1. Introduction
Broiler chicken diets primarily consist of cereals, which are often contaminated with multiple mycotoxins [
1]. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), above 25% of the global food crops are contaminated with mycotoxins [
2], causing a USD 5 billion annual economic loss for North America [
3]. The fungi
Fusarium verticillioides and
Fusarium proliferatum are prominent pathogens of corn and produce fumonisins (FB1, FB2, and FB3), while
Fusarium graminearum and
Fusarium culmorum (and other species) infect corn, wheat, and other grains and produce the mycotoxins deoxynivalenol (DON) and zearalenone (ZEA) [
4,
5].
According to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the maximum permissible levels for FB1 and DON in the finished feed for broiler chickens are 50 and 5 mg/kg, respectively [
6], and no guidelines have been established for ZEA in growing chickens. Additionally, according to the European Union (EU), the maximum permissible levels for fumonisins (FB1 + FB2), DON, and ZEA in poultry feed are 20 mg/kg, 5 mg/kg, and 0.25 mg/kg, respectively [
7]. In North American commercial poultry settings, 92% of the finished diet contains more than one mycotoxin, according to the BIOMIN mycotoxin survey, 2023 [
8]. Among these, fumonisins (FBs) and DON are the most prevalent mycotoxins detected in 70% of the tested corn samples. The average concentration of FBs was 4.2 mg/kg, with a maximum of 83.3 mg/kg, while DON averaged 1.4 mg/kg, with a maximum concentration of 11.3 mg/kg detected in corn samples [
8]. This co-occurrence of multiple mycotoxins in poultry feed [
9], even at subclinical doses, which are well below FDA regulations of 50 mg/kg diet of FB and 5 mg/kg diet of DON, causes adverse effects on chicken growth performance [
10]. Further, these subclinical doses of FB1 and DON in feed predispose broiler chickens to various diseases, including coccidiosis [
11], necrotic enteritis [
6], and salmonellosis [
12], by compromising immune function and damaging gut integrity.
Currently, there are no biomarkers to detect subclinical mycotoxicosis in poultry, and identifying subclinical mycotoxicosis in poultry based on production performances is not practical. Therefore, it is important to identify biomarkers for FB1 and DON toxicity that can accurately pinpoint real-time mycotoxin exposure and toxicity to facilitate early intervention. Mycotoxins are metabolized to various degradation derivatives in the digestive tract, intestinal mucosa, liver, and kidneys [
13]. Quantifying mycotoxins and their metabolites in various biological matrices, such as excreta [
14], plasma or serum [
14,
15], muscle, liver, kidney [
16,
17,
18], and feed [
19,
20], are currently available biomarkers for detecting mycotoxicosis. However, due to the lack of commercial standards, these methods have challenges in detecting phase I and II mycotoxin metabolites [
21]. The mere quantification of FBs in feed or the liver cannot predict mycotoxicosis because chickens often do not exhibit clinical signs of toxicity. FB1 exposure can be identified by analyzing the altered ratio of the sphingolipids, particularly sphinganine (Sa)/sphingosine (So), in the serum and tissue [
22]. In chickens, exposure to 20 mg/kg of FB1 for nine days caused detectable changes in the Sa/So ratio in muscle and liver tissues [
23,
24]. However, these doses did not reflect any detectable changes in the plasma Sa/So ratio [
24]. In addition, feed processing methods, such as heat processing, increase protein-bound fumonisins. Although the protein-bound form is not toxic, free mycotoxins could be released into the digestive tract and cause toxicity [
25,
26]. Another concern is that although FBs were identified in feed, liver, and muscle, the birds exhibited no clinical signs of toxicity [
27,
28,
29,
30], thereby questioning the validity of utilizing serum or liver FBs content as a biomarker of FBs contamination in poultry. In poultry species, DON and its bio-transformed product, de epoxy-deoxynivalenol (DOM-1), are not considered ideal biomarkers because their levels are below the detection limits in chicken blood and excreta [
31,
32,
33,
34]. Further, LC-MS/MS and LC-HRMS analysis involve complex instrumentation, making it difficult to quantify the DON and other bio-transformed products, such as DON-3-sulfate and DON-15-sulfate [
33]. This complexity may lead to an underestimation of mycotoxin levels in foodstuffs and an associated increase in health risks to consumers.
