Next Article in Journal
A Balanced Risk-Benefit Analysis to Determine Human Risks Associated with Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids (PA)—The Case of Herbal Medicinal Products Containing St. John’s Wort Extracts (SJW)
Previous Article in Journal
Effects of Fish Oil on Lipid Metabolism and Its Molecular Biological Regulators in Chronic Ethanol-Fed Rats
 
 
Search for Articles:
Title / Keyword
Author / Affiliation / Email
Journal
Article Type
 
 
Advanced Search
 
Section
Special Issue
Volume
Issue
Number
Page
 
Journals
Nutrients
Volume 10
Issue 7
10.3390/nu10070803
nutrients-logo
Submit to this Journal Review for this Journal Propose a Special Issue
► Article Menu

Article Menu

share Share announcement Help format_quote Cite question_answer Discuss in SciProfiles thumb_up
...
Endorse textsms
...
Comment
first_page
settings
Order Article Reprints
Font Type:
Arial Georgia Verdana
Font Size:
Aa Aa Aa
Line Spacing:
Column Width:
Background:
Article

Assessment of the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria for Restricting Children’s Food and Beverage Marketing in Canada

by
Christine Mulligan
1,
Marie-Ève Labonté
2,
Laura Vergeer
1 and
Mary R. L’Abbé
1,*
1
Department of Nutritional Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON M5S 3E2, Canada
2
School of Nutrition & Institute of Nutrition and Functional Foods, Laval University, Québec City, QC G1V 0A6, Canada
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Nutrients 2018, 10(7), 803; https://doi.org/10.3390/nu10070803
Submission received: 25 May 2018 / Revised: 13 June 2018 / Accepted: 19 June 2018 / Published: 22 June 2018
Versions Notes

Abstract

:
Imposing governmental restrictions on the marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages to children is a demanded policy action since in Canada, this remains self-regulated by the voluntary, industry-led Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative (CAI) whose participants pledge to only advertise products that satisfy its Uniform Nutrition Criteria to children. This study evaluated the stringency of this nutrient profiling (NP) model for restricting child-directed food and beverage marketing in Canada. Data was obtained from the University of Toronto Food Label Information Program (FLIP) 2013 database, providing nutritional information for 15,342 packaged products which were evaluated using the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria. Products with child-directed packaging and those from CAI participating companies were identified. Of the n = 15,231 products analyzed, 25.3% would be allowed and 57.2% would be restricted from being marketed to children according to the CAI Criteria. Additionally, 17.5% of products lacked criteria by which to evaluate them. Child-directed products represented 4.9% of all products; however, 74.4% of these would be restricted from being marketed to children under CAI standards. Products from CAI participating companies represented 14.0% of all products and 33.3% of child-directed products; 69.5% of which would be restricted from being marketed to children. These results indicate that if the CAI was mandatory and covered a broader range of advertising platforms, their Uniform Nutrition Criteria would be relatively stringent and could effectively restrict children’s marketing in Canada.

1. Introduction

Poor diet has been identified as a leading risk factor for death and disability among many Canadians [1]. The elevated prevalence of obesity in Canada contributes to a significant portion of this mortality risk [2]. Canadian children are not exempt from this trend, with the Heart and Stroke Foundation reporting that childhood obesity rates have tripled since 1979 [3], and the 2015 Canadian Community Health Survey showing that over one third of Canadian children currently have overweight or obesity [4].
A growing body of evidence shows that food and beverage advertising to children is playing a detrimental role in the childhood obesity crisis [5,6,7,8,9,10]. There is consensus in the literature that child-directed food products are typically energy dense and nutrient poor, and therefore do not represent ideal food choices for children [6,7,11,12]. Studies have shown that exposure to child targeted advertising results in increased consumption of less healthful foods by children and youth [6,7,10,13]. In response, government restrictions on unhealthy food and beverage marketing to children have been widely proposed as a means of protecting the health of this vulnerable population [3,5,7,8,13,14,15].
Currently in Canada, the only body overseeing food and beverage marketing to children is the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative (CAI), introduced and monitored by Advertising Standards Canada as of April 2007 [16]. The CAI is an industry-led, voluntary code, currently holding commitments from 18 companies [16]. These companies have pledged to either eliminate advertising to audiences under 12 years of age entirely, or to advertise only products that meet the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria, a nutrient profiling (NP) model implemented by the CAI in December 2015 [16,17]. NP is the science of determining the degree of healthfulness of food products based on a set of nutritional criteria for a variety of nutrition-related public health purposes, such as restricting food and beverage marketing to children [18].
Since its development, the CAI has expanded its coverage to include media channels such as television, websites, video games and child-directed mobile media [16,17]. However, the CAI’s framework does not currently address all media used to market to children, such as child-directed product packaging, leaving manufacturers free to advertise to children on product packaging regardless of the nutritional quality of the product [16]. Studies have shown that voluntary, self-regulated initiatives such as the CAI have limited effectiveness in reducing children’s exposure to the promotion of unhealthy foods, further suggesting a need for government regulations on the marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages to children [15,19,20].
Therefore, the objective of this project was to evaluate the stringency of applying the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria for the purpose of restricting unhealthy food and beverage marketing to children in the Canadian context. Secondary objectives were to examine the extent to which products with child-directed packaging and products from CAI participating companies meet the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Study Design

A cross-sectional analysis of the 2013 Canadian packaged food supply was conducted using nutritional data sourced from the University of Toronto Food Label Information Program 2013 database (FLIP 2013). Briefly, FLIP 2013 includes information on 15,342 unique packaged food products from the four top Canadian supermarket chains (Metro, Loblaw’s, Safeway, and Sobeys) which represent approximately 75% of the Canadian grocery retail market share. For each food product, FLIP 2013 includes information such as the nutritional values reported in the Nutrition Facts table (NFt), the list of ingredients, front-of-pack information (e.g., nutrient content claims and disease risk reduction claims), and company and brand information. Photos of products’ packaging are also available for analysis. The database is organized based on Schedule M of the Food and Drug Regulations (version current between 15 March 2012 and 13 December 2016) [21]. Schedule M includes 22 major food categories, and 153 subcategories. A more detailed description of FLIP 2013 is provided elsewhere [22].

2.2. Product Classification into CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria Categories

First, products were classified into their appropriate CAI food categories and subcategories as described in the CAI White Paper [17]. Products that did not fall into any of the designated product categories were classified either as “Automatically Allowed” (products automatically allowed to be marketed to children; e.g., pure frozen fruits or vegetables), “Automatically Restricted” (products that are automatically restricted from being marketed to children; e.g., soft drinks), or as “No Criteria” (products for which the CAI has not established nutritional criteria; e.g., spices and sauces) [17].
Following the initial classification, a 10% random verification of the classifications into CAI food categories and subcategories was performed by a second evaluator, and a 95% agreement level was achieved. Categories with higher levels of disagreement (i.e., “Snacks”, “Dairy products and substitutes”, “Desserts”) were examined in depth, with any discrepancies resolved through consensus between researchers.

2.3. Product Evaluation Using the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria

Each product was evaluated based on the nutritional criteria outlined in the CAI White Paper for its respective subcategory [17]. For a product to “meet” the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria, it had to satisfy the criteria for both the “nutrients to limit” (e.g., sodium, total sugars) and the “nutrients to encourage” (e.g., whole grains, fibre and calcium). For example, to meet the Uniform Nutrition Criteria, a serving of cookies per stated size must contain: ≤150 kcal; ≤1.5 g of saturated fat; ≤190 mg of sodium; ≤10 g of sugars; ≥8 g of whole grain or 2 g of fiber, or ≥5% of the Daily Value (DV) of any essential nutrient (other than sodium) [17]. In this analysis, essential nutrients were considered to be vitamin C, vitamin A, calcium and iron, since these were the only nutrients available on all product NFts. Additionally, some of the CAI’s “nutrients to encourage” had to be estimated, such as whether the product contained the required 8 g of whole grain or ½ serving of Milk and Alternatives [17]. These could not be calculated directly from information on-package and instead were estimated from the ingredients lists. To increase the precision of our evaluations, these estimations were only conducted if they were the only remaining criterion that a product had to meet in order to satisfy the CAI criteria.
Products that required preparation (e.g., powdered puddings, dry pancake mix), were evaluated using the nutrient values for the “as consumed” version of the product in FLIP 2013; otherwise, “as purchased” values were used for all calculations.

2.4. Identification of Products with on-Package Marketing to Children

Products with child-directed packaging were identified within the FLIP 2013 database by analysing product packaging photos and were subsequently evaluated against the Uniform Nutrition Criteria. As detailed previously by Labonté et al. [23], criteria for identifying “child-directed” products were adapted from Colby et al. [24] and Elliott [25]. For a product to be considered “child-directed”, packaging had to include at least one of the following: (1) allusions to fun or play; (2) child-oriented lettering or graphics; (3) unconventional flavours, colours or shapes; (4) reference to toys, coupons, prizes or contests; (5) games; (6) children’s product lines (e.g., “mini” or “junior” product lines); or (7) characters appealing to children.
If a product’s packaging did not possess any aspects directed at children except for a character/image that was part of the product’s brand or company logo, it was not considered to be child-directed (e.g., Pita BreakTM, Kraft© peanut butter and Pringles® products were not considered to be child-directed since no other aspect of the packaging, other than their logo, would appeal to children). Branded characters (e.g., Kellogg’s Frosted Flakes’ Tony the Tiger©, Quaker’s Cap’n Crunch©), however, were considered as part of child-directed packaging. A second evaluator completed a 20% random verification of these classifications, and 97% agreement was achieved. Categories with higher levels of disagreement (i.e., “Bakery products”, “Desserts”, “Sugars and sweets”) were examined in further detail, with any discrepancies resolved through consensus between researchers.

2.5. Identification of Products from Companies Participating in the CAI

Despite child-directed product packaging not being included in the realm of the CAI [16], it is possible that companies who have committed to the CAI may be more likely to have child-directed products that meet the CAI criteria compared to products from companies who have not committed to the CAI, since their products would have to meet the CAI criteria to be advertised to children on platforms other than product packaging [16]. Given this rationale, products from companies who have pledged to be a part of the CAI were identified within the FLIP 2013 database. Products were considered to be from CAI participating companies if they were from any of the following 18 companies [16]: Campbell Company of Canada (Toronto, ON, Canada), Coca-Cola Ltd., (Atlanta, GA, USA), Danone Inc., (Paris, France), Ferrero Canada Ltd., (Brantford, ON, Canada), General Mills Canada Corporation, (Mississauga, ON, Canada), Hershey Canada Inc., (Mississauga, ON, Canada), Kellogg Canada Inc., (Mississauga, ON, Canada), Kraft Canada Inc., (Chicago, IL, USA), Maple Leaf Foods Inc., (Mississauga, ON, Canada), Mars Canada Inc., (Bolton, ON Canada), McDonald’s Restaurants of Canada Limited, (Toronto, ON, Canada), Mondelēz Canada, (Toronto, ON, Canada), Nestlé Canada Inc., (Toronto, ON, Canada), Parmalat Canada Inc., (Toronto, ON, Canada), PepsiCo Canada ULC, (Mississauga, ON, Canada), Post Foods Canada Inc., (Niagara Falls, ON, Canada), Unilever Canada Inc., (Toronto, ON, Canada), Weston Bakeries Limited, (Toronto, ON, Canada).
It is important to note that given the nature of the FLIP 2013 database, no products from McDonald’s Restaurants of Canada Limited were included. Products that did not come from any of the above companies were considered to be from CAI non-participating companies.

