3.2.1. Optical and Color Properties
The optical and color properties of the films prepared from PVA with
Clitoria ternatea L. flower anthocyanin extracts are presented in
Table 4. Gloss at 60°, CIE Lab* parameters, hue angle, chroma, and color difference were determined, providing a detailed view of the visual appearance of the obtained materials.
The optical properties of the studied formulations vary according to the addition of anthocyanin extract (EAC). The films progressively darkened, as evidenced by the decrease in luminosity (L*), and exhibited more intense tones toward green and blue, indicated by negative a* and b* values. Furthermore, increasing anthocyanin content generated more saturated colors and more perceptible color changes relative to the control, observed in higher chroma (C) and total color difference (ΔE) values. Gloss also followed a similar trend, increasing from 18 (PA-C) to 41 (PA-A30). This can be attributed to anthocyanins, which are highly sensitive to the chemical conditions of the medium and possess a molecular structure that interacts intensely with light. Additionally, their flavonoid structure contains conjugated double bonds that enable absorption of visible light, particularly at wavelengths corresponding to red, purple, and blue colors [
28]. As anthocyanin content in the film increases, greater light absorption occurs, manifesting as reduced luminosity (L*) and the appearance of darker colors. Simultaneously, the specific chemical form adopted by the pigment within the polymeric matrix—determined by factors such as pH and molecular interactions—promotes structures that reflect bluish and greenish tones [
29]. This explains the negative values recorded in the a* and b* coordinates. From an optical perspective, higher pigment concentration intensifies selective light scattering and absorption phenomena, altering both gloss and color purity (C). Consequently, the progressive increase in ΔE demonstrates the significant chromatic effect exerted by anthocyanin incorporation into the material.
In summary, anthocyanin incorporation significantly modifies the visual appearance of the films, imparting darker and bluer tones as their proportion in the formulation increases.
3.2.2. Transmittance and Opacity
Figure 4 shows the direct transmittance spectra in the UV-Vis range (200–900 nm) of the films prepared from PVA with EAC addition. Transmittance measures the passage of light through the films [
30], thereby indicating the transparency of the studied films.
The control film (PA-C) exhibited the highest transmittance across the visible spectrum, remaining around 47–48%, demonstrating high transparency and low light absorption. With the addition of small amounts of anthocyanin (PA-A5 and PA-A10), transmittance decreased moderately, especially in the 400–500 nm region corresponding to the maximum absorption of these pigments. This reduction was more pronounced in PA-A10 than in PA-A5, confirming greater light absorption with increasing colorant concentration. At higher concentrations (PA-A20 and PA-A30), the decrease in transmittance was even more marked. PA-A20 recorded values between 25% and 42%, while PA-A30 showed the lowest transmittance (10–28%), indicating a notably darker and less transparent material. This behavior is consistent with the strong capacity of anthocyanins to absorb light in the visible region, particularly at short wavelengths (400–500 nm), explaining the greater opacity observed in films with higher pigment loading [
31].
In
Table 5, the opacity values of the films prepared from PVA with EAC are presented. Opacity relates to the fraction of light blocked or absorbed by the film and is inversely related to transmittance. In this sense, the control film (PA-C), formulated without anthocyanin, recorded the lowest opacity value (1.27), confirming its high transparency compared to the other samples. The incorporation of increasing amounts of anthocyanin (PA-A5 and PA-A10) generated a progressive increase in opacity, attributable to the pigment’s capacity to absorb radiation in the UV-Vis range and thereby reduce light passage through the material. This trend aligns with the previously reported transmittance patterns.
In formulations with higher pigment concentration (PA-A20 and PA-A30), opacity increased substantially, reaching its maximum value in PA-A30 (4.52). This result reflects a notably darker film with lower light transmission, evidencing the opacifying effect of anthocyanin. This behavior is explained by the highly conjugated molecular structure of the pigment, which favors intense absorption of visible light [
32]. Statistical differences among samples (indicated by different superscripts,
p < 0.05) validate that each increase in anthocyanin concentration generates a significant change in opacity, ruling out random variation.
These findings confirm anthocyanin’s role as a light-absorbing agent, with efficacy intensifying proportionally with its concentration. This direct relationship is explained by the conjugated molecular structure of the pigment, which enhances absorption of ultraviolet and visible radiation, imparting protective properties against light exposure to the material.