In poultry, the absorption of mycotoxins like FBs and DON varies from 1% to 6% and is associated with decreased gut integrity [
35]. Additionally, FBs and DON undergo entero-hepatic circulation, resulting in reabsorption and prolonged retention in the gut. This limited absorption of FBs and DON [
35,
36,
37] indicates that a substantial portion of non-absorbed toxin remains within the lumen of the gastrointestinal tract (GIT) and targets the gut epithelial cells. Since mycotoxicity leads to gut damage, assessing the intestinal permeability using FITC-d (4 kD) [
38] can be used as an indicator for detecting both acute and chronic mycotoxicity. Among other modes of action, both FBs and DON directly inhibit protein synthesis, leading to decreased serum immunoglobulin levels and serum protein levels, as well as increased apoptosis in the liver. Hence, gut inflammatory markers and apoptosis-related markers could serve as potential biomarkers to identify FBs and DON exposure.
In recent years, microRNAs (miRNAs) have emerged as a promising class of biomarkers for monitoring toxicity and diseases in farm animals [
39]. These biomarkers can show alterations in their expression before pathophysiological changes occur [
40,
41]. They are very stable in biofluids [
42,
43], and expression is often tied to inflammatory pathways [
44]; thus, miRNAs can be desirable molecular biomarkers in response to acute environmental cues [
45]. Studies have identified potential miRNA biomarkers for poultry diseases like Marek’s disease [
46], avian leukosis [
47], infectious bursal disease [
48], avian influenza [
49], and chicken necrotic enteritis [
50]. Studies in chickens have also examined the role of miRNA in identifying the toxicity mechanisms of aflatoxin B1 in Roman laying hens [
51] and ochratoxin A in broiler chickens [
52]. However, to the best of our knowledge, there has been no research on utilizing miRNA as biomarkers of FB1, DON, and ZEA toxicity in broiler chickens. Identifying miRNA biomarkers of mycotoxicosis is underexploited and has great potential to allow non-destructive, real-time tracking of mycotoxin exposure in poultry. Thus, the objective of this study was to quantify the effects of different combinations of subclinical doses of FB1, DON, and ZEA on production performance, blood biochemistry, gut permeability on day 14 and day 21, and miRNA expression on day 14 to identify potential biomarkers for early mycotoxin exposure.
3. Discussion
This study identified possible biomarkers for exposure to subclinical doses of combined FB1, DON, and ZEA. According to the BIOMIN Mycotoxin Survey 2023, approximately 92% of corn and corn by-products [
8] were contaminated with more than one mycotoxin, contributing to a USD 900 million annual economic loss due to the contamination of FBs, DON, ZEA, and aflatoxin B1. Hence, this study aimed to identify biomarkers for combined exposure to subclinical mycotoxins and exposure to major mycotoxins, including FB1, DON, and ZEA, that could be detected in commercial settings as early as 14 d after exposure. In the current study, birds exposed to subclinical doses of 2.0 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet had decreased BWG at d 21, increased gut FITC-d permeability, higher early, late, and total apoptotic cell percentages, and lower phosphorus, glucose, and potassium, and higher total protein in the serum by day 21. On d 14, broiler chickens exposed to subclinical concentrations of 21.0 mg FB1 + 3.0 mg DON + 1.0 mg ZEN/kg diet had higher expressions of miRNA gga-let-7a-5p, gga-miR-19b-3p, gga-miR-9-5p, gga-miR-217-5p, gga-miR-133a-3p, and gga-miR-215-5p in the liver.
