tomonaga, S. On a relativistically invariant formulation of the quantum theory of wave fields. Prog. Theor. Phys. 1946, 1, 27–42. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  13. Friedman, A. The Cauchy problem in several time variables. J. Math. Mech. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 1962, 11, 859–889. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  14. Saunders, D.J. The Geometry of Jet Bundles; London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 142; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1989. [Google Scholar]
  15. Prepeliţă, V. Stability of a class of multidimensional continuous-discrete linear systems. Math. Rep. 2007, 9, 387–398. [Google Scholar]
  16. Mititelu, Ş.; Treanţă, S. Efficiency conditions in vector control problems governed by multiple integrals. J. Appl. Math. Comput. 2018, 57, 647–665. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. Ma, W.-X. Conservation laws of discrete evolution equations by symmetries and adjoint symmetries. Symmetry 2015, 7, 714–725. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  18. Ma, W.-X. Conservation laws by symmetries and adjoint symmetries. Discret. Contin. Dyn. Syst. 2018, 11, 707–721. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]

Share and Cite

MDPI and ACS Style

Treanţă, S. Noether-Type First Integrals Associated with Autonomous Second-Order Lagrangians. Symmetry 2019, 11, 1088. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym11091088

AMA Style

Treanţă S. Noether-Type First Integrals Associated with Autonomous Second-Order Lagrangians. Symmetry. 2019; 11(9):1088. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym11091088

Chicago/Turabian Style

Treanţă, Savin. 2019. "Noether-Type First Integrals Associated with Autonomous Second-Order Lagrangians" Symmetry 11, no. 9: 1088. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym11091088

Note that from the first issue of 2016, this journal uses article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Article Metrics

Back to TopTop