Next Article in Journal
Optimizing Fe-N-C Electrocatalysts for PEMFCs: Influence of Constituents and Pyrolysis on Properties and Performance
Next Article in Special Issue
Eco-Friendly Synthesis of Thiazole Derivatives Using Recyclable Cross-Linked Chitosan Hydrogel Biocatalyst Under Ultrasonic Irradiation as Anti-Hepatocarcinogenic Agents
Previous Article in Journal
Copper-Catalyzed Benzothiazolyldifluoroalkylation of Arylidenemalonitriles or para-Quinone Methides
Previous Article in Special Issue
Exploring the Synthesis of Novel Sillenite Bi12SnO20: Effect of Calcination Temperature on the Phase Formation and Catalytic Performance
 
 
Article
Peer-Review Record

The Activation of Oxygen Species on the Pt/CeO2 Catalyst by H2 for NO Oxidation

Catalysts 2024, 14(11), 778; https://doi.org/10.3390/catal14110778
by Xiangru Li 1, Shuangye Li 1, Yao Cheng 1, Lechen Zheng 2, Liyun Song 1, Xuehong Zi 2,* and Hongxing Dai 2
Reviewer 1: Anonymous
Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Catalysts 2024, 14(11), 778; https://doi.org/10.3390/catal14110778
Submission received: 27 September 2024 / Revised: 28 October 2024 / Accepted: 31 October 2024 / Published: 4 November 2024
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Catalytic Energy Conversion and Catalytic Environmental Purification)

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

The article is devoted to the optimization of the conditions for the preparation of Pt-CeO2 catalysts for the NO oxidation reaction. The authors use different calcination temperatures and additionally reduce the catalysts with hydrogen.

However, the effects of the heat treatment conditions are very insignificant in the opinion of the reviewer. Judging by Fig. 1, an increase in the calcination temperature only worsens the properties of the catalyst, while reduction with hydrogen slightly improves the conversion of NO. In this case, it is necessary to indicate the temperature and time of treatment with hydrogen. The authors do not compare the obtained results with literature data, so it remains unclear what the advantages of the systems used are.

When analyzing the structure of the catalysts, inaccuracies and errors are allowed. For example, when analyzing DRIFTS data on CO adsorption (section 2.3.6.2), almost no references to the literature are given when assigning spectra. In Fig. 8 bands 2166, 2117, which the authors attribute to Ce3+ and Pt2+, are apparently related, according to the literature, to the spectrum of gaseous CO, so their disappearance after purging with nitrogen is quite natural. The bands in the region of 1600-1200, which the authors unreasonably attribute to the adsorption of CO on different forms of platinum, are apparently related to the formation of CO oxidation products, carbonates, oxalates, etc. The characteristics of CO on different forms of platinum and cerium are well known.

(see, for example,(M. Y. Mihaylov, et al., Catalysis Today, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cattod.2019.05.014

F. C. Meunier Relevance of IR Spectroscopy of Adsorbed CO for the Characterization of Heterogeneous Catalysts Containing Isolated Atoms https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jpcc.1c06784)

The authors often draw conclusions about the presence of a Pt-O-Ce bond, in particular, in TEM analysis (lines 190-194), however, a uniform distribution of elements on the surface does not yet indicate their interaction.

Table 1 shows the kinetic parameters for NO oxidation over Pt/CeO2. It is not clear whether the data in the bottom 3 lines are the results of the authors of this article or are literary. And if these are the results obtained in this work, then why is their production and properties not described.

In the opinion of the reviewer, the article cannot be published in this form.

Author Response

Reviewer #1: The article is devoted to the optimization of the conditions for the preparation of Pt-CeO2 catalysts for the NO oxidation reaction. The authors use different calcination temperatures and additionally reduce the catalysts with hydrogen. However, the effects of the heat treatment conditions are very insignificant in the opinion of the reviewer.

Comments 1: Judging by Fig. 1, an increase in the calcination temperature only worsens the properties of the catalyst, while reduction with hydrogen slightly improves the conversion of NO. In this case, it is necessary to indicate the temperature and time of treatment with hydrogen. The authors do not compare the obtained results with literature data, so it remains unclear what the advantages of the systems used are.

