1. Introduction
The increased demand for energy and the risk of depletion of the fossil fuels has led to an increased demand for the rapid development of renewable energy sources in order to meet clients’ needs. Renewable energies entail the exploitation of natural energy flows (e.g., wings, sunlight, falling water, waves, tides, and ocean currents) or the exploitation of natural resources at a level equivalent to or higher than the human utilization rate (e.g., biofuels, ocean thermal gradients, and hydroelectric reservoirs) [
1,
2,
3]. The concept refers to energy generated from sources whose supplies are regenerative and inexhaustible. The search for an alternative source of energy supply is increasing by the day. The world’s growing population, climate change, and sustainable development seem to be significant drivers of renewable energy technologies. Global studies suggest a consensus on the significance of the renewable energy market, and by improving environmental performance and developing green products, companies improve their reputation [
2,
4]. However, it is essential to note that not all environmentally friendly goods successfully garner customer interest in the market. Therefore, RE marketing must overcome local marketing challenges to increase demand in various marketing contexts. Renewable energy could play a key role in providing sustainable energy to vast populations in less privileged countries (LDCs). However, despite the need for continuous growth in renewable energy development, some countries still have doubts about using these resources [
5,
6]. This applies to the Nigerian case, which has a large energy market; there seems to be low acceptance amongst consumers of renewable energy sources. Sub-Saharan Africa continues to be the lowest-ranked according to energy access, with just over 40% of Nigerians having access to electricity that is highly reliant on fossil fuels. Drivers of RE in Nigeria include economic growth, the urge to solve energy access problems and security, improved energy supplies, population, climate change, and the electrification of rural and grid-inaccessible areas [
7]. Nigeria’s total RE potential is not fully utilized, and electricity supply is far less than demand [
8,
9]. The critical role of public acceptance in the successful introduction of renewable energy infrastructures into society is well-established, especially in the advanced world [
10,
11]. Low acceptance could hamper the implementation of sustainable energy technologies, which hinders critical environmental goals and vice versa [
12].
Several national policies have been introduced to promote the optimal utilization of Nigeria’s energy resources (conventional and renewable) for sustainable development. These include the National Energy Policy [
13] 2003, and the Renewable Energy Master Plan (NREMP) 2005, with high expectations regarding the active participation of the private sector [
14,
15]. The overall aim was to achieve 10% RE penetration by 2020. However, minor or short-term results were achieved, and the results of these policies fall far short of Nigeria’s renewable energy potential [
16,
17]. In recent years, there has been an increase in renewable energy installations across various world countries, at least at a small-scale level. However, Nigerian electricity consumers have low acceptance of green energy, hence our investigation of the factors that might be responsible for low consumer intention to purchase RE. Nigeria has participated in global movements against climate change; therefore, studying consumer behavior toward intention to use RE provides valuable insights both locally and internationally. The previous study attributed the lack of willingness to use small-scale renewable energy for household energy to a lack of consumer confidence, lack of adequate policy, low public awareness, prices, financing constraints, low community acceptance, a lack of skilled human resources, and weak technology dissemination strategies [
5,
10,
18,
19]. While personal views on the intention to use renewable energy have been well studied in developed countries, they have been neglected in developing trends [
20,
21]. In particular, the results of studies conducted in the industrialized world cannot be effectively generalized to developing nations [
22] due to their very different social, cultural, economic, political, and legal contexts [
23]. Many scholars have worked on the Nigerian renewable energy market. Some consider the people’s perception of RE technologies, while others studied extensively the potentials, policies, constraints, and current generation capacities. Few studies have concentrated on the individual’s opinion of RE in Nigeria. To date, no detailed study has been targeted directly at the households, their socio-economic perceptions, and their intention to purchase RE technologies. There are few studies on the motivations behind intention to purchase, and actual demand remains very low. As such, the major factors affecting people’s intention to use RE have not been fully evaluated in Nigeria. These factors may vary across technologies or countries. This study focuses on the factors in Nigeria, and aims to examine them in relation to intention to use renewable energy. The question imposed is “What are the factors that drive consumers’ RE purchase intention in Nigeria?” Thus, the study aims to investigate factors that explain consumer intention to purchase RE technologies. This study presents the argument of factors influencing intention to purchase RE technologies, and the results will be beneficial to stakeholders. The findings will provide evidence and proof of the underlying motives for investing in RE in households. Furthermore, a proper evaluation of intention to purchase RE technologies will help stakeholders when making investment decisions, and in the development of products and market strategies. Factors such as relative advantages, cost, subjective norms, ease of use, awareness, attitude, perceived behavioral control, as well as age, gender, income and education, were chosen for testing. Because it is crucial for developing countries to understand the processes involved in the shift from conventional to renewable energy, this study focuses on factors and theories relevant to pre-purchase intention to use renewable energy.
