Genetic Analysis and Gene Mapping for a Short-Petiole Mutant in Soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.)

Abstract

Short petiole is a valuable trait for the improvement of plant canopy of ideotypes with high yield. Here, we identified a soybean mutant line derived short petiole (dsp) with extremely short petiole in the field, which is obviously different from most short-petiole lines identified previously. Genetic analysis on 941 F₂ individuals and subsequent segregation analysis of 184 F_2:3 and 172 F_3:4 families revealed that the dsp mutant was controlled by two recessive genes, named as dsp1 and dsp2. Map-based cloning showed that these two recessive genes were located on two nonhomologous regions of chromosome 07 and chromosome 11, of which the dsp1 locus was mapped at a physical interval of 550.5-Kb on chromosome 07 near to centromere with flanking markers as BARCSOYSSR_07_0787 and BARCSOYSSR_07_0808; whereas, the dsp2 locus was mapped to a 263.3-Kb region on chromosome 11 with BARCSOYSSR_11_0037 and BARCSOYSSR_11_0043 as flanking markers. A total of 36 and 33 gene models were located within the physical genomic interval of dsp1 and dsp2 loci, respectively. In conclusion, the present study identified markers linked with genomic regions responsible for short-petiole phenotype of soybean, which can be effectively used to develop ideal soybean cultivars through marker-assisted breeding.

1. Introduction

Plant canopy architecture is an important agronomic trait for improving the yield potential in soybean and other legumes crops [1,2]. Ideal canopy structure with suitable leaf area index values has advantages of increasing light interception efficiency, that leads to increased photosynthesis as well as accumulation of photosynthetic assimilates, and eventually results in a higher yield [3,4]. It has been suggested that the desirable leaf area index of a population can be achieved by developing new cultivars for dense planting [1]. The interception capacity of crops on both direct and diffuse solar radiation is expected to increase under a horizontal canopy of dense seeding [5]. However, closed canopy profile also results in large within-canopy shading, which subsequently induces shade avoidance response and promotes lodging by excessive vegetative growth [6]. Kokubun (1988) investigated the characteristics of high-yielding soybean cultivars and proposed a high-yield ideotype model with the upper leaves vertically closed. The fraction of light absorption by the lower surface will be increased in this model [7]. Hence, it is an immediate prerequisite to modify plant canopy in a desirable direction through genetic manipulation for increasing crop yield.

Petiole length is an important trait that influences canopy architecture besides leaf petiole angle and branching capacity [8,9]. The short petiole changes geometric architecture of soybean plants and makes it possible for group canopy closing in a vertical plane when applied in dense seeding. Although the petiole length in soybean varies depending on photoperiod and light quality [9], environmental factors do not have much effect on this trait. Therefore, investigating short-petiole genetic resources is an efficient way to understand petiole development for further plant canopy improvement. Until now, various soybean mutants with short petiole have been identified as well as characterized. For example, D76-1609 and SS98206SP are two short-petiole lines which are controlled by two different single recessive genes, lps1 and lps3, respectively [10,11]. You (1998) described a short-petiole line NJ90L-1SP, which is controlled by two duplicated loci of a recessive gene, lps1, that also controls short-petiole trait in D76-1609, and lps2, which controls the abnormal pulvinus [12]. These findings suggest that lps1 and lps2 might control different stages of petiole development. In addition, Cary and Nickell (1999) described a short petiole LN89-3502TP that is controlled by a single gene with incomplete dominance (lc), fitting a 1:2:1 segregation ratio in F₂ population [13]. So far, only lps3 gene has been mapped on chromosome 13 within the flanking markers Sat_234 and Sct_033 [14]. Hence, identifying short-petiole mutant in soybean as well as the underlying gene will be helpful in promoting ideotype breeding in soybean for increasing yield.