2.6. Statistical Analyses

The numbers and proportions of products that were considered to be “allowed” or “restricted” for marketing to children according to the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria were calculated overall and for each individual Schedule M category and subcategory. Analyses were repeated in the subset of products that were determined to have child-directed marketing on their packages. Additionally, analyses were repeated for all products and within the subset of products with child-directed packaging, separating products from CAI participating and non-participating companies. Given that many subcategories had few products from CAI participating companies, these analyses were completed only at the major category level. All descriptive statistics were calculated using SAS (version 9.3, Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA).

3. Results

3.1. Evaluation of all Canadian Packaged Food and Beverage Products

In total, 15,231 products were included in the analyses following the exclusion of 111 products (n = 55 products which, based on Atwater calculations, had nutrient values in the NFt that were >20% different from the declared caloric values; n = 55 meal replacement drinks; and n = 1 Natural Health Product). Overall, 25.3% of products included in this sample would be allowed to be marketed to children; of these products, 21.5% met the Uniform Nutrition Criteria and 3.8% were considered to be automatically allowed (Table 1). Alternatively, 49.9% of products did not meet the CAI criteria, and 7.3% of products were automatically restricted, for a combined total of 57.2% of products that would be restricted from being marketed to children. There were missing data for an additional n = 7 products (0.05%), as values were missing for at least one of the nutrients that were required to determine whether a product would or would not meet the CAI criteria. However, in cases where values were missing for at least one of the tested nutrients but it did not affect the product’s evaluation (e.g., a “nutrient to encourage” had a missing value but the product already did not meet the “nutrients required to limit”), it was still possible to classify these products as ‘restricted’ from marketing to children. Therefore, such products were not considered as having missing data. A total of 17.5% of products could not be evaluated at all, as there were no relevant CAI criteria by which to evaluate them.

3.1.1. Categories with the Highest Proportion of Products that Would Be Allowed to Be Marketed to Children

Categories with the highest proportions of products (i.e., ≥50%) that would be allowed to be marketed to children included: “Eggs and Egg Substitutes” (75.0%); “Salads” (68.6%); “Dairy Products” (58.4%); “Nuts and Seeds” (57.3%); “Vegetables” (54.4%); “Potatoes, Sweet Potatoes and Yams” (52.9%); and “Fruit and Fruit Juices” (50.2%) (Table 1). For most categories, products would have to meet the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria in order to be marketed to children; however, in the “Vegetables” category, the majority of allowed products (96%; n = 435) were automatically allowed to be advertised to children. This included all products in the “Vegetables without Sauce” and “Lettuce and Sprouts” subcategories (Table A1). “Dairy Products” and “Fruit and Fruit Juices” also had a certain proportion of products (6.4% and 5.3%, respectively) that would not need to meet the CAI criteria in order to be marketed to children, and would be automatically allowed (Table 1).

3.1.2. Categories with the Highest Proportion of Products that Would Be Restricted from Being Marketed to Children

In contrast, many categories had a large proportion of products that would be restricted from being marketed to children. Based on the CAI criteria, several categories consisted of >75% of products that would be restricted for marketing to children, including: “Beverages” (100.0%); “Dessert Toppings and Fillings” (100.0%); “Desserts” (92.7%); “Meat, Poultry, and Substitutes” (91.4%); “Soups” (84.9); “Marine, Fresh Water Animals” (81.6%); “Snacks” (79.0%); and “Bakery Products” (77.4%) (Table 1). All products in the “Beverages” and “Dessert Topping and Fillings” categories would be restricted from being marketed to children, since the products in these categories are automatically restricted under the CAI criteria. A large proportion of products in the “Sugars and Sweets” category (66.2%) were also automatically restricted from being marketed to children (Table 1).

3.1.3. Categories for Which There Were no Relevant CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria

Products for which there were no relevant CAI criteria included all products in the “Fats and Oils” and “Sauces, Dips, Gravies and Condiments”. Additionally, several products in the “Sugars and Sweets” (33.8%; e.g., jams, marmalades), “Vegetables” (39.9%; e.g., pickles, olives, vegetable purées), and “Miscellaneous Products” (50.7%; e.g., baking powder, seasonings, and spices) categories could not be evaluated due to the absence of relevant CAI criteria.

3.2. Evaluation of Canadian Packaged Food and Beverage Products with Child-Directed Packaging

3.2.1. Categories with the Highest Proportion of Products with Child-Directed Packaging

As previously reported by Labonté et al. [23], sub-analyses showed that 4.9% (n = 747) of products analyzed had child-directed packaging (Table 2). The categories with the highest proportion of child-directed products were “Desserts” (17.4%, n = 144), “Sugars and Sweets” (9.6%, n = 72), “Bakery Products” (8.3%, n = 173), “Snacks” (6.8%, n = 54), “Dairy Products” (6.0%, n = 74) and “Dessert Toppings and Fillings” categories (6.0%, n = 7) (Table 2). Overall, these categories did not fare well by CAI standards, with at least 42% of all products (i.e., child-directed and those directed at a general audience) failing to meet the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria (Table 1). Only the “Dairy Products” category contained ≥50% of products considered to be allowed for children’s marketing according to the CAI (Table 1).
The child-directed products most commonly seen in Canada (i.e., n ≥ 40 child-directed products in an individual subcategory) belonged to one of the following subcategories: “Cookies, with or without coating/filling, graham wafers” (n = 84, 25.1% of “Cookies” subcategory); “Ice cream, frozen yogurt and sherbet” (n = 54, 13.9% of subcategory); “Chips, popcorn and extruded snacks” (n = 52, 9.3% of subcategory); “Juices, nectars and fruit drinks” (n = 45, 7.1% of subcategory); “Candies” (n = 45, 11.9% of subcategory) and “Dairy desserts, frozen” (n = 43, 23.0% of subcategory) (Table A2).

3.2.2. Products with Child-Directed Packaging that Would Be Restricted from Being Marketed to Children

After evaluation using the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria, 74.4% of products with child-directed packaging did not meet the nutritional standards of the CAI and would be restricted from being marketed to children on other media included in the CAI framework (Table 2). At least 39.2% of child-directed products from each of the 16 major food categories containing products with child-directed packaging would not be allowed to be marketed to children, with 8 of these major categories having ≥75% of their child-directed products failing to meet the CAI criteria (Table 2). In the categories with the highest proportion of child-directed products, the vast majority of child-directed products would not be allowed to be marketed to children (i.e., 97.2% of “Desserts”, 86.1% of “Sugars and Sweets”, 73.4% of “Bakery Products”, 81.5% of “Snacks”, 100% of “Dessert Toppings and Fillings”; Table 2). The only exception was the “Dairy Products” category, which actually had the lowest proportion (39.2%) of child-directed products that would be restricted from marketing to children of any category containing child-directed products (Table 2).

3.3. Evaluation of Packaged Food Products from CAI Participating and Non-Participating Companies

3.3.1. Evaluation of All Packaged Food and Beverage Products from CAI Participating and Non-Participating Companies

In total, 14.0% (n = 2131) products in FLIP 2013 were from CAI participating companies, and 86.0% (n = 13,093) were from non-participating companies (Table 3). Overall, the proportion of products from CAI participants that would be allowed to be marketed to children according to the CAI criteria was similar to that of non-participating companies (24.0% and 25.5%, respectively) (Table 3).

3.3.2. Evaluation of Products with Child-Directed Packaging from CAI Participating and Non-Participating Companies

When looking only at products with child-directed packaging, 33.3% (n = 249) were from CAI participating companies, and 66.7% (n = 498) were from non-participating companies (Table 4). A higher proportion of products with child-directed packaging from CAI participating companies (30.5%) would be allowed to be marketed to children according to the CAI compared to the proportion of child-directed products from non-participating companies that would be allowed to be marketed to children (19.9%) (Table 4).