Finally, although the study was conducted in a particular geographical area (Nigeria), these findings pertain to consumers’ intention-based variables in acquiring and using RE, as Nigeria has a multitude of renewable energy sources, such as solar, wind, biomass, geothermal, and hydroelectric electricity. With such numerous renewable energy sources, the nation can satisfy 100% of its present and future energy demands if they are properly exploited. However, Nigeria is a developing nation that is not well-known for its renewable energy support, due to various difficulties and hurdles, including economic, regulatory, technical, and social constraints [
24]. Nigeria’s economy cannot bear such a load. As a result, the nation faces a serious energy crisis [
25]. Furthermore, Nigerian society is interlinked, implying that the actions of peers, relatives, and neighbors have a major effect on the views of residents [
25]. As a result, individuals are concerned about their efficacy, neighbor involvement, and the advantages of RE. As a developing nation, it is expected that these new elements, coupled with the current energy problem, will occur in other emerging countries. Consequently, the study’s findings are not case-specific, but are rather transferable to other nations, emphasizing the significance of the impact of surrounding variables on RE use. As a result, Nigeria could be seen as an example for other nations seeking to identify these phenomena. Furthermore, the findings of this study will assist other developing and rising economies in formulating plans and policies for RE deployment in their respective nations.
2. Study Model and Hypothesis Development
The effectiveness of renewable energy product categories or services on the market depends largely on the acceptance and/or rejection of customers, which is ascertained by purchase intentions. The intention could be defined as a person’s plan, commitment, or decision to carry out an action or achieve a certain goal [
26]. According to Azjen’s TPB, a person’s intention is the central factor to performing a given behavior. Customer purchase intention indicates a person’s willingness to buy a specific product chosen after evaluating factors [
27]. It is a self-conscious plan of whether or not to purchase a specific product after considering the individual aspects (e.g., personal experience, feelings, etc.) and extrinsic aspects, such as cost and benefit [
28]. Intentions are meant to be impacted motivational factors affecting a behavior; they are indicators of how willing customers are to try, and how much commitment they intend to invest in executing the behavior [
29]. It implies that an individual’s intention to perform progresses to a particular behavior—the shift from meaning to action [
29].
Evidence suggests that intention is a good predictor of renewable energy purchasing behavior, and is a critical factor in evaluating people’s actual purchasing behavior [
6,
30,
31]. The behavioral intention of adoption refers to the consumer’s intention to use a potential product or service [
31].
This study aims to understand the intention of consumers to use renewable power. Several dependent variables may affect purchase intention, which can be defined as the mind’s ability to behave a certain way as a means to purchase [
32]. This study uses the combination of UTAUT, TPB, TAM and DOI as the basis of its theory. Researchers in different areas and in renewable energy have applied and illustrated these concepts in order to understand the intent to use renewable technology [
6,
30,
31,
33]. Studies show that it is possible to project customer intentions to use renewable power with reasonable precision. The evaluated determinants include relative advantage, ease of use, perceived behavioral control, subjective norm, awareness, cost, attitude, income, and education. These constructs selected for analysis were drawn from the mentioned theories, and are deemed to influence purchase intention. The constructs tested are as follows: Relative advantage refers to the extent to which an innovative product is considered better than those before it or its closest substitute [
34,
35]. It is the degree to which an invention is considered superior to its predecessor [
36]. Thus, it refers to the marginal advantage of using solar energy over conventional energy, which various factors could influence. Consumers recognize the use of renewable energies and other socio-economic advantages from an environmental viewpoint [
31,
37]. RE’s low penetration could be due to its low relative advantage over simple and user-friendly power sources for some parts of the world. The relative advantage is guaranteed if the new system provides higher value, is developed based on local taste, and provides a substitution incentive if consumers wish to revert to a previous technology [
38,
39]. The greater the perceived relative value of renewable power, the higher the adoption rate.
