Next Article in Journal
Effects of Azithromycin on the Functioning of the Food Web in Freshwater Plankton
Previous Article in Journal
Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals, Nitrogen, and Phosphorus in Seawater of Taizhou Bay, China
 
 
Font Type:
Arial Georgia Verdana
Font Size:
Aa Aa Aa
Line Spacing:
Column Width:
Background:
Article

Adverse Event Signals Associated with Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors: Disproportionality Analysis of USFDA Adverse Event Reporting System

by
Kannan Sridharan
1,* and
Gowri Sivaramakrishnan
2
1
Department of Pharmacology & Therapeutics, College of Medicine & Medical Sciences, Arabian Gulf University, Manama 26671, Bahrain
2
Bahrain Defence Force Royal Medical Services, Riffa 28743, Bahrain
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
J. Xenobiot. 2025, 15(5), 144; https://doi.org/10.3390/jox15050144
Submission received: 7 August 2025 / Revised: 31 August 2025 / Accepted: 6 September 2025 / Published: 9 September 2025
(This article belongs to the Section Drug Therapeutics)

Abstract

Background: Beta-lactamase inhibitors (BLIs) are widely used with beta-lactam antibiotics to combat resistant infections, yet their safety profiles, especially for newer agents, remain underexplored. This study aimed to identify potential adverse event (AE) signals associated with BLIs using the USFDA Adverse Event Reporting System (USFDA AERS). Methods: The USFDA AERS was queried for AE reports involving FDA-approved BLIs from March 2004 to March 2024. After removing duplicates, only reports with BLIs listed as primary suspects were included. Disproportionality analysis was conducted using frequentist and Bayesian approaches, with statistical significance assessed by chi-square testing. Results: A total of 12,456 unique reports were analyzed. Common AEs across BLIs included hematologic disorders, hypersensitivity reactions, emergent infections, organ dysfunction, and neurological complications. Signal detection revealed specific associations: septic shock and respiratory failure with avibactam; lymphadenopathy and congenital anomalies with clavulanic acid; antimicrobial resistance and epilepsy with relebactam; disseminated intravascular coagulation and cardiac arrest with sulbactam; and agranulocytosis and conduction abnormalities with tazobactam. For vaborbactam, no distinct AE signals were identified apart from off-label use. Mortality was significantly more frequent with avibactam and relebactam (p < 0.0001). Conclusions: This analysis highlights a spectrum of AE signals with BLIs, including unexpected associations warranting further investigation. While some events may reflect comorbidities or concomitant therapies, these findings underscore the importance of continued pharmacovigilance and targeted clinical studies to clarify causality and ensure the safe use of BLIs in practice.

Graphical Abstract

1. Introduction

Beta-lactam antimicrobials (penicillins, carbapenems, cephalosporins, and monobactams) constitute a vital class of antibiotics within the antimicrobial arsenal. These agents are widely preferred due to their broad antimicrobial spectrum, favorable safety profile, and tolerable adverse effects. However, the extensive use of β-lactam antibiotics has been observed to primarily drive the production of β-lactamases that hydrolyze the β-lactam ring, leading to the development of resistance amongst both Gram-positive and Gram-negative pathogens [1]. To date, sequence analysis has identified over 8200 distinct β-lactamase enzymes [2].
To combat this resistance, β-lactamase inhibitors (BLIs) have been developed and are commonly co-administered with β-lactam antibiotics to enhance their efficacy against drug-resistant infections. Currently, six BLIs, avibactam, clavulanic acid, relebactam, sulbactam, tazobactam, and vaborbactam, are approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration (USFDA) [3]. Clavulanic acid, sulbactam, and tazobactam were developed earlier and were initially effective against a limited range of β-lactamase enzymes. However, the rise of extended-spectrum β-lactamases and carbapenemases necessitated the development of novel BLIs such as avibactam, relebactam, and vaborbactam, which exhibit enhanced activity against these resistant strains [4]. These newer BLIs are particularly valuable in managing infections caused by multidrug-resistant Enterobacterales and Pseudomonas aeruginosa [5].
The first-generation BLIs, clavulanic acid, sulbactam, and tazobactam, are β-lactam-based molecules structurally related to penicillins; they act as “suicide substrates” by forming a covalent acyl-enzyme complex with serine β-lactamases [6]. In contrast, the more recently approved BLIs represent structural innovations designed to expand inhibitory activity. Avibactam and relebactam are diazabicyclooctane (DBO) derivatives, lacking the classical β-lactam core but instead possessing a bicyclic urea scaffold that provides reversible covalent inhibition of both class A and some class C and D β-lactamases [7]. Vaborbactam, on the other hand, belongs to the cyclic boronate class, with a boronic acid moiety that mimics the tetrahedral intermediate of β-lactam hydrolysis, conferring potent activity against class A carbapenemases, notably Klebsiella pneumoniae carbapenemase (KPC) [8].
Interestingly, some BLIs exhibit weak intrinsic antibacterial activity against specific pathogens. Sulbactam, for example, is active against Acinetobacter spp., Neisseria gonorrhoeae, and Bacteroides spp.; clavulanic acid is effective against Haemophilus influenzae and Neisseria gonorrhoeae; and tazobactam shows activity against Borrelia burgdorferi [9,10,11].
Despite their widespread use, the adverse event profiles of BLIs are not comprehensively characterized. Reported adverse effects include gastrointestinal symptoms (nausea, constipation, and diarrhea), nervous system disorders (seizures and insomnia), altered platelet function, and hypersensitivity reactions, including anaphylaxis, Stevens–Johnson syndrome (SJS), toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN), and eosinophilia [12]. The USFDA Adverse Event Reporting System (AERS) collects spontaneously reported adverse events from healthcare professionals and is publicly accessible [13]. Disproportionality analysis of the USFDA AERS database has proven to be a valuable tool in identifying potential adverse event signals, warranting further exploration through clinical studies or mechanistic models [14].
However, there is a significant lack of literature on the adverse event profiles of BLIs, particularly the novel agents. A recent disproportionality analysis of the USFDA AERS database identified 654 reports associated with ceftolozane–tazobactam and 506 reports related to ceftazidime–avibactam, revealing signals of agranulocytosis and encephalopathy, respectively [15]. Beyond this, no prior study has systematically evaluated the adverse event signals across the entire spectrum of FDA-approved BLIs. Therefore, the novelty of our work lies in providing the first comprehensive pharmacovigilance assessment of both early- and recently approved BLIs using the FAERS database, thereby addressing an important gap in safety characterization.

2. Methods

2.1. Data Source

We queried the USFDA AERS database using the names of the USFDA-approved beta-lactamase inhibitors listed in Table 1 [16]. The data analyzed in this study encompassed 81 quarterly reports spanning March 2004 (the earliest publicly available USFDA AERS dataset) to March 2024 (the most recent complete dataset at the time of analysis).

2.2. Data Processing

Data processing followed the USFDA’s recommendations for the removal of duplicate reports [17]. Cases were identified using their unique case identification numbers, and for each case, only the entry with the highest individual safety report number was retained, with duplicate records removed. The USFDA categorizes the association between drugs and suspected adverse events into four categories: primary suspect, secondary suspect, interacting, or concomitant. For the purposes of this study, only unique reports in which a BLI was designated as the primary suspect were included, as this classification reflects the reporter’s assessment of the most likely causal drug and reduces confounding from concomitant therapies. From each unique report, data on gender, year of report, adverse events, and outcomes were extracted. Missing data points within the reports were excluded from further analysis.

2.3. Data Mining Algorithms

For this disproportionality analysis, we applied the case–non-case methodology to identify potential safety signals. In this approach, the frequency of specific adverse events reported with the drug of interest (“cases”) is compared against the frequency of the same events reported with all other drugs (“non-cases”) [18]. Signal detection was performed using the OpenVigil 2.1 platform, which incorporates both frequentist and Bayesian statistical methods.
Within the frequentist framework, the measures assessed included the reporting odds ratio (ROR) and the proportional reporting ratio (PRR) [19]. The ROR was expressed with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). A signal was considered statistically significant if it satisfied the following thresholds: a minimum of three independent case reports, PRR of at least 2, chi-square (χ2) value of 4 or greater, and a lower 95% CI bound for the ROR exceeding 1 [20].
For the Bayesian approach, the Bayesian Confidence Propagation Neural Network (BCPNN) and Multi-item Gamma Poisson Shrinker (MGPS) methods were applied to estimate signal detection measures. In BCPNN, signals were identified when the lower 95% CI limit of the information component (IC025) exceeded zero. In the Empirical Bayes geometric mean (EBGM) model, a signal was considered significant when the lower 95% CI limit of EBGM05 exceeded 2 [20].
The reported outcomes were categorized into one of the following: death, life-threatening events, or hospitalization (initial or prolonged).

2.4. Statistical Analysis

The demographic characteristics were described using descriptive statistics. Categorical variables were summarized as percentages. The chi-square (χ2) test was applied to evaluate the significance of differences in the distribution of reported outcomes. A p-value ≤ 0.05 was interpreted as statistically significant. All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS software (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA; Version 27.0, released 2020).

2.5. Search Results

Out of the 28,655,483 reports that were available in the USFDA AERS database, 12,456 unique reports were included in the final analysis (Figure 1). Clavulanic acid (n = 5627) and tazobactam (n = 5248) accounted for most reports, followed by other beta-lactamase inhibitors. The demographic characteristics of patients associated with each beta-lactamase inhibitor are summarized in Table 2. Excluding unreported data, most patients were elderly (>65 years) and predominantly male.

2.6. Signals Detected for Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors

Common adverse events identified across all beta-lactamase inhibitors included hematologic disorders such as myelosuppression, hemolysis, thrombocytopenia, neutropenia, eosinophilia, and hemolytic anemia. Hypersensitivity reactions, including anaphylaxis, drug reaction with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms (DRESS), Stevens–Johnson syndrome (SJS), and toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN), were also observed, along with increased susceptibility to infections such as Clostridium difficile, Klebsiella, and Candida. Additional adverse events included organ dysfunction, particularly altered hepatic function, renal failure, and multiple organ dysfunction syndrome, as well as neurological disorders like encephalopathy, epilepsy, neurotoxicity, and delirium.
Specific adverse events associated with individual beta-lactamase inhibitors were as follows:
  • Avibactam: Reported adverse events included eosinophilia, myelosuppression, death, septic shock, osteomyelitis, hyponatremia, neurotoxicity, encephalopathy, delirium, and respiratory failure (Table 3).
  • Clavulanic Acid: Associated with lymphadenopathy, splenomegaly, congenital anomalies, hypergammaglobulinemia, Kounis syndrome, mastoiditis, conjunctivitis, diarrhea, oral candidiasis, enterocolitis, megacolon, and serum-sickness-like reaction (Table 4).
  • Relebactam: Primarily showed signals of antimicrobial resistance and epilepsy (Table 5).
  • Sulbactam: Notable adverse events included disseminated intravascular coagulation, hemorrhagic diathesis, Kounis syndrome, cardiogenic shock, cardiac arrest, prolonged activated partial thromboplastin time, anaphylactic reaction, elevated creatine phosphokinase, and coagulopathy (Table 6).
  • Tazobactam: Specific adverse events included agranulocytosis, lymphohistiocytosis, prolonged prothrombin time, Evans syndrome, platelet dysfunction, cardiac conduction abnormalities, pulseless electrical activity, anaphylactic reaction, and perinatal complications (Table 7).
  • Vaborbactam: No specific adverse events were reported, apart from off-label use (Table 8).

2.7. Comparison of Outcomes Between Adverse Events with Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors

The distribution of key outcomes among beta-lactamase inhibitors is presented in Figure 2. Death was reported more frequently with avibactam and relebactam compared to other inhibitors, with a statistically significant difference (p < 0.0001).

3. Discussion

3.1. Key Findings of This Study

Common adverse events reported for all beta-lactamase inhibitors included hematologic disorders (myelosuppression, hemolysis, thrombocytopenia), hypersensitivity reactions (anaphylaxis, DRESS, SJS, TEN), risk of emergent infections (Clostridium difficile, Klebsiella, Candida), organ dysfunction (hepatic, renal, multiple organ), and neurological issues (encephalopathy, epilepsy, delirium). Avibactam-specific events include septic shock and respiratory failure, while clavulanic acid shows lymphadenopathy, congenital anomalies, and enterocolitis. Relebactam is linked with antimicrobial resistance and epilepsy. Sulbactam shows disseminated intravascular coagulation and cardiac arrest, and tazobactam is associated with agranulocytosis and cardiac conduction abnormalities. Vaborbactam only reported off-label use.

3.2. Comparison with the Existing Literature

Among the adverse event signals identified in this study, hematologic reactions, including myelosuppression and hemolysis, were unexpected. However, these could be attributed to concomitant diseases or drugs causing myelotoxicity, particularly since tazobactam combinations are frequently used in patients with hematological malignancies [21]. Similarly, renal failure, hepatic failure, and multiple organ dysfunction, although unexpected, may result from underlying conditions such as sepsis or the use of other concurrent medications. Discontinuation of beta-lactam/BLI combinations due to organ failure has been previously reported [22]. The emergence of infections, particularly iatrogenic infections like Clostridium difficile, has also been documented with broad-spectrum β-lactam/BLIs [23]. Notably, the incidence of such infections appears higher with newer generations of cephalosporins and tetracyclines, whose usage has declined with the introduction of β-lactam/BLIs due to their comparable efficacy and spectrum [24].
Congenital anomalies associated with clavulanic acid use were identified as potential signals in this study. Clavulanic acid is commonly co-administered with amoxicillin, and epidemiological data have suggested an increased risk of cleft lip with/without cleft palate (odds ratio of 2), particularly when used in the last trimester of pregnancy (odds ratio of 4.3) [25]. However, a prospective, controlled study involving 191 pregnant women exposed to amoxicillin–clavulanic acid during the first trimester found no significant increase in the risk of major congenital malformations (1.9% with amoxicillin–clavulanic acid versus 3% in controls) [26]. Therefore, the association of clavulanic acid with congenital anomalies observed in this study is likely a false signal.
The adverse event patterns observed in this analysis can be interpreted in the context of the distinct chemical scaffolds and mechanisms of action of different BLIs. The classical β-lactam-based inhibitors such as clavulanic acid, sulbactam, and tazobactam share structural similarity with penicillins, which may explain the strong association with hypersensitivity reactions, cutaneous eruptions, and hepatic cholestasis seen in the disproportionality signals, reflecting immunoallergic pathways commonly linked to β-lactam cores. In contrast, the newer DBO derivatives, avibactam and relebactam, which lack a β-lactam ring, demonstrated signals of neurotoxicity, encephalopathy, epilepsy, and septic shock, which may be attributable to their broader β-lactamase binding spectrum and reversible covalent inhibition mechanism, raising the possibility of off-target interactions in neuronal or metabolic pathways. Vaborbactam, a cyclic boronate inhibitor, showed no distinct adverse event signals apart from off-label use, which may reflect its novel boronic-acid-based scaffold and limited clinical exposure to date [27]. Interestingly, signals of hematologic toxicity such as agranulocytosis with tazobactam and myelosuppression with avibactam further suggest potential structural contributions to bone marrow suppression. Similarly, the identification of congenital anomalies and lymphadenopathy with clavulanic acid could be linked to its β-lactam structural reactivity and potential immune-modulatory effects. Taken together, these findings highlight how the evolution of BLI structures, from β-lactam analogues to DBOs and cyclic boronates, may contribute to differing adverse event profiles, underlining the importance of considering both chemical class and mechanism of action when interpreting pharmacovigilance signals.

