1. Introduction
Phosphorus, an important biogenic element in nature, is an essential element for all life forms such as plants, animals and microorganisms, and is also the main control factor for eutrophication of water bodies. Its distribution, migration and circulation at the sediment–water interface directly affect the primary productivity of the water body [
1,
2,
3]. Phosphorus in the water environment is generally divided into dissolved phosphorus (TDP) and particulate phosphorus (TPP) [
4]. Dissolved and particulate phosphorus can be converted under specific conditions: phosphorus in the water environment has “particle adsorption property”, that is, phosphorus is easy to adsorb, complex or precipitate with metal oxides and small molecular organic matter attached to the sediment surface or inside, forming phosphorus containing compounds insoluble in water [
5,
6,
7,
8]. When the content of dissolved phosphorus in the environment is low or it is not enough for aquatic organisms to absorb and utilize, the unstable bound phosphorus contained on the surface of some particles will undergo desorption, reduction or dissociation reactions, which will transform into dissolved phosphorus and enter the water body for diffusion and transport. In the process of phosphorus transport in rivers (including river type reservoirs), TDP mainly diffuses and migrates along the flow direction, and TPP mainly keeps consistent with the transport path of suspended sediment.
Sediment at the bottom of the river is an important part of the aquatic ecosystem, and sediment movement affects the transport trajectory and existing form of phosphorus. Riverbed sediment is not only a phosphorus sink, but also a phosphorus release source: when the water environment is disturbed, the phosphorus in the sediment will be released into the water, and the endogenous release of sediment will increase the phosphorus concentration in the water. The water flow is smooth and stable, and the suspended sediment in the water absorbs the phosphorus in the water and settles at the bottom of the riverbed. Therefore, water and sediment are the main carriers of phosphorus [
9]. The dynamic change relationship between water, sediment and phosphorus is the most active part of the basin, which is closely related to the stability of water potential and river lake ecosystem. Its essence is the redistribution of phosphorus carried by the river in the river reservoir system [
10].
Experts and scholars at home and abroad have conducted a lot of research on water and sediment movement and phosphorus transport. Tian et al. have studied the transport, adsorption and bioavailability characteristics of water, suspended sediment (SS) and phosphorus along the Dongting Lake of the Yangtze River. The results show that phosphorus transport is significantly related to sediments [
11]. Jin et al. studied the phosphorus dynamics in the low flow zone through flume and numerical simulation, and revealed the migration and distribution of phosphorus in pore water [
12]. Hanchaonan took the Three Gorges Reservoir as the research object, with the help of hydrological data collection, field sampling investigation and indoor experimental simulation methods, the source and budget characteristics of total phosphorus in the Three Gorges Reservoir water were determined, and the morphological distribution characteristics of phosphorus in water, suspended particulate matter, soil and sediment in the water level fluctuation zone were analyzed [
13,
14]. Wang et al. built a dynamic and water quality model of the Yangtze River Estuary based on DHI’s Ecolab open platform, and simulated and analyzed the migration and transformation process of different forms of nitrogen and phosphorus nutrients [
15]. Huang et al. established a phase separation model of hydrodynamic sediment–phosphorus transport and applied the model to the Three Gorges Reservoir. The calculation shows that the sediment discharge ratio of the Three Gorges Reservoir is 27.4% from 2003 to 2011, and about 51.4% of TP is deposited in the reservoir area [
16]. Liu et al. adopted Integrated Model to Assess the Global Environment—Global Nutrient Model (IMAGE-GNM); it is found that about 10% of the incoming TP is retained in the Three Gorges Reservoir [
17].
Plants have a significant impact on the distribution of water flow characteristics. Vegetation affects the average flow field and turbulent field of water flow [
18], flow transport [
19], sediment transport [
20], river morphology and morphology dynamics [
21], and is a key component in controlling the fluid dynamics of aquatic ecosystems [
22]. At the same time, vegetation also directly or indirectly affects the transport of particles. Zhao, F. analyzed the characteristics of water flow near plants based on physical and mathematical models [
23]. J. Lu et al. analyzed the characteristics of water flow and the distribution of pollutants under vegetation conditions through numerical simulations [
24,
25,
26].
Fish, as an important component of river ecosystems, can serve as a crucial indicator for evaluating the quality of river ecosystems. There are many factors that affect the swimming behavior of aquatic animals such as fish, which can be roughly divided into physiological factors and environmental factors. Environmental factors mainly include food, temperature, oxygen content, pH value, and hydraulic characteristics [
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32]. Hydraulic characteristics mainly include flow velocity, water depth, turbulence intensity, flow velocity gradient, etc. Fish will gather and inhabit certain specific areas, which are suitable for fish survival [
33,
34].