By keeping the above in view, the present study identified a short-petiole mutant named as dsp. The objectives of our study were to elucidate the inheritance of the genes controlling short-petiole trait in dsp and to map underlying genes by using bulked segregant analysis (BSA) method.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Plant Material

The dsp is a derived soybean mutant with extremely short petiole, which is identified during soybean breeding in the field. Two crosses were made by crossing two soybean cultivars, viz., HDS-1 and BW-2, with the common dsp short-petiole mutant for genetic analysis and gene mapping of dsp. All F₁ seeds were planted and single-plant threshed. The 703 and 238 F₂ seeds were planted for HDS-1 × dsp and BW-2 × dsp F₂ populations, respectively (

Table 1. Genetic analysis of the short-petiole trait in the F₂ and F_3:4 populations.

Population	Year	No. of Wild-type Plants	No. of Mutant-type Plants	Total Number	Expected Ratio	χ2	p-Value
F2(HDS-1 × dsp)	2014	681	22	703	15:1	11.16	0.00
F2(BW-2 × dsp)	2014	230	8	238	15:1	2.91	0.09
		No. of Segregating Lines	No. of Non-segregating Lines	Total Number	Expected Ratio	χ2	p-Value
F2:3(HDS-1 × dsp)	2015	87	97	184	8:7	2.47	0.12
F3:4(HDS-1 × dsp)-Dsp1_ dsp2dsp2	2016	54	27	81	2:1	0.01	0.91
F3:4(HDS-1 × dsp)-dsp1dsp1 Dsp2_	2016	59	32	91	2:1	0.07	0.80

). All the 941 F₂ lines together with three parents were evaluated by visual inspection in the summer of 2014. In the summer of 2015, 50 seeds of 184 random F_2:3 progenies of HDS-1 × dsp were sown and used to determine the genotype of each F₂ plant.

To further validate the inheritance of dsp controlled by two loci, F₂ plants of HDS-1 × dsp with one locus as recessive homozygous and the other locus as heterozygotic were specifically selected by simple sequence repeats (SSR) markers according to gene mapping results. In this process, the flanking markers BARCSOYSSR_07_0787 and BARCSOYSSR_07_0808 for dsp1 locus and BARCSOYSSR_11_0037 and BARCSOYSSR_11_0049 for dsp2 locus were used to screen out those F₂ plants of which genotypes as Dsp1dsp1dsp2dsp2 or dsp1dsp1Dsp2dsp2. Then 81 and 91 F_2:3 dominant individuals derived from the above selected F₂ plants were randomly harvested, and 50 seeds for each F_3:4 progenies were grown to evaluate the genotype of above F_2:3 individuals in the summer of 2016 (Table 1). A total of 30 mutant individuals from F₂ populations of HDS-1 × dsp and BW-2 × dsp were collected for gene mapping. There were 132 F_2:3 recessive individuals derived from Dsp1dsp1dsp2dsp2 or dsp1dsp1Dsp2dsp2 F₂ plants used to verify the mapping results of dsp1 and dsp2 loci.

The dsp mutant has extremely short petiole, however, a very small, nonsignificant variation exists for petiole length at different leaf positions, and thus were ignored. Therefore, short petiole of dsp was regarded as a qualitative trait in our study, and the petiole length was phenotypically evaluated as mutant-type (MT) and wild-type (WT) by visual inspection.

All materials were planted at the research field in Jiangpu Experimental Station of Nanjing Agricultural University (Nanjing, China).

2.2. Genetic Analysis of dsp

A Chi-square (χ²) test (1) was used to analyze the segregation ratio of alleles with the expected ratio at a significance threshold of p-value>0.05 (χ² < 3.84) [15,16]. The formulas used are shown as below

$$\chi 2=\sum \frac{{\left(\left|O-E\right|-0.5\right)}^2}{E}$$

(1)

where O and E represent observed and expected value, respectively, under the expected ratio.