3.3. Strengths and Limitations

This study leverages a large dataset from the USFDA AERS, offering a comprehensive evaluation of adverse event signals associated with beta-lactamase inhibitors. A major strength of this analysis is the use of robust statistical methods, including frequentist and Bayesian approaches, which enhance the reliability of signal detection. However, the study has several limitations. First, the USFDA AERS is based on spontaneous reporting, which may be subject to underreporting, reporting biases, and incomplete data, potentially affecting the accuracy of the findings. Additionally, the study’s observational nature precludes establishing causality between the drugs and the adverse events. The lack of detailed clinical information in the reports, such as concomitant medications, underlying comorbidities, and dosing regimens, limits the ability to fully understand the context of the adverse events. Furthermore, novel BLIs such as vaborbactam had limited data due to their recent approval, restricting the analysis of adverse events associated with these newer agents.
Moving forward, prospective studies with more detailed clinical data and controlled settings are essential to validate these findings and establish causality. Expanding pharmacovigilance efforts and enhancing reporting accuracy through better healthcare provider awareness and electronic health record integration could provide more precise adverse event data. Additionally, mechanistic studies exploring the pathophysiology of unexpected adverse events, particularly hematologic and organ dysfunctions, are warranted to better understand the safety profile of BLIs and inform safer clinical use.

4. Conclusions

This study highlights a broad spectrum of adverse events associated with beta-lactamase inhibitors, including hematologic, hypersensitivity, infectious, organ dysfunction, and neurological disorders. While some adverse events are consistent with known safety profiles, unexpected signals such as myelosuppression, hemolysis, and organ dysfunction were also observed, warranting further investigation. The findings underscore the importance of continuous pharmacovigilance and signal detection to monitor the safety of both established and novel BLIs. Given the limitations of spontaneous reporting systems, future research should focus on prospective studies and mechanistic evaluations to better understand the causality and clinical implications of these adverse events. This knowledge is critical for optimizing the safe use of beta-lactamase inhibitors in clinical practice, particularly in populations with complex comorbidities.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, K.S.; methodology, K.S. and G.S.; software, K.S. and G.S.; validation, K.S.; formal analysis, K.S.; data curation, K.S. and G.S.; writing—original draft preparation, K.S.; writing—review and editing, K.S. and G.S.; visualization, K.S. and G.S.; supervision, K.S.; project administration, K.S. and G.S. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Informed Consent Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request, as the authors did not seek permission to publicly share them from the data owner.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