In summary, water and sediment, as the primary carriers of phosphorus, are influenced by the presence of plants, which affects inter-plant water flow and sediment movement, leading to changes in phosphorus transport and distribution. Simultaneously, the transport patterns of water, sediment, and phosphorus also impact fish habitats. Therefore, the sediment–water interface (SWI), as a crucial interface in the terrestrial surface system, serves as a significant site for phosphorus migration and transformation.
This study focuses on riverbank slopes as the research area. Riverbank slopes are the most active areas for life in the river ecosystem, serving as a transition zone between water and land. They possess dual characteristics, facilitating the exchange of matter, energy, and information between aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems, and fulfilling functions such as flood control, ecological corridor, and buffer zone.
Therefore, focusing on the waters near the river bank slopes, this study developed a sediment transport program using numerical simulation. The study investigates the water flow, sediment transport patterns, water–sediment–phosphorus coupling transport patterns, and riverbed sediment release patterns near the riverbank under parallel plant distribution conditions. Based on the fuzzy mathematical model and the characteristics of water–sediment–phosphorus movement, the feasibility analysis of fish habitat suitability was carried out with the four famous domestic fishes in the Yangtze River Basin as the research object. Most previous studies have treated the movement of water, sediment, and phosphorus separately from the study of fish habitats. This study focuses on the waters near the riverbank as the primary research area, considering the impact of the transport and distribution patterns of water, sediment, and phosphorus on the fish’s living environment. It provides ideas and methods for studying nearshore phosphorus transport patterns and fish habitats.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Flow Model
The numerical simulation of hydraulic characteristics in this chapter mainly adopts the large eddy simulation turbulence model. The working principle of the LES turbulence model is to divide fluid flow into large-scale flow and small-scale flow. Large-scale flow is sensitive to boundaries and is currently mainly simulated and solved directly based on the Navier-Stokes (N-S) equation. The turbulence model filters out small-scale flow directly through filtering. For small-scale flows, which have isotropic properties and are less affected by boundary conditions, a subgrid scale model with universality for small-scale flows is established for simulation.
2.1.1. Flow Control Equation
The basic equation of turbulence model is the classical N-S equation. This chapter simulates incompressible fluid, and the equation is as follows:
Momentum equation:
where
represents instantaneous velocity in
(i represents x, y and z);
represents the mass force component in the direction;
stands for viscosity coefficient; and
p is the instantaneous pressure on the computational grid.
The filtered N-S equation is as follows:
Momentum equation:
where the subgrid stress is expressed as follows:
.
2.1.2. Subgrid Stress Model
In LES simulation, the subgrid stress model affects the accuracy of the calculation results; therefore, selecting an appropriate subgrid stress model can accurately simulate the energy transfer process between large and small scales. The research area is located near the nearshore ecological protection structure of the bank slope; therefore, the WMLES model based on the evolution of the Smagorinsky model is adopted.
The Smagorinsky has the advantages of simple form, good stability, and convenient calculation. The Smagorinsky model is similar to viscous stress in laminar flow, and the subgrid stress term
is obtained by solving the strain rate tensor
and viscous coefficient
:
is not a unique property of fluids, but a parameter based on the modeled flow field:
Among them, l represents the mixing length; q represents the flow velocity at the subgrid scale. Compared to the RANS model, the calculation of mixing length in LES is relatively simple and requires modeling the maximum scale to be similar to the filtering scale:
represents the Smagorinsky constant; and
represents the grid scale. Based on the Prandtl mixing assumption, the flow velocity at the subgrid scale is as follows:
Substitute Equations (7) and (8) into Equation (6):
The Smagorinsky subgrid model has irreversible transfer, which means that the subgrid model can only simulate the process of energy transfer from a large scale to a small scale. Meanwhile, in complex three-dimensional flows, value varies with position, and the Smagorinsky subgrid model cannot accurately simulate it.
This study chose the improved subgrid stress model WMLES based on the Smagorinsky subgrid stress model. The WMLES model overcomes the scale limitation of Reynolds number and allows for the simulation of high Reynolds number conditions:
In the formula, S is the strain rate; dw is the distance from the point to the wall; k is a constant, 0.41; Csmag = 0.2; and represents the subgrid scale size: .