4. Discussion

As mentioned, the voluntary, self-regulated, industry-led CAI is currently the only program in Canada that has been implemented to limit the marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages to children. However, the Government of Canada has recently committed to developing mandatory national regulations in this area. In October 2016, Health Canada published its Healthy Eating Strategy, a set of initiatives intended to make the “healthier choice the easier choice” for Canadians that specifically highlights the need to take action towards restricting the marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages to children [26]. Most notably, Senator Nancy Greene Raine proposed Bill S-228: The Child Health Protection Act, which as of February, 2018, has been passed in the Canadian Senate and is awaiting its third and final reading in the House of Commons, after which it will move to become Canadian law [27]. If passed, this bill would mandate that only “healthier” foods are marketed to Canadians under the age of 13 [27]. However, defining “healthier foods” requires an objective classification system, such as an NP model [14,18]. Health Canada has recently proposed a model for this purpose as part of a public consultation [28], but no final decisions have been made to date.
Therefore, the present study aimed to evaluate the application of the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria to the Canadian food supply for the purpose of restricting food and beverage marketing to children. Our results showed that only one quarter of packaged foods in Canada would be allowed to be marketed to children using this industry developed model. This can be compared to results from a recent study by our group in which we tested several NP models built by governmental or inter-governmental organizations for the purpose of restricting marketing to kids, using the same FLIP 2013 database [23]. In that earlier study, we found that the proportion of food products that would be allowed to be marketed to children varied considerably across four NP models (between 10–49% of foods) [23]. Results from the present study show that the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria would be stricter than both the World Health Organization’s Regional Office for Europe (WHO-EURO) NP model (30% of food products allowed) and the Food Standards Australia New Zealand Nutrient Profiling Scoring Criterion (FSANZ-NPSC) (49%), but less strict than the original Pan American Health Organization (PAHO, Washington, DC, USA) NP model (16%) and a modified version of the PAHO NP model (10%) [23]. It is worth acknowledging, however, that for the comparison of these results with the results of Labonté et al., (2017), products with “No Criteria” would have to be excluded from the assessments using the 4 authoritative-based NP models so that only products that could be evaluated using all models would be included in that analysis. In another study, Ni Mhurchu and colleagues tested the New Zealand Ministry of Health Food and Beverage Classification System (FBCS), Health Star Rating (HSR) system and the WHO-EURO NP model on a sample of over 13,000 packaged products in New Zealand [29]. Their results showed that each of these models would permit roughly a third (29–41%) of products to be marketed to children, more than the CAI [29]. In combination, these findings suggest that the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria would be more restrictive than these alternative NP models, but less strict than the PAHO model. Given that the NP model to restrict the marketing of unhealthy foods to children in Canada has not yet been finalized, a comparison of the CAI to this proposed NP model would be preliminary and outside the scope of this study. Future research will be needed to evaluate the potential impact of such a policy once the specific regulations have been published.
The current study suggests that the CAI could be an effective model to restrict the marketing of foods that are widely considered to be of lower nutritional quality. For example, it completely restricts soft drinks and confectionary, which are often noted as being poor dietary choices for children [14,30]. Products in other categories such as “Desserts”, “Snacks” and some “Bakery products” which should be consumed only occasionally [30] are also largely found to have a nutritional profile that does not meet the CAI requirements. On the other hand, many “Vegetables” and “Nuts and Seeds” were found to be allowed for marketing to children according to the CAI. Generally, the way in which the CAI evaluates different types of products is in line with healthy dietary patterns, such as the proposed recommendations for the new Canada’s Food Guide [31].
Since approximately three quarters of products that are currently marketed to children on their packaging would not meet the CAI criteria with their current nutritional composition, adding product packaging in the realm of the CAI would be an effective way to increase the CAI’s impact on limiting the marketing of unhealthy foods to children. These results also highlight the importance of ensuring that on-package marketing to children is included in any system designed to restrict marketing to children since most products marketed in this way were found to be unhealthy. Applying the CAI as a mandatory system could also motivate product reformulation, particularly for those manufacturers targeting children. These findings reiterate the stringency of this NP model, while also reinforcing the need for a policy to restrict food and beverage marketing to children, since this study and others [32,33,34] show that child-directed products tend to be from “less healthy” food categories, and also less healthy than the overall food supply.
Analysis showed that most products with child-directed packaging were from non-participating companies, and a higher proportion of child-directed products from CAI participating companies met the CAI criteria compared to products from non-participating companies. In combination, these findings suggest that participating companies’ pledges to eliminate or only advertise healthier products to children in other media may be carrying over to the packaged food environment. However, products from CAI participating companies make up less than one-fifth of the packaged food supply and over two-thirds of their child-directed products still fail to satisfy the CAI’s nutritional standards. These results highlight the limitations of voluntary approach to restricting food and beverage marketing to children, and support the need for mandatory regulations with a broad coverage of potential marketing platforms.
A major strength of the CAI NP model is the consideration of both positive (e.g., fiber) and negative (e.g., sodium) nutrients in its nutritional criteria, to give a more wholesome evaluation of the nutritional quality of the product. While researchers have criticized such a system as it may encourage the addition of ‘positive nutrients’ (e.g., fiber, protein isolates) [35] or discretionary addition of vitamins and minerals [36] rather than reductions in nutrients to limit (e.g., sodium), the CAI criteria require that a product satisfy both the positive and negative criteria separately, in order to be allowed to be marketed to children. As such, a higher level of stringency is maintained as compared with other models in which the positive nutrients can ‘balance out’ the negative nutrients and raise a product’s NP score [37,38]. Importantly, the CAI NP model is already in use by many major food companies and one large restaurant chain [16], which speaks to the acceptability of this model by industry stakeholders.
As with any NP model, the CAI has its limitations. Nearly one fifth of products had no criteria by which to be evaluated, reducing the scope of these criteria. However, these products were from food categories with very few child-directed products, indicating that including these products in their criteria would not likely have a critical impact on restricting children’s products. Additionally, the CAI NP model uses multiple food categories that are not always clearly defined, making product classification ambiguous (e.g., “Other Snacks”) [17]. It is generally accepted that having fewer food categories is the favored approach (i.e., the Ofcom NP model [38]) since little classification is necessary, and all products are evaluated by more consistent criteria [39,40]. Worth noting is that WHO Euro uses a category based NP model; however, its adoption is not yet widespread throughout Europe [41]. Should the CAI be considered, a modification of the number of food categories could be warranted; otherwise, clearer guidelines would be necessary in order to facilitate consistent product classification and evaluation. Additionally, clear guidelines on which nutrients are to be considered as “essential nutrients” in the CAI’s “nutrients to encourage” would be necessary. Should the CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria be used as the NP model to fulfill the requirements of Bill S-228 as has been proposed [27], other existing limitations of the current CAI structure, such as its voluntary nature and limited coverage of marketing techniques and participating companies would no longer apply.
A major strength of this study was the use of a large, highly representative sample of food and beverage products available to Canadians, and presents the first analysis of the potential impact of scaling up a voluntary NP model for use as a mandatory NP model in Canada. Nonetheless, this work was not without its limitations. Firstly, it is important to note that the FLIP 2013 database does not contain any fresh, unpackaged foods. This is important to take into account when interpreting our results, since fresh products such as fruits and vegetables would be “automatically allowed” by the CAI and are not included in the analysis and therefore our results may portray the CAI as more restrictive than if fresh products were included. Additionally, as described previously, some of the CAI’s “nutrients to encourage” had to be estimated using the available NFt information and therefore may not represent the true composition of these components for certain products.

5. Conclusions

The CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria offer a relatively stringent approach to restricting the marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages to Canadian children, but the voluntary nature of this approach and its failure to address certain marketing platforms (e.g., product packaging), is largely insufficient and urgent regulatory action in this area—such as the implementation of Bill-S228—is needed. Legislation mandating adherence to the CAI NP model for products marketed across all child-directed settings and communication channels would, however, likely prove effective in promoting a children’s food environment in line with dietary guidelines and national nutrition goals [27,31,42].

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, C.M., M.-È.L. and M.R.L.; Formal analysis, C.M.; Investigation, C.M.; Methodology, C.M. and M.-È.L.; Supervision, M.R.L.; Validation, M.-È.L. and L.V.; Writing—original draft, C.M.; Writing—review & editing, C.M., M.-È.L., L.V. and M.R.L.

Acknowledgments

Ontario Graduate Scholarship Indigenous Scholar Award (CM), Burroughs Wellcome Fund—Innovation in Regulatory Science (MRL; #1014187), Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) Postdoctoral Fellowship (MEL; #MFE-140953), CIHR Strategic Operating Grant (MRL; #201103SOK−118150), Canadian Stroke Network (MRL; #201103SOK−01194-000), Earle W. McHenry Research Chair unrestricted research grant from the University of Toronto (MRL).

