A WPT system is defined as a set of technologies that enable the transfer of electrical energy without physical contact between the transmitter and the receiver. The transmitting unit, typically stationary and powered by an energy source, is responsible for generating and transmitting energy in a form suitable for wireless transfer. The receiving unit, which can be stationary or integrated into a mobile application, captures the transmitted energy to either use it directly or store it, depending on the application’s needs. Depending on the physical principle and configuration used, the WPT technologies cover different types that can be adapted for different contexts. We describe in this section some of the leading WPT technologies: inductive power transfer (IPT), capacitive power transfer (CPT), resonant magnetic induction power transfer (RIPT), radiofrequency power transfer (RFPT), and microwave power transfer (MWPT).
2.1. Inductive Power Transfer (IPT)
Inductive power transfer, or inductive coupling, traces its origins back to the 19th century, with Nikola Tesla laying the groundwork for the concept in 1891 [
14,
15]. This technology works based on the principle of magnetic induction: a transmitting coil generates a variable magnetic field, which is captured by a receiving coil placed nearby. It is similar to a transformer but without a ferromagnetic core, allowing energy to be transferred without direct physical contact between the two coils. Magnetically coupling two coils, with inductances
and
, respectively, introduces what is known as mutual inductance (
M). Mutual inductance is characterized by a positive value called the coupling coefficient (
), which represents the amount of magnetic flux transferred from the transmitter to the receiver coil and is defined by Equation (
1).
According to Kirchoff’s voltage law, the voltages at the first terminal
and at the second terminal
on the inductive circuits can be defined as follows:
where
is the angular frequency, and
and
are the currents flowing through the first and second inductors.
These equations represent a classic model of a magnetically coupled circuit, as seen in a transformer or inductive coupling system.
Inductive power transfer offers several advantages. It is simple to implement with relatively basic circuits and is safe, as there is no direct contact with electrical conductors, reducing the risk of electric shock. Additionally, it is quite robust, resistant to water and dust, which makes it suitable for challenging environments such as agricultural settings [
14]. However, it also has some limitations. The transfer is effective only over short distances, typically a few centimeters. Furthermore, for efficient energy transfer, the coils must be well-aligned; otherwise, the energy transmission will not be optimal. Energy losses due to Joule heating and magnetic dissipation further reduce efficiency. Finally, this technology is not well-suited for very high-power transmissions or long distances [
16].
Despite these limitations, it is widely used in various fields. For example, in consumer electronics, it enables wireless charging for smartphones, smartwatches, and earbuds. In the electric vehicle sector [
17], it supports wireless charging for electric cars and buses. In medicine, it is used to recharge implants and portable devices, avoiding invasive connections. It is also applied in robotics and drones for industrial applications, as well as in home automation, where it powers wireless sensors and connected devices in smart homes.
Some related works show that inductive power transfer can be proposed as a promising alternative for underground wireless sensor network applications, as magnetic fields are not significantly affected by soil and water properties [
18]. In summary, while inductive coupling is a reliable technology for transferring energy without physical contact, it remains limited by its range and energy efficiency. However, its robustness under harsh environments, including water and dust, broadens its application potential.
2.2. Capacitive Power Transfer (CPT)
Capacitive power transfer (CPT) relies on the use of capacitors to transfer electrical energy without physical contact by exploiting an oscillating electric field between two metallic electrodes. Unlike inductive power transfer, which is based on a magnetic field, CPT uses an alternating electric field to transmit energy [
19,
20]. In a CPT system, two conductive plates (transmitter and receiver) form a capacitor separated by a dielectric material such as air or polypropylene, which enables energy transmission [
21]. The capacitance C between two parallel plates is given by:
where
is the permittivity of free space (
F/m),
is the relative permittivity of the dielectric (air: 1.00059 at 1 atm),
A is the surface area of the plates (cm
2), and
d is the vertical distance between the plates (cm).
The voltage across or the voltage stress
appearing for each capacitor can be calculated as follows:
where
is the current passing through the capacitor.
However, one of the main drawbacks identified for CPT systems is the presence of high voltages between the plates and the requirement for high operating frequencies (in the MHz range), which necessitate the implementation of safety measures [
22]. The voltages and electric fields generated by CPT systems must comply with ICNIRP (International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection) standards and recommendations [
23], e.g., the exposure limits at frequencies between 100 kHz and 10 MHz are defined in
Table 1, and the devices must be designed to limit exposure by maintaining adequate spacing.
This method offers several advantages, including reduced eddy current losses, lower cost, and better tolerance to misalignment compared to inductive power transfer (IPT) [
24]. CPT is used in various industrial fields such as consumer electronics (mobile phones and laptops), transportation (electric vehicles (EVs), drone charging, and underwater charging), biomedical applications, such as powering medical implants, thanks to reduced electromagnetic interference, and electrical machines [
24].