2.2. Riverbed Scouring Motion Model
2.2.1. Stress Analysis of Sediment Movement
The sediment on the bank slope is mainly affected by underwater gravity (W), flow drag force (
) and Coulomb force (
), as shown in
Figure 1.
The vector form of water drag force is as follows:
where C
D is the drag coefficient, which is generally assumed to be constant; D refers to sediment particle size;
is the bank slope shear stress;
=
+
+
, represents the unit vector in the drag force direction,
,
and
are cosine values in the X, Y, Z axis directions respectively, and
and
represent the unit vector in the X, Y and Z axis directions.
The shear stress of gravity parallel to the bed surface is expressed as follows:
where
is the unit vector in the normal direction outside the bank slope, and
is the angle between
and the positive direction of Y axis, that is, the bank slope.
The Coulomb force on sediment is expressed as follows:
where
=
,
is the resultant force of sediment on the bank slope:
The included angles between the normal direction outside the bed and the X and Z axes are expressed in α and β, respectively. The satisfaction relationship between α, β and γ is .
is the angle of repose of sediment. The choice of angle of repose is based on the calculation formula obtained from test [
35]:
2.2.2. Sediment Critical Threshold Analysis
When the resultant force of the active force acting on the sediment particles and the Coulomb friction force balance, the particles reach the critical starting state, and the force balance equation is as follows:
When the slope is 0, W
t = 0, substitute Equations (13) and (14) into Equation (17):
Considering the effect of shear stress and sediment transport caused by the tangential component of gravity as a whole, an effective shear stress
and the corresponding critical starting effective shear stress
are defined in the direction of Fe.
Combine Equations (14), (18) and (19) to obtain:
Combine Equations (17), (19) and (20) to obtain:
where
is the temporary shear stress of sediment initiation; s is the relative density;
s/
,
s is the sediment density; d
50 is the median particle size of sediment; and
is the critical Shields number, as follows:
where
.
To determine whether the local sediment is scoured, the dimensionless shear stress discrimination coefficient T determines the sediment start-up:
2.2.3. Solution of Riverbed Scouring Transport
Based on the principle of sediment transport balance, the scouring and silting equation formula of riverbed changes with time:
where n is the sediment porosity of bank slope, n = 0.4;
and
respectively represent the transverse and downstream components of sediment discharge rate
, where ε and σ represent the included angle between the normal direction of bank slope and the X and Z axes:
2.3. Theoretical Equation of Discrete Phase Model
The discrete phase model simulates the motion trajectory of particles in the continuous phase through the Lagrangian tracking method, with the core assumption of ignoring the interactions between particles. According to Sommerfeld’s classical theory [
36], when the volume fraction of particle phase is less than 10%, the collision frequency between particles can be ignored. Therefore, the applicability conditions of DPM (Discrete Phase Model) are highly consistent with the working conditions of this study. The model predicts the motion trajectory of particles by solving the force balance equation. The specific method is to time integrate the resultant forces (including fluid resistance, gravity, buoyancy, and other additional forces) acting on the particles. The dynamic equation follows Newton’s second law, which is the vector balance relationship between particle inertia and external forces. The formula is as follows:
In the formula: fD is the directional force, N;
v is the fluid velocity, m/s;
is the particle velocity, m/s;
is the acceleration due to gravity, m/s2;
fx is the force per unit mass of particles, N;
is the particle density, kg/m3;
is the particle diameter, m;
is the drag coefficient;
is the relative Reynolds number of particles.
2.4. Fuzzy Mathematics Theory
The fuzzy set theory is an extension of the classical set theory with fuzzy set or membership function as the central concept. The fuzzy logic method uses fuzzy sets and fuzzy rules to infer unknown models, uncertain system descriptions, and control objects with strong nonlinearity and large delay through the judgment of uncertain concepts and reasoning thinking mode, and expresses transitional boundaries or qualitative knowledge and experience by simulating human brain. At this stage, the key hydraulic factors suitable for fish habitat have not been determined; therefore, the establishment of fuzzy mathematical model is very useful to express the distribution of fish habitat suitability.
For the regular fuzzy information problem which is difficult to be solved by conventional methods, fuzzy comprehensive judgment is adopted. According to the above analysis, fuzzy logic reasoning is divided into three steps:
The membership function is used to fuzzify the explicit value input: in fuzzy mathematics, a real number between 0 and 1 is used to reflect the degree that the element belongs to the fuzzy set, which is called membership degree. The membership function can be used to convert the general set and the fuzzy set described by membership degree. Fuzzification is to transform the explicit value into the linguistic variable value with a certain degree of membership through the membership function, which provides input for fuzzy reasoning.