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Appendix A

Table
Table A1. Evaluation of Canadian packaged food and beverage products 1 according to the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria 2, presented by food subcategory 3.
Table A1. Evaluation of Canadian packaged food and beverage products 1 according to the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria 2, presented by food subcategory 3.
Schedule M Category/Subcategory 3 CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria 2
AllowedRestricted
Total ProductsMissing Data 4Meets CAI Criteria 2Automatically Allowed 2Total AllowedDoes Not meet CAI Criteria 2Automatically Restricted 2Total RestrictedNo Criteria 2
n% 5n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6
TOTAL152,314100.070.0327821.55723.8385025.3760649.911057.3871157.2266317.5
1. Bakery Products208413.720.147022.600.047022.6161277.400.0161277.400.0
1. Bread (excl. sweet quick-type rolls)2311.500.06528.100.06528.116671.900.016671.900.0
2. Bagels, scones, rolls, buns, tortillas, etc.2881.900.05719.800.05719.823180.200.023180.200.0
3. Brownies280.200.0310.700.0310.72589.300.02589.300.0
4. Heavy weight cake (e.g., cheese cake, cake with fruits and nuts)440.300.000.000.000.044100.000.044100.000.0
5. Medium weight cake (e.g., Boston cream pie, cream puffs, cupcakes)800.500.000.000.000.080100.000.080100.000.0
6. Light weight cake (e.g., angel food, chiffon, without icing or filling)60.000.000.000.000.06100.000.06100.000.0
7. Coffee cakes, doughnuts, danishes, muffins, sweet quick-type rolls, etc.1230.800.086.500.086.511593.500.011593.500.0
8. Cookies, with or without coating/filling, graham wafers3912.600.07017.900.07017.932182.100.032182.100.0
9. Crackers, hard bread sticks, melba toast2771.800.012545.100.012545.115254.900.015254.900.0
10. Dry breaks, matzo, rusks670.400.03349.300.03349.33450.700.03450.700.0
11. Flaky type pastries, with or without filling/icing150.100.0213.300.0213.31386.700.01386.700.0
12. Toaster pastries110.100.000.000.000.011100.000.011100.000.0
13. Ice cream cones270.200.0622.200.0622.22177.800.02177.800.0
14. Croutons370.212.7410.800.0410.83286.500.03286.500.0
15. French toast, pancakes, waffles590.400.01322.000.01322.04678.000.04678.000.0
16. Grain-based bars, with filling or coating1050.700.02221.000.02221.08379.000.08379.000.0
17. Grain-based bars, without filling or coating1000.700.04141.000.04141.05959.000.05959.000.0
18. Rice cakes and corn cakes510.300.01835.300.01835.33364.700.03364.700.0
19. Pies, tarts, cobblers, other pastries1010.700.000.000.000.0101100.000.0101100.000.0
20. Pie crust180.100.000.000.000.018100.000.018100.000.0
21. Pizza Crust110.100.000.000.000.011100.000.011100.000.0
22. Taco shell, hard140.117.1321.400.0321.41071.400.01071.400.0
2. Beverages (soft drinks, iced teas, coffees)4823.200.000.000.000.000.0482100.0482100.000.0
23. Carbonated and non-carbonated beverages, wine coolers2641.700.000.000.000.000.0264100.0264100.000.0
24. Sports drinks and water1250.800.000.000.000.000.0125100.0125100.000.0
25. Coffee, espresso, flavored/unflavored290.200.000.000.000.000.029100.029100.000.0
26. Tea and herbal tea, flavored/unflavored370.200.000.000.000.000.037100.037100.000.0
27. Cocoa and chocolate beverages (hot)270.200.000.000.000.000.027100.027100.000.0
3. Cereals, other grain products9886.510.133233.600.033233.659259.900.059259.9636.4
28. Hot breakfast cereals (oatmeal, cream of wheat)1050.711.09287.600.09287.61211.400.01211.400.0
29. Ready-to-eat breakfast cereals, puffed and uncoated 20.000.000.000.000.02100.000.02100.000.0
30. Ready-to-eat breakfast cereals, puffed and coated, flaked, extruded, without fruit/nuts, high fiber cereal770.500.04355.800.04355.83444.200.03444.200.0
31. Ready-to-eat breakfast cereals, with fruit/nuts, granola, biscuit type cereals1711.100.06336.800.06336.810863.200.010863.200.0
32. Bran and wheat germ50.000.05100.000.05100.000.000.000.000.0
33. Flours (incl. cornmeal)500.300.000.000.000.000.000.000.050100.0
34. Grains (e.g., rice, barley, etc.)1100.700.05146.400.05146.45953.600.05953.600.0
35. Pastas without sauce4372.900.07517.200.07517.236282.800.036282.800.0
37. Starch (e.g., cornstarch, potato starch, tapioca starch, etc.)130.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.013100.0
38. Stuffing180.100.0316.700.0316.71583.300.01583.300.0
4. Dairy products, substitutes12408.110.164552.0796.472458.451541.500.051541.500.0
39. Cheese (incl. cream cheese and cheese spread), except those listed as separate item4533.010.232471.500.032471.512828.300.012828.300.0
40. Cottage cheese270.200.02177.800.02177.8622.200.0622.200.0
41. Cheese, as an ingredient (e.g., dry cottage cheese, ricotta, etc.)170.100.0317.600.0317.61482.400.01482.400.0
42. Hard cheese, grated (e.g., parmesan, romano)300.200.02790.000.02790.0310.000.0310.000.0
43. Quark, fresh cheese, fresh dairy desserts990.700.022.000.022.09798.000.09798.000.0
44. Cream and cream substitute500.300.000.000.000.050100.000.050100.000.0
45. Cream and cream substitute, powder130.100.000.000.000.013100.000.013100.000.0
46. Cream and cream substitute, aerosol or whipped220.100.000.000.000.022100.000.022100.000.0
48. Milk, evaporated or condensed180.100.000.000.000.018100.000.018100.000.0
49. Plant-based beverages, milk, buttermilk, milk-based drinks (e.g., chocolate milk)2461.600.011848.07932.119780.14919.900.04919.900.0
50. Shakes and shake substitutes (e.g., dairy shake mix)110.100.0327.300.0327.3872.700.0872.700.0
51. Sour cream180.100.000.000.000.018100.000.018100.000.0
52. Yogurt2361.600.014762.300.014762.38937.700.08937.700.0
5. Desserts (Dairy and non-Dairy)8275.400.0597.100.0597.176792.700.076792.710.1
53. Ice cream, ice milk, frozen yogurt and sherbet3892.600.04611.800.04611.834388.200.034388.200.0
54. Dairy desserts, frozen (e.g., cakes, bars, sandwiches, cones)1861.200.031.600.031.618398.400.018398.400.0
55. Non-dairy desserts, frozen (e.g., flavored/sweetened ice or pops, frozen fruit juices in bars or cups)460.300.0510.900.0510.94189.100.04189.100.0
56. Sundaes90.100.000.000.000.09100.000.09100.000.0
57. Custard, gelatin, pudding1971.300.052.500.052.519197.000.019197.010.5
6. Dessert toppings, fillings1160.800.000.000.000.000.0116100.0116100.000.0
58. Dessert toppings (e.g., maple butter, marshmallow cream)300.200.000.000.000.000.030100.030100.000.0
59. Cake frostings and icings580.400.000.000.000.000.058100.058100.000.0
60. Pie fillings280.200.000.000.000.000.028100.028100.000.0
7. Eggs, egg substitutes560.400.04275.000.04275.01425.000.01425.000.0
61. Egg mixtures (e.g., egg foo young, scrambled eggs, omelets)70.100.07100.000.07100.000.000.000.000.0
62. Eggs490.300.03571.400.03571.41428.600.01428.600.0
8. Fats, oils5353.500.000.000.000.000.000.000.0535100.0
64. Butter, margarine, shortening, lard910.600.000.000.000.000.000.000.091100.0
65. Vegetable oil1360.900.000.000.000.000.000.000.0136100.0
67. Dressings for salad2521.700.000.000.000.000.000.000.0252100.0
68. Mayonnaise, sandwich spread and mayonnaise-type dressing400.300.000.000.000.000.000.000.040100.0
69. Oil, spray type160.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.016100.0
9. Marine, fresh water animals4402.900.08118.400.08118.435981.600.035981.600.0
70. Canned anchovies, anchovy paste, caviar60.000.000.000.000.06100.000.06100.000.0
71. Marine and fresh water animals with sauce (e.g., shrimp with lobster sauce)400.300.0512.500.0512.53587.500.03587.500.0
72. Marine and fresh water animals without sauce (e.g., plain or fried fish/shellfish, fish cakes) with or without breading/batter2091.400.02411.500.02411.518588.500.018588.500.0
73. Marine and fresh water animals, canned1290.900.05038.800.05038.87961.200.07961.200.0
74. Marine and fresh water animals, smoked or pickled, or spreads560.400.023.600.023.65496.400.05496.400.0
10. Fruit, fruit juices10897.200.048944.9585.354750.252848.500.052848.5141.3
75. Fruit, fresh, canned or frozen, except those listed as separate item2781.800.012043.24817.316860.411039.600.011039.600.0
76. Candied or pickled fruit50.000.000.000.000.05100.000.05100.000.0
77. Dried fruit (e.g., raisins, dates, figs)1410.900.02114.900.02114.912085.100.012085.100.0
78. Fruit for garnish or flavor (e.g., maraschino cherries)50.000.000.000.000.05100.000.05100.000.0
79. Fruit relishes140.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.014100.0
81. Cranberries, lemons, limes, used as ingredients30.000.000.03100.03100.000.000.000.000.0
83. Juices, nectars and fruit drinks for use as substitutes for fruit juices6364.200.034854.700.034854.728845.300.028845.300.0
84. Juices, used as ingredients (e.g., lemon or lime juice)70.100.000.07100.07100.000.000.000.000.0
11. Legumes1801.200.08949.400.08949.49150.600.09150.600.0
85. Bean curd (tofu) and tempeh160.100.0318.800.0318.81381.300.01381.300.0
86. Beans, peas, lentils (e.g., chickpeas, kidney beans, soybeans)1641.100.08652.400.08652.47847.600.07847.600.0
12. Meat, poultry, their products, substitutes8955.900.0778.600.0778.681891.400.081891.400.0
87. Pork rinds and bacon380.300.000.000.000.038100.000.038100.000.0
88. Beef, pork and poultry breakfast strips110.100.0218.200.0218.2981.800.0981.800.0
89. Dried meat and poultry (e.g., jerky, Parma ham) and dry sausage products (e.g., salami)770.500.000.000.000.077100.000.077100.000.0
90. Luncheon meats (e.g., bologna, mortadella), pâté, sandwich spread, taco fillings, meat pie fillings1010.700.076.900.076.99493.100.09493.100.0
91. Sausage products (e.g., wieners breakfast sausage, pepperoni, frankfurters)1721.100.063.500.063.516696.500.016696.500.0
92. Cuts or meat and poultry without sauce, and ready-to-cook cuts, with or without breading/batter, including marinated, tenderized, injected cuts1230.800.01411.400.01411.410988.600.010988.600.0
93. Patties, cutlets, choppettes, steakettes, meatballs, sausage meat, ground meat, with or without breading/batter1911.300.03015.700.03015.716184.300.016184.300.0
94. Cured meat products (e.g., cured ham, back bacon, corned beef, smoked meat etc.)860.600.022.300.022.38497.700.08497.700.0