  1. Tooke, C.L.; Hinchliffe, P.; Bragginton, E.C.; Colenso, C.K.; Hirvonen, V.H.A.; Takebayashi, Y.; Spencer, J. β-Lactamases and β-Lactamase Inhibitors in the 21st Century. J. Mol. Biol. 2019, 431, 3472–3500. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  2. Beta-Lactamase Database-Structure and Function. Available online: http://www.bldb.eu/ (accessed on 4 September 2024).
  3. Yahav, D.; Giske, C.G.; Grāmatniece, A.; Abodakpi, H.; Tam, V.H.; Leibovici, L. New β-Lactam-β-Lactamase Inhibitor Combinations. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 2020, 34, e00115-20. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  4. Wong, D.; van Duin, D. Novel Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors: Unlocking Their Potential in Therapy. Drugs 2017, 77, 615–628. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  5. Sader, H.S.; Mendes, R.E.; Arends, S.R.; Carvalhaes, C.G.; Shortridge, D.; Castanheira, M. Comparative activity of newer β-lactam/β-lactamase inhibitor combinations against Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from US medical centres (2020–2021). Int. J. Antimicrob. Agents. 2023, 61, 106744. [Google Scholar]
  6. Bush, K.; Bradford, P.A. β-Lactams and β-Lactamase Inhibitors: An Overview. Cold Spring Harb. Perspect. Med. 2016, 6, a025247.1. [Google Scholar]
  7. Yang, Z.; Chen, Y.; Wan, L.; Cen, X.; Tang, P.; Chen, F. Catalytic asymmetric total synthesis of diazabicyclooctane β-lactamase inhibitors avibactam and relebactam. Chem. Commun. 2022, 58, 10869–10872. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  8. Pemberton, O.A.; Tsivkovski, R.; Totrov, M.; Lomovskaya, O.; Chen, Y. Structural Basis and Binding Kinetics of Vaborbactam in Class A β-Lactamase Inhibition. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 2020, 64, e00398-20. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  9. Drawz, S.M.; Bonomo, R.A. Three decades of beta-lactamase inhibitors. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 2010, 23, 160–201. [Google Scholar]
  10. Higgins, P.G.; Wisplinghoff, H.; Stefanik, D.; Seifert, H. In vitro activities of the beta-lactamase inhibitors clavulanic acid, sulbactam, and tazobactam alone or in combination with beta-lactams against epidemiologically characterized multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii strains. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 2004, 48, 1586–1592. [Google Scholar]
  11. Levin, A.S. Multiresistant Acinetobacter infections: A role for sulbactam combinations in overcoming an emerging worldwide problem. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. 2002, 8, 144–153. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  12. Khanna, N.R.; Gerriets, V. Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors; StatPearls Publishing: Treasure Island, FL, USA, 2024. Available online: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK557592/ (accessed on 27 June 2025).
  13. FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS) Public Dashboard. Available online: https://www.fda.gov/drugs/questions-and-answers-fdas-adverse-event-reporting-system-faers/fda-adverse-event-reporting-system-faers-public-dashboard (accessed on 5 September 2024).
  14. Sridharan, K.; Sivaramakrishnan, G. A pharmacovigilance study assessing risk of angioedema with angiotensin receptor blockers using the US FDA Adverse Event Reporting System. Expert Opin. Drug Saf. 2024, 19, 1–8. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  15. Gatti, M.; Raschi, E.; De Ponti, F. Serious adverse events with novel beta-lactam/beta-lactamase inhibitor combinations: A large-scale pharmacovigilance analysis. Eur. J. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 2021, 40, 1169–1176. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  16. Drugs@FDA: FDA-Approved Drugs. Available online: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cder/daf/index.cfm (accessed on 5 September 2024).
  17. Khaleel, M.A.; Khan, A.H.; Ghadzi, S.M.S.; Adnan, A.S.; Abdallah, Q.M. A Standardized Dataset of a Spontaneous Adverse Event Reporting System. Healthcare 2022, 10, 420. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  18. Faillie, J.L. Case-non-case studies: Principle, methods, bias and interpretation. Therapie 2019, 74, 225–232. [Google Scholar]
  19. Ahmed, I.; Thiessard, F.; Miremont-Salamé, G.; Bégaud, B.; Tubert-Bitter, P. Pharmacovigilance data mining with methods based on false discovery rates: A comparative simulation study. Clin. Pharmacol. Ther. 2010, 88, 492–498. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  20. Park, G.; Jung, H.; Heo, S.J.; Jung, I. Comparison of Data Mining Methods for the Signal Detection of Adverse Drug Events with a Hierarchical Structure in Postmarketing Surveillance. Life 2020, 10, 138. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  21. Chaftari, A.M.; Hachem, R.; Malek, A.E.; Mulanovich, V.E.; Szvalb, A.D.; Jiang, Y.; Yuan, Y.; Ali, S.; Deeba, R.; Chaftari, P.; et al. A Prospective Randomized Study Comparing Ceftolozane/Tazobactam to Standard of Care in the Management of Neutropenia and Fever in Patients with Hematological Malignancies. Open Forum Infect. Dis. 2022, 9, ofac079. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Van Anglen, L.J.; Schroeder, C.P.; Couch, K.A. A Real-World Multicenter Outpatient Experience of Ceftolozane/Tazobactam. Open Forum Infect. Dis. 2023, 10, ofad173. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  23. Brink, A.; Coetzee, J.; Richards, G.; Feldman, C.; Lowman, W.; Tootla, H.; Miller, M.; Niehaus, A.; Wasserman, S.; Perovic, O.; et al. Best practices: Appropriate use of the new β-lactam/β-lactamase inhibitor combinations, ceftazidime-avibactam and ceftolozane-tazobactam in South Africa. South. Afr. J. Infect. Dis. 2022, 37, 453. [Google Scholar]
  24. Lee, N.; Yuen, K.Y.; Kumana, C.R. Clinical role of beta-lactam/beta-lactamase inhibitor combinations. Drugs 2003, 63, 1511–1524. [Google Scholar]
  25. Lin, K.J.; Mitchell, A.A.; Yau, W.P.; Louik, C.; Hernández-Díaz, S. Maternal exposure to amoxicillin and the risk of oral clefts. Epidemiology 2012, 23, 699–705. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  26. Berkovitch, M.; Diav-Citrin, O.; Greenberg, R.; Cohen, M.; Bulkowstein, M.; Shechtman, S.; Bortnik, O.; Arnon, J.; Ornoy, A. First-trimester exposure to amoxycillin/clavulanic acid: A prospective, controlled study. Br. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 2004, 58, 298–302. [Google Scholar]
  27. Novelli, A.; Del Giacomo, P.; Rossolini, G.M.; Tumbarello, M. Meropenem/vaborbactam: A next generation β-lactam β-lactamase inhibitor combination. Expert. Rev. Anti Infect. Ther. 2020, 18, 643–655. [Google Scholar]
Figure 1. Study flow diagram. A total of 12,456 unique reports were included in the final analysis.
Figure 1. Study flow diagram. A total of 12,456 unique reports were included in the final analysis.
Jox 15 00144 g001
Figure 2. Comparison of the reported outcomes between beta-lactamase inhibitors. The stacked bar chart depicts the distribution of key outcomes reported for each beta-lactamase inhibitor.
Figure 2. Comparison of the reported outcomes between beta-lactamase inhibitors. The stacked bar chart depicts the distribution of key outcomes reported for each beta-lactamase inhibitor.
Jox 15 00144 g002
Table 1. USFDA approved beta-lactamase inhibitors.
Table 1. USFDA approved beta-lactamase inhibitors.
Beta-Lactamase InhibitorsYear of USFDA Approval
Avibactam2015
Clavulanic acid1984
Relebactam2019
Sulbactam1986
Tazobactam2005
Vaborbactam2017
Table 2. Demographic characteristics of patients in the reports.
Table 2. Demographic characteristics of patients in the reports.
CharacteristicsAvibactam (n = 685)Clavulanic Acid (n = 5627)Relebactam (n = 43)Sulbactam (n = 825)Tazobactam
(n = 5248)
Vaborbactam
(n = 28)
Age groups
[n (%)]
<1816 (2.3)641 (11.4)054 (6.5)277 (5.3)0
18 to <4520 (2.9)1066 (18.9)3 (7)130 (15.8)791 (15.1)5 (17.9)
45 to <6563 (9.2)1158 (20.6)12 (27.9)141 (17.1)1360 (25.9)5 (17.9)
≥6569 (10.1)1354 (24.1)13 (30.2)308 (37.3)1938 (36.9)5 (17.9)
Not specified517 (75.5)1408 (25)15 (34.9)192 (23.3)882 (16.8)13 (46.3)
Quantitative age (years) Mean (SD)57.5 (23.4)49.2 (25.3)64.4 (15.2)56.7 (24.3)58 (22.1)53.7 (16.4)
Median (range)61 (1–95)53 (1–103)63.5 (25–87)64 (0–100)62 (1–101)61 (26–83)
Gender
[n (%)]
Male310 (45.3)2121 (37.7)27 (62.8)371 (45)2803 (53.4)11 (39.3)
Female158 (23.1)2851 (50.7)16 (37.2)275 (33.3)1893 (36.1)5 (17.9)
Unknown217 (31.7)655 (11.6)0179 (22.7)552 (10.5)12 (42.9)
Reporting top countriesUSA, UK, GE, CNUSA, UK, FR, CAUSA, JPUSA, UK, JPUSA, FR, CA, JP USA, GE
USA: The United States of America; UK: The United Kingdom; FR: France; GE: Germany; CN: China; CA: Canada.; and JP: Japan.
Table 3. Summary of signal detection measures for reports associated with avibactam.
Table 3. Summary of signal detection measures for reports associated with avibactam.
SOCMedDRA CodeAdverse EventPRRχ2RRRROR [95% CI]IC25EBGM05Number of Cases
Blood and lymphatic system disorders10014950Eosinophilia8.720.18.78.7 [3.3, 23.4]1.23.34
10028584Myelosuppression5.29.85.25.3 [2, 14]0.924
10018910Hemolysis15.627.715.615.7 [5, 48.7]1.353
Cardiac disorders10007515Cardiac arrest3.310.43.33.3 [1.6, 6.6]0.81.68
Gastrointestinal disorders10082129Dysbiosis387.82279.5379.8391.7 [184.6, 831.3]41797
10027141Melena4.75.54.74.8 [1.5, 14.8]0.71.53
General disorders and administration site conditions10011906Death4.1317.84.14.8 [4, 5.8]418.7131
10059866Drug resistance41.91355.241.844.1 [31.4, 62]3.829.735
10010264Condition aggravated2.08.02.02.1 [1.3, 3.3]0.61.317
10077361Multiple organ dysfunction syndrome20.0233.519.920.4 [12, 34.6]2.511.714
10066901Treatment failure5.344.65.35.4 [3.2, 9.1]1.43.114
10051118Drug ineffective for unapproved indication5.327.15.35.3 [2.8, 10.3]1.22.79
10061819Disease recurrence3.85.63.83.8 [1.4, 10.1]0.71.44
Hepatobiliary disorders10019670Hepatic function abnormal8.653.58.68.8 [4.5, 16.9]1.64.59
10072268Drug-induced liver injury9.351.19.39.4 [4.7, 18.8]1.64.68
10060795Hepatic enzyme increased4.317.14.34.3 [2.2, 8.7]12.18
10008635Cholestasis10.534.110.510.6 [4.4, 25.6]1.44.45
10019837Hepatocellular injury11.428.111.311.4 [4.3, 30.5]1.34.24
10067125Liver injury6.112.26.16.1 [2.3, 16.3]12.34
Infections and infestations10034133Pathogen resistance156.66903.3155.3167.8 [124.3, 226.7]5.411546
10040070Septic shock10.282.510.210.4 [5.7, 18.8]1.85.611
10061259Klebsiella infection74.1575.973.875.1 [38.8, 145.1]3.238.29
10040047Sepsis3.110.53.13.1 [1.6, 5.9]0.81.69
10061471Pseudomonas infection39.2260.039.139.6 [19.7, 79.6]2.619.48
10074170Candida infection7.611.17.67.6 [2.4, 23.6]0.91.43
10054236Clostridium difficile infection6.38.76.36.3 [2, 19.7]0.923
10031252Osteomyelitis6.18.36.16.2 [2, 19.1]0.823
10035717Pneumonia Klebsiella68.1136.467.868.4 [21.9, 212.9]221.83
Injury, poisoning, and procedural complications10053762Off-label use4.2263.94.24.8 [3.9, 5.9]1.73.4105
10076309Product use issue3.427.73.43.4 [2.1, 5.5]1.12.118
10079843Product storage error2.77.32.72.8 [1.4, 5.6]0.71.48
10081581Incorrect product administration duration6.413.36.46.4 [2.4, 17.2]12.44
10081578Product administered to patient of inappropriate age16.529.616.516.6 [5.3, 51.6]1.35.33
Investigations10035528Platelet count decreased5.044.55.05.1 [3.1, 8.5]1.4315
10005483Blood creatinine increased7.162.37.17.2 [4.2, 12.5]1.64.113
10047942White blood cell count decreased3.213.13.23.2 [1.7, 6.1]0.91.710
10043554Thrombocytopenia2.66.72.62.7 [1.3, 5.4]0.71.38
10005364Blood bilirubin increased7.929.57.97.9 [3.6, 17.7]1.33.56
10033318Oxygen saturation decreased3.98.03.93.9 [1.6, 9.4]0.81.65
10054889Transaminases increased7.923.47.87.9 [3.3, 19]1.23.35
10005802Blood sodium decreased8.017.98.08.0 [3, 21.4]1.134
10004685Bilirubin conjugated increased48.896.648.749.1 [15.8, 152.7]1.815.63
10059570Blood alkaline phosphatase increased4.55.04.54.5 [1.4, 13.9]0.71.43