Furthermore, some earlier studies suggest a relative advantage that indirectly affects the behavioral intention to use RE. Relative advantage specifically affects the attitude that mediates the relationship with the intention [
6,
40,
41,
42]. This study, therefore, argues that:
Hypothesis 1 (H1). The relative advantage has a positive and major effect on the attitude towards the customer’s intention to buy.
Hypothesis 2 (H2). Relative advantage has a significant and positive impact on buyer intention to use renewable energy.
Subjective norms, SN, refer to an individual’s impression that most people close to him think that a given behavior should or should not be performed, i.e., the perceived social influence to perform or not to perform [
43]. It is the result of the conviction that the person should act in accordance with the behavior and the incentive to comply with other specific groups of people [
44]. It is the extent to which a person perceives that close relative/friends believe they should use RE. SNs consist of two elements that interact: belief in other people’s values, how one would like to see other people behave (normative beliefs), and negative or positive opinions on each belief (outcome assessments) [
45]. Thus, SN is changes one’s behavior through the influence of others. Studies reveal that SN strongly affects consumers’ green purchase decision-making process [
2,
46,
47,
48]. The level of impact other people’s perceptions have on the adoption of renewable resources can differ between individuals. This study argues that the consumer’s intention to adopt renewable energy is affected by intimate relationships involving friends, relatives, academics, employers, coworkers, etc. This is anchored in the belief that people who can influence an individual could influence them to purchase renewable energy products. With this view, the following hypotheses are presented:
Hypothesis 3 (H3). Subjective norms have a significant and robust effect on the attitude towards customers’ intention to buy.
Hypothesis 4 (H4). Subjective norms have a significantly positive impact on the intention of consumers to buy renewable energy sources.
Perceived behavioral control (PBC) is the impression of the easiness or difficulty of performing a specific behavior, i.e., the degree to which a person believes that the behavior in question is enacted or not performed within his\her volitional control [
28,
49]. Studies show that individuals’ behavior is greatly affected by their confidence in their ability to perform it. The literature demonstrates that PBC is a key factor in determining behavioral intent, which has a substantial effect on the self-efficacy of a specific behavior, including renewable energy [
32,
50,
51]. The theory of planned behavior posits that individuals regulate their behavior, and thus, buying decision is a matter of individual convictions. PBC focuses on how much influence the individual has over the behavior, and how confident they feel about engaging or not engaging in it. The higher PBC a consumer has over using renewable energy, the more likely they are to adopt it, and vice versa [
31]. Factors (situational and internal) considered by consumers include, but are not limited to, cost, changes in living standards, and other socio-economic parameters [
52].
The following hypothesis is therefore given:
Hypothesis 5 (H5). Higher PBC has a significant positive impact on the attitude towards customer purchasing intention.
Hypothesis 6 (H6). Higher perceived behavioral control has a significantly positive effect on the intention to use renewable power.
The degree to which a technology is believed to be challenging to use is referred to as perceived ease of use [
49]. Perceived ease of use refers to the degree to which an individual presumes that a particular system would be convenient to use [
53], i.e., the degree to which a new advancement in technology has been easily understood, operated, and managed by users [
31]. Energy sources considered to be relatively easy to use and affordable would usually have higher market penetration. Researchers have discovered that renewable energy, such as solar energy, poses numerous technical barriers to users [
2,
54,
55]. Renewable energy’s installation, use, maintenance, and technicalities shape opinion concerning it. Simple to install, user-friendly and family-friendly renewable energy technologies that are beneficial to living standards are more likely to positively affect intent to adopt [
56]. Producers could enhance ease of use if there is a clear understanding of the target markets’ living standards, if they employ effective quality control, and if they ensure usage policy is easy to understand [
43,
57,
58,
59].
Hypothesis 7 (H7). Perceived ease of use significantly affects the attitude towards the customers’ intention to purchase.
Hypothesis 8 (H8). Perceived ease of use has a strong positive effect on customers’ intention to purchase renewable power.