2.3. DNA Extraction and SSR Markers Analysis

A plant tissue kit from Tiangen Biotech (Beijing, China) was used to extract DNA from the young and healthy fresh leaves of three parents, F₂ generations, and 132 F_2:3 individuals derived from the crosses HDS-1 × dsp and BW-2 × dsp. PCR amplifications were performed in 10 µL reactions containing 50–100 ng of template DNA, 1 × PCR buffer, 2.0 mM MgCl₂, 75 µM of each dNTP, 0.2 µM each of the forward and reverse primers, and 0.1 U of Taq DNA polymerase. DNA polymerase, deoxy-ribonucleoside triphosphate (dNTP) mix, and DNA Ladder (50 base pairs) were purchased from Tiangen Biotech (Beijing, China). Primer sequences were obtained from SoyBase website (http://www.soybase.org) and were synthesized by Invitrogen Biological Technology (Shanghai, China). The PCR reaction was performed under the following condition: Initial denaturation at 95 °C for 5 min, followed by 29 cycles with 30 seconds of denaturation at 94 °C, 30 seconds of annealing at 43–56 °C, depending on the optimum annealing temperature for each primer pair, and 30 seconds of extension at 72 °C, with a final 10 min extension at 72 °C on a Peltier thermal cycler (PTC-225, MJ Research, Quebec, QC, Canada). The PCR products were separated by electrophoresis through 8% non-denaturing polyacrylamide gels, and then the gels were stained with 1 g L⁻¹ AgNO₃ for 15 min, followed by a 1% NaOH and 1% CH₃OH solution for 10 min before visualizing under LED light box.

2.4. Bulked Segregant Analysis (BSA) and Target Gene Mapping of the dsp Mutant

Bulked segregant analysis (BSA) was performed to identify SSR markers potentially linked to the genes responsible for short-petiole trait [17]. A total of 1015 pairs of SSR (simple sequence repeat) primers covering all the 20 chromosomes were included in this process. The normal bulk was formed by pooling DNA of six individuals with normal petiole from the F₂ populations. Similarly, the mutant bulk was created with the DNA of six individuals with short petiole. The normal and mutant DNA bulks as well as the DNA of two parents for the F₂ population of HDS-1 × dsp cross were screened with 1015 SSR markers to identify polymorphic markers that are potentially linked to the short-petiole trait of dsp. Linkage relationship of the locus and SSR markers were calculated with the program Mapmaker 3.0 [18], using a minimum LOD (logarithum of the odds) score of 3.0 and a maximum recombination value of 0.4 as a threshold. Linkage calculations were completed using the Kosambi mapping function [19]. SSR markers identified to be linked were consequently screened against the entire mapping population. Then subsequent mapping processes were conducted according to Song (2004) [20]. Searching of the physical position of the primer sequence was performed via BLASTN engine on National Center for Biotechnology Information database (NCBI) (http//www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/) and converting the genetic map to a physical map based on the physical position of SSR markers.

2.5. Synteny Information and Homologous Protein Information Retrieval

For every locus, the synteny information on genome was retrieved from the SoyBase website (https://soybase.org/) through “Genome Browser” [21]. The duplicated region of this locus (if it exists) would be displayed under the precondition of checking “old duplicated blocks” or “recent duplicated blocks” options in select track. Phytozome website (http://www.phytozome.net) [22] was used to retrieve the corresponding homologous proteins information of every candidate protein.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Characteristics of Short-Petiole Trait in the dsp Mutant

Soybean short-petiole mutant dsp has a compact stature in the natural field conditions (Figure 1), and also revealed different levels of dwarfing under different genetic background and environments (plant height variation data not shown). The petiole length of dsp was less than 2 cm, showing a difference from previously described short-petiole mutants, for instance D76-1609 (8.59 ± 0.93 cm) [10], NJ90L-1SP (7–13 cm) [12], and LN89-3502TP (5–12 cm) [13]. Moreover, dsp was relatively more valuable for progenies selection compared with NJ90-1SP and LN89-3502TP, which have inferior agronomic characters including abnormal leaf and pulvinus trait. Considering the ideal soybean architecture model proposed as compact plants with a small stature as well one or two branches [1], dsp mutant provides a valuable genetic resource for the development of a soybean ideal plant-type.

3.2. Genetic Analysis of Petiole Length in the dsp Mutant

Two crosses were made between the common short-petiole dsp mutant and two soybean cultivars with normal petiole, HDS-1 and BW-2, respectively. All the F₁ plants obtained from the two populations (HDS-1 × dsp and BW-2 × dsp) had normal petioles, indicating that the short petiole of dsp mutant was recessive to the normal petiole. This result was consistent with that of previous genetic studies based on short-petiole lines, which also revealed the recessive nature of short-petiole length in soybean [10,11,12]. However, the results of Cary and Nickell (1999) [13] were in contrast. They reported that a short petiole was controlled by a single gene with incomplete dominance.