10017693Gamma-glutamyl transferase increased5.46.75.45.4 [1.7, 16.7]0.81.73
10051608Platelet count increased7.811.77.87.8 [2.5, 24.4]12.53
Nervous system disorders10029350Neurotoxicity20.9169.820.921.2 [11.3, 39.5]2.311.210
10014625Encephalopathy13.087.712.913.1 [6.8, 25.3]1.96.79
10012373Depressed level of consciousness6.632.56.66.6 [3.3, 13.3]1.43.38
10015037Epilepsy8.948.98.99.0 [4.5, 18.2]1.64.58
10039906Seizure2.45.22.42.4 [1.2, 4.8]0.61.28
10010071Coma4.716.84.74.7 [2.2, 9.9]1.12.27
10001854Altered state of consciousness8.425.48.38.4 [3.5, 20.3]1.33.45
10029202Nervous system disorder4.39.74.34.4 [1.8, 10.5]0.91.85
10028622Myoclonus7.911.97.98.0 [2.6, 24.8]12.53
10034759Petit mal epilepsy19.836.419.819.9 [6.4, 61.9]1.46.43
Psychiatric disorders10012218Delirium8.143.18.18.2 [4.1, 16.5]1.548
Renal and urinary disorders10038435Renal failure3.728.73.73.7 [2.3, 6.1]1.12.216
10062237Renal impairment4.832.14.84.8 [2.7, 8.5]1.32.712
10069339Acute kidney injury2.48.12.42.5 [1.4, 4.5]0.71.311
Respiratory, thoracic, and mediastinal disorders10038695Respiratory failure4.014.94.04.0 [2, 8]128
10043089Tachypnea7.911.87.97.9 [2.6, 24.7]12.53
Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders10073508Drug reaction with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms4.98.94.94.9 [1.9, 13.2]0.91.84
10044223Toxic epidermal necrolysis6.79.56.76.8 [2.2, 21]0.92.23
SOC: System organ classification; MedDRA: Medical dictionary of adverse events; PRR: Proportional reporting ratio; χ2: Chi-square test; RRR: Relative reporting ratio; ROR: Reporting odds ratio; IC: Information component; and EBGM: Empirical Bayes Geometric Mean.
Table 4. Summary of signal detection measures for reports associated with clavulanic acid.
Table 4. Summary of signal detection measures for reports associated with clavulanic acid.
SOCMedDRAAdverse EventPRRχ2RRRROR [95% CI]IC025EBGM05Number of Reports
Blood and lymphatic system disorders10025197Lymphadenopathy4.383.04.34.3 [3.1, 6.1]1.53.134
10041660Splenomegaly3.717.03.73.7 [2, 6.9]1210
10029783Normochromic normocytic anemia9.537.39.59.5 [4.3, 21.2]1.54.26
10020973Hypocoagulable state19.251.419.019.2 [7.2, 51.3]1.67.14
10055128Autoimmune neutropenia40.678.239.940.6 [13, 127.3]1.712.73
10020630Hypergammaglobulinemia30.858.430.430.8 [9.9, 96.2]1.69.73
10025188Lymphadenitis6.28.56.26.2 [2, 19.4]0.823
10025226Lymphangitis16.829.916.616.8 [5.4, 52.2]1.35.33
Cardiac disorders10069167Kounis syndrome85.83874.982.786.5 [65, 115.3]4.862.149
10028606Myocarditis2.76.02.72.7 [1.3, 5.7]0.71.37
10074636Fetal heart rate deceleration abnormality17.030.316.917.0 [5.5, 52.9]1.35.43
Congenital, familial, and genetic disorders10025391Macroglossia22.842.122.622.8 [7.3, 71.1]1.47.23
10084407Otospondylomegaepiphyseal dysplasia259.2479.6232.5259.4 [78.5, 857.2]2.470.43
Ear and labyrinth disorders10014025Ear swelling9.121.29.19.1 [3.4, 24.3]1.23.44
10026900Mastoiditis14.826.014.814.9 [4.8, 46.2]1.24.73
Eye disorders10015993Eyelid edema10.6250.310.610.7 [7.4, 15.3]2.47.430
10015967Eye swelling2.722.62.72.7 [1.8, 4.1]0.91.823
10034545Periorbital edema15.8274.115.715.8 [10.3, 24.3]2.610.221
10010741Conjunctivitis4.443.44.44.4 [2.8, 7]1.33.718
10058117Ocular icterus8.854.78.88.8 [4.6, 17]1.64.69
10051625Conjunctival hyperemia9.250.49.29.2 [4.6, 18.5]1.64.68
10056647Periorbital swelling3.65.13.63.6 [1.3, 9.5]0.71.34
Gastrointestinal disorders10012735Diarrhea3.3774.03.33.5 [3.2, 3.8]1.63476
10047700Vomiting3.0429.23.03.1 [2.8, 3.5]1.42.7323
10072268Drug-induced liver injury28.65231.928.229.6 [25.7, 34.1]4.224.5200
10000081Abdominal pain2.5121.32.52.6 [2.2, 3.1]1.12.1130
10000087Abdominal pain upper2.490.32.42.4 [2, 2.9]12113
10024558Lip edema65.13861.963.365.8 [51.2, 84.9]4.749.364
10024570Lip swelling5.8182.75.85.9 [4.4, 7.8]1.94.447
10043967Tongue edema47.81884.046.848.2 [35.6, 65.2]434.643
10043528Throat tightness5.2108.55.25.3 [3.7, 7.4]1.73.733
10016100Feces discolored5.595.35.55.5 [3.8, 8.1]1.73.827
10042727Swollen tongue3.339.63.33.3 [2.3, 4.9]1.22.226
10056998Palatal oedema78.01763.175.478.4 [52.5, 116.8]4.250.625
10016102Feces pale50.71096.049.650.9 [34, 76.4]3.833.124
10018836Hematochezia2.011.62.02.0 [1.4, 3]0.71.424
10044032Tooth discoloration32.0591.031.532.1 [20.8, 49.4]3.220.521
10012741Diarrhea hemorrhagic9.4133.79.49.4 [6, 14.8]2.15.919
10068318Oropharyngeal discomfort9.8140.79.89.8 [6.3, 15.4]2.16.219
10033647Pancreatitis acute3.019.63.03.0 [1.9, 4.9]11.816
10034829Pharyngeal edema3.932.33.94.0 [2.4, 6.5]1.22.416
10082270Pharyngeal swelling7.374.97.37.3 [4.4, 12.1]1.74.415
10030094Odynophagia11.2119.911.211.3 [6.7, 19]2.16.614
10061008Biliary tract disorder36.4372.335.836.5 [20.6, 64.5]2.920.212
10030963Oral candidiasis4.832.34.84.8 [2.7, 8.5]1.32.712
10027141Melena2.15.42.12.1 [1.2, 3.8]0.61.211
10038776Retching2.37.02.32.3 [1.3, 4.2]0.71.311
10014893Enterocolitis8.255.98.28.2 [4.4, 15.3]1.64.410
10027110Megacolon28.8237.928.428.8 [15.4, 53.8]2.615.210
10002959Aphthous ulcer6.032.56.06.0 [3.1, 11.6]1.33.19
10057009Pharyngeal erythema18.8133.618.718.9 [9.8, 36.4]2.29.79
10082129Dysbiosis54.1357.252.954.2 [26.9, 109.4]2.826.28
10014896Enterocolitis hemorrhagic21.6136.121.421.7 [10.8, 43.5]2.210.78
10017999Gastrointestinal pain3.411.33.43.4 [1.7, 6.8]0.91.78
10080124Lip erythema36.5170.636.036.6 [16.3, 82]2.3166
10000097Abdominal tenderness4.410.14.44.4 [1.8, 10.7]0.91.85
10008417Cheilitis4.08.64.04.0 [1.7, 9.7]0.81.75
10051402Dysentery11.136.111.011.1 [4.6, 26.7]1.44.65
10030110Edema mouth5.514.15.55.5 [2.3, 13.2]12.35
10036772Proctalgia4.08.64.04.0 [1.7, 9.7]0.81.75
10042101Stomach discomfort2.94.62.92.9 [1.2, 7]0.61.25
10048946Anal abscess4.16.44.14.1 [1.5, 10.8]0.81.54
10036200Portal hypertension5.510.75.55.5 [2.1, 14.8]0.92.14
10050247Anal inflammation26.950.426.526.9 [8.6, 83.9]1.58.53
10068172Anal pruritus7.911.97.98.0 [2.6, 24.7]12.53
10002958Aphthous stomatitis5.36.65.35.3 [1.7, 16.5]0.81.73
10006326Breath odor5.26.45.25.2 [1.7, 16.1]0.81.73
10061971Gastritis bacterial29.355.428.929.3 [9.4, 91.6]1.69.33
10030997Oral mucosal eruption8.513.18.58.5 [2.7, 26.5]12.73
10052894Oral pruritus5.67.25.65.6 [1.8, 17.4]0.81.83
10056674Oral pustule64.2125.262.464.2 [20.4, 202.4]1.919.83
10052453Palatal disorder21.539.621.321.5 [6.9, 67.2]1.46.83
10043945Tongue coated8.412.88.48.4 [2.7, 26.1]12.73
10070072Tongue pruritus16.830.016.716.8 [5.4, 52.4]1.35.43
10047708Vomiting projectile4.95.74.94.9 [1.6, 15.1]0.71.63
General disorders and administration site conditions10037660Pyrexia3.2348.23.23.3 [2.9, 3.7]1.52.8235
10016029Face edema27.52646.527.128.0 [23.1, 33.9]422.4106
10049438General physical health deterioration2.550.02.52.5 [1.9, 3.2]11.959
10042682Swelling face3.695.33.63.6 [2.7, 4.7]1.42.753
10030095Edema4.2121.34.24.2 [3.2, 5.6]1.63.251
10061218Inflammation2.521.62.52.5 [1.7, 3.7]0.91.726
10059866Drug resistance3.645.33.63.7 [2.5, 5.4]1.32.525
10077361Multiple organ dysfunction syndrome4.254.74.24.2 [2.8, 6.2]1.42.724
10018092Generalized edema7.9120.27.98.0 [5.2, 12.2]1.95.221
10028116Mucosal inflammation2.38.72.32.4 [1.4, 4.1]0.71.413
10048961Localized edema10.576.410.510.5 [5.6, 19.6]1.85.610
10069221Product color issue6.532.16.56.5 [3.3, 13.1]1.43.38
10053459Secretion discharge3.07.33.03.0 [1.4, 6.2]0.71.47
10020741Hyperpyrexia7.125.67.17.1 [3.2, 15.9]1.33.26
10039740Screaming3.25.43.23.2 [1.3, 7.7]0.71.35
10014579Enanthema33.995.533.433.9 [12.6, 91.1]1.912.44
10049998Idiosyncratic drug reaction14.437.314.414.5 [5.4, 38.7]1.45.44
10028133Mucous membrane disorder11.327.711.211.3 [4.2, 30.1]1.34.24
10048723Multiple-drug resistance4.88.64.84.8 [1.8, 12.9]0.91.84
10030111Edema mucosal13.022.212.913.0 [4.2, 40.5]1.24.23
Hepatobiliary disorders10023126Jaundice18.61967.818.519.0 [15.8, 22.8]3.515.4120
10019754Hepatitis cholestatic85.48118.082.387.0 [71.2, 106.2]5.267.4102
10008635Cholestasis21.01507.120.821.3 [17.1, 26.5]3.516.781
10019717Hepatitis11.4641.811.311.5 [9.1, 14.6]2.88.969
10024690Liver function test abnormal5.2129.95.25.2 [3.8, 7.1]1.73.840
10060795Hepatic enzyme increased2.635.32.62.6 [1.9, 3.5]11.939
10067125Liver injury6.8178.66.86.9 [5, 9.5]24.937
10019837Hepatocellular injury11.5303.111.411.5 [8.2, 16.2]2.58.133
10023129Jaundice cholestatic41.21156.040.541.5 [29, 59.2]3.728.431
10020578Hyperbilirubinemia13.6336.013.513.7 [9.5, 19.6]2.69.430
10003827Autoimmune hepatitis16.6377.416.516.7 [11.4, 24.4]2.811.327
10019663Hepatic failure3.648.73.63.6 [2.5, 5.3]1.32.527
10019727Hepatitis acute17.4382.817.317.5 [11.9, 25.7]2.811.726
10019670Hepatic function abnormal2.722.82.72.7 [1.8, 4.1]0.91.823
10019851Hepatotoxicity3.842.23.83.8 [2.5, 5.8]1.32.522
10019708Hepatic steatosis4.852.84.84.8 [3, 7.5]1.4319
10067969Cholestatic liver injury37.7596.137.037.8 [23.7, 60.2]3.323.218
10066758Mixed liver injury32.3507.431.832.4 [20.3, 51.6]3.12018
10000804Acute hepatic failure4.640.94.64.6 [2.8, 7.5]1.32.816
10049199Hepatic cytolysis6.260.76.26.3 [3.8, 10.4]1.63.715
10071634Deficiency of bile secretion561.74486.5449.5562.8 [290.5, 1090.2]4.523211
10019795Hepatitis toxic17.8156.717.717.8 [9.8, 32.3]2.39.811
10019842Hepatomegaly4.017.03.94.0 [2.1, 7.6]12.19
10061998Hepatic lesion8.444.98.48.4 [4.2, 16.9]1.54.28
10019692Hepatic necrosis7.533.17.57.5 [3.6, 15.8]1.43.67
10019668Hepatic fibrosis7.427.37.47.5 [3.3, 16.6]1.33.36
10024714Liver transplant6.221.36.26.2 [2.8, 13.9]1.22.86
10004685Bilirubin conjugated increased9.931.69.99.9 [4.1, 23.9]1.44.15
10008604Cholangitis3.98.13.93.9 [1.6, 9.4]0.81.65
10011411Cross-sensitivity reaction27.9102.827.527.9 [11.5, 67.4]211.45
10008605Cholangitis acute27.676.627.227.6 [10.3, 74]1.810.24
10008909Chronic hepatitis15.126.415.015.1 [4.8, 47]1.34.83
10050904Cytolytic hepatitis4.34.74.34.3 [1.4, 13.4]0.71.43
10056956Subacute hepatic failure77.5151.274.977.5 [24.5, 245.1]223.73
Immune system disorders10013700Drug hypersensitivity11.46507.111.312.8 [11.8, 13.9]3.210.4683
10020751Hypersensitivity5.6923.05.65.8 [5.1, 6.6]2.24.9245
10002198Anaphylactic reaction12.91791.812.813.3 [11.3, 15.5]3.211165
10002199Anaphylactic shock21.42314.021.221.9 [18.2, 26.2]3.717.7121
10053613Type IV hypersensitivity reaction77.83811.375.378.6 [59.7, 103.4]4.757.253
10079645Therapeutic product cross-reactivity88.21990.384.988.6 [59.3, 132.2]4.356.925
10045240Type I hypersensitivity29.1642.728.829.2 [19.7, 43.4]3.319.425
10040402Serum-sickness-like reaction81.4844.278.681.6 [45.9, 145.3]3.544.212
10047115Vasculitis4.428.44.44.4 [2.5, 7.8]1.22.512
10071583Hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis6.234.26.26.2 [3.2, 12]1.43.29
10002216Anaphylactoid reaction8.143.08.18.1 [4.1, 16.3]1.548
10051379Systemic inflammatory response syndrome8.941.38.98.9 [4.2, 18.7]1.54.27
Infections and infestations10054236Clostridium difficile infection13.9632.413.914.1 [10.8, 18.4]2.910.654
10009657Clostridium difficile colitis22.8948.122.623.0 [17.2, 30.7]3.416.947
10040070Septic shock3.868.83.83.9 [2.8, 5.4]1.42.734
10017533Fungal infection3.754.83.73.7 [2.6, 5.4]1.32.629
10074170Candida infection8.0152.08.08.0 [5.5, 11.8]25.426
10034133Pathogen resistance9.9182.89.910.0 [6.7, 14.9]2.26.624
10027201Meningitis aseptic22.3403.022.122.4 [14.6, 34.5]2.914.421
10061126Escherichia infection8.382.58.38.3 [4.9, 14.1]1.84.914
10061259Klebsiella infection14.1156.214.014.1 [8.3, 23.9]2.28.314
10037128Pseudomembranous colitis27.5302.027.227.5 [15.9, 47.6]2.815.713
10064899Vulvovaginal mycotic infection12.5104.512.412.5 [6.9, 22.6]26.911
10061043Clostridial infection8.653.18.68.6 [4.5, 16.6]1.64.59
10015108Epstein–Barr virus infection6.636.96.56.6 [3.4, 12.6]1.43.49
10058305Clostridium colitis25.7140.525.425.7 [12.2, 54.1]2.2127
10021914Infectious mononucleosis13.971.013.813.9 [6.6, 29.3]1.86.67
10061471Pseudomonas infection4.213.84.24.2 [2, 8.8]127
10014568Empyema14.159.914.014.1 [6.3, 31.4]1.76.36
10061124Enterococcal infection5.413.75.45.4 [2.2, 13]12.25
10034686Peritonsillar abscess28.5105.328.228.5 [11.8, 69]211.75
10068556Anal fungal infection230.4633.6209.1230.6 [82.4, 645.52.874.74