The cost of renewable energy includes initial installation, maintenance, and the opportunity cost of adopting RE. This study has demonstrated that costs were also crucial in limiting the deployment and development of renewable energy solutions, particularly in developing nations with low per capita incomes [
60]. This is mostly because the minimal level of capital needed for installing renewable power is usually higher than the minimum required for traditional energy. Several studies have discovered a direct and consequential link between cost and technology adoption [
61,
62]. Consumers will usually make a comparison of the potential benefits derived when adopting an RE technology with its perceived total cost. The higher the perceived cost, the lower its market value and the lower its usage rate [
56]. Buyers will more likely develop stronger and more positive purchase intentions towards RE if the benefit–cost ratio high. The lower the perceived costs, the higher the rate of adoption of renewable energy, and vice versa.
Hypothesis 9 (H9). Cost has a negative effect on the attitude towards the intention of customers to buy.
Hypothesis 10 (H10) Cost has a negative and significant effect on the intention of consumers to purchase.
Awareness is the degree to which individuals are knowledgeable of modern technology, its advantages and disadvantages, and whether they can keep abreast of new emerging technology updates [
31]. Awareness involves prospective customers being able to access sufficient details on RE’s basic usage, economic opportunities, and environmental impacts [
58]. Awareness is one major component of UTAUT that directly affects the behavioral intention to use renewable energy sources [
6,
63,
64]. Our findings indicate that knowledge of a specific technology influences the interpretation of that technology’s risks and benefits, including defining the potential impacts of the technology [
65]. A higher awareness level is bound to increase the acceptability among new consumers of RE technologies [
66].
Furthermore, knowledge of green products enables customers to build a positive awareness of RE marketing, and increase their interest in preventing environmental problems [
67]. According to previous studies, most Nigerians are not well informed about environmental issues, and are unaware of how their behavior could reduce its impact [
68]. Understanding consumer awareness is crucial to knowing how consumers make their purchasing decision concerning RE. Consumers’ low use of RE in Nigeria may result from a lack of awareness (availability of products and added value). Consumers with more information about environmental degradation and its impacts on society will normally think they need to do something about it, and might consider purchasing RE [
69,
70]. Practically, the more knowledge people have, the better their awareness and the greater their intention to buy new clean energy technologies. The presence of an information gap or a lack of information negatively influences RE purchase behavior.
Hypothesis 11 (H11). Low awareness has a negative effect on the attitude towards the intention of the buyer to purchase.
Hypothesis 12 (H12). High awareness has a profound positive influence on intention to use renewable energy.
Attitude refers to the positive or negative feelings of a person about performing a target behavior [
42]. It concerns personal views or behaviors towards an object, often in an evaluative way [
71]. Attitude towards a behavior implies a positive or negative subjective assessment of an individual’s behavior’s consequences [
72], which defines how individuals respond to that behavior [
72]. The theory of planned behavior proves that the person’s attitude towards a particular technology is the strongest predictor of the intent of the person to use that technology [
32]. A higher attitude towards adopting renewable energies leads to the formation of intention, and eventually adoption. A person who has a positive attitude toward renewable power feels pressure to adopt it, and is likely to establish a purchasing intention. Some studies identified attitude as a key predictor of pro-environmental behavior, such as using renewable energy [
63,
73,
74,
75]. However, some authors opined the mediating role of attitude in predicting consumer RE behavior [
6,
33,
76], based on the idea that attitude is a first-stage mediator between other factors and intention.
This study seeks to further explore this concept by analyzing the mediator’s role in the relationship between variables: relative advantage, ease of use, subjective norms, awareness, PBC, cost, and intention to use, in the context of an ideal model. The following hypotheses were thus tested:
Hypothesis 13 (H13). Attitude acts as a mediator between the intention to use renewable energy and its use variables.
Hypothesis 14 (H14). Intention to use mediates the relationship between use of behavior and determinants of renewable energy use.
Several studies have shown social and economic factors as essential in relation to primary determinants and behavioral intention [
42]. This study posits that the demographic factors of age, gender, education, and income control the relationship between the selected variables and purchase intention. A survey on the buying of domestic energy-efficient and renewable power facilities in China showed that households’ incomes positively moderate the interaction between purchasing attitude and intention, and incentives in the form of subsidies are more likely to enhance purchasing [
77]. High-income and trained professionals have shown they are more likely to pay for clean energy, and young people are more supportive of renewable power adoption [
78,
79]. Some studies have also highlighted the impact of gender on the adoption of renewable energy, i.e., males imvested more than females in adopting renewable energy in Kaohsiung and Pingtung, Malaysia. [
33] However, women in LA, USA showed much higher tendencies than men in terms of green buying and ecological attitudes [
80,
81]. While studies show the influence of socio-economic factors, income has not been found to impact the adoption of renewable energy [
33] significantly. This study posits that the level of control or influence of socio-economic factors may vary depending on many factors according to the individual environment. To investigate this perspective in Nigeria, the following hypotheses were formulated:
Hypothesis 15 (H15). There is a strong positive relationship between high-income and purchase intention.