In the F₂ population from the cross BW-2 × dsp, eight out of 238 F₂ individuals had the mutant-type phenotype the same as the dsp parent (MT plants). However, the ratio of wild-type plants (WT plants) relative to mutant-type plants (MT plants) was not significantly different from a 15:1 ratio (χ² = 2.91, p = 0.09) (Table 1). In the case of HDS-1 × dsp cross, segregation for petiole-length trait was observed in 87 of the 184 F_2:3 rows derived from 184 F₂ WT plants, which was not significantly different from a 8:7 ratio for segregating and nonsegregating in long-petiole rows (χ² = 2.47, p = 0.12) (Table 1). According to subsequent mapping results of genes responsible for dsp, F₂ WT plants with genotype as Dsp1dsp1dsp2dsp2 or dsp1dsp1Dsp2dsp2 from HDS-1 × dsp cross were screened out based on flanking markers of two mapping regions (Figure 2 and Figure 3), and random 81 and 91 F_2:3 WT plants were grouped to validate the inheritance of dsp mutant. As a result, both ratios between those segregating and homozygous (nonsegregating) F₃ individuals fit a 2:1 ratio based on F_3:4 families (χ² = 0.01, p = 0.91; χ² = 0.07, p = 0.80) (Table 1).

These results demonstrated that the short-petiole trait of dsp mutant is controlled by two recessive genes even though the segregation ratio in F₂ population of HDS-1 × dsp was significantly different from a 15:1 ratio (χ² = 11.16, p = 0.00) in the 2014 field experiment. That is probably attributed to poor emergence by poor seed quality of mutant plants (Table 1). This is somewhat similar to the case of genetic analysis for SS98206SP, a short-petiole line controlled by a single recessive gene and fit a 15:1 ratio of F₂ progenies between long and short petioles based on bad seed quality in 2006 [11].

3.3. Mapping Genes dsp1 and dsp2 with SSR Markers

Out of a total 1015 SSR markers screened for polymorphism, only 67 markers distributed to 12 chromosomes were found to be polymorphic between WT and MT DNA pools derived from F₂ population of HDS-1 × dsp cross. Finally, polymorphic markers on chromosome 07 (linkage group M) and chromosome 11 (linkage group B1) were detected to be linked with the short-petiole mutant phenotype of dsp. These genomic regions governing the mutant phenotype of dsp was named as dsp1 and dsp2, respectively.

A total of 22 and 8 F₂ MT plants from HDS-1 × dsp and BW-2 × dsp, respectively, were genotyped using linked markers screened from chromosome 07 and chromosome 11. New SSR markers from Song (2010) [23] were synthesized to narrow the mapping regions of dsp1 and dsp2 loci. Eventually, the dsp1 locus was mapped to a 550.5-Kb region on chromosome 07 with flanking markers as BARCSOYSSR_07_0787 and BARCSOYSSR_07_0808 (Figure 2). The mapping region is near to centromere according to SoyBase database [21]. A total of 36 gene models were present within this region (Glyma.Wm82.a1.v1.1) (

Table 2. List of gene models in the 550.5-Kb physical interval of the derived short-petiole1 (dsp1) locus.