10053555Arthritis bacterial4.37.24.34.3 [1.6, 11.6]0.81.64
10007152Candidiasis3.65.23.63.6 [1.4, 9.7]0.71.44
10037569Purulent discharge4.88.44.84.8 [1.8, 12.7]0.81.84
10062279Urinary tract infection pseudomonal33.995.533.433.9 [12.6, 91.1]1.912.44
10052815Antibiotic-associated colitis518.5873.4421.4518.7 [147.8, 1820.8]2.51203
10057847Biliary sepsis27.752.227.427.8 [8.9, 86.7]1.58.83
10006105Brain abscess4.95.94.94.9 [1.6, 15.3]0.71.63
10069657Burkholderia cepacia complex infection45.888.845.045.9 [14.6, 143.9]1.714.33
10069748Burkholderia pseudomallei infection224.7420.9204.3224.8 [68.6, 736.8]2.362.33
10058666Cytomegalovirus infection reactivation4.55.04.54.5 [1.4, 13.9]0.71.43
10015296Escherichia sepsis5.26.45.25.2 [1.7, 16.2]0.71.73
10058017Infective aneurysm28.453.728.128.5 [9.1, 88.9]1.593
10033079Otitis media acute18.633.718.518.6 [6, 58]1.45.93
10053461Trichosporon infection30.457.630.030.4 [9.7, 94.9]1.69.63
10062233Uterine infection26.048.825.726.0 [8.3, 81.3]1.58.23
Injury, poisoning, and procedural complications10027091Medication error2.741.72.72.7 [2, 3.7]1241
10081770Product prescribing error2.818.52.82.9 [1.8, 4.6]0.91.817
10076470Documented hypersensitivity to administered product45.8344.245.045.9 [23.7, 88.9]2.823.29
10076245Transcription medication error14.272.714.114.2 [6.8, 29.9]1.86.77
10081579Wrong product administered3.68.93.63.6 [1.6, 8.1]0.81.66
10017051Foreign body trauma17.646.617.417.6 [6.6, 47]1.56.54
10001605Alcohol poisoning4.44.94.44.4 [1.4, 13.8]0.71.43
Investigations10001551Alanine aminotransferase increased3.692.83.63.7 [2.8, 4.8]1.42.750
10003481Aspartate aminotransferase increased3.891.83.83.9 [2.9, 5.2]1.42.945
10024378Leukocytosis9.8307.79.89.9 [7.2, 13.5]2.47.240
10005364Blood bilirubin increased6.1156.36.16.1 [4.4, 8.4]1.94.438
10059570Blood alkaline phosphatase increased6.5162.96.56.6 [4.7, 9.1]1.94.736
10006825C-reactive protein increased5.0105.85.05.1 [3.6, 7.1]1.73.634
10017693Gamma-glutamyl transferase increased7.2169.37.27.2 [5.1, 10.2]25.133
10022595International normalized ratio increased4.375.44.34.3 [3, 6.2]1.5331
10014950Eosinophilia7.2136.97.17.2 [4.9, 10.5]1.94.927
10024384Leukopenia2.419.72.42.4 [1.6, 3.5]0.91.626
10054889Transaminases increased4.663.94.64.6 [3.1, 6.9]1.53.124
10021015Hypokalemia2.110.42.12.1 [1.4, 3.3]0.71.320
10001507Agranulocytosis4.955.54.94.9 [3.1, 7.8]1.53.119
10005911Body temperature increased4.344.04.24.3 [2.7, 6.7]1.32.719
10068237Hypertransaminasemia14.2219.314.114.3 [9.1, 22.4]2.4919
10077692Liver function test increased2.36.72.32.3 [1.3, 4.1]0.71.211
10009802Coagulopathy2.68.02.62.6 [1.4, 4.8]0.71.410
10021113Hypothermia3.614.13.63.6 [1.9, 6.9]11.89
10029379Neutrophilia5.629.55.65.6 [2.9, 10.8]1.32.99
10070027Clostridium test positive17.8109.717.717.8 [8.9, 35.7]2.18.88
10014392Electrocardiogram ST segment elevation8.136.98.18.1 [3.9, 17.1]1.43.97
10069826Inflammatory marker increased6.924.86.97.0 [3.1, 15.5]1.33.16
10005586Blood immunoglobulin a increased36.8104.236.336.9 [13.7, 99]1.913.54
10009736Coagulation factor decreased59.9171.958.460.0 [22.2, 161.9]2.221.64
10062685Hepatic enzyme abnormal3.34.23.33.3 [1.2, 8.7]0.61.24
10050791Leukocyturia24.467.224.224.4 [9.1, 65.5]1.794
10063342Tryptase increased26.473.026.126.4 [9.8, 70.7]1.89.74
10009799Coagulation time prolonged7.611.17.57.6 [2.4, 23.5]0.92.43
10067081Procalcitonin increased13.423.013.313.4 [4.3, 41.7]1.24.33
10060888Skin test negative187.2355.4172.9187.3 [57.7, 608.4]2.353.23
10070055Streptococcus test positive13.723.713.713.7 [4.4, 42.7]1.24.43
Metabolism and nutrition disorders10000159Abnormal loss of weight3.44.53.43.4 [1.3, 9]0.71.34
10057248Cell death7.210.47.27.2 [2.3, 22.4]0.92.33
10021083Hypoproteinemia9.114.29.19.1 [2.9, 28.3]12.93
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders10003267Arthritis reactive20.136.719.920.1 [6.5, 62.7]1.46.43
Nervous system disorders10036653Presyncope3.223.43.23.2 [2, 5.1]1217
10040108Serotonin syndrome2.510.72.52.6 [1.5, 4.4]0.81.513
10027199Meningitis3.15.23.13.1 [1.3, 7.5]0.71.35
10042264Stupor4.78.34.74.7 [1.8, 12.7]0.81.84
10003805Autism8.412.88.48.4 [2.7, 26.1]12.73
10070511Hypoxic–ischemic encephalopathy4.75.44.74.7 [1.5, 14.6]0.71.53
10074869Language disorder5.57.05.55.5 [1.8, 17.1]1.593
10068357Neurological decompensation6.18.26.16.1 [2, 19]0.823
Pregnancy, puerperium, and perinatal conditions10036590Premature baby2.724.42.72.7 [1.8, 4]11.825
10036595Premature delivery2.711.32.72.7 [1.5, 4.8]0.81.512
10049550Live birth4.113.24.14.1 [1.9, 8.5]11.97
10030289Oligohydramnios4.47.34.44.4 [1.6, 11.7]0.81.64
10073024Preterm premature rupture of membranes9.615.29.69.6 [3.1, 29.9]13.13
Psychiatric disorders10026749Mania2.25.42.22.2 [1.2, 4.1]0.61.210
Renal and urinary disorders10008796Chromaturia11.1511.111.011.2 [8.6, 14.5]2.78.557
10048302Tubulointerstitial nephritis6.5141.96.46.5 [4.6, 9.2]1.94.532
10024515Linear IgA disease50.71047.049.650.9 [33.6, 77]3.732.823
10038436Renal failure acute2.111.32.12.1 [1.4, 3.3]0.71.421
10008684Choluria268.54286.7239.9269.4 [167.3, 433.8]4.914919
10018867Hematuria2.413.92.42.4 [1.5, 3.7]0.81.519
10013990Dysuria2.210.02.22.2 [1.4, 3.4]0.71.418
10002847Anuria3.06.03.03.0 [1.3, 6.6]0.71.36
10030302Oliguria4.312.04.34.3 [1.9, 9.6]0.91.96
10071503Crystal nephropathy25.068.824.725.0 [9.3, 66.9]1.79.24
Reproductive system and breast disorders10037093Pruritus genital20.0143.019.920.1 [10.4, 38.7]2.210.39
10054816Genital erythema76.8507.874.376.9 [38, 155.7]3.136.78
10047784Vulvovaginal candidiasis22.7102.622.522.7 [10.2, 50.8]210.16
10018175Genital rash11.929.611.811.9 [4.5, 31.8]1.34.44
Reproductive system and breast disorders10047768Vulval ulceration57.2164.255.857.3 [21.2, 154.6]2.220.74
10004078Balanoposthitis16.328.916.216.3 [5.2, 50.7]1.35.23
10030104Edema genital19.335.019.119.3 [6.2, 60]1.46.13
Respiratory, thoracic, and mediastinal disorders10013968Dyspnea2.5279.52.52.5 [2.3, 2.9]1.22.2317
10006482Bronchospasm12.2366.212.112.2 [8.8, 16.9]2.68.837
10023845Laryngeal oedema20.5513.220.320.6 [14.3, 29.7]314.129
10047924Wheezing2.422.22.42.4 [1.7, 3.5]0.91.729
10013952Dysphonia2.114.82.12.1 [1.5, 3.1]0.71.427
10021143Hypoxia2.719.62.72.7 [1.7, 4.2]0.91.720
10011703Cyanosis5.260.45.25.2 [3.3, 8.2]1.53.319
10038687Respiratory distress2.28.42.22.2 [1.3, 3.8]0.71.314
10043089Tachypnea4.228.34.24.2 [2.4, 7.2]1.22.413
10084380COVID-19 pneumonia2.55.02.52.5 [1.2, 5.3]0.61.27
10080148Eosinophilic pleural effusion85.9406.482.785.9 [38, 194.3]2.836.66
10006473Bronchopulmonary aspergillosis3.05.03.03.0 [1.3, 7.3]0.71.35
10008590Choking sensation4.18.84.14.1 [1.7, 9.9]0.81.75
10006469Bronchopneumonia4.98.74.94.9 [1.8, 13]0.91.84
10006487Bronchostenosis35.9101.635.436.0 [13.4, 96.6]1.913.24
10035724Pneumonia mycoplasmal25.971.625.625.9 [9.7, 69.5]1.79.64
10035728Pneumonia pneumococcal13.233.413.113.2 [4.9, 35.2]1.44.94
10037833Rales3.65.03.63.6 [1.3, 9.5]0.71.34
10044003Tonsillar hypertrophy10.124.210.110.1 [3.8, 27]1.23.84
10064779Breath sounds114.2221.7108.8114.3 [35.8, 364.7]2.134.13
10006440Bronchial obstruction10.517.010.410.5 [3.4, 32.6]1.13.43
10023891Laryngospasm5.06.05.05.0 [1.6, 15.5]0.71.63
10081792Lung opacity6.38.56.26.3 [2, 19.5]0.923
10078257Tonsillar exudate374.4664.2321.1374.6 [110.3, 1272.2]2.594.63
Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders10037087Pruritus5.21456.75.25.6 [5, 6.2]2.24.7422
10037844Rash3.5649.63.53.7 [3.3, 4.1]1.63.2354
10046735Urticaria8.21985.78.28.6 [7.7, 9.7]2.77.3314
10015150Erythema6.0903.96.06.2 [5.4, 7.1]2.35.2218
10037868Rash maculo-papular39.26737.338.540.5 [34.9, 47]4.533.3185
10073508Drug reaction with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms17.51778.217.417.9 [14.9, 21.5]3.414.5116
10037884Rash pruritic8.7687.28.78.9 [7.3, 10.8]2.67.1102
10002424Angioedema8.2627.28.28.4 [6.9, 10.2]2.56.7100
10037858Rash generalized8.2345.98.28.3 [6.4, 10.8]2.36.356
10048799Acute generalized exanthematous pustulosis27.91333.727.628.2 [21.5, 37]3.62153
10037855Rash erythematous5.5184.65.55.6 [4.2, 7.3]1.94.251
10052576Pruritus generalized8.9326.78.88.9 [6.7, 11.9]2.46.748
10040882Skin lesion6.7199.66.76.8 [5, 9.2]2542
10044223Toxic epidermal necrolysis11.6392.611.511.6 [8.6, 15.8]2.68.542
10040844Skin exfoliation3.051.33.03.0 [2.2, 4.1]1.22.240
10005191Blister3.359.63.33.3 [2.4, 4.5]1.22.439
10013687Drug eruption9.5263.09.49.5 [6.9, 13.2]2.36.836
10057970Toxic skin eruption18.3566.118.118.4 [13.2, 25.5]31336
10037867Rash macular4.892.14.84.8 [3.4, 6.8]1.63.432
10040914Skin reaction9.5225.39.49.5 [6.7, 13.5]2.36.631
10042033Stevens–Johnson syndrome5.095.15.05.0 [3.5, 7.2]1.63.531
10037888Rash pustular18.6477.418.418.7 [13, 26.8]2.912.830
10015218Erythema multiforme11.4235.211.311.4 [7.8, 16.8]2.47.726
10012434Dermatitis allergic7.9126.47.98.0 [5.2, 12.1]25.222
10037876Rash papular5.780.25.75.7 [3.8, 8.7]1.63.722
10012441Dermatitis bullous11.8185.911.711.8 [7.6, 18.4]2.37.620
10037549Purpura10.2148.010.210.2 [6.5, 16.1]2.16.519
10012455Dermatitis exfoliative13.5171.713.413.5 [8.3, 22.1]2.38.216
10051576Generalized erythema11.4131.611.411.4 [6.9, 19]2.16.815
10002473Angioneurotic edema16.9191.816.716.9 [10, 28.6]2.49.914
10012456Dermatitis exfoliative generalized19.1219.918.919.1 [11.3, 32.3]2.511.214
10078325Symmetrical drug-related intertriginous and flexural exanthema70.2860.368.170.4 [41.3, 119.9]3.64014
10082980Mucocutaneous disorder227.21640.8206.4227.5 [114.6, 451.9]3.91049
10034754Petechiae4.017.04.04.0 [2.1, 7.6]12.19
10037578Pustule17.6108.617.517.7 [8.8, 35.4]2.18.78
10016741Fixed eruption16.385.216.216.3 [7.8, 34.3]1.97.77
10054107Nodule2.54.72.52.5 [1.2, 5.2]0.61.27
10034277Pemphigoid4.414.94.44.4 [2.1, 9.2]12.17
10037870Rash morbilliform11.154.511.111.1 [5.3, 23.4]1.75.37
10058679Skin edema32.0177.631.532.0 [15.2, 67.5]2.414.97
10048245Yellow skin6.426.66.46.4 [3, 13.4]1.337
10011686Cutaneous vasculitis7.628.07.67.6 [3.4, 17]1.33.46
10067868Skin mass4.211.64.24.2 [1.9, 9.4]0.91.96
10014141Ecthyma50.6191.749.550.6 [20.9, 122.9]2.320.45
10015226Erythema nodosum6.217.06.26.2 [2.6, 15]1.12.65
10084905Generalized bullous fixed drug eruption70.2267.068.170.3 [28.8, 171.2]2.5285
10020764Hypersensitivity vasculitis7.521.97.57.5 [3.1, 18]1.23.15
10037083Prurigo30.0111.329.730.1 [12.4, 72.7]212.35
10040893Skin necrosis4.18.84.14.1 [1.7, 9.8]0.81.75
10042343Subcutaneous abscess4.811.44.84.8 [2, 11.5]0.925
10047642Vitiligo9.429.39.39.4 [3.9, 22.5]1.33.95
10037898Rash vesicular3.96.03.93.9 [1.5, 10.4]0.71.54
10053262Skin swelling3.34.43.33.3 [1.2, 8.9]0.61.24
10047097Vascular purpura14.738.114.614.7 [5.5, 39.4]1.45.54
10047476Viral rash46.8133.645.946.8 [17.4, 126.1]2174
10000748Acute febrile neutrophilic dermatosis5.06.05.05.0 [1.6, 15.5]0.71.63
10070599Acute hemorrhagic edema of infancy337.0606.0293.2337.2 [100.2, 1135]2.4873
10009869Cold urticaria55.7108.454.455.7 [17.7, 175.3]1.817.33
10019617Henoch–Schönlein purpura6.28.46.26.2 [2, 19.4]0.823
10064000Lichenoid keratosis6.18.26.16.1 [2, 19]0.823
10029415Nikolsky’s sign25.146.824.825.1 [8, 78.2]1.473
10035039Piloerection11.920.011.911.9 [3.8, 37.1]1.13.83
10046742Urticaria contact396.5697.7337.1396.7 [116.2, 1354]2.598.83
10052569Urticaria generalized14.926.114.814.9 [4.8, 46.4]1.24.83
Surgical and medical procedures10050729Self-medication13.8176.913.813.9 [8.5, 22.7]2.38.416
Vascular disorders10021097Hypotension2.265.12.22.2 [1.8, 2.7]0.91.8101
10009192Circulatory collapse3.626.13.63.6 [2.2, 6.1]1.12.215
10018852Hematoma2.512.52.52.5 [1.5, 4.2]0.81.515
10033546Pallor2.39.72.32.3 [1.4, 3.8]0.71.415
10020565Hyperemia17.6108.317.517.6 [8.8, 35.3]2.18.78
10052076Hemodynamic instability2.84.02.82.8 [1.2, 6.7]0.61.25
10034636Peripheral vascular disorder3.24.13.23.2 [1.2, 8.6]0.61.24
10034567Peripheral circulatory failure37.471.936.837.5 [12, 117.3]1.711.83
10048820Urticarial vasculitis26.449.626.126.4 [8.5, 82.6]1.58.43