Hypothesis 16 (H16). There is no significant relationship between age and purchase intention for renewable energy.
Hypothesis 17 (H17). There is no significant relationship between gender and purchase intention.
Hypothesis 18 (H18). There is a significant relationship between high education and purchase intention.
RE purchase intention’s conceptual framework would depend on various considerations, such as country, users, investors, goals, study problems and objectives, etc. [
81]. The conceptual framework for this study is presented below
Figure 1.
5. Discussions
Given the importance of RE as a sustainable source of clean energy and its determinants on the one hand, and the attitudes that mediate the relation between RE and intention towards use behavior on the other hand, this study aimed at studying the factors affecting the intention towards use behavior of RE in Nigeria. According to the outcome, hypothesis 1 is supported, and there exists a significant direct relationship between relative advantage and attitude. This means that the higher the perceived relative advantage of renewable energy, the higher the rate of adoption. However, some previous studies supported the hypothesis that relative advantage directly influences individual attitude to use RE [
6,
40,
41,
42]. According to the result of hypothesis 2, this is supported. There is a significant direct relationship between the subjective norms and attitudes towards purchase intention and use behavior of RE. Individuals in Nigeria have high opinions of adopting renewable energy, but these may vary from one person to another. As such, this hypothesis argued that intention to purchase renewable energy is potentially influenced by close subjective norms, such as friends, family, educators, employers, and professional colleagues.
The result of hypothesis 3 showed that PBC has a significant positive relationship with customers’ attitudes toward purchase intention and use of RE. However, this result also supported the theory of planned behavior. This hypothesis pertains to the individual’s perception of his influence over behavior, and it represents the instigators of and obstacles before the success of a specific behavior. In this case, If Nigeria’s consumers have sufficient financial funds to purchase RE and technology, they can use these advanced renewable resources to demonstrate greater self-efficacy and confidence. Most villagers live with relatively low incomes, so the government should financially help individuals to purchase RE. Hypothesis 4 is supported, showing that perceived ease of use directly significantly influences attitude towards purchase intention. According to this result, individuals in Nigeria believed that this technology is straightforward to understand, operate, and maintain. A renewable energy system that is easy to install, user-friendly, family-friendly, and beneficial to the standard of living will more likely positively influence the intention to adopt RE. This would enhance the use behavior of customers. Based on the outcomes, hypothesis 5 is supported, and there exists a negative relationship between the perceived cost of RE and attitude towards purchase intention and use of RE.
The perceived cost of any product is considered an essential element in the adoption of the product. So, the cost of renewable energy contains initial installation process costs, maintenance costs, and the opportunity cost of adopting the RE. Consumers will typically equate the possible benefits resulting from RE technology’s introduction with its perceived overall costs. The higher the perceived value, the lower its value to consumers, and the lower its ease of consumption; the lower the quality, the higher the price of adoption of renewable energy. According to the given results of
Table 6 and
Figure 2, the outcomes of all mediating variables (hypotheses 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11) indicated that attitude has a positive significant mediating effect in the relationship between intention to use and determinants (relative advantage, subjective norm, perceived behavior control, easy to use, cost and awareness) of renewable energy. In general, following the attitude component’s inclusion as a mediating variable in the study, the model’s predictive capacity is substantially improved. Intention to purchase plays an essential role in mediating influences between the determinants of renewable energy and use behavior. The result of hypothesis 14 shows that the intention to purchase has a positive significant mediating effect in the relationship between renewable energy determinants and use behavior of renewable energy. All results are comparable to those of [
6]. In simple words, if positive subjective evaluations of individual behavior increase among the citizens of Nigeria, then the intention to use such energy sources will increase. This will manifest a higher intention to purchase RE among individuals. If purchase intention increases among the citizens of Nigeria, then the use of renewable sources will boost. Hence, according to its indirect effect, improving individuals’ purchasing intention regarding renewable energy sources can also affect their willingness to use REs by strengthening their attitudes. Finally, the control variables had no significant positive impact on purchase intention.