95. Canned meat and poultry230.200.014.300.014.32295.700.02295.700.0
96. Meat and poultry with sauce (e.g., meat in barbeque sauce, turkey with gravy), excluding combination dishes730.500.01520.600.01520.65879.500.05879.500.0
13. Miscellaneous4503.000.0184.000.0184.019342.9112.420445.322850.7
97. Baking powder, baking soda, pectin50.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.05100.0
98. Baking decorations (e.g., colored sugars, sprinkles)60.000.000.000.000.000.06100.06100.000.0
99. Bread crumbs and batter mixes2111.400.0188.500.0188.519391.500.019391.500.0
101. Cocoa powder40.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.04100.0
102. Non-alcoholic drink mixers (e.g., piña colada, daiquiri)50.000.000.000.000.000.05100.05100.000.0
104. Salad and potato toppers (e.g., salad crunchies, crispins, substitutes for bacon bits)280.200.000.000.000.000.000.000.028100.0
105. Salt and salt substitutes, seasoned salts (e.g., garlic salt)170.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.017100.0
106. Spices and herbs1701.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.0170100.0
14. Combination Dishes13578.930.247334.900.047334.988164.900.088164.900.0
107. Measurable with a cup (e.g., casserole, macaroni and cheese, stir fry, chili, ravioli in sauce, poutine)6714.400.019729.400.019729.447470.600.047470.600.0
108. Not measurable with a cup (e.g., burritos, egg rolls, pizza, quiche, stuffed vegetables, shish kabobs, meat and poultry lunch packages)5223.410.215329.300.015329.336870.500.036870.500.0
109. Meat pie and tourtière1641.121.212375.000.012375.03923.800.03923.800.0
15. Nuts, seeds2201.400.012657.300.012657.38739.600.08739.673.2
110. Nuts and seeds, not for use as snacks, whole, chopped, sliced, slivered, ground1300.900.010177.700.010177.72922.300.02922.300.0
111. Butters, pastes, creams (excl. peanut butter)330.200.02575.800.02575.8824.200.0824.200.0
112. Peanut butter500.300.000.000.000.050100.000.050100.000.0
113. Flours (e.g., coconut flour)70.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.07100.0
16. Potatoes, sweet potatoes, yams1400.900.07452.900.07452.96647.100.06647.100.0
114. French fried, hash browns, skins and pancakes690.500.05782.600.05782.61217.400.01217.400.0
115. Mashed, candied, stuffed or with sauce560.400.047.100.047.15292.900.05292.900.0
116. Plain, fresh, canned or frozen150.100.01386.700.01386.7213.300.0213.300.0
17. Salads700.500.04868.600.04868.62231.400.02231.400.0
117. Salads (e.g., Egg, fish, shellfish, bean, fruit, vegetable, meat), except those as separate item460.300.03473.900.03473.91226.100.01226.100.0
119. Pasta or potato salad240.200.01458.300.01458.31041.700.01041.700.0
18. Sauces, dips, gravies, condiments12298.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.01229100.0
120. Sauces for dipping (e.g., barbeque, hollandaise, tartar, mustard, sweet and sour)1040.700.000.000.000.000.000.000.0104100.0
121. Dips (legume or dairy-based)1400.900.000.000.000.000.000.000.0140100.0
122. Major main entrée sauce (e.g., spaghetti sauce)2251.500.000.000.000.000.000.000.0225100.0
123. Minor main entrée sauce (e.g., pizza sauce, pesto sauce, salsa, etc.)2871.900.000.000.000.000.000.000.0287100.0
124. Major condiments (e.g., ketchup, steak sauce, vinegar, marinades)3752.500.000.000.000.000.000.000.0375100.0
125. Minor condiments (e.g., horseradish, hot sauce, mustard, Worcestershire sauce)980.600.000.000.000.000.000.000.098100.0
19. Snacks (Chips, pretzels, meat or nut snacks)7945.200.016721.000.016721.062779.000.062779.000.0
126. Chips, pretzels, popcorn, extruded snacks, grain-based snack mixes and fruit-based snacks (e.g., fruit chips)5583.700.08715.600.08715.647184.400.047184.400.0
127. Nuts or seeds for use as snacks2231.500.08035.900.08035.914364.100.014364.100.0
128. Meat or poultry snack food sticks130.100.000.000.000.013100.000.013100.000.0
20. Soups4563.000.06915.100.06915.138784.900.038784.900.0
129. All varieties4563.000.06915.100.06915.138784.900.038784.900.0
21. Sugars, sweets7494.900.000.000.000.000.049666.249666.225333.8
130. Candies (incl. chocolate bars and chocolate products), except those as separate item3772.500.000.000.000.000.0377100.0377100.000.0
131. Hard candies, except those as separate item80.100.000.000.000.000.08100.08100.000.0
132. Baking candies, such as chocolate chips300.200.000.000.000.000.030100.030100.000.0
133. Breath mints60.000.000.000.000.000.06100.06100.000.0
135. Confectioner’s or icing sugar10.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.01100.0
136. Bread spreads, except those as separate item, honey, molasses500.300.000.000.000.000.000.000.050100.0
137. Jams, jellies, marmalades, fruit butters, spreads1931.300.000.000.000.000.000.000.0193100.0
138. Marshmallows130.100.000.000.000.000.013100.013100.000.0
139. Sugars, except those as separate item60.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.06100.0
140. Sugar substitute30.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.03100.0
141. Syrups (incl. chocolate, maple and corn syrup)620.400.000.000.000.000.062100.062100.000.0
22. Vegetables8345.500.0192.343552.245454.4475.600.0475.633339.9
142. Vegetables without sauce (incl. cream style corn, stewed tomatoes), except vegetables without sauce listed as separate item4182.700.000.0418100.0418100.000.000.000.000.0
143. Vegetables with sauce170.100.01482.400.01482.4317.600.0317.600.0
144. Vegetables for use as garnish/flavoring, fresh, canned or frozen, but not dried (e.g., parsley or garlic)240.200.000.000.000.000.000.000.024100.0
145. Chili pepper and green onion420.300.000.000.000.000.000.000.042100.0
146. Seaweed60.000.0116.700.0116.7583.300.0583.300.0
147. Lettuce and spouts170.100.000.017100.017100.000.000.000.000.0
148. Vegetable juice and vegetable drink430.300.049.300.049.33990.700.03990.700.0
149. Olives830.500.000.000.000.000.000.000.083100.0
150. Pickles1120.700.000.000.000.000.000.000.0112100.0
151. Relish240.200.000.000.000.000.000.000.024100.0
152. Vegetable pastes, (e.g., tomato paste)120.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.012100.0
153. Vegetable sauce or puree (e.g., tomato sauce or tomato puree)360.200.000.000.000.000.000.000.036100.0
1 Packaged food products are from the Food Label Information Program (FLIP) 2013, as described in [22]. 2 Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria are defined in: Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative; Uniform Nutrition Criteria White Paper; September 2014 [17]. 3 Food categories are defined in Schedule M of the Food and Drug Regulations (C.R.C., c. 870), Sections B.01.001, B.01.002A and D.01.001, Government of Canada, Health Canada [21]. 4 Missing data indicates products which were evaluated, but values were missing for at least one of the tested nutrients that were required to determine whether a product would or would not meet the CAI criteria. However, in cases where values were missing for at least one of the tested nutrients but it did not affect the product’s evaluation (e.g., a “nutrient to encourage” had a missing value but the product already did not meet the “nutrients required to limit), it was still possible to classify these products as or ‘restricted’ from marketing to children, therefore such products were not considered as having missing data. 5 Percentage of total products (i.e., out of n = 15,231 products). 6 Percentage of total products in that food category/subcategory.
Table
Table A2. Percentage of packaged food and beverage products 1 with child-directed packaging 2 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 3, presented by food subcategory 4.
Table A2. Percentage of packaged food and beverage products 1 with child-directed packaging 2 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 3, presented by food subcategory 4.
Schedule M Category/Subcategory 4All Packaged Foods 1Packaged Foods with Child-Directed Packaging 2
Total Products AnalyzedTotal Products AnalyzedTotal Allowed 3Total Restricted 3No CAI Criteria 3
n% 5n% 6n% 7n% 7n% 7
TOTAL15,231100.07474.917523.455674.4162.1
1. Bakery Products208413.71738.34626.612773.400.0
1. Bread (excl. sweet quick-type rolls)2311.510.400.01100.000.0
2. Bagels, scones, rolls, buns, tortillas, etc.2881.920.700.02100.000.0
3. Brownies280.227.100.02100.000.0
4. Heavy weight cake (e.g., cheese cake, cake with fruits and nuts)440.300.0N/AN/AN/A
5. Medium weight cake (e.g., Boston cream pie, cream puffs, cupcakes)800.51316.300.013100.000.0
6. Light weight cake (e.g., angel food, chiffon, without icing or filling)60.000.0N/AN/AN/A
7. Coffee cakes, doughnuts, danishes, muffins, sweet quick-type rolls, etc.1230.864.900.06100.000.0
8. Cookies, with or without coating/filling, graham wafers3912.68421.53035.75464.300.0
9. Crackers, hard bread sticks, melba toast2771.83111.2722.62477.400.0
10. Dry breaks, matzo, rusks670.400.0N/AN/AN/A
11. Flaky type pastries, with or without filling/icing150.100.0N/AN/AN/A
12. Toaster pastries110.111100.000.011100.000.0
13. Ice cream cones270.213.700.01100.000.0
14. Croutons370.200.0N/AN/AN/A
15. French toast, pancakes, waffles590.411.700.01100.000.0
16. Grain-based bars, with filling or coating1050.798.6222.2777.800.0
17. Grain-based bars, without filling or coating1000.71212.0758.3541.700.0
18. Rice cakes and corn cakes510.300.0N/AN/AN/A
19. Pies, tarts, cobblers, other pastries1010.700.0N/AN/AN/A
20. Pie crust180.100.0N/AN/AN/A
21. Pizza Crust110.100.0N/AN/AN/A
22. Taco shell, hard140.100.0N/AN/AN/A
2. Beverages (soft drinks, iced teas, coffees)4823.2112.300.011100.000.0
23. Carbonated and non-carbonated beverages, wine coolers2641.772.600.07100.000.0
24. Sports drinks and water1250.810.800.01100.000.0
25. Coffee, espresso, flavored/unflavored290.200.0N/AN/AN/A
26. Tea and herbal tea, flavored/unflavored370.200.0N/AN/AN/A
27. Cocoa and chocolate beverages (hot)270.2311.100.03100.000.0
3. Cereals, other grain products9886.5515.22549.02651.000.0
28. Hot breakfast cereals (oatmeal, cream of wheat)1050.732.83100.000.000.0
29. Ready-to-eat breakfast cereals, puffed and uncoated 20.000.0N/AN/AN/A
30. Ready-to-eat breakfast cereals, puffed and coated, flaked, extruded, without fruit/nuts, high fiber cereal770.53342.71339.42060.600.0
31. Ready-to-eat breakfast cereals, with fruit/nuts, granola, biscuit type cereals1711.1148.2964.3535.700.0
32. Bran and wheat germ50.000.0N/AN/AN/A
33. Flours (incl. cornmeal)500.300.0N/AN/AN/A
34. Grains (e.g., rice, barley, etc.)1100.700.0N/AN/AN/A
35. Pastas without sauce4372.910.200.01100.000.0
37. Starch (e.g., cornstarch, potato starch, tapioca starch, etc.)130.100.0N/AN/AN/A
38. Stuffing180.100.0N/AN/AN/A
4. Dairy products, substitutes12408.1746.04560.82939.200.0
39. Cheese (incl. cream cheese and cheese spread), except those listed as separate item4533.0163.51381.3318.800.0
40. Cottage cheese270.200.0N/AN/AN/A
41. Cheese, as an ingredient (e.g., dry cottage cheese, ricotta, etc.)170.100.0N/AN/AN/A
42. Hard cheese, grated (e.g., parmesan, romano)300.200.0N/AN/AN/A
43. Quark, fresh cheese, fresh dairy desserts990.788.1112.5787.500.0
44. Cream and cream substitute500.300.0N/AN/AN/A
45. Cream and cream substitute, powder130.100.0N/AN/AN/A
46. Cream and cream substitute, aerosol or whipped220.100.0N/AN/AN/A
48. Milk, evaporated or condensed180.100.0N/AN/AN/A
49. Plant-based beverages, milk, buttermilk, milk-based drinks (e.g., chocolate milk)2461.63413.82676.5823.500.0
50. Shakes and shake substitutes (e.g., dairy shake mix)110.1545.500.05100.000.0
51. Sour cream180.100.0N/AN/AN/A
52. Yogurt2361.6114.7545.5654.500.0
5. Desserts (Dairy and non-Dairy)8275.414417.442.814097.200.0
53. Ice cream, ice milk, frozen yogurt and sherbet3892.65413.900.054100.000.0
54. Dairy desserts, frozen (e.g., cakes, bars, sandwiches, cones)1861.24323.012.34297.700.0
55. Non-dairy desserts, frozen (e.g., flavored/sweetened ice or pops, frozen fruit juices in bars or cups)460.32452.228.32291.700.0
56. Sundaes90.1333.300.03100.000.0
57. Custard, gelatin, pudding1971.32010.215.01995.000.0
6. Dessert toppings, fillings1160.876.000.07100.000.0
58. Dessert toppings (e.g., maple butter, marshmallow cream)300.2310.000.03100.000.0
59. Cake frostings and icings580.446.900.04100.000.0
60. Pie fillings280.200.0N/AN/AN/A
7. Eggs, egg substitutes560.400.0N/AN/AN/A
61. Egg mixtures (e.g., egg foo young, scrambled eggs, omelets)70.100.0N/AN/AN/A
62. Eggs490.300.0N/AN/AN/A
8. Fats, oils5353.500.0N/AN/AN/A
64. Butter, margarine, shortening, lard910.600.0N/AN/AN/A
65. Vegetable oil1360.900.0N/AN/AN/A
67. Dressings for salad2521.700.0N/AN/AN/A
68. Mayonnaise, sandwich spread and mayonnaise-type dressing400.300.0N/AN/AN/A
69. Oil, spray type160.100.0N/AN/AN/A
9. Marine, fresh water animals4402.920.500.02100.000.0
70. Canned anchovies, anchovy paste, caviar60.000.0N/AN/AN/A
71. Marine and fresh water animals with sauce (e.g., shrimp with lobster sauce)400.300.0N/AN/AN/A
72. Marine and fresh water animals without sauce (e.g., plain or fried fish/shellfish, fish cakes) with or without breading/batter2091.421.000.02100.000.0
73. Marine and fresh water animals, canned1290.900.0N/AN/AN/A
74. Marine and fresh water animals, smoked or pickled, or spreads560.400.0N/AN/AN/A
10. Fruit, fruit juices10897.2585.31831.04069.000.0
75. Fruit, fresh, canned or frozen, except those listed as separate item2781.8134.6969.2430.800.0
76. Candied or pickled fruit50.000.0N/AN/AN/A
77. Dried fruit (e.g., raisins, dates, figs)1410.900.0N/AN/AN/A
78. Fruit for garnish or flavor (e.g., maraschino cherries)50.000.0N/AN/AN/A
79. Fruit relishes140.100.0N/AN/AN/A
81. Cranberries, lemons, limes, used as ingredients30.000.0N/AN/AN/A
83. Juices, nectars and fruit drinks for use as substitutes for fruit juices6364.2457.1920.03680.000.0
84. Juices, used as ingredients (e.g., lemon or lime juice)70.100.0N/AN/AN/A
11. Legumes1801.200.0N/AN/AN/A
85. Bean curd (tofu) and tempeh160.100.0N/AN/AN/A
86. Beans, peas, lentils (e.g., chickpeas, kidney beans, soybeans)1641.100.0N/AN/AN/A
12. Meat, poultry, their products, substitutes8955.940.5125.0375.000.0
87. Pork rinds and bacon380.300.0N/AN/AN/A
88. Beef, pork and poultry breakfast strips110.100.0N/AN/AN/A
89. Dried meat and poultry (e.g., jerky, Parma ham) and dry sausage products (e.g., salami)770.500.0N/AN/AN/A
90. Luncheon meats (e.g., bologna, mortadella), pâté, sandwich spread, taco fillings, meat pie fillings1010.700.0N/AN/AN/A
91. Sausage products (e.g., wieners breakfast sausage, pepperoni, frankfurters)1721.100.0N/AN/AN/A
92. Cuts or meat and poultry without sauce, and ready-to-cook cuts, with or without breading/batter, including marinated, tenderized, injected cuts1230.800.0N/AN/AN/A
93. Patties, cutlets, choppettes, steakettes, meatballs, sausage meat, ground meat, with or without breading/batter1911.342.1125.0375.000.0
94. Cured meat products (e.g., cured ham, back bacon, corned beef, smoked meat etc.)860.600.0N/AN/AN/A
95. Canned meat and poultry230.200.0N/AN/AN/A
96. Meat and poultry with sauce (e.g., meat in barbeque sauce, turkey with gravy), excluding combination dishes730.500.0N/AN/AN/A
13. Miscellaneous4503.0143.100.0857.1642.9
97. Baking powder, baking soda, pectin50.000.0N/AN/AN/A
98. Baking decorations (e.g., colored sugars, sprinkles)60.0466.700.04100.000.0
99. Bread crumbs and batter mixes2111.441.900.04100.000.0
101. Cocoa powder40.000.0N/AN/AN/A
102. Non-alcoholic drink mixers (e.g., piña colada, daiquiri)50.000.0N/AN/AN/A
104. Salad and potato toppers (e.g., salad crunchies, crispins, substitutes for bacon bits)280.200.0N/AN/AN/A
105. Salt and salt substitutes, seasoned salts (e.g., garlic salt)170.100.0N/AN/AN/A
106. Spices and herbs1701.163.500.000.06100.0
14. Combination Dishes13578.9695.12029.04971.000.0
107. Measurable with a cup (e.g., casserole, macaroni and cheese, stir fry, chili, ravioli in sauce, poutine)6714.4243.6625.01875.000.0
108. Not measurable with a cup (e.g., burritos, egg rolls, pizza, quiche, stuffed vegetables, shish kabobs, meat and poultry lunch packages)5223.4387.21128.92771.100.0
109. Meat pie and tourtière1641.174.2342.9457.100.0
15. Nuts, seeds2201.494.1444.4555.600.0
110. Nuts and seeds, not for use as snacks, whole, chopped, sliced, slivered, ground1300.900.0N/AN/AN/A
111. Butters, pastes, creams (excl. peanut butter)330.2412.14100.000.000.0
112. Peanut butter500.3510.000.05100.000.0
113. Flours (e.g., coconut flour)70.100.0N/AN/AN/A
16. Potatoes, sweet potatoes, yams1400.942.9250.0250.000.0
114. French fried, hash browns, skins and pancakes690.545.8250.0250.000.0
115. Mashed, candied, stuffed or with sauce560.400.0N/AN/AN/A
116. Plain, fresh, canned or frozen150.100.0N/AN/AN/A
17. Salads700.500.0N/AN/AN/A
117. Salads (e.g., Egg, fish, shellfish, bean, fruit, vegetable, meat), except those as separate item460.300.0N/AN/AN/A
119. Pasta or potato salad240.200.0N/AN/AN/A
18. Sauces, dips, gravies, condiments12298.100.0N/AN/AN/A
120. Sauces for dipping (e.g., barbeque, hollandaise, tartar, mustard, sweet and sour)1040.700.0N/AN/AN/A
121. Dips (legume or dairy-based)1400.900.0N/AN/AN/A
122. Major main entrée sauce (e.g., spaghetti sauce)2251.500.0N/AN/AN/A
123. Minor main entrée sauce (e.g., pizza sauce, pesto sauce, salsa, etc.)2871.900.0N/AN/AN/A
124. Major condiments (e.g., ketchup, steak sauce, vinegar, marinades)3752.500.0N/AN/AN/A
125. Minor condiments (e.g., horseradish, hot sauce, mustard, Worcestershire sauce)980.600.0N/AN/AN/A
19. Snacks (Chips, pretzels, meat or nut snacks)7945.2546.81018.54481.500.0
126. Chips, pretzels, popcorn, extruded snacks, grain-based snack mixes and fruit-based snacks (e.g., fruit chips)5583.7529.31019.24280.800.0
127. Nuts or seeds for use as snacks2231.520.900.02100.000.0
128. Meat or poultry snack food sticks130.100.0N/AN/AN/A
20. Soups4563.010.200.01100.000.0
129. All varieties4563.010.200.01100.000.0
21. Sugars, sweets7494.9729.600.06286.11013.9
130. Candies (incl. chocolate bars and chocolate products), except those as separate item3772.54511.900.045100.000.0
131. Hard candies, except those as separate item80.1337.500.03100.000.0
132. Baking candies, such as chocolate chips300.213.300.01100.000.0
133. Breath mints60.000.0N/AN/AN/A
135. Confectioner’s or icing sugar10.000.0N/AN/AN/A
136. Bread spreads, except those as separate item, honey, molasses500.3918.000.000.09100.0
137. Jams, jellies, marmalades, fruit butters, spreads1931.310.500.000.01100.0
138. Marshmallows130.1323.100.03100.000.0
139. Sugars, except those as separate item60.000.0N/AN/AN/A
140. Sugar substitute30.000.0N/AN/AN/A
141. Syrups (incl. chocolate, maple and corn syrup)620.41016.100.010100.000.0
22. Vegetables8345.500.0N/AN/AN/A
142. Vegetables without sauce (incl. cream style corn, stewed tomatoes), except vegetables without sauce listed as separate item4182.700.0N/AN/AN/A
143. Vegetables with sauce170.100.0N/AN/AN/A
144. Vegetables for use as garnish/flavoring, fresh, canned or frozen, but not dried (e.g., parsley or garlic)240.200.0N/AN/AN/A
145. Chili pepper and green onion420.300.0N/AN/AN/A
146. Seaweed60.000.0N/AN/AN/A
147. Lettuce and spouts170.100.0N/AN/AN/A
148. Vegetable juice and vegetable drink430.300.0N/AN/AN/A
149. Olives830.500.0N/AN/AN/A
150. Pickles1120.700.0N/AN/AN/A
151. Relish240.200.0N/AN/AN/A
152. Vegetable pastes, (e.g., tomato paste)120.100.0N/AN/AN/A
153. Vegetable sauce or puree (e.g., tomato sauce or tomato puree)360.200.0N/AN/AN/A
1 Packaged food products are from the Food Label Information Program (FLIP) 2013, as described in [22]. 2 Products with child-directed packaging were identified using criteria based on previous publications [23]. 3 Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria are defined in: Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative; Uniform Nutrition Criteria White Paper; September 2014 [17]. 4 Food categories are defined in Schedule M of the Food and Drug Regulations (C.R.C., c. 870), Sections B.01.001, B.01.002A and D.01.001, Government of Canada, Health Canada [21]. 5 Percentage of total products (i.e., out of n = 15,231 products). 6 Percentage of total products in that food category. 7 Percentage of products with child-directed packaging in that food category.

References

  1. Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation. Gbd Profile: Canada; Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation: Seattle, WA, USA, 2015; Available online: http://www.healthdata.org/canada (accessed on 6 June 2018).
  2. Janssen, I. The public health burden of obesity in Canada. Can. J. Diabetes 2013, 37, 90–96. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  3. Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada. The Kids Are Not Alright. How the Food and Beverage Industry is Marketing Our Children and Youth to Death. 2017 Report on the Health of Canadians. 1 February 2017. Available online: http://www.heartandstroke.ca/-/media/pdf-files/canada/2017-heart-month/heartandstroke-reportonhealth2017.ashx?la=en&hash=1D4354193C46A235D2A657230FE2EB29DC6F34C8 (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  4. Statistics Canada. Table 105-2024—Measured Children and Youth Body Mass Index (BMI) (World Health Organization Classification), by Age Group and Sex, Canada and Provinces, Canadian Community Health Survey—Nutrition, Occasional, Cansim (Database). Statistics Canada. Ottawa, Canada. Available online: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1310079501 (accessed on 6 June 2018).
  5. World Health Organization. Consideration of the Evidence on Childhood Obesity for the Commission on Ending Childhood Obesity. Report of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Science and Evidence for Ending Childhood Obesity; World Health Organization: Geneva, Switzerland, 2016; Available online: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/206549/9789241565332_eng.pdf?sequence=1 (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  6. Boyland, E.J.; Whalen, R. Food advertising to children and its effects on diet: Review of recent prevalence and impact data. Pediatr. Diabetes 2015, 16, 331–337. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  7. Sadeghirad, B.; Duhaney, T.; Motaghipisheh, S.; Campbell, N.R.; Johnston, B.C. Influence of unhealthy food and beverage marketing on children’s dietary intake and preference: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials. Obes. Rev. 2016, 17, 945–959. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  8. Cairns, G.; Angus, K.; Hastings, G.; Caraher, M. Systematic reviews of the evidence on the nature, extent and effects of food marketing to children. A retrospective summary. Appetite 2013, 62, 209–215. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  9. Potvin Kent, M.; Dubois, L.; Wanless, A. A nutritional comparison of foods and beverages marketed to children in two advertising policy environments. Obesity 2012, 20, 1829–1837. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  10. Keller, K.L.; Kuilema, L.G.; Lee, N.; Yoon, J.; Mascaro, B.; Combes, A.L.; Deutsch, B.; Sorte, K.; Halford, J.C. The impact of food branding on children’s eating behavior and obesity. Physiol. Behav. 2012, 106, 379–386. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  11. Rincon-Gallardo Patino, S.; Tolentino-Mayo, L.; Flores Monterrubio, E.A.; Harris, J.L.; Vandevijvere, S.; Rivera, J.A.; Barquera, S. Nutritional quality of foods and non-alcoholic beverages advertised on mexican television according to three nutrient profile models. BMC Public Health 2016, 16, 733. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  12. Rovirosa, A.; Zapata, M.E.; Gomez, P.; Gotthelf, S.; Ferrante, D. Food and beverage advertising on children’s TV channels in argentina: Frequency, duration, and nutritional quality. Arch. Argent. Pediatr. 2017, 115, 28–34. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  13. Boyland, E.J.; Nolan, S.; Kelly, B.; Tudur-Smith, C.; Jones, A.; Halford, J.C.; Robinson, E. Advertising as a cue to consume: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of acute exposure to unhealthy food and nonalcoholic beverage advertising on intake in children and adults. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 2016, 103, 519–533. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  14. World Health Organization. Set of Recommendations on the Marketing of Foods and Non-Alcoholic Beverages to Children. 2010, p. 16. Available online: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44416/9789241500210_eng.pdf;jsessionid=15D6E01BD97F1C3A4BD2EB6897148D29?sequence=1 (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  15. Kraak, V.I.; Vandevijvere, S.; Sacks, G.; Brinsden, H.; Hawkes, C.; Barquera, S.; Lobstein, T.; Swinburn, B.A. Progress achieved in restricting the marketing of high-fat, sugary and salty food and beverage products to children. Bull. World Health Organ. 2016, 94, 540–548. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  16. Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative. Core Principles. January 2016. Available online: http://www.adstandards.com/en/childrensinitiative/corePrinciples.html (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  17. Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative. Uniform Nutrition Criteria White Paper; September 2014. Available online: http://adstandards.com/en/childrensinitiative/CAIUniformNutritionCriteriaWhitePaper.pdf (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  18. World Health Organization. Nutrient Profiling. 2016. Available online: http://www.who.int/nutrition/topics/profiling/en/ (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  19. Raine, K.; Lobstein, T.; Landon, J.; Potvin Kent, M.; Pellerin, S.; Caulfield, T.; Finegood, D.; Mongeau, L.; Neary, N.; Spence, J. Restricting marketing to children: Consensus on policy interventions to address obesity. J. Public Health Policy 2013, 34, 239–253. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  20. Galbraith-Emami, S.; Lobstein, T. The impact of initiatives to limit the advertising of food and beverage products to children: A systematic review. Obes. Rev. 2013, 14, 960–974. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  21. Government of Canada. Food and Drug Regulations (c.R.C., c. 870); Minister of Justice: Ottawa, ON, Canada, 2016.
  22. Bernstein, J.T.; Schermel, A.; Mills, C.M.; L’Abbe, M.R. Total and free sugar content of Canadian prepackaged foods and beverages. Nutrients 2016, 8, 151. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  23. Labonté, M.; Poon, T.; Mulligan, C.; Bernstein, J.T.; Franco-Arellano, B.; L’Abbé, M.R. Comparison of global nutrient profiling systems for restricting the commercial marketing of foods and beverages of low nutritional quality to children in Canada. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 2017, 106, 1471–1481. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  24. Colby, S.E.; Johnson, L.; Scheett, A.; Hoverson, B. Nutrition marketing on food labels. J. Nutr. Educ. Behav. 2010, 42, 92–98. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  25. Elliott, C. Marketing fun foods: A profile and analysis of supermarket food messages targeted at children. In Canadian Public Policy; University of Toronto Press: Toronto, ON, Canada, 2008; Volume 34, pp. 259–273. [Google Scholar]
  26. Health Canada. Strategy. Ottawa, Canada. 2016; p. 10. Available online: https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/canada/health-canada/migration/publications/eating-nutrition/healthy-eating-strategy-canada-strategie-saine-alimentation/alt/pub-eng.pdf (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  27. Senate of Canada. Bill s-228: An Act to Amend the Food and Drugs Act (Prohibiting Food and Beverage Marketing Directed at Children)—As Passed in Senate; First Session, Forty-Second Parliament, 64-65-66 Elizabeth II. Senate of Canada. Ottawa, Canada. Available online: https://www.parl.ca/Content/Bills/421/Private/S-228/S-228_3/S-228_3.PDF (accessed on 6 June 2018).
  28. Government of Canada. Restricting Marketing of Unhealthy Food and Beverages to Children: An Update on Proposed Regulations. 14 May 2018. Available online: https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/programs/consultation-restricting-unhealthy-food-and-beverage-marketing-to-children/update-proposed-regulations.html#adv (accessed on 6 June 2018).
  29. Mhurchu, C.N.; Mackenzie, T.; Vandevijvere, S. Protecting new zealand children from exposure to the marketing of unhealthy foods and drinks: A comparison of three nutrient profiling systems to classify foods. N. Z. Med. J. 2016, 129, 41–53. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  30. Health Canada. Eating Well with Canada’s Food Guide. Canada, 2011. Available online: https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/hc-sc/migration/hc-sc/fn-an/alt_formats/hpfb-dgpsa/pdf/food-guide-aliment/print_eatwell_bienmang-eng.pdf (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  31. Health Canada. Summary of Guiding Principles and Recommendations. Available online: https://www.foodguideconsultation.ca/guiding-principles-detailed (accessed on 2 October 2017).
  32. Kelly, B.; Halford, J.C.; Boyland, E.J.; Chapman, K.; Bautista-Castaño, I.; Berg, C.; Caroli, M.; Cook, B.; Coutinho, J.G.; Effertz, T.; et al. Television food advertising to children: A global perspective. Am. J. Public Health 2010, 100, 1730–1736. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  33. Elliott, C.D. Packaging fun: Analyzing supermarket food messages targeted at children. Can. J. Commun. 2012, 37, 303. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  34. Potvin Kent, M.; Martin, C.L.; Kent, E.A. Changes in the volume, power and nutritional quality of foods marketed to children on television in Canada. Obesity 2014, 22, 2053–2060. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  35. Lawrence, M.A.; Dickie, S.; Woods, J.L. Do nutrient-based front-of-pack labelling schemes support or undermine food-based dietary guideline recommendations? Lessons from the australian health star rating system. Nutrients 2018, 10, 32. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  36. Wellard, L.; Hughes, C.; Watson, W.L. Investigating nutrient profiling and health star ratings on core dairy products in australia. Public Health Nutr. 2016, 19, 2860–2865. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  37. Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code—Standard 1.2.7—Nutrition, Health and Related Claims. Australian Government. Canberra, Australia. Available online: https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/F2017C00716 (accessed on 2 October 2017).
  38. United Kingdom Department of Health. Nutrient Profiling Technical Guidance January 2011. 2011. Available online: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/216094/dh_123492.pdf (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  39. Scarborough, P.; Rayner, M.; Stockley, L. Developing nutrient profile models: A systematic approach. Public Health Nutr. 2007, 10, 330–336. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  40. Rayner, M.; Scarborough, P.; Stockley, L. Nutrient Profiles: Options for Definitions for Use in Relation to Food Promotion and Children’s Diets Final Report; British Heart Foundation Health Promotion Research Group, Department of Public Health, University of Oxford: Oxford, UK, October 2004. [Google Scholar]
  41. World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe. Who regional office for europe nutrient profile model. 2015. Available online: http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/270716/Nutrient-children_web-new.pdf (accessed on 24 April 2018).
  42. Stop Marketing to Kids Coalition. The Ottawa Principles. Available online: http://stopmarketingtokids.ca/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Stop-M2K-Ottawa-Principles.pdf (accessed on 24 April 2018).
Table
Table 1. Evaluation of Canadian packaged food and beverage products 1 according to the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria 2, presented overall and by major food category 3.
Table 1. Evaluation of Canadian packaged food and beverage products 1 according to the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria 2, presented overall and by major food category 3.
Schedule M Category 3 CAI Uniform Nutrition Criteria 2
AllowedRestricted
Total Products AnalyzedMissing Data 4Meets CAI Criteria 2Automatically Allowed 2Total AllowedDoes Not Meet CAI Criteria 2Automatically Restricted 2Total RestrictedNo Criteria 2
n% 5n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6n% 6
TOTAL15,231100.070.0327821.55723.8385025.3760649.911057.3871157.2266317.5
1. Bakery Products208413.720.147022.600.047022.6161277.400.0161277.400.0
2. Beverages (soft drinks, iced teas, coffees)4823.200.000.000.000.000.0482100.0482100.000.0
3. Cereals, other grain products9886.510.133233.600.033233.659259.900.059259.9636.4
4. Dairy products, substitutes12408.110.164552.0796.472458.451541.500.051541.500.0
5. Desserts (Dairy and non-Dairy)8275.400.0597.100.0597.176792.700.076792.710.1
6. Dessert toppings, fillings1160.800.000.000.000.000.0116100.0116100.000.0
7. Eggs, egg substitutes560.400.04275.000.04275.01425.000.01425.000.0
8. Fats, oils5353.500.000.000.000.000.000.000.0535100.0
9. Marine, fresh water animals4402.900.08118.400.08118.435981.600.035981.600.0
10. Fruit, fruit juices10897.100.048944.9585.354750.252848.500.052848.5141.3
11. Legumes1801.200.08949.400.08949.49150.600.09150.600.0
12. Meat, poultry, their products, substitutes8955.900.0778.600.0778.681891.400.081891.400.0
13. Miscellaneous4503.000.0184.000.0184.019342.9112.420445.322850.7
14. Combination Dishes13578.930.247334.900.047334.988164.900.088164.900.0
15. Nuts, seeds2201.400.012657.300.012657.38739.500.08739.573.2
16. Potatoes, sweet potatoes, yams1400.900.07452.900.07452.96647.100.06647.100.0
17. Salads700.500.04868.600.04868.62231.400.02231.400.0
18. Sauces, dips, gravies, condiments12298.100.000.000.000.000.000.000.01229100.0
19. Snacks (Chips, pretzels, meat or nut snacks)7945.200.016721.000.016721.062779.000.062779.000.0
20. Soups4563.000.06915.100.06915.138784.900.038784.900.0
21. Sugars, sweets7494.900.000.000.000.000.049666.249666.225333.8
22. Vegetables8345.500.0192.343552.245454.4475.600.0475.633339.9
1 Packaged food products are from the Food Label Information Program (FLIP) 2013 database, as described in [22]. 2 Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria are defined in: Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative; Uniform Nutrition Criteria White Paper; September 2014 [17]. 3 Food categories are defined in Schedule M of the Food and Drug Regulations (C.R.C., c. 870), Sections B.01.001, B.01.002A and D.01.001, Government of Canada, Health Canada [21]. 4 Missing data indicates products which were evaluated, but values were missing for at least one of the tested nutrients that were required to determine whether a product would or would not meet the CAI criteria. However, in cases where values were missing for at least one of the tested nutrients but it did not affect the product’s evaluation (e.g., a “nutrient to encourage” had a missing value but the product already did not meet the “nutrients required to limit”), it was still possible to classify these products as or ‘restricted’ from marketing to children. Therefore, such products were not considered as having missing data. 5 Percentage of total products (i.e., out of n = 15,231 products). 6 Percentage of total products in that food category.
Table
Table 2. Proportion of packaged food and beverage products 1 with child-directed packaging 2 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 3, presented overall and by major food category 4.
Table 2. Proportion of packaged food and beverage products 1 with child-directed packaging 2 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 3, presented overall and by major food category 4.
All Packaged Foods 1Packaged Foods with Child-Directed Packaging 2
Schedule M Category 4Total Products AnalyzedTotal Products AnalyzedTotal Allowed 3Total Restricted 3No CAI Criteria 3
n% 5n% 6n% 7n% 7n% 7
TOTAL15,231100.07474.917523.455674.4162.1
1. Bakery Products208413.71738.34626.612773.400.0
2. Beverages (soft drinks, iced teas, coffees)4823.2112.300.011100.000.0
3. Cereals, other grain products9886.5515.22549.02651.000.0
4. Dairy products, substitutes12408.1746.04560.82939.200.0
5. Desserts (Dairy and non-Dairy)8275.414417.442.814097.200.0
6. Dessert toppings, fillings1160.876.000.07100.000.0
7. Eggs, egg substitutes560.400.0N/AN/AN/A
8. Fats, oils5353.500.0N/AN/AN/A
9. Marine, fresh water animals4402.920.500.02100.000.0
10. Fruit, fruit juices10897.1585.31831.04069.000.0
11. Legumes1801.200.0N/AN/AN/A
12. Meat, poultry, their products, substitutes8955.940.4125.0375.000.0
13. Miscellaneous4503.0143.100.0857.1642.9
14. Combination Dishes13578.9695.12029.04971.000.0
15. Nuts, seeds2201.494.1444.4555.600.0
16. Potatoes, sweet potatoes, yams1400.942.9250.0250.000.0
17. Salads700.500.0N/AN/AN/A
18. Sauces, dips, gravies, condiments12298.100.0N/AN/AN/A
19. Snacks (Chips, pretzels, meat or nut snacks)7945.2546.81018.54481.500.0
20. Soups4563.010.200.01100.000.0
21. Sugars, sweets7494.9729.600.06286.11013.9
22. Vegetables8345.500.0N/AN/AN/A
1 Packaged food products are from the Food Label Information Program (FLIP) 2013 database, as described in [22]. 2 Products with child-directed packaging were identified using criteria based on previous publications [23]. 3 Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria are defined in: Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative; Uniform Nutrition Criteria White Paper; September 2014 [17]. 4 Food categories are defined in Schedule M of the Food and Drug Regulations (C.R.C., c. 870), Sections B.01.001, B.01.002A and D.01.001, Government of Canada, Health Canada [21]. 5 Percentage of total products (i.e., out of n = 15,231 products). 6 Percentage of total products in that food category. 7 Percentage of products with child-directed packaging in that food category.
Table
Table 3. Proportion of packaged food and beverage products 1 offered by CAI participating and non-participating companies 2 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 3, presented overall and by food category 4.
Table 3. Proportion of packaged food and beverage products 1 offered by CAI participating and non-participating companies 2 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 3, presented overall and by food category 4.
Schedule M Category 4All Packaged Foods 1Packaged Foods from CAI Participating Companies 2Packaged Foods from Non-Participating Companies
Total Products AnalyzedMissing Data 5Total Products AnalyzedTotal Allowed 3Total Restricted 3No CAI Criteria 3Total Products AnalyzedTotal Allowed 3Total Restricted 3No CAI Criteria 3
n% 6n% 7n% 7n% 8n% 8n% 8n% 7n% 9n% 9n% 9
TOTAL15,231100.070.0213114.051124.0143167.21898.913,09386.0333925.5728055.6247418.9
1. Bakery Products208413.720.135817.28724.327175.700.0172482.738322.2134177.800.0
2. Beverages (soft drinks, iced teas, coffees)4823.200.017235.700.0172100.000.031064.300.0310100.000.0
3. Cereals, other grain products9886.510.112212.37662.34436.121.686587.625629.654863.4617.1
4. Dairy products, substitutes12408.110.128122.716458.411741.600.095877.356058.539841.500.0
5. Desserts (Dairy and non-Dairy)8275.400.020224.442.019898.000.062575.6558.856991.010.2
6. Dessert toppings, fillings1160.800.01412.100.014100.000.010287.900.0102100.000.0
7. Eggs, egg substitutes560.400.000.0N/AN/AN/A56100.04275.01425.000.0
8. Fats, oils5353.500.09317.400.000.093100.044282.600.000.0442100.0
9. Marine, fresh water animals4402.900.000.0N/A N/AN/A440100.08118.435981.600.0
10. Fruit, fruit juices10897.100.0928.43437.05863.000.099791.651351.547047.1141.4
11. Legumes1801.200.010.61100.000.000.017999.48849.29150.800.0
12. Meat, poultry, their products, substitutes8955.900.0626.946.55893.500.083393.1738.876091.200.0
13. Miscellaneous4503.000.07416.434.15168.92027.037683.6154.015340.720855.3
14. Combination Dishes13578.930.222716.75825.616974.400.0112783.141536.871263.200.0
15. Nuts, seeds2201.400.0167.300.016100.000.020492.712661.87134.873.4
16. Potatoes, sweet potatoes, yams1400.900.0128.6216.71083.300.012891.47256.35643.800.0
17. Salads700.500.011.400.01100.000.06998.64869.62130.400.0
18. Sauces, dips, gravies, condiments12298.100.0715.800.000.071100.0115894.200.000.01158100.0
19. Snacks (Chips, pretzels, meat or nut snacks)7945.200.0253.1520.02080.000.076996.916221.160778.900.0
20. Soups4563.000.017137.53721.613478.400.028562.53211.225388.800.0
21. Sugars, sweets7494.900.09713.000.09597.922.165287.000.040161.525138.5
22. Vegetables8345.500.0404.83690.037.512.579495.241852.6445.533241.8
1 Packaged food products are from the Food Label Information Program (FLIP) 2013 database, as described in [22]. 2 Companies Participating in the CAI, as Defined by the CAI Core Principles, October 2017 [16]. 3 Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria are defined in: Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative; Uniform Nutrition Criteria White Paper; September 2014 [17]. 4 Food categories are defined in Schedule M of the Food and Drug Regulations (C.R.C., c. 870), Sections B.01.001, B.01.002A and D.01.001, Government of Canada, Health Canada [21]. 5 Missing data indicates products which were evaluated, but values were missing for at least one of the tested nutrients that were required to determine whether a product would or would not meet the CAI criteria. However, in cases where values were missing for at least one of the tested nutrients but it did not affect the product’s evaluation (e.g., a “nutrient to encourage” had a missing value but the product already did not meet the “nutrients required to limit”), it was still possible to classify these products as or ‘restricted’ from marketing to children. Therefore, such products were not considered as having missing data. 6 Percentage of total products (i.e., out of n = 15,231 products). 7 Percentage of total products in that food category. 8 Percentage of products from CAI participating companies in that food category. 9 Percentage of products from non-participating companies in that food category.
Table
Table 4. Proportion of packaged food and beverage products 1 with child-directed packaging 2 offered by CAI participating and non-participating companies 3 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 4, presented overall and by food category 5.
Table 4. Proportion of packaged food and beverage products 1 with child-directed packaging 2 offered by CAI participating and non-participating companies 3 that would be allowed to be advertised to children according to the CAI’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria 4, presented overall and by food category 5.
Schedule M Category 5 Packaged Foods 1 from CAI Participating Companies 3Packaged Foods 1 from Non-Participating Companies
Total Products AnalyzedTotal Products AnalyzedTotal Allowed 4Total Restricted 4No CAI Criteria 4Total Products AnalyzedTotal Allowed 4Total Restricted 4No CAI Criteria 4
n% 6n% 7n% 8n% 8n% 8n% 7n% 9n% 9n% 9
TOTAL747100.024933.37630.517369.500.049866.79919.938376.9163.2
1. Bakery Products17323.26537.61726.24873.800.010862.42926.97973.100.0
2. Beverages (soft drinks, iced teas, coffees)111.5436.400.04100.000.0763.600.07100.000.0
3. Cereals, other grain products516.83364.72369.71030.300.01835.3211.11688.900.0
4. Dairy products, substitutes749.93851.42463.21436.800.03648.62158.31541.700.0
5. Desserts (Dairy and non-Dairy)14419.33826.425.33694.700.010673.621.910498.100.0
6. Dessert toppings, fillings70.9114.300.01100.000.0685.700.06100.000.0
7. Eggs, egg substitutes00.0N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
8. Fats, oils00.0N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
9. Marine, fresh water animals20.300.0N/AN/AN/A2100.000.02100.000.0
10. Fruit, fruit juices587.83051.7516.72583.300.02848.31346.41553.600.0
11. Legumes00.0N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
12. Meat, poultry, their products, substitutes40.500.0N/AN/AN/A4100.0125.0375.000.0
13. Miscellaneous141.917.100.01100.000.01392.900.0753.8646.2
14. Combination Dishes699.268.7116.7583.300.06391.31930.24469.800.0
15. Nuts, seeds91.2222.200.02100.000.0777.8457.1342.900.0
16. Potatoes, sweet potatoes, yams40.500.0N/AN/AN/A4100.0250.0250.000.0
17. Salads00.0N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
18. Sauces, dips, gravies, condiments00.0N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
19. Snacks (Chips, pretzels, meat or nut snacks)547.21018.5440.0660.000.04481.5613.63886.400.0
20. Soups10.100.0N/AN/AN/A1100.000.01100.000.0
21. Sugars, sweets729.62129.200.021100.000.05170.800.04180.41019.6
22. Vegetables00.0N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
1 Packaged food products are from the Food Label Information Program (FLIP) 2013 database, as described in [22]. 2 Products with child-directed packaging were identified using criteria based on previous publications [23]. 3 Companies Participating in the CAI, as Defined by the CAI Core Principles, October 2017 [16]. 4 Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s (CAI) Uniform Nutrition Criteria are defined in: Advertising Standards Canada. Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative; Uniform Nutrition Criteria White Paper; September 2014 [17]. 5 Food categories are defined in Schedule M of the Food and Drug Regulations (C.R.C., c. 870), Sections B.01.001, B.01.002A and D.01.001, Government of Canada, Health Canada [21]. 6 Percentage of total products (i.e., out of n = 747 products). 7 Percentage of total products in that food category. 8 Percentage of products from CAI participating companies in that food category. 9 Percentage of products from non-participating companies in that food category.

Share and Cite

MDPI and ACS Style

Mulligan, C.; Labonté, M.-È.; Vergeer, L.; L’Abbé, M.R. Assessment of the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria for Restricting Children’s Food and Beverage Marketing in Canada. Nutrients 2018, 10, 803. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu10070803

AMA Style

Mulligan C, Labonté M-È, Vergeer L, L’Abbé MR. Assessment of the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria for Restricting Children’s Food and Beverage Marketing in Canada. Nutrients. 2018; 10(7):803. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu10070803

Chicago/Turabian Style

Mulligan, Christine, Marie-Ève Labonté, Laura Vergeer, and Mary R. L’Abbé. 2018. "Assessment of the Canadian Children’s Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative’s Uniform Nutrition Criteria for Restricting Children’s Food and Beverage Marketing in Canada" Nutrients 10, no. 7: 803. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu10070803

Note that from the first issue of 2016, this journal uses article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Article Metrics

Back to TopTop