SOC: System organ classification; MedDRA: Medical dictionary of adverse events; PRR: Proportional reporting ratio; χ2: Chi-square test; RRR: Relative reporting ratio; ROR: Reporting odds ratio; IC: Information component; and EBGM: Empirical Bayes Geometric Mean.
Table 5. Signal detection measures for adverse events reported with relebactam.
Table 5. Signal detection measures for adverse events reported with relebactam.
SOCMedDRAAdverse EventPRRχ2RRRROR [95% CI]IC025EBGM05Number of Cases
General disorders and administration site conditions10011906Death4.015.74.04.7 [2.2, 10.1]0.91.88
Injury, poisoning, and procedural complications10076476Product use in unapproved indication11.136.611.112.4 [4.9, 31.5]1.44.45
10053762Off-label use8.379.48.311.5 [6, 22]1.64.313
Infections and infestations10034133Pathogen resistance161.5331.4161.4173.5 [53.7, 561]2.349.93
Nervous system disorder10015037Epilepsy71.3211.571.278.5 [28, 219.6]2.225.54
SOC: System organ classification; MedDRA: Medical dictionary of adverse events; PRR: Proportional reporting ratio; χ2: Chi-square test; RRR: Relative reporting ratio; ROR: Reporting odds ratio; IC: Information component; and EBGM: Empirical Bayes Geometric Mean.
Table 6. Signal detection measures for adverse events reported with sulbactam.
Table 6. Signal detection measures for adverse events reported with sulbactam.
SOCMedDRA CodeAdverse EventPRRχ2RRRROR [95% CI]IC025EBHM05Number of Cases
Blood and lymphatic system disorders10018916Hemolytic anemia19.587.419.419.6 [8.8, 43.8]1.98.76
10025197Lymphadenopathy4.39.74.34.3 [1.8, 10.5]0.91.85
10013442Disseminated intravascular coagulation8.619.98.68.7 [3.2, 23.2]1.23.24
10062713Hemorrhagic diathesis25.147.325.125.2 [8.1, 78.4]1.58.13
Cardiac disorders10007515Cardiac arrest3.719.23.73.7 [2.1, 6.8]1211
10043071Tachycardia3.010.03.03.0 [1.6, 5.8]0.81.59
10007617Cardio-respiratory arrest5.323.75.35.3 [2.7, 10.7]1.22.68
10069167Kounis syndrome95.1649.594.596.0 [47.7, 193]3.3478
10006093Bradycardia3.16.43.13.1 [1.4, 6.9]0.71.46
10047290Ventricular fibrillation10.224.710.210.3 [3.8, 27.4]1.33.84
10007625Cardiogenic shock6.18.26.16.1 [2, 19]0.823
Gastrointestinal disorders10014896Enterocolitis hemorrhagic720.625,373.2687.6755.4 [541.5, 1053.8]6.8492.938
10018836Hematochezia3.58.33.53.5 [1.6, 7.8]0.81.66
10024570Lip swelling3.44.53.43.4 [1.3, 9]0.71.34
10042727Swollen tongue3.44.73.43.5 [1.3, 9.2]0.71.34
10012743Diarrhea neonatal493.3990.0477.6495.1 [156.4, 1566.9]2.8150.93
General disorders and administration site conditions10037660Pyrexia2.214.72.22.2 [1.5, 3.4]0.81.524
10010264Condition aggravated2.09.22.02.0 [1.3, 3.2]0.61.320
10016029Face edema12.261.312.212.3 [5.9, 25.9]1.75.87
10059866Drug resistance6.020.56.06.1 [2.7, 13.6]1.22.76
10020741Hyperpyrexia41.3157.941.241.5 [17.2, 100.2]2.217.15
10061819Disease recurrence3.24.13.23.2 [1.2, 8.6]0.61.24
10028154Multi-organ failure5.811.45.85.8 [2.2, 15.5]0.92.24
Hepatobiliary disorders10023126Jaundice9.459.29.49.5 [4.9, 18.3]1.74.99
10019670Hepatic function abnormal6.431.36.46.5 [3.2, 13]1.33.28
10008635Cholestasis12.462.312.412.5 [5.9, 26.3]1.75.97
10019663Hepatic failure6.426.66.46.4 [3.1, 13.5]1.337
10072268Drug-induced liver injury5.919.75.95.9 [2.7, 13.2]1.12.66
10024670Liver disorder3.89.63.83.8 [1.7, 8.5]0.91.76
10024690Liver function test abnormal5.216.45.25.2 [2.3, 11.7]1.12.36
10019795Hepatitis toxic55.1213.654.955.5 [23, 133.8]2.422.85
10023129Jaundice cholestatic44.3170.144.244.6 [18.5, 107.5]2.318.35
10067125Liver injury6.417.66.46.4 [2.7, 15.4]1.12.65
10008612Cholecystitis9.923.69.99.9 [3.7, 26.5]1.23.74
10019772Hepatitis fulminant40.8117.640.741.0 [15.3, 109.6]215.24
Immune system disorders10013700Drug hypersensitivity4.9136.04.95.2 [3.8, 7]1.73.644
10002198Anaphylactic reaction16.6439.616.617.2 [12, 24.6]2.811.631
10002199Anaphylactic shock36.3993.636.237.6 [26.1, 54.2]3.625.130
10020751Hypersensitivity2.615.82.62.7 [1.7, 4.3]0.91.617
10002216Anaphylactoid reaction20.838.420.720.8 [6.7, 64.8]1.46.73
10053613Type IV hypersensitivity reaction29.356.029.229.4 [9.4, 91.3]1.69.43
Infections and infestation10035664Pneumonia3.350.73.33.4 [2.4, 4.8]1.22.333
10040047Sepsis3.417.93.43.4 [1.9, 6]11.912
10009657Clostridium difficile colitis36.4343.636.336.9 [20.3, 66.9]2.92011
10034133Pathogen resistance22.4142.722.422.6 [11.3, 45.4]2.211.18
10040070Septic shock5.421.15.45.5 [2.6, 11.5]1.22.67
10061043Clostridial infection38.4182.438.338.7 [17.3, 86.5]2.417.16
10061259Klebsiella infection41.5198.041.441.8 [18.7, 93.5]2.418.56
10061126Escherichia infection16.242.916.216.3 [6.1, 43.5]1.56.14
10037128Pseudomembranous colitis56.7166.256.557.0 [21.3, 152.5]2.221.14
10058080Staphylococcal infection3.75.53.73.7 [1.4, 10]0.71.44
10003997Bacteremia8.513.08.58.5 [2.7, 26.5]12.73
10058852Clostridium bacteremia444.4894.3431.6446.1 [141.2, 1409.2]2.8136.63
10058305Clostridium colitis73.0146.472.673.3 [23.5, 228.2]223.33
10054236Clostridium difficile infection5.46.85.45.4 [1.7, 16.8]0.81.73
Injury, poisoning, and procedural complications10049193Drug exposure during pregnancy3.37.43.33.3 [1.5, 7.3]0.81.56
10061355Poisoning6.89.66.86.8 [2.2, 21.2]0.92.23
Investigations10011631Culture stool positive1039.18751.1971.71051.8 [552.1, 2004]5.251010
10070091Klebsiella test positive582.25039.4560.4589.3 [312.2, 1112.6]4.829710
10043554Thrombocytopenia2.89.62.82.8 [1.5, 5.2]0.81.510
10001551Alanine aminotransferase increased3.914.83.94.0 [2, 8]128
10003481Aspartate aminotransferase increased4.619.44.64.7 [2.3, 9.4]1.12.38
10005734Blood pressure decreased3.612.73.63.7 [1.8, 7.3]0.91.88
10070027Clostridium test positive129.3886.4128.2130.5 [64.9, 262.7]3.563.78
10005470Blood creatine phosphokinase increased6.125.16.16.2 [2.9, 13]1.22.97
10037063Prothrombin time prolonged32.8184.532.733.0 [15.7, 69.5]2.415.57
10021015Hypokalemia4.312.14.34.3 [1.9, 9.6]0.91.96
10033318Oxygen saturation decreased3.910.33.93.9 [1.8, 8.8]0.91.86
10005364Blood bilirubin increased5.413.95.45.4 [2.3, 13.1]12.25
10009802Coagulopathy8.726.78.78.7 [3.6, 21]1.33.65
10020679Hypernatremia33.3125.633.233.5 [13.9, 80.7]2.113.85
10024378Leukocytosis8.325.48.38.4 [3.5, 20.2]1.33.55
10033661Pancytopenia2.84.22.82.8 [1.2, 6.8]0.61.25
10047943White blood cell count increased4.18.74.14.1 [1.7, 9.8]0.81.75
10000636Activated partial thromboplastin time prolonged22.461.722.422.5 [8.4, 60.1]1.78.44
10005851Blood urea increased7.817.37.77.8 [2.9, 20.8]1.12.94
10006825C-reactive protein increased4.06.44.04.1 [1.5, 10.9]0.81.54
10014950Eosinophilia7.315.97.37.3 [2.7, 19.6]1.12.74
10005630Blood lactate dehydrogenase increased6.38.56.36.3 [2, 19.5]0.923
10005728Blood pressure abnormal4.44.94.44.5 [1.4, 13.9]0.71.43
10005758Blood pressure systolic decreased20.036.720.020.0 [6.4, 62.3]1.46.43
10005911Body temperature increased4.65.14.64.6 [1.5, 14.2]0.71.53
10018838Hematocrit decreased4.75.44.74.7 [1.5, 14.7]0.71.53
Metabolism and nutrition disorders10001598Alcohol intolerance309.32116.2303.1312.3 [154.6, 631.1]4.11508
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders10039020Rhabdomyolysis3.25.53.23.2 [1.3, 7.7]0.71.35
Nervous system disorders10010904Convulsion3.19.13.13.1 [1.5, 6.2]0.81.58
10001854Altered state of consciousness4.24.44.24.2 [1.3, 13]0.71.33
10048962Brain edema6.99.86.96.9 [2.2, 21.5]0.92.23
Renal and urinary disorders10062237Renal impairment5.660.25.65.7 [3.5, 9.2]1.53.517
10038436Renal failure acute7.454.57.47.5 [4.1, 13.5]1.64.111
10018867Hematuria3.44.63.43.4 [1.3, 9.1]0.71.34
10038540Renal tubular necrosis9.715.69.79.8 [3.1, 30.4]1.13.13
Respiratory, thoracic, and mediastinal disorders10022611Interstitial lung disease9.6106.89.69.7 [5.8, 16.2]25.715
10001053Acute respiratory failure14.184.614.114.2 [7.1, 28.5]1.978
10006482Bronchospasm17.8110.817.818.0 [9, 36.1]2.18.98
10035598Pleural effusion3.16.43.13.1 [1.4, 6.9]0.71.46
10021143Hypoxia3.75.43.73.7 [1.4, 9.9]0.71.44
10023845Laryngeal edema19.251.919.219.3 [7.2, 51.5]1.67.24
10023891Laryngospasm45.9133.145.746.1 [17.2, 123.3]2.117.14
10038678Respiratory depression8.018.08.08.0 [3. 21.4]1.134
10043089Tachypnea6.69.36.66.6 [2.1, 20.6]0.92.13
Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders10037844Rash2.950.12.93.0 [2.2, 4]1.12.142
10037087Pruritus3.149.23.13.2 [2.3, 4.4]1.22.236
10015150Erythema3.838.03.83.8 [2.5, 6]1.22.420
10037855Rash erythematous12.8173.812.813.1 [8.1, 21.1]2.37.917
10013687Drug eruption26.9348.026.827.4 [16.4, 45.6]2.816.115
10044223Toxic epidermal necrolysis28.0363.828.028.5 [17.1, 47.5]2.916.815
10042033Stevens–Johnson syndrome15.2172.315.215.5 [9.1, 26.3]2.3914
10046735Urticaria2.511.12.52.5 [1.5, 4.3]0.81.514
10037868Rash maculo-papular18.6199.518.618.9 [10.9, 32.7]2.410.813
10037858Rash generalized10.787.310.710.8 [6, 19.6]1.95.911
10002424Angioedema5.125.45.05.1 [2.6, 9.8] 1.22.69
10073508Drug reaction with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms8.344.08.28.3 [4.1, 16.7]1.54.18
10048799Acute generalized exanthematous pustulosis25.0137.824.925.2 [12. 53]2.211.87
10051576Generalized erythema30.3141.730.230.5 [13.7, 68.2]2.213.56
10024515Linear IgA disease88.4432.087.989.0 [39.8, 199.2]2.939.36
10037867Rash macular6.221.26.26.2 [2.8, 13.9]1.22.86
10037549Purpura14.637.814.514.6 [5.5, 39.1]1.45.44
10057970Toxic skin eruption13.935.713.813.9 [5.2, 37.2]1.45.24
10012434Dermatitis allergic7.410.97.47.5 [2.4, 23.3]0.92.43
10033733Papule13.322.913.313.3 [4.3, 41.5]1.24.33
Surgical and medical procedures10061105Dialysis5.16.35.15.1 [1.7, 16]0.81.73
Vascular disorders10021097Hypotension3.437.13.43.5 [2.3, 5.3]1.22.323
10040560Shock18.0224.718.018.4 [11, 30.6]2.510.815
10047115Vasculitis17.693.717.617.8 [8.4, 37.4]28.47
10011703Cyanosis9.329.29.39.4 [3.9, 22.5]1.33.95
SOC: System organ classification; MedDRA: Medical dictionary of adverse events; PRR: Proportional reporting ratio; χ2: Chi-square test; RRR: Relative reporting ratio; ROR: Reporting odds ratio; IC: Information component; and EBGM: Empirical Bayes Geometric Mean.
Table 7. Signal detection measures for adverse events with tazobactam.
Table 7. Signal detection measures for adverse events with tazobactam.
SOCMedDRAAdverse EventPRRχ2RRRROR [95% CI]IC025EBGM05Number of Cases
Blood and lymphatic system disorders10016288Febrile neutropenia3.578.13.53.6 [2.7, 4.8]1.42.644
10018916Hemolytic anemia20.1682.419.920.2 [14.7, 27.7]3.114.539
10001507Agranulocytosis10.6318.710.510.6 [7.7, 14.7]2.57.638
10065553Bone marrow failure6.8146.76.86.8 [4.8, 9.7]24.731
10028584Myelosuppression5.195.45.15.1 [3.6, 7.4]1.63.630
10009802Coagulopathy7.1130.57.17.2 [4.9, 10.5]1.94.826
10071583Hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis16.3299.116.216.4 [10.8, 24.9]2.610.622
10018910Hemolysis13.6220.513.613.7 [8.8, 21.2]2.48.720
10013442Disseminated intravascular coagulation6.583.06.56.5 [4.2, 10.3]1.74.119
10073785Autoimmune hemolytic anemia24.4354.924.224.5 [15.2, 39.5]2.81517
10083842Immune thrombocytopenia14.8152.414.714.8 [8.6, 25.5]2.28.513
10053873Evans syndrome77.6368.675.277.7 [34.5, 175.3]2.833.46
10056335Factor V inhibition137.5645.5130.2137.7 [60.5, 313.6]3.757.16
10073391Platelet dysfunction84.9403.182.185.0 [37.7, 192.1]2.836.36
10075185Allergic eosinophilia859.62558.3633.6860.4 [309.8, 2389.6]3.52285
10062713Hemorrhagic diathesis6.718.76.76.7 [2.8, 16.1]1.12.85
10050245Autoimmune thrombocytopenia32.792.132.332.8 [12.2, 87.9]1.9124
10048930Factor V deficiency103.5297.299.3103.6 [38.1, 281.9]2.436.54
10043561Thrombocytopenic purpura13.233.613.213.2 [5, 35.4]1.44.94
10002046Anemia hemolytic autoimmune13.823.913.813.8 [4.4, 43.1]1.24.43
10061729Bone marrow disorder4.24.44.24.2 [1.3, 12.9]0.71.33
10021245Idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura7.110.27.17.1 [2.3, 22.1]0.92.33
10025280Lymphocytosis6.38.66.36.3 [2, 19.7]0.923
Cardiac disorders10043071Tachycardia3.6132.23.63.7 [2.9, 4.7]1.52.970
10007515Cardiac arrest3.184.03.13.2 [2.4, 4.1]1.32.459
10007617Cardio-respiratory arrest3.346.13.23.3 [2.3, 4.6]1.22.331
10044066Torsade de pointes8.394.58.28.3 [5.1, 13.5]1.9516
10069167Kounis syndrome27.4351.827.127.5 [16.5, 45.8]2.916.315