Response: We have indicated the temperature and time of treatment with hydrogen in the H2 pretreatment procedure of the catalysts in the revised manuscript. In addition, we have also compared catalytic activities of our 1 wt% Pt/CeO2 catalysts before and after H2 reduction treatment and the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2 catalyst reported in the literature [24] in the revised text.

Modification: Lines 127~129/Page 4: During the H2 pretreatment process, the total flow rate of 10% H2/N2 was 200 mL/min. The catalyst was thermally treated in a heating rate of 5 ℃/min at 200 ℃ for 30 min.

            Lines 131~135/Page 4: Compared to the NO reaction rate of 0.13 μmol/(g·h) at 325 oC over the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2 catalyst reported in the literature [24], those over the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2 catalysts before and after H2 reduction treatment obtained in the present work were 0.76 and 0.87 μmol/(g·h), respectively. Obviously, our catalyst outperformed the catalyst reported in the literature [24].

 

Comments 2: The bands in the region of 1600-1200 cm-1, which the authors unreasonably attribute to the adsorption of CO on different forms of platinum, are apparently related to the formation of CO oxidation products, carbonates, oxalates, etc. The characteristics of CO on different forms of platinum and cerium are well known. (see, for example, M. Y. Mihaylov, et al., Catalysis Today, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cattod.2019.05.014; F. C. Meunier Relevance of IR Spectroscopy of Adsorbed CO for the Characterization of Heterogeneous Catalysts Containing Isolated Atoms https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jpcc.1c06784).

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good comment. We have cited several references to make the appropriate band assignment in the revised text.

Modification: Lines 368~373/Page 12: The CO-DRIFTS spectra of CO adsorption on the catalysts are shown in Figure 9. The band at 2086 cm-1 was associated with the linear adsorption of CO on Pt nanoparticles. For the catalyst calcined at 500 °C, the band observed at 2117 cm-1 was attributed to the linear adsorption of CO on the oxidized Pt species, the one at 2166 cm-1 was linked to the CO adsorbed on the Ce3+ ions [33,39], and the ones at 1481 and 1566 cm-1 were related to the products (e.g., carbonates) of CO oxidation [30].

 

Comments 3: The authors often draw conclusions about the presence of a Pt-O-Ce bond, in particular, in TEM analysis (lines 190-194), however, a uniform distribution of elements on the surface does not yet indicate their interaction.

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good comment. It can be found from the TEM images (Figure 3a and b) that the lattice fringes of CeO2 and PtO2 species are clearly seen in the Pt/CeO2 catalysts calcined at 500 and 800 oC, indicating the possible formation of a Pt-O-Ce-like bond. Such a deduction was confirmed by the subsequent EDS mappings of Pt, O, and Ce elements, in which the Pt species were uniformly dispersed on the CeO2 support (i.e., there might be the formation of a Pt-O-Ce-like bond).

         We have made up the XPS characterization of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 and 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-600 catalysts before and after H2 pretreatment, and their XPS spectra are shown Figure 7. The positions of the O 1s, Pt 4f, and Ce 3d peaks of the two catalysts after H2 pretreatment were significantly shifted, revealing the formation of a Pt-O-Ce-like bond in the Pt/CeO2 catalysts.

Modification: Please see Figures 3a and b and 7.

Figure 3a and b. TEM images of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2 catalysts calcined at (a) 500 °C and (b) 800 °C.

Figure 7. (a) O 1s, (b) Pt 4f, and (c) Ce 3d XPS spectra of the as-prepared catalysts.

Modification: Lines 207~212/Page 6: It can be found from the TEM images (Figure 3c1 and c2) that the lattice fringes of CeO2 and PtO2 species are clearly seen in the Pt/CeO2 catalysts calcined at 500 and 800 oC, indicating the possible formation of a Pt-O-Ce-like bond. Such a deduction was confirmed by the subsequent EDS mappings of Pt, O, and Ce elements, in which the Pt species were uniformly dispersed on the CeO2 support (i.e., there might be the formation of a Pt-O-Ce-like bond).