Using fuzzy rules for fuzzy logic reasoning: generally, fuzzy reasoning is based on expert experience and existing conclusions to formulate fuzzy rules, and fuzzy input is transformed into fuzzy output.
The output result is defuzzified to obtain a definite value: the output result of fuzzy logic reasoning is defuzzified to convert it into a definite value. Defuzzification methods: barycenter method, area integral method, maximum method, etc. The center of gravity method is the most commonly used, and the center of gravity (cog) calculation method is as follows:
where z is the explicit value of the language variable; z1 and z2 represent the minimum and maximum values of z, respectively; μ(z) represents the membership function of the language variable C; and Vcog represents the explicit value of the final output after defuzzification.
2.5. Habitat Suitability Index
The habitat suitability index (HSI) represents the degree to which the habitat requirements of the target species in the study area are met [
37]. It is calculated using a grid as the smallest unit and directly output from the habitat model. The range of values for the habitat suitability index is between 0 (completely not meeting the target species’ habitat needs) and 1 (fully meeting the target species’ habitat needs).
2.6. Experimental Design
2.6.1. Selection of Grid Size, Initial and Boundary Conditions
In the calculation process, selecting appropriate grids can improve the convergence and accuracy of numerical simulations. In this study, the computational domain was chosen as an unstructured mesh with regular tetrahedra, which has the advantages of high generation quality, simple data structure, and convenient information storage. In order to accurately reflect the hydraulic characteristics near the coast. The grid thickness near the wall is y+ = 1, which is 2 × 10−5 m, and the laying thickness is 5 layers. The grid layout in the vicinity of the computational domain is dense, accounting for 70% of the total grid. Due to the stable boundary conditions at the far end and transition section, the grid size is appropriately increased.
The boundary conditions of the model are set as shown in
Figure 2. Use the fully developed water flow UDF file written above to set the inlet as the velocity inlet boundary (velocity inlet). The outlet is set as a pressure outlet boundary condition (pressure output). The top region of the computational domain (with slight fluctuations in the water surface) is set as a rigid cover boundary. The bottom and sides of the computational domain are set as wall boundary conditions, satisfying the no slip condition. Solution time: Time step of 1 × 10
−3 s.
In this study, the length of the computational domain will be shortened to 3.5 m long, 1 m wide, and 0.6 m high. In this study, plants were treated as discrete cylindrical units, as shown in
Figure 2. Aquatic plants have a certain height and small diameter; therefore, multiple small plants are summarized as one large plant for analysis.
The calculation area of this study is near the river bank slope, and the water–sediment–phosphorus coupling transport and distribution law near the plants under non submerged state is studied. The applicable situation is to maintain the ecological riverbank by planting plants to ensure smooth, stable, and ecological water flow near the riverbank. Small aquatic plants and large arbor are neatly arranged on the bank slope. Considering the computational cost and analysis difficulty, this study adopts plant patches for analysis, dividing the research unit into several small emergent plants and one large tree. In this study, tall grass cover plants were selected, such as miscanthus that is a perennial reed like herbaceous plant in the Poaceae family, with a stem height of over 50 cm and a diameter of over 2 mm. Due to the uniform morphology of the vegetation studied in the vertical direction, an equivalent representation of an equal diameter cylinder can be used, ignoring subtle morphological differences such as sharp top and sparse bottom of the canopy, as shown in
Figure 2. Aquatic plants have a small diameter, with a concentrated planting area. Therefore, 3–5 small plants are summarized as one large plant for analysis.
2.6.2. Test Conditions Design
The generalized simulation of the experiment is based on on-site data collected from the Three Gorges Reservoir area in the middle and upper reaches of the Yangtze River. The common bank slope gradient in the Jingjiang section of the Yangtze River Basin is generally between 15° and 40°. Therefore, the experimental bank slope in this article is selected to be around 20°, with a slope of 1:3. According to hydrological data, the average flow velocity in the middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River ranges from 0.5 to 3.0 m/s [
38]. Different conditions were simulated through experiments, and an average flow velocity of 1.3 m/s was selected as the experimental average flow velocity. Due to limitations in experimental conditions and model computational capabilities, a water depth of 0.6 m was chosen as the experimental depth. The concentrations of sediment, dissolved nitrogen, and dissolved phosphorus are 5 mg/L, 2.7 mg/L, and 0.24 mg/L, respectively, as shown in
Table 1.