3.2.3. Physical Properties and Water Absorption
Table 6 presents the mean values and standard deviation of the physical properties and water absorption of the films developed from PVA with EAC. The evaluated parameters include thickness (μm), water vapor permeability (WVP), moisture content (Xw), and water absorption capacity (WCA) of the studied films. Incorporation of EAC modified the physical properties of the obtained materials relative to the control film.
Thickness increased with EAC incorporation, reaching maximum values in PA-A20. This increase can be attributed to the additional solid content introduced by the extract and to the establishment of intermolecular hydrogen bonding between hydroxyl groups of PVA and phenolic groups present in the anthocyanins. These interactions likely promote partial molecular rearrangement and increased matrix compactness during film formation, contributing to changes in thickness. The extract is expected to remain physically entrapped within the polymeric network rather than forming covalent bonds. Regarding water vapor permeability (WVP), an initial increase was observed in formulation PA-A5, followed by a reduction at higher concentrations. At low extract levels, the incorporation of anthocyanins may disrupt the continuity of the polymer network, increasing free volume and facilitating water vapor diffusion. At higher concentrations, however, enhanced intermolecular interactions and possible matrix reorganization may reduce molecular mobility and improve barrier properties [
33], who analyzed PVA films with purple tomato anthocyanin extract and found that thickness increases with higher extract concentration, while WVP also varies. On the other hand, water absorption capacity (WCA) decreased significantly in all formulations containing anthocyanins compared to the control (PA-C), reflecting lower hydrophilicity. This is likely due to interactions between PVA hydroxyl groups and phenolic compounds in the extract, reducing the availability of hydrophilic sites for water binding [
34]. Moisture content (Xw) showed similar values across all formulations, indicating that extract addition does not significantly alter residual moisture in the dry material. Nevertheless, the integrated analysis of thickness, water vapor permeability, and absorption capacity reveals that anthocyanins induce structural modifications that directly affect the stability and functional performance of the films [
35].
Therefore, although moisture content (Xw) showed no significant differences, the combined relationship of increased thickness, reduced water absorption, and variations in permeability demonstrates that anthocyanins act as structuring agents within the PVA matrix, altering molecular organization and, consequently, functional performance as a packaging material.
3.2.4. Contact Angle
Figure 5 compares the water contact angle (CAw) and oil contact angle (CAo) for different film formulations developed from PVA with EAC addition. The contact angle is an indicator of the hydrophilic or hydrophobic properties of the films. Addition of anthocyanin extract (EAC) produced a significant modification in the water contact angle, which increased progressively from 25.3° in the control film (PA-C) to 39.13° in formulation PA-A30. This increase evidences a reduction in surface hydrophilicity as extract concentration rises, a trend that correlates with the previously observed decrease in water absorption capacity (WCA). The phenomenon can be attributed to interactions between phenolic compounds in the extract and PVA hydroxyl groups, reducing the availability of active sites for water molecule binding [
34]. This explanation consistently integrates both reduced surface hydrophilicity and lower water absorption. Collectively, the results support the hypothesis that anthocyanins exert a structuring effect in the polymeric matrix, generating a surface less affinitive to water and, consequently, with greater potential stability in humid environments. In contrast, the oil contact angle (CAo) showed relatively homogeneous values among formulations, with no significant differences between the control film (PA-C) and those with low or moderate extract concentrations. However, formulation PA-A30 exhibited a considerable increase compared to the other groups. This behavior indicates that material oleophobicity remains practically unaltered with reduced or intermediate anthocyanin incorporation but can increase significantly at higher concentrations [
36].
The behavior toward water and oil demonstrates that the extract selectively modifies surface affinity, predominantly affecting interaction with polar substances. Collectively, the contact angle, water absorption, and permeability data show structural coherence and confirm that extract incorporation not only alters internal film morphology but also modulates surface behavior toward liquids of different polarities.
3.2.5. Mechanical Properties
Mechanical properties allow assessment of film strength and flexibility.
Table 7 shows the mean values and standard deviation of mechanical properties (EM: elastic modulus, TS: tensile strength, E: elongation at break) of the studied formulations.