            Lines 322~325/Page 10: The XPS spectra of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 and 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-600 catalysts before and after H2 pretreatment are shown Figure 7. The positions of the O 1s, Pt 4f, and Ce 3d peaks of the two catalysts after H2 pretreatment were significantly shifted, revealing the formation of a Pt-O-Ce-like bond in the Pt/CeO2 catalysts.

 

Comments 4: Table 1 shows the kinetic parameters for NO oxidation over Pt/CeO2. It is not clear whether the data in the bottom 3 lines are the results of the authors of this article or are literary. And if these are the results obtained in this work, then why is their production and properties not described?

Response: The data in the bottom 3 lines are from the literature [25,26].

Modification:  Line 169/Page 4: The reference numbers (Refs. 25 and 26) have been indicated in Table 1.

Catalyst

Ea

(kJ/mol)

Feed gas composition

Ref.

Fresh

H2 pretreatment

 

 

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500

23.7

19.5

500 ppm NO, 10% O2, N2 (balance)

This work

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-600

26.7

20.9

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-700

31.1

30.6

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-800

32.2

31.8

0.5 wt% Pt/CeO2-500

31.4

-

500 ppm NO, 10% O2, N2 (balance)

[25]

1.7 wt% Pt/SiO2-500

57.7

-

250 ppm NO, 3.5%O2, N2 (balance)

[26]

0.35 wt% Pt/CeZrO2-500

34.6

-

500 ppm NO, 8% O2, N2 (balance)

[26]

 

Reviewer 2 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

  This manuscript describes the effect of H2 pretreatment of Pt/CeO2 catalyst for NO oxidation, using temperature programmed spectroscopy techniques. While these spectroscopic investigations gave the insights into the electronic states of the catalyst, supports for these findings by other characterization techniques should be necessary. The revision by explanation of following concerns will improve the quality of manuscript suitable for Catalysts.

 

 

1. The particle size is critical to catalytic performance. But the effect of H2 treatment on Pt particle sizes is not clearly unveiled. High-resolution TEM measurement of the catalysts is necessary to confirm the particle sizes.

 

2. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy is recommended to investigate the oxidation state of the catalysts and effect of H2 pretreatment.

 

3. How is the durability of the catalysts? Time-dependence of NO oxidation activity of the catalyst is important.

 

4. The authors claim that “It is evident that the NO2 signal intensity of the catalyst after H2 reduction treatment is higher than that of the untreated catalyst”. However, it is difficult to understand this conclusion from NO-TPSR results in Fig. 5.

 

5. Fig.10 should be revised to illustrate the catalytic mechanism more clearly. The temperature programmed spectroscopy results identified gaseous molecules with various adsorption structures. Identify which is the most effective for the catalytic performance.

 

Author Response

Reviewer #2: This manuscript describes the effect of H2 pretreatment of Pt/CeO2 catalyst for NO oxidation, using temperature programmed spectroscopy techniques. While these spectroscopic investigations gave the insights into the electronic states of the catalyst, supports for these findings by other characterization techniques should be necessary. The revision by explanation of following concerns will improve the quality of manuscript suitable for Catalysts.

Comments 1: The particle size is critical to catalytic performance. But the effect of H2 treatment on Pt particle sizes is not clearly unveiled. High-resolution TEM measurement of the catalysts is necessary to confirm the particle sizes.

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good suggestion. We made up the high-resolution TEM images of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 catalysts before and after H2 treatment, as shown in Figure 3c and d. Due to the similar contrast of Pt and Ce, it was difficult to distinguish them in the high-resolution TEM images. Therefore, we did not provide the sizes of Pt particles before and after H2 treatment.

Modification: Please see Figure 3c and d.

Figure 3c and d. (c, d) HRTEM images of 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 before and after H2 pretreatment.

            Lines 212~216/Page 7: The high-resolution TEM images of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 catalysts before and after H2 treatment are shown in Figure 3c and d. Due to the similar contrast of Pt and Ce, it was difficult to distinguish them in the high-resolution TEM images. Therefore, the sizes of Pt particles before and after H2 treatment were not provided.