2.6.3. Feasibility Verification of Numerical Models
The data generated from physical model experiments is mainly used for feasibility verification of numerical models, ensuring the accuracy and reliability of mathematical model experimental data. The physical experiment research in this article is conducted using a rectangular water tank. As shown in
Figure 3a, the water tank is a glass wall circulating water tank with a length of 30 m and a width of 2 m and the water flow cross-section and numerical model are the same. This study divides the experimental water tank into three parts: upstream transition section, experimental section, and downstream transition section. The upstream and downstream transition sections are designed to ensure a smooth, constant, and fully developed flow state of the water entering the experimental section. In the experiment, the flow rate is controlled by the inlet valve and electromagnetic flowmeter, while the water depth is controlled by an adjustable height tailgate installed at the end of the water tank.
The velocity fitting results show that the model is constructed reasonably and can be used for further research, as shown in
Figure 3b.
4. Conclusions
This article uses numerical simulation methods to develop a sediment transport model and systematically study the coupled transport laws of water, sediment, and phosphorus in the nearshore waters of emergent plants. At the same time, combining the fuzzy mathematics theory, a fish habitat suitability evaluation model is constructed with flow velocity and the nitrogen–phosphorus ratio (TN/TP) as the main influencing factors, focusing on exploring the distribution characteristics of the habitat suitability index (HSI) of nearshore fish habitats, and clarifying the impact mechanism of plants on coupled transport and fish habitats.
1. There are significant differences in flow velocity distribution among plants, and there is a strong correlation between water and sediment movement. In the direction of water flow, there is a vortex structure near the arbor, and the flow velocity is relatively low. Between the spreading structures, the measured flow velocity on the shallow water side is higher than that on the deep water side, and the distribution range of high flow velocity is wider. The distribution of flow velocity leads to differences in sediment movement at the bottom of the bank slope, and erosion mainly occurs between the spreading plants. The depth of erosion is greatest near the arbor, and the depth of erosion pits on the shallow water side is significantly greater than that on the deep water side.
2. The transport of suspended sediment and dissolved phosphorus is closely related to water flow. The flow of water between plants in the downstream direction is strong, and the high concentration areas of the two are distributed in a “strip” shape along the water flow. The proportion of high concentration areas between plants on the shallow water side is higher than that on the deep water side, and they migrate towards the deep water side after passing through arbors.
3. The concentration on the water side behind the arbor is 0 and varies with water depth. The difference in flow velocity between the two sides leads to differences in its distribution near the ground and water surface. The area with a concentration of 0 tends to have a lower flow velocity and slopes along the water depth direction, forming an inclined distribution along the water depth.
4. Arbors have a significant impact on the transport and diffusion of phosphorus. The turbulent flow characteristics and disturbance of water flow near them can promote the release of phosphorus adsorbed by sediments into the water body, while also promoting the release of dissolved phosphorus from sediment pore water into the water body, resulting in an increase in phosphorus concentration in the area and achieving dynamic release of phosphorus flux.
5. The distribution of TN/TP ratio between plants has regularity, with areas with a ratio greater than 30 dispersed and having a lower proportion. The TN/TP ratio between diffusion structures is 12–24, which is close to the Redfield value and suitable for the growth of phytoplankton.
6. There is significant differentiation in the habitat of fish in the water near plants. Under the parameter conditions of this study, the suitability index of juvenile fish in the water near the plant is 0–0.2, which is not suitable for providing a stable living environment for juvenile fish. The areas suitable for fish to lay eggs are mainly concentrated among the spreading plants, with a relatively low proportion of area. But plants can provide emergency shelter, making the waters near the plants suitable as spawning grounds for fish.
The innovation of this study lies in the development of a dedicated sediment transport model through numerical simulation, which accurately reveals the regulatory mechanism of emergent plants (especially arbor) on the coupled transport of nearshore water, sediment, and phosphorus. At the same time, a targeted fish habitat suitability evaluation model is constructed to clarify the distribution pattern of habitat suitability for different stages of fish life (juvenile fish, spawning period). The research results have enriched the research content of the coupling process of nearshore ecosystems in inland river basins, providing scientific basis and practical reference for nearshore water environment governance, aquatic organism protection, and ecosystem restoration.