Glyma.Wm82. a1.v1.1 Gene Models	Glyma.Wm82. a2.v1 Gene Models	Description
Glyma07g16731	Glyma.07g139000	Mitochondrial carrier protein
Glyma07g16740	Glyma.07g139100	Major Facilitator Superfamily
Glyma07g16750	Glyma.07g139200	Uncharacterized protein
Glyma07g16760	Glyma.07g139300	Uncharacterized protein
Glyma07g16770	Glyma.07g139400	Probable lipid transfer
Glyma07g16790	Glyma.07g139500	PRONE (Plant-specific Rop nucleotide exchanger)
Glyma07g16800	Glyma.07g139600	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16810	Glyma.07g139700	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16830	Glyma.07g139800	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16840	Glyma.07g139900	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16850	Glyma.07g140000	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16860	Glyma.07g140200	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16876	Glyma.07g140300	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16893	-	Cytochrome P450 CYP4/CYP19/CYP26 subfamilies
Glyma07g16910	Glyma.07g140400	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16925	Glyma.07g140500	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16940	Glyma.07g140700	Glutathione S-transferase, C-terminal domain
Glyma07g16950	Glyma.07g140800	Universal stress protein family
Glyma07g16970	Glyma.07g141000	Uncharacterized protein
Glyma07g16980	Glyma.07g141100	Myb-like DNA-binding domain
Glyma07g16990	Glyma.07g141200	Ctr copper transporter family
Glyma07g17000	Glyma.07g141300	Probable lipid transfer
Glyma07g17010	Glyma.07g141400	Non-specific serine/threonine protein kinase.
Glyma07g17030	Glyma.07g141500	Probable lipid transfer
Glyma07g17060	Glyma.07g141600	Ctr copper transporter family
Glyma07g17080	Glyma.07g141700	Hsp20/alpha crystallin family
Glyma07g17090	Glyma.07g141800	Uncharacterized protein
Glyma07g17101	Glyma.07g141900	Domain of unknown function (DUF3527)
Glyma07g17110	Glyma.07g142000	PAP2 superfamily C-terminal
Glyma07g17116	Glyma.07g142100	Ubiquitinyl hydrolase 1.
Glyma07g17130	Glyma.07g142300	RING-variant domain
Glyma07g17140	Glyma.07g142400	Multicopper oxidase
Glyma07g17150	Glyma.07g142500	Multicopper oxidase
Glyma07g17170	Glyma.07g142600	Multicopper oxidase
Glyma07g17180	Glyma.07g142700	Fructose-1-6-bisphosphatase
Glyma07g17190	Glyma.07g142800	Uncharacterized protein

). The dsp2 locus was mapped within a 263.3-Kb region between BARCSOYSSR_11_0037 and BARCSOYSSR_11_0049 markers on the front of chromosome 11, harboring 33 gene models (Figure 3,

Table 3. List of gene models in the 263.3-Kb physical interval of the dsp2 locus.

Glyma.Wm82. a1.v1.1 Gene Models	Glyma.Wm82. a2.v1 Gene Models	Description
Glyma11g01300	Glyma.11G011000	RNA-binding proteins
Glyma11g01310	Glyma.11G011100	Uncharacterized protein
Glyma11g01320	Glyma.11G011200	NADH: ubiquinone oxidoreductase, B17.2 subunit
Glyma11g01330	Glyma.11G011300	E3 ubiquitin ligase
Glyma11g01340	Glyma.11G011400	Translin-associated protein X
Glyma11g01350	Glyma.11G011500	Chalcone and stilbene synthases
Glyma11g01360	Glyma.11G011600	PPR repeat
Glyma11g01370	Glyma.11G011700	Nuclear transport receptor CRM1/MSN5 (importin beta superfamily)
Glyma11g01380	Glyma.11G011800	GTP-binding ADP-ribosylation factor Arf1
Glyma11g01390	Glyma.11G011900	Plant protein of unknown function (DUF946)
Glyma11g01405	Glyma.11G012000	Guanosine-3′,5′-bis(diphosphate)3′-pyrophosphohydrolase
Glyma11g01420	Glyma.11G012100	Ribonuclease P
Glyma11g01430	Glyma.11G012200	DEAD/DEAH box helicase/Helicase conserved C-terminal domain
Glyma11g01441	Glyma.11G012300	Pwwp domain-containing protein
Glyma11g01450	Glyma.11G012400	Cell division cycle 20 (CDC20) (Fizzy)-related
Glyma11g01460	Glyma.11G012500	Putative u4/u6 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein
Glyma11g01470	Glyma.11G012700	Mitochondrial outer membrane protein
Glyma11g01480	Glyma.11G012800	Galactosyltransferases
Glyma11g01491	Glyma.11G012900	Aspartyl proteases
Glyma11g01501	Glyma.11G013000	Aspartyl proteases
Glyma11g01510	Glyma.11G013100	Aspartyl proteases
Glyma11g01520	Glyma.11G013200	Uncharacterized protein
Glyma11g01530	Glyma.11G013300	PLAC8 family
Glyma11g01536	Glyma.11G013400	DYW family of nucleic acid deaminases (DYW_deaminase)
Glyma11g01543	Glyma.11G013500	PPR repeat (PPR)
Glyma11g01550	Glyma.11G013600	PPR repeat (PPR)
Glyma11g01570	Glyma.11G013700	leucine-rich PPR motif-containing protein, mitochondrial (LRPPRC)
Glyma11g01580	Glyma.11G013800	Complex 1 protein (LYR family)
Glyma11g01595	Glyma.11G013900	KH domain containing RNA binding protein
Glyma11g01610	Glyma.11G014000	Protein Phosphatase methylesterase-1 related
Glyma11g01620	Glyma.11G014100	Cytochrome c
Glyma11g01640	Glyma.11G014200	Ethylene-responsive transcription factor ERF021
Glyma11g01650	Glyma.11G014300	Nuclear transport factor 2 (NTF2) domain