Capacitive power transfer is particularly advantageous for applications requiring lightweight design, low electromagnetic interference emissions, and reduced cost. However, this technology still faces challenges such as the need for high voltages and increased complexity in the design of compensation networks.
2.3. Resonant Magnetic Induction Power Transfer (RIPT)
The resonant inductive power transfer (RIPT) technique is similar to inductive power transfer but overcomes the limitation of short transmission distances. This method combines an inductor and a capacitor to create a magnetic resonance effect, hence the term “resonant circuit” [
25]. Electrical energy is efficiently transferred from the primary coil to the secondary coil through the magnetic field generated by the resonance between the inductor and the capacitor [
26].
Figure 1 illustrates the four main resonant circuit configurations used in wireless power transfer systems. These topologies are named based on how the resonant capacitors are connected either in series (S) and/or in parallel (P) with the inductor [
27].
As described by Equation (
1), the resulting coupling coefficient
quantifies the portion of the magnetic flux transferred from the transmitting coil
to the receiving coil
[
28,
29]. The coupling coefficient ranges from 0% (no magnetic coupling) to 100% (perfect magnetic coupling, with optimal coil alignment). To reduce the size of the coils, a frequency of several tens of kilohertz is used [
28,
29]. This frequency, denoted by
, is given by Equation (
6), where
represents the angular resonance frequency (in rad/s)
The choice of the resonant compensation circuit topology depends on the application and its environment, while also being economically viable.
Table 2 provides a clear and comparative overview of the different topologies based on several key criteria. It highlights the performance of each topology in terms of efficiency for various applications [
26,
30], voltage/current constraints [
31], alignment impact [
29,
31], frequency independence [
32], and overall efficiency [
33,
34,
35]. From this comparison, it should be highlighted that series–series (S-S) is the most widely used topology (45%) due to its simplicity and efficiency for fixed loads, such as smartphone chargers and stationary batteries. Series–parallel (S-P) represents 30% of the market, primarily for applications where the load varies, such as IoT sensors and mobile devices. Parallel–series (P-S) is less common (15%), and it is mainly used in specific applications like implanted medical devices. Parallel–parallel (P-P) is the least used (10%) due to its complexity, but it is preferred for applications requiring high tolerance to misalignment, such as drones and electric vehicles.
Hybrid solutions have been developed to mitigate the sensitivity to the misalignment issue. These hybrid methods involve combining SS, PP, SP, and PS compensation circuits with another LC compensation network to form compensation circuits such as LCC-LCC, LCL-LCL, LCC-LCL, etc. [
32,
36,
37,
38,
39].
Table 3 compares basic resonant topologies and hybrid topologies of compensation circuits in wireless power transfer (WPT) systems. The goal of this hybridization is to create a compensation resonance to improve the efficiency of the power transmission system and ensure better tolerance to misalignment, improved efficiency and stability, and adaptability to diverse conditions. It remains that the main advantages of basic topologies are the simplicity in design and implementation, the low cost, and the efficiency under optimal conditions.
To maintain optimal efficiency without loss of performance, it is essential to study the characteristics of coupling systems, including the coupling coefficient (k), the quality factor (Q), and the misalignment tolerance.
Standards have been established to harmonize the use of this technology, ensure compatibility, and protect users. Among these, we can mention the SAE J2954 standard. It standardizes inductive charging so that a primary and a secondary coil manufactured by different companies are compatible. It specifies that the resonance frequency
of power transfer systems for mobile applications must be limited to 100 kHz [
28,
29,
40]. For maximum power transfer, the resonance frequencies of the primary and secondary coils must be matched. The standard also specifies that the coupling coefficient must be between 10% and 30% for wireless charging systems in mobile applications to maximize efficiency [
29,
41]. Additionally, it classifies inductive charging systems based on their nominal apparent power into different classes. It also defines a second classification based on the distance between the two coils (Z-classes) [
28,
29,
40].
2.4. Radiofrequency (RF) Transfer and Microwave Power Transfer (MWPT)
Radiofrequency (RF) is an electromagnetic technology that emerged at the beginning of the 20th century with the development of wireless communications. Since its inception, it has undergone numerous advancements and found applications in various fields, including telecommunications, energy, and agriculture [
42,
43]. RF traces its origins to the work of pioneers such as Heinrich Hertz, who demonstrated the existence of electromagnetic waves, and Guglielmo Marconi [
44,
45], who achieved the first wireless transmission. Its development accelerated with the advent of radio, radar during World War II, and more recently with modern communication systems and wireless power transfer (WPT) [
44,
45]. Radiofrequency relies on the transmission of electromagnetic waves within a frequency spectrum ranging from 3 kHz to 300 GHz. For wireless power transfer, these waves are generated by an alternating electrical signal, typically in the MHz or GHz range, which is amplified to increase its power and then transmitted via a transmitting antenna. This antenna converts the electrical signal into electromagnetic waves, which propagate through space according to Equation (
7). At the other end, a receiving antenna captures these waves and converts them back into an electrical signal. This energy can then be used to power a device.
where
is the electric field,
is the magnetic permeability of the medium, and
is the electric permittivity of the medium.