 

Comments 2: X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy is recommended to investigate the oxidation state of the catalysts and effect of H2 pretreatment.

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good suggestion. The related revision has been made, as shown in the modification below.

Modification: Please see Figure 7a-c and Table 3.

Figure 7. (a) O 1s, (b) Pt 4f, and (c) Ce 3d XPS spectra of the as-prepared catalysts.

Table 3. The surface element compositions of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2 catalysts obtained by the XPS technique.

Catalyst

Molar ratio

Pt0/(Pt2++ Pt4+)

Ce3+/Ce4+

Oads/Olatt

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500

0.86

0.18

0.35

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-600

0.48

0.25

0.32

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500-H2

0.98

0.49

0.51

1 wt% Pt/CeO2-600-H2

0.86

0.37

0.35

 

Lines 286~326/Page 9~10: The metal chemical valence and adsorbed oxygen species of the catalysts play important roles in catalyzing NO oxidation. The XPS characterization experiments of the Pt/CeO2 catalysts were performed, and the results are shown in Fig. 7 and Table 3. Each of the asymmetrical O 1s XPS spectra of the catalysts could be divided into three components at binding energies of 529.3, 531.3, and 533.1 eV (Figure 7a), which were attributed to the surface lattice oxygen (Olatt), adsorbed oxygen (Oads), and adsorbed water or carbonate species, respectively. The Oads/Olatt molar ratios of Pt/CeO2-500 and Pt/CeO2-600 increased from 0.35 and 0.32 to 0.51 and 0.35 after H2 pretreatment, respectively. The increase in Oads/Olatt molar ratio enhanced the catalytic activity of the Pt/CeO2 catalyst for NO oxidation.

The Pt 4f XPS spectra of Pt/CeO2-500 and Pt/CeO2-600 are shown in Figure 7b. Pt was present mainly in metallic state (Pt0) and platinum oxide (Ptn+, i.e., Pt2+ and Pt4+). The deconvoluted components at binding energies of 71.5 and 74.8 eV were related to the 4f7/2 and 4f5/2 states of the surface Pt0 species, those at binding energies of 72.6 and 75.9 eV were assigned to the 4f7/2 and 4f5/2 of the surface Pt2+ species, and the those at binding energies of 74.2 and 77.5 eV were ascribed to 4f7/2 and 4f5/2 states of the surface Pt4+ species. The signals of Pt 4f5/2 were 3.3 eV higher than those of Pt 4f7/2. After H2 treatment, the Pt4+ species nearly disappeared. The Pt0/ (Pt2+ + Pt4+) molar ratios on the surface of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 and 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-600 catalysts before and after H2 treatment were from 0.86 and 0.48 to 0.98 and 0.86, respectively. In other words, the rise in Pt0/ (Pt2+ + Pt4+) molar ratio increased the activity of the Pt/CeO2 catalyst after H2 treatment for NO oxidation.

The deconvolution of Ce 3d XPS spectra (Figure 7c) indicates that both Ce3+ and Ce4+ species exist on the surface of Pt/CeO2. It is generally believed that oxygen vacancies are generated to maintain the electroneutrality of a catalyst owing to the existence of Ce3+. The higher the content of Ce3+, the more the oxygen vacancies. The H2 pretreatment increased the content of Ce3+, leading to an increase in oxygen vacancy concentration on the catalyst surface. The Ce3+/Ce4+ molar ratios of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 and 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-600 catalysts before and after H2 treatment were from 0.18 and 0.25 to 0.49 and 0.37, respectively. It is well known that oxygen vacancies on the surface of a catalyst can adsorb O2 to generate the reactive adsorbed oxygen species. Hence, the more the oxygen vacancies, the better catalytic activity of the Pt/CeO2 catalyst.

 

Comments 3: How is the durability of the catalysts? Time-dependence of NO oxidation activity of the catalyst is important.

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good suggestion. We have conducted the catalytic stability test of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 catalyst after H2 pretreatment at 325 ℃ for 10 h. Apparently, no significant decreases in NO conversion were observed in 10 h of NO oxidation under the adopted reaction condition.