The selected mycotoxin concentrations aimed to simulate real-world contamination levels encountered in commercial poultry production, ranging from low risk to high levels of subclinical exposures without exceeding FDA guidance limits. However, the variability in mycotoxin concentrations across treatment groups reflects real-world challenges, as achieving consistent toxin ratios, especially with DON to ZEA culture materials, is quite challenging. Despite thorough mixing to minimize variability, “hot spots” mimic practical feed contamination scenarios. While precise dose–response effects are influenced by environmental factors such as temperature and humidity, observed trends in this present study, particularly at higher toxin concentrations, suggest a general dose-dependent relationship. This approach highlights the complexities of co-contamination and provides insights into subclinical mycotoxin exposure risks in poultry.
In the current study, FB1, DON, and ZEA concentrations were below the FDA guidance levels. As mycotoxins are ubiquitous in nature, even though clean corn was used to produce the basal diet, natural contamination in the finished diet reflects the field conditions. Hence, in this current study, the starter basal diet in the control group was naturally contaminated with 0.4 mg/kg FB1 and 0.6 mg/kg DON [
10]. The mycotoxin levels in the basal diet (FB1; 0.4 mg/kg and DON; 0.6 mg/kg) were much lower than the regulatory guidance levels (e.g., FDA limits: 50 mg/kg FB1 and 5 mg/kg DON for broiler finished feed). Considering all experimental groups, including the control, were fed the same baseline diet, the background contamination had an identical impact on each group. This guarantees that the variation observed between treatment groups can still be caused by the additional mycotoxin exposure introduced in the treatments. Subclinical concentrations of mycotoxins had no impact on production performances until d 14. However, on d 21, the BWG was decreased by 13%, even at the lowest subclinical concentration of 2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet. When the mycotoxin concentration was increased to 21 mg FB1 + 3 mg DON + 1 mg ZEA/kg diet, it further decreased the BWG up to 17%. These findings are consistent with previous research by Kubena et al. (1997) [
53], who reported a 19% reduction in BWG on d 21 when chickens were exposed to 300 mg FB1+ 15 mg DON per kg diet. Similar results were observed in broiler chickens exposed to 20 mg FUM + 1.5 mg DON/kg diet and 20 mg FUM + 5.0 DON/kg diet for 21 d, resulting in a 6% decrease in BWG [
54]. The presence of multiple mycotoxins in poultry diets, even at low doses, had a negative effect on chicken production performance [
10,
54], and earlier studies reported the negative effects of DON on production performance at doses only above 5 mg/kg diet [
55]. In this present study, even in groups with a diet containing 2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet, there is a reduction in BWG. This significant decrease in BWG among the mycotoxin treatment groups suggests that because of the lowest bioavailability of FBs and DON, even the low levels of combined toxins in the feed likely contribute to gut damage. This intestinal damage is most likely linked to reduced nutrient absorption and increased maintenance demands on the gut, leading to higher metabolic costs for tissue repair and immune system activation, ultimately resulting in decreased BWG in chickens.
In the present study, even the lowest concentration of mycotoxins (2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet) increased gut permeability, with higher doses further increasing gut permeability both on d 14 and d 21. These results suggest that the presence of DON as low as 2.5 mg/kg feed can compromise gut integrity irrespective of FB1 and ZEA concentration. A similar finding was observed when broiler chickens were exposed to 3 mg FB1 + 4 mg DON per kg diet [
10] and/or 5 mg/kg DON alone, resulting in compromised intestinal integrity [
56]. The absorption of FB1 and DON in poultry is low, typically ranging from 1% to 6% [
35], meaning that a substantial portion of feed mycotoxin remains in the gastrointestinal tract [
36,
37]. In addition, FB1 and DON undergo entero-hepatic circulation, resulting in prolonged exposure of gut epithelial cells to these mycotoxins [
38]. Mycotoxins induce oxidative stress [
57] and inflammatory responses [
58], which further compromise gut health. Gut microbiota can biotransform mycotoxins, such as DON, FB1, and ZEA, into secondary metabolites, which may have less, similar, or even greater toxicity. These metabolites could potentially act on the gut lining, leading to inflammation and increased permeability [
59]. In this study, a general tendency for a dose-dependent increase in serum FITC-d was observed, which indicates that the FITC-d assay can be a potential biomarker for evaluating d 14 and d 21 when combined mycotoxin exposure concentrations, even at 2.0 FB1 + 2.5 DON + 0.9 ZEA mg/kg diet.