The transmission distance ranges from a few meters to several kilometers, depending on the frequency, signal power, and environmental conditions. However, the efficiency of the transfer decreases with distance due to energy losses in the form of heat or scattered radiation. The power received by a receiving antenna can be calculated using the Friis equation defined by (
8).
where
is the received power,
is the transmitted power,
and
are the gains of the transmitting and receiving antennas,
is the wavelength of the signal, and
d is the distance between the antennas.
This equation shows that the power received decreases with the square of the distance, which explains the loss of energy over long distances. RF is widely used to power low-consumption devices, particularly in hard-to-access environments. For example, in remote agricultural areas, RF-powered IoT sensors measure critical parameters such as soil moisture, temperature, or air quality [
46,
47]. It is also used in the medical field to power deeply implanted devices, such as pacemakers, neurostimulators, or biomedical sensors [
48]. In the consumer electronics sector, emerging technologies enable the wireless charging of small devices, such as wireless earbuds or smartwatches, through charging stations that emit RF signals [
49]. Despite its advantages, RF technology has several major drawbacks. First, its energy efficiency is low: a significant portion of the energy is lost as heat or scattered (
9) radiation, making the transfer less efficient than wired methods. This inefficiency increases with distance, limiting its use to low-power devices. For applications requiring high power, such as electric vehicles, RF is not yet viable. The thermal energy
Q dissipated in a system can be calculated using Equation (
9).
where
I is the electric current,
R is the resistance of the system, and
t is the time.
Some drawbacks of RF waves concerning interference, safety, and health also appear, e.g., they may interfere with other electronic devices and have potential biological effects on human tissues, especially at high power or specific frequencies. Furthermore, RF systems are sensitive to physical obstacles, such as walls or metals, which can attenuate or block the waves. They can also interfere with other technologies using similar frequencies, such as Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, or mobile communications. Wireless power transfer via RF is particularly suitable for low-power devices and environments where cables are impractical. However, its limitations, particularly in terms of energy efficiency, safety, and sensitivity to obstacles, remain challenges to be addressed.
Similarly to RF, microwave power transmission (MWPT) has its origins in the pioneering work on electromagnetic waves in the 19th century. Heinrich Hertz in 1887 experimentally demonstrated the existence of electromagnetic waves, paving the way for their use in wireless power transmission. Nikola Tesla, at the end of the 19th century, explored the idea of transmitting electrical energy over long distances wirelessly, although his experiments did not lead to practical applications at the time. In the 1960s, William C. Brown revolutionized the field by demonstrating microwave power transmission to power a miniature helicopter. His work laid the foundation for modern microwave power transmission technology [
44]. Since then, this technology has been studied for space applications, particularly in the context of space solar power (SSP) projects, where solar energy collected in orbit would be transmitted to Earth via microwaves [
50,
51].
Microwave power transmission relies on the conversion of electrical energy into electromagnetic waves in the microwave band (typical frequencies of 2.45 GHz or 5.8 GHz), followed by their transmission and reconversion into electrical energy [
52]. A microwave generator, such as a magnetron or klystron, converts electrical energy into electromagnetic waves. These waves are then directed to a transmitting antenna in the form of a directed beam. The transmission distance depends on the emitted power, frequency, and antenna efficiency, as described by the Friis Equation (
8). At the receiving end, an antenna equipped with rectennas (rectifying antennas) converts the microwaves into usable direct current.
Microwave power transmission and radio frequency (RF) power transmission are based on the same physical principle: the conversion of electrical energy into electromagnetic waves, their propagation through space, and their reconversion into electrical energy. Both technologies use antennas to emit and receive waves, and their efficiency depends on similar factors, such as frequency, emitted power, and transmission distance.
Table 4 provides a comparison of these technologies.
Microwave power transmission (MWPT) is a promising technology with enormous potential, particularly for applications such as space-based solar power, in-flight drone powering, or long-distance wireless charging. However, it must overcome several challenges to become a viable large-scale solution. On the technical side, a significant portion of energy is lost during the conversion, transmission, and reconversion stages. For instance, microwave generators (such as magnetrons or klystrons) have limited efficiency, and rectennas (rectifying antennas) only convert a fraction of the received energy into usable electricity. Additionally, long-distance transmission leads to losses due to beam divergence and atmospheric attenuation. Environmental conditions, such as rain, fog, or dust, can also attenuate or deflect the microwave beam, reducing transmission efficiency and requiring sophisticated compensation systems. Finally, on the societal front, the public often perceives this technology as risky due to concerns about the effects of microwaves on health and the environment. Although the power levels used are generally safe, skepticism persists, and clear communication, along with thorough studies, is necessary to reassure users and decision-makers.