Modification: Please see Figure 1c.

Figure 1c. ... and (c) catalytic stability of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 catalyst after H2 pretreatment.

Lines 136~139/Page 4: The catalytic stability test of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 catalyst after H2 pretreatment was carried out at 325 ℃ for 10 h of NO oxidation, and its result is shown in Figure 1c. Apparently, no significant decreases in NO conversion were observed in 10 h of NO oxidation under the adopted reaction condition.

 

Comments 4: The authors claim that “It is evident that the NO2 signal intensity of the catalyst after H2 reduction treatment is higher than that of the untreated catalyst”. However, it is difficult to understand this conclusion from NO-TPSR results in Fig. 5.

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good comment. The mentioned sentence has been deleted in the revised manuscript.

 

Comments 5: Fig.10 should be revised to illustrate the catalytic mechanism more clearly. The temperature programmed spectroscopy results identified gaseous molecules with various adsorption structures. Identify which is the most effective for the catalytic performance?

Response: After H2 pretreatment, the Ce4+ species in CeO2 were partially reduced to the Ce3+ species, forming a large number of oxygen vacancies on the catalyst surface. Molecular oxygen could be first adsorbed at the oxygen vacancies and Pt sites, which then reacted with the adsorbed NO. The active adsorbed oxygen species might be the most effective factor for the high activity of the Pt/CeO2 catalyst.

Modification: Please see the modified figure below.

Figure 11. Catalytic mechanism diagram of NO oxidation over Pt/CeO2.

Lines 450~454/Page 14: After H2 pretreatment, the Ce4+ species in CeO2 were partially reduced to the Ce3+ species, forming a large number of oxygen vacancies on the catalyst surface. Molecular oxygen could be first adsorbed at the oxygen vacancies and Pt sites, which then reacted with the adsorbed NO. The active adsorbed oxygen species might be the most effective factor for the high activity of the Pt/CeO2 catalyst. 

Round 2

Reviewer 1 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

The article can be published

Author Response

Thank you for your review and support of our manuscript.

Reviewer 2 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

The authors revised the manuscript according to the reviewers comment. While a part of the revision satisfied the reviewer, some significant concerns still remain in the manuscript.

 

1. The explanation for the NO-TPSR results shown in Figure 5 is insufficient. The authors should discuss the difference between each sample.

 

2. The authors conducted the temperature-programmed measurements and various spectroscopic techniques to identify the oxidation state of each element in the catalysts and the adsorption mode of the gaseous molecules on the catalysts. However, such information obtained by the authors is not depicted in Figure 11. The current figure can be drawn without the knowledge obtained in the research.

 

Author Response

Comments1: The explanation for the NO-TPSR results shown in Figure 5 is insufficient. The authors should discuss the differences between each sample.

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good comment. The related revision has been made, as shown in the modification below.

Modification: Lines 251~256/Page 8: As shown in the NO-TPSR profiles of the 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-500 and 1 wt% Pt/CeO2-800 samples (Figure 5), the intensity of NO2 signal was stronger in the sample treated in H2 at 500 or 800 ℃ than that  in the sample treated in air at 500 or 800 ℃, indicating H2 treatment was beneficial for the improvement in catalytic activity of the sample. The worse activity of the sample treated at 800 ℃ than the sample treated at 500 ℃ might be due to its sintering.

 

Figure 5. NO-TPSR profiles of the catalysts before and after H2 pretreatment at 500 and 800 °C.

 

Comments 2: The authors conducted the temperature-programmed measurements and various spectroscopic techniques to identify the oxidation state of each element in the catalysts and the adsorption mode of the gaseous molecules on the catalysts. However, such information obtained by the authors is not depicted in Figure 11. The current figure can be drawn without the knowledge obtained in the research.

Response: Thank the Reviewer for the good comment. We have added the related characterization results of temperature-programmed measurements and various spectroscopic techniques to Figure 11 in the revised manuscript. 

Modification: Please see Figure 11 on Lines 451~453/Page 14: 

 

Figure 11. Catalytic mechanism diagram of NO oxidation over Pt/CeO2.

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Back to TopTop