TS values refer to the maximum resistance of the films before rupture. A decrease in this parameter is observed as (EAC) increases. Similarly, EM values, a key indicator of material rigidity, exhibit the same behavior. Additionally, E values show a direct proportional relationship with (EAC). This may be related to interactions between the extract and the polymeric structure. Its phenolic compounds, containing multiple hydroxyl groups, interfere with hydrogen bonds that maintain the polymeric network. This reduces internal cohesion, increases chain mobility, and produces a plasticizing effect. Furthermore, extract addition may create microscopic irregularities and decrease polymer crystallinity, preventing ordered chain organization. As a result, the matrix becomes less rigid and more flexible, reducing tensile strength [
37]. Similar behavior was reported by [
38], where biodegradable chitosan and poly (vinyl alcohol) (PVA) films with
Clitoria ternatea L. anthocyanin extract showed decreased TS and EM values with increasing extract, achieving tensile strength of 11.02 MPa and elongation of 48.00%. According to one study, optimal tensile strength in edible films is 11.417 N/mm
2. However, mechanical stability may decrease with excessive ingredient addition, while anthocyanin incorporation contributes to increased film flexibility [
39]. According to research published in [
39], the incorporation of anthocyanins from red cabbage into κ-carrageenan/CMC films induced notable alterations in their mechanical properties. Specifically, a slight increase in tensile strength (TS) was observed at low dosages of the extract, which is attributed to the formation of hydrogen bonds between the pigments and the polymer matrix, resulting in a denser network. However, upon increasing the pigment concentration, a decrease in TS and a more pronounced reduction in elongation at break (EAB) were recorded, reflecting a loss of flexibility and an increase in material rigidity. These findings suggest that while anthocyanins can act as reinforcing agents at low concentrations, an excess of them disrupts the cohesion of the polymeric structure. Consequently, when contrasting these results with those of other intelligent films, the existence of an optimal anthocyanin level that
harmonises acceptable mechanical performance with its capacity to respond as an indicator is confirmed.
The molecular weight of Polyvinyl Alcohol (200,000 g/mol) is a key factor in the mechanical properties of the system, as longer polymer chains promote greater entanglement and a higher density of hydrogen bonding interactions, contributing to an initially more resistant and cohesive matrix. However, the progressive incorporation of the additive alters these intermolecular interactions, reducing the entanglement efficiency characteristic of a high molecular weight PVA [
40]. Consequently, a decrease in tensile strength and elastic modulus is observed, along with an increase in elongation at break, indicating a more ductile behaviour associated with greater mobility of the polymer chains.
3.2.7. Evaluation of Film Performance in a Food Matrix
The shrimp was selected as a study model because it is a highly perishable marine product that undergoes rapid biochemical and microbiological changes after harvest. During spoilage, shrimp exhibit appreciable increases in pH and generate volatile nitrogenous compounds, such as ammonia and trimethylamine, widely recognised as indicators of freshness loss. These characteristics make it a suitable matrix for evaluating the responsiveness of colorimetric indicators intended for applications in intelligent packaging. However, since the detection mechanism of the films is based on interaction with basic volatile compounds associated with protein degradation, their potential application is not limited exclusively to shrimp but could extend to other protein-rich food matrices with similar spoilage patterns, such as fish, other seafood, and fresh meats. Nevertheless, specific studies would be necessary to validate their performance in each particular system.
Color responses of each film at different pH values are presented in
Table 8. Films prepared with
Clitoria ternatea L. extract showed clearly time- and anthocyanin concentration-dependent color variations (see
Figure 7). On day 0, all formulations exhibited light or dark bluish tones. During days 3, 5, 8, and 12, due to gradual interaction with volatile compounds released by shrimp (stored with the films in hermetic Ziploc
®®-type bags), a progressive transition to greenish-blue or green tones was observed, especially in formulations with higher extract concentration (PA-A20 and PA-A30). This is evidenced by increased b* (tendency toward yellow) and decreased a* (greater tendency toward green), as well as changes in hue angle h, which increased in several formulations as storage progressed. Luminosity values (L*) also varied over time, showing initial increases followed by stabilization, coinciding with slight surface lightning during the first days. Chroma (c*) decreased more markedly in formulations with lower anthocyanin concentrations, suggesting gradual loss of color saturation as films reacted with volatile nitrogenous compounds [
43,
44].
Although the present study demonstrates the effectiveness of the films as non-contact colourimetric indicators, the potential migration of anthocyanins from the PVA matrix into food systems represents an important safety consideration. Due to the hydrophilic nature of both poly(vinyl alcohol) and anthocyanins from Clitoria ternatea, diffusion of bioactive compounds could occur under conditions of direct contact, high moisture content, or prolonged storage. In the experimental design employed here, film fragments were suspended inside a sealed system without direct contact with the shrimp, thereby limiting migration through physical transfer or surface moisture interaction. Nevertheless, this configuration does not replace a standardised migration assessment. Therefore, future investigations should include global and specific migration tests using appropriate food simulants, followed by spectrophotometric or chromatographic quantification of released anthocyanins. Such studies would allow a more comprehensive evaluation of the material’s compliance with food-contact safety regulations and contribute to the optimisation of film formulation for commercial intelligent packaging applications.