10058151Pulseless electrical activity12.6105.812.612.6 [7, 22.9]2711
10024119Left ventricular failure5.410.35.45.4 [2, 14.4]0.924
10007601Cardiac pacemaker removal200.6381.0185.2200.7 [61.8, 651.9]2.3573
10049434Cardiac pacemaker replacement30.357.630.030.4 [9.7, 94.8]1.69.63
10057651Cardiac valve vegetation27.752.127.427.7 [8.9, 86.4]1.58.83
10050011Electromechanical dissociation14.525.214.414.5 [4.7, 45.1]1.24.63
10024803Long QT syndrome5.36.65.35.3 [1.7, 16.4]0.81.73
Eye disorders10015993Eyelid edema5.344.45.35.3 [3.1, 9]1.43.114
10042690Swelling of eyelid4.39.54.34.3 [1.8, 10.3]0.91.85
10015683Exophthalmos6.58.96.56.5 [2.1, 20.1]0.92.13
Gastrointestinal disorders10024570Lip swelling4.063.94.04.0 [2.8, 5.7]1.42.830
10016100Feces discolored2.47.72.42.4 [1.3, 4.4]0.71.311
10082129Dysbiosis72.9620.570.873.1 [38.9, 137.2]3.337.710
10027141Melena2.14.52.12.1 [1.1, 3.8]0.61.110
10057371Hypoesthesia oral2.45.12.42.4 [1.2, 4.8]0.61.28
10077605Anal incontinence3.15.03.03.1 [1.3, 7.3]0.71.35
10080276Trichoglossia53.2202.352.153.3 [22, 129.3]2.421.55
10021333Ileus paralytic4.47.44.44.4 [1.7, 11.8]0.81.64
10022642Intestinal dilatation16.041.915.916.0 [6, 42.8]1.55.94
10022680Intestinal ischemia3.34.43.33.3 [1.2, 8.8]0.61.24
10024558Lip edema4.26.94.24.2 [1.6, 11.3]0.81.64
10027110Megacolon12.230.612.212.2 [4.6, 32.7]1.34.64
10028124Mucosal ulceration16.543.316.416.5 [6.2, 44]1.56.14
General disorders and administration site conditions10037660Pyrexia4.7962.14.75.0 [4.4, 5.5]24.2327
10010264Condition aggravated2.065.32.02.0 [1.7, 2.4]0.81.7129
10008531Chills4.3254.24.34.3 [3.6, 5.3]1.73.5103
10008469Chest discomfort3.299.73.23.2 [2.5, 4.1]1.32.567
10051118Drug ineffective for unapproved indication4.8180.14.74.8 [3.7, 6.2]1.73.762
10066901Treatment failure2.968.42.92.9 [2.2, 3.7]1.22.258
10059866Drug resistance8.8376.28.78.8 [6.8, 11.5]2.46.756
10077361Multiple organ dysfunction syndrome7.5216.77.47.5 [5.5, 10.2]2.15.440
10016029Face edema8.3183.68.28.3 [5.8, 11.9]2.15.730
10057040Temperature intolerance11.6239.511.511.6 [7.9, 17.1]2.47.826
10028154Multi-organ failure5.168.65.15.1 [3.4, 7.8]1.53.422
10020843Hyperthermia8.275.48.28.3 [4.8, 14.2]1.84.813
10020741Hyperpyrexia15.3145.115.215.3 [8.7, 27]2.28.612
10015866Extravasation7.633.87.67.6 [3.6, 16]1.43.67
10018092Generalized edema2.86.52.82.8 [1.3, 5.9]0.71.37
10064774Infusion site extravasation6.225.46.26.2 [2.9, 13]1.22.97
10011912Death neonatal14.361.214.214.3 [6.4, 32]1.76.36
10048659Concomitant disease progression10.935.410.810.9 [4.5, 26.2]1.44.55
10053664Infusion site pruritus10.835.110.810.8 [4.5, 26.1]1.44.55
10068072Potentiating drug interaction6.919.66.96.9 [2.9, 16.6]1.22.95
10018691Granuloma5.510.45.55.5 [2, 14.6]0.924
10062654Foaming at mouth6.69.16.56.6 [2.1, 20.4]0.92.13
Hepatobiliary disorders10008635Cholestasis16.0798.215.916.2 [12.5, 21]3.112.358
10019670Hepatic function abnormal7.3308.17.37.4 [5.7, 9.5]2.25.658
10019837Hepatocellular injury14.9501.714.815.0 [11, 20.5]2.810.840
10024690Liver function test abnormal5.4135.05.45.4 [4, 7.4]1.83.939
10049199Hepatic cytolysis16.6521.916.416.7 [12, 23]2.911.937
10072268Drug-induced liver injury5.1109.45.15.2 [3.7, 7.3]1.73.734
10067125Liver injury5.9118.35.96.0 [4.2, 8.6]1.74.130
10019717Hepatitis4.984.04.95.0 [3.4, 7.2]1.63.428
10019663Hepatic failure3.954.93.93.9 [2.7, 5.7]1.33.727
10024670Liver disorder2.623.22.62.6 [1.7, 3.8]0.91.726
10019851Hepatotoxicity4.253.54.24.2 [2.8, 6.4]1.42.823
10019754Hepatitis cholestatic15.7231.115.615.7 [9.9, 25]2.59.818
10023126Jaundice2.614.72.62.6 [1.6, 4.3]0.91.616
10066758Mixed liver injury24.9271.724.624.9 [14.4, 43.2]2.714.313
10067969Cholestatic liver injury22.2180.522.022.3 [11.9, 41.6]2.411.810
10023129Jaundice cholestatic12.784.912.612.7 [6.6, 24.4]1.96.59
10008614Cholecystitis acute4.915.14.94.9 [2.2, 11]12.26
10019842Hepatomegaly2.85.32.82.8 [1.3, 6.3]0.71.36
10084058Congestive hepatopathy68.4260.666.568.4 [28.1, 166.5]2.527.45
10019795Hepatitis toxic6.914.76.96.9 [2.6, 18.4]12.64
10050904Cytolytic hepatitis4.65.34.64.6 [1.5, 14.4]0.71.53
Immune system disorders10013700Drug hypersensitivity3.5349.43.53.6 [3.1, 4.1]1.63196
10002198Anaphylactic reaction9.6876.99.69.8 [8.1, 11.8]2.78115
10020751Hypersensitivity2.6108.62.62.7 [2.2, 3.2]1.22.2108
10002199Anaphylactic shock12.1636.612.012.2 [9.5, 15.6]2.89.464
10023125Jarisch–Herxheimer reaction98.81488.895.099.1 [61, 161.2]458.417
10053613Type IV hypersensitivity reaction18.4178.918.318.4 [10.4, 32.5]2.410.312
10048595Histiocytosis hematophagic13.6103.713.513.6 [7.3, 25.3]27.610
10002216Anaphylactoid reaction8.747.08.78.7 [4.4, 17.5]1.64.38
10011411Cross sensitivity reaction35.9167.835.436.0 [16.1, 80.6]2.315.86
10040400Serum sickness8.023.87.98.0 [3.3, 19.2]1.23.35
10040402Serum-sickness-like reaction35.6133.435.135.6 [14.7, 86.2]2.114.55
10045240Type I hypersensitivity6.216.86.26.2 [2.6, 14.9]12.65
Infections and infestations10034133Pathogen resistance54.56166.253.355.8 [46.5, 66.9]4.844.4121
10040047Sepsis3.8170.43.83.8 [3.1, 4.7]1.5385
10040070Septic shock8.9500.68.89.0 [7.1, 11.3]2.5773
10054236Clostridium difficile infection17.7986.717.617.9 [14, 23]3.213.764
10009657Clostridium difficile colitis23.9976.623.724.1 [18, 32.2]3.417.746
10017523Fungemia100.72936.496.7101.3 [71, 144.4]4.667.832
10074170Candida infection7.6124.67.67.6 [5.1, 11.5]1.9523
10061043Clostridial infection22.7431.522.522.8 [15, 34.8]314.822
10061471Pseudomonas infection13.5228.613.413.5 [8.8, 20.8]2.48.721
10058080Staphylococcal infection2.820.02.82.8 [1.8, 4.4]0.91.819
10017533Fungal infection2.311.62.32.3 [1.5, 3.8]0.81.417
10061259Klebsiella infection18.3259.618.218.4 [11.4, 29.7]2.611.317
10061124Enterococcal infection18.6247.118.518.6 [11.4, 30.5]2.611.316
10053461Trichosporon infection184.32541.2171.2184.8 [111.1, 307.5]4.5102.916
10003997Bacteremia6.666.16.66.6 [4, 11]1.6415
10014665Endocarditis11.4102.911.311.4 [6.5, 20.1]26.412
10060945Bacterial infection2.89.72.82.8 [1.5, 5.2]0.81.510
10064687Device-related infection3.312.13.33.3 [1.7, 6.3]0.91.79
10061126Escherichia infection5.122.25.15.1 [2.5, 10.2]1.22.58
10037128Pseudomembranous colitis18.0111.417.918.1 [9, 36.2]2.18.98
10042938Systemic candida17.4107.317.317.5 [8.7, 35]28.58
10056660Geotrichum infection189.31047.2175.6189.6 [87.8, 409.3]3.581.37
10060921Abdominal abscess7.427.27.47.4 [3.3, 16.6]1.33.36
10014666Endocarditis bacterial35.0163.134.535.0 [15.6, 78.4]2.315.46
10054160Klebsiella sepsis29.2134.728.829.2 [13.1, 65.4]2.212.96
10024652Liver abscess9.336.29.29.3 [4.2, 20.7]1.44.16
10028098Mucormycosis10.743.410.710.7 [4.8, 23.9]1.54.86
10061354Pneumonia fungal7.627.87.57.6 [3.4, 16.9]1.33.46
10035734Pneumonia staphylococcal16.170.216.016.2 [7.2, 36.1]1.77.26
10048709Urosepsis3.37.53.33.3 [1.5, 7.4]0.81.56
10006041Botulism37.6141.237.037.6 [15.6, 91.1]2.215.35
10058305Clostridium colitis19.669.919.419.6 [8.1, 47.2]1.885
10015296Escherichia sepsis7.416.37.47.5 [2.8, 19.9]1.12.84
10071699Infectious pleural effusion13.634.613.513.6 [5.1, 36.3]1.454
10058806Mycobacterium avium complex infection7.115.27.07.1 [2.6, 18.9]1.12.64
10051017Staphylococcal bacteremia5.29.65.25.2 [1.9, 13.8]0.91.94
10001980Amoebiasis58.7114.557.358.7 [18.7, 184.7]1.918.23
10001985Amoebic colitis120.3234.0114.7120.4 [37.8, 384]2.1363
10007810Catheter-related infection11.018.110.911.0 [3.5, 34.1]1.13.53
10058666Cytomegalovirus infection reactivation4.85.64.84.8 [1.5, 14.9]0.81.63
10012742Diarrhea infectious20.737.920.520.7 [6.6, 64.5]1.46.63
10014568Empyema7.511.07.57.5 [2.4, 23.3]0.92.43
10051998Febrile infection15.026.214.915.0 [4.8, 46.7]1.34.83
10020431Human herpesvirus 6 infection6.99.86.96.9 [2.2, 21.5]0.92.23
10021784Infected skin ulcer7.911.87.97.9 [2.5, 24.6]12.53
10060738Intervertebral discitis8.913.98.98.9 [2.9, 27.8]12.93
10058923Pseudomonal bacteremia20.437.320.220.4 [6.5, 63.6]1.46.53
10070087Raoultella ornithinolytica infection225.6425.2206.4225.8 [69.1, 737.5]2.463.23
10047931Whipple’s disease34.566.134.134.6 [11.1, 108.1]1.610.93
Injury, poisoning, and procedural complications10076476Product use in unapproved indication2.164.62.12.1 [1.8, 2.5]0.91.7115
10051792Infusion-related reaction2.520.92.52.5 [1.7, 3.8]0.91.724
10073311Occupational exposure to product3.49.53.43.4 [1.6, 7.1]0.71.67
10064372Documented hypersensitivity to administered drug72.9346.370.873.0 [32.4, 164.6]2.731.46
10064306Incorrect drug administration rate7.829.17.87.8 [3.5, 17.5]1.33.56
10076470Documented hypersensitivity to administered product27.099.626.827.1 [11.2, 65.4]2115
10075462Drug monitoring procedure not performed9.020.99.09.0 [3.4, 24]1.23.44
10084721Labeled drug–drug interaction issue11.919.911.811.9 [3.8, 37]1.13.83
10051373Wound hemorrhage4.04.14.04.0 [1.3, 12.4]0.61.33
Investigations10043554Thrombocytopenia8.71350.88.69.0 [7.8, 10.3]2.77.5200
10029354Neutropenia3.6201.03.63.6 [3, 4.4]1.53109
10014950Eosinophilia23.81771.023.524.1 [19.4, 30]3.718.983
10047942White blood cell count decreased3.4130.33.43.4 [2.7, 4.2]1.42.780
10005483Blood creatinine increased5.6297.25.65.7 [4.6, 7.1]24.579
10035528Platelet count decreased3.3121.43.33.4 [2.7, 4.2]1.42.676
10001551Alanine aminotransferase increased5.4249.85.45.5 [4.4, 7]1.94.370
10070027Clostridium test positive166.910021.8156.1169.0 [131.5, 217.2]5.7121.566
10024384Leukopenia6.4291.26.46.5 [5.1, 8.3]2.1565
10033318Oxygen saturation decreased5.9229.05.95.9 [4.6, 7.7]24.558
10003481Aspartate aminotransferase increased4.9165.84.95.0 [3.8, 6.5]1.83.854
10033661Pancytopenia4.7155.84.74.8 [3.7, 6.3]1.73.654
10005734Blood pressure decreased2.949.82.92.9 [2.2, 4]1.12.141
10006825C-reactive protein increased5.9144.55.95.9 [4.3, 8.2]1.84.237
10060795Hepatic enzyme increased2.531.62.52.5 [1.8, 3.5]11.836
10054889Transaminases increased6.4134.76.46.4 [4.5, 9.1]1.94.531
10059570Blood alkaline phosphatase increased5.288.55.25.3 [3.6, 7.7]1.63.627
10005911Body temperature increased6.5119.56.56.5 [4.5, 9.5]1.84.427
10021015Hypokalemia2.827.32.82.8 [1.9, 4.2]11.925
10029366Neutrophil count decreased3.030.93.03.0 [2, 4.4]1.1225
10047943White blood cell count increased3.235.63.23.2 [2.2, 4.8]1.12.225
10022595International normalized ratio increased3.437.03.43.4 [2.3, 5.2]1.22.323
10024378Leukocytosis6.091.86.06.1 [4, 9.1]1.7423
10017693Gamma-glutamyl transferase increased5.169.05.15.1 [3.4, 7.8]1.53.422
10005364Blood bilirubin increased3.636.93.63.6 [2.4, 5.5]1.22.321
10020578Hyperbilirubinemia10.2164.310.110.2 [6.7, 15.7]2.26.621
10014945Eosinophil count increased11.3177.111.311.4 [7.3, 17.6]2.27.320
10020679Hypernatremia20.9355.820.721.0 [13.5, 32.6]2.813.320
10005630Blood lactate dehydrogenase increased5.660.05.65.6 [3.5, 9.1]1.53.517
10013722Drug level increased3.014.13.03.0 [1.7, 5.3]0.91.712
10005851Blood urea increased3.112.03.13.1 [1.7, 5.7]0.91.610
10069826Inflammatory marker increased12.493.512.412.4 [6.7, 23.2]1.96.610
10025327Lymphopenia3.414.53.43.4 [1.8, 6.3]0.91.810
10000636Activated partial thromboplastin time prolonged8.048.38.08.0 [4.2, 15.4]1.64.19
10018838Hematocrit decreased2.25.02.22.2 [1.2, 4.3]0.61.29
10037063Prothrombin time prolonged6.738.06.76.7 [3.5, 12.9]1.43.59
10040250Serum ferritin increased7.941.37.97.9 [3.9, 15.8]1.53.98
10058956Bicytopenia20.1107.719.920.1 [9.6, 42.3]2.19.57
10018681Granulocyte count decreased20.2108.120.020.2 [9.6, 42.5]2.19.57
10051608Platelet count increased2.44.32.42.4 [1.1, 5]0.61.17
10070052Staphylococcus test positive18.9100.518.718.9 [9, 39.8]28.97
10005803Blood sodium increased10.844.010.810.8 [4.9, 24.2]1.54.86
10068237Hypertransaminasemia4.814.44.84.8 [2.2, 10.7]12.16
10020942Hypoalbuminemia4.412.74.44.4 [2, 9.9]126
10043563Thrombocytosis7.828.97.87.8 [3.5, 17.3]1.33.56
10005488Blood culture positive7.722.77.77.7 [3.2, 18.5]1.23.25
10058363Eosinophils urine present388.21346.0334.4388.6 [151, 999.7]3.31305
10024574Lipase increased3.04.83.03.0 [1.3, 7.2]0.71.25
10067081Procalcitonin increased24.087.623.824.0 [10, 58]1.99.95
10037469Pulse absent4.711.24.74.7 [2, 11.4]0.925