). Furthermore, these F_2:3 MT plants from Dsp1dsp1dsp2dsp2 or dsp1dsp1Dsp2dsp2 F₂ individuals were used to confirm the mapping regions. Among them, 86 F_2:3 MT plants from Dsp1dsp1 dsp2dsp2 F₂ plants were utilized to validate the mapping result of dsp1. Then dsp1 was mapped to the same genomic region as identified earlier using F₂ populations (Figure 2). Similarly, 46 F_2:3 MT plants from dsp1dsp1 Dsp2dsp2 F₂ plants confirmed the locus dsp2. The right boundary of dsp2 is definite with BARCSOYSSR_11_0049, which is also consistent with the mapping result of dsp2 in F₂ populations (Figure 3). The petiole length of dsp mutant is very similar to another SS98206SP line, while the lps3 locus underlying short petiole of SS98206SP was reported to be mapped on chromosome 13 [14]. Hence, dsp is a novel short-petiole line different from SS98206SP.

Based on the synteny information obtained from SoyBase [21], the mapping region of dsp1 and dsp2 belongs to two nonhomologous fragments on chromosome 07 and chromosome 11, respectively (Figure 4). Furthermore, homologous protein information retrieved from Phytozome [22] revealed that none of the encoding proteins within both regions displayed homology (Table 2 and Table 3). Hence, these two above loci identified to be responsible for short-petiole phenotype of the dsp mutant did not function as duplicated genes.

As a paleopolyploid, the genome of soybean contains 70.3% duplicate regions due to two whole genome duplication (WGD) events [24,25,26,27]. Duplicated genes may undergo pseudogenization, sub-functionalization, or neo-functionalization [28], and the divergence of duplicated genes is thought to provide the basis for adaptive evolution [29]. For example, among the four homologous genes of the Arabidopsis terminal flower gene (TFL1) in soybean, only one has been found to control growth habit; the other copies may have additional functions because they have been reported to show different transcriptional patterns [30]. A disease-like rugose leaf phenotype in soybean was attributed to two recessive duplicated loci of rl1 and rl2 [31]. In our study, all genes located within the mapping regions of dsp1 and dsp2 loci have one or more duplicated copies in other chromosomes. The duplicated effect of dsp1 and dsp2 candidate genes on the short petiole of dsp mutant indicated the possible functional differentiation or genetic interaction during petiole development. Therefore, the short petiole of dsp mutant is a complex trait, and the identification of candidate genes underlying dsp1 and dsp2 loci will greatly help to clarify the mechanism of petiole development.

4. Conclusions

In summary, we identified a novel short-petiole mutant line “dsp” that was demonstrated to be controlled by two recessive gene designated as dsp1 and dsp2. The mapping of dsp1 and dsp2 revealed a redundant function between two nonhomologous loci on the formation of short petiole. Hence, the present study provides potential genetic resources, linked markers as well as genes governing the short petiole in dsp mutant, and these valuable genes will be in turn used for rapid introgression into elite soybean backgrounds for developing cultivars with short petiole and high yield via marker-assisted breeding. Therefore, the availability of these resources could greatly facilitate the dream of developing soybean ideotype.