Total color difference (ΔE) showed perceptible variations in all formulations, with values well above the threshold ΔE > 5, indicating clearly visible differences to the naked eye. PA-A20 and PA-A30 exhibited the largest changes between days, reaching ΔE values above 20 at certain points, confirming their sensitivity to chemical environmental changes caused by shrimp spoilage [
45].
Overall, these results demonstrate that the films respond differently depending on incorporated anthocyanin concentration and confirm their capacity to detect volatile compounds associated with spoilage, exhibiting color change transitions that can be interpreted visually without specialized instruments. As stated by Zhao et al. [
46], these films have potential for use as colorimetric sensor labels. However, to date, the use of natural pigments for manufacturing pH-sensitive intelligent colorimetric products has not been widely reported. Additionally, film RGB values can be converted to total volatile basic nitrogen (TVB-N) values and analyzed automatically via a smartphone application to determine meat freshness [
47].
Although total color difference (ΔE) values exceeded 5 in all formulations—indicating clearly perceptible color changes to the naked eye and thereby confirming the films’ sensitivity to chemical changes induced by shrimp spoilage a limitation inherent to the anthocyanins from
Clitoria ternatea must be acknowledged. In the typical pH range of shrimp muscle during storage and spoilage, these anthocyanins maintain a dominant blue coloration with only subtle variations in intensity, transitioning from light blue to bluish-green or greenish-blue, rather than exhibiting sharp or dramatic color shifts. As evidenced in
Figure 8 and
Table 3, these changes are reliably quantifiable using instrumental methods; however, visual perceptibility may be less pronounced under practical conditions, such as variable lighting or in the absence of direct side-by-side comparison, potentially limiting the indicator’s utility for rapid, unaided visual assessment by non-expert users [
48].
To overcome this limitation and enhance visual contrast in the alkaline pH ranges relevant to seafood spoilage, future formulations could explore blending
C. ternatea anthocyanins with other natural pigments known for more pronounced pH-dependent transitions, such as anthocyanins from red cabbage or curcumin. Such hybrid systems may produce larger ΔE values and clearer visual cues while retaining the advantages of natural and sustainable indicators [
49].
These results can be compared with those of [
9], who state that this color behavior relative to the film and food matrix may reflect pH changes during the decomposition process.
3.2.10. First-Order Kinetic Model for Evaluating Shrimp Spoilage via TVB-N Formation
Figure 10 and
Table 9 show the kinetics of total volatile basic nitrogen (TVB-N) formation and the kinetic parameters of the first-order model in refrigerated shrimp at 5 °C covered with intelligent anthocyanin films. The temporal evolution of TVB-N exhibits a linear relationship with first-order kinetic fit, demonstrating a direct correlation between storage time and accumulation of these compounds. This sustained increase reflects typical proteolytic decomposition and microbial development processes in refrigerated fishery products. The slope of the kinetic equation (5.5783) quantifies the generation rate of basic volatile compounds, predominantly ammonia, trimethylamine (TMA), and dimethylamine (DMA), originating from degradation of proteins and nitrogenous precursors such as trimethylamine oxide [
52]. Progressive accumulation of these substances constitutes a reliable indicator of freshness and sensory quality loss in crustaceans, justifying its inclusion in international quality regulations [
53].
Regarding growth parameters (see
Table 9), these reveal a high-rate constant (k = 5.57 day
−1), confirming rapid generation of volatile compounds despite refrigeration, characteristic of shrimp high perishability. Initial TVB-N content (Q
0 = 5.60 mg/100 g) and estimated shelf life (4.4 ± 0.23 days) establish the period until reaching the regulatory spoilage limit (generally 30 mg/100 g in European standards). Half-life (t
1/2 = 2.01 ± 0.15 days) evidences the rapid doubling of initial TVB-N, while the coefficient of determination (R
2 = 0.997) validates the precision of the kinetic model in describing the spoilage mechanism. These quantitative parameters provide a scientific basis for predicting product behavior during refrigerated storage. Selection of this model was appropriate because it described progressive formation of volatile basic nitrogen (TVB-N) in marine products during refrigerated storage. The study by Wannawisan et al. [
52] demonstrated that TVB-N accumulation follows linear behavior with respect to time, showing high coefficients of determination (R
2 > 0.98), confirming that its increase depends directly on advancement of microbial and enzymatic spoilage.