10059895Urine output decreased2.94.52.92.9 [1.2, 7]0.61.25
10002793Antimicrobial susceptibility test resistant46.7133.645.946.8 [17.4, 125.8]2.1174
10014391Electrocardiogram ST segment depression8.318.88.38.3 [3.1, 22.1]1.13.14
10072234Enzyme level increased21.357.821.121.3 [7.9, 56.9]1.67.94
10069962Acinetobacter test positive75.2147.173.075.3 [23.8, 237.5]223.13
10001549Alanine aminotransferase decreased23.543.723.323.5 [7.5, 73.4]1.57.53
10058542Anti-platelet antibody328.2597.2288.9328.4 [98.3, 1097.5]2.486.53
10049471Blood phosphorus decreased4.04.04.04.0 [1.3, 12.3]0.61.33
10050380Electrocardiogram t wave abnormal8.512.98.48.5 [2.7, 26.3]12.73
10070090Escherichia test positive14.324.814.214.3 [4.6, 44.5]1.24.63
10070748False positive investigation result10.918.010.910.9 [3.5, 34]1.13.53
10067350Hypercreatinemia46.991.046.046.9 [15, 147.1]1.814.73
10070091Klebsiella test positive26.449.726.226.5 [8.5, 82.6]1.58.43
10061313Neutrophil count abnormal4.95.74.94.9 [1.6, 15.1]0.71.63
10061880Occult blood positive6.69.26.66.6 [2.1, 20.5]0.92.13
10059168Oxygen consumption increased6.38.56.26.3 [2, 19.5]0.923
10037070Prothrombin time shortened10.316.710.310.3 [3.3, 32.1]1.13.33
Metabolism and nutrition disorders10027417Metabolic acidosis2.925.42.92.9 [1.9, 4.4]11.922
10016803Fluid overload2.64.42.62.6 [1.2, 5.8]0.61.26
10047634Vitamin K deficiency41.079.240.441.0 [13.1, 128.5]1.712.93
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders10039020Rhabdomyolysis2.111.12.12.1 [1.4, 3.2]0.71.421
10021119Hypotonia neonatal6.89.76.86.8 [2.2, 21.3]0.92.23
Nervous system disorders10014625Encephalopathy6.8171.26.86.8 [4.9, 9.5]24.936
10012218Delirium3.233.73.23.2 [2.1, 4.8]1.12.124
10012373Depressed level of consciousness2.09.12.02.0 [1.3, 3.2]0.71.319
10044221Toxic encephalopathy13.2145.013.113.2 [7.8, 22.4]2.27.814
10045555Unresponsive to stimuli2.510.82.52.5 [1.5, 4.2]0.81.514
10028622Myoclonus4.531.84.54.5 [2.6, 7.8]1.34.613
10029350Neurotoxicity3.316.73.33.3 [1.9, 5.8]11.912
10003547Asterixis16.543.616.416.6 [6.2, 44.3]1.56.14
10061666Autonomic neuropathy13.924.113.813.9 [4.5, 43.3]1.24.53
10022840Intraventricular hemorrhage5.06.05.05.0 [1.6, 15.5]0.71.63
Pregnancy, puerperium, and perinatal conditions10036590Premature baby2.210.92.22.2 [1.4, 3.4]0.71.419
10067508Low birth weight baby3.713.43.73.7 [1.9, 7.5]0.91.88
10071409Fetal exposure during delivery14.725.714.714.7 [4.7, 45.9]1.24.73
10071407Maternal exposure during delivery15.727.715.615.7 [5, 48.9]1.353
Product issues10069250Product deposit31.3260.830.931.4 [16.8, 58.6]2.716.610
10069293Product container issue4.420.64.44.4 [2.3, 8.6]1.12.39
10064685Device occlusion2.64.22.62.6 [1.1, 5.7]0.61.16
10070617Device infusion issue12.441.212.312.4 [5.1, 29.8]1.55.15
10081540Recalled product administered3.04.83.03.0 [1.2, 7.2]0.71.25
Psychiatric disorders10013954Dysphoria4.717.14.74.8 [2.3, 10]1.12.37
10076227Disorganized speech9.723.19.79.7 [3.6, 26]1.23.64
Renal and urinary disorders10069339Acute kidney injury5.0541.95.05.1 [4.4, 6]24.3171
10048302Tubulointerstitial nephritis20.71744.120.521.0 [17.1, 25.8]3.616.795
10038436Renal failure acute9.2611.79.29.3 [7.5, 11.6]2.67.485
10062237Renal impairment4.1182.24.14.1 [3.3, 5.2]1.63.379
10038435Renal failure2.243.82.22.2 [1.7, 2.7]0.91.772
10038540Renal tubular necrosis20.2704.620.020.3 [14.9, 27.8]3.214.740
10029155Nephropathy toxic13.2345.713.113.2 [9.3, 18.8]2.69.232
10024515Linear IgA disease71.31951.469.371.7 [49.8, 103.2]4.248.130
10029134Nephritis interstitial85.12167.082.285.5 [58.6, 124.8]4.456.328
10029117Nephritis29.0507.028.729.1 [18.7, 45.3]3.118.420
10002847Anuria7.571.77.47.5 [4.4, 12.6]1.74.414
10061105Dialysis3.825.83.83.8 [2.2, 6.4]1.12.214
10018875Hemodialysis6.660.86.66.6 [3.9, 11.2]1.63.914
10029151Nephropathy3.511.73.53.5 [1.7, 7]0.91.78
10030302Oliguria6.129.46.16.1 [3.1, 12.3]1.33.18
10029147Nephrogenic diabetes insipidus23.6128.523.423.6 [11.2, 49.8]2.211.17
10038537Renal tubular disorder8.325.28.38.3 [3.5, 20.1]1.33.45
10018906Hemoglobinuria17.245.617.117.2 [6.4, 46.1]1.56.44
10050791Leukocyturia19.635.619.419.6 [6.3, 61]1.46.23
10037686Pyuria14.625.514.514.6 [4.7, 45.5]1.24.73
Respiratory, thoracic, and mediastinal disorders10038695Respiratory failure5.5308.05.55.6 [4.5, 6.9]24.485
10043089Tachypnea18.3845.718.218.5 [14.1, 24.3]3.213.953
10047924Wheezing2.939.82.92.9 [2.1, 4.1]1.12.133
10021143Hypoxia4.580.24.54.5 [3.2, 6.4]1.53.131
10022611Interstitial lung disease2.830.22.82.8 [1.9, 4]11.928
10035669Pneumonia aspiration4.974.84.95.0 [3.4, 7.4]1.63.325
10001052Acute respiratory distress syndrome6.198.16.16.2 [4.1, 9.2]1.84.124
10038687Respiratory distress3.636.93.63.6 [2.4, 5.5]1.12.321
10038712Respiratory rate increased11.3176.211.211.3 [7.3, 17.6]2.27.220
10023845Laryngeal edema14.3221.014.214.4 [9.1, 22.6]2.4919
10006482Bronchospasm6.065.36.06.0 [3.7, 9.6]1.63.717
10043528Throat tightness2.512.52.52.5 [1.5, 4.2]0.81.515
10006473Bronchopulmonary aspergillosis9.193.29.19.2 [5.4, 15.5]1.95.414
10018964Hemoptysis2.510.72.52.5 [1.5, 4.2]0.81.514
10025102Lung infiltration5.230.05.25.2 [2.8, 9.7]1.32.810
10035731Pneumonia pseudomonal41.6351.040.941.7 [22.3, 78]2.921.910
10052832Eosinophilic pneumonia acute47.3355.946.447.4 [24.5, 91.7]2.8249
10064780Breath sounds abnormal8.237.18.28.2 [3.9, 17.2]1.43.97
10037833Rales6.728.36.76.7 [3.2, 14]1.33.27
10003497Asphyxia3.26.93.23.2 [1.4, 7.1]0.71.46
10003598Atelectasis3.47.93.43.4 [1.5, 7.6]0.81.56
10037382Pulmonary eosinophilia48.6229.647.748.7 [21.7, 109.3]2.521.26
10038661Respiratory acidosis7.024.96.97.0 [3.1, 15.5]1.33.16
10039109Rhonchi25.6116.825.325.6 [11.4, 57.2]2.111.36
10042241Stridor9.638.09.69.6 [4.3, 21.5]1.44.36
10001029Acute pulmonary edema4.811.34.84.8 [2, 11.5]0.925
10014962Eosinophilic pneumonia7.321.17.37.3 [3, 17.5]1.235
10038647Respiration abnormal3.35.93.33.3 [1.4, 8]0.71.45
10011376Crepitations6.413.36.46.4 [2.4, 17.2]12.44
10019027Hemothorax4.75.44.74.7 [1.5, 14.5]0.71.53
10020591Hypercapnia5.36.55.35.3 [1.7, 16.3]0.81.73
10021133Hypoventilation4.04.24.04.0 [1.3, 12.6]0.61.33
10025080Lung consolidation5.67.15.65.6 [1.8, 17.3]0.81.83
10028923Neonatal asphyxia16.329.016.216.3 [5.2, 50.9]1.35.23
10035717Pneumonia Klebsiella8.913.88.98.9 [2.9, 27.6]12.83
10070774Respiratory tract edema20.738.020.620.8 [6.7, 64.7]1.46.63
10042444Suffocation feeling5.97.85.95.9 [1.9, 18.4]0.81.93
Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders10037844Rash3.7688.73.73.9 [3.5, 4.3]1.73.3346
10037087Pruritus3.1348.73.13.2 [2.8, 3.7]1.42.8237
10015150Erythema4.3373.64.34.4 [3.7, 5.2]1.83.7147
10073508Drug reaction with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms22.52813.922.323.1 [19.5, 27.4]3.818.8139
10037855Rash erythematous10.0686.610.010.2 [8.2, 12.6]2.78.186
10037868Rash maculo-papular19.11431.119.019.4 [15.7, 24.1]3.415.385
10046735Urticaria2.466.62.42.4 [1.9, 3]11.985
10002424Angioedema5.8258.15.85.9 [4.6, 7.5]24.566
10013687Drug eruption17.8975.117.718.0 [14, 23.1]3.213.863
10044223Toxic epidermal necrolysis14.2570.814.114.3 [10.7, 19]2.910.648
10042033Stevens–Johnson syndrome7.4232.67.47.5 [5.5, 10.1]2.15.543
10037884Rash pruritic3.774.43.63.7 [2.7, 5]1.42.740
10048799Acute generalized exanthematous pustulosis20.8672.720.621.0 [15.1, 29]3.214.937
10057970Toxic skin eruption20.1648.120.020.3 [14.6, 28]3.114.437
10005191Blister2.833.92.82.8 [2, 4]1231
10034754Petechiae13.7327.713.713.8 [9.6, 19.9]2.69.529
10040844Skin exfoliation2.320.72.32.3 [1.6, 3.4]0.81.629
10037858Rash generalized4.469.74.44.4 [3, 6.4]1.5328
10012434Dermatitis allergic8.1123.88.18.2 [5.3, 12.5]25.321
10037867Rash macular3.432.63.43.4 [2.2, 5.2]1.12.221
10037870Rash morbilliform32.6544.232.232.8 [20.8, 51.6]3.220.519
10058919Drug rash with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms15.3171.615.215.3 [9, 25.9]2.3914
10040914Skin reaction3.618.03.63.6 [2, 6.5]1211
10012431Dermatitis2.79.02.72.7 [1.4, 5]0.81.410
10012455Dermatitis exfoliative9.063.29.09.0 [4.8, 16.8]1.74.810
10037876Rash papular2.89.62.82.8 [1.5, 5.2]0.81.510
10078325Symmetrical drug-related intertriginous and flexural exanthema53.2451.852.153.3 [28.5, 99.9]327.810
10033733Papule6.234.06.26.2 [3.2, 11.9]1.43.29
10037888Rash pustular5.932.15.95.9 [3.1, 11.4]1.33.19
10051576Generalized erythema6.531.96.56.5 [3.3, 13]1.33.28
10020764Hypersensitivity vasculitis11.255.111.211.2 [5.3, 23.6]1.75.37
10015218Erythema multiforme2.85.32.82.8 [1.3, 6.3]0.71.36
10016741Fixed eruption14.964.414.915.0 [6.7, 33.4]1.76.76
10064579Exfoliative rash9.429.59.49.4 [3.9, 22.7]1.33.95
10018999Hemorrhage subcutaneous6.216.86.26.2 [2.6, 14.9]1.12.65
10012456Dermatitis exfoliative generalized4.34.74.34.3 [1.4, 13.5]0.71.43
10048768Dermatosis21.840.221.621.8 [7, 68]1.46.93
10084905Generalized bullous fixed drug eruption44.686.343.844.6 [14.2, 139.8]1.7143
10024377Leukocytoclastic vasculitis7.210.57.27.2 [2.3, 22.5]0.92.33
10025421Macule4.34.64.34.3 [1.4, 13.3]0.71.43
Surgical and medical procedures10059513Palliative care11.227.411.111.2 [4.2, 29.9]1.34.24
Vascular disorders10021097Hypotension2.8137.72.82.8 [2.4, 3.4]1.22.3120
10016825Flushing2.023.82.02.1 [1.5, 2.8]0.81.546
10011703Cyanosis7.9156.67.98.0 [5.5, 11.7]25.427
10040560Shock4.355.24.34.3 [2.9, 6.5]1.42.923
10033546Pallor2.38.92.32.3 [1.4, 3.9]0.71.414
10037549Purpura8.079.28.08.1 [4.8, 13.6]1.84.714
10011686Cutaneous vasculitis10.961.910.810.9 [5.4, 21.8]1.75.48
10020565Hyperemia18.8117.018.718.9 [9.4, 37.9]2.19.38
10047115Vasculitis3.29.73.23.2 [1.6, 6.3]0.81.58
10052076Hemodynamic instability3.68.63.63.6 [1.6, 8]0.81.66
10058017Infective aneurysm51.2194.350.251.3 [21.1, 124.3]2.320.75
10034879Phlebitis4.911.74.94.9 [2, 11.7]0.925
10047097Vascular purpura11.819.711.711.8 [3.8, 36.7]1.13.83
SOC: System organ classification; MedDRA: Medical dictionary of adverse events; PRR: Proportional reporting ratio; χ2: Chi-square test; RRR: Relative reporting ratio; ROR: Reporting odds ratio; IC: Information component; and EBGM: Empirical Bayes Geometric Mean.
Table 8. Signal detection measures for adverse events with vaborbactam.
Table 8. Signal detection measures for adverse events with vaborbactam.
SOCMedDRAAdverse EventPRRχ2RRRRORIC025EBGM05Number of Cases
General disorders and administration site conditions10051118Drug ineffective for unapproved indication71.7282.371.787.1 [33.1, 229.2]2.327.35
Injury, poisoning, and procedural complications10053762Off label use11.8112.011.819.9 [9.4, 42]1.75.612
SOC: System organ classification; MedDRA: Medical dictionary of adverse events; PRR: Proportional reporting ratio; χ2: Chi-square test; RRR: Relative reporting ratio; ROR: Reporting odds ratio; IC: Information component; and EBGM: Empirical Bayes Geometric Mean.
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Share and Cite

MDPI and ACS Style

Sridharan, K.; Sivaramakrishnan, G. Adverse Event Signals Associated with Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors: Disproportionality Analysis of USFDA Adverse Event Reporting System. J. Xenobiot. 2025, 15, 144. https://doi.org/10.3390/jox15050144

AMA Style

Sridharan K, Sivaramakrishnan G. Adverse Event Signals Associated with Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors: Disproportionality Analysis of USFDA Adverse Event Reporting System. Journal of Xenobiotics. 2025; 15(5):144. https://doi.org/10.3390/jox15050144

Chicago/Turabian Style

Sridharan, Kannan, and Gowri Sivaramakrishnan. 2025. "Adverse Event Signals Associated with Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors: Disproportionality Analysis of USFDA Adverse Event Reporting System" Journal of Xenobiotics 15, no. 5: 144. https://doi.org/10.3390/jox15050144

APA Style

Sridharan, K., & Sivaramakrishnan, G. (2025). Adverse Event Signals Associated with Beta-Lactamase Inhibitors: Disproportionality Analysis of USFDA Adverse Event Reporting System. Journal of Xenobiotics, 15(5), 144. https://doi.org/10.3390/jox15050144

Article Metrics

Back to TopTop