Next Article in Journal
Linear Parks along Urban Rivers: Perceptions of Thermal Comfort and Climate Change Adaptation in Cyprus
Next Article in Special Issue
Public Open Space Development for Elderly People by Using the DANP-V Model to Establish Continuous Improvement Strategies towards a Sustainable and Healthy Aging Society
Previous Article in Journal
Sustainable and Resilient Garment Supply Chain Network Design with Fuzzy Multi-Objectives under Uncertainty

Sustainability 2016, 8(10), 1037;

An Application of the Short-Term Forecasting with Limited Data in the Healthcare Traveling Industry
Department of Industrial Engineering and Management, National Kaohsiung University of Applied Sciences, No. 415, Chien Kung road, Sanmin district, Kaohsiung City 80778, Taiwan
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Academic Editor: Marc A. Rosen
Received: 3 July 2016 / Accepted: 9 October 2016 / Published: 16 October 2016


In real practice, forecasting under the limited data has attracted more attention in business activities, especially in the healthcare traveling industry in its current stage. However, there are only a few research studies focusing on this issue. Thus, the purposes of this paper were to determine the forecasted performance of several current forecasting methods as well as to examine their applications. Taking advantage of the small data requirement for model construction, three models including the exponential smoothing model, the Grey model GM(1,1), and the modified Lotka-Volterra model (L.V.), were used to conduct forecasting analyses based on the data of foreign patients from 2001 to 2013 in six destinations. The results indicated that the L.V. model had higher prediction power than the other two models, and it obtained the best forecasting performance with an 89.7% precision rate. In conclusion, the L.V. model is the best model for estimating the market size of the healthcare traveling industry, followed by the GM(1,1) model. The contribution of this study is to offer a useful statistical tool for short-term planning, which can be applied to the healthcare traveling industry in particular, and for other business forecasting under the conditions of limited data in general.
forecasting; limited data; healthcare traveling industry