Subclinical exposure to multiple mycotoxins causes damage to internal organs without causing overt clinical signs. In this study, exposure to even low concentrations of 2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet was sufficient to increase AST concentrations in all experimental groups on d 21, whereas, on d 14, concentrations with high FB1 of 21 mg/kg (T6) and high DON of 3.5 mg/kg (T4) showed a significant increase in serum AST. Elevated AST concentrations correlated with mycotoxin-induced histological changes in liver tissues that included necrosis, apoptosis, and inflammatory infiltrates. Hepatocellular injury releases AST into the circulation [
60], and thus, increased AST concentrations reflect significant hepatocellular damage and compromised liver function [
61,
62]. Mycotoxins can interfere with various hepatic metabolic pathways, including gluconeogenesis [
63]. In the present study, histological changes in liver tissues, including necrosis, apoptosis, and inflammatory infiltrates in all the treatment groups, correlated with elevated AST levels across all treatment groups.
CK is crucial for maintaining cellular energy homeostasis by catalyzing the transfer of a phosphoryl group from ATP to creatine to produce phosphocreatine (PCr), which acts as a buffer and transporter of energy [
64]. PCr shuttles energy to ATP-dependent enzymes like Na
+, K
+-ATPase, and H
+-ATPase, which are essential for cellular ionic balance and pH regulation [
65]. Studies suggest that mycotoxins impair the CK/PCr system, reducing ATP availability and thus compromising ATPase activities, affecting Na
+, K
+, and Ca
2+ balance, and disrupting ATP production and energy homeostasis [
66]. In the current study, an increased concentration of CK was observed in birds exposed to even the lowest doses of mycotoxins (2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg feed) as early as day 14 and continuing through day 21. This clearly indicates that combined mycotoxins, even at subclinical doses, affect CK activity. Thus, elevated serum CK indicates extracellular leakage of the enzymes into the bloodstream due to tissue injury and intracellular inhibition of CK activity, reducing the availability of ATP and compromising Na
+, K
+-ATPase, and H
+-ATPase activity. A previous meta-analysis study identified that exposure to 0.95 mg/kg for aflatoxins or 4.29 mg/kg DON, 2.87 mg/kg T2 toxin, 0.78 mg/kg ochratoxins, or 5.05 mg/kg ZEA or 112.80 mg/kg FUM can disrupt metabolic pathways and cause hepatic and kidney damage [
67]. Our study findings suggest that elevated serum AST and CK may be biomarkers of subclinical mycotoxicity. However, more investigation is required to understand the ontogeny of biomarker changes and whether these changes are specific to an individual or a combination of mycotoxins.
In the present study, serum phosphorus (P) levels were significantly decreased at low concentrations (2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet) on d 21. This reduction is most likely due to a cytoprotective mechanism where serum P is used to produce phosphorylated sphingosine, which serves as a defense against the toxic effect of FB1 [
68]. Additionally, the ingestion of fusarium mycotoxins impairs kidney function, which affects P homeostasis and causes increased excretion of P in urine, causing a decrease in serum P concentration [
69]. P availability is critical for physiological functions such as bone development, and the reduction in P availability across all treatment groups may contribute to the decreased growth performance observed in those birds [
70,
71]. Blood glucose concentrations were also significantly lower in all treatment groups compared to control groups. The T4 treatment groups, which had a DON concentration of 3.5 mg/kg, showed a greater reduction in glucose levels. DON is known to decrease gut integrity and downregulate the expression of sodium-dependent glucose transporters (SGLT-1, GLUT-2) in the intestine [
72,
73], leading to a decrease in blood glucose concentrations [
74]. A similar result was observed when the pigs exposed to a combined dose of DON 1.0 mg + ZEA 1.04 mg/kg diet decreased the sucrase, maltase, and lactase enzyme activities in the intestine [
75]. This suggests that when the mycotoxin concentrations are even at 2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet, they are sufficient to decrease the blood glucose levels. There were no significant differences in d 14 serum phosphorus and glucose concentrations, which shows that these cannot be potential biomarkers for detecting day 14 exposure.
In this study, 21-day exposure to FB1 + DON + ZEA had a significant impact on potassium homeostasis across all treatment groups, but there was no significant effect on day 14 potassium concentrations, which shows that serum potassium concentration can be a potential biomarker for the lowest mycotoxin concentrations of 2 mg FB1 + 2.5 mg DON + 0.9 mg ZEA/kg diet on day 21. Similar results were observed when broiler chickens were exposed to 1.7 mg DON + 0.2 mg ZEA/kg diet for 35 days [
76]. Serum potassium level is considered an indicator of protein metabolism, and decreased levels are associated with decreased catabolism and nephrotoxicity. Potassium is primarily reabsorbed in the kidneys, particularly in the proximal tubules, and is secreted in the distal tubules [
77]. The decreased serum potassium level observed in this study is most likely linked to impaired renal function due to multiple mycotoxin exposure. In addition, potassium is an indicator of overall metabolic health, and the decreased serum levels could indicate disruptions in protein metabolism and overall catabolism, leading to significant biochemical changes in blood parameters, including alterations in electrolyte balance [
61,
62].
In this study, we also aimed to assess whether combined exposure to mycotoxins altered miRNA expression before the presence of observable damage in the gut and liver. We tested miRNA expression on d 14, prior to any significant histological changes or functional impairments in these organs. The results showed that even at this early time point, exposure to 21 mg FB1 + 3 mg DON + 1 mg ZEA/kg diet caused a significant upregulation of liver miRNAs, including gga-let-7a-5p, gga-miR-19b-3p, gga-miR-9-5p, gga-miR-217-5p, gga-miR-133a-3p, and gga-miR-215-5p. These changes in miRNA expression suggest that alterations in gene regulation can occur before any overt damage to the gut or liver, highlighting the potential of miRNAs as early biomarkers for detecting mycotoxin exposure and its subclinical effects. Additionally, studies on these miRNAs in poultry and other species indicated that gga-miR-155 and gga-miR-9-5p play an important role during inflammation [
78,
79,
80]. miRNAs such as gga-miR-29c-3p and gga-miR-217-5p are involved in apoptosis [
81,
82,
83], and gga-miR-375 is related to oxidative stress [
84]. Further, gga-miR-19b-3p and gga-miR-133a-3p are involved in lipid metabolism and growth [
85,
86,
87], and gga-miR-215-5p, and gga-let-7a-5p have roles in the cell differentiation process [
88,
89,
90]. The expression of the gga-miR-155, gga-miR-375, and gga-miR-29c-3p miRNAs was not affected by the mycotoxin exposure levels analyzed in this study. Increased expression of gga-let-7a-5p miRNA indicates that mycotoxins cause stress to hepatocytes and promote liver apoptosis. Similarly, upregulation of gga-miR-217-5p expression suggests the presence of oxidative stress since gga-miR-217-5p stimulates apoptosis-related pathways in order to remove any damaged cells and maintain cell homeostasis in the liver [
83]. The overexpression of gga-miR-19b-3p suggests that mycotoxins are causing inflammation in the hepatocytes by activating the NF-κB signaling, which in turn increases the production of inflammatory cytokines [
91]. miRNA gga-miR-215-5p controls cell cycle and proliferation [
92], and overexpression of gga-miR-215-5p can be a host compensatory response to mitigate cell damage caused by mycotoxins. Studies have also shown that, both in vitro and in vivo, mycotoxicosis can modify the expression of specific miRNAs [
93]. ZEA exposure in pigs modifies ssc-miR-455-5p, 493-3p, 135a-5p, 432-5p, 542-3p, and 493-3p, and aflatoxin B1 exposure modifies gga-miR-301a-3p and gga-miR-301b-3p miRNA in poultry [
51]. These modifications suggest that miRNAs are potential biomarkers for detecting mycotoxin exposure. These above studies suggest that the expression pattern of miRNAs could serve as a potential marker to track subclinical mycotoxicity and disease severity in chickens.
Out of nine candidate miRNAs, gga-let-7a-5p, gga-miR-19b-3p, gga-miR-9-5p, gga-miR-217-5p, gga-miR-133a-3p, and gga-miR-215-5p can be used as biomarkers for detecting subclinical concentrations of combined mycotoxin exposure, particularly at the 21 mg FB1 + 3 mg DON + 1 mg ZEA/kg diet (T6). These combined doses of mycotoxins significantly upregulate miRNAs, suggesting that these miRNAs are particularly reliable for detecting mycotoxin exposure. While serum FITC-d, AST, and CK levels provide valuable information about mycotoxin-induced damage even at subclinical doses, changes in miRNA expression detected at day 14 suggest that miRNAs are more sensitive and timelier tools for identifying early disruptions in gene regulation. Further histological changes, such as necrosis, apoptosis, and gut integrity, were observed at day 21 and were preceded by alterations in miRNA expression at day 14. These results suggest that miRNA could serve as an early biomarker for subclinical mycotoxicity and a useful molecular tool for detecting mycotoxin exposure before severe pathological damage. This ability to detect changes in miRNA expression as early as 14 days after exposure would help farmers take preventive measures and reduce economic losses.
In commercial settings, chickens are rarely exposed to individual mycotoxins. Therefore, the findings from this study provide insights into the combined effects of mycotoxins under practical conditions, even if precise interactions (synergistic, additive, or antagonistic) could not be separately evaluated. While single-toxin treatment groups could have allowed us to analyze specific interactions, outcomes vary depending on several factors, including toxin type, dosage, and duration of exposure. For example, some studies have demonstrated that the co-occurrence of DON and ZEA has a synergistic effect on intestinal integrity [
75,
94,
95], while other combinations may show antagonistic effects [
75,
96]. Hence, results of the current study are especially relevant to poultry, where chickens are exposed to several mycotoxins.
In summary, subclinical exposure to combined FB1 + DON + ZEA (<5 mg/kg DON and 50 mg/kg FB1) increased intestinal permeability by 1-fold, liver total apoptotic cells by 8-fold, decreased serum P by 57%, increased serum total protein by 40%, decreased serum glucose by 8%, and decreased serum potassium concentrations by 50% on day 21. Serum FITC-d could serve as a potential biomarker for detecting mycotoxin doses of 9 FB1 +3.5 DON +0.7 ZEA and above for 14 d exposure. However, miRNAs gga-let-7a-5p, gga-miR-19b-3p, gga-miR-9-5p, gga-miR-217-5p, and gga-miR-215-5p by several folds, these miRNAs could serve as potential biomarkers at doses of 21 mg FB1 + 3 mg DON + 1 mg ZEA/kg diet for 14 d exposure. However, further research is needed to validate the expression patterns of these liver miRNAs with those in serum and jejunum. This will not only help us to understand the molecular mechanisms involved in the mycotoxin-induced apoptosis but also allow early diagnosis of mycotoxin exposure, thereby facilitating timely intervention strategies.