1. Introduction

Healthcare traveling, also known as the medical tourism industry, is a type of service industry which is a combination of healthcare or medical treatments and tourism services. The development of the healthcare traveling industry is a product of the rise of private healthcare demand, the globalization of healthcare services, the rapid development of the Internet, and the increasing providers of low-cost traveling abroad. Therefore, sustainable development of the healthcare traveling industry has an important role for promoting and enhancing the level of social-economic performance of nations. Crucial factors that cause most foreign patients to look for access to therapeutic procedures across borders include the shortage of medical availability, lengthy waiting lists, or the affordability of treatments [1,2]. In addition, from the viewpoint of patients, seeking the advanced medical surgeries in foreign nations is also a main factor for healthcare traveling. As a result, there is a phenomenon of patient movement from developed countries to less developed countries, so that they can receive a high medical standard of healthcare, treatment, or beauty services through traveling [3]. In fact, the demand for out-of-pocket healthcare and medical services abroad is increasing around the world. According to [4], in 2019, the global medical tourism market will be have a market worth of 32.5 billion USD. The market size of this industry has been quickly expanding, which has created lucrative businesses on healthcare services, tourism services, and related businesses. In recognition of the potential contributions of healthcare traveling on economic development, several countries have been defined healthcare traveling as a core industry at the national level. Utilizing the advantages of medical technologies and tourism resources, governments have been investing more money in healthcare and medical infrastructure, as well as proposing promotion campaigns aimed at developing this industry. Some successful cases include Hungary, Belgium, Turkey, Poland, Mexico, Brazil, India, Thailand, Singapore, Malaysia, Korea, Taiwan, etc.
With the full effort and encouragement of the government, as well as the success of taking advantage of the competitive prices of medical services, advanced technologies in medical specialties, flexible treatment processes, and effective business strategies of the service providers, some countries in Asia including Thailand, Korea, Singapore, India, Malaysia, Thailand, and Taiwan have created their own accreditation system for exporting medical services to the global market. Although these countries joined the global market for healthcare traveling quite late compared to numerous destinations in Europe such as Hungary, Belgium, Spain, Czech Republic, Poland, etc., the performance of the countries in Asia has received close attention. Actually, the foreign patients from developed countries toward these countries for receiving healthcare and medical services, especially for healthcare screening, medical treatments, beauty or sex changes procedures, etc are increasing. Furthermore, along with the rise of China’s economy, the GDP and private income of people have been improving, and the medical tourism demand from Chinese patients has also made the Asian medical tourism market more lively in recent years. Within a decade, this area has become a popular destination of healthcare traveling with world class standards. This area continues to attract a large number of foreign medical tourists from around the world, compared to other areas. Among the Asian countries, Thailand and Singapore are far ahead with approximately 90% of the foreign patients in this area [5]. Statistical data of the number of medical tourists in six major destinations in Asia are presented in Table 1.
As mentioned above, the growth of healthcare traveling in Asia has been booming, and it has been assessed as a lucrative industry. Moreover, promoting sustainable development of this industry will help maintain three major sections of the host countries, including the environment, the economy, and the local community [14]. Particularly, the development of the healthcare traveling industry has not only positively impacted the quality of the local medical systems directly but has also played a crucial role in promoting related businesses, especially for the tourism industry. Therefore, it is necessary to have a reliable tool to estimate the market size of this industry in order to understand the changes in future demands. A suitable forecasting approach can help policymakers and stakeholders propose the correct strategies for their business activities. However, obtaining full data is a big problem for the healthcare traveling industry as discussed previously. Therefore, the idea of this study was to find numerous high predictive models which can apply to predict the demand of the healthcare travelling industry under the condition of small data points for model construction.
Regarding the forecasting of tourism demand, research in [15] addressed that forecasting accuracy is especially important and acute for the tourism industry because of the perishability of tourism. Based on the output of forecasting models, information can be utilized by policymakers to make different policy decisions under particular circumstances as “tourism flows have consequences for a wide range of different policy-making situation” [16]. Most of the current studies focused on the application of quantitative forecasting techniques with time series, econometric models, and some new techniques such as artificial intelligence (AI), artificial neural networks (ANNs), genetic algorithms (GAs), etc. [17] in various destinations. However, the performance of the forecast model relies on data frequencies used in the model estimation, destination-origin country/region pairs under consideration, and the length of the forecasting horizons concerned [18].
Asia’s healthcare traveling industry is still in its early stages, and thus gaining reliable data on the volume of consumption of health services aboard is challenging. In addition, the limited data from this industry cannot support the traditional approaches for long-term forecasts. Therefore, short-term forecast techniques using limited historical data can be considered. Previous literature [19] applied the GM(1,1) alpha model to forecast the demand for healthcare tourism in some Asian countries. However, this model did not perform well (the mean absolute percent error or MAPE is 29.1%) with India’s healthcare service provider. Aside from the GM(1,1) model, the time series autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA )model was also implemented to predict the demand for medical tourism in India [20]. The scope of this study only focused on a number of medical tourist arrivals from different countries traveling to India to receive healthcare services. Despite the fact that existing studies on medical tourism indicate that the businesses relative to the healthcare travelling are the large market for exploration, the estimation for this demand is regarded at a particular destination. Thus, the application of prediction methods in this industry still need to be developed.
As mentions above, it is necessary to have a high accuracy model to forecast the demand of the healthcare traveling industry. An effective tool for predicting play a crucial role in the process of decision making, which helps the policy makers, healthcare service providers, tourism industry leaders, as well as related service managers clearly recognize the changing in the future. To address the forecasting process using limited past information, as well as to determine the application scope of the proposed models in real practice, three models including the exponential smoothing model of time series forecast, the grey model, and the Lotka-Votterra (L.V.) model [21], were applied with the data of tourist arrivals of the healthcare traveling industry in six major medical destinations in Asia, as shown in Table 1. Finally, the forecasting power of the three forecasting models was also computed based on evaluating the precision rate of the forecasting models.
Following this section, in the next section we present the theoretical foundations related to the short-term forecasting and literature reviews of the three proposed forecasting models. The methodology is described in Section 3. The empirical results and discussion are presented in Section 4. Section 5 outlines the conclusions of this paper.

2. Theoretical Foundation

In this section, we present the discussions on short-term forecasting and the literature reviews of some forecast models with small data sets.
Forecasting is a crucial procedure in business strategic planning. Organization managers use forecast information for most of their business decisions. Thus, a trustworthy forecast cannot only help companies clearly recognize the future opportunities, but it can also reduce potential risks as well as fully utilize company resources. According to different business planning techniques and characteristics of each industry, managers intend to employ different time horizon based forecast techniques to estimate future demand. Generally speaking, the time horizon forecast will be segmented into three types including short-term, medium-term, and long-term forecasts. However, along with the rapid development of the internet and economic exchanges, business environments around the world are also rapidly changing, and therefore forecasting accuracy has been impacted by more uncertainty factors. As a result, many strategists have adopted short-term forecasting methods in order to respond to the change of business environments in real-time. Short-term forecasts have been popularly utilized in demand estimation, inventory control, finance, etc. A good short-term forecast will not only expand enterprise’s profits based on reduced inventory level and enhanced customer service levels, but it will also increase the prediction credibility of the organization [22].
Worthwhile information for business decisions is achieved by the output of a reliable forecast model, and thus choosing the right model for forecasting is crucial for the entire forecasting process. The right model is utilized as an effective tool to help forecasters realize the changing future trends. There are a few criteria used to help select a suitable forecast model. However, the data that is available and the data characteristics are the crucial criteria that impact the model selection. Some guides to determine suitable forecasting models based on the data requirements for several common forecasting models are summarized in Table 2. According to that, when the data sample size is small, only a few models can be used. Notice that, in this study “short-term forecasting” means forecasting for one or two following periods, and the forecasting process has been assumed slow incremental change. Therefore, between one or two periods and the next one, the time series can be rendered approximately stationary. Thus, we can predict that its statistical properties will be the same in the future as they have been in the past.
Even though forecasts are a vital part of an organization’s activities, its process still relies on historical information. However, full data is not always easy to obtain in real situations, such as the estimation of the demand of a new product, new services businesses, etc. Therefore, accurate forecasts with limited historical data have garnered the attention of researchers and company managers [23].

2.1. The Time Series Forecasting Using Exponential Smoothing

Presently, the traditional statistical approach offers some time series forecasting models which are commonly used in business forecasting. Time series forecasting models mainly predict the future change based on understanding the past data, that may contain one or more component: trend, seasonal, cyclical, autocorrelation, and random. Several popular time series models are ARIMA models, structural models, the generalized autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity (GARCH) models, neural networks, etc. However, most of the models require the use of large amounts of historical data in order to ensure the stationary of the forecast model.
Exponential smoothing forecasting is one model of time series which is popularly applied in business forecasting. According to the information in Table 2, this model takes advantage of the small data requirement, simple computation, and emphasizes the most up-to-date information compared to the rest of the models. As a result, the exponential smoothing has been determined to be an extremely valuable tool for short-term planning and inventory control with high forecast accuracy [25,26,27,28].

2.2. The Grey Forecasting

Besides the traditional forecasting approach mentioned above, the grey prediction is also used as a popular forecasting tool under the conditions of limited observations and uncertainty circumstances. As part of the grey system theory which was developed in 1989 by Deng [29], grey prediction models mainly focus on sequence prediction, disaster prediction, seasonal prediction, topology prediction, and composite prediction. Several common grey prediction models include the GM(1,1), the grey Verhulst, the DGM(1,1) [29], etc. Compared with traditional statistical forecast models, the historical data requirement for model construction of grey predictions can be minimized to at least four data points, the mathematical background for modeling is quite simple, and the forecast performance has high accuracy. For these reasons, grey prediction models have been widely utilized in the different fields of business forecasting, in both previous and current studies [23,30,31,32,33]. Therefore, grey predictions have become a favorite short-term forecasting technique for understanding the statements with limited past information or difficult to obtain data in the recent three decades. Until now, the application, exploration, and improvement of grey forecasts has been proposed in scholarly research and real applications.

2.3. The Lotka-Vottera System

The original Lotka-Vottera model was constructed based on the different equations of the predator and the prey, which was proposed by Alfred Lotka and Vito Volterra for determining the ecological law of nature around 1950 [34]. It mainly addressed the interactive relationship which was generated in an environment between two or more diversified competitors. Recently, research that analyzes the dynamic competition related to issues of society, economy, business, marketing, etc., by L.V. systems have been found in the literature. Lee et al. [35] employed the L.V. model to analyze the dynamic relationship between two competing markets in the Korean stock market. Wijeratne et al. in [36,37] used the L.V. model to analyze the competitive dynamics in the telecommunications sector of Sri Lanka and the market economics, respectively. Marasco et al. [38] also applied this model to analyze the market share dynamic. Furthermore, L.V. models which have been modified from the original competitive L.V. model have also been used for forecasting in recent studies. For instance, a modified L.V. model for Taiwan’s retail industry in [31] has proved better than the Bass model and was suggested as an effective method to forecast the level of competition. For the other case, an L.V. model was used as a decision making tool in the Taiwan IC assembly industry by estimating the parameters of this prediction model, and the results also indicated that the L.V. model was more accurate than the grey model, and that it could also utilize limited or incomplete data for its forecast. According to the empirical results, the L.V. model also proved better at short-term forecasting [39].

3. Methodology

According to the literature reviews on short-term forecasting as discussed in the previous section, in this section the mathematical functions of three forecasting models, namely the exponential smoothing, the grey model GM(1,1), and the Lotka-Votterra model (L.V.) are presented as follows.

3.1. The Exponential Smoothing Model

Exponential smoothing is one of the most common models of traditional time series forecasting. It has widespread use in business management because of its ease of understanding and application. Exponential smoothing forecasting is known as a sophisticated weighted averaging method. Accordingly, the new forecasted value is estimated by the previous forecast plus a percentage of the forecast error. Currently, there are two kinds of common exponential smoothing models; one is the simple exponential smoothing model, and the other is the exponential smoothing model with trend justified. Generally, when a time series presents no strong or discernable seasonality or trend, the single exponential smoothing will be used. As a result, the simple exponential smoothing model is applied in this work, and the mathematical formula of this model is cited from the research of Makridakis [40], and is described as follows.
Y ^ i + 1 = α Y i + ( 1 α ) Y ^ i
  • Y ^ i + 1 : Predicted value for the time period i + 1
  • Y ^ i : Predicted value for the time period i
  • α: Smoothing constant
In this model, the value of α ranges from 0 to 1. The smoothing constant is a key factor which decides the success of forecasting. When α is close to 1, the new forecast will include a substantial adjustment for the error in the previous forecast. Conversely, when α is close to 0, the new forecast will include very little adjustment. According to discussions in [41], there are several recommendations for choosing the value of the smoothing constant. Among them, the trial and error approach in [42] is utilized to determine the best smoothing weight. Thus, the minimum value of the statistical measures such as the mean absolute deviation (MAD), the mean squared error (MSE), and the mean absolute percent error (MAPE) have been used as the criteria for selecting the best α value for the forecasting model. Therefore, in this paper, different α values from 0 to 1 were adopted continuously to try to determine the best forecasting model with the minimum error. Finally, the exponential smoothing model with the best smoothing weight is presented.

3.2. Traditional Grey Forecasting Model GM(1,1)

GM(1,1) is a very popular model of grey prediction, that is known as a first order model with one variable. Presently, GM(1,1) has been widely applied in forecasting in different fields. In accordance with the Grey system theory [21], the formula of GM(1,1) is shown below:
Step 1: Given an original sequence as follows:
x ( 0 ) = { x ( 0 ) ( 1 ) , x ( 0 ) ( 2 ) , x ( 0 ) ( 3 ) , , x ( 0 ) ( i ) , x ( 0 ) ( n ) }
where, x ( 0 ) ( i ) is the value for the time period i   ( i = 1 , 2 , ... , n ) .
Step 2: A new sequence x ( 1 ) can be generated by a one time accumulated generating operation (1-AGO) based on the original sequence x ( 0 ) , which is:
x ( 1 ) = { x ( 1 ) ( 1 ) , x ( 1 ) ( 2 ) , x ( 1 ) ( 3 ) , , x ( 1 ) ( i ) , , x ( 1 ) ( n ) }
where, x ( 1 ) ( i ) = j = 1 i x ( 0 ) ( j )
Step 3: A first-order differential equation with one variable is expressed as follows:
d x ( 1 ) d t + u x ( 1 ) = v
where, u , v are the developing coefficient and the grey input coefficient, respectively. These two coefficients can be determined by the least square method as follows:
[ u , v ] T = ( P T P ) 1 P T Q
P = [ ( x ( 1 ) ( 1 ) + x ( 1 ) ( 2 ) ) / 2 1 ( x ( 1 ) ( 2 ) + x ( 1 ) ( 3 ) ) / 2 1 ( x ( 1 ) ( n 1 ) + x ( 1 ) ( n ) ) / 2 1 ]   and Q = [ x ( 0 ) ( 2 ) , x ( 0 ) ( 3 ) , , x ( 0 ) ( n ) ] T
Solving Equation (5), the time response function of the GM(1,1) is given by:
x ^ ( 1 ) ( i ) = [ x ( 0 ) ( 1 ) v u ] e u ( i 1 ) + v u ( i = 2 , 3 , , n )
The forecasted series x ^ ( 0 ) can be calculated by the operation of a one time inverse accumulated generating operation (1-IAGO) as follows:
x ^ ( 0 ) ( i ) = x ^ ( 1 ) ( i ) x ^ ( 1 ) ( i 1 ) ( i = 2 , 3 , , n )
Among which, x ^ ( 0 ) ( 1 ) = x ^ ( 1 ) ( 1 ) .

3.3. The Lotka-Votterra Forecasting Model

The Lotka-Vottera model was used to determine the competitive relationship of two species or two products or two companies. Presently, there are a few revised diffusion L.V. models used for forecasting in various industries [21,23,39]. However, in this study we applied the modified L.V. model described in [21] for forecasting based on the estimation of the main parameters of the prime equation, and the mathematical function of the L.V. trend forecast model is expressed as follows:
Step 1: Estimating parameters
Suppose the original function of the random L.V. model is as follows:
d x ( t ) = x ( t ) ( [ β α x ( t ) ] + σ d w ( t ) ) t > 0
  • d w ( t ) is the variation in the random process,
  • x ( t ) is the time steps
  • d x ( t ) is the dynamic change of x ( t ) .
Set y ( t ) = log ( x ( t ) ) , t > 0 and substitute the result into Equation (8). The initial statistic is presented as follows:
d y ( t ) = [ β 0.5 σ 2 α e y ( t ) ] d t + σ d w ( t ) t > 0
Hypothesize μ = β - 0.5 σ 2 to obtain
d y ( t ) = [ μ α e y ( t ) ] d t + σ d w ( t ) , t 0
Set Δ 0 , Y 0 = log ( x 0 ) , Equation (10) can be expressed as following:
Y i - Y i - 1 = μ α e Y i Δ + σ w i i = 1 , 2 ... , n
where w i is the difference of change for two different time points, and
w i = w ( ( i ) Δ ) w ( ( i - 1 ) Δ ) i = 1 , 2... , n
Setting the step size Δ = 1 allow us to obtain
Y i - Y i = μ α e Y i + σ w i i = 1 , 2 ... , n
To hypothesize numerous pieces of discrete series data, calculate Y i = log ( X i ) , let Z i = Y i - Y i - 1 , and then set time gap U i = X i - 1 , using Equation (13) as follows:
Z i = μ α e Y i - 1 + σ w i 1 i n
Substitute the time gap to obtain:
Z i = μ α U i + σ w i 1 i n
Equation (14) is a standard linear regression model. Thus, the parameters μ ^ , α ^ , σ ^ can be computed by least squares regression as follows:
μ ^ = Z ¯ + α ^ U ¯ ,   α ^ = S U Z S U U   and   σ ^ = S S E n - 2
Z ¯ = 1 n i = 1 n Z i   and   U ¯ = 1 n i = 1 n U i
S U U = i = 1 n U i 2 n U ¯ 2 ;   S U Z = i = 1 n U i Z i n U ¯ Z ¯   and   S Z Z = i = 1 n Z i 2 n Z ¯ 2
S S E = S Z Z + α ^ S U Z ;   and   β ^ = μ ^ + 0.5 σ ^ 2
Step 2: Forecasting
The above estimate parameters can obtain:
d x ^ ( t ) = x ^ ( t ) ( [ β ^ α ^ x ^ ( t ) ] d t + σ ^ d w ( t ) ) t 0
Substituting x ( t ) into Equation (20) to obtain d x ( t ) , the right-tailed interval estimate is used to forecast the next step x ( t ) .
The sample population can be large or small, and the normal distribution interval estimate serves as the basis of forecasting. The interval estimate equation is:
x ¯ ± z α 2 σ n   The   right-tailed   interval   is   x ¯ + z α 2 σ n
According to the data from steps one through step n, Equation (20) is used to forecast the d x ( t ) scope of step n + 1 . Research indicates that the difference between d x ( t ) and d x ( t 1 ) can be employed to estimate the gap between initial x ( t ) and x ( t 1 ) , as follows:
d x ( t ) d x ( t 1 ) d x ( t 1 ) x ( t ) x ( t 1 ) x ( t 1 )
Setting d x ^ ( t ) = x ^ ( t ) ( [ β ^ α ^ x ^ ( t ) ] d t + σ ^ d w ( t ) ) , t 0 is used to estimate x ( t ) , as follows:
x ^ ( t ) = d x ^ ( t ) [ β ^ α ^ x ^ ( t ) ] d t σ ^   d w ( t ) t 0
And then, x ^ ( t + 1 ) is estimated using x ^ ( t + 1 ) = d x ( t + 1 ) d x ( t ) x ( t ) .

3.4. Assessing Forecast Performance

The forecast errors will impact decisions in two somewhat different ways. The first is in making a choice between various forecasting alternatives, and the other is evaluating the success or failure of a technique in use [22]. Hence, when deciding on a forecast model to use, error measurements are usually employed based on the forecasted values and actual values. In this study, we adopted various error measurements to assess the forecast performance of the proposed models, including relative percentage errors (RPE), mean absolute deviation (MAD), mean absolute percent error (MAPE), root mean squared error (RMSE), and the accuracy rate or precision rate (p). These measurements were commonly applied in the previous literature when deciding among forecast alternatives [31,32,33]. Its functions are expressed as follows:
RPE = | x ( 0 ) ( i ) x ^ ( 0 ) ( i ) | x ( 0 ) ( i ) × 100 %
MAD = | x ( 0 ) ( i ) x ^ ( 0 ) ( i ) | n
RMSE = i = 1 n ( x ( 0 ) ( i ) x ^ ( 0 ) ( i ) ) 2 n
MAPE = ( 1 n i = 1 n x ( 0 ) ( i ) x ^ ( 0 ) ( i ) x ( 0 ) ( i ) ) × 100 %
In addition, the precision rate (p) which measures the level of the closeness of the statement of the forecast quantity and the actual value was also applied to confirm the forecasted performance. It was calculated based on the value of MAPE, and the formula is defined as follows:
p = 1 MAPE
Moreover, to clearly evaluate the performance of the forecasted model, several papers proposed the grades of forecast capability based on the value of MAPE [28,43,44]. In this work, we used the forecast grades of Ma and Zhang in [44]; four levels of the precision rate include excellent (>0.95), good (>0.90), qualified (0.85), and unqualified (≤0.85), respectively.

4. Results and Discussion

As shown in Table 1, the annual data of medical tourist arrivals for six destinations in Asia (Thailand, Singapore, Malaysia, Korea, Taiwan and India) were collected to conduct the forecast process. First, the total number of data points for individual destinations were utilized to build the forecast models. Then, to determine the forecast performance of different models in the healthcare traveling industry, model construction was conducted by the simple exponential smoothing model, the GM(1,1) model, and the L.V. model, respectively, for each destination. Finally, several statistical measurements of model errors and forecast precision (described in Section 3.4) have been used to analyze the performance of the proposed models.
The forecasted results have been calculated by the simple exponential smoothing model, the GM(1,1) model, and the L.V. model, and are reported in Figure 1. Forecasted curves and actual curves of medical tourist arrivals in individual destinations have been drawn. The forecasted performance of each forecast model was also evaluated and is shown in Table 3.
According to the results of the forecast performance of the three proposed models shown in Table 3, the error values of some measurements including the MAD, RMSE, and MAPE of the exponential smoothing model were clearly larger than the GM(1,1) model and the L.V. model, while these values of the GM(1,1) model were larger than the L.V. model. Particularly, the values of the error measurements of the exponential smoothing model fell from 669,091.67 to 32,907.03 for MAD value, from 1,058,751 to 37,672.3 for RMSE value and 41.8% to 27.21% for MAPE. Moreover, the precision rate of exponential smoothing ranged from 58.2% to 72.79%, and it did not reach the standard for reliable forecast as set by the classification grade of Ma and Zhang [44].
Similarly, the forecast performance of the GM(1,1) models were not better in this case. The values of MAD, RMSE, and MAPE of the GM(1,1) models were quite large, compared with the L.V. model. Thus, the forecast accuracy was much smaller, and the precision rate ranged from 82.2% to 97.17%. It was the only model to reach excellent forecast levels; one model achieved good forecast performance, and the other four GM(1,1) models had unqualified forecast performance.
In comparison with the previous two models, and based on the statistics of the error measures and the precision rate of the L.V. model as presented in Table 3, we realized that the L.V. models presented good forecast capability, with two models obtaining excellent forecast levels (96.39% and 97.9%), one model obtained good forecast levels (93.97%), one model presented a qualified forecast level (89.9%), and only two models (Korea and Taiwan) had unqualified forecast performances (75.9% and 84.69%). However, the forecast performance of these two cases by the GM(1,1) model was better than that of the L.V. model.
For making a clear and convenient comparison, we used the mean values of the precision rate in the six destinations to present the forecast performance of the three proposed models, shown in Figure 2.
Forecasted results from the 18 models indicated that the L.V. model had the best forecasted performance over the GM(1,1) model and the simple exponential smoothing model. According to Table 3, the values of some error measurements of the exponential smoothing model and the GM(1,1) were larger than the L.V. model. This means that the accuracy of the L.V. model was higher than the other two models. Generally, the mean precision rate of the L.V models was 89.7%, while that of the GM(1,1) models and exponential smoothing models was 86.36% and 65.94%, respectively.
The results proved that the L.V. models had higher prediction power than the traditional grey models and the exponential smoothing of traditional time series models under the same numerical data, and achieved the best forecasted performance among the three proposed models. Based on the empirical results, we suggest that the L.V. model can be used as an effective tool to estimate the future trend of medical tourist arrivals in the healthcare traveling industry. In contrast, the exponential smoothing model presented with inaccuracy for short-term forecasting with a small data size, so it is not suitable for use in this case. The forecasted performance of the GM(1,1) model was lower than the L.V. model, however its forecast level was still of a qualified grade. Therefore, besides the L.V. model, the GM(1,1) could be an alternative model for short-term forecasting with limited historical data.

5. Conclusions

Our research strengthens the prediction capability of forecasting models when using limited historical data. Based on the data of medical tourist arrivals, we applied three forecast models which did not require many historical data points for model construction, and these included the simple exponential smoothing model, the GM(1,1) model, and the L.V. model, to determine the forecast performance. The performance of proposed models was analyzed using the annual data of medical tourists in the healthcare traveling industry from 2001 to 2013 in six destinations (Thailand, Singapore, Malaysia, Korea, Taiwan and India) in Asia.
The results proved that the L.V. model had higher prediction power than the traditional grey model and the exponential smoothing model. It also presented the best forecasted performance among the three proposed models (89.7% precision rate). Based on the empirical results, we suggest that the L.V. model can be utilized as an effective tool to estimate the market size and identify the future trend of medical tourist arrivals in the healthcare traveling industry. Furthermore, although the forecasted performance of the GM(1,1) model was not better than the L.V. model, its accuracy level was still of a qualified grade (86.36% precision rate). Therefore, besides as the L.V. model, the GM(1,1) model can be an alternative for short-term forecasting with limited historical data. The exponential smoothing model was not appropriate for use in this case. The contribution of this study offers a useful statistical tool, which can be applied to the healthcare traveling industry in particular, and for other business forecasting as well, under the conditions of limited data in general. A good forecast can be obtained by using limited past data when using the right model.

Author Contributions

In this paper, Ying-Fang Huang collected the data and formulated analysis ideas, while Chia-Nan Wang designed the theoretical verifications. Hoang-Sa Dang analyzed the data and prepared the manuscript. Thuy-Mai-Trinh was involved in the results and discussion. All authors have both read and approved of the final version of the manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.


  1. Burkett, L. Medical Tourism. J. Leg. Med. 2007, 28, 223–245. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  2. Mudur, G. Hospitals in India woo foreign patients. Br. Med. J. 2004, 328, 1338. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  3. Lunt, N.; Mannion, R. Patient mobility in the global marketplace: A multidisciplinary perspective. Int. J. Health Pol. Manag. 2014, 2, 155–157. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  4. Transparency Market Research. Medical Tourism Market (India, Thailand, Singapore, Malaysia, Mexico, Brazil, Taiwan, Turkey, Korea, Costa Rica, Poland, Dubai and Philippines)—Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, Trends and Forecast, 2013–2019. Available online: (accessed on 31 May 2016).
  5. NaRanong, A.; NaRanong, V. The effects of medical tourism: Thailand’s experience. Bull. World Health Organ. 2011, 89, 336–344. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  6. Chee, H.L. Medical tourism and the state in Malaysia and Singapore. Glob. Soc. Pol. 2010, 10, 336–357. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  7. Penang Institute. Available online: (accessed on 13 October 2016).
  8. International Medical Travel Journal. Available online: (accessed on 13 October 2016).
  9. Report of Taiwan Ministry of Health and Welfare. Available online: (accessed on 13 October 2016).
  10. Tourism Bureau of Taiwan. Available online: (accessed on 13 October 2016).
  11. KaisiKon Research Center. Available online: (accessed on 13 October 2016).
  12. International Medical Travel Journal. Available online: (accessed on 13 October 2016).
  13. Khan, M.J.; Chelliah, S.; Haron, M.S. Medical tourism destination image formation process: A conceptual model. Int. J. Healthc. Manag. 2016, 9, 134–143. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  14. Darwazeh, D. Medical Tourism: Establishing a Sustainable Medical Facility. Master’s Thesis, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada, August 2011. [Google Scholar]
  15. Archer, B.; Ritchie, J.R.B.; Goeldner, C.R. Demand Forecasting and Estimation. Travel, Tourism, and Hospitality Research. A Handbook for Managers and Researchers; John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: New York, NY, USA, 1987. [Google Scholar]
  16. Van Doorn, J.W.M. Tourism forecasting and the policymaker. Tour. Manag. 1984, 5, 24–39. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. Song, H.; Li, G. Tourism demand modelling and forecasting—A review of recent research. Tour. Manag. 2008, 29, 203–220. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef][Green Version]
  18. Li, G. Recent developments in econometric modelling and forecasting. J. Trav. Res. 2005, 44, 82–99. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef][Green Version]
  19. Huang, Y.L. Forecasting the demand for health tourism in Asian countries using a GM(1,1)-alpha model. Tour. Hospit. Manag. 2012, 18, 171–181. [Google Scholar]
  20. Rai, A.; Chakrabarty, P.; Sarkar, A. Forecasting the demand for medical tourism in India. IOSR Int. J. Humanit. Soc. Sci. 2014, 19, 22–30. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  21. Teng, H.; Huang, Y. The use for the competition theory of the industrial investment decisions—A case study of the Taiwan IC assembly industry. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 2013, 141, 335–338. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Stevenson, W.J. Operations Management-9/E.: International Student Edition with Global Readings; McGraw-Hill Education (Asia): Singapore, 2007. [Google Scholar]
  23. Lin, C.S. Forecasting and analyzing the competitive diffusion of mobile cellular broadband and fixed broad-band in Taiwan with limited historical data. Econ. Model. 2013, 35, 207–213. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  24. Wilson, J.H.; Allison-Koerber, D. Combining subjective and objective forecasts improve results. J. Bus. Forecast. 1992, 11, 3–8. [Google Scholar]
  25. Brown, R.G. Smoothing, Forecasting and Prediction of Discrete Time Series; Dover Publications: Mineola, NY, USA, 2004. [Google Scholar]
  26. Gardner, E.S. Exponential smoothing: The state of the art. J. Forecast. 1985, 4, 1–28. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  27. Harrison, P.J. Exponential smoothing and short-term sales forecasting. Manag. Sci. 1967, 13, 821–842. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  28. Snyder, R.D.; Koehler, A.B.; Ord, J.K. Forecasting for inventory control with exponential smoothing. Int. J. Forecast. 2002, 18, 5–18. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  29. Deng, J.L. Introduction to grey system theory. J. Grey Syst. 1989, 1, 1–24. [Google Scholar]
  30. Wen, K.L.; Huang, Y.F. The development of grey Verhulst toolbox and the analysis of population saturation state in Taiwan-Fukien. In Proceeding of the IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics (IEEE Cat. No.04CH37583), The Hague, The Netherlands, 10–13 October 2004.
  31. Huang, Y.-F.; Wang, C.-N.; Dang, H.-S.; Lai, S.-T. Predicting the trend of Taiwan’s electronic paper industry by an effective combined grey model. Sustainability 2015, 7, 10664–10683. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  32. Hsu, L.-C. Applying the Grey prediction model to the global integrated circuit industry. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang. 2003, 70, 563–574. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  33. Huang, Y.-F.; Wang, C.-N.; Dang, H.-S.; Lai, S.-T. Evaluating performance of the DGM(2,1) model and its modified models. Appl. Sci. 2016. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  34. Lotka, A.J. Elements of Physical Biology, 1924; Republished as Elements of mathematical biology; Dover Publications: New York, NY, USA, 1956. [Google Scholar]
  35. Lee, S.J.; Lee, D.J.; Oh, H.S. Technological forecasting at the Korean stock market: A dynamic competition analysis using Lotka–Volterra model. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang. 2005, 72, 1044–1057. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  36. Wijeratne, A.W.; Karunaratne, J.A.; Wang, C.; Wei, J. An empirical Lotka-Volterra system for competition dynamics in the telecommunication sector of Sri Lanka. Int. J. Bus. Inform. Syst. 2008, 3, 482–497. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  37. Wijeratne, A.W.; Yi, F.; Wei, J. Bifurcation analysis in the diffusive Lotka–Volterra system: An application to market economy. Chaos Solitons Fractals 2009, 40, 902–911. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  38. Marasco, A.; Picucci, A.; Romano, A. Market share dynamics using Lotka–Volterra models. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang. 2016, 105, 49–62. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  39. Hung, H.-C.; Tsai, Y.-S.; Wu, M.-C. A modified Lotka–Volterra model for competition forecasting in Taiwan’s retail industry. Comput. Ind. Eng. 2014, 77, 70–79. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  40. Makridakis, S.; Wheelwright, S.C.; McGee, V.E. Forecasting: Methods and Applications; John Wiley & Son, Inc.: New York, NY, USA, 1983. [Google Scholar]
  41. Ravinder, H.V. Determining the optimal values of exponential smoothing constants-does solver really work? Am. J. Bus. Educ. 2013. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  42. Chopra, S.; Meindl, P. Supply Chain Management: Strategy, Planning, and Operation, 5th ed.; Prentice Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA, 2013. [Google Scholar]
  43. Lewis, C.D. Industrial and Business Forecasting Methods: A Practical Guide to Exponential Smoothing and Curve Fitting; Butterworth-Heinemann: Oxford, UK, 1982. [Google Scholar]
  44. Ma, H.; Zhang, Z. Grey Prediction with Markov-Chain for crude oil production and consumption in China. Adv. Intell. Soft Comput. 2009, 56, 551–561. [Google Scholar]
Figure 1. Forecasted results of the healthcare traveling industry in six destinations: (a) Singapore; (b) Malaysia; (c) Thailand; (d) Taiwan; (e) Korea; (f) India.
Figure 1. Forecasted results of the healthcare traveling industry in six destinations: (a) Singapore; (b) Malaysia; (c) Thailand; (d) Taiwan; (e) Korea; (f) India.
Sustainability 08 01037 g001
Figure 2. Forecasted performance of three proposed modes.
Figure 2. Forecasted performance of three proposed modes.
Sustainability 08 01037 g002
Table 1. Number of medical tourists in the healthcare industry (persons).
Table 1. Number of medical tourists in the healthcare industry (persons).
2003102,946 730,000
2005232,161370,0001,249,984 153,000
2006296,689410,0001,450,000 230,000
2007341,228571,0001,540,000 450,000
2013770,134 2,530,000211,218100,083
Sources: [6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13].
Table 2. Historical data requirement for several forecast models.
Table 2. Historical data requirement for several forecast models.
Forecast ModelsData RequirementTime Horizon for Forecasting
Moving average2 to 30Short
Simple exponential smoothing5 to 10Short
Trend models10 to 20Short, medium
Casual regression models10 observations per independent variableShort, medium, or long
Neural networkLarge numberShort
Grey models4Short, medium, or long
Source: [23,24].
Table 3. Performance of the proposed models for predicting the medical tourist arrivals in six destinations.
Table 3. Performance of the proposed models for predicting the medical tourist arrivals in six destinations.
Evaluative itemsMaylaysiaSingaporeThailandKoreaTaiwanIndia
Exponential SmoothingMAD191,682.06157,220.89669,091.6732,907.0345,471.7125,534.9
MAPE (%)39.7329.2831.934.4241.827.21
Precision rate (%)60.2770.7268.165.5858.272.79
Forecasting gradeUnqualifiedUnqualifiedUnqualifiedUnqualifiedUnqualifiedUnqualified
GM(1,1) ModelMAD39,040.55113,545.53115,834.492993.9921,540.4441,644.10
MAPE (%)17.7423.627.512.8417.8012.31
Precision rate (%)82.2676.3892.4997.1682.2087.69
Forecasting gradeUnqualifiedUnqualifiedGoodExcellentUnqualifiedQualified
Lotka-Votterra ModelMAD13,995.9821,074.9930,303.9913,415.2922,615.5438,838.85
MAPE (%)6.033.612.1015.8724.1010.10
Precision rate (%)93.9796.3997.9084.1375.9089.90
Forecasting gradeGoodExcellentExcellentUnqualifiedUnqualifiedQualified